CC BY
49
Arfaoui Sonia*, Frini-Srasra Najoua* **, Srasra Ezzeddine*
SYNTHESIS AND CHARACTERIZATION OF HYDROXY-CHROMIUM
PILLARED BENTONITE
*Unité de recherche Matériaux, Institut National de la Recherche Scientifique et Technique,
[email protected] Faculté des Sciences de Tunis
Introduction
Pillared interlayred clays are a very important family of porous solids that has been developed in the last years. Furthermore smectite clay can be pillared with oligomeric metal hydroxide ions for that, many researches have been reported the synthesis and characterization of Al(III)[1]; Zr(IV)[2]; Ti(III)[3]; Fe(III)[4]; Cr(III)[5] and Rh(III)[6] pillared clays. These hydrolytic polynuclear metal cations can form thermally stable materials and micro porous structures where the clay layers are held apart by catalytically active metal oxide pillars. The porous materials are of interest mostly thanks to their potential usefulness in catalysis. In particular, chromium pillared clays have attracted the researchers attention after being tested as catalytic in a wide range of reactions such as catalytic conversion of hydrocarbons [7], ester formations [8] and elimination of water from alcohols[9]. This is due essentially to their high surface area, sizeable gallery height, porous structure and acidity [10], [11], [12], [13] .
In this work the synthesis procedure includes three principal steps: first the preparation of polyoxo-cations by hydrolysis of certain multivalent cations which under appropriate conditions give rise to cationic polymeric species; second, the formation of the intercalated clays by ion exchange of the original charge compensating cations of swellable smectite clays by the polyoxocations synthesized in first step and finally the formation of the pillared clays by calcination of the intercalated clays to high temperatures at which the metastable polyxocations are transformed into stable oxi-hydroxidic phases, which act as pillars that support the clay layers and maintain them separated. The synthesized pillared clays were characterized focusing mainly on the properties of these new materials (basal spacing, thermal stability surface area and pore structure).
Experimental
Hydroxy-Cr oligomeric solution
A number of methods have been developed to produce the chromium oligomers spaces that are incorporated into the interlamellar space of clays. In our case the Cr(III) oligomers have been prepared as follows: a certain amount of aqueous Na2CO3 was gradually added to aqueous chromium nitrate solution or chromium chlorite solution with constant stirring until a final CO32+/Cr3+ ratio of 1 . The mixture is maintained at a temperature of 80°C for 36h [14], [15],[16].
Pillaring process
Na+-clay was obtained from the Haidoudi deposit, a Tunisian interstratified illite-smectite bentonite mineral [17]. In this study the illitic fraction represents about 15% of the interstratified material; the smectitic fraction is in sodium form which pronounced a beidellitic character. The average elemental formula determined from the Na exchange purified fraction is
Na 0.54 K 0.16 Ca 0.03 (Si 7.4 Al 0.6) IV (Al 2.94 Fe 0.79 Mg 0.33) VI O22
The cationic capacity exchange of material is about 80 meq/100g of calcined clay and its nitrogen BET surface area is 100 m2/g.
The intercalation was achieved by adding slowly a suspension of Na+- clay to the solution containing Cr (III) oligomers at room temperature. The mixture was stirred continuously for 2h to ensure that the intercalation has been completed and then the suspension was centrifuged, the supernatant removed and the green clay material repeatedly washed with distilled water and centrifuged.
After intercalation the pillared clays are obtained by heating in vacuum at 350°C are denoted as Hp n meq(Cl) or Hp n meq(NO3), where n indicates the molar ratio of CO32+ to Cr3+ cations.
