CC BY
15
UDC 621.314.228
doi: 10.20998/2074-272X.2019.5.08
A.G. Gurin, I.A. Kostiukov
THE EFFECT OF THE ACTIVE RESISTANCE OF THE PULSE TRANSFORMER WINDINGS ON THE PARAMETERS OF VOLTAGE PULSES GENERATED ON A CAPACITIVE LOAD
Goal. Analysis of the influence of the active resistance of the primary and secondary windings of a pulse transformer on the voltage at the load capacitance based on the developed methodology for the analysis of transients caused by the discharge of the storage capacitance in the primary winding. Methodology. A model for calculating transients is developed using the Laplace transform. Transient modeling is carried out in the MATLAB software package. The results of transient calculations are compared with experimental results. Results. A method for calculating transients in test installations with pulse transformers has been developed, which allows taking into account the effect of power losses in the primary and secondary windings on the voltage at the load capacitance. The calculated relations are obtained, allowing to take into account the influence of the active resistance of the primary and secondary windings of the transformer on the voltage at the load capacitance, the currents in the primary and secondary windings of the transformer, as well as on the voltage drop on the inductance of the primary winding of the transformer. Scientific novelty. A mathematical model is developed for calculating transients in the primary and secondary windings of a pulse transformer, taking into account the influence of the active resistance of the windings when it changes over a wide range of possible values. Practical value. Using the proposed technique, it is possible to determine the parameters of the discharge circuit at which test voltage pulses are formed on the load capacitance without distorting the shape of the pulse front. References 14, figures. 5.
Key words: pulse transformer, capacitive load, winding active resistance, test voltage pulse, electrical insulation test.
Мета. Аналiз впливу активного опору первинног та вторинног обмоток мпульсного трансформатору на напругу на навантажувальнш eмностi на основi розробленог методики аналiзу перехiдних процеав, що обумовлен розрядом накопичувальног eмностi в первиннш обмотць Методика. Модель для розрахунку перехiдних процеыв розроблена i3 використанням перетворення Лапласа. Моделювання перехiдних процеыв проведено в програмному пакетi MATLAB. Результаты розрахунку перехiдних процеыв порiвняно ii експериментальними результатами. Результаты. Розроблено методику розрахунку перехiдних процеыв у випробувальних установках з тпульсними трансформаторами, що дае можлив^ть враховувати втрати потужностi в первиннш та вториннш обмотках на напругу на навантажувальнш емностй Отримат розрахунковi спiввiдношення, що дозволяють враховувати вплив активного опору первинног та вторинног обмоток трансформатору на напругу на навантажувальнш емностi, струми у первиннш та вториннш обмотках трансформатору, а також на напругу на iндуктивностi первинног обмотки трансформатору. Наукова новизна. Розроблена математична модель для розрахунку перехiдних процеав в первиннш та вториннш обмотках трансформатору i! врахуванням впливу активного опору обмоток при його змiнi в широкому дiапазонi можливих значень. Практичне значення. Використання розробленог методики дозволяе визначати параметри розрядного кола, при яких на навантажувальнш емностi вiдбуваеться формування тпульЫв напруги без змни форми фронту мпульсу. Бiбл. 14, рис. 5.
Ключовi слова: iмпульсний трансформатор, емшсне навантаження, активний onip обмоток, iмпульс випробувально!" напруги, випробування електрично!" iзoляцil.
Цель. Анализ влияния активного сопротивления первичной и вторичной обмоток импульсного трансформатора на напряжение на нагрузочной емкости на основании разработанной методики анализа переходных процессов, вызванных разрядом накопительной емкости в первичной обмотке. Методика. Модель для расчета переходных процессов разработана с применением преобразования Лапласа. Моделирование переходных процессов проводилось в программном пакете MATLAB. Результаты расчетов переходных процессов сравнивались с экспериментальными результатами. Результаты. Разработана методика расчета переходных процессов в испытательных установках с импульсными трансформаторами, позволяющая учитывать влияние потерь мощности в первичной и вторичной обмотках на напряжение на нагрузочной емкости. Получены расчетные соотношения, позволяющие учитывать влияние активного сопротивления первичной и вторичной обмоток трансформатора на напряжение на нагрузочной емкости, токи в первичной и вторичной обмотках трансформатора, а также на падение напряжения на индуктивности первичной обмотки трансформатора. Научная новизна. Разработана математическая модель для расчета переходных процессов в первичной и вторичной обмотках импульсного трансформатора с учетом влияния активного сопротивления обмоток при его изменении в широком диапазоне возможных значений. Практическое значение. Использование предложенной методики позволяет определять параметры разрядной цепи, при которых на нагрузочной емкости происходит формирование тестовых импульсов напряжения без искажений формы фронта импульсов. Библ. 14, рис. 5.
