CC BY
119
ФИНАНСЫ FINANCE
УДК 336.71
DOI: 10.18413/2409-1634-2020-6-2-0-6
Быканова Н.И., Гордя Д.В., Евдокимов Д.В.
Тенденции и закономерности процесса цифровизации банковского сектора
Белгородский государственный национальный исследовательский университет ул. Победы, 85, г. Белгород, 308015, Россия
e-mail: bykanova@bsu.edu.ru, dariagordya@gmail.com, 971454@bsu.edu.ru Аннотация
В связи с рядом негативных событий для российской экономики, цифровизация и внедрение финансовых технологий могут стать главными конкурентными преимуществами, определяющими перспективы роста отечественного банковского бизнеса в краткосрочной и среднесрочной перспективе. Помимо проектов, реализуемых при поддержке государства и Банка России, в настоящее время крупные российские банки самостоятельно инвестируют значительные средства в финансовые технологии (финтех) и активно реализуют инновационные пилотные проекты. Выявлено, что ключевыми технологиями цифровой трансформации в России являются такие технологии, как анализ больших данных и предиктивная аналитика, искусственный интеллект, роботизация, машинное обучение и чат-боты, технологии распределенных реестров, открытые интерфейсы, оптическое распознавание интернет вещей, виртуальная и дополненная реальность. В статье проанализирован опыт лидеров в области цифрового банкинга - ПАО Сбербанк, АО «Тинькофф Банк», Банк ВТБ (ПАО). Кроме того, в статье рассмотрены основные тенденции и закономерности процесса цифровизации российского банковского сектора, которые включают поддержание кибербезопасности, внедрение B2B-маркетплейсов, цифровизацию государственных услуг, развитие трансграничного сотрудничества и создание общих IT-платформ. В этой связи отдельно стоит отметить тренд на создание в целях привлечения и поддержания лояльности клиентов банковских экосистем, предоставляющих клиентам как финансовые, так и нефинансовые услуги посредством суперприложений.
Ключевые слова: банковский сектор, финансовые технологии, финтех, цифровой банкинг, цифровизация, цифровая трансформация.
Информация для цитирования: Быканова НИ., Гордя Д.В., Евдокимов Д.В. Тенденции и закономерности процесса цифровизации банковского сектора // Научный результат. Экономические исследования. 2020. Т.6. № 2. С. 42-51. DOI: 10.18413/2409-1634-2020-6-2-0-6
Natalia I. Bykanova, Daria V. Gordya, Denis V. Evdokimov
Trends and patterns of the banking sector digitalization process
Belgorod State National Research University 85, Pobedy st., Belgorod, 308015, Russia
e-mail: bykanova@bsu.edu.ru, dariagordya@gmail.com, 971454@bsu.edu.ru Abstract
Due to a number of negative events for the Russian economy, the process of digitalization and implementation of financial technology (fintech) may become the main competitive advantages to determine the growth prospects of the banking business of Russia in the short and medium term. In addition to projects implemented with the support of the government and the Bank of Russia, large Russian banks are currently investing heavily in fintech and are actively implementing innovative pilot projects. The article reveals the key technologies of digital transformation in Russia are technologies such as Big Data and predictive analytics, artificial intelligence, robotics, machine learning and chat bots, distributed ledger technologies, open interfaces, optical recognition of the Internet of Things, virtual and augmented reality. The article considers the experience of the leaders in the field of digital banking in the Russian Federation - Sberbank, Tinkoff Bank, and VTB Bank. Besides, the article discusses the main trends and patterns of the digitalization process in the Russian banking sector, which include maintaining cyber-security, introducing B2B marketplaces, digitalizing public services, developing cross-border cooperation, and creating common IT platforms. In this regard, the trend to create banking ecosystems in order to attract and maintain customer loyalty, providing both financial and non-financial services through super applications, should be noted. Key words: banking sector; financial technology; fintech; digital banking; digitalization; digital transformation.
