UU4PnSLSbUU^hSn^3nM.
4UP4UL3UL
<"7îS< $¡ibuibubbp¡i LuiSpfinbfi uiuui/ipuibip © https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7413-0455
tfCbP 4UP4UL3UL
^ШJШusшb^ шtbp^LJшb hшtшlишpшbft huiiSuiLiujpq¿ujj¡ib b 1рЬ^Ы/ш1рь1ш1^шЬ q/iipriLpjuib iSuiq/iuippnu
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6864-592X
LbP—hL ^LU3nanh^3nhLLbPR4 SLSbURh^3UL PUP^nh^3UL UUShöULh PUPaPUStfUL CUtfUP ULCPUrfbCS LbP^PnhtfLbPh &hLULUU4nPtfUL <U3bSU4UP0-U3hL CPSULU4
¿ínty^ónLtJ fbbшpL^nLt bb « Чшnш^шpnLpJшb 2021-2026 pp. ópшqpn^ ишh-« sbsbишLшb pшp^.nLpJшb pшpâpшдtшb nLqbbfobbpb ШПЬ^ПЦ hшpgbp' ^шц^шд ££-nLÚ ишhtшbшJftb ipbfribninq^bbpft bbpq.p^b фftbшbиш^nptшb шp-b bbpfftb шqpJnLpbbp^ hbyi, Ь^ш^Ь nLbbbшln^, np bpLpfi sbsbишLшb pшp-ГJ.nLpJшb шиstltiшbp u|ШJtшbш^npшó t hшtш2|шphшJftb 1РЬ1ЬП^^Ш^ШЬ ишhtш-bftg bpш hbnш^npnLpJnLb^g: UшhtшbшJftb ipbfribninq^bbpfr bbpq.p^b hшtшp ШЬ-hpшàb2S шpsшq.pnqшLшb qftyiblppbbpfr фn|шbgtшb LшщnLqpbbp^g úb^b osшp-bpLpJш nLq^Lfi bbpq.pnLtbbpb (ОПЬ-Ъ) bb, npnbg bbphnufft tJшLшpq.шLp pш^шpшp jt, fruL L¿bp£^b sшиbшúJшL^ tJftyinLtbbpft b COVID-19-ft шqq.bgnLpJшtp шфф bb tb-0шдЬ[ bbpfftb bbpq.pnLLÍbbpft фftbшbиш^nptшb шpsшfftb шqpJnLpbbpft hbyi ^шцфд шbnpn2nLpJnLbbbpp: bqpшLLшgфl t, np 1рЬ1Ьп^^ш^шЬ шnш2pbpшgft фш hfttb-Цшд LшJnLb nL ^Ьш^шЬ sbsbишLшb шб^ hшtшp шbhpшàb2S bbpq.pnLtbbpft LшJnLb b pшpâp tïшLLшpцшLLP u/byif t шu|шhnфl bbpfftb |ybшJnqnLpJnLbbbpn^: U.nш£шpLLфl t sbsbишLшb pшp^.nLpJшb шиstlбшbfr pшpâpшgtшbp tSftyi^ó шpsшhшbtшb hшppшLft ОПЬ-Ъ-ft b bbpfftb bbpq.pnLtbbpft hшJbgшLшpqшJftb 2P2шbшL:
^rfbwpwnbp. huiiJuifriuinb fubuijmim.pjm.bbbp, huiiJuifriuinb bbppftb fubuijmim.pjm.b-bbp, hftlbuiLiuib L/uiuiftyiwip L/ms^L/miS, sbsbuutLuib puipq.mpjmb, uuihiJuibuijftb sbfabninqftuibbp, uipswhuibiJuib hu/pput^ bbppftb bbp^pmbbbp, Onh-L
JEL: E21, E22
DOI: 10.52174/1829-0280_2022.1-9
Lbpw6mpjnLb: « Mmnm^mpnLpjmh 2021-2026 pp. ôpmqpnLJ (mjunLhbmU frpmqhp) h2^mô t. «^wjwumul^ mhmbumlmh pmprçnLpjmh pmpÔpmgJmh ^^mmu^n^ hm^mmbu^nLJ t hwdw^p JhgngmnmJhbph hpmlmhmgmJ1 Jhm-^mô ÔbnhmplnLpjmhhbph mb^hnLnqhmlmh ^bpmqhhJmhQ, hh^bu hmU Jh-gmqqmjhh hnp 2nLlmhbp hbppm^mhgJmhh nL mn^m ^hpfbph mJpm^hrçJm-hQ»1: Lm^mmbu^b t mhmbumlmh pmprçmpjmh hmJmph^Q (SP^) 2018 p. -0.39-hg hmughbL 0.1-h U 10 mmp^m QhpmgpmJ rçwu^b pmpôp mhmbumlmh pmp^nLpjrnh rnhbgn^ bplphbph 2mpfhh: fàb^bm mju h^mmmlm^pJmh hpmmbumlmhnLpjnLhQ, npn2 mnmJhbpn^, fuhrç.pmhmpnLjg t, mjhmmJbhmjhh^, mhmbumlmh ImjnLh U mUmlmh m6h, Qh^hmhmp mnJmJp, mhmbumlmh qmpqmgJmh ^hrçhpQ LnLÔbLnL 6mhm^mphh mbumhljnLhhg, phpm^m^npmJQ hhJhm^np^mô t: Unh^mqh bpbf ImpUnp ^h^hp ^bmp t LnLÔbL umhJmh^mô mrçbhh2hbphh hmuhbLnL hmJmp. (1) mnlm lmJ ^nmbhghmL nLnpmhbpnLJ pmpÔpmghbL mpmm^pmhfh pmp^mpjmh mum^6mhQ, (2) mb^hnLnqhmhbph Jhgmqqmjhh ^n^mhgJmh qnpÔQhpmghbpnLJ bplph hbpqpm^mônLpjmh m^mhn^nLjQ Qhmp^mô nLnpmhbpnLJ ORh-L-h ^pmhJmJp, (3) hbpfhh ^hm-jnrçnLpjrnhhbph Jmlmprçwlh pmpÔpmgmJQ:
9-pw^wbmpjwb w^bwp^: «<bmmqnmnLpjnLhhbp mqqbph hmpumnLpjmhi phnLjph U ^mm6mnhbph Jmuhh» m2^mmmpjmh Jbg U. UJhpQ2 h2bL t, np m2^mmmhfh pmdmhJmJp pmpÔpmhmJ t mhmbumlmh mprçjmhm^bmnLpjnL-hQ, qmpqmhnLJ bh mhmbumlmh Jhm^nphbph, m2^mmnrçhbph hJmnLpjnLh-hbpQ, fmhh np hpmhf JmuhmqhmmhnLJ bh Jbl qnpônrçnLpjmh Jbg:
Upmmrç.pmhfh Jbô JmuQ ^mhmhgnLJ t m^h 2ms qhmbLhfhbp, fmh lmpn^ t jnLpmghbL JmprçQ: U~hmdmJmhml, qhmbLhfhbph jnLpmgnLJQ pmp-rçwhmJ t hpmhn^, np rçpmhp LhhnLJ bh pmgmhmjm U n^ pmgmhmjm («hmJp»): ^pn^bunp 9-. 4mprç.mhjmhh ^^rnmp^JmJp' «Pmgmhmjm qhmbLhfhbpQ ômô-Imqp^n^ bh nL Jmm^bLh—: £mJp qhmbLhfhbpQ... rçd^mp t humml mpmm-hmjmbL qpm^np lmJ pmhm^np ÔUn^, rçpmhf Ôbnp bh pbp^nLJ mhôhm^mh ^npôn^»3:
U^hhmjmnpbh, bpb pnLnp qhmbLhfhbpQ Lhhb^h pmgmhmjm, m^m bplphbpQ 2mm mpmq Ihmuhbhh umhJmhmjhh mb^hnLnqhmhbphh (frontier technology)4, ^thh Lhhh qmpqmgJmh Jm^mp^m^hbph U blmJmh mjh^huh
1 « Mwnw^wpnLpjwh 2021-2026 p^wlwhhbph ôpmqhp, t2 29:
2 Sb'u Smith A., An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, London, 1776, t2 9, https://books.google.am/books?id=C5dNAAAAcAAJ&pg=PP7&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false
3 ^mp^mbjmb 9-., 9-hmbLhgwhbhg mhmbunLpjnLh. hhwpw^npnLpjnLhhbp U Jwpmwhpw^bphbp, bp., «9-himnLpjnLh», 2008, t2 46:
4 LbplwjmJ umhJmhmjhh mb^hnLnqhwhbp bh hwJwp^nLJ mphbumm^mh pmhm^mhnLpjnLhQ (Artificial intelligence-AI), hpbph hmJmgmhgQ (Internet of Things-IoT), Jbô m^JwLhbpQ (Big data), PLnl^bjhQ (Blockchain), bnw^wi^ m^mqpnLpjnLhQ (3D printing), nnpnmw2hhnLpjnLhQ (Robotics),
mmppbpnLpjmhhbp, hh^huhh mjuop bh, hu^ hmJm2^mphmjhh mnUmph ^m-nnLg4m&ph tm^mhnpbh ^mmppbp4bp hbp^mjhu ^mnnLg4m&fhg: Shmbum-^mh pmp^nLpjmh mumh6mhh 4bpmpbpjm[ ^mm^bpmgmJ ^mqJb|m b^usu-nmJn4 mh^.pm^.mp5 t ^mmmp4b Jh mpdbfm4np m2^mmmpjmh, npmd ph^.hmhpmg4m& bh bpUnLjph mmppbp ^n^Jbphh mnh^nn. hm^np^. hhJhm-^mh hbmmqnmnLpjnLhhbph mp^jnLhfhbpp:
0-h^mp^.n <mmuJmhp U nLph2hbp mhmbumpjmh pmp^nLpjnLhp Jb^hm-pmhnLJ bh hbmUjmL ^bp^. «....mhmbunLpjmh pmp^nLpjnLhp hpmhmJ ^mpnL-hm^^nT. mprnm^pn^m^mh qhmb[hfhbph pmhm^h mpmmgn|nLJh t: Uj^. qhmb-Lhfhbph ummgmJp U ^n^mhgmJp pmh^ t mpdbhnLJ, ^.pmhp mpnh^mS bh Jmubph, npnhf Jbhf mh4mhmJ bhf ^mpnT.nLpjnLhhbp: MmpnTnLpjnLhhbpp ^d^mp t ^nLmm^b[, npn^hbmU mj^ dmJmhm^ mnmgmhmJ t hm4h U S4h pmp^ hhJhm^h^hpQ: Uh ^n^hg' bp^phbpp ^bh ^mpnq. umbT&b[ mpmm^-pmhf, npp ^mhmhgnLJ t ^mpn^nLpjnLhhbp, npnhf hpmhf ^rnhbh: UjnLu ^nT.-Jhg' fh^ bh ^mpn^nLpjnLhhbp ^nLmm^bm ^pmhhbph mjhmb^, npmb^ qnjnL-pjmh ^mhbh n|npmhbp, npnhf ^pmhg ^mphfh nLhbh: H-m hmm^m^bu 62Jm-phm t, bpp ^nmbhghm[ hnp n|npmh hmJmp ^mhmhg^nT, um^mjh, ^m^m-unT ^mpnTnLpjnLhhbpp 2mm bh: Uj^ ^.b^fmJ npUt Jb^ ^m^munq. ^mpnT.nL-pjmh mpmJm^pnLJp ^hhh n^ pm^mpmp1 hnp n|npmp qnp&mp^b|nL hmJmp»5: Shmbum^mh pmp^mpjmh mumh6mhh mju Jb^hmpmhnLpjnLhp npn2 62qpmJmh ^mphf nLhh: U^hhmjm t, np mpmm^pnT.m^mh qhmb|hfh mn^m-jnLpjmhh mhhpmdb2m, pmjg n pm^mpmp ^mjJmh t hnpmpmpnLpjmhhbph mp^jnLhf hmh^humgnT. pmp^ mpmm^pmhf pn^mp^b[nL hmJmp: ^pm hmJmp ^whwhg^bh ^m^hmm[h hnp hmJm^gnLpjrnhhbp U hnp ^Jpm4npmJ-hbp' hhJh^mS mpmm^pnT.m^mh qhmb|hfhbph mp^jnLhm^bm ^hpmnJmh 4pm: Uj^ mnmJn4, ^bj4h^ ^mp^bpp U thmnhh th^pbup h2nLJ bh. «Mm^h-mm[h hnp hm Jm^gnLpjnLhhbpp U 4bpm^Jpm4npmJhbpp ^mprnhm^mJ bh npUt hnpmpmpnLpjrnh U hmhqbghnLJ m4b|h 4mT qnjnLpjrnh rnhbgnq. hh^-np ^mpnT.nLpjmh jmpmgJmhp: hu^m^bu, Sbnhmp^mmbp-mpmm^pnThbph U umbT^mqnpS oqmmqnpSn^hbph ^nTJhg ^m^hmm[h hm Jm^gnLpjmhhbph hmJmmbT ^.bpm^mum^npnLJp hnpmpmpmpjnLhhbph hhJhm^mh m^pjnLph t 2nL^mjm^mh mhmbunLpjnLhnLJ»6:
<hJh4.b[n4 h2^m6h 4pm' nLunLJhmuhp4nT bpUnLjph Jb^ mj[ Jb^hmpmhnL-pjnLh ^mpnT. t LhhbL hbmUjm[Q. mhmbunLpjmh pmp^nLpjnLhp ^.pwhmJ ^mpnL-hm^4nT. mpmm^pnT.m^mh qhmb[hfhbph fmhm^h mpmmgn[nLJh t U ^pmhg wp^jnLhw4bm ^hpmnnLpjnLhp' ^m^hmm[h hnp hmJm^gnLpjnLhhbph nL 4bpm-^Jpm4npnLJhbph Jh2ngn4 hnpmpmpnLpjnLhhbph hpm^mhmgnLJp, mj^ hbh-fn4' pmp^ mpmm^pmhfh pn^mp^nLJp:
^pnhhbpp (Drones), qbhmjhh ^JpmqpmJp (Gene editing), hmhnmb^hn[nqhmhbpp
(Nanotechnology), wpUwjhh ^nmn4n[mmjhh mb^hn[nqhmhbpp (Solar photovoltaic, Solar PV):
Sb'u Technology and Innovation, Report 2021. New York, United Nations, 2021, t2 17:
5 Hausmann R., Hidalgo C., Bustos S., Coscia M., Simoes A., Yildirim M., The Atlas of Economic Complxity. Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Center for International Development, Harvard University, 2013, p. 18.