Ключевые слова: импульсный трансформатор, емкостная нагрузка, активное сопротивление обмоток, импульс испытательного напряжения, испытания электрической изоляции.
Introduction. The problem of controlling the stability of insulation of electric power equipment in relation to overvoltages due to various causes is usually solved by using pulse voltage generators. Such generators can be developed using the widespread Arkadyev-Marx
scheme [1], which, when applied, implies the charge of electric capacitors when they are connected in parallel, followed by discharge when connected in series. An example of the practical application of the mentioned
© A.G. Gurin, I.A. Kostiukov
method for generating test pulses is given in [2], which describes a generator with stored energy up to 0.48 MJ, for generating voltage pulses with amplitude of up to 3 MV. This approach allows to simulate overvoltage pulses that occur as a result of lightning strikes, as well as switching overvoltages. A detailed description of the metrological equipment used in the practice of forming high-voltage voltage pulses is given in [3]. Although the use of Marx generators allows the generation of voltage pulses with sufficient amplitude levels and time characteristics that are satisfactory for practical purposes, the practical implementation of such schemes leads to certain difficulties, primarily due to the need to use a significant number of arresters [4].
Another widespread approach that is used in the practice of generating high-voltage pulses is based on the implementation of various circuits, which involve amplifying voltage pulses to the required level using pulse transformers. A typical example is the pulse transformer with a magnetic core consisting of 68 ferrite rods described in [5]. In some technical applications, certain advantages can be obtained by using air transformers, since transformers of this type do not require additional demagnetization circuits, which are usually used to ensure maximum magnitude of magnetic flux density in the core [6].
One of the most common problems for high-voltage installations with pulse transformers is the need to determine the voltage at the load capacitance in a wide range of its values. In the case of using pulse transformers with magnetic cores, relatively small values of the open circuit current in some cases allow mathematical analysis of the discharge of the storage capacitor, neglecting the value of the magnetization inductance. The results of mathematical modelling of discharge processes of a storage capacitor on the primary circuit of a pulse transformer with a magnetic core, performed in [4], showed that an increase in the load capacitance leads to a decrease in the voltage across it. In the case of using an air transformer, its analysis is often carried out without taking into account the active resistance of the primary and secondary windings. A detailed analysis of the transient in a pulse transformer, taking into account the influence of energy losses in the primary and secondary windings on the voltage value at the load capacitance, was performed in [8]. However, the solution of a differential equation of the 4th order, which determines the shape of the current in the primary and secondary windings, was obtained in the form in which the existence of only complex conjugate roots of the characteristic equation is implied. These types of roots usually occur in the case of analysis of circuits with a sufficiently high quality factor. Therefore, the scope of the mentioned analysis is limited by the range of problems that occur in the case of rather insignificant losses in the primary and secondary windings. Although such an analysis is sufficient for the vast majority of practical cases, an increase in losses in the primary and secondary windings can lead to other solutions of the characteristic equation. Obviously, such pulse transformers will have degraded technical characteristics compared to transformers with reduced
losses. Nevertheless, if it is necessary to generate voltage pulses with certain requirements for the duration of the front and the cutoff of the pulse, for example, when forming voltage pulses in a shape close to aperiodic, circuits with a reduced quality factor may be of some interest. The increase in active resistance allows to reduce or completely eliminate the distortion of voltage pulses, which are caused by oscillatory processes in electrical circuits with high quality factor. Therefore, for some cases, it is preferable to develop a more universal solution that allows to analyze transients in the primary and secondary windings of a pulse transformer for a wider range of power losses in the windings. Such a problem was also considered in [9]; however, the presented solutions, similarly to the results of [8], describe the case of weakly damped oscillations, which usually occur in the case of relatively insignificant losses in the primary and secondary windings. In addition, issues related to determining the voltage across the capacitance of the tested object are not addressed in [9]. The expression for the voltage at the load capacitance in operator form and general form is given in [10]. However, the original of this expression was determined for its simplified form, in which the value of the active resistance of the windings was not taken into account. The solutions given in [11] take into account the influence of the secondary active resistance on the voltage on the capacitance of the secondary circuit, but the analysis was carried out for the case of primary circuit excitation by harmonic voltage. In this paper, attention is focused on the case of primary circuit excitation by discharging the storage capacitance. A detailed analysis of the conditions for obtaining maximum voltages on the capacitance of the secondary circuit without taking into account the influence of the active resistance of the windings of the primary and secondary circuits on the temporal characteristics of the voltage was performed in [12]. There are no publications that take into account the attenuation of the voltage at the load capacitance associated with the parameters of the primary and secondary circuits [13]. The relations given in [13] for the voltage on the electric capacitance of the secondary winding obtained after such an analysis are also based on the consideration of the oscillation voltage on it. Thus, the issues of the formation of test voltage pulses at the load capacitance close to the aperiodic shape are closely related to the results given in [8, 13]. Nevertheless, if it is necessary to form such pulses, the analysis should be carried out for the case of more significant values of the active resistance of the windings, which lead to a different type of roots of the characteristic equation.
