ВОКРУГ ВОПРОСА МЕТОДОЛОГИИ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЯ БИЗНЕС-НЕУДАЧИ

Мардумян Микаел

0UPeb©h"UQ

<1S< L/nrfbpgfiLUjfi L pjqCbuj L/uiqduiL]bpu]i!iuiO wipjnCj i[uipfa, LnCmbuwqjLnnLpjwC pbLCw&nL, qngbCm

Pha"UbUh au^nauub nhUnh0bUUhPnhB3U"b 0b©n^UPUbnh©3Ub <UP8h CnhPa

hO t dbnDLupLjLULnjipLuLjLuD dwfunqnLJp, L ¡iQ^n"L bC npn dbaDLupLjnLpjnLDDbp L/QluJ dbiCwpLwinbpbp dwfunqlnLJ: Uju hwpgbpj 2nLpp 2wpnLCwmnLJ bC qjLnwLwC pwCwlbAbpp, npnCg pCpwCnLi bC bpQnL inLnbgiwC 2,ppLuOLuLObpnLJ.' IpwCgjg ibLip ipnpdnLi t dwfunqnLip pwgwmpb[ dbiCwpLwLnjpnLpjwC qnjWLnLiwC winLiinl, juL bpLpnpqp qw JbLCwpwCnLJ t dbiCwpLwLnjpnp qCQluiJluC mbuLuCLnLCIg: nLunLiiCu-ujpnLpjnLCCbpnLiii pwlwpwp nL2LuqpnLpjnLC ¿j qwpdlnLii дbl?Cwp|wLnjpw|wC dwfu-nqiwC mbuwibpnqwpwCw|wC IbpujiwuinwlnpiwCp: Ujq pwqiwpCnLjp L pwqiw-Lnqi bpLnLjpj hwJpCqqp!nLC pC!w[JwC lbpwpbpjw[ ui2fuuuinuuCgCbpp uwHwpjl bC: <nqlLudj CtWLnw!C t дbl?Cwp|wLnjpw|wC dwfunqJwC opjbLwjL pC!w[JwC hw-iup LUI?LU2LUp!b[ «2nLLw—ttblLnLpjnLC / |UlqiiUl|bpU|nLpJnLC-LUChLULn» dLiU£LUlJinl hwCqjtywLwg dwfunqnLiCbpj IbpinLdnLpjnLC oqrnwqnpdbinl UjuuCwLwC rnbuw-dbpnqw!wC hjdg:

<jtiGwpwrcbp dwfunqnul, diufunqiiuC inwbgnLi, hwCqju]w!wg dwfunqnLi JEL: M2, M20, M29

1 Sb'u Minniti M. & Levesque M., Entrepreneurial types and economic growth. Journal of Business Venturing, 2010, 25 (3), ¿2 305—314:

o

¿^mm^bpmgüb[ní ^pm mímpmp :

Uju^|uní' Óm^n^nLÚp n¿ ú|mjü pmqúm¿m^i L pmqúmÓL bpLnLjp ¿, mj[L ^mmómémhbmLmü.mjfiü bp^nrúmü| qnpópüpmg: Om pmqúm-

2 Sb'u Cooper A. C., Challenges in Predicting New Firm Performance. Journal of Business Venturing, 1993, 8 (3), t? 241-253:

3 Sb'u Hayward M. L. A., Shepherd D. A., Griffin D., A hubris theory of entrepreneurship. Management Science, 2006, 52 (2), ¿2 160-172:

4 Sb'u McGrath R. G., Falling forward: Real options reasoning and entrepreneurial failure. Academy of Management Review, 1999, 24 (1), ¿2 13-30:

5 Sb'u ünLjü mbrrQ, ¿2 241-253:

6 Sb'u Wennberg K., Wiklund J., DeTienne D. R., Cardon M. S., Reconceptualizing entrepreneurial exit: Divergent exit routes and their drivers. Journal of Business Venturing, 2010, 25 (4), ¿2 361-375:

7 Sb'u Cardon M. S., Stevens C. E., Potter D. R., Misfortunes or mistakes? Cultural sense making of entrepreneurial failure. Journal of Business Venturing, 2011, 26 (1), ¿2 79-92:

8 Sb'u DeTienne D. R., Entrepreneurial exit as a critical component of the entrepreneurial process: Theoretical development. Journal of Business Venturing, 2010, 25 (2), ¿2 203-215:

9 Sb'u Wennberg K., Entrepreneurial Exit. In L. P. Dana (Ed.), World Encyklopedia of Entrepreneurship, 2011, ¿2 170-177:

10 Sb'u Wennberg K., Wiklund J., DeTienne D.R., Cardon M.S., ü2í. w2^., ¿2 361-375:

Cum ¿brcOwp^wmbpbp ^diwpwOnLd bO hwu^wOw[, np w^wqwO |pbOg u^wuwd| OdwO ¿t: bpwOg dbd dwup ^wpdnLd t, np w^wqwO ^wpqw^bu Obp^wjfi tpumpw^n[jwg|wO t' nLrlr ¿wOw^wph, np 6q4nLd t hnp|qnOnLd:

QbnOwp^wmhpw^wG fiwfni|fiwO mbuwdbpn^wpwOw^wG hh^nLbpbbpQ

2o

j|O dnmbgnLdObpnLd:

PulfllnrldulOo ijkinkpdtiQfiuinLutyLuOj dnimbgnnd

u^qpOw^wO ^nL[| hbm, pwO| np qnpdnLObnLpjwO wj^ iwr 2p2wOO t 4^Rn-

11 Sb'u Zacharakis A.L., Meyer G.D., De Castro J., Differing perceptions of new venture failure: a matched exploratory study of venture capitalists and entrepreneurs, Journal of Small Business Management, vol.37, 1999, n.3, ¿ç 1-14:

12 Sb'u Singh S., Corner P., Pavlovich K., Coping with entrepreneurial failure. Journal of Management & Organization, 2007, 13 (4), ¿ç 331-344:

13 Sb'u Everett J., Watson J., Small Business Failure and External Risk Factors. Small Business Economics, 1998, 11(4), ¿ç 371-390:

14 Sb'u Wennberg K., Wiklund J., De Tienne D.R., Cardon M.S., Ù2Î. W2Ë., ¿ç 361-375:

15 Sb'u Hannan M.T., Freeman J., The population ecology of organisations. Am. J. Sociol. 1977, 82 (5), ¿ç 929-964:

16 Sb'u Wernerfelt B., A resource-based view of the firm. Strateg. Manag. J., 1984, 5 (2), ¿ç 171180:

17 Sb'u De Tienne D.R., Shepherd D.A., De Castro J.O., The fallacy of "only the strong survive": the effects of extrinsic motivation on the persistence decisions for underperforming firms. Journal of Business Venturing, 2008, 23 (5), ¿ç 528-546:

18 Sb'u Everett J., Watson J., Ú2í. W2[u., ¿Ç 371-390:

19 Sb'u De Tienne D.R., Shepherd D.A., De Castro J.O., Ü2í. W2Ë., ¿Ç 528-546:

20 Sb'u Nabil Khelil, The many faces of entrepreneurial failure: Insights from an empirical taxonomy, Journal of Business Venturing 31, 2016, ¿ç 72-94:

pn2 rçbp ïwmwpnLÙ ÔbéùwpïwmÇpnLpjwù ïwjnLùwgùwù wénLÚní21: <wúwp-ínLÚ np ùnpwumbrçô ïwqùw^bp^nLpjnLùùbpÇ hwúwp hÇùùw^wù rçdiwpnL-pjnLùp n¿ pb ùnp 2nL^m qmùb[ù t, wjL qnjnLpjnLÙ nLùbgnrç 2nL^mjnLÚ hwumwm-íbip22:

Unínpwpwp 2nLÏmjÇg ïwqùw^bp^nLpjwù b[ùp pwgwmpínLÚ t Ôbéùwp-ÏwmÇpnLpjwù wpnjnLùwibmnLpjwù wùpwiwpwp úw^wp^w^ní, Çù^p bù-pwrçpnLÙ t ïwqùw^bp^nLpjwù íwówé£, qnpônLùbnLpjwù rçwrçwpbgnLÙ ïwù ^w^mú: Dum ^n^nL[jwgÇnù tÏn[nqÇwjÇ mbunLpjwù bùpwrçpinLÙ t, np pÇq-

23

ùbuÇ qnjwmLmúp L hwçnrçnLpjnLùp hnùwùÇ2ùbp bù , Çuï ïwqùw^bp^nLpjwù ^w^múp L b[pp 2nLÏmjÇg' Ôw^nrçûwù hnùwùÇ2ùbp24: Uw^wjù hwpï t ù^w-mb[, np ¿Ç ïwpb[Ç ùÇwpdbpnpbù hwúwpb[, np 2nL^wjÇg b[£ù nL Ów^n^nLÚp hnùwùÇ2Ùbp bù, ùwùÇ np ^wqúw^bp^nLpjnLÚp Ïwpnrç t ^iw^íb[ ïwù íw-¿wéíb[ ùwL rçpw^wù hÇùpbpni25, wjrç pinLÙ ùbprçpnLÙùbpÇ hbmpbpùwù, wj[ qnpônLùbnLpjwùp qpw^íb[nL ÔbéùwpïwmÇpnç ùïwmwénLÙùbpni, Çù^bu ùwL pÇqùbuÇ ùÇqpwgÇwjÇ ^wmówrcní L wj[ù, npnùp Ôw^nrçnLÙ ¿Ç ïwpb[Ç hwúwpb[26: SwppbpnLÚ bù ÔbéùwpïwmÇpwïwù b[ùÇ bpïnL mbuwï «ÔwËn-rçnLÙ» [wí w2ËwmwùùÇ hbmLwùpni (gwù^w[Ç b[ù)27 L Ôw^n^nLÙ w2Ëw-rnwùpÇ íwm wpnjnLùpÇ hbmLwùpni (wùgwù^w[Ç b[ù):

<wmïwù2w^wù t, np ÔbéùwpïwmÇpwïwù b[pbpÇ wib[Ç pwù Ïbuù wù-gwùïw[Ç t,28 pùrç npnLÙ wùgwùïw[Ç t Çù^bu ÔbéùwpïwmbpbpÇ29, wjù^bu

30

t[ 2pçw^wmÇù hwúwp : ñL2wqpwí t wjù hwùqwùwùpp, np ùÇwjù pwgw-uwïwù b[pbpní ¿Ç ïwpb[Ç pwùw^w^bu qùwhwmb[ Ôw^nrçnLÙùbpÇ pùrçhw-ùnLp wumÇôwùp, pwùÇ np Ów^n^íwá ïwqùwïbp^mpjnLùùbpp Ïwpnrç bù ùwL ùùw[ 2nL^wjnLÚ b[ùÇ ËÇum wpqb[pùbpÇ ^wmówrcní:

Dum rçbmbpùÇùÇumwïwù ùnmbgùwù ÔbéùwpïwmÇpwïwù Ôw^n^nLÙp Ïw^iwô t pÇqùbuÇ éÇuïwjÇù iwË^wùÇ hbm: Uju rçb^pnLÙ ÔbéùwpïwmÇ-pwïwù Ôw^n^nLÙp ùbpïwjwginLÙ t «ïwqùw^bp^nLpjwù úwh» bqpnLjpní31, npp bppbùù ïw^nLÙ bù uùwùïwgùwù ÇpwiÇôw^Ç hbm32, bpp Ôw^n^nLÙp Çpwiwïwù hÇùpbp nLùÇ:

ObmbpùÇùÇumwïwù únmbgnLÚp bùpwrçpnLÙ t, np pÇqùbunLÙ ùnp Çpw-rçwpÔmpjnLùùbpp, opÇùwï ÔwËnrçnLÙùbpp, mb^Ç bù nLùbùnLÙ Ôbéùwpïwmb-pbpÇ ïwùùÇg wùïwË, ùpwùg ïnrçûÇg ¿íbpwhu^ín^ wpmwpÇù ùÇçwiwjpÇ

21 Sb'u Littunen H., Storhammar E., Nenonen T., The survival of firms over the critical first 3 years and the local environment. Entrepreneurship & Regional Development, 1998,10 (3), 189-202:

22 Sb'u Hay M., Verdin P., Williamson P., Successful new ventures: Lessons for entrepreneurs and investors, Long Range Planning, 1993, vol. 26, n.5, 31-41:

23 Sb'u De Tienne D.R., Shepherd D.A., De Castro J.O., ù2Î. w2Ë., tç 361-375:

24 Sb'u Wennberg K., ù2Î. w2Ë., tç 170-177:

25 Sb'u De Tienne D.R., Cardon M., Impact of founder experience on exit intentions. Small Bus. Econ, 2012, 38 (4), 351-374:

26 Sb'u Wennberg K., Wiklund J., De Tienne D. R., Cardon M.S., ù2Î. w2Ë., tç 361-375:

27 Sb'u De Tienne D. R., ù2Î. w2Ë., tç 203-215:

28 Sb'u Wennberg K., Wiklund J., DeTienne D.R., Cardon M.S., ù2Î. w2Ë., tç 361-375:

29 Sb'u Hayward M. L. A., Shepherd D. A., Griffin D., ù2Î. w2Ë., tç 160-172:

30 Sb'u Vaillant Y., Lafuente E., Do different institutional frameworks condition the influence of local fear of failure and entrepreneurial examples over entrepreneurial activity? Entrepreneurship & Regional Development, 2007, 19(4), tç 313-337:

31 Sb'u Mellahi K., Wilkinson A., Organizational failure: a critique of recent research and a proposed integrative framework, International Journal of Management Reviews, 2004, 5-6 (1), tç 21-41:

32 Sb'u Singh S., Corner P. & Pavlovich K., ù2i. w2Ë., tç 331-344:

qnpônùùbpÇ uù|nLuu^ib[Ç uqrçbgmpjuù hbmLuùpnl33: <bmLupup, np^bu luùnù, uéuçùujÇù t huùupinLÙ ÔbéùuplumbpbpÇ lnrùÇg ¿ibpuhulinr tlnjnqÇuluù ^ujûuùùbpÇ lbùuuluù lupLnpnLpjnLùp, npnùg ¿Ù2nLÙp L uuhùuùu^ulnLÛùbpp huùqbgùnLÛ bù luqûulbp^nLpjuù Ôu|nrùuù: Uju ùnmbgnLÙp puguénLÙ t Û2mu^bu uùuprçjnLùuibm qnpônr luqûulbp^nL-pjnLùùbpÇ qnjnLpjnLÛp 2nLÏmjnLÙ, npnùù uibjÇ 2um ébunLpuùbp bù ôu|unLÙ, ùuù umbrônLÙ: <uûuplnLÙ t, np ujrç^ÇuÇp ^bmp t huùibù 2nLlujÇg, Çù^ù, pum tnLpjuù, bùpurçpnLÛ t uùuprçjnLùulbm luqûulbp^nLpjnLùùbpÇ «t$-muùuqÇujÇ» lÇpuénLÙ:

PuilunriûuiCi inijnLÛinLupfiuinLulïLuû lÙnimhgnuÙ

^njjnLùmupÇumuluù ûnmbgmûp hÇûùinLÛ t luqûulbp^nLpjuù éb-unLpuujÇù mbunLpjuù ipu L ¿Ç pùrçmùnLÛ ujù mbuulbmp, np Ôbéùuplumb-pbpù uùqnp bù luù|bjnL hùupuinp Ôu|nrnLÙùbpp34: Uju ûnmbgnLÛù pù-^nLÙnLÙ t luqûulbp^nLpjuù ébunLpuùbpÇ qbpulu rçbpp L ^inpÔnLÙ pu-gumpbj, pb Çù^nL ùÇLùnLjù ^ujùuùùbpnLÛ npn2 luqûulbp^nLpjnLùùbp huu-ùnLÛ bù huçnrnLpjuù, Çul npn2ùbpp Ôu|nrÎnLÙ bù: Uju Ùnmbgûuûp' Ôu|n-rnLÙp lw|4wô t qnpônùùbpÇg, npnùp ¿bù rçuulnLÙ ÔbéùuplumbpbpÇ ibp-uhulnrnLpjuùp ¿bùpuplinr qnpônùùbpÇ 2uppÇù35: Dum injjnLùmupÇumu-luù ûnmbgûuù Ôu|nrnLÙp lu|iuô t mùmbuuluù qnpônLùbnLpjuù ujù-iqÇuÇ rçpuLnpmûùbpÇg, Çù^^ÇuÇp bù $Çùuùuuluù ¿qùuduûbpp, puguuu-luù bluùmupbpnLpjnLùp L uùi^upnLùulnLpjnLùp: Uju ùnmbgùuù huùu-Ôujù ÔbéùuplumÇpuluù Ôu|nrnLÙp luù bjùp pugumpinLÙ bù ébunLpuùbpÇ (lu^Çmuj ulmÇiùbp, ûuprçlujÇù lu^Çmuj) uùpuiupup Ùulup-rçulnl: Ujj lbp^ uuuô' mbrÇ t nLùbùnLÛ bluùnLmùbpÇ ûuluprçulÇ ujù-iqÇuÇ uùlnLÛ L/luù ôu|ubpÇ ujù^ÇuÇ uibjugnLÙ, np luqûulbp^nLpjnLùp i^uéùnLÛ t uùl^upmùul L ¿Ç lupnruùnLÛ ùbpqpuibj ùnp rçbpÇmnpùbp luù ùnp $Çùuùuuluù ébunLpuùbp: <bmLupup' ùu ¿Ç lupnr qnpôbj pù-pugÇl ub^uluùmpjuù L luéuiupùuù 2pçuùulùbpnLÛ:

Dum injjnLùmupÇumuluù ûnmbgûuù' ÔbéùuplumbpbpÇ npn2nLÛùbpù bù ^uéùnLÛ Ôu|nrûuù hÇùùuluù ^um^uéùbpp36: <bmLupup' lbùmpn-ùugùbjni luqûulbp^nLpjuù ébunLpuùbpp, Ôbéùuplumbpp lupnr t |nL-uu^bj ÔbéùuplumÇpuluù Ôu|nrnLÙÇg: UjuÇùpù' ùnp luqûulbp^nLpjnLù-ùbpp Ôu|nrÎnLÛ bù ^ pb upmupÇù qnpônùùbpÇ, ujj ÔbéùuplumÇpnç pnLjj mluô u|ujùbpÇ L uùhpudb2m hùmnLpjnLùùbpÇ pugulujnLpjuù ^umiu-éni37:

Puilunrûuiùù qquigûnLCipuijÇùj Ùnimbgnuù

QqugûnLùpujÇù ùnmbgnLÙp l^énpn2 ^bp t humlugùnLÛ Ôbéùuplu-mÇpnç 2uhu^p^ûuùp: h muppbpnLpjnLù rçbmbpûÇùÇumuluù L injjnLùmu-pÇumuluù ûnmbgnLÛùbpÇ, uju ùnmbgnLÙp hu2ÎÇ t uéùnLÛ ÔbéùuplumÇ-pnç hnqbpuùuluù qnpônùùbpp, npnùp âu|nrûuù luù qnjumLûuù mbu-uùljnLùÇg lupnr bù uibjÇ lupLnp jÇùbj, puù tlnjnqÇuluù luù luqùu-

33 Sb'u Cardon M.S., Stevens C.E., Potter D.R., ù2i. u2|., tç 79-92.

34 Sb'u Mellahi K., Wilkinson A., Organizational failure: a critique of recent research and a proposed integrative framework. Int. J. Manag. Rev. 2004, 5 (1), t2 21-41:

35 Sb'u Cardon M.S., Stevens C.E., Potter D.R., ù2i. u2|., tç 79-92:

36 Sb'u Mellahi K., Wilkinson A., ù2i. u2|., tç, 21-41:

37 Sb'u Cardon M.S., Stevens C.E., Potter D.R., ù2i. u2|., tç 79-92:

^Ьрщш^шй qnpônùùbpp38: Uju ünmbgümüp фпр0 t шрЦтй ршдштр»[т rnûÔûrnjÇû йш^шр^ш^ qnpônùùbpp, ш}^ рЦтй' hnqbpшûшïшû, npnùù 0ш-qrnü bù 0ьр0шр4шш^рп2 qqшgйnLÛùШJÛnLpJШû шр^тйртй39 L h^üqbgürnü бш^^йшй:

Эш^^йшй qqшgünLÛùШJÇû ùnrnbgnLÛp hbûinLÛ t àbRÛшpïшmÇpnLpJШû n[npm йЬрйт0Цш0 шûhшйшщшmшuËшûnLpJШû mbunLpJШû (discrepancy theory) Црш40: Uju mbunLpjnLÛp [pшgûnLÜ t 2»^jÇû mbunLpjnLÛp41, pum npÇ pÇqùbuÇ •^шт^тйр щшJüшûшЦnpЦшô t n^ йÇшJÛ mûmbuшïшû gnLgшûÇ2-ùbpni, ШJ[L ^шЁЦшб t àbrc^p^mÇpnç qnpônLÛbnLpJШû шр^тйшЦЬтт-PJШÛ 2»ùÇg42: ЭbRÛшpïшmÇpn2 шp^JnLÛшЦbmnLpJШû ßbüp шршш^рп^ш^ш-uшhüшûЦшô йшЦшр^шЦй t, npÇg gшôpÇ ^Ьщртй ЙЬгсйшрЦштЬрр npnßnLÜ t фшЦЬ[ ïшqüшïbpщnLpJnLÛp43: UûhшйшщшmшuËшûnLpJШû mbunLpJnLÛp ùbpùnLÔnLÛ t ÔbßûшpïшmÇpшïшû qnpônLÛbnLpJnLÛÇg «ршЦшршр-^ômpJnLÛ» h^u^gnLpjnLÛp: Uju bqpnLJpp hшûrçbu t •ш^ np^bu шûhшmÇ ЙЬгсйшрЦшт^ршЦшй hш2nrçnLpJШû hnqbpшûшïшû ¿шфтй, npp Цшрп^ t шq-