6 Harper D., Endres A., Innovation, Recombinant Capital and Public Policy. University of Chicago. Supreme Court Economic Review, Vol. 23, 2015, t2 217:
Shrnbumlmh pmp^mpjmJp t, pb mnmpJmh hmJm2^mphmjhh
2npmhbpmJ npfmh ^664m6 t ^n^qnp&mlgnLpjrnhhbph gmhgp: Shrnbumlmh pmp^nLpjnLhh mpmmhmm4m& t bplph mprnm^pmhfh ImqJnLJ L mp-mmgn|nLJ t mjh Imnnyghbpp, npnhf mnmgmhmJ bh qhmb[hfhbpp qmhb|nL L hmJmlgb|nL hmJmp:
hh^bu «, mjhqbu t[ qmpqmgn^ JjnLu bplphbph mhmbumlmh m6h L qmpqmgJmh mbumhljrnhhg lmpLnp4nLJ t Jhgmqqmjhh pm-
dmhJmhh mjhqhuh Jmuhmlgmpjmh hmuhb|p, npp lbpm2^m4nph mpmm^-pn^wlmh L hhumhmnLghnhm[ qhmb[hfhbph ^n^mhgmJp qmpqmgm6 bplphbphg, H-pmhg oqmmqnp&mJp mhmbunLpjmh m4b|h nL m4b|h pmp^mgn^ n|npmhbpnLJ, hh^p bhpm^.pmJ t mhmbumlmh pmp^nLpjmh mumh6mhh pmpSpmgmJ, mb^hn|nqhmlmh phpmghl umhJmhhg bplph hbnm4npnLpjmh lp6mmmJ:
<mjmhh ImqnL^hhbphg bh ORh-L-p: Pmgh pnLh lmqhmm|.hg, ORhL-p lmpn^ bh hqmumb[ mpmmumhJmhjmh mpmm^.pmlmh mb^hn|nqhmhbphh, mpmmumhJmhjmh 2mlmhbphh L mnmpJmh Jhgmqqmjhh 2T.pmhbphh 6mhn-pmhm|nLh: Uj^ ^npSmnnLpjrnhp lmpn^ t mpdbhm[ m4b|hh, fmh pnLh ^mq^-mm|p: 2mpqmgn^ JjnLu bplphbpnLJ ORhL-p hbp^.pmJhbph ph^.hmhmp 6m-4m|h ^npp Jmuh bh ImqJnLJ, umlmjh qhmb[hfhbph ^n^mhgJmh 2hnphh4 H-pmhg h2mhm^nLpjnLhp 2mm m4b|hh t, fmh Jmuhmlh hbp^pmhpp hbp^.pmJ-hbph ph^hmhnLp Sw^wimJ7:
^hpbp <m^hpp L ^bj4h^ ^mjbp-in[^bup8, mb^hn|nqhm-
lmh ^n^n^nLpjrnhhbph hhJhmlmh mnmhShmhmmlnLpjmhhbpp, mmppbpm-l|nLJ bh mb^hn|nqhw^wh hbp^.pmJhbph bplnL mbuml, npnhf hmJmqm-mmu^mhmJ bh hmJm2^mphmjhh mb^hn|nqhmlmh umhJmh ^.mpu qm|nL bplnL mmppbp nmqJm^mpnLpjnLhhbph' «dmJmhmlmlhg hbmmqnmnLpjmh-hbp L J2mlnLJhbp (R&D)» L «hbp^pmJ»: Uj^ bplnLup Jhmuhh mb^h bh nLhb-hnLJ qmpqmgm6 bplphbpnLJ, Jhh^bn Jhmjh hbp^.pmJp, nph hpbhhg hbp-ImjmghnLJ t jnLpmgnLJ L hmpJmpbgnLJ, lmpn^ t mb^h nLhbhm[ qmlmu qmpqmgm6 bplphbpnLJ: bplnLuh t[, hhJh^mS [hhb[n^ hmJm2^mphmjhh ph-pmghl mb^hn[nqhmlmh umhJmhh 4pm, qmhmhgnLJ bh Jb6 6m^ubp: U4b-Lhh, mnmghhp qmhmhgnLJ t hJmnLpjrnhhbph m4b|h pmpSp Jmlmp^ml, fmh bplpnp^p: Unmghhp hhJh^mS t qhsmlmh qhmb[hfhbph, ^pmhg hmumm-mnLpjnLhhbph 4pm L mnmgm^np mb^hn|nqhmhbph qmpqmgJmhp qnLqph-pmg Jhs4m6 t qbpmqmhgbm mb^hn|nqhmjh hbp^pJmh hmJmp mhhpm-db2s hmJmp4n^. qhmb[hfhbph 2bJmjhh Jmlmp^mlp:
bplpnp^p1 rnb^hn[nqhmhbph hbp^pnLJhbpp, qmhmhgnLJ bh hmJmqm-mmu^mh hJmmpjnLhhbp, hh^h hmJmp bplhpp qbsf t nLhbhm mj^ hJmnL-pjnLhhbpp pbpb[nL Impn^nLpjnLh, qmpqmgJmh hmJmqmmmu^mh Jm-Imp^ml: ^h^ mp^.jnLhm4bm t hmJmp4nLJ nLunLgJmhp lmJ 4bpmqmm-pmumJmhp dmJmhml hmrnlmghb[p, fmhh np nLunLgnLJp mb^h t nLhbhnLJ rnb^hn[nqhmhbphh hmJbJmmmpmp mh6mhnp ^mum4mh^n^hbph n^ pmpSp
7 Sb'u Commission on Growth and Development. The Growth Report : Strategies for Sustained Growth and Inclusive Development. Washington, DC : World Bank, 2008, t2 42:
8 Sb'u Howitt P., Mayer-Foulkes D., R&D, Implementation, and Stagnation: A Schumpeterian Theory of Convergence Clubs// ournal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. 37, No. 1, Feb., 2005, t2147-177:
^mpn^nLpjmhhbph, mp^hm^mh [mpnpmmnphmhbph pmgm^mjmpjmh Jhgm-^mjpmJ: fah^hpp m2^mmn^hbphh mjh^huh mpmm^.pn^w^mh qhmb|hfhbph mpmJm^.pmJh t, npnhf ^hmJm^mmmu^mhbh phpmgh^ mb^hn|nqhm^mh umhJmhhh: <mjmummhmJ, pbpLu, npn2m^h mnmgphpmg mb^h t nLhbgb mb^b^mm^m^mh mb^hn|nqhmhbph n|npmmJ, nph mhhpmd^m, pmjg n^ pm-^mpmp t bp^ph mhmbumlmh pmp^mpjmh mumhömhp pmpäpmghbm mbu-mh^|nLh^g: H-pm m^mgrnjgp hm^np^. bpbf mmuhmJjm^mJ «-mJ mb^hn|n-qhm^mh hbp^.pmJhbph gmöp mp^jnLhm^bmnLpjnLhh t, nph uhhpbmh^ qhm-hmmm^mhp bp^ph hbnm^npnLpjmhh t mb^hn|nqhm^mh umhJmhhg L mhmbumlmh pmp^.mpjmh gmöp mum^ömhp:
^njnLpjrnh nLhbh [nLp2 ^n^ph^nrnhbp mnmgm^np mb^hn|nqhmhbph hbp^pJmh ömhm^mph^h, npnhf ^mjJmhm^npmJ bh, pus mprnm^pn^m^m-hmpjmh, bp^phbph J^L h2mhm^m|h mmppbpnLpjmhhbpp: nLumJhmuhpb|n4 mj^ ^n^ph^.nmhbph phrnjpp1 <mp4.mp^h L Ppmrnhn^jmh hmJm|umpmhhbph hbmmqnmnqhbp &hl.h^ Uqhhbhp, ^hpbp <m^hpp, ^hbqn £mJhhp L hqm-pb[ Sb^mh9 J2m^b[ bh Jn^.b[, npmJ mb^hn|nqhmhbph J^gmqqmj^h mmpmö-Jmh mnm^binLpjmh oqmmqnpöJmh bp^ph ^mpn^nLpjmhp ^pm^mh ^nnb|wg-^mö t hpm ^hmjn^nLpjrnhhbph Jm^mp^m^h hbm: UmhJmhmjhh mb^hn|n-qhmhbphh pmgmmbqjm^nLpjnLhp h^wqbghmJ t T-pmhg hbp^pJmh öm^ubpp: nLumh mnmgm^np mhmbunLpjnLhhbpmJ ^h^^phbp ^bh mnmgmhmJ ^pmhf hbp^.hb[hu: Unmhg mnmgm^np bp^phbph mgm^gmpjmh1 mb^hn|nqhm^mh umhJmhhg hbnrn bp^phbph hmJmp umhJmhmjhh mb^hn|nqhmhbph hbp^prn-Jp pm^m^mh pmh^ ^mpdbhm: hh^bu gnLjg t mm|hu Jhgmqqmjhh ^npöp, mj^ ^h^.ph |nLÖmJp mb^m^mh Öbnhmp^mmbpbph L umhJmhmjhh mb^hn|n-qhmhbphh mhpm^bmn^ ommpbp^pjm hbp^pn^hbp^ hmJmqnpöm^gmpjmhh t: L^mpmqp^mö Jn^.b|h mpdmhhfh mjh t, np umhJmhmjhh mb^hn|nqhmjhg hbnrn qmh^n^ bp^phbph ^Jph hmJmp hm^np^ 10 mmphhbph phpmgpmJ ^hmjn^nLpjmhhbph Jm^mp^m^h 10%-n^ pmpÖpmgmJp ^hmhqbghh hmgnp^ 10 mmphhbphh 1.3%-mjhh ^bmn^ mhmbumlmh m6h Jhghh mbJ^h pmpöpmg-Jmhp, mju^hfh1 ^mjmh L mLm^mh mhmbumlmh m6h m^mhn^Jmhp:
Cbmwqnmmpjwb dbpn^wpwbmpjnLb: <bmmqnmmpjmh phpmgpmJ oq-mmqnpö4.b[ bh ph^.hmhmp qhmm^mh (mbum^mh L ^npömnm^mh), Jmuhm-^npm^bu1 hmJbJmmnLpjrnhhbph, dmJmhm^mjhh 2mpfbph 4.bp[nLÖnLpjmh Jb-pn^hbpp1 bpLnyph J^mnLJhbp^ L op^hm^m^nLpjnLhhbp^ pmgmhmjmJmh h^mmm^n^.: ShmbunLpjmh pmp^nLpjmh mum^ömh^ nLunLJhmu^pnLpjmh hmJmp oqmmqnpö4.b[ t hwJw|uwpwh^ [mpnpmmnp^mj^ J2m-^mö mhmbunLpjmh pmp^nLpjmh hmJmp^4.P (Economic Complexity Index-ECI), npp hhmpm^npnLpjnLh t phÖbnnLJ qhwhwmb|nL mpmm^pn^m^mh q^mb[hf-hbp^ phpmg^^ ^h^m^p bp^pnLJ: The Atlas of Economic Complexity qnpö^fh oqmmqnpö^nLJ t mhmbumlmh ^hhmJh^mh L jnLpmfmh^jnLp bp^ph hmJmp hnp hhmpm^npnLpjnLhhbpp qhmhmmb[nL h^mmm^n^.: nLumJhwuhpnLpjwh phpmgpnLJ oqmmqnpö^bL bh 1994-2020 pp. dmJmhm^mhmm^möh « hm-
9 Sb'u Aghion Ph., Comin D. and Howitt P., When does domestic saving matter for economic growth? Working paper, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 2006, 44 tg (+8), http://nrs.harvard.edU/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:27759050
dm^wnb ^hwjn^nLpjnLhhbph, wpmwhwhJwh m4jw[hbph dwJwhw^wjhh 2wppbpp, hh^bu hwU mhmbunLpjwh pwp^.nLpjwh hwJwp^h 2000-2019 pp. m^jwLhbpp: 4bp2hhhbpu hhwpw^npnLpjnLh frh phÓbnnLJ pwgwhwjmb[nL bp^phbph wpmw^.pw^wh hhwpw^npnLpjnLhhbph wpmwhwhJwh qwJpjnL^-hfrph hhJwh 4pw10: Cum mhmbuw^wh pwp^nLpjwh hwJwp^K bp^phbph wumhówhw^wpqmJh hpw^whwghmJ t ^wp^wp^h hwJw[uwpwhh U6| [w-pnpwmnphwh:
Mwmwp^L frh hwU Jhgwqqwjhh hwJbJwmnLpjnLhhbp, nLunLJhwuhp^M t « mhmbunLpjwh pwp^.nLpjwh hwJwp^h 2wptfQhpwgp: <wJwp^h pwpb-[w^Jwh hhwpw^npnLpjnLhp t hwJw2^wphwjhh mb^hn[nqhw-
^wh uwhJwhhg bp^ph hbnw^npnLpjwh ^pówmJwh hwJwmbpumnLJ, hh^h hwJwp wh^pw^wpó t wp^frL ^pw hwJwp whhpwdfr2m hfrpfhh hbp^pmJ-hfrphh U ORhL-hh: <wJw^wnh ^hwjn^nLpjnLhhbph U hhJhw^wh ^nLmw^-Jwh JhgU mUw^wh dwJwhw^ qnjnLpjnLh rnhbgn^ nbumpuwjhh ób^p^wófh nLunLJhwuhp^M t nL^^w^h hbp^pnLJhbph hw Jw2^wphwjhh hnuffrph 5Uw-^np^wó' «-h hwJwp n^ h^wumw^np JhmmJhbph 2p2whw^mJ: Mwmwp-
4.frpLnLÓnLpjnLhhbph hhJwh ^pw wnwgwp^^L t mhmbunLpjwh pwp^nL-pjwh wurnh^whh pwpÓpwgJwh hwjbgw^wpq:
^bpimámpjnLb: « mhmbuw^wh pwp^nLpjwh wumhówhh pwpÓpwgJwh nwqJw^wpnLpjwh J2w^Jwh wnmJn^ ^wpUnp^nLJ t ^ Jhgwqqwjhh H-hpfh nLunLJhwuhpnLpjnLhp: U.QjnLuw^ 1-hg frpUnLJ t, np « wpmwhwhJwh Jbg Jfró mbuw^wpwp nLhbgn^ wpmw^pwhpp hwJw^.pb[h ^t SP< pwpóp gnLgw-hh2n^. bp^phbph wpmwhwhJwh ^wnnLg^wófh hbm, npp hwJw2^wphwjhh mb^hn[nqhw^wh uwhJwhhh ^wJ ^.pwh Jnm qmh^LnL wpmwgn[nLJh t:
UqjnLum^ 1
Cuip SP< luuipftáiuhiutyiupqft (UU) ¡¿bpfib 5 bptypbbpfi h £iujiuuipiuhft hiuiiuptfbpp (2019 p.)