The goal of the work is an analysis of the influence of the active resistance of the primary and secondary windings of a pulse transformer on the voltage at the load capacitance based on the developed technique for the analysis of transients caused by the discharge of the storage capacitance in the primary winding.
Analysis of the equivalent circuit of a pulse transformer. Transient analysis is performed for the transformer's equivalent circuit shown in Fig. 1.
Fig. 1. Equivalent circuit for determining effect of the test object on the voltage pulse parameters at the load capacitance [8]
In the equivalent circuit in Fig. 1, C1, C2 represent the capacitances of the capacitor in the primary winding (storage capacitor) and the load capacitance of the test object in the secondary winding, respectively; R1, R2 are the resistances of the primary and secondary circuit, respectively; M is the mutual induction coefficient between the primary and secondary windings; L1, L2 are the inductances of the primary and secondary windings, respectively.
The analysis is carried out under the assumption of an insignificant parasitic capacitance of the primary and secondary windings (see Fig. 1). In resonance mode, the equality holds
L1C1 = L2C2 . (1)
In this case, the equivalent circuit (Fig. 1) is actually a Tesla transformer's equivalent circuit. For the case of negligibly small active resistances of the primary and secondary windings and the previously given equality (1), which determines the relationships between the inductances L1, L2 and capacitances C1, C2, the voltage at the load capacitance C2 can be determined using the following expression [14]:
U2 _ uM C^cos
B
IC2
((
®0
w
\ A t J J
(
- cos
®0
w
VT+k
A A t
JJ
(2)
1 uc (pLi + Ri +--)ii - pMi2 _-J-pCi p
(pL2 + R2 +-T-)i2 - pMii _ 0, pC2
(4)
(5)
where uc1 is the voltage across the storage capacitor at the beginning of the transient.
Taking the expressions (4), (5), we can write the expressions for the current in the secondary winding:
i2( p) _
p 2 MucCC2
4 3 2 '
ap + bp + cp + dp +1
(6)
where constants a, b, c, d can be determined using the following expressions:
a = L2C2 L1C1 - M 2C1C2, (7)
b = L2C2 R1C1 + R2C2 L1C1, (8)
c = L2C2 + R2C2 R1C1 + L1C1, (9)
d = R2C2 + R1C1. (10)
In accordance with the usual scheme of applying the Laplace transform, the expression for the dependence of the current in the secondary circuit on time can be written in the general form:
i2(t ) =
N ( pn )
.pj
(11)
n=1 M'(Pn) '
where all N(pn) are the numerator values in formula (6) at the points that correspond to the roots of the polynomial in the denominator of (6), and all M(pn) are the values of the derivative of the polynomial in the denominator of the expression (6) at the points corresponding to the zeros of this denominator.