Information for citation: N.I. Bykanova, D.V. Gordya, D.V. Evdokimov (2020), "Trends and patterns of the banking sector digitalization process", Research Result. Economic Research, 6 (2), 42-51, DOI: 10.18413/2409-1634-2020-6-2-0-6
Introduction
The beginning of 2020 has been characterized by several events, which expose a significant risk to the growth of the Russian economy. The breakdown of the OPEC+ deal and the subsequent disruption in the balance of supply and demand in the oil market, the pandemic of the coronavirus infection COVID-19 and the associated economic downturn create an environment for a moderately negative or crisis scenario for the development of the Russian banking sector in 2020.
The peculiarity of 2020 is, unlike previous stressful situations (primarily in 2008-2009 and partly in 2014-2015), the problem is not the financial system (global or Russian), but the real economy. Both worldwide and in Russia, financial systems and central banks have been more prepared for the beginning of 2020: the necessary tools and experience were accumulated, regulation was significantly improved. Experts and analytics assess the current stability of the Russian banking sector as higher than during previous crises. A significant role in this
situation is played by the previous getting rid of "weak players" from the sector. Given the extremely high uncertainty with the development of the COVID-19 pandemic, the extent of the damage to the global and Russian economies is not yet known and forecasting with sufficient accuracy is now practically impossible. In this situation, a high level of digitalization may become the main competitive advantage that determines the growth prospects of the banking business in the new decade. Основная часть
Discussion
During 2008-2018 banking sector in Russia has tended to be consolidated and reorganized after the 2008 crisis. The dynamics of revoked licenses of credit organizations in the Russian Federation for the period 2008-2019 is shown in the Fig. 1, according to the official website of the Bank of Russia statistics.
120
100
so
60
40
20
як 93 97
\ no
52 \S4
44 28 3 у 431
18 22
200S 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 201S 2019 Number of credit organizations with revoked license
Fig. 1. Dynamics of credit organizations with a revoked license in the Russian Federation
during 2008-2019 [Source: O razvitii bankovskogo sektora Rossijskoj Federatsii, 2020] Рис. 1. Динамика кредитных организаций с отозванной лицензией в РФ за период 2008-2019 гг.
Thus, according to Fig. 1, it is possible to conclude during 2008-2016 there was an active increase in the number of license revocation and liquidation of credit organizations. The largest number of revocations and liquidations were observed in 2015-2016, namely 93 and 97, respectively, which is 1.8 times more than in 2008. Nevertheless, 2019 is characterized by a significant decrease in the rate of revocation of licenses of credit organizations: 31 licenses were revoked against 58 in 2018 and 54 in 2017, which indicates the end of the period of active cleansing of the market from unscrupulous players.
Initially, the active introduction of digital technologies has begun in the banking sector, which controls gold and foreign exchange flows, as a trigger for the global economy. As the most important segment of the economy of any state, the financial sector reflects the most
progressive solutions in digitalization, namely in the field of financial technologies. Innovations proposed in this area are aimed at improving financial performance through better and personalized service for lower customer costs [Andreev M.Ju., 2010].
Small and medium-sized banks had traditionally been considered to work more efficiently with medium-sized enterprises, since they are able to flexibly respond to customer requests, pay more attention to them, while large players sometimes are physically unable to delve into all the problems of small and medium-sized businesses.
Currently, however, digitalization is fundamentally changing the landscape of the banking sector. This process has become even more obvious and fast in quarantine due to the COVID-19 pandemic. A medium-sized universal bank will inevitably have to play on the
same field with large competitors. It is easier for large credit organizations to create unique personalized offers for each client using advanced IT services and Big Data technology.
Competition in the banking services market is shifting from the price area to the area of quality of service, ease of interaction and communication channels, completeness of the product offer, opportunities for personalization and product design.
Therefore, only banks capable of offering the clients the full range of products and services in the most convenient way can actively build up their client base and sources of income. In order to do that, they need not only vision, but also large investments, the ability to handle huge amounts of data and powerful analytics. However, for most Russian banks, the implementation of such projects is extremely difficult. Experts believe in the medium term small and some medium-sized banks may "not cope" with the growing competition in the market. Meanwhile, competition between large banks will only increase.
