CC BY
115y^K 94(480)
Aleksi Mainio
The Elite on the Warpath — Finland and the Russian Combat Organizations in 1918-1939
In this article based on my thesis1 I examine the White émigré organizations that operated in the Finnish territory in 1918-1939 and their armed combat against the Soviet Union. Not only where there counter-revolutionary combat organizations operating in Finland, but government representatives also participated in various plots and even terrorist attacks.
These events in Finland were very much a part of the history of the Russian elite. The revolutions of 1917 had exiled a significant portion of the old Russian upper-== class and lead to a "brain drain" from the east to the west. The refugees had lost a great deal during the political turmoil: possessions, social influence, and homes ^ were left behind in the old homeland. Many refugees became unappeasable enemies g to Bolshevism and driving forces for the counter-revolutionary struggle. They had ^ the motivation, social relationships, and the capital without which credible combat
Jg against the Soviet Union was out of the question.
s «
o &
V
H The Arrival of the Refugees
Eh O
The geographical position of Finland had a significant impact on shaping its | role in the history of the Russian diaspora. The country, which had recently be-(i come independent, was located next to the Russian Empire and its old capital ^ Petrograd, so fleeing to Finland did not necessarily require enormous physical ex-h ertion. The exact number of refugees who arrived to Finland during the years of c
the Russian revolution and Civil war is unknown. According to one estimate, in 1922 there were approximately 33,500 former Russian subjects2 in Finland, 19,000 of which were Great Russians and the rest, in particular, Ingrians, East Karelians, and Finns3. During the 1920s, the number of refugees fell quickly at first, then slowing down4.
Refugees came to Finland especially from Petrograd and its immediate vicin-ity5. Many of the arrivals were specifically high-ranking civilian and military authorities and influential political leaders, academics, and prominent representatives of the upper-class. These members of the old elite included, among others, Prince Vladimir Volkonsky and the former Prime Ministers Alexander Trepov and Vladimir Kokovtsov6. The refugees also included the cousin of the last Emperor of Russia, Grand Duke Kirill Vladimirovich. He and his son Vladimir Kirillovich, who was born in Finland, were legitimate heirs to the Russian crown.
Another significant group of refugees consisted of high-ranking White officers. The defeat suffered by the Northwestern Army led by General Nikolai Yudenich in the Baltics at the end of 1919 initiated a wave of migration to Finland. The Kronstadt rebellion and the disintegration of the Northern Army led by Lieutenant General Yevgeni Miller near Arkhangelsk and Murmansk at the beginning of 1920 had similar effects7.
White Combat Organizations 1918-1920
Authorities from different countries were forced to take a stand on the clandestine operations of the Russian opposition forces during 1918, at the latest. Activists of the White forces established their own intelligence and combat organizations, which used Central Europe and the neighboring countries of Soviet Russia as their support areas. The idea was that these more or less competing organizations would act secretly behind the Bolsheviks' backs. They organized bomb attacks, arsons, and assassinations and smuggled clandestine information to White armies operating in ^ different parts of Russia and neighboring areas8. §
By 1919, Nikolai Yudenich, a general in the Russian Imperial Army, became the ^ most significant émigré leader. This military commander, who had fled to Finland, ^ wanted to assemble an army in the Finnish and Baltic region, to lead the attack S into Petrograd either by itself or with the Finns, for example. Yudenich held secret  negotiations with General Gustaf Mannerheim, even discussing the seizing of Saint 8 Petersburg. In the spring of 1919, General Yudenich created a secret espionage unit ° close to his staff. The unit's mission was to gather information from Russia. The or- £ ganization established close ties to Petrograd and the White forces operating in dif- j? ferent parts of Russia. Espionage, sabotage operations, and other clandestine initia- ^ tives were led from Finland by sending secret agents to Soviet Russia, in particular -5 through the border parish Terijoki. 5
The émigré organizations and the Finnish military intelligence had an abundance of shared agents. In practice, the conspirative actions of the Finnish general staff and the émigré organizations were difficult, if not impossible, to separate from each other. Both were connected to Petrograd and elsewhere in Soviet Russia through counterrevolutionary agents and saboteurs9.