Thus, assuming that the load capacitance at the beginning of the transient is not charged, the voltage on it can be found using the following expression:
^ --L). (12)
o C2 n=1M (Pn) Pn Pn
Since the transfer of energy from the primary circuit to the secondary one is made by inductive coupling, the analysis of transients must be performed taking into account the time dependence of the voltage on the inductance of the primary winding. Taking into account relations (4), (5), the expression for the current in the primary circuit can be written in the form:
i f , w i ^ N (
uc2(t)=Ciri'2 )dt = ciT^M
-, UcCi( p L2C2 + pR2C2 +1)
li(p) _-4-3-2-•
ap + bp + cp 2 + dp +1
(i3)
where k is the coupling coefficient between primary and secondary windings, m0 is the natural frequency of oscillations of the primary and secondary windings [i4] :
©o_ i _ i (3)
VLïCr VL2C2™
Applying the Laplace transform to the expressions for the voltage drop across the elements of the equivalent circuit (Fig. i), we can obtain relations for determining the current in the secondary winding in the operator form:
The currents in the primary and secondary circuits are determined by expressions in which the denominator is the same (compare (6) and (13)). This circumstance makes it possible to simplify the simulation of transients caused by the discharge of capacitor C1. Taking into account (13), the expression for the dependence of the current in the primary winding on time can be written in the form:
4 W (Pn ) ■ Pni
U (t) _ V — epn'
n_i M ' ( pn )
(i4)
where W(Pn) represent the values of the numerator from (13) at the points that correspond to the roots of the polynomial from the denominator (6) and (13).
Taking into account the expression (14), the voltage drop across the inductance of the primary winding L1 can be determined using the following expression:
uL(t) = L1Y -W(Pnl PnePnt. (15)
L1 M'(Pn)
Taking into account (11), (14), as well as (4), (5), the expressions for the voltages on the load capacitance (12) and the inductance of the primary winding (15) can be written in the form:
UC (t) = M — dt
L2 +Rh(t ),
dt
(16)
uLi{t) = ucl+M^^-ilmi-^\h(t)t. (17) |
dt
C
4 5
t, S x10"4
. Results of simulation and measurement of the current in the primary winding for C2 = 6.128 10 9 F, C1 = 4.5-106 F, R2 = 1.57 Q, R1 = 2.79 Q
Expressions (16), (17) can also be used to partially verify the previously given formulas for the voltage at the load capacitance and inductance of the primary winding.
Simulation results of transients in the primary and secondary windings caused by the discharge of the storage capacitor. Figures 2-5 show the results of transient calculations in the described model of the pulse transformer during its operation on the capacitive load. All calculations and measurements were carried out with the mutual induction between the primary and secondary windings M = 1.133*10 4 H. The inductance of the primary winding is taken equal to Lx = 186 10 6 H. Secondary winding inductance: L2 = 126 10 6 H. Despite the fact that in practical applications such circuit parameters do not provide certain advantages from the point of view of technical characteristics, they can be used both to verify the described solutions and to determine the general trends of transients in the primary and secondary windings.
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
t,s x10"4
Fig. 4. Voltage at the load capacitance with the active resistance of the primary winding 20.79 Q and the resistance of the secondary winding 100.57 Q
Fig. 3.
Currents in the primary winding for C2 = 6,128-10 Ci = 4.5-106 F and charge voltage 1000 V
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
t,S x10"4
Fig. 5. Voltage at the load capacitance with the active resistance of the primary winding 20.79 Q and the resistance of the secondary winding 20.57 Q
It can be seen from the above results that even in the case of the aperiodic discharge mode of the storage capacitor C (calculation results in Fig. 3), which can be achieved by increasing the primary active resistance, the mathematical simulation does not allow the aperiodic shape of the voltage across the load capacitance to be obtained (results calculation in Fig. 4). In this case, at the aperiodic discharge mode of the storage capacitor, the absence of jumps that distort the shape of the voltage at the load capacity of the test object, which are clearly visible in Fig. 5 is not provided. Elimination of the illustrated distortions can be achieved by increasing the time constant of the RC circuit in the secondary circuit of the transformer, whose action on the shape of the voltage pulse is seen in Fig. 4.
Conclusions.
1. The described solutions obtained using the Laplace transform can be used if it is necessary to generate voltage pulses on the capacitive load that are close in shape to aperiodic by adjusting the active resistance values of the primary and secondary transformer windings.
2. An increase in the active resistance of the primary winding allows achieving an aperiodic discharge mode of the storage capacitor. However, even with such a discharge mode, it is not possible to provide an aperiodic
shape of voltage at the load capacitance. One of the possible ways to obtain voltage pulses at a capacitive load that is as close as possible to the aperiodic shape is to increase the active resistance of the primary winding to values providing an aperiodic discharge of the storage capacitance, followed by an increase in the active resistance of the secondary winding, to eliminate jumps that distort the shape of the voltage.
3. A negative consequence of the described approach to the formation of voltage pulses is the fact that the elimination of jumps that distort the shape of the voltage due to an increase in the active resistance of the windings is accompanied by an inevitable decrease in the amplitude of the voltage pulse at the capacitive load.