ÔbßûшpïшmÇpnLpJШû щшЬ|щшййшй Цшй ^рш b[pÇ hbm ЦшщЦшб àbrc-ûшpïшmÇpn2 npn2nLÙûbpÇ Црш44: bûpш^pЦnLй t, np pшЦшpшpЦшônLpJШû йшЦшр^шЦр npnßinLÜ t pum шûhшmÇ фшumшgÇ щшpqLшmpйшû L йрш ûщшmшïûbpÇ Цшй uщшunLйûbpÇ ùÇçL ^йшй hшйшщшmшuËшûnLpJШû:

UûhшйшщшmшuËшûnLpJШû mbunLpjnLÛù nLÛÇ bpïnL ïn^ù: 0Ç ïn^ùÇg' ЦЬршрЬртй t ûщшmшïûbpÇ йЦш^йшй pшgpnrçnLйûbpÇû, bûpш^pb[nЦ, np ÔbßûшpïшmÇpn2 pшЦшpшpЦшônLpJnLÛp npnßinLÜ t uïqpûшïшû йщштш^ L фшumшgÇ шр^тй^ Ëqйшйp45: 0jnLu ïn^ùÇg' ^ш ЦbpшpbpnLй t uщш-unLÙûbpÇ L ÇpшïшûnLpJШû ^йшйр' bûpш^pb[nЦ, np pшЦшpшpЦшônLpJnLÛp npnßinLÜ t pûpшgÇï ÇpшЦÇ¿шïÇ L ÔbßûшpïшmÇpn2 uщшunLйûbpÇ Ëqйшйp46:

ЭЬвйшрЦштЬрш^шй Öm^n^ümü ЦЬ^тбт^шй йш^шр^шЦйЬрр

ЭbßûшpïшmÇpnLpJnLÛp ^тшрЦЦтй t np^bu qnpôpûpшg47, Çuï Ôbé-ûшpïшmÇpшïшû ¿^ËnrçnLÙp' b[p ШJrç qnpôpûpшgÇg48: UnЦnpшpшp b[pÇ Îbp[nLÔnLpjnLÙûbpû ÇpшïшûшgЦnLй bù bpïnL йшЦшр^шЦтй' ШÛÔÛШJÇÛ L ÏшqйшïbpщnLpJШû, шûmbub[nЦ ш!й hшûqшйшûùp, np ÔbßûшpïшmÇpшïшû бш^^тйр ^pnrç t öшqb[ ûшL щЬтшЦшй ЦшгсшЦшрйшй L 2nLÏШJШïшû йbËшûÇqйûbpÇ бш^^йшй йшЦшр^шЦйЬртй:

38 Sb'u Van Gelder J.L., Vries R.E., Frese M., Goutbeek J.P., Differences in psychological strategies of failed and operational business owners in the Fiji Islands. J. Small Bus. Manag. 2007, 45 (3), ¿2 388-400:

39 Sb'u Jenkins A.S., Wiklund J., Brundina E., Individual responses to firm failure: appraisals, grief, and the influence of prior failure experience. Journal of Business Venturing, 2014, 29(1), ¿2 17-33:

40 Sb'u Cooper A.C., Artz W.A., Determinants of satisfaction for entrepreneurs. J. Bus. Ventur. 1995, 10 (6), 439-457:

41 Sb'u Gimeno J., Folta T.B., Cooper A.C., Woo C.Y., Survival of the fittest? Human capital and the persistence of underperforming firms. Adm. Sci. Q., 1997, 42 (4), ¿2 750-783:

42 Sb'u DeTienne D.R., Shepherd D.A., De Castro J.O., üßi. Ш2|., ¿2 528-546:

43 Sb'u Gimeno J., Folta T.B., Cooper A.C., Woo C.Y., üßi Ш2|., ¿2 750-783:

44 Sb'u Carree M.A., Verheul I., What makes entrepreneurs happy? Determinants of satisfaction among founders. J. Happiness Stud., 2012, 13 (2), ¿2 371-387:

45Sb'u De Tienne D.R., Shepherd D.A., De Castro J.O., üßi. Ш2|., ¿2 528-546:

46 Sb'u Cooper A.C., Artz W.A., üßi. Ш2|., ¿2 439- 457:

47 Sb'u Shane S. Venkataraman S., The premise of entrepreneurship as a field of research. Academy of Management Review, 2000, 25 (1), 217-226:

48Sb'u Wennberg K., Wiklund J., De Tienne D. R., Cardon M. S., üßi. Ш2|., ¿2 361-375:

UUPßbföbbQ 161

бш^п^йшЬ ^^ürnü^^rnj^ Црш rnq^mü Ьй ßnL^rnj^ L щЬттр}шй äшËn^nLÜйЬрp: йй^ npnLÜ, L ^brnnLpjnLÜü тйш^ Ьй