Kronstadt Rebellion
When the Provisional Revolutionary Committee launched the rebellion on February 28, 1921, the émigré circles began to think that the end of the Soviet Russia had finally come. In Finland, refugee activists tightened their contacts to the flagship of the counter-revolution, the Kronstadt fortress. Dozens of ambassadors from the combat organizations arrived to Vyborg and the Isthmus from Central Europe10. In defiant spirits, the so-called Petrograd Combat Organization11 had been formed in Petrograd and the neighboring areas.
The most important communications of the Petrograd Combat Organization — or the Tagantsev Conspiracy — went through the couriers of the activist organizations and intelligence services from Finland to Petrograd. The messengers smuggled letters and weapons over the border and delivered reports and other information to Finland12. While the clandestine activities died down in 1921-1922, they were seen as alarming by the Soviet Russian security services. They concluded that the Finnish region had been used as a support area for espionage and bombings13. Even the All-Russian Congress of Soviets emphasized that Finland was "becoming an outpost of the world, thrust in front of the counter-revolution"14.
R ROVS
o
^ The setbacks in the counter-revolutionary struggle forced the émigré circles to head out for new ideological winds. The support for monarchism especially increased
g in the early years of the 1920s, but its influence never reached the level it could have.
jl The refugee circles could not reach a consensus on who should wear the crown. This
X resulted in two competing camps, one supporting Grand Duke Kirill Vladimirovich
| and the other standing behind Grand Duke Nikolay Nikolayevich. The dispute over
cu the order of succession originated from the fact the most logical Romanov heirs had
^ been murdered during the Russian Civil War.
§ The monarchists' schism impeded the fight against Bolshevism, which was suffering from other problems as well. After the Russian Civil War, The Russian White Army had
| disintegrated into smaller parts. The situation was dire. The commander of the White
si Army Pyotr Wrangel tried to maintain the combat readiness of his troops by setting up
^ a common umbrella organization for white officers. This coalition was officially estab-
h lished in September of 1924 and named the Russian All-Military Union15, i.e. ROVS16. c
A secret combat organization led by General Alexander Kutepov was created within the ROVS. One of its most important Russian routes, so-called "windows", was located in the Karelian Isthmus. ROVS agents traveled through Southern Finland using secret routes over the eastern border and back into Western Europe17.
The Isthmus Window
The collaborative initiatives between the émigrés and their allies caused a great deal of concern in the Soviet Union. The secret police OGPU18 decided to fight back using a tactic which was heavily influenced by the history of the Okhrana, the secret police of the Russian Empire. OGPU created fake counter-revolutionary organizations, the most famous of which was the Monarchist Union of Central Russia, or more simply Trust. This organization, which presented itself as anti-Bolshevist, but was actually monitored by the OGPU, pretended to operate in the Soviet Union. It managed to win the trust of both the Finnish general staff intelligence and the Secret Intelligence Service (SIS) of Great Britain19.
With the help of the Trust, the head of the secret police of the Soviet Union Lubyanka and its subdivision in Leningrad managed to control the intelligence and other clandestine operations by various western countries and the émigrés in Soviet Russia in 1921-192720. The scheme was successful, but gradually suspicions began to emerge. The émigré activists and western intelligence officers found it hard to explain to themselves why counter-revolutionary operations met with ever-increasing misfortune.
The situation culminated in the beginning of 1927. In March, a meeting was held in the Frolov Villa in Terijoki, protected by the Finnish general staff intelligence. Attending the meeting were Trust liaisons and general staff officers, but also a secret guest of honor from Paris. "The actual leader of the Russian Monarchist émigrés" Alexander Kutepov had been allowed into Finland. Atmosphere at the meeting was intense and the discussion focused on initiating a counter-revolutionary bomb war21. £7 The secret police of the Soviet Union drew its own conclusions on the situation. § The operation of Trust was no longer worthwhile, because the fake organization was ^ dangerously close to being exposed and it could no longer curtail the terrorist plots ^ by émigré activists. Evidently, the first step in shutting down the organization was S a mission given to an OGPU agent. He was ordered to reveal the deception which  had continued for years to the ROVS representatives smuggled into Moscow22. 8
The scandalous news quickly travelled to Helsinki and Vyborg and from there ° to Paris raising concerns23. If an organization like Trust could have been controlled £ by the OGPU, then anyone could be a traitor24. The leadership of the ROVS was j? shocked by the revelation, but not paralyzed. The émigré generals in Paris wanted revenge. In the spring of 1927, the leader of the armed wing of the ROVS Alexander -5 Kutepov and his allies decided to launch a terror campaign against the Soviet Union. ^
The situation seemed opportune, as the relationship between Great Britain and Soviet Union had been severed, which was believed to predict war.