Large Russian banks adhere to the transformation into digital organizations that provide a wide range of financial products and services. They invest heavily in fintech and are actively implementing innovative pilot projects. Through a full-scale digital transformation, banks will be able to provide customers with a wide range of services within their own financial and even non-financial ecosystems. The creation of such platforms is already taking place in the largest banks, which gives them significant competitive advantages [Shhegolev, A.V., Alenina, K.V. and Jakushina A.V., 2019].
The limited funds for digital transformation are partially offset by the creation of nationwide platforms with a range of technological services. Due to the formation of a nationwide financial infrastructure, the competitive capabilities of various groups of banks are partially equalized, the role of the bank's geographical location is leveled, conditions are created for a significant reduction in the cost of doing business, and the availability of financial services is increased.
In addition to projects implemented with the support of the government and the Bank of Russia, financial institutions themselves are actively involved in the process of digital innovations implementation. The key technologies of digital transformation in Russia are big data analysis and predictive analytics, artificial intelligence, robotics, machine learning and chat bots, distributed ledger technologies, open interfaces, optical recognition, Internet of Things, virtual and augmented reality [Bolsun V.S., 2019]. Furthermore, according to KPMG, 72 % of banks are planning to develop artificial intelligence technology in the next two years, 61 % of the banks surveyed have already implemented or are testing robots, 45 % of banks have already implemented predictive analytics in several processes [Cifrovye tekhnologii v ros-sijskih bankah]. Moreover, banks have already occupied leading positions in the use of chat bots in industrial operation among various fields of activity. New technologies allow different banks to reduce costs and constantly improve the quality of services provided; thereby equalizing market conditions.
However, competition is pushing an increasing number of banks to develop services for individuals and entrepreneurs based on partner services, turning them into ecosystems. The main feature of the ecosystem is that a client through one of its participating companies can access all other organizations included in ecosystem through related services, possibly even on special (preferential) conditions that exist only within its boundaries. The technical capabilities that the created ecosystem will provide its participants include a customer identification system, fast data exchange, unified software interfaces and other services [Radkovskaja, N.P. and Fomicheva, O.E., 2018].
Several criteria are generally used in order for an organization to become an "ecosystem center". Firstly, organizations should have a large-scale client base and a high level of trust with the client. Secondly, they must be open to change and ready to adapt to a changing business environment. Thirdly, organizations need to own customer data and use it to improve col-
laboration. Fourthly, a recognizable brand and a positive perception of the organization in the financial market are needed [Bykanova, N.I., Solovej, Ju.A., Gordya, D.V. and Kon'shina, L.A., 2020].
It should be singled out for mention that in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, ubiquitous lockdown and most employees working remotely, digital services have become more relevant than ever. The process promptly and simultaneously affected the organization of the functioning of banks, and products and services offered to customers
Sberbank as the largest bank in Russia is one of the forces driving the digitalization process. Two years ago, it presented the strategy of transition to ecosystem principles. Currently, this ecosystem includes companies specializing in various fields of activity, including ecommerce, medicine, telecommunications, cloud technologies, communications, identification, services for optimizing business processes, et al.
Another striking example of digital banking in Russia is Tinkoff Bank, which calls itself a "technology company with a banking license". It offers online banking and lifestyle services and is constantly developing the latest technologies (machine learning and artificial intelligence are used in almost all processes).
Analytics call the emergence of super apps (applications that combine many services to
maximize the client's vital needs) is one of the main trends of 2019-2020. The banking industry is increasingly intersecting with other industries, thus Russian banks create super apps. This distinguishes the Russian market from the foreign one, where banks are less developed from the point of view of technology, there financial services are usually integrated into nonbanking applications.
Formally, it is possibly to call VK (VKon-takte - the largest Russian online social media and social networking service) the first Russian super app based on platform of miniapplications, but Tinkoff Bank was officially the first in a press release to launch the super app. In April 2019, Tinkoff launched the Entertainment section in its application (including restaurant reservation and movie ticket purchase services), then created its own travel agency, connecting to all major Russian booking systems, investing about $ 2 million in the project. Finally, in December 2019, Tinkoff announced the launch of its super app, the structure of which is shown in Fig. 2.