4. Using the above methodology for calculating transients allows controlling the active resistance of the windings in order to eliminate distortion of the front of the voltage pulse, generated at the capacitive load, by high-frequency oscillations.
REFERENCES
1. Baranov M. I., Koliushko G. M., Kravchenko V. I. Generation of standard switching aperiodic impulses of high and superhigh voltage for full-scale tests of electrical power objects. Electrical engineering & electromechanics, 20i3, no.2, pp. 5256. (Rus). doi: 10.20998/2074-272X.2013.2.10.
2. Baranov M.I., Bocharov V.A., Ignatenko N.N., Kolobovsky A.K. Powerful generators of pulse voltages and currents with top parameters for testing of power electroenergetic equipment. Electrical engineering & electromechanics, 2003, no.2, pp. 7580. (Rus).
3. Baranov M.I., Buriakovskyi S.G., Rudakov S.V. The metrology support in Ukraine of tests of objects of energy, aviation and space-rocket engineering on resistibility to action of pulses of current (voltage) of artificial lightning and commutation pulses of voltage. Electrical engineering & electromechanics, 20i8, no.5, pp. 44-53. doi: 10.20998/2074-272X.2018.5.08.
4. Ivanov V.M. High voltage pulsed transformers with low leakage inductance. Electrical engineering & electromechanics, 20 i0, no.5, pp. i7-20. (Rus). doi: 10.20998/2074-272X.2010.5.04.
5. Liu Z., Winands G.J.J, Van K., Pemen A.J.M., van Heesch E.J.M. A high-voltage pulse transformer with a modular ferrite
core. Review of Scientific Instruments. 2008, vol.79, no.1. pp. 625-630. doi: 10.1063/1.2830943.
6. Bortis D., Biela J., Kolar J. W. Optimal design of a DC reset circuit for pulse transformers. Proceedings of the IEEE Twenty-Second Annual IEEE Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition APEC 07 (Cat. No.99TH8475), 2007, pp. 11711177. doi: 10.1109/APEX.2007.357663.
7. Lee Li, Chaobing Bao, Xibo Feng, Yunlong Liu, Lin Fochan. Fast switching thyristor applied in nanosecond-pulse high-voltage generator with closed transformer core. Review of Scientific Instruments. 2013, vol.84, no.2. pp. 425-432. doi: 10.1063/1.4792593.
8. Corum J., Daum J. Moore H. L. Tesla coil research. New Jercey, US army armament research, development and engineering center Publ., 1992, 38 p.
9. Kontorovich M.I. Operatsionnoe ischislenie i nestatsionarnye iavleniia v elektricheskikh tsepiakh [Operational calculus and non-stationary phenomena in electrical circuits]. Moscow, Gostekhizdat Publ., 1955. 277 p. (Rus).
10. Smith P.W. Transient electronics. Pulsed circuit technology. New-York, John Wiley & Sons Publ, 2011. 288 p.
11. Batygin Yu.V., Chaplygin E.A., Shynderuk S.A., Sobokar
0.5. Resonance in the secondary circuit of the Tesla transformer excitated by the harmonic voltage. Bulletin of NTU «KhPI», 2017, no.30(1252), pp. 21-27. (Rus).
12. Denicolai M. Optimal performance for Tesla transformers. Review of Scientific Instruments. 2002, vol.73, no.9. pp. 33323336. doi: 10.1063/1.1498905.
13. Reed J.L. Note: Tesla transformer damping. Review of Scientific Instruments. 2012, vol.83, no.7. pp. 76101-76103. doi: 10.1063/1.4732811.
14. Vavriv L.V., Ivanov V.M., Martsenyuk V.E., Mirzoev R.S. Devices for obtaining high voltage pulses in electrotechnologies. Bulletin of NTU «KhPI», 2017, no.15(1237), pp. 23-30. (Ukr).
Received 25.04.2019
A.G. Gurin1, Doctor of Technical Science, Professor,
1.A. Kostiukov1, Candidate of Technical Science,
1 National Technical University «Kharkiv Polytechnic Institute»,
2. Kyrpychova Str., Kharkiv, 61002, Ukraine, e-mail: [email protected]
How to cite this article:
Gurin A.G., Kostiukov I.A. The effect of the active resistance of the pulse transformer windings on the parameters of voltage pulses generated on a capacitive load. Electrical engineering & electromechanics, 20i9, no.5, pp. 45-49. doi: 10.20998/2074-272X.2019.5.08.