UU bp^p SP< Upswhwbdwb Jb£ libó ipbuwtywpwp lf2hn nihbgnq lupipiu^piuhp
1 owi^nhhw 2.49 2 C^bjgwphw 2.13 "3 CLhniii i itihi i i 0 n"7 Uqmnubgbhwhbp, SCS (mb^hnLnqhwhbp) S<S, nu^h, i^wpbpw^np^wó ^b^wJh2nghbp hhmbqpwL u^bJwhbp, S<S, w^snJbgbhwhbp S<S, w^snJbgbhwhbp S<S, w^snJbgbhwhbp UnLhp^bhh U hwhgwgwpbp U ^mwhjnLpbp, nu^h, uhqwphbp U ó^w^nm, nqb[|ig ^Jh^fihbp
3 HupUwUhw 2.07 4 Mnpbw 2.05 C 1 IUV.«......... o nn
o 76 U|IU4.LUU^[IL|I <wjwumwh z.uu -0.27
Uqpjnip* Country & Product Complexity Rankings. https://atlas.cid.harvard.edu/rankings; https://www.worldstopexports.com/armenias-top-10-exports/
Shmbuw^wh pwp^nLpjwh wumhówhh wpmwgn[4.nLJ t bp^ph wpmwhwhJwh ^wnnLg^wópnLJ pwp^nLpjwh pwpóp wumhówhh wpmw^pwhfh sfr-uw^wpwp Uumhówhw^wpqh ^frphh hhhq bp^phbph U <wjwumwhh
wpmwhwhJwh Jbg Jfró ów^wl rnhbgn^ wpmw^pwhfQ hbmUjw[h t. fiwqn-hhw' w^mnJbfbhwhbp, S<S (mb^hn[nqhwhbp), C^frjgwphw' S<S, nu^h, ^wpbpw^np^wó ^b^wJhgnghbp, ^bpJwhhw' hhmbqpw[ u^bJwhbp, S<S,
10 Sb'u Mealy P., Farmer D., Teytelboym A., Interpreting economic complexity//Science Advances, Vol. 5, Issue 1, eaau1705, 4 Jan 2019, t2 1-8:
w^sndbpbhwhbp, <wpw4.wj^h Mnpbw1 S<S, w^sndbpbhwhbp, U^hqw^mp1 S<S, w^sndbpbhwhbp, <wjwumwh' dni^PT-bh^ U ^qhö^ hwhpwpwpbp L ^mwhjmpbp, nu^, u^q.wphbp U nq.b[hg ^d^fhbp (wqjmuw^ 1)11:
UqjnLuw^ 2
bptypbbpfi luuipfiäiuhiu^iupqh pus iphipbuiu^iuh piupqmpjiuh hiudiuptffi Rank\ Country ||2019 \Rank\ Country \2019 \Rank\ Country ¡¡20/9 \Rank\ Country \2019
1 Japan 2.49 35 Bosnia and 0.73 69 Dominican -0.18 103 Ghana -0.85
Herzegovina Republic
2 Switzerland 2.13 36 Canada 0.69 70 Mauritius -0.19 104 Nicaragua -0.88
3 4 Germany South Korea 2.07 2.05 37 38 Latvia Portugal 0.67 0.63 71 72 Chile Namibia -0.21 -0.22 105 106 Bangladesh Uganda -0.88 -0.89
5 Singapore 2.00 39 Saudi Arabia 0.62 73 Argentina -0.24 107 Zimbabwe -0.91
6 Czechia 1.80 40 Turkey 0.61 74 Jamaica -0.24 108 Ethiopia -0.92
7 Austria 1.77 41 Norway 0.56 75 Sri Lanka -0.25 109 Burkina Faso -0.93
8 Q Sweden 1.75 1 &A 42 A Bulgaria 0.53 O AR 76 77 77 Armenia -0.27 n ßn 110 111 Malawi -0.94
9 10 Slovenia Hungary 1.64 1.63 43 44 India Costa Rica 0.46 0.38 78 Kenya Kazakhstan -0.30 -0.32 111 112 Madagascar Togo -0.95 -0.95
11 United States 1.57 45 Tunisia 0.36 79 Guatemala -0.32 113 Mongoli -0.96
12 1 5 UK 1.55 1 /Iß 46 /17 Cyprus 0.32 O Qfl 80 Iran -0.35 n /10 114 IIC Myanmar -1.00 1 nn
13 14 Finland Slovakia 1.48 1.45 47 48 Ukraine Panama 0.30 0.24 81 82 Qatar UAE -0.42 -0.44 115 116 Tanzania Algeria -1.00 -1.03
15 Italy 1.37 49 New Zealand 0.23 83 Albania -0.44 117 Ecuador -1.11
16 China 1.35 50 Greece 0.13 84 Oman -0.44 118 Cote d'Ivoire -1.11
17 Ireland 1.33 51 Trindad & Tobago 0.13 85 Paraguay -0.45 119 Yemen -1.13
18 1Q Mexico 1.31 52 CO Russia Pi-mii 0.12 n in 86 A7 Australia -0.45 n /Iß 120 Azerbaijan -1.11 1 O/l
19 20 France Israel 1.31 1.26 53 54 Brazil El Salvador 0.1 0 0.09 87 88 Uzbekistan Cambodia -0.48 -0.50 ■ ¿I LlUyd 122 Mozambique -1.24 -1.25
21 Belgium 1.21 55 Colombia 0.09 89 Morocco -0.52 123 DR of the Congo -1.34
22 Romania 1.20 56 Vietnman 0.05 90 Honduras -0.57 124 Mauritania -1.37
23 Thailand 1.15 57 Lebanon 0.04 91 Mali -0.60 125 Republic of the Congo -1.38
24 Malaysia 1.12 58 North Macedonia 0.04 92 Laos -0.65 126 Gabon -1.44
25 Netherlands 1.11 59 Bahrain 0.04 93 Pakistan -0.66 127 Angola -1.49
26 Denmark 1.10 60 South Africa 0.03 94 Cuba -0.69 128 Venezuela -1.49
27 Poland 1.08 61 Indonesia 0.02 95 Turkmenistan -0.70 129 Cameroon -1.53
28 Philippines 0.95 H QO 62 CO Uruguay 0.01 n 96 Q7 Zambia -0.72 O 7/1 130 1 Papua New Guinea -1.57 1 7H
29 30 Eston ia Croatia Belarus 0.92 0.87 f) 63 64 Georgia Eswatini -0.0I -0.03 P) DA 97 98 QQ Tajikistan Kuwait Botswana -0.74 -0.77 H 7Q 131 132 Liberia Guinea -I./0 -1.75 1 77
31 32 33 Spain Lithuania 0.83 0.81 0.79 65 66 67 Jordan Kyrgyzstan Egypy -0.04 -0.04 -0.15 99 100 101 Peru Senegal -0.7 9 -0.80 -0.80 133 Nigeria -I.ZZ
34 Serbia 0.75 68 Moldova -0.16 102 Bolivia -0.83 Uqpjnip* https://atlas. cid. harvard. edu/rankings
11 UipjnL|V https://www.worldstopexports.com/armenias-top-10-exports/
U||nLum^ 2-nLd 133 bp^phbph mush6mhm^mpqh t' pus shsbum^mh pmp^.nLpjmh hmdmp^h: Country & Product Complexity Rankings-md hmdm-p4.bpp hbp^mjmg4.m& bh pus «^m^mu pmp^. bp^hp» («most comlex country») -«wnw^bL pmp^ bp^hp» («least comlex country») umh^.|m^h (q&m^ms^bp 1)12:
2019 p. mush6mhm^mpqnLd «mnm^bL pmp^. bp^p» ^dph (q&m^ms-^bp 1-nLd dnLq ^m^nLjs hms4.m&) usnphh hnphqnhm^mhmd Pb|qhmh t' 1.21 hmdmp^n^.: Uj^. ^dphh hm^np^.n| ^dph (bp^hmqnyh hms4.m&), npp ^mjdmhm^mh ^mpb|h t mh^mhbL «^m^m^np pmp^. bp^hp», usnphh' 43-p^ hnphqnhm^mhmd <h^musmhh t' 0.46 hmdmp^n^.: 0.1 hmdmph^ nLhbgn| Ppmqhihmh qpm|bghnLd t 53-p^ hnphqnhm^mhp:
^-¿w^wm^bp 1. bptypbbpfi iphipbuiu^iuh pwpqmpjwb luuipftfiiuhiutyiupqmdp1
^Sm^ms^bp 1-hg bpUnLd t, np «-h ^mspmus^m&nLpjmh -0.27 hm-dmp^n^ (0-1 umh^.|m^) 158 bp^phbph 2mpfnLd 2019 p. qpm|bgpb[ t 76-p^ hnphqnhm^mhp (gm&p-d^^h Nmdp), hbsUmpmp' sb^hn|nqhm^mh umhdm-hhg h2mhm^m[h hbnnL t: t h^msb[, np qpbpb hnLjh dbpn^mpmhrn-
pjmdp shsbum^mh pmp^nLpjmh mum^6mh^ qhmhmmdmh hmdmp d2m^4.m6 hmdmp^n^ <mjmusmhp 2019 p. -0.31 hmdmp^n^ qpm|bgpb[ 88-p^ hnphqnhm^mhp 146 bp^phbph 2mpfnLd14:
bhpm^pmpmp' « Mmnm^mpnLpjmh SpmqpnLd umhdmh^mS h^msm-^p15 4.bpmpbpb[ t «^m^m^np pmp^ bp^hp» («pmpSp shsbum^mh pmp^nL-pjnLh»), mjL n^' «mnm^bL pmp^ bp^hp» ^dphh ^.mu4.b|nLh: <bsUmpmp' mj^ hqmrnm^^h hmuhb|nL hmdmp 0.1 hmdmp^h ^n^mpbh mnh^mqh ^bsp t hmuhb[ 0.5 hmdmp^hh, hh^h hpmsbum^mh ^mpn| t hmdmp^b hmdm^m-mmu^uh db^mhhqd qnp&m^.pb|nL ^.b^prnd: 2000 p. « T-hpfh mju mush-6mhm^mpqmd (35-p^ hnphqnhm^mh, npp 2019 p. qpm|bgpb[ t Pnuhhmh U
12 Sb'u Country & Product Complexity Rankings. https://atlas.cid.harvard.edu/rankings
13 9Um^n^nLpjnLhhbpp L|mrnmpb[ bh hb|hhml|hbpp: U|pjnLp' https://atlas.cid.harvard.edu/rankings
14 UipjnLp' https://oec.world/en/rankings/eci/hs6/hs96
15 « Mmnm^mpnLpjmh 2021-2026 pp. Spmqhp, t2 29-30:
<bpgbqn^hhwh 0.73 hwJwp4.n4), hw^whwpwp, qwjJwhw^np^wö t b^b wpmwhwhJwh rn^jwLhbph n^ 6h2s Uhh^U 2000-w^wh
^whhbph u^hqPQ «-hg qwhq^wöwpwp wprnwhwh^b bh n^ Jhwjh mb^w-^wh, wj[U wpmwuwhJwhjwh wprnw^pnLpjwh Jbpbhwuwppw^npnLJhbp: Uju-qbu ophhw^' qus Standard International Trade Classification-h (SITC)16, Jhwjh bp^nL (<4S-mJ17' «Uh2nL^wjh^ nbw^mnphbp, ^wpuwhbp, uwppw^npnLJhbp, Jb^whh^w^wh hwpJwpwhfhbp U H-pwhg Jwubp» U «tLb^mpw^wh Jbfbhw-hbp U uwppw^npnLJhbp, öwjhwqpn^ wqwpwmhbp U H-pwhg Jwubp»)18 wq-pwhpwjhh Mpbph wpmwhwhJwh Qh^hwhmp öw^wLh (npqbu wpmwhwhJwh Qh^hwhmp öw^wLh Jwuhwpwdhh) 2wpdQhpwgQ hbp^wjwg^wö t qöw-qwm^bp 2-nLJ: Uqpwhpwjhh wju ^JpbpQ bp^ph rnhmbuw^wh pwp^nLpjwh wumh6whQ qwjJwhw^npn^ qL^w^np ^Jpbphg bh19:
Cum qöwqwm^bp 2-h bp^ph rnhmbuw^wh pwp^nLpjwh wumh6whh pwpÖpwgJwhQ hqwumbL bh Jbpbhwuwppw^npnLJhbph wpmwhwhJwh öw-^wL^bph w6h pwpöp mbJqbpQ: Uhh^.bn, wj^ wpmw^pwhfQ hhJhw^whmJ Jwuhw^npbg^wö ^wJ qbmw^wh Öbnhwp^mpjnLhhbph whqnpömpjwh Jwmh^wö uwppw^npnLJhbph bh b^bL, hu^ T-pwhg öwqJwh bp^hpQ, hw^w-hwpwp' n^ <wjwumwhQ:
15 1 17. 4.414.4 2 10 15.2 .5
10 5 - - - — 10.3
7 .5 1 J. o 4 2 3 r 3 8
I2|93|12.82.2||3.^.9^53i.40is^,i.2119118i.ei17
1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 oooz 6661 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 §§§§§§§§§SSSS5SSSSS3
2. «Wfamtywjfib nbwtyipnphbp, Ipupuiuhbp, uiupfiu^npmdhbp, Sbfaiuhfäiu^iuh hiupSiupiuhfhbp h rypiuhg Swubp» h «t[b^ippiu-Ipuh Sbfbbwbbp h uiupfiutfnpmSbbp, äiujhiuqpnq luiqiupiuiphbp h rypiuhg Swubp» luiqpiuhfiujfth ¡vSpbpft lupipiuhiuhSiuh Siuuhiupiudfthp (%) « phtyhiuhmp lupipiuhiuhSiuh iw^wimS20
<wm^wqbu Jbö pwhw^h pwpöp wprnw^pn^w^wh Jbpbhwuwppw^n-pnLJhbp hbpJmö^bghh 1988 p. bp^pw2wpdhg hbmn, wjuhhph' ^.pwtip hhJ-hw^whmJ Qhpwgh^ 4-p^ mb^hnLnqhw^wh ^wgmpwÖUh («^nh^.pwmUjwh wLhfhbph mbuwh^jrnhhg») mb^hninqhwhbph thh: Uh^w^nLpjwh wnwghh mwuhwJjw^mJ <wjwumwhQ, qus tnLpjwh, ^npgpbg hp Jbfbhw2hhw^wh
16 Sb'u Standard International Trade Classification, Revision 4. United Nations, 2006, t2 113, 139:
17 <wjwumwb|i 4h6wl|wqpwl|wb mwpbq|ipg:
18 <wJwi^wmwu^wbmJ t SITC 2006-|i hbmbjw[ ^Jpbp|ib. Division 71-Power-generating machinery and equipment; Division 77 - Electrical machinery, apparatus and appliances, n.e.s., and electrical parts thereof (including non-electrical counterparts, n.e.s., of electrical householdtype equipment.