Analysis of products
The basal spacing d00i were measured with X-Ray diffractometer using Ni-filtered CuK a radiation by scanning 1° (20) min-1 between 2° and 20°. The determination of chemical composition sample was accomplished by atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS VARIO) after dissolving the clay samples in a mixture
© Arfaoui S., Najoua F., Ezzeddine S., Электронная обработка материалов, 2009, № 3, С. 78-85.
of three acid extracts (HCl; H2SO4; HNO3) in a known proportion. The proportion of silica was determined by gravimetric method. Thermal studies were performed on Perkin-Elmer analysers, TGA and DTA for thermogravimetric and differential thermal analysis, respectively. All measurements were carried out at a heating rate of 10 °C/min under a flow of nitrogen. The BET surface area and pore size structure data were derived from N2 adsorption-desorption isotherm at 77K using an Autosorb-1 (quanta chrome) device. All pillared clays were degassed at 373K for 2h.
Results and discussion Characterization Elemental composition
The chemical compositions of all the solids are given in Table 1. It can be observed a decrease in the amount of Na+, Mg2+ and Al3+ cations in modified samples compared to natural clay. In addition, modified clays showed the presence of Cr species. We can estimate from these observations the incorporation of chromium species which have been intercalated in the place of Al3+ and Na+ cations. On the other hand, the amount of fixed chromium species varied almost linearly with the initial concentration of Cr3+ cations reaching high fixation amounts, mainly in the case of 60 meq (NO3). From chemical analysis we cannot confirm the formation of polynuclear chromium. Evidence for the intercalation of hydroxy-chromium species in bentonite is provided by XRD diffractograms.
Table 1. Elemental composition of chromium pillared clays
Sample Al2Ü3 S1O2 Fe2Ü3 Mg Ü Na2Ü K2O Ca Ü &2Ü3 PF
purified Clay (Hp) 18.1 54.28 7.45 3.5 2.12 1.7 0.089 0 13.73
(Hp)20 (NO3) 17.52 53.8 7.05 2.3 0.63 0.68 0.063 2.45 16.44
(Hp)40 (NO3) 14 51.69 8.23 2.51 0.73 0.99 0.07 3.2 18.87
(Hp)60 (NO3) 12.5 48.35 8.83 3.06 0.79 1.57 0.081 5.84 21.39
G ® ë 17.18 53.32 7.86 2.1 0.5 0.57 0.056 1.95 16.46
(Hp)40 (Cl) 14.23 52.3 8.2 2.4 0.68 0.912 0.071 2.6 18.11
G 0 ''O ê 12.08 50.81 8.55 2.8 0.77 1.44 0.087 5.6 19.57
XRD Analysis
The XRD patterns along with basal spacing (d001) data of n meq (Cl) and n meq(NO3) compounds are presented in figure. 1. It reveals that d001 is about 13.8 A for natural clay and it ranged from 18.43 to 21.13 for chromium modified clays. Taking into account the thickness of the silicate layer (about 9.6 A) an increase of d00i has been observed and which varied from 8.83 to 11.53 A. These values are in agreement with that found in the literature for chromium pillared clays.
In fact, Roulia has reported the synthesis of chromium pillared clays with basal spacing of 24.5 A, the intercalating solution has been prepared by quick addition of base and acid to Cr (III) monomeric solutions followed by reflux [18]. On the other side C.Volzone has reported the preparation at 60°C of OH-Cr smectites with different proportions of Cr3+ to clay. The authors showed a chromium pillared clays gallery heights of 10.9-11.1A [19]. Other experiments were performed with intercalation of Cr(III) polynuclear species generated by aging hot solutions of Cr3+ in base such that OH/Cr=0.5-2.5 [20,21] this method has yielded Cr(III) pillared clays with d001 spacing of 21A. Whereas another method that based on intercalation of individual Cr (III) hydrolytic oligomers gave materials with d001 spacing of 15.7A [22] which were consistent with the geometries of the intercalated oligomers. These methods also allowed the study of the ion-exchange properties of these materials and it was found that when the Cr(III) intercalated clays and the oligomers became covalently bound to the silicate clay sheets and that the intercalated oligomers did not polymerize whilst
within the clay layers.