Offers from partners: Goods and online-retail Healthcare and beauty Cars, gas stations, taxi Leisure and entertainment Fitness and wellness Cleaning Flowers and pets
Cashback, bonuses, points, miles management Lifestyle services cashback Special offers with cashback up to 30 % Payment by installments
Own integration: Cinema, concerts, theatres Travelling Restaurants Shopping Sport
V?
,\e
Voice assistant Oleg Tinkoff Stories Tinkoff Target
individual offers with cashback up to 30 ° Big Data and Machine Learning Biometrics, et al.
H2S
9в,
s
t
-¿Л.
О)
Tinkoff
Super App
ÖO
1
3 45
\ ь %
/
Single Tinkoff ID
Wallet with ecosystem products
Tinkoff Investment
Tinkoff Insurance
Tinkoff Mobile
Tinkoff Business
All financial products of the bank Opening new products Detailed receipts Expenditure pattern Ordering documents Chat support 24/7
Apple Pay, Samsung Pay, Google Pay Crowdfunding
Banking for children over 7 y/o Limit management and expenditure control Assignments for children with rewards Child geolocation Tinkoff Junior App Lifestyle services for children Stories for children
'4
°ff.
4
'OA
Transfers by phone or card number
Faster payments system (FPS)
Public services
Traffic fines
Billing subscriptions
Payment of services in various fields
Payment automatization
QR-code operations
Fig. 2. The structure of the Tinkoff super app [Source: 2020 Banking & Fintech: obzor trendov v bankovskom biznese i fintehe, 2020] Рис. 2. Структура супер-приложения "Тинькофф"
Thus, Tinkoff super app is designed to solve any tasks in the field of finance, leisure, and lifestyle. The application offers solutions for a large number of financial tasks: ordering a new card, issuing an additional card, taking a loan, opening a deposit, buying insurance, opening an account for business, et al. It is also possible to order a SIM card from the virtual mobile operator Tinkoff Mobile. Transfers, payment for services, donations can be carried out.
Tinkoff Bank offers payment by QR code, though this method of payment is not very common among sellers. In addition, user can select the categories of increased cashback and see special offers with discounts from partners, store documents in an electronic wallet. Investments are in a separate application.
The "non-financial" part of the Tinkoff super app is concentrated in the Services tab. Third-parties are integrated according to the White Label - that is, they are deprived of branded identification marks, user can find out about the service provider through the Info tab. Currently, the following categories are presented: ordering flowers; cosmetics; payment for online training; purchase of tickets to cinema, theaters, concerts, quests, sporting events -separately in different mini-apps; restaurant reservation, and calling a taxi through Yan-dex.Taxi; airtickets purchase, hotel reservation, travel insurance - all with cashback; cleaning; doctor appointment; shopping - information about all shopping centers of the city; insurance; purchase of goods through goods.ru marketplace.
Financial services are still at the center of the Tinkoff super app, they were assigned the main screen. All services will be integrated with the voice assistant Oleg and will support single authorization via Tinkoff ID soon. Dif-
ferent levels of integration are available - from "difficult", at the level of Tinkoff own services, to "simple", through the Open API, for which it is enough to go through moderation. It is expected that by 2023 the ecosystem will unite more than 20 million people (currently the number of users reaches 10 million customers). Following Tinkoff Bank, VTB Bank picked up the trend, announcing creating a life- style platform, investments in which would amount to more than 2.5 billion rubles. The services of taxi calling, food delivery, restau- rant reservations, movie tickets, theater, sport- ing events, air and train ticket purchases will be combined within a single platform. As for financial services, it will include virtual cards, payments and transfers, credit products. The platform wants to collaborate with market leaders in different industries.
VTB Bank has promised to launch its own superapp in the summer of 2020. It is expected that by the end of 2022 the number of lifestyle platform users will reach 4 million people. In addition, by this time, 500 thousand bank cards should be issued for users of the platform.