19 Sb'u Hidalgo C., Hausmann R., The building blocks of economic complexity//PNAS , June 30, 2009, vol. 106, no. 26, https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/106/26/10570.full.pdf
20 U^pjmp' - 1995, 1996, t2 183, - 2005, t2 484-485, - 2021, t2 527-528:
hmJm[hpp, nph npn2 Jhm^nphbp, Ôbnhmp^nLpjnLhhbp, mjh dmJmhm^m umhJmhmjhh rnb^hn[nqhmhbphh Jnm thh: Ujh, hh umhJmh^b t ^mnm^m-pnLpjmh ôpmqpn^ (JhghmdmJ^brnnLJ hmuhb[ 0.1 hmJmp^hh)21, ^h hmgnrç^bL mhb[ bpbf mmuhmJjm^h phpmgpmJ. pmg t pn^h^b umhJmhmjhh rnb^hn[n-qhmhbphh Jnsbhm[nL rnb^hn[nqhm^mh hhmpm^npnLpjnLhhbph ^mrnmhmhp HbnLu 1990-m^mhhbphh' ^mjJmhm^np^wô hbpfhh ^hmjnrçnLpjmhhbph Hb-ph mhmbuJmJp L ORhL-h h^mmJmJp phrnpmhpmjhh JnmbgJmh pmgm^m-jnLpjmJp: Um^mjh hm^ ^mpLnp t ^mpqb[, pb pmpôp murnh^mhm^mpq rnhbgn^ bp^phbph hh^n^ bh mmppbpmJ JjnLuhbphg: PmpÔp 4.mp^mhh2n4 bp^phbpp, un^npmpmp, ods^mô bh hbmLjmL hmm^mhh2hbpn4.. (1) mprnm-hmh^n^ mpmm^pmhfh pmqJmrnbum^nLpjmh, (2) pmprç. L bqm^h mprnm-hmh^n^ mpmm^pmhf (mjuhhfh' Jh fmhh bp^hp t mjrç^huh mpmm^pmhf pnrçwp^mJ)22: ^mumnpbh, bp^ph rnhrnbum^mh pmp^nLpjmh 4.mp^mhh2p t «mprnm^pn^m^mh qhsbLhfhg»: Uprnm^pn^m^mh qhmb[hfh «mh-hpmd^m mmppbphh» un^npmpmp rnhpm^brnmJ bh nLunLJhmnnLpjmh, ^np-ÔmnnLpjmh Jhgngn^.: <brnLmpmp' ^hrçph [nLÔnLJp hmhqnLJ t mprnm^pn^w-^mh qhsbLhfhbphh L hJmnLpjnLhhbphh mhpm^bmn^ ^m^pbp ^mmpmumb-LnLh, m^bLhh, rnb^hn[nqhmjh ^[mhJmh1 bp^ph ^mpnrçnLpjrnhp qmpqmghbLnLh: Pmjg mjrç. 6mhm^mphhh qmpqmgn^ L mhgmJmjhh mhmbunLpjmJp bp^phb-pp, npnhf qmh^nLJ bh hmJm2^mphmjhh rnb^hn[nqhm^mh umhJmhhg hbnnL, hmh^h^nLJ bh ^d^mphm^pmhmpbLh ^n^ph^nmh' hbpfhh hbp^pnLJhbph um-^m^nLpjmhp:
<m Jm2^mphmjhh pmh^h m6h L qmpqmgJmh hmhôhmdnrçn^p (mjunL-hbs' <mhÔhmdnrçn4), The Growth Report-mJ phrç.hmhpmghb[n4 «rnhrnbum-^mh hpm2fhbph» 13 ophhm^hbph (npnhg m6p ^mqJb[ t mmpb^mh, Jh2hh hm2^n4, 7%' 25 ^mJ m4.b[h smphhbp 2mprnhm^) ^npôp23, bqpm^mgpb[ t, np mdbrç, hmpmmL m6p ^mhmhgnLJ t hbprçpnLJhbph pmpôp Jm^mprçw^, <LU mnh^mqh 25%-p' hm2^h mnmô hh^bu ^brnm^mh, mjh^bu tL Jmuhm^np hbp^pnLJhbpp: ftbumpuhbpp hbprç.hb[nL, mjL n^ pb u^mnb[nL rçb^pnLJ mhmb-unLpjnLhhbpp ^n^qhgnLJ bh mhnLJ hbp^m L m^mqm ^bhumJm^mp^m^hbph JhgL: hh^bu m6h t hbp^pnLJhbphg, mjh^bu tL hbp^pnLJhbpp
^m^^mô bh rçpwhp ^hhmhum^npbLnL bp^ph ^mpnrçnLpjnLhhg' h hw2h4 hbp-fhh ^hmjnrçnLpjmhhbph ^mJ ommpbp^pjm mrçpjmphbph: U"hh^.bn, mprnm-umhJmhjmh ^n^mnnLpjmhhbpp ^m^^mô bh nhu^h hbs: <mhÔhmdn^n^.p h2nLJ t, np «^^m ^mjrnh pmpôp hbp^pnLJmjhh nL^nL npLt H-b^p, nph m^m-hn^4.mô ^h brçbL hbpfhh pmpôp ^hmjn^nLpjnLhhbpn^.»24: 2b^nLjgnLJ mu^nLJ t, np qmpqmgn^ bp^phbpnLJ pb^bm ORhL-p hbp^pnLJhbph ph^hmhnLp ôm4.m-LnLJ ^mqJnLJ bh n^ Jbô Jmuhmpmdhh, mjhnLmJbhmjhh^., Hpmhg ^mpLnpnL-pjnLhh m^bih Jbô t Jmuhmpmdhmjhh hbp^pnLJhg. Hpmhg Jhgngn^. ^n^mhg-
21 Sb'u « Mwnw^wpnLpjwh 2021-2026 pp. ôpmqhpp, t2 29:
22 Sb'u These are the most complex economies around the globe, https://www.weforum.org/agenda^019/12/countries-ranked-by-their-economic-complexity/
23 Pnpu^whw, Ppwqh[|iw, Qhhmummh, <nh^nhq, hh^nhbqhm, Ûwi^nhhw, Mnpbmjh <mhpm^b-mnLpjnLh, Um[mjqhm, Uw[pw, OJmh, Uhhqm^nLp, ^mj^mh, ^mhLmh^:
24 Commission on Growth and Development. The Growth Report: Strategies for Sustained Growth and Inclusive Development. Washington, DC : World Bank, 2008, pp. 34, 54.
i[nlJ bh wpmw^pw^wh U |hum|mnLg|nhw[ q|mb||fhbp: U| 2wPf bplphbp, npnhg p[nLJ Upqbhm|hwh, Ppwq|||wh, <h^lwumwhp, L|qbp|wh U Ubf-u|lwh bh, pb^bm mUw^wh dwJwhwl nLhbgb bh ^wjrnh mhmbuw^wh w6, wjhnLwJbhwjh|[, hbmwqwjmJ ^bh lwpn|wgb[ hwuhb[ Lhwpdbp qwpqwg-Jwh lwpqw[|6wl|: Cum ^|pbp <w[|p| U Uwjbp-&n|^bu^ «wj^.
mwppbp bpUnLjphbpp lwpn| bh mb^hn|nq|wlwh hhwpw[npnLpjnLhhb-p| ^wmmhwhhbp| wp^jnLhp, npnhf pwg[nLJ U ^wUrnJ bh mwppbp dwJw-hw^hbpnLJ»25:
2008 p. $|hwhuwmhmbuwlwh 6qhwdwJ|g hbmn, ph^hrn^ J|h^U 2020 p., « hbphnuni OnhL-p ^.puUnpb[ bh ^^us pwgwuw^wh J|mnLJhbp (q&w^wm^bp 3), npnhf w[b|| nLdqhwgwh COVID-19 hwJw[wpwl| hb-sUwhfn[: UUM-| World Investment Report 2021-mJ hbp^wjwg[w6 t wj^. wq-^.bgmpjwh ^w^p. 2020 p. 35%-n[ h[wqb[ bh OnhL-| hwJw2^wphwj|h hnu-fbpp, |ul «-mJ1 54%-n[: Qb^nygnLJ h2[nLJ t, np w[b|| Jb6 t bqb[ qwpqwgni U whgmJwj|h mhmbunLpjwJp bplphbp hnufbp| wh^mJp: <b-mUwpwp' « Mwnw[wpnLpjwh 2021-2026 pp. 6pwqpn[ uwhJwh[w& h^w-mwl|h hhwpw[np t hwuhb[ hbpf|h ^hwjn|nLpjnLhhbp| IbhmpnhwgJwJp, OnhL-| h[wqn| hnufbpp uwhJwhwj|h mb^hn|nq|whbp| hbp^pJwhh nL|-|np^.b|nl, npnhf ^h^wumbh mhmbunLpjwh pwp^nLpjwh wum|6wh| pwp5-pwgJwhp:
^^m OnhL ^^m <wJw^wnh ^hwjnqnLpjnLh
^^m H-bunLpuwjfih 6b|g[wSg —□—<|Jhwl|wh l|nLmwl|nLJ
3. Cfidhiu^iuh lpuiqfiipiu[fi l/nupiu^diuh (Cbb, CLU-f h^iuipdiudp, %), hiudiufaiunh fahiujnqmpjmhhbpfi (Cto, CLU-f h^iuipdiudp, %), OnhL-f l nbumpuwjfb fibrftfiudffi (CLL-Cto, CLU-f h^iuipdiudp, %) 2wpdpbpwgp CC-nid26
^6w^wm^bp|g bpUnLJ t, np mUw^wh dwJwhwl nbunLpuwj|h 6b|£-[w6f t bqb[ h|Jhw^wh lw^|mw|| ^mmw^Jwh U hwJw^wnh ^hwjn|nL-pjnLhhbp| J|gU: ^pw n^ Jb6 Jwup 6w6^lb[ t OnhL-|, |ul h2whwlw|| Jw-up' Jwuhw[np ^np^npwm|[ hwm[w6| ^hwjn|nLpjnLhhbp| U ^n^wnnL-pjnLhhbp| hw2l|h:
25 Howitt P., Mayer-Foulkes D., R&D, Implementation, and Stagnation: A Schumpeterian Theory of Convergence Clubs// Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. 37, No. 1, Feb., 2005, pp. 147-177.