The expectant atmosphere culminated with terrorist attacks attempted by ROVS activists in Leningrad and Moscow, with the support of the Finnish general staff intelligence and the Secret Intelligence Service of Great Britain25. The attack on Lubyanka's dormitory was a failure, but the devastating grenade assassination at a party clubhouse by the Moyka encouraged the attackers to continue the bombing campaign. In August of 1927, the new leader of Kutepov's combat organization, émigré activist Georgy Radkovich, arrived to Finland, sending two two-person bombing teams to the Soviet Union from the area to the north of Lake Ladoga26.
From Brotherhood to Separatists
ROVS's most active clandestine operations in the Karelian Isthmus began to fade in 1928-1930. The change resulted, in particular, from the fact that the Finnish authorities had banished Russian activists from the country after the terrorist attacks carried out in the Soviet Union had unnerved the Finnish political leaders. The President and the government did not want to sever all of their ties to their eastern neighbor. As the ROVS was losing its ability to take action, another activist organization, Brotherhood of Russian Truth21 and its leader in Finland Anatoly Toll intensified their operations in Finland. Brother number 213 sent his spies into Leningrad from the Isthmus and made arrangements in several other directions. Toll and his contacts in Berlin caused concern in the Finnish security authorities. They were still interested in influencing the events in the Soviet Union and even contributing to terrorist attacks, but they were afraid that OGPU had interfered in Toll's clandestine undertakings28.
The concerns were justified as the secret police had infiltrated the brotherhood.
Most terror plots by Toll and his partners were doomed to fail. OGPU was aware of
== both the clandestine undertakings of the brotherhood and their connections to the
intelligence services of various countries. This was especially clear in the case where
^ the general staff intelligence and Toll attempted to sneak Armenian freedom fighter
g terrorists into Caucasia from Finland in the early years of the 1930s29. The "Armenian
^ case" and other similar incidents were part of a larger chain of events: underground
Jg operations by Soviet national minorities intensified in the turn of the 1930s. New
| activist organizations attempted to turn Ukraine, Armenia, Georgia, and many other
f regions into independent countries and did not shy away from violent methods30. s
O H o
« The Skoblin Affair
s «
& When General Yevgeny Miller was elected to lead the ROVS in 1930, his position ^ was far from enviable. While Miller took a more reserved view on terrorism than his h predecessor Alexander Kutepov, he also wanted to increase underground contacts c
into the Soviet Union. One aspect of this was the attempt to establish a new intelligence channel from the Karelian Isthmus to the Soviet Union in 193331.
Miller tightened his contacts with Major General Severin Dobrovolsky32. The émigré officer who resided in Vyborg suggested in 1933 that the intelligence connections could be established with the help of the Finnish security authorities33. A little later, General Miller received a letter from Finland, in which the head of intelligence at the Finnish general staff Erik Malmberg announced that the Finnish general staff supported the idea34.
Major General Nikolai Skoblin was named to head the new intelligence channel. He made arrangements with the Finnish intelligence officers regarding the shared intelligence channel for ROVS and the general staff. The ROVS activists wanted to gather information from the Soviet Union, but also to attempt to carry out terrorist attacks and even assassinate Joseph Stalin. Despite the big talk, the cooperation between the intelligence officers and ROVS did not work as planned. The agents that ROVS had delivered to Finland were not only exposed, but very nearly captured on their way to Leningrad. The general staff was unnerved by the firefight on the Soviet Union's side of the border and cancelled the agreement, never continuing the cooperation on the previous scale after 1936.
While the Skoblin affair ended in a failure, even that did not convince the Finnish general staff intelligence officers to end the ROVS cooperation for good. The policy seems stubborn at first, but it was based on some rational justification. When the international situation grew tense in the final years of the 1930s, the general staff could not relinquish their émigré contacts as the information they provided was more valuable than ever before35. The final boom of counter-revolutionary activism happened just before the Second World War. The Russian policy of Nazi Germany was activated, leading to a momentary warming of relations between Germany and a few White émigré organizations. This also reflected quickly on Finland. The region of the republic was once more to be used as a support area for terrorists and spies, but operations ceased with the signing of the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact in August 193936.