In this work, the larger dooi spacing was observed with solutions of higher Cr (III) oligomers content presumably because these solutions contain larger and more highly charged polynuclear cations which are preferentially incorporated into the clay. On the other hand a higher d001 was obtained by using nitrate as anion in the intercalating solution. This increase may be attributed to the formation of higher Cr (III) oligomers. From figure 1, we can notice the d001 peak are sharper extended in chromium pillared clays compared to unmodified clay especially Hp40 (NO3), Hp40(Cl) and Hp60(Cl) samples. This observation can be attributed to the heterogeneity of intercalated chromium hydroxyl species which has been caused by the incomplete pillaring of the clay, to the insufficient swelling of the host material and to the presence of large Cr (III) oligomers that are adsorbed in the surface, blocking pores, thus hindering intercalation [16].
Fig.1. XRD diagrams of crude, purified and chromium pillared clays Textural Properties
Nitrogen Adsorption
The great importance of textural properties of chromium pillared clays are proved by the amount of published literature related to BET surface area and pore size structure characterizations data .
The BET surface areas, the micro pore and the total pore volumes for all pillared clays are presented in table 2. It can be seen that with increasing of Cr3+ cation content the surface area, pore and micro pore volumes increased. The highest surface areas and the most micro pores values have been obtained with pillared clays synthesized using nitrate as anion in the intercalating solution. C .Volzone and co-workers have reported a specific area increase of smectite of about 175 m2/g after treatment with OH-Cr solution.
The N2 adsorption-desorption isotherms of different samples are represented in figure 2. It can be noticed that Cr-pillared smectites showed the same shape as the starting material which correspond to H3 type in the IUPAC classification [23]. This hysteresis type corresponds to a system formed by slit-shaped pores having a vertical adsorption branch at a relative pressure close to unity and a desorption branch close to medium pressure. Furthermore the Fig 2 shows that the nitrogen isotherms of Cr(III) intercalated species clay is
of type I in the BDDT classification [24] being characteristic of micro porous solids. In the same way, Mikhail Sychev [25] showed a N2 adsorption isotherm for the chromia-pillared clay of type I.
Table 2. Textural characteristics of chromium pillared clay
Chromium pillared clay SBET (m2g-1) VW (cm3/g) Vp (cm3/g)
Clay purified 100 0.0125 0.18
Chlorite (Cl) anion
20 103.85 0.0165 0.32
40 174.6 0.0226 0.388
60 176.9 0.0531 0.298
Nitrate ( NO3) anion
20 183 0.0562 0.25
40 194.3 0.057 0.28
60 198.1 0.0617 0.21
Adsorption-de sorption isotherms of Chlorite Cr-PILCS
Fig. 2. Isotherms obtained for chromium pillared clays
Thermal stabilities
Differential thermal analysis was used to investigate the thermal stability of pillared clays. As shown in the figure 3 and table 3, for pillared clays, the first endothermic peak in all cases are localised at 42°C-250°C exhibiting a continuous weight loss of about 7-10 wt % which can be attributed to the loss of water. At the same temperature range a shallow endothermic event takes place, which may be possibly related to a rearrangement of the silicate network caused by the water release. Moreover, several other thermal events
occur at the pillared clays. For the peak at about 250°C it can be stated that, perhaps, they indicate the presence of different kinds of structural water such as water combined to chromium pillars, axial and equatorial. Other researchers treated this technique on decked chromium pillared clay prepared by various methods for examples chromia-pillared clay has been synthesized from naturally occurring montmorillonite through exchange of interlamellar ions with hydroxychromium polycations exhibits a continuous weight loss of about 24 wt % between 323 and 698K can be attributed to the removal of interlayer water and water coordinated to the hydroxychromium oligomers [25]. A second endothermic peak is observed for temperatures ranged from 250 to 350 °C corresponding to a weight loss of about 5 wt % and can be attributed to the partial oxidation of chromium species and partial collapse of pillars in the clay. Interestingly this peak is observed in natural clay at about 500°C. These results indicated that the pillar structure ameliorates the thermal stability of the clay. In the