26 <w2[wpl|hbpp L|wimwpb[ U qSwi^wiml|bpp L|wqJb[ bh hbqjihwlihbpp: UipjnLp' <4S, 20002021: <wJw2^wphwjfih pwhl|| im[jw[hbpfi pwqw:
40.00 30.00 20.00 10.00 0.00 -10.00 -20.00
33.1
24.2
-15.2 m o
14.7 15.3
-17.4
1990 1
<1994
3
| | |
8.6
■ ■ i ■ i ■ i ■ i ■ i ■ i ■ i ■ i ■ i ■ 111 i i "i
0022004200620082010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020
'I
^-¿w^wm^bp 4. « hiudiufaiunb bbpfftb fabiujnqmpjmbbhpft 2lupdDbpiugp (<hU-h bljiuipiiiuiip, %), 1990-2020 pp.27
Uj^.nLhwh^.bp5, hlwmh nLhbhw|n[, np « mhmbuwlwh pwp^.nLpjwh wumh6whp gw&p t, h^h hbrnUwhpn[ wpmwhwh[n| wprnw^pwhpp hnLjh-^bu pwp^.nLpjwh gw&p Jw^wp^w^ nLhh, mwuhwJjwlhbp 2wpnLhwl « wp-rnwfh^ wnUmph hw2[bJhwgnp^.p pwgwuwlwh t b|b[, hh^h t[ pwgwuwpwp t wh^pw^wp5b[ hwJw^wnh hbpfhh fuhwjninLpjnLhhbph Jw^wp^w-
lh [pw: Up^rnhprnJ' Jw^wp^w^p 1991-2020 pp. dwJwhwlwhwm-
[w&nLJ lwqJb[ t, Jh2hh hw2[n[, 1% (q&w^wmlbp 4): <wJbJwmmpjwh hw-Jwp h2bhf' w2^wphh Jh2hh gnLgwhh2P lwqJb[ t' 25.9%, Jh2hhhg pwpSp b^wJmn[ bplphbphhp' 33.8%, b[pn^wjh U Mbhmpnhw^wh Uuhwjh mwpw-6w2p2whh bplphbphhp' 25.1 %28: « U phmp[w6 mwpw6w2p2whhbph Cbfa U
gnLgwhh2hbpp hbplwjwg[w& bh wqjmuw^ 3-nLJ:
4bpnh2jw[ [bp|nL&nLpjnLhp hhJf t sw|hu bqpwlwghb|nL, np. 1) Mwjmh mhmbuwlwh w6h U qwpqwgJwh hwJwp wnwhgpwjhh t bp^ph rnhrnbunL-pjwh pwp^nLpjwh ^bpp, nph wprnw^pn^w^wh qhmb[hfhbph InLmwlJwh U wp^jnLhw[bm IhpwnJwh wp^jmhf t: 2) bplph mhmbuwlwh pwp^mpjwh wumh6whp ^wjJwhw[npw& t hwJw2^wphwjhh mb^hn|nqhw^wh uwhJw-hhg ^pw hbnw[npnLpjnLhhg: 3) UwhJwhwjhh mb^hn|nqhwhbph hbp^pJwh hwJwp whhpwd^m wprnw^pn^w^wh qhmb[hfhbph ^n^whgJwh lw^nL|h-hbphg Jblh omwpbplpjw nL||wlh hbp^.pmJhbph bh, npnhg hbphnufh Jw-lwp^.wlp pw[wpwp ^t, hul [bpghh mwuhwJjw^h JhsnLJhbph U COVID-19-h hbmUwhpn[ w[bLh bh Jb6wgb[ hbpfhh hbp^.pmJhbph $hhwhuw[npJwh wp-mwfhh w^pjnLphbph hbm lw^[w& whnpn2nLpjnLhhbpp: 4) Uhlw^nLpjnLhhg h [bp' bpbf mwuhwJjwlmJ, hbpfhh U wpmwphh hbp^.pmJhbph mb|wpw2-[unLJp qpbpb ^h h^wurnb[ bp^ph mhmbuwlwh pwp^nLpjwh wumh6whh pwpSpwgJwhp: 5) Lbpphh ^hwjn|nLpjnLhhbpn[ hbp^.pmJhbph $hhwhuw-[npJwh w^whn[[w&nLpjwh gw&p Jw^wp^w^p qu^mJ t bp^ph mhmbunL-pjwh IwjnLh w6p U qwpqwgnLJp: 6) <wJw2^wphwjhh mb^hn|nqhwlwh uwhJwhhh Jnmbhw|nL U « mhmbunLpjwh pwp^mpjwh wumh6whp pwp5-pwghb|nL hwJwp whhpwd^m hbp^.pmJhbpp hbpfhh w^pjmphbph hw2[hh ^hhwhuw[npb[nL IwpUnpnLpjnLhp Jb&wgb[ t:
27 UipjnLp' World Development Indicators// https://data.worldbank.org/indicator
28 UipjnLp' <wJw2^wphwj|ih pwhl|h rn[jw[hbph pwqw: World Development Indicators// https://data.worldbank.org/indicator
UqjnLum^ 3
« b bptypbbpfi pbipptfiud ¡vdpbpfi hiudiufoiunb Ivbiujnqmpjmbbbpp b hfidhiu^iuh lpuiqfiipiu[fi l/mipiutymdp
1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000
<mjmummb - - -5.4 2.6 -2.1 1.8 3.9 0.8 2.8 -0.9
28.5 17.1 12.5 20.2 16.2 17.9 16.2 16.2 16.4 21.7
Jh2h^h9 pmpfcp 31.0 31.0 33.3 33.1 31.0 30.4 30.4 29.5 28.9 29.5
b^mdmn^ bp^pbbp 23.4 26.2 29.9 28.8 27.1 26.7 26.3 26.6 25.5 26.0
U^mph 23.3 23.7 23.9 24.6 24.6 25.1 25.6 25.3 24.9 25.6
23.8 24.1 24.7 24.4 24.0 24.1 24.1 24.3 24.0 24.2
b^pn^m U - 25.0 23.5 23.2 20.2 20.1 23.6 28.2
^bbmpnbm^mb Uuhm 22.3 24.1 22.2 22.7 21.7 21.5 21.3 19.5 17.4 19.2
\2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 \2010
<mjmummb 5.4 10.2 16.3 19.7 24.3 28.5 28.6 27.9 14.0 13.2
20.8 24.8 27.1 28.1 35.1 41.9 46.8 42.9 39.4 30.7
Jh2h^h9 pmpfip 29.8 30.8 32.7 35.0 35.3 37.3 38.4 39.2 36.7 37.9
b^mdmn^ bp^pbbp 26.5 27.1 29.1 30.1 30.3 30.3 31.3 33.2 33.5 33.6
U2^mph 24.9 24.6 25.1 26.3 26.8 28.0 27.9 27.1 25.0 26.3
24.0 23.6 24.1 24.6 25.1 25.4 25.5 24.9 24.5 24.7
b^pn^m U 26.8 25.6 24.7 26.4 26.9 27.6 27.2 27.1 21.6 24.6
^bbmpnbm^mb Uuhm 19.6 19.5 20.5 22.0 22.0 22.3 24.8 25.3 23.3 23.3
\2011 \2012 \2013 \2014 \2015 2016 2017 \2018 2019 \2020
<mjmummb 11.1 14.1 14.8 13.3 18.4 17.8 16.9 15.3 9.8 14.7
23.6 21.2 20.0 20.6 17.4 17.6 16.7 15.8 16.6 43.5
Jh2h^h9 pmpfip 37.3 36.5 35.4 35.4 34.1 33.3 33.8 33.9 33.2 33.9
b^mdmn^ bp^pbbp 33.9 34.1 33.6 32.5 31.8 31.8 32.1 31.8 32.1 30.3
U2^mph 26.6 26.8 26.4 26.7 26.3 25.7 26.4 26.5 26.4 26.1
24.9 24.9 25.0 24.8 24.6 24.7 24.9 25.1 25.2 25.4
b^pn^m U 26.4 25.5 24.1 24.5 25.5 24.3 25.2 27.3 25.6 25.8
^bbmpnbm^mb Uuhm 23.9 23.8 23.9 23.6 23.5 23.8 24.0 23.4 23.1 23.7
^mqdbi bb hbqpbu^bbpp:
Uqpjmp' <UuiLiui2lwuiphuijlb pwbtyp ip^jw[bbpp puiqui: World development indicators, https://data. worldbank. org/indicator
«-md mhwj^h mhrnbunLpjrnhhbp^ ^hwjn^mpjmhhbp^ ^wqdw^bp^w& 5Up h^dhw^whmd w^wh^hbph bh, npnhf 2020 p. (1661.9 d[p^ H-pwd), 1997 p. hwdbdwmmpjwdp (46.7 d[p^ H-pwd), w6b[ bh 35.6 whqwd: 1997 p. wnUmpwj^h pwh^bp^ ^wp^wj^h hbp^pmdhbpp ^wqdb[ bh 46.6 d^wp^. ^.pwd, wju^hph1 phw^mpjwh w^wh^hbpp 100.2%-n^ bh mpwdw-
^wp^bpp: 2020 p. wj^. Swd^nypp ^wqdb[ t 42.7%, ^h^p h2whw^md t, np wnUmpwj^h pwh^bp^ ub^w^wh d^nghbpp h2whw^w[h w6b[ bh: Mwpb[h t bqpw^wghb[, np mhwj^h mhmbunLpjmhhbp^ ^hwjn^mpjmhhbpp h^wurnb[ bh « pwh^wj^h hwdw^wpq^ qwpqwgdwhp, wh2nL2s, MP-^ ^n^d^g ^n2m ^brnmpjwhp ^wd qwpqwgdwh ^brnmpjwhp phnpn2 qnp&wnnyphbp^ ^pw-^whwgdwdp: <bmUwpwp, hnyh^bp^, hoqmm mhmbumpjwh ^pw^wh hwm-wpwq w6n^ U phpwg^ hwdw2^wphwj^h mb^hn|nq^w^wh uwhdw-h^h dnmbhwm h^wmw^n^ ^hwjn^mpjmhhbp^ hbpqpw^nLdp ^wpn^ t
l^mumb[ lmU bp^ph mlmbum^ml qmpqmgJmlp: Ujrç. qnpöplpmghl mm^muimgnLpjnLl U hmJm^mpq^mömpjml hmrçnprç.b|nL mnmJn^, l^msm-^mhmpJmp t p^nLJ ommpbp^pjm nLrç^m^h lbp^pmJlbph mpmmhmlJml hmppm^lbph JnmbgJml ^^pmnnLJp «-mJ, hl^p ^mpUnp^nLJ t ^ Mmnm-^mpmpjml 2021-2026 pp. öpmqph hbmUjm[ ^pnLjpn^. «<mjmummlp, nLlb-lm|n^ ^nfp mlmbunLpjml, Jhgmqqmjhl 2nL^mlbpmJ ^mpn^ t JpgnLlm^ lbf pn^mp^b|n^ mlmbum^bu pmprç., pmpöp m^mg^mö mpdbf mlbgn^ m^pmlflbp U ömnmjnLpjmllbp»29: H-pm hmJmp ^mhmlg^nLJ bl n^ un^n-pm^ml JnmbgnLJlbp: U^lhmjmnpbl' « mlmbunLpjml hbmmqm m6p U qmpqmgnLJp ^m^mö bl mpmmfhl 2nL^mlbph hlmpm^npnLpjmllbpl oq-mmqnpöbinL1 bp^ph ^mpnrçmpjml hbm: Uprçbl l2^mö «The Growth Report»-md «mlmbum^ml hpm2flbph» 13 ophlm^lbph nLunLJlmuhpnLpjmJp pmgmhmjm^mö m^bgnLgh^ hhlq ^nrçJbphg Jb^p bqb[ t hmJm2^mphmjhl mlmbunLpjml hlmpm^npnLpjrnllbpp [hmpdbf oqmmqnpöb|p, hu^ bp^pnprçp' ^lmjnrçnLpjmllbph U lbp^pmJlbph pmpöp gmgml^lbpp (Jlmgmö bpbfp' Jm^pnmlmbum^ml ^mjnLlnLpjrnl, nbumpulbph pm2^nLJ 2nL^mjh Jhgngn^, l^hp^mö, ^ummhnLpjnLl lbp2l^n^ U ^mpnrçrnlm^ ^mnm^mpnLpjrnllbp)30: <bmUmpmp' « Mmnm^mpmpjml öpmqpnLJ 12^lJ t hblg mjrç. ^bmbphg Jb^h' mpmmfhl 2m^mlbph hlmpm^npnLpjmllbph oqmmqnpöJml Jmuhl: Ujuhlfl' mb^ln[nqhm^ml umhJmlhl Jnmblm[p blpm^pmJ t lbpfhl ^lm-jnrçnLpjmllbph ^blmpnlmgmJ U nL^rçnprç.mJ mnmgm^np mb^ln|nqhmlbpn^ pn^mp^mö mpmm^pmlfh Jbö Jmuh mpmmhmlJmlp' l^mmh nLlblm|n^ « 2nL^mjh ^npp Lhlb[p:
UJpn^2 m2^mphnLJ ORhL-h m6l mpmmgn|mJ t hl^bu mpmm^pnL-pjml Jhgmqqmjhl pmdmlnLJp' ^m^mö q|npm[mgJml hbm, mjl^bu t[ mp-mmhmlJmlp ^n^Jlnpn2^mö mjrç. mbum^h lbp^pmJlbph ^pm^muJml fm-^mfm^mlnLpjmlp qmpqmgn^ bp^plbph mlmbum^ml nmqJm^mpnLpjmllb-ph 2p2mlm^lbpnLJ: Ujrç^huh lbp^pmJlbpl ml^mlmJ bl mpmmhmlJml hmppm^h ORhL (Export Platform FDI): Mmpn[hlm t^n[Jp, fth^mprç. inpu-Lhn-P U SbjJu U"mp^mublp31 mpmmhmlJml hmppm^h ORhL-p umhJmlnLJ bl np^bu lbprçpmJlbp mpmm^pnLpjnLl plrçnln^ bp^pmJ, npmb^ pnrçmp^-^mö mpmm^pmlfp hhJlm^mlmJ ^mömn^nLJ t bppnprç., mj[ n^ pb plrçnln^ ^mJ lbp^pn^ bp^plbph 2nL^mlbpnLJ: UpmmhmlJml hmppm^h lbprçpmJ-lbph hmjbgm^mpqp mmulmJjm^lbp 2mpnLlm^ ^npÖmp^b[ t Jh 2mpf bp^plbpmJ (Mmlm^m, ^bfuh^m, hn[ml^hm U mj[l)32: L^mmh nLlblm[n^, np mnmlg lbpfhl ^lmjn^nLpjnLllbph Jhgngn^ lbpfhl lbp^pmJlbph ^h-lmlum^npJml hlmpm^np ^t Jnmblm[ mb^ln[nqhm^ml plpmgh^ umhJmlhl, mjrç. hmjbgm^mpq t lbpJnLö^bL lbpfhl lbp^pmJlbph ^mJ ^lmjn^nLp-jnLllbph mmppp: <bmUmpmp' mj^^huh hmppm^p ^ml^ml^h «mpmmhml-
29 « Mwnw^wrinLpjwb 2021-2026 ôpwq^p, t2 29:
30 Sb'u Commission on Growth and Development. The Growth Report : Strategies for Sustained Growth and Inclusive Development. Washington, DC : World Bank, 2008, t"2 21:
31 Sb'u Ekholm K., Forslid R., Markusen J., Export-platform foreign direct investment. NBER Working Paper, No. 9517, February 2003, 35 tg:
32 Sb'u ^mp^mbjmb T-., UpmwhwbJwb hwppwl|bbp|i omwpbpl|pjw nL^^w^^ bbp^pnLJbbp^
^npâp: «Uj^bmpwbg» q^mwlwb hwb^bu, 2019, tg 82-88:
^^ hшpрш|^ отшрЬр|р]ш и ^Ьрр^Ь ^Ьр^рт^Ьр» (и<ОЪЪ); ПрщЬи Ьррпр| ЬрЦрЪЬр^ 2т|ш^Ьр ЬЦЭ^33 и иЬрЙш-
фр ЦриЬ[р^ прп2 ЬрЦрЪЬр^ 2^|ш^Ьрр, ^^ шпш^Й^ hЬmшqnmnLрJшh шпшр|ш |шрп^ t Ц|и шпт^ф и<ОЪЪ ^ш^шфшрр hшdшhnL^ t
ЬиЭ^ «Ьфши^ш|ш^ т^тЬиш|ш^ d^nLрJnLhnLd т^тЬитр^^' ^^тЬ^рш-д^п^ ^Ьрт^ т^Ьдп^ пщрт^Ьр^ и |рш oqmшqnp&dшhh т^дЦшб dши^» фшитшр^р^' «^ЬтЬишр^Ь' Ьррпр| ЬрЦрЪЬр шpmшhшЫшh dЬ-&шдdшh и ф^ЬриЬФЬ^шд^Ь ^Ьрт^ т^Ьдп^ 6]т^Ьрр» 2.2 |Ьт^, пртЬ^ Ь^ ш^ ^прбп^^Ьрр, прп^д ЦЬр|ш5шр]ш№Ьрр рпьц ЬЬ
тшфи т^тЬитр^^ пLпpmпLJ ^mЬqpdшh ЬЬрш^ шп|ш]шр]шЬ dши^h Ьqpш|шдnLрJnLh ш^Ь[. ш) шщрш^р^Ьр^ (бшпш^р^^Ьр^) шртшр^ ш^итр^ ^ип^ шh|шd щЬттр^^Ьр^ hшdЬdшmш|шh шпшЦЬ|шр]ш№Ь-рр' Ш2^шph^ шд ЬрЦрЪЬр^ hЬm hшJЬJшmш6 (ш2^шph^ рп|пр ЬрЦрЪЬр^ Jшип4 пpп24пLJ ЬЬ Рш|шишф ^Ь^ЬрипЦ), р) Ьррпр| ЬрЦрЪЬр и ифтр^Ь шh|шd щЬттр^^Ьр фшитшд^ и hhшpш4np шpmшhшЫшh |шптд-^ш&рр»34:
и<ОЪЪ qшpqшдdшh hшJшp |шpUnp4nLd ЬЬ ЬpЦпL тЬиш|^ ^рш^Ьр. (1) и<ОЪЪ отшрЬр|р]ш ^Ьр^рпфЬр^ mpшdш|p4n^ hшp|шJ^ шртп^т-р^^Ьрр, (2) и<ОЪЪ ^Ьр^рпфЬр^ mpшdш|p4n^ hшp|шJ^
шртп^тр^^Ьрр и итри^фш^Ьрр' ^Ьрр^Ь ^ш^^тр^^Ьр^ ^ршЫш^ и ишhdшhшJ^ тЬ^п^^ш^Ьр^ ^Ьр^^ш^Ь т^дпр^Ьщ Ьцштш-
|пф Чшпш^шртр^^Ьр^ JЬ6 ^и^ ш|т^прЬ^ шпш2 t ^р ЬрЦ^рр' прщЬи hЬp|pnLdшJ^ qшpqшдdшh hшиhЬ|nL hшJшp
Jши^ш4пp |шщ^тш[, тЬ^п^^ш^Ьр и hdmnLрJnLhhЬp
hЬpqpш4Ь|пL ^щштш|пф Uшhdшh4nLd Ь^ шртп^тр^^Ьр, ^рш^Ьр: Цц
^Ь^ии 1994 р. t «ОтшрЬр|р]ш hЬp|pnLdhЬp^
и^» « орЬ^рр: и<ОЪЪ шпт^ф ^пирр 4ЬpшрЬpnLd t ОрЬ^р^ 4-р| hn|-^шбп^ ишhJш^4ш6 отшрЬр|р]ш тЬиш|^Ьр^д р) |Ьтп^ шJ-
pшqp4ш&^. «<ш]шитш^ <шЬршщЬттр]ш^ ш^Йш^д,
ш^Й^ |шpqшф6ш| ^п^Ьдп^ ЙЬп^шр^тр^^Ьр^ |шd <ш]шитш^ <шЬршщЬттр]ш^ рш^шршд^Ьр^ dшиhш|дnLрJшdр ^пр ЙЬп^шр^тр^^Ьр h^J^ш^pЬLпL qпp6п^ ЙЬnhшp^пLр|пLhhЬpпLd рш^-^ЬJши ЙЬпр рЬpЬLпL ^2пдпф>: Сит tпLрJШ^, ОрЬ^р^ ^ ^Ьр, рп-
[пр тЬиш^^ отшрЬр^ш mpшJш^p4ЬL Ь^ шртп-
^пLрJпL^^Ьpр, ^рш^^Ьрр: Up^.JпL^fпLJ, прп2 фпрр ршдшnпLрJпL^^Ьpп4, ЬрЦр^ m^mЬипLрJШ^ шпш2р^-
ршд ^^ 4^ШJпLрJпL^р 4Ьpп^2|ШL hшJшр4Ьp^ Ь^: ^^^^р^ ш]^
t, пр hшp^ШJ^ ^pш^пLипLJр цЬтр t hиmш^ ^цштш^^Ьр'
33 ^Ь^Ьт, hшJшЙШJb Распоряжение Евразийского межправительственного совета от 7 марта 2017 г. N 2 фшитшр^р^, bU.SU ^ЬmnLрJnLbbЬp шртшИшЬт^ t пр^Ьи ЬЬрр^Ь шпитр|пЬ ЬpUnLJр, ШJ^nLhшb^ЬpЙ, U^nLрJшb 2P2ш^шN^ЬpnLJ « Jшubшq^-mшдJшb ^npшдJшb l^.ЬщgnLJ U^nLрJшb ЬЬрр^Ь 2nL^ш шртш^ршЬр^ ^тш1|шршр^ф ИЬшрш^пр t фп^шр^ЬЬ[ ш][ ^ЬmnLрJnLbbЬp Ьррпр| Ьр|рЬЬр^д bЬpJnL&nLJр^
ип^ JЬ&шдbЬ[n4 « шpmшhшbJшb йшфшщ:
34 Распоряжение Евразийского межправительственного совета от 7 марта 2017 г., N 2, О сферах экономики, обладающих интеграционным потенциалом в Евразийском экономическом союзе, и мерах, направленных на его использование.
bp^p^ qmpqmgJmh mbumh^jmh^g, fiu^ ORhL-^ ^pmhmJp L^h^ rç.pm hbm. hbp^pmJhbpp ^bmp t hbpqpm^b mjh^u^ nLnpmhbp, npnhf h^mummJ bh bp^p^ mb^hnLnq^m^mh mnmgphpmg^h (op^hm^' tLb^mpn-h^mj^), U rçpmhp ^pm^mubL mjL nLnpmhbpnLJ (op^hm^' hmhfmprçjrnhmpb-pmpjmh), ^h^bu phrçmh^mô t brçbL hmJm2^mphmj^h mb^hnLnq^m^mh umhJmh^h JnmbhmLnL hmgn^mô ^npö rnhbgn^ bp^phbpmJ35: Sb^hnLnq^m-^mh phpmg^ umhJmh^h «-^ JnmbhmLnL' ommpbp^pjm U hbpp^h hbp-rçpmJhbp^ mpmmhmhJmh hmppm^ hmjbgm^mpqmj^h 2p2mhm^p hbp^m-jmg^mô t qöm^mm^bp 5-nLJ:
hh^bu bpUnLJ t qöm^mm^bp 5-^g, « mhmbum^mh pmprç.mpjmh mum^ömh^ pmpÖpmgJmh, hbmUmpmp' ^mjmh U mUm^mh mhmbum^mh m6^ hmJmp hm^m^pjmLhbp^ umbrçôJmh $^hmhum^mh ^nrçdp bhpmrçpmJ t ^pmhhbp^ bp^nL mbum^. hmp^mj^h ^pmhhbp' umhJmhmj^h mb^hnLnq^m-hbp^ ^n^mhgmJh m^mhn^n^ ORh-L-^ hmJmp U umpu^m^nprnJ' umhJm-hmj^h mb^hnLnq^mhbp (US) hbprçhbLnL hmJmp hbpp^h ^hmjnrçnLpjmhhbpp ^bhmpnhmghbLnL h^mmm^n^:
j «Greenfield» tibpr^priLd «-mil tinp ÖbtlllUipl|llL- Upipui- mm
UiuhJiubiujIib mb[ubn[nq|iLU pjmti h[iiftiuii).pni\ huibnid
1 ^ J «Upmwr|.pnriiul|iub q|imb[)ig» [ipuii|uipuitiuiljuiti uitiä, UH
Umpupqptubbp' tibpgfiti jubutjnqnipjnibbbpQ tjbbtppnbtugbbini htutitup
buiujLpujLip' uiuhtliubiujpb qib[vbn[nqpiubbpp bbpqpiliub Ivpiubnul' huiiluiäuijb Uqhpbbp b mpp2bbpp ¡¡¿uilfuià iinqb[p: US-bbpnil hiutliuiphq âbnbiupljnLp-jnLb uipbqâb[riL huiiluip « "-(uinuiLluipnL[3juib umpupqpuijp 30%-p ¿ujiprul IvbiujnqnLp-jriLbbbp bbpqpiuilb[m iqiujtliubnil:
5. Sbfabn[nqfiiutyiub pbpiugfä uiuhdiubfib CC-f ilmpbbiu[m' lupipiu-hiubdiub hiuppiu^fi oipiupbp^pjiu b bbpffb bbpqpmdbbpfi (Ü.COLL) hiujbgiutyiupqiujfib 2p£iubiutyp
Ldwhwm^ hwp^wj^h ^pwhhbpp hwdw^wp^w^ hbp^wjwg^wö bh wnUmp^ U qwpqwgdwh hwdwdn^n^h Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment ^wumwp^pmd36 U d^ 2wpg wpdbpw^np d2w^mdhbpmd37. Un^npwpwp, hdwhwm^ wpmwhwhdwh hwppw^hbpp qnpörnd bh wqwm wnUmp^ qnm^hbpmd (Free-trade zone-FTZ): Lnp umb^ö^nT. fibnhwp^nLpjmh-hbpmd hbp^.pmdhbpp (Greenfield Investment) dbö hbmwppppnLpjnLh bh hbp^wjwghmd hwm^w^bu qwpqwgnq. bp^phbp^ hwdwp, pwh^ np h^wu-mmd bh mhmbumpjwh wpwq ph^.|wjhdwhp, pwpöp ^wpÖwrnp^nT. U pwpöp
35 Sb'u Commission on Growth and Development. The Growth Report : Strategies for Sustained Growth and Inclusive Development. Washington, DC : World Bank, 2008, t2 34:
36 Sb'u Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment. A Global Survey. New York and Geneva, UN, 2000, t2 13:
37 Devereux M., Griffith R., 2003; Egger P., Loretz S., 2008; Muthitacharoen A., 2020:
biyuiqiwlji]' «Sbfabn[nqpwbbpp ipnfawbgmb» (fapwbbbp' hpbb^ujô UNCTAD/ITE/IPC/Misc.3 lïhlbwpwbmp-jnLb, qputynb-ipuiilnpluiâ EMTR-p b EATR-p):
npm^m^npnLJ ^mhmlgn^ m2^mmmmbrçbph umbrçôJmlp U mb^ln[nqhm^ml mnmgplpmghl:
<mp^ t l2b[, np lbp^pnLJlbph ^mjpl plmpb|nL ^bpmpbpjm[ npn2nLJlbpp ^m^^mö bl hmp^mjhl öm^ubphg' hl^bu lbpfhl, mjl^bu t[ Jh2mqqmjhl: <bmUmpmp' hmp^mjhl ^pmllbp J2m^b[hu un^npmpmp hm24h t mnl^nLJ hbmUjmip. 1) lbp^pn^lbpp ^mlqlmö bl bp^nL ^mJ m^b[h ^n^m^mpömpmp pmgmnn^ lm^mqöbph JhgU rçhu^pbm plmpnLpjml mngU, 2) 4bpmqqmjhl pl^bpnLpjnLllbph qml^b[nL 4mjpp U mjl, np lpmlg plmpnLpjnLlp ^m^^mö t mp^jnLlm^bm Jh2hl hmp^mjhl rçpnLjfm^m^hg, 3) np^bu hhJf ^mpn^ bl pl^nLl^bL bp^nrçJmlh mp^jnLlm^bm hmp^Jml JnmbgnLJlbpp:
Slmbumqbmlbph 2p2mlnLJ Lmjlnpbl pl^nLl^mö t, np pmqJmqq pl^b-pnLpjnLllbph mpmm^pmpjml U lbp^pmJmjhl npn2nLJlbph hmJmp ^np^n-pmmh4 hmp^Jml rçbph 4bpmpbpjmL ^npömnm^ml m2^mmmlfp ^bmf t hhJl^h hmp^mjhl m^bLh pl^qp^nLl pm^m^ph^lbph, mjL n^ Jhmjl opblu-rçpmpjmJp umhJml^mö ^np^npmmh4 hmp^h ^pnLjfm^m^bph 4pm:
UmjfL ^Ubpnl U hmJmhb^hlm^lbpp l2nLJ bl. «Un^npmpmp, ^np^npm-mh4 b^mJmmjhl hmp^p.... qnpönLJ t np^bu ^n^pl^nm lbp^pmJlbph hmJmp: Ujrç. ^bpm^n^nLJlbph bp^nL ^nrçJp (rçpnLjfm^m^h l^mqbgnLJ U pmqm-jh pl^LmjlnLJ) ^n^hmmnLgn^ mqrçbgnLpjrnl bl nLlblnLJ mjrç. ^n^pl^nmh 4pm. gmöp hmp^mjhl ^.pnLjfm^m^p pmpÖpmglnLJ t lbp^pmJlbph ^pmlp, Jhl^bn mJnpmhqmghnl gmöp JmuhmlnLJlbpp JbömglnLJ bl rçpmlf»38: <b^hlm^lbpl oqmmqnpöbL bl «mprçjmlm4bm hmp^mjhl rçpnLjfm^m^bp» (effective tax rate-ETR) bqpnLjpp' Lhlh umhJmlmjhl (effective marginal tax rate-EMTR), pb Jh2hl (effective average tax-EATR) hmp^mjhl opblu^pmpjml 4pm hhJl^mö JhgngmnnLJlbph hmJmp:
OnhL-h ^pmllbpp np^bu hhJf bl pl^mlmJ hl^bu hmp^mjhl T-pnLj-fm^m^p, mjl^bu tL hmp^mjhl pmqml, hl^p ^mjJmlm4np4mö t 4bpnl2jmL mnmghl ^bmn4, Jmulm4npm^bu' rçhu^pbm plmpnLpjmJp. m) np mbum^h lbp^pmJp ^bmf t Öbnlmp^bL, p) lbp^pmJlbph öm4mLp, q) lbp^pmJlbph 4mjpp: ^hpbp tqbpp U UmjJnl Unnbgp39, nLunLJlmuhpbLn4 S<2M bp^plb-pnLJ qnpön^ hmp^mjhl opblu^pnLpjrnllbpp U hmp^mjhl pnLnp hmJmÖmjlm-qpbpp, hm24mp^bL bl mprçjmlm4bm (umhJmlmjhl U Jh2hl) hmp^mjhl ^pnLjfm^m^bpp, npnlf ömnmjmJ bl S<2M bp^plbph JhgU bp^nrçJmlh mpmmhnun^ OnhL-h öm4mLlbph 4pm ^np^npmmh4 hmp^Jml mqrçbgmpjnL-lp qlmhmmbLnL hmJmp: Lpmlf hmlqbL bl hbmUjmLhl. 1) ^np^npmmh4 hmp^bpl tm^mlnpbl mq^mJ bl mpmm^pmpjml U mb^mpm2^Jml 4bpm-pbpjmL 4bpmqqmjhl pl^bpnLpjnLllbph npn2nLJlbph 4pm, 2) qnLjq bp^plbphl plnpn2 hmp^mjhl pbnh hmpm^m^l mpmmgnLnLJ t nL^^m^h mqrçbgnLpjrnlp OnhL-h 4pm' mqqmjhl pl^bpnLpjnLllbph hmJmp hmp^mjhl rçpnLjfm^m^bph hm24mnJmJp, 3) Jhm^nrçJmlh hmp^mjhl rçpnLjfm^m^bpp lbp^pmJlbph ömqJml U plrçmln^ bp^plbpmJ mpmmgnLnLJ bl hmp^mjhl rçpnLjfm^m^bph rçbpp, nphl hml^h^nLJ bl mqqmjhl pl^bpnLpjnLllbpp hmJm^mmmu^mlm-