o
(N
In Conclusion 2
It can be said that Finland had a significant role as a support area for the counter- S
revolutionary struggle. Several intelligence and combat organizations, in which the  old elite of the Russian Empire in particular had a key role, operated in the region 8
of the republic. The representatives of the old elite wanted to overthrow the Soviet °
system and return to their homeland, one way or another. Some did not hesitate £ to use terrorist attacks, sabotage, and assassinations to help reach their goals. It is j? clear that most terrorist attacks and espionage plots would have lost their vitality
without the active and passive support of the Finnish authorities. Some Finnish -5 security authorities saw the Soviet Union as a giant with feet of clay, who could ^
collapse at any time. This belief was at its strongest in the 1920s, but did not disappear during the 1930s. This view was based on an anti-Bolshevist worldview, but also on knowledge of the problems gnawing at the Soviet Union. The political elite and the security authorities of the Soviet Union often defined the Finnish region to be "a country of White bandits" and even "a den of terrorists"37. It was not left unnoticed in Moscow that the Finnish authorities turned a blind eye to the activities of the counter-revolutionary forces and even supported them. This phenomenon provided the political leadership of the Soviet Union a major propaganda weapon which it was able to use masterfully. Purpose-oriented anti-Finnish views with enough basis in fact to seem plausible were publicized at convenient times. The trails of many exposed espionage and terror plots led straight to the headquarters of the secret police of the Soviet Union, Lubyanka. The intelligence officers of the Bolshevik authority infiltrated their provocateurs inside the combat organizations, thus attempting to control their underground operations. The tactic was successful and made active resistance difficult.
1 Mainio A. 1) Nákymátón sota. Suomi vastavallankumouksellisen terrorismin ja vakoilun tuki-alueena 1918-1939. Doctoral thesis. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2015; 2) Terroristien pesa. Suomi ja taistelu Venájástá 1918-1939. Siltala, 2015.
2 It should be kept in mind that before the revolution, Russian empire had over 130 million residents, who were divided into dozens of different nationalities. "Former Russian subject" was an ambiguous concept: at the time, it could just as well be used to described Great Russians, Armenians, or, for example, Ingrians, who had previously had a Russian citizenship. When this article speaks about Russians, it usually means Great Russians. The terms "Russian refugee" and "emigré" can be used to mean all persons who arrived to Finland, regardless of their nationality.
3 KopteffG. Venáláisten emigranttien járjestótoiminta Suomessa 1917-1945. Master's thesis. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 1983. S. 7-8; Haimila M. Kun kumous vie kodin. Suomeen paenneet venáláiset 1917-1927 // Historiallinen arkisto. 1998. N 111. S. 61; Nevalainen P. Vis-koi kuin Luoja kerjáláisiá. Venáján pakolaiset Suomessa 1917-1939. Helsinki: SKS, 1999.
^ S. 307; Marrus M. The Unwanted, European Refugees from the First World War Through the ^ Cold War. Temple University Press, 2002. S. 61.
4 According to one estimate, in 1927-1935 the number of Russian, Ingrian, and East Karelian refugees remained at around 18,000, from where it declined to 14,000 by 1938.
S 5 Polvinen T. Venáján vallankumous ja Suomi 1917-1920 II. Toukokuu 1918 — joulukuu 1920. g Helsinki: WSOY, 1971. S. 63; Leggett G. The Cheka: Lenin's Political Police. The All-Russian jÜ, Extraordinary Commission for Combating Counter-Revolution and Sabotage. December 1917 ^ to February 1922. New York: Clarendon, 1981. P. 105-123; Jussila O. Neuvostoliiton tragedia. Utopiasta vankileirien saaristoksi. Otava, 2012. S. 128, 365-373; The National Archives
§ (TNA), Lontoo, War Office (WO) 106/6101, General Information Received by Military Intelligence Branches, Extract from Military Intelligence Summary 11, Situation in Soviet Russia
sp 9.1.1919 and Intelligence Summary of Information 14.12.1918.
o 6 Kokovtsov V. Out of My Past. The Memoirs of Count Kokovtsov. Stanford: Stanford University,
^ 1935. P. 530-531; Pankakoski J. Varjonyrkkeilya itarajalla. Venalaisten emigranttien poliittinen
liikehdinta Suomessa 1917-1927. Licentiate thesis. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2005.