It is expected that the general trend towards digitalization of the banking sector will contribute to the emergence of similar superapplications from other market participants. Over the past few years, the needs of consumers of financial services have changed: they are no longer interested in banks or in the financial services that they offer. Customers need services and products to solve specific life tasks, and the business is transformed in accordance with this request. Currently, companies and financial institutions strive to satisfy as many needs as possible from different areas of their clients' lives. In addition, the boundaries between different industries are gradually blurring
due to a shift in focus from products to customer needs, which are often cross-industrial in nature. All these processes take place against the background of the formation and growing up of the "digital" generation of people who are used to using modern technology in everyday life.
However, the basic asset in the digital space is information, and data security is one of the components of the foundation of the digital economy. In order to ensure information interaction and coordination of efforts to combat crime in the IT sector, the Bank of Russia has created a Center for Monitoring and Response to Computer Attacks in the Credit and Financial Sphere (FinCERT of the Bank of Russia). Recognizing the need for consolidation on the issue of information security, the Association of Banks of Russia launched a cyber threat data exchange platform [Platforma obmena dannymi o kiberugrozah].
The platform allows participants to automatically receive verified and relevant infor-
mation automatically online. The platform is based on the REST API, which allows to automate the settings of security features without the participation of people. Credit organizations, if necessary, can get the support of technical specialists who will help to set up a credit institution's protection for future use and integration with the platform. The advantages of the platform are the aggregation of more than 26 sources of threat data (FinCERT of the Bank of Russia, telecom operators, BI.ZONE), downloading only useful information to protect the bank, and automating the process of applying this information. The functionality of the platform can be used both in the largest and in small organizations that do not have advanced security features and highly qualified personnel.
Thus, some general trends in the digital transformation of the banking industry can be highlighted (Table 1).
General trends in the digitalization of the banking sector Общие тенденции цифровизации банковского сектора
Table 1
Таблица 1
Trend Explanation
Cybersecurity With the increase in Internet space, the issue of cybersecurity is reaching a whole new level. This leads to an influx of investment in information security
B2B-marketplaces Like retail consumers, businesses need a comfortable online shopping experience and a variety of payment methods
Digitalization of public services In addition to the external motivation of organizations, the digitalization of the economy contributes to the development of a digital state, the goal of which remains the same - interaction with the population and business. In addition, it eliminates corruption, saves time and money
Cross-border cooperation Investments in the development of international associations create priorities for years to come. In addition, the prospects of such alliances are promising
Creation of common IT platforms This leads to the creation of common digital solutions, stimulating a joint search for solutions
[S ource: Borkova et al, 2019]
Thus, Sberbank is one of the leaders in the field of cybersecurity in Russia. It formulates its development strategy, considering the regularity of cyberattacks, and seeks to enhance data security by reducing time and money loss-
es. As for B2B marketplaces, in 2018 Sberbank launched SberB2B, a platform for conducting sales transactions of goods and services for any customers and sellers. The main reason was the negative dynamics of the development of the
B2B sector in the country, which leads to significant losses of time and money. In the field of digitalization of public services, a great example is created by March 2019 system that provides the remote issuance of certificates for housing property in Moscow. As for cross-border cooperation, the project "Interreg. Baltic Sea Region", aimed at development in areas of innovation, modern transport and natural resource management is noteworthy. Among the common IT platforms, ERA can be mentioned - the 3rd generation blockchain platform DATACHAINS.world, which has become a solution not only for individuals, but also for commercial companies and government agencies.
Conclusion
Thus, it can be concluded that digitaliza-tion helps to blur the boundaries between the banking and non-banking areas of activity, and this leads to the creation of fundamentally new means of payment that radically change the banking environment overall. In addition, it should be taken into consideration that digitali-zation has a direct and increasing impact on economic growth, affects the dynamics of GDP, as well as the productivity and well-being of agents in all sectors of the economy. Nowadays, the degree of digitalization of the economy shows the country's position on the world scene. Consequently, issue of improving the policy of digitalization of the Russian economy is becoming increasingly important if the country is faced with the goal of increasing competitiveness, labor efficiency and productivity.
Список литературы
1. Андреев М.Ю., 2010. Эконометриче-ское исследование и модельное описание деятельности современной российской банковской системы // М.: Вычислительный центр РАН им. А. А. Дородницына, 2010. № 46. С. 135-136.