¿ЬqngшgйЬ[nL й|^шйд äшËnrnLÜйЬpp:

QujflinrinLll Ll/hLnnLßJLUÜ ÜLUQLUpiJLUQnLÜ

äшËnrnLÜйЬp| nLunLÜйшu|pnLрJnLййЬpp hbüinLÜ Ьй Ишиш-рш^ш^шй pйmpnLpJшй mЬunLpJшй (public choice theory) Цpш, npp йЬplшJnLÜ ^|mшplЦnLÜ t npL»u ßшrшßшlшйnLpJшй mйmЬuшq|mшlшй mbumpjnLÜ: äЬmnLpJшй Йш^г^й шuЬ[nЦ hшulшйnLÜ Ьйр äшpЬmn-шp^JnLйшЦЬmnL-PJшй |pшlшйшgüшй шйpй^nLйшlnLpJnLй:

^pl t üßb[, np LЬLnLpJшй äшËnrnLÜйЬpp ^шщЦшд Ьй hшuшpшlш-^шй йшËpйmpnLpJnLййЬp| pшgшhшJmüшй, qnpöшlш[шlшй hшpшpЬpnL-PJnLййЬp|, шйЬ|шйш£шф mЬrЬlшmЦnLpJшй, pJnLpnlpшmшlшй üЬйш2йnph| L гсЬйтш}| h^^p üpgшЦшqß| h|üйшËй^|pйЬp| hbm49, npnйg »p^pnLÜ äЬßйшplшm|pшlшй qnpönLйЬnLpJшй äшËnrnLÜйЬp| ¿ш^шй Ьй щш-pnLйшlnLÜ:

Qm^nrnLÜ ßnil^mJ/i üшQшplJшQnLÜ

Qm^nrnLÜ llшqüшllhpLцnLpJшй üшl^шpl}шllnLÜ

ЭЬßйшplшm|pnLpJшй шp^JnLйшЦЬmnLpJnLйp •йшЬ^тЬ^ h^^p Ьp-pЬüй йшËpйmpnLÜ Ьй oqmшqnpöЬ[ n£ рЬ 2nLlшJ|g Ь[р| шpqЬ[gйЬp|, ШJ[ •^штЫшй шpqЬ[gйЬp| hшJЬgшlшpqp: <ш2пгш1 йnpшumЬrö ^^pnL-PJnLййЬpp pйnLршqpЦnLÜ Ьй •^штЫшй шpqЬ[gйЬpp hшrршhшpЬ[nL тйш-lnLрJШüp: QйшJШö äЬßйшplшmЬpЬpp, np^u lшйnй, Ü2mшLЬu ЬйршplЦnLÜ Ьй lшqüшlЬpLnLрJnLй|g ^mpu qш[nL ШJйnLШÜЬйшJй|Ц, йpшйg щши-

iНе можете найти то, что вам нужно? Попробуйте сервис подбора литературы.

щшйтй Ьй |pЬйg p|qйЬu| •^штЫшй hnLJup50: Uju mЬuшйlJnLй|g, •^ш-тЩр йnp p|qйЬu| h^^p ^шгсйтй t hш2nrnLрJшй Ь^ййш^шй gnLgшй|2: hul 6шёпгЦш0 Ьй h^^p^Ld ШJй äЬßйшplшmЬpЬpp, ni^p | ф^шЦ ¿Ьй uЬфшlшй p|qйЬup lЬйunLйшl LшhЬ[nL51: Qm^nrnLÜ шйäйшJ/^й üшlJшpl}шl^nLÜ

bppЬüй lшqüшlЬpLnLрJшй |pшЦшlшй «üшhp» Lшpшш^|p ¿| й2Ш-йшlnLÜ äЬßйшplшm|pn2 шйб| ung|n[nq|шlшй Цш^^шй: Ршйй ШJй t, np lшqüшlЬpLnLрJnLйp lшpnr t hшй^Ьu •ш[ ЦЬpшlшqüшlЬpLЦшö йnp |pш-

49SЬ'u Архипова О. В., Анализ провалов государства и провалов рынка в сравнительной форме. Вестник Челябинского государственного университета, 2010, № 27 (208). Экономика. Вып. 29, t2 12-16: http://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/analiz-provalov-gosudarstva-i-provalov-rynka-v-sravnitelnoy-forme

50 S^u Shepherd D.A., Douglas E.J., Shanley M., New venture survival: ignorance, external shocks, and risk reduction strategies, Journal of Business Venturing, vol.15, 2000, n. 5-6, t2 393-410:

51 S^u Chrisman J.J., Bauerschmidt A., Hofer C.W., The Determinants of New Venture Performance: An Extended Model, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, vol. 22, 1999, n.1, t2 5-29:

Цшpшûшïшû шйё^ mbupni: PшgÇ шûЦ¿шpnLÛшïnLpJШû ÇpшЦÇ¿шïÇg, 0ш-^^тй цшрп^ t mb^Ç тйЬйш[ ûшL ïшqйшïbpщnLpJnLÛûbpÇ йÇшÔnL[йшû L ^[шййшй ^Ьщртй: îшqйшïbpщnLpJШû йшhp цшрп^ t щшJйшûшЦnpЦbl n^ йÇшJÛ фnpйш[ uûшûïшgйшû bpLnLjpni, ШJ[L ùnp ïnpщnpшmÇЦ йÇшЦnpÇ ïшqйшïbpщшïшû ûnLJÛшïшûшgйшйp: PшJg ïшqйшïbpщnLpJШû «йшЬ|й» шpÔшûшqpb[nL hшйшp ïшqйшïbpщшïшû ûnLJÛшïшûшgnLйp ¿Ç ЦшрЬф ^Çmшpïb[ np^bu •[ЁШЦПР uïqpnLÛp:

ОдЦшр t ïшûËшmbub[ ùnp ïшqйшïbpщnLpJШû «йшЬ^»' b[ùb[ni ^q-йш^Ьрщш^шй ^rcmg^ôùÇg, npù шpmшgn[ЦnLй t ^рш шßшûôûшhшm-ÏnLpJШû, ïшJnLÛnLpJШû L hbmLn^шïшûnLpJШû pûnLpшqpbpnЦ:

^m^éùbpÇ mbuшûÏJnLÛÇg, ÔшËn^йшû ШÛÔÛШJÇÛ йnmbgйшû щшрш-qшJnLй шßшûgùШJÇû t !шйшрЦтй ÔbßûшpïшmÇpn2 uщшunLйp, npp pnLj[ t mш[Çu pшgшmpb[, pb mЦJШ[ Ôbßûшpïшmbpû Çù^nL t npn2nLй ^^pbgùb[ ÔbßûшpïшmÇpшïшû qnpônLùbnLpjnLùp: <bmLшpшp, ÔbßûшpïшmÇpшïшû b[pp ЦшщЦшб t ûшL ÔbßûшpïшmÇpn2 uщшunLйûbpÇ hbm52: b[pÇ ШÛÔÛШJÇÛ йш^шр^ш^р I^ùî^ù t ÔbßûшpïшmÇpn2 ûщшmшïÇ L ûЦш¿йшû mшppb-pnLpJШû Црш53: Фшumnpbû, ^ш Цшрп^ t ЦшщЦЬ[ ШÛÔÛШJÇÛ pшЦшpшpЦш-ônLpJШû (шûpшЦшpшpЦшônLpJШû) hbm, Çù^p npLt pшûÇ ûЦш¿йшû (^ЦшЙ-йшû) Цшй прп2ш^ ÔqmnLйûbpÇ nL uщшunLйûbpÇ Çpшïшûшgйшû (^ршЦш-ûшgйшû) шp^JnLÛù t:

Uju^Çuni' ÔbßûшpïшmÇpшïшû ¿^^^LÜP hnqbpшûшmûmbuшqÇmш-^ù bpLnLjp t, npp ^bmp t ùûûшpïb[ rçbmbpйÇûÇumшïшû, Цn[JnLÛmшpÇu-mшïшû L qqшgйnLÛùШJÇû hшJшgùûbpÇ hшйшmbrçйшû йÇшuûшïшû mbuш-йbpnrçшpшûшïшû Ь^й^Ц: ЭbßûшpïшmÇpnLpJШû шЦшр^щ hшuïшûш[nL 1Ш-йшр h^pï t ïшmшpb[ ÔшËn^йшû йшïшprçшïûbpÇ ibpinLÔnLpjnLù «2/2» uËbйшJnЦ (2nLÏш-щbmnLpJnLÛ/ïшqйшïbpщnLpJnLÛ-шûhшm), b[ùb[ni h^ùrçÇ-щшïшg ÔшËn^йшû qnpôpûpшgûbpÇ opjbïmÇi qnjnLpjnLùÇg:

ОЧШШЧПР6ЦШ0 qпшЦшйnLpJnLй

1. Архипова О.В., Анализ провалов государства и провалов рынка в сравнительной форме. Вестник Челябинского государственного университета, № 27 (208), 2010. http://cyberleninka.ru/article/n /analiz-provalov-gosudarstva-i-provalov-rynka-v-sravnitelnoy-forme

2. Cultural sense making of entrepreneurial failure. Journal of Business Venturing, 26 (1), 2011.

3. Carree M.A., Verheul I., What makes entrepreneurs happy? Determinants of satisfaction among founders. J. Happiness Stud., 13 (2), 2012.

4. Chrisman J.J., Bauerschmidt A. et Hofer C.W., The Determinants of New Venture Performance: An Extended Model Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, vol. 22, n.1, 1999.

5. Cooper A.C., Challenges in Predicting New Firm Performance. Journal of Business Venturing, 8 (3), 1993.

6. Cooper A.C., Artz W.A., Determinants of satisfaction for entrepreneurs. Journal of Business Venturing, 10 (6), 1995.

7. De Tienne D.R., Shepherd D.A., De Castro J.O., The fallacy of "only the strong survive": the effects of extrinsic motivation on the persistence decisions for underperforming firms. Journal of Business Venturing, 23 (5), 2008.

52 Sb'u Ucbasaran D., Westhead P., Wright M., Flores M., The nature of entrepreneurial experience, business failure and comparative optimism. Journal of Business Venturing 25 (6), 2010, ¿2 541—555:

53Sb'u Cooper A.C., Artz W.A., O2I w2f., t2 439—457:

UUPeb^hbQ 163

8. DeTienne D. R., Entrepreneurial exit as a critical component of the entrepreneurial process: Theoretical development. Journal of Business Venturing, 25 (2), 2010.

9. DeTienne D.R., Cardon M., Impact of founder experience on exit intentions. Small Bus. Econ, 38 (4), 2012.

10. Everett J., Watson J., Small business failure and external risk factors. Small Bus. Econ, 11 (4), 1998.

11. Gimeno J., Folta T.B., Cooper A.C., Woo C.Y., Survival of the fittest? Human capital and the persistence of underperforming firms. Adm. Sci. Q., 42 (4), 1997.