§ 7 Approximately 1,000 refugee soldiers exhausted by the northern front traveled to Finland at
^ the beginning of 1920. When the rebellion in the Kronstadt fortress was squashed, a large group
^ of beaten refugees consisting of 6,500-8,000 sailors, officers, and civilians arrived to Terijoki
^ over the ice. Up to 5,000 of the comers returned to Russian during the 1920s. Haimila M. Kun
£ kumous vie kodin. S. 76; Nevalainen P. Viskoi kuin Luoja kerjalaisia. S. 18-19, 26-27.
8 Zubarev D. I. "Krasnaja tsuma" i belyi terrorizm (1918-1940) // K. N. Morozov (Ed.) Indi-vidualnyi polititseski terror v Rossii, XIX — natsalo XX v. M.: Memorial, 1996. S. 163; Brook-Shepherd G. Iron Maze. The Western Secret Services and the Bolsheviks. Pan Books, 1999. P. 35; Gosudarstvennyi arhiv Rossijskoi Federatsii (GA RF). Moskova, Narodnyi sojuz zastsity rodiny i svobody. F. 5872. Op. 1. D. 19. L. 1-7, Report on Savinkov's Organisation, 1918.
9 National Archives. The Sornainen office (SA), pikkukokoelma (PK) 2414, suojelukuntain tie-dustelukeskus 1919-1920, communiques 183 and 441, July 29 and October 21 1919.
10 Tsentr deistvija // State Archives of Russian Federation (GARF). F. 5784. Op. 1. D. 100. L. 46-51; Laidinen E. P., Verigin S. G. Finskaja razvedka protiv Sovetskoi Rossii. Spetsialnyje sluzby Finljandii i ih razvedyvatelnaja dejatelnost na Severo-Zapade Rossii. 1914-1939 gg. Petrozavodsk: Kompanija RIF, 2004. S. 177-178.
11 Петроградской боевой организации (ПБО).
12 TsernjajevJu. V. Finljandski sled v "dele Tagantseva" // Rossija i Finljandija v XX veke. K 80-letiju nezavisimosti Finljandskoi Respubliki. SPb., 1997. C. 189-190; Kronstadtskaja tra-gedija 1921 goda. Kn. 2. Tagantsev's statement to Cheka 24.07.1921; letter from David Grimm's secretary Georgy I. Novitsky to Vladimir Tagantsev 05.05.1921. S. 177-181, 128-129.
13 Kronstadtskaja tragedija 1921 goda. Kn. 2. GPU employee Mikhail V. Pavlov's presentation 24.01.1923; "final summary of Matvei A. Komarov's delo", representative Stepan Lebedev 19.07.1921; Cheka special assistant Yakov S. Agranov's communique to Lenin 08.09.1921. S. 301-310, 176-177,195.
14 Korhonen K. Naapurit vastoin tahtoaan. Suomi neuvostodiplomatiassa Tartosta talvisotaan I 1920-1932. Tammi, 1966. S. 57-58.
15 Русский общевоинский союз.
16 Goldin V. I. Rossijskaja vojennaja emigratsija i sovetskije spetssluzby v 20-e gody XX veka. Solti, 2010. S. 234, 243; Robinson P. The White Russian Army in Exile 1920-1941. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. P. 98-102.
17 Bakhmeteff Archive (BAR), Columbia University, New York. ROVS Collection. Box 9. Correspondence, correspondence between Kutepov's representatives and Hogstrom, 1924-1926; Russkaja vojennaja emigratsija 20-40-h godov, dokumenty i materialy. T. 6. M.: RGGU, 2013. S. 468.
18 Объединенное государственное политическое управление. OGPU had other names in 1918-1939, but for clarity, this article only uses one.