38 Devereux M.P., Griffith R., Klemm A., Economic Policy, Volume 17, Issue 35, 1 October 2002, p. 452.
39 Sb'u Egger P., Loretz S., Bilateral Effective Tax Rates and Foreign Direct Investment // International Tax and Public Finance, 16(6), 2008, t2 1-24:
pmp' ömqJmh m4jm[ bp^pmJ U ph^.mhn^ bp^pmJ, 4) Jhmjh Jhm^n^Jmhh mp^jnLhm4bm hmp^mjhh ^.pnLjfm^m^bph oqmmqnpömJp ^mpn^ t hmhqbg-hb[ bp^n^Jmhh ORhL-h 4pm hmp^mjhh qnpöhfhbph (ophhm^ bp^n^Jmhh hmp^mjhh hmJmÖmjhmqpbph Jhgngn4) ^n^n^mpjmh mq^bgmpjmh Jmuhh n^ mpdmhmhm4mm bqpmhmhqnLJhbph: Ophhm^' hhmpm4np t, np ph^mhn^ bp^pmJ Jhm^n^Jmhh hmp^mjhh ^.pnLjfm^m^bph pmpÖpmgmJp, nph mq^.mJ t mqqmjhh ph^bpnLpjrnhhbph 4pm, u^m|JmJp ^m^4h mj^ bp^pmJ ORhL-h h4mqJmh hbm:
4bpn^2jmLP hhJf t' bqpm^mghb|nL, np umhJmhmjhh mb^hn|nqhmhbph hbp^.pJmh L^mmm^n4 « ORh-L-h hbpqpm4Jmh hmp^mjhh ^pmhhbpp ^bmf t hh Jh4mö [hhbh bp^n^Jmhh mp^jnLhm4bm hmp^mjhh ^pnLjf m^m^b-ph 4pm, npn2 62qpmnLJn4' ^m^4mö <<-h' ön4mjhh b|f ^rnhbgn^ bp^ph ^mp-qm4h^m^h hbm: <mJmÖmjh ^UM-h qhmhmmmJhbph' ön4mjhh b|f ^rnhbgn^ bp^phbph mpmmhmhmJhg Jhh^U 15%-n4 ^m^mu b^mJmm bh ummhmJ, fmh mhbgnqhbpp: UNCTAD-h ^npömqbmhbpp ^mpömJ bh, np «mmpmöm2p2m-hmjhh mnUmpmmhmbum^mh hhmbqpmJp, hh^bu hmU n|npmhbph qmpqmg-Jmh h^mmm^n4 mmpmömpjmh h^mmJmJp n^ qqmjrnh, ORhL-h hbpqpm4-Jmh gmhfbpp ^mpn^ bh oqhbf ^n^hmmnLgbm mj^ bp^phbph' m2^mp-hmqpm^mh mnmJn4 pnLjL ^n^Jp»40: « mj^ pnLj[ ^n^Jp Jb^Jbm JnmbgnLJ ^mpn^ t T-hm4b[ «wp^jnLhw4bm hmp^mjhh ^.pnLjfm^m^bph» ^hu^nhmm4n-pnLJp' mpmmhmhJmh U hbpJnLöJmh hm4bijm[ öm^ubph qnpöm^gn4: L^mmh rnhbhm|n4 ön4mjhh b|f ^nLhbhmm qnpönhp U hhJf ph^.nLhb|n4 ^mjf[ H-Ub-pnjh nL JjnLuhbph Jbpn^mpmhnLpjnLhp'41 mpmmhmhJmh hmppm^h ORh-L-h hmJmp «wp^jnLhw4bm hmp^mjhh ^.pnLjfm^m^bph» hm24mp^p ^mpn^ t ^m-mmp4b[ hbmUjm[ pmhmÖUbpn4.
1. LupiynLhw^bs uuihduihuijfih huipliuijfih
DEMTR = EMTR * (XCt + Mj),
2. LupijnLhw^bs dfahh huipiiuijfiti rpnLjfw^w^.
DEATR = EATR * (XCi + Mj), nprnb^' DEMTR-p U DEATR-p ön4mjhh b[f ^nLhbhmm qnpönhn4 62qpm4mö, hmJm^mmmu^mhmpmp' umhJmhmjhh U Jh2hh hmp^mjhh ^.pnLjfm^m^bph bh, XCi -h' mpmmhmh4n^. i mpmm^pmhfn4 Ö2qprnJmh qnpöm^hgp, MCi'-h hbpJnLÖ4nn. mpmm^pmhfn4p: L24mö qnpöm^hghbpp ^mpn^ bh ummg4b[ m2^mphh ^mJ ORhL-h ömqJmh bp^ph mpmmhmhJmh U hbpJnLÖJmh öm^-ubph Jm^mp^m^hbpp hmpmpbpb[n4 ph^nLhn^ bp^ph, mju ^b^fnLJ' « mpmmhmhJmh U hbpJnLÖJmh öm^ubph Jm^mp^m^hbphh' pum pn^mp^4b[hf mpmm^pmhfh: U^hhmjm t, np mj^ qnpöm^gh JbönLpjnLhp ^mjJmhm4np4mö ^Lhhh pn^mp^4b[hf mpmm^pmhfh pmp^nLpjm Jp42, hh^h w4b|wgJwJp mm-phhbph phpmgfnLJ pmpÖpmhnLJ t hmU bp^ph mhmbum^mh pmp^nLpjmh mu-mhömhp, mj^^hun4' ^pm^mh mq^bgnLpjnLh nLhbhm|n4 mpmmhmh4n^. mp-mm^pmhfh m^mhn4mqpm^mh U ^n^m^pJmh öm^ubph 4pm: ^jnLu ^n^-Jhg' ORhL-h mpmmhmhJmh hmppm^nLJ mpmm^pmhf pn^mp^b[nL hmJmp hmp^ t hbpJnLöb[ npn2m^h hnLJf U hjnLpbp, hh^p ^^mhmhgh ^n^m^pJmh
40 Development and Globalization: Facts and Figures. UNCTAD. New York and Geneva, 2004, p. 4.
41 Sb'u Devereux M.P., Griffith R., Klemm A., h24. W2^., t2 452:
42 Sb'u Country & Product Complexity Rankings, https://atlas.cid.harvard.edu/rankings/product
w^b|h dbS Sw^ubp: ^Sw^wrnlbp 6-nLJ, ophhwl, hbplwjwg^wS t hbpdrnS-dwh Sw^wLh hlwmdwdp (%) w^whn^wqpwlwh U pbnhw^n^w^.pmdhbph Sw^ubph (Costs of insurance and freight services) dwlwp^.wlh 2wpdphpwgp 1980-2002 pp.43, bpp, mb^blwrn^wlwh mb^hn|nqhwlwh hb^w^n^mpjwh wq^bgmpjwdp, hhmbhuh^wgwh n^ dhwjh mhmbuwlwh q|npw|wgdwh, wj|U wprnw^pwhfh pwp^mpjwh wurnh^whh pwpSpwgdwh qnpSphpwghbpp:
Suipquigwd hptypbhp
Ltbbyipnbuityuib b Upbhywb bijpniyuijp hptypbhp
&n^wjpb hf ¿mbhgnq hptypbhp Suipquignq hptypbhp U.2^uiph
■ 2002 ■1980
3.8
4.8
3.3 8 4.7
13.5
10
15
4
3
0
5
6. Uiqiuhntfiuqpiutylub b pbnbiuilinfaiuqpmdbbpfr dwfaubpp44
hh^bu bpUnLd t q&w^wmlbphg, Sn^wjhh b[f ¿rnhbgn^ bplphbph hbp-dnL&dwh Sw^ubpp h2whwlw|h qbpwqwhgnLd bh djnLu bplphbph Sw^ubpp: <w2^wp^h hwdwp Iwrnwpbhp npn2 bhpw^pnLpjmhhbp. EMTR = 10%, EATR = 15%, XC=i 0.05, M/=0.1: <brnUwpwp' MTR = 8.5%,
DEATR = 12.75%:
Uju dnmbgnLdp d^rn^wS t Sn^wjhh b|f ¿nLhbhw|nL qnpSnhh ¿bqnfwgdw-hp: « wpmwhwhdwh U hbpdnL&dwh Sw^ubph hw2^wpldwh hwdwp ^^w-hwhg^bh [pwgmgh^ nLumdhwuhpnLpjnLhhbp, ph^. npnLd, jnLpwpwhymp hbp-^.pmdwjhh hw^wq&h hwdwp l^whwhg^bh hwmml hw2^wplhbp, npnhg dh-2ngn^ urnwg^wS ^u^nhmw^npdwh qnpSwlhghbpp mwppbp bplphbph hbp-^.pnqhbph U hbp^pdwh n|npmh hwdwp mwppbp lihhbh:
Uhwdwdwhwl, hwpl l^|_hhh nLumdhwuhpbi « bplln^dwhh U pwqdw-In^dwhh hwp^wjhh hwdwSwjhwqpbpp1 whhpwd^mmpjwh ^.b^pmd hwdw-^wmwu^wh 62qpmnLdhbp whb|nL h^wmw^n^: Omwpbplpjw hbp^pn^hbphh whhpwd^m bh hhdhw^np ^wumwplhbp wn wjh, pb hh^nL hbp^.pmdhbp ^bmf t whb[ rn^jw[ bplpnLd: <brnUwpwp'
- wnwgwpl^nLd t dh2hh hwplwjhh ^.pnypw^w^h &2qphm ¿w^md, npp ^bmf t hw^wuwp Lhhh wp^jmhw^bm uwhdwhwjhh hwplwjhh ^pnLj-gw^w^h dh2hh db&mpjwhp, npmb^ l2hnhbpp Iw^wS bh hbp^pnLdhbph b^wdmwpbpnLpjnLhhg,
- hbplwjwghb[ U hwdw^pb[ wj^ gnLgwhh2h pw2^nLdp hbpfhh U omwpbplpjw hbp^pnLdhbph hwdwp:
Uh IwpUnp h^wrnwnnLd1 Iw^wS OHhL-h pw2^dwh mwpwubnnLpjwh hbm: Uph^wm Umphmw^wpnbhp qmm OHhL-p ^hswplb t np^bu bpl-
43 <bmwqw swphhbph qblnLjghbpnLd ¿bh hwhi^h^nLd hdwh rn^jw[hbp: 2hwjwS i^pwh, wji^ rn^jw[hbpp Iwpni^ bh lnqdhnpn2h lhhb[ wjumbi^ hbplwjwg^wS dnsbgdwh hwdwp:
44 Sb'u Development and Globalization: Facts and Figures. UNCTAD. New York and Geneva, 2004, t2 5:
|n^Jmhh mp^jnLhm4bm Jh2hh hmp|mjhh ^pnLjfm^m^bph U mj[ ^n^n^m-|mhhbph $mh|ghm: Uju JnmbgmJp hm24h t mnhmJ ORhL-h muhJ^mnmh! pm2^nLJp U hhmpm4npnLpjnLh phÖbnmJ hmJm|n^Jmhh n-hmmp|b|nL hmp-|mjhh qqmjmhnLpjmhp ORhL-h pm2^Jmh Jbg' 4bpmhu|b|n4 ^hmmp|4nT. phnLpmqpbph pus bp|phbph, hh^bu hmU dmJmhm|h phpmgfnLJ ph^hm-hnLp ghgnLJhbpp, ophhm| 2008 p. $hhmhum|mh |mJ COVID-19 hmJm4m-pm|h mnmgmgpmö öqhmdmJbpp: Ch^.nLhb|n4, np hmp|nLJp |mpUnp ^bp t ^m^mJ ORhL-h hbpqpm4Jmh mnmJn4, mj^nLhmh^bpÖ, hm |mpönLJ t, np pb^bm 4h^m^mqpnpbh ^pmhf h2mhm|m|h bh hbp^.pmJhbph pm2^Jmh Jbg,
pus mJpnq^ pw2^Jwh Jhmubn ^bh: <mp|bpp ^m|mu h2mhm|nLpjnLh nLhbh hbp^pnLJmjhh Jbö hnufbpn4 bp|phbph hmJmp, npmb^ hbp^pn^hbph mp^bh huL| ömhnp bh ph^mhn^ bp|phbph hbm, hh^p |mpUnp t' pJpnhbm hmp|Jmh mq^bgnLpjmhp pm2^Jmh 4pm: bqpm|mg4b t, np ph^.mhn^ bp|ph hhJhm-pmp qnpönhhbpp' m2^mmmhfh mpmm^pn^m|mhnLpjnLhp U opbhfh qbpm-|mjnLpjnLhp, |mpUnp bh ORhL-h hmJmp. ^pmhg mhmbum|mh h2mhm|nLp-jnLhh m4b[h pmpöp t, fmh hmp|bphhp45: <bmUmpmp' f m^mfm|mhnLpjmh J2m|n^hbph |n^Jhg hmp|mjhh ^pmhhbph, h24mö hhJhmpmp U jmpwfwh^-jnLp bp|ph hmJmp jnLpmhmmnL| qnpönhhbph pJpnhmJp |mpUnp t ORhL-h hmJmp:
Pmgh 4bpnh2jm[ h|mmmnmJhbphg, npn2 hbmmqnmnLpjnLhhbph46 mp^-jnLhfhbp 4|mjnLJ bh, np bp||n^Jmhh hmp|mjhh ^pnLjfm^m^bpp ph^mhn^ n^ Jbö bp|phbpnLJ gmgm^pmJ bh ^m|mu ph^hmhnLp mp^jmhm4bm ^pnLjfm-^m^, pbU m4b|h ^n2np bp|phbpp Jbö hm4mhm|mhnLpjmJp h4mqbghnLJ bh hmp|mjhh pbnp bp||n^Jmhh Jm|mp^m|nLJ' hmp|mjhh hm Jmömjhmqpbph Jhgngn4: U|hhmjm t, np |^mhmhg4bh [pmgmgh^ hbmmqnmnLpjnLhhbp' hmp-|mjhh qpm4h^ ^pmhhbph J2m|Jmh hmJmp: U|qpnLhf npbh, «-h hmJmp tm|mh ^bmf t H-hmmp|4bh hmp|mjhh b|mJnLmhbpp, bpp ^nufp 4bpmpb-pnLJ t umhJmhmjhh mb^hn|nqhmhbp hbp^.hb|nLh, mb^hn|nqhm|mh 6b^fmJ
mhb|nLh:
UnLjh hn^4möh h^mmm|hg ^h P^nLJ bp||n^Jmhh mp^jmhm4bm hmp-|mjhh H-pnLjfm^m^bph Jbpn^m|mh J2m|nLJp |mJ hmp|mjhh ^pmhhbphh mnh^4nn. hmpgbph n-hmmp|mJp. ^nufp 4bpmpbpnLJ t Jh2mqqmjhh ^pm|-mh|mjnLJ hpbhg mp^mpmgpmö hmp|Jmh ^pmhhbphh, npnhf h^mumb[ bh n^ Jhmjh ORhL-h hbpqpm4Jmhp, mj|U ph^mhn^ bp|phbph mb^hn|nqhm|mh mnmgphpmgh m^mhn4b|rnh ^pmhg nL^np^Jmhp:
hh 4bpmpbpnLJ t umhJmhmjhh mb^hn|nqhmhbph $hhmhum4npJmh JjnLu hbpfhh m^pjnLphh' Mmnm4mpmpjmh |n^Jhg unLpuh^m4npJmhp, m^m hmp| t h2b[, np umhJmhmjhh mb^hn|nqhmhbph hbp^pJmh qnpöphpmghbph mpmqmgJmhp Jhm4mö hbpfhh U mpmmfhh hbp^.pmJhbph hmppm|h qm-^m^mpp hhJh4mö t Mmnm4mpnLpjnLh-Jmuhm4np hmm4mö qnpöph|bpnL-pjmh qmpqmgJmh 4pm: Unm2mp|4nT. JnmbgnLJp hmU bhpm^pnLJ t ^hmjn-^m|mh qnpöphpmghbpnLJ Jmuhm4np hmm4möh hbpmnm|mhnLpjmh ph^-
45 Sb'u Muthitacharoen A., Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment in Developing Countries, Austaxpolicy: Tax and Transfer Policy Blog, 9 March 2020:
46 Sb'u Loretz S., Determinants of Bilateral Effective Tax Rates: Empirical Evidence from OECD Countries. Fiscal Studies, Vol. 28, No. 2, 2007, t2 227-229:
HjtnLd1 шnш2ш4np mЬ^tnLnqhшtЬph tЬpтpdшt tш^шqöЬph 2P2шtш^nLd: <шт^шцЬи ^pUnp^nLd Ь! mtmЬunLpJnLttЬph цши^^ ^^jn^nL-
PJnLttЬpQ (ш4шtт.tЬph ÖUn^ щшh4nq) шЫh2ш^шtnpЬt mtmЬunLpJшt hpш^шt hшm4шö m^^pT^m!, ht^h hшdшp щшhшt24nLd Ь! hшdшщш-тши^ш^ ^pшttЬp, npntghg dЬ^Q шpmшhшЫшt hшppш^h tЬpтpnLdшJht tш^шqöЬph unLpuhт.ш4npnLdt t:
Ьqpш^шgnLpJnLbbЬp <hdf « Чшnш4шpnLpJшt 2021-2026 pp.