12. Hannan M.T., Freeman J., The population ecology of organisations. Am. J. Sociol. 82 (5), 1977.

13. Hay M., Verdin P., Williamson P., «Successful new ventures: Lessons for entrepreneurs and investors», Long Range Planning, vol.26, n.5, 1993.

14. Hayward M. L. A., Shepherd D. A., Griffin D., A hubris theory of entrepreeurship. Management Science, 52(2), 2006.

15. Jenkins A.S., Wiklund J., Brundina E., Individual responses to firm failure: appraisals, grief, and the influence of prior failure experience. Journal of Business Venturing, 29 (1), 2014.

16. Littunen H., Storhammar E., Nenonen T., The survival of firms over the critical first 3 years and the local environment. Entrepreneurship & Regional Development, 10(3), 1998.

17. McGrath R. G., Falling forward: Real options reasoning and entrepreneurial failure. Academy of Management Review, 24 (1), 1999.

18. Mellahi K., Wilkinson A., Organizational failure: a critique of recent research and a proposed integrative framework, International Journal of Management Reviews, 5-6(1), 2004.

19. Minniti M., Levesque M., Entrepreneurial types and economic growth. Journal of Business Venturing, 25(3), 2010.

20. Nabil Khelil, The many faces of entrepreneurial failure: Insights from an empirical taxonomy, Journal of Business Venturing, 31, 2016.

21. Shane S., Venkatarama S., The premise of entrepreneurship as a field of research. Academy of Management Review, 25(1), 2000.

22. Shepherd D.A., Douglas E.J., Shanley M., New venture survival: ignorance, external shocks, and risk reduction strategies, Journal of Business Venturing, vol.15, n. 5-6, 2000.

23. Singh S., Corner P., Pavlovich K., Coping with entrepreneurial failure. Journal of Management & Organization, 13(4), 2007.

24. Ucbasaran D., Westhead P., Wright M., Flores M., The nature of entrepreneurial experience, business failure and comparative optimism. Journal of Business Venturing, 25(6), 2010.

25. Van Gelder J.L., Vries R.E., Frese M., Goutbeek J.P., Differences in psychological strategies of failed and operational business owners in the Fiji Islands. J. Small Bus. Manag, 45(3), 2007.

26. Vaillant Y., Lafuente E., Do different institutional frameworks condition the influence of local fear of failure and entrepreneurial examples over entrepreneurial activity? Entrepreneurship & Regional Development, 19(4), 2007.

27. Wennberg K., Wiklund J., DeTienne D. R., Cardon M. S., Reconceptualizing entrepreneurial exit: Divergent exit routes and their drivers. Journal of Business Venturing, 25(4), 2010.

28. Wennberg K., Entrepreneurial Exit. In L. P. Dana (Ed.), World Encyklopedia of Entrepreneurship, 2011.

29. Wernerfelt B., A resource-based view of the firm. Strateg. Manag. J., 5(2), 1984.

30. Zacharakis A.L., Meyer G.D., De Castro J., Differing perceptions of new venture failure: a matched exploratory study of venture capitalists and entrepreneurs, Journal of Small Business Management, vol. 37, n.3, 1999.

МИКАЕЛ МАРДУМЯН

Заведующий кафедрой коммерции и организации бизнеса АГЭУ, кандидат экономических наук, доцент

Вокруг вопроса методологии исследования бизнес-неудачи.- Продолжаются научные споры, происходящие в рамках двух подходов вокруг вопросов: "что такое предпринимательская неудача и почему некоторые предприятия и/или предприниматели терпят неудачу". Первый из подходов пытается объяснить неудачу с точки зрения существования предпринимательства, второй же - комментирует ее с точки зрения предпринимателя. В существуюших исследованиях недостаточное внимание уделяется теоретико-методологическому переосмыслению неудачи. Мало работ относительно глобального восприятия этого многогранного явления. Целью данной статьи является предложение анализа с использованием единой теоретико-методологической основы для объективного восприятия предпринимательской неудачи в формате "рынок-государство - организация-индивид".

Ключевые слова: неудача, подход неудачи, встречная неудача.

JEL: M2, M20, M29 MIKAEL MARDUMYAN

Head of the Chair of Commerce and Business Organization at ASUE, PhD in Economics, Associate Professor

The Study of Methodology of Business Failure.- The

scientific debates around the questions "What is business failure, why do some companies and/or entrepreneurs fail?" continue within the circles of two approach methods. One of them is trying to explain the failure in terms of the survival of the enterprise, and the second discusses it from the perspective of the perception of the entrepreneur. There is not enough attention paid to the study of reconsidering the methodology of business failure. There are few works on the inclusive understanding of this diverse and multilateral process. Using a single-acting theoretical-methodological basis this article aims to offer "market-state/company-individual" format of failure analysis for an objective comprehension of the business failure.

Key words: failure, failure approach, oncoming failure. JEL: M2, M20, M29

ВОКРУГ ВОПРОСА МЕТОДОЛОГИИ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЯ БИЗНЕС-НЕУДАЧИ Текст научной статьи по специальности «Экономика и бизнес»

Похожие темы научных работ по экономике и бизнесу , автор научной работы — Мардумян Микаел

Текст научной работы на тему «ВОКРУГ ВОПРОСА МЕТОДОЛОГИИ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЯ БИЗНЕС-НЕУДАЧИ»