19 Brook-Shepherd G. Iron Maze. P. 255-256, 283-290; Elfvengren E., Laidinen E. Vakoilua itarajan takana. Yleisesikunnan tiedustelu Neuvosto-Karjalassa 1918-1939. Helsinki: Minerva, 2012. S. 112-122, 296-297; Kotakallio J. "Kaikkialla lasna oleva Lontoon Secret Service". Secret Intelligence Service ja Suomi 1918-1941. Doctoral thesis. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2014. S. 172-184; Rossijski gosudarstvennyi arhiv sotsialno-polititseskoi istorii (RGASPI), о Moscow. Felix Edmundovich Dzerzhinsky. F. 76. Op. 3. D. 356. L. 1-8, Top secret report to ^ KRO's head Artur Artuzov signed by Vladimir Styrne 05.02.1925; Smith M. Six. A History z; of Britain's Secret Intelligence Service. Murder and Mayhem 1909-1939. Dialogue, 2010. "3 P. 288. Regarding the British agency, see also: BAR, ROVS Collection. Box 9, correspondence, | Kutepov's letters to Bunakov, years 1925-1926; RGASPI. Felix Edmundovich Dzerzhinsky. Д F. 76. Op. 3. D. 356. L. 1-8, Top secret report to KRO's head Artur Artuzov signed by KRO's "S assistant director Vladimir Styrne 05.02.1925. -д
20 Cook A. Ace of Spies. The True Story of Sidney Reilly. Tempus, 2004. P. 221; Fleishman L. -2 V tiskah provokatsii. Operatsija "Trest" i russkaja zarubeznaja petsat. M.: Novoje literaturnoje щ obozrenije, 2003; Spence R. Trust No One. The Secret World of Sidney Reilly. Feral House, 2002. P. 418-437. J
21 KA, EK-Valpo, emigres. Folder 2825, Secret letter signed by Esko Riekki to the head of the £ Vyborg subdivision, 23.03.1927; Robinson P. The White Russian Army in Exile 1920-1941. g P. 140; The Ministry of Foreign Affairs Archives (UM), Ulkoasiainministerio ja Suomen ^ diplomaattinen edustus ulkomailla, 5 C18, Reports from the Moscow embassy, ambassador -S
oo
Pontus Artti's report, 01.09.1927. On Kutepov's trip, see also: KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 10253, Alexander Kutepov, Pehr Johansson's "rapport 25", 25.03.1927. KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 10170, Georg and Maria Schulz, Georgy Radkovich's interrogation, 05.09.1927.
KA, Pontus Artti collection, 5, Esko Riekki's letter to ambassador Pontus Artti, 26.05.1927. KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 10170, Georg ja Maria Schulz, top secret report, based on the statement of émigré informant Kirill Pushkarjov, 19.08.1927. Compare also: BAR, Alexander Kutepov Collection, box 2 and 3, correspondence, Kutepov's materials on Trust, 1927. For more detailed information on the terrorist attacks, see: KA, EK-Valpo, émigrés, folder 2830, Schultz affair, interrogation of Dmitri Monomakhov and Viktor Larionov, 15.09.1927. On Rosenstrôm's role, see also, for example: KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 10170, Georg and Maria Schulz, top secret report, based on the statement of émigré informant Kirill Pushkarjov, 19.08.1927.
Goldin V. I. Rossijskaja vojennaja emigratsija i sovetskije spetssluzby v 20-e gody XX veka. S. 413-414; KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 10170, Georg and Maria Schulz, Esko Riekki's report to the Minister of the Interior and Foreign Minister, 25.01.1928; Kosonen M. Raja railona aukeaa. Tiedustelua Neuvosto-Karjalassa 1920-1939. Ilias, 2001. S. 182-183; KA, Pontus Artti collection, 5, Esko Riekki's letter to ambassador Pontus Artti, 24.09.1927; KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 10682, Alexander Shvetsov, Riekki's notes on a phone discussion with Lieutenant Colonel Ilmari Relander, 10.12.1927; Lubjanka, Stalin i VTSK-GPU-OGPU-NKVD, jan-var 1922 — dekabr 1936. Memo sent by the head of KRO Artur Artuzov to Dmitri I. Kursk, 09.09.1927. P. 140. Братство Русской Правды.
KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 10886, Anatoly Toll, Esko Riekki's notes 05.01.1929 and Toll's interrogation 07-08.01.1929.
KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 11041, Anushavan Zatikjan, passim; Mainio A. Nâkymâtôn sota. P. 223-237.
KA, EK-Valpo, foreigners in Finland, folder 2755, refugee question, Stendahl and Pajari's report of a meeting with Kaapre Tynni and Roman Smal-Statski, 18.4.1932; Mainio A. Nâ-kymâtôn sota. P. 238-242.
Prianishnikov B. Nezrimaja pautina, VTSK-OGPU-NKVD protiv beloi emigratsii. M.: Tsas pik, 1979. S. 269.
BAR, ROVS Collection. Box 12, correspondence, correspondence between Yevgeni Miller and Severin Dobrovolsky, year 1933.