öpшqpшJht qpnLjpQ, ^шщ^шй « т^тЬиш^ш^ pшpт.nLpJшt шит^бш^^ pшpöpшgdшt ^щшшш^п^ hшdшLhp dh2ngшnnLdtЬph hpш^шtшgdшt hЬm, шnш2шp^4ЬL t Т^ш hpшqnpödшt dЬ^шthqd, ^p^ht ^tшJnqnLpJnLttЬph tЬpqpш4dшdp, t^mh т^Ышщф np ш^ hшutЬLnL hшdшp
щЬтр t ^n^p^L ^j^p1 mЬ^tnLnqhш^шt hшdш2^шphшJht uшhdшtht dnmЬhшLnL nLqqnLpJшdp, ht^Q htшpш4np t omшpЬp^pJш U тЬ^ш^ш! ^p-Tpn^^p^ hшdшqnpöш^gnLpJшt шpтJnLhfnLd: UшhdшtшJht mЬ^tnLnqhшtЬ-pht рш2штЬ^|ш^ omшpЬp^pJш tЬpтpnqtЬph tЬpqpш4nLdQ b^^g^Ld t Tpшtg tЬpтpdшt öш^uЬpQ: nLumh шnш2ш4np mtmЬunLpJnLttЬpnLd ^tqhp-^p ^Ь! шnш2шhnLd тpшhf ^p^^hu: Urntg шnш2ш4np Ьp^ptЬph ш2ш^-g^p^t mЬ^hnLnq^ш^шh uшhdшthg hЬnш4np Ьp^ptЬph hшdшp uшhdш-mЬ^tnLnqhшtЬph ^pTprndQ pш4ш^шt ^pd^^: ht^щЬu
gnLjg t dh2шqqшJht фnpÖQ, ш]т ^tqph m^nLdQ тЬ^ш^ш! ÖЬntшp-
^шmЬpЬph U uшhdшtшJht mЬ^tnLnqhшtЬpht mhpшщЬmnq omшpЬp^pJш tЬpтpnqtЬph hшdшqnpöш^gnLpJnLhh t: Uju rç^pmd ^p^ht шnш2шtnLd t ^itiThp1 ^шщ^шй тЬ^ш^ш! ÖЬnhшp^шmЬpЬph U omшpЬp^pJш tЬpтpnqtЬph фn^hшpшpЬpnLpJnLhhЬph pшpnJшhnqЬpшtш^шt ^nqdh hЬm. тЬ^ш^ш! ÖЬntшp^шmЬpQ ^ ^pnrçmlmd hp ^pTp^dt т!Ь!ш[, ЬpЬ hшdшmЬq ^pTp^d^p tш^шmЬunq tш^шqöh dЬ2 ^h ^pTp^ pш4шpшp ^шщhmш|.: U.nш2шp^nLpJnLlQ 4ЬpшpЬpnLd t omшpЬp^pJш т^дш^ ^pTp^d^ph шp-mшhшЫшt hшppш^h hшJЬgш^шpqh tЬpтpdшtQ U ш]т hшp-
L^jhti hшdшцшmшu^шl шpmntnLpJnLttЬph mpшdштpdшtQ, hш2ф шп!Ь-[n^ dh2шqqшJhl шnш2ш4np фnpÖQ: L^mh т^Ышщф np шпш^ ^p^ht ^lшJnrçпLpJnLllЬph dh2ngn^ ^p^ht ^pTp^d^ph фhtшtuш4npdшt h^-pш4np ^t dnmЬlшL mЬ^tnLnqhш^шt Qtpшgh^ uшhdшtht, ш]т OnhL-h шp-mшhшЫшt hшppш^h hшJЬgш^шpq t IЬpdnLÖ4ЬL ^p^hl IЬpтpnLdlЬph ^шd lЬpfhl ^lшJn^nLpJnLllЬph mшppQ: <шJЬgш^шpqшJhl 2P2шlш^h ^ш-pUnp pшrçштph^lЬpl Ь! uшhdшlшJhl mЬ^lnLnqhшlЬph фn^шlgnLd Ь^ш-Tpn^ OnhL-h lЬpqpш4dшl hшdшp hшp^шJhl ^pшllЬpQ U шJТцhuh !ш-^шqöЬpnLd тЬ^ш^ш! lЬpтpn^lЬph ^n^dhg « Чшnш4шpnLpJшl unLpuh-Тш4npdшl qnLdшph шnl4шql 30% ^pTP^d^pQ ^pш^nLuЬLQ:
Oqmшqnpö^шö qpш^шbnLpJnLb
1. « 4umuii^uipnLpjuiti 2021-2026 p^ш^шllbph ôpшqhp// https ://www. gov.am/files/docs/4586.pdf
2. <uijiiiuiTiiiitih ^hбш^шqpш^шl mшpbqpfbp, 2000-2021:
3. M-inpTwitijiiiti ^hmbLhßшhblf mlmbunLpJnLl. hlшpш^npnL-p^L^t^p U dшpmшhpш^bptbp: bp., «^hmnLpjnLt», 2008:
30 риърьп
2022.1
4. 4uipq.iiibjiiib Т., lipmuihiiibdiiib huippiiilbbp|i omuipbplpjixi тпдшЦп bbpq.pmdbbp|i d|i2iiiqqiiij|ib фпрйр: bp., «UjLQbmpiiibg» q|imiiiliiib huibqbu, 2019:
5. Распоряжение Евразийского межправительственного совета от 7 марта 2017 г., N 2, О сферах экономики, обладающих интеграционным потенциалом в Евразийском экономическом союзе, и мерах, направленных на его использование.
6. Aghion Ph., Comin D. and Howitt P., When does domestic saving matter for economic growth? Working paper, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 2006, http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:27759050
7. Hausmann R., Hidalgo C., Bustos S., Coscia M., Simoes A., Yildirim M., The Atlas of Economic Complxity. Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Center for International Development, Harvard University, 2013.
8. Development and Globalization: Facts and Figures. UNCTAD. New York and Geneva, 2004.
9. Howitt P., Mayer-Foulkes D., R&D, Implementation, and Stagnation: A Schumpeterian Theory of Convergence Clubs// Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. 37, No. 1 (Feb., 2005).
10. Hidalgo C., Hausmann R., The building blocks of economic complexity//PNAS, June 30, 2009, vol. 106, no. 26, https://www.pnas.org/content/pnasZ106/26/10570.full.pdf
11. Commission on Growth and Development. The Growth Report : Strategies for Sustained Growth and Inclusive Development. Washington, DC : World Bank, 2008.
12. Country & Product Complexity Rankings, https://atlas.cid.harvard.edu/rankings.
13. Ekholm K., Forslid R., Markusen J., Export-platform foreign direct investment. NBER Working, Paper No. 9517 February, 2003.
14. Mealy P., Farmer,D., Teytelboym A., Interpreting economic complexity//Science Advances, Vol. 5, Issue 1, eaau1705, 4 Jan 2019.
15. Smith A., An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, London, 1776.
16. SITC, 2006: Division 71-Power-generating machinery and equipment; Division 77 - Electrical machinery, apparatus and appliances, n.e.s., and electrical parts thereof (including nonelectrical counterparts, n.e.s., of electrical householdtype equipment.
17. These are the most complex economies around the globe. Technology and Innovation Report 2021. New York, United Nations, 2021.
18. Standard International Trade Classification, Revision 4. United Nations, 2006.
19. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/12/countries-ranked-by-their-economic-complexity/
20. UNCTAD.Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment. A Global Survey. New York and Geneva, UN, 2000.
21. World Development Indicators// https://data.worldbank.org/indicator
22. https://oec.world/en/rankings/eci/hs6/hs96
ДАВИД ВАРДАНЯН
Аспирант кафедры финансов АГЭУ
МГЕР ВАРДАНЯН
Магистр компьютерных и информационных наук АУА
Концептуальная рамка финансирования инвестиций, необходимых для повышения уровня экономической сложности, при помощи внутренних сбережений.- В
статье рассматриваются вопросы, связанные с внешними и внутренними источниками финансирования инвестиций для внедрения передовых технологий, с учетом ориентиров по повышениию экономической сложности Республики Армения, установленных в программе Правительства Республики Армения на 2021-2026 гг. Степень экономической сложности зависит от ее удаленности от мирового технологического рубежа. Одним из каналов передачи производительных знаний, необходимых для внедрения передовых технологий, являются ПИИ, уровень притока которых недостаточен, а под влиянием COVID-19 и тенденций последнего десятилетия увеличилась неопределенность внешних источников финансирования инвестиций. Основываясь на результатах анализа, авторы пришли к выводу, что стабильный, высокий уровень инвестиций, необходимый для устойчивого экономического роста на основе технологического прогресса, должен обеспечиваться за счет внутренних сбережений. Предложена концептуальная рамка экспортной платформы ПИИ и внутренних инвестиций, нацеленной на повышение уровня экономической сложности страны.
Ключевые слова: валовые сбережения, валовые внутренние сбережения, накопление основного капитала, экономическая сложность, передовые технологии, внутренние инвестиции экспортной платформы, ПИИ. JEL: E21, E22
DOI: 10.52174/1829-0280_2022.1 -9
DAVIT VARDANYAN
PhD Student of the Chair of Finance of ASUE
MHER VARDANYAN
Master of Science in Computer & Information Science AUA
A Conceptual Framework for Domestic Saving Financing the Investment Required to Increase the Complexity of the
Economy.-The paper reviews the issues related to external and internal sources of investment financing for the introduction of frontier technologies, considering the guidelines for increasing the economic complexity of the Republic of Armenia, established
in the program of the Government of the Republic of Armenia for 2021-2026. The degree of economic complexity depends on its distance from the world technological frontier. One of the channels for the transfer of productive knowledge needed for the adoption of frontier technologies is FDI, which suffers insufficient levels of inflows. In addition, the uncertainty of external sources of financing has increased under the trends of the last decade and recent influence of COVID-19. Based on the results of the analysis, the authors concluded that the stable, high level of investment required for sustainable economic growth based on technological progress must be provided through domestic savings. A conceptual framework for an export platform for FDI and domestic investment is proposed, aimed at increasing the level of economic complexity of the country.
Keywords: gross saving, gross domestic saving, fixed capital formation, resource gap, economic growth, economic complexity, frontier technology, export platform FDI and domestic investment JEL: E21, E22
DOI: 10.52174/1829-0280_2022.1-9