2. Болсун В.С., 2019. Особенности внедрения цифровых технологий в банковском секторе России // Актуальные проблемы и перспективы развития инновационной экономики и управления: сборник научных статей. 2019. С. 166-171.
3. Боркова Е.А., Осипова К.А., Светлови-дова Е.В., Фролова Е.В., 2019. Цифровизация
экономики на примере банковской системы // Креативная экономика. 2019. Т. 13. №6. URL: https://creativeconomy.ru/lib/40734 (дата обращения: 07.06.2020)
4. Быканова Н.И., Соловей Ю.А., Гордя Д.В., Коньшина Л.А., 2020. Формирование экосистем банков в условиях цифровизации банковского пространства // Научные ведомости Белгородского государственного университета. Серия: Экономика. Информатика. 2020. Т. 47. № 1. С. 91-100.
5. Каткова, Е.К. 2020. Анализ банковского сектора Российской Федерации на протяжении 2008-2019 гг. // Молодой ученый. 2020.
№ 2 (292). С. 275-278.
6. Радковская Н.П., Фомичева О.Е., 2018. Финансовая экосистема - основной тренд цифровой трансформации модели банковского бизнеса // Журнал правовых и экономических исследований. 2018. №4. С. 186-189.
7. Щеголев А.В., Аленина К.В., Якушина А.В., 2019. Тенденции цифровизации банковского сектора в Российской Федерации. Вектор экономики. 2019. № 12 (42). С. 79.
8. О развитии банковского сектора Российской Федерации. URL: https://www.cbr.ru/analytics/bank_system/din_razv _16_07/ (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
9. Платформа обмена данными о киберу-грозах / Ассоциация банков России. URL: https://asros.ru/projects/cyber/ (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
10. Цифровые технологии в российских банках / KPMG. URL: https://docplayer.ru/122726951-19-marta-2019-goda-moskva-cifrovye-tekhnologii-v-rossiyskih-bankah-marianna-danilina-kpmg-zamestitel-direktora-praktiki-operacionnoy-effektivnosti.html (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
11. Цифровые технологии в российских компаниях / KPMG. URL: https://assets.kpmg/content/dam/kpmg/ru/pdf/2019/ 01/ru-ru-digital-technologies-in-russian-companies.pdf (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
12. Экосистема Тинькофф: от билетов в кино до оплаты алиментов / FrankRG. URL: https://frankrg.com/7716 (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
13.2020 Banking & Fintech: обзор трендов в банковском бизнесе и финтехе / SPEKTR. URL:
https://spektr.team/pdfj s/web/2019bankingtrends.ht ml?file=2019bankingtrends.pdf (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
14. Cornerstone of future growth: ecosystems / Accenture. URL: https: //www .accenture.com/_acnmedia/PDF-77/Accenture -Strategy-Eco systems -Exec-Summary-May2018-P0V.pdf#zoom=50 (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
15. Global FinTech Adoption Index / EY. URL: https://www.ey.com/en_gl/ey-global-fintech-adoption-index (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
16. Ecosystem Playbook / EY. URL: https://fintech.neu.edu.vn/Resources/Docs/SubDom ain/fintech/EY-fintech-ecosystem-playbook2045865662.pdf (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
17. Fintech in 2019 - Five trends to watch / Clifford Chance. URL:
https: //www .cliffordchance.com/briefings/2019/01/ fintech_in_2019_fivetrendstowatch.html (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
18. Payments trends 2020 / Deloitte. URL: https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/financial-services/articles/infocus-payments-trends.html (дата обращения: 07.06.2020).
19. Vaganova O.V., Bykanova N.I., Gri-goryan A.S., Cherepovskaya N.A.. 2018. Directions of development of bank technologies applied in the Russian market of retail credit services // Revista Publicando. 2018. Vol. 15. № 2. Pp. 13651377.
20. Vaganova, O.V., Bykanova, N.I., Mi-tyushina, I.L., Mohanad, A.-S., Salim, R., 2019. Introduction of the Latest Digital Technologies in the Banking Sector: Foreign Experience and Russian Practice. // Humanities and Social Sciences Reviews. 2019. Vol. 7 (5). Pp. 789-796.
21. Glagolev S.N., Vaganova O.V. Specific determinants for structuring the economy, taking into account the factor of integration // World Applied Sciences Journal. 2013. Т. 24. № 10. С. 13221329.
22. Vladyka M.V., Vaganova O.V., Ku-cheryavenko S.A., Bykanova N.I. Analysis of efficiency indicators of a macro region's economy (on the example of the Central Federal District) // The Social Sciences (Pakistan). 2016. Т. 11. № 15.
С. 3728-3733.
Resources
1. Andreev M.Ju., 2010. Ekonometricheskoe issledovanie i model'noe opisanie dejatel'nosti sov-remennoj rossijskoj bankovskoj sistemy (2010), "Econometric research and model description of the modern Russian banking system activities",
Vychislitel'nyj centr RAN im. A. A. Dorodnicyna, 46, 135-136.
2. Bolsun V.S., 2019 Osobennosti vnedreni-ja tsifrovyh tekhnology v bankovskom sektore Ros-sii "Features of the digital technologies introduction in the banking sector of Russia" // Aktual'nye prob-lemy i perspektivy razvitija innovatsionnoj ekonomiki i upravlenija, 2019166-171.
3. Borkova, E.A., Osipova, K.A., Svetlovi-dova, E.V. and Frolova, E.V., 2019. Tsifrovizatsija ekonomiki na primere bankovskoj sistemy "Digitalization of the economy on the example of the banking system" 2019, Kreativnaja ekonomika. 13, 6 [Online], available at:
https://creativeconomy.ru/lib/40734. (Accessed 07 June 2020).
4. Bykanova, N.I., Solovej, Ju.A., Gordya, D.V. and Kon'shina, L.A., 2020. Formirovanie ekosistem bankov v uslovijah tsifrovizatsii bankovskogo prostranstva "Formation of banks ecosystems in conditions of digitalization of banking space", Nauchnye vedomosti Belgorodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija: Ekonomika. Informatika, 47, 1, 2020: 91-100.
5. Katkova, E.K., 2020. Analiz bankovskogo sektora Rossijskoj Federatsii na prot-jazhenii 2008-2019 gg. "Analysis of the banking sector of the Russian Federation during 20082019", Molodoj uchenyj, 2 (292), 2020: 275-278.
6. Radkovskaja, N.P. and Fomicheva, O.E., 2018. Finansovaja ekosistema - osnovnoj trend tsifrovoy transformatsii modeli bankovskogo bizne-sa "The financial ecosystem - a basic trend of the banking business model digital transformation", Zhurnal pravovyh i ekonomicheskih issledovanij, 4, 2018:186-189.
7. Shhegolev, A.V., Alenina, K.V. and Jaku-shina A.V., 2019. Tendentsii tsifrovizatsii bankovskogo sektora v Rossijskoj Federatsii "Bank sector digital trends in the Russian Federation" (2019), Vektor ekonomoki, 12 (42), 2019: 79.
8. O razvitii bankovskogo sektora Rossijskoj Federatsii "On the development of the banking sector of the Russian Federation" (2020) [Online], available at:
https://www.cbr.ru/analytics/bank_system/din_razv _16_07/ (Accessed 07 Jube 2020).
9. Platforma obmena dannymi o kiberugrozah "Cyber Threat Data Exchange Platform" (2019), Associacija bankov Rossii [Online], available at: https://asros.ru/projects/cyber/ (Accessed 07 June 2020).
10. Tsifrovye tekhnologii v rossijskih bankah "Digital technologies in Russian banks" (2019),
KPMG [Online], available at:
https://docplayer.ru/122726951-19-marta-2019-
goda-moskva-cifrovye-tekhnologii-v-rossiyskih-
bankah-marianna-danilina-kpmg-zamestitel-
direktora-praktiki-operacionnoy-effektivnosti.html
(Accessed 07 June 2020).
11. Tsifrovye tekhnologii v rossijskih kom-panijah "Digital technologies in Russian companies" (2019), KPMG [Online], available at: https://assets.kpmg/content/dam/kpmg/ru/pdf/2019/ 01/ru-ru-digital-technologies-in-russian-companies.pdf (Accessed 07 June 2020).
12. Ekosistema Tin'koff: ot biletov v kino do oplaty alimentov "Tinkoff Ecosystem: From movie tickets to child support payments" (2019), FrankRG [Online], available at: https://frankrg.com/7716 (Accessed 07 June 2020).
13.2020 Banking & Fintech: obzor trendov v bankovskom biznese i fintehe "2020 Banking & Fintech: review of trends in banking and fintech" (2020), SPEKTR [Online], available at: https://spektr.team/pdfj s/web/2019bankingtrends.ht ml?file=2019bankingtrends.pdf (Accessed 07 June 2020).
14. Accenture: Cornerstone of future growth: ecosystems (2018) [Online], available at: https: //www.accenture.com/_acnmedia/PDF-77/Accenture-Strategy-Ecosystems-Exec-Summary-May2018-POV.pdf#zoom=50 (Accessed 07.06.2020).
15. Global FinTech Adoption Index (2019), EY [Online], available at: https://www.ey.com/en_gl/ey-global-fintech-adoption-index (Accessed 07 June 2020).
16. Ecosystem Playbook (2018), EY [Online], available at:
https://fintech.neu.edu.vn/Resources/Docs/SubDom ain/fintech/EY-fintech-ecosystem-playbook2045865662.pdf (Accessed 07 June 2020).
17. Fintech in 2019 - Five trends to watch (2019), Clifford Chance [Online], available at: https: //www.cliffordchance .com/briefings/2019/01/ fintech_in_2019_fivetrendstowatch.html (Accessed 07 June 2020).
18. Payments trends 2020 (2020), Deloitte [Online], available at: https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/financial-services/articles/infocus-payments-trends.html (Accessed 07 June 2020).
19. Vaganova, O.V., Bykanova, N.I., Gri-goryan, A.S. and Cherepovskaya N.A., 2018. Directions of development of bank technologies applied in the Russian market of retail credit services, Revista Publicando, 15, 2, 2018: 1365-1377.
20. Vaganova, O.V., Bykanova, N.I., Mi-tyushina, I.L. and Mohanad, A.-S., Salim, R., 2019. Introduction of the Latest Digital Technologies in the Banking Sector: Foreign Experience and Russian Practice, Humanities and Social Sciences Reviews, 7 (5), 2019: 789-796.
21. Glagolev S.N., Vaganova O.V. Specific determinants for structuring the economy, taking into account the factor of integration // World Applied Sciences Journal. 2013. Т. 24. № 10. С. 13221329.
22. Vladyka M.V., Vaganova O.V., Ku-cheryavenko S.A., Bykanova N.I. Analysis of efficiency indicators of a macro region's economy (on the example of the Central Federal District) // The Social Sciences (Pakistan). 2016. Т. 11. № 15.
С. 3728-3733.
Информация о конфликте интересов:
авторы не имеют конфликта интересов для декларации.
Conflicts of Interest: the authors have no conflict of interest to declare.
Быканова Н.И. - доцент, кандидат экономических наук, доцент кафедры инновационной экономики и финансов, Института экономики и управления, НИУ «БелГУ», (г. Белгород, Россия)
Natalia I. Bykanova - Associate Professor, Candidate of Economic Sciences, Associate Professor of the Department of Innovative Economy and Finance, Institute of Economics and Management, Belgorod State National Research University (Belgorod, Russia)
Гордя Д.В. - аспирант Института экономики и управления, НИУ «БелГУ», (г. Белгород, Россия)
Daria V. Gordya - PhD Student, Institute of Economics and Management, Belgorod State National Research University (Belgorod, Russia)
Евдокимов Д.В. - директор ООО «БИТ-ТРЕЙД», (г. Белгород, Россия)
Denis V. Evdokimov - OOO "BIT- TREID" (LLC), (Belgorod, Russia)