BAR, ROVS Collection. Box 12, correspondence, Severin Dobrovolsky's letters to "Ivan Iva-novich" i.e. Yevgeni Miller, 23.05 and 28.08.1933. Compare also: KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 11180, Jalmari Sinivaara's top secret communique, 20.08.1933; KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 11180, Severin Dobrovolsky, Jalmari Sinivaara and Kaarlo Stendahl's handwritten notes on
g meeting with Severin Dobrovolsky and^Nikolai Skoblin, 30.01.1934.
Prianishnikov B. Nezrimaja pautina, VTSK-OGPU-NKVD protiv beloi emigratsii. S. 270-271.
N 35 KA, EK-Valpo. Personal file 10886b, Anatoly Toll, Sinivaara's notices on meetings with Sa-
!g lokorpi and Toll, 27.04. and 05.08.1936. See also: KA, EK-Valpo. Personal file 4491, Toivo Salokorpi, reports on the general staff intelligence operation, 22.04.-22.05.1947, A. Toll; Ko-
f sonen M. Raja railona aukeaa. S. 81.
H 36 KA, EK-Valpo, émigrés, folder 2829, Jalmari Sinivaara's report "Venâlâiset emigrantit",
h 07.09.1938; KA, EK-Valpo, personal file 11160, Ivan, Yuri, and Boris Solonevich, passim.
s 37 Neobhodimo razrusit gnezdo terroristov v Finljandii // Izvestija. 1927. 04.10. «
s «
o \o
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
References
BROOK-SHEPHERD G. Iron Maze: The Western Secret Services and the Bolsheviks. Pan Books, 1999.
COOK A. Ace of Spies: The True Story of Sidney Reilly. Tempus Publ., 2004.
ELFVENGREN E., EINAR LAIDINEN E. Vakoilua itarajan takana: Yleisesikunnan tiedustelu Neuvosto-Karjalassa 1918-1939 [Espionage behind the Eastern Border: Intelligence of the General Staff of Finland in Soviet Karelia from 1918 to 1939. In Finnish]. Minerva Publ., 2012.
FLEISHMAN L. V tiskah provokatsii: Operatsija "Trest" i russkaja zarubeznaja petsat [Operation "Trust" and the Russian press abroad. In Russ.]. Moscow: Novoje literaturnoje obozrenije, 2003.
GEORGE K. Venalaisten emigranttien jarjestotoiminta Suomessa 1917-1945 [Activity of Russian Emigrant Organisations in Finland from 1917 to 1945]. Master's thesis. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 1983.
GOLDIN V. I. Rossijskaja vojennaja emigratsija i sovetskije spetssluzby v 20-e gody XX veka [Russian Military Emigration and Soviet Special Services in 1920s. In Russ.]. Solti, 2010.
HAIMILA M. Kun kumous vie kodin: Suomeenpaenneet venalaiset 1917-1927 [Russian Emigrants in Finland from 1917 to 1927. In Finnish] / Historiallinen arkisto. 1998. T. 111.
JUSSILA O. Neuvostoliiton tragedia: Utopiasta vankileirien saaristoksi [The Tragedy of the Soviet Union: from Utopia into a Gulag Archipelago. In Finnish]. Otava Publ., 2012.
KOKOVTSOV V. Out of My Past: The Memoirs of Count Kokovtsov. Stanford: Stanford University, 1935.
KORHONEN K. Naapurit vastoin tahtoaan: Suomi neuvostodiplomatiassa Tartosta talvisotaan: I: 19201932 [Neighbours against Their Will: Finland and the Soviet Diplomacy from the Tartu Peace Treaty into the Winter War. In Finnish]. Tammi Publ., 1966.
KOSONEN M. Raja railona aukeaa: Tiedustelua Neuvosto-Karjalassa 1920-1939 [Finnish Intelligence in the Soviet Karelia from 1920 to 1939. In Finnish]. Ilias, 2001.
KOTAKALLIO J. "Kaikkialla lasna oleva Lontoon Secret Service": Secret Intelligence Service ja Suomi 1918-1941 [Secret Intelligence Service and Finland from 1918 to 1941. In Finnish]. Doctoral thesis. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2014.
Kronstadtskaja tragedija 1921 goda: dokumenty v dvuh knigah: kniga 2 [The Tragedy of Kronstadt in 1921. In Russ.]. Moscow: ROSSPEN Publ., 1999.
LAIDINEN E. P., VERIGIN S. G. Finskaja razvedka protiv Sovetskoi Rossii: Spetsialnyje sluzby Finljandii i ih razvedyvatelnaja dejatelnost na Severo-Zapade Rossii: 1914-1939 gg. [Finnish Espionage against the Soviet Russia: The Finnish Special Services and their Intelligence Activity in North-West Russia from 1914 to 1939. In Russ.]. Petrozavodsk: Kompanija RIF Publ., 2004.
LEGGETT G. The Cheka: Lenin's Political Police: The All-Russian Extraordinary Commission for Combating Counter-Revolution and Sabotage: December 1917 to February 1922. New York: Clarendon Press., 1981.
Lubjanka: Stalin i VTSK-GPU-OGPU-NKVD: janvar 1922-dekabr 1936 [Stalin and Cheka-GPU-OGPU-NKVD. In Russ.]. Moscow: Materik, 2003.
NEVALAINEN P. Viskoi kuin Luoja kerjalaisia: Venajan pakolaiset Suomessa 1917-1939 [Russian Emigrants in Finland from 1917 to 1939. In Finnish]. SKS, 1999.
MAINIO A. Nakymaton sota: Suomi vastavallankumouksellisen terrorismin ja vakoilun tukialueena 19181939 [The Invisible War: Finland as a Support Area for Anti-Revolutionary Terrorism and Espionage from 1918 to 1939. In Finnish]. Doctoral thesis. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2015.
MAINIO A. Terroristien pesa: Suomi ja taistelu Venajasta 1918-1939 [The Lair of Terrorists: Finland and |Z the Fight for Russia from 1918 to 1939]. Siltala, 2015.
MARRUS M. The Unwanted: European Refugees from the First World War Through the Cold War. Temple University Press, 2002.
PANKAKOSKI J. Varjonyrkkeilya itarajalla: Venalaisten emigranttien poliittinen liikehdinta Suomessa 1917-1927 [Political Activity of Russian emigrants in Finland from 1917 to 1927. In Finnish]. Licentiate thesis. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2005.
POLVINEN T. Venajan vallankumous ja Suomi 1917-1920: II: Toukokuu 1918-joulukuu 1920 [The Russian Revolution and Finland from 1917 to 1920. In Finnish]. Helsinki: WSOY Publ., 1971.
PRIANISHNIKOV B. Nezrimaja pautina: VTSK-OGPU-NKVD protiv beloi emigratsii [Cheka-OGPU- -3 NKVD against White Emigration. In Russ.]. Moscow: Tsas pik, 1979. <»
ROBINSON P. The White Russian Army in Exile 1920-1941. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. £
Russkaja vojennaja emigratsija 20-40-h godov: dokumenty i materialy: tom 6 [The Russian Military Emigration from 1920s to 1940s. In Russ.]. Moscow: RGGU, 2013. g
d
SMITH M. Six. A History of Britain's Secret Intelligence Service: Murder and Mayhem 1909-1939. Dialogue, 2010.
SPENCE R. Trust No One. The Secret World of Sidney Reilly. Feral House, 2002.
TSERNJAJEV JU. V. Finljandski sled v "dele Tagantsevd' [The Finnish Trail in the Tagantsev Case. In Russ.] // Rossija i Finljandija v XX veke: K 80-letiju nezavisimosti Finljandskoi Respubliki. St Petersburg: Jevropeiski Dom, 1997.
ZUBAREV D. I. "Krasnaja tsuma" i belyi terrorizm: 1918-1940 ["The Red Plague" and the White Terrorism from 1918 to 1940] // In Individualnyi polititseski terror v Rossii: XIX — natsalo XX v. [Political Terror in Russia in the 19th Century and at the Beginning of the 20th Century. In Russ.]. Moscow: Memorial, 1996.
Aleksi Mainio. The Elite on the Warpath — Finland and the Russian Combat Organizations in 1918-1939
Author examines the White émigré organizations that operated in the Finnish territory in 1918-1939 and their armed combat against the Soviet Union. Not only where there counter-revolutionary combat organizations operating in Finland, but government representatives also participated in various plots and even terrorist attacks.
Key words: Finland, White émigré organizations, Soviet Union, 1918-1919.
Mainio, Aleksi — researcher, Department of Philosophy, History, Culture and Art Studies, University of Helsinki.
Майнио, Алекси — исследователь, факультет философии, истории, культуры и искусств Хельсинкского университета.
E-mail: [email protected]
es
и ce К
«
S «
о
v
s çp
о
H о
S «
S «
о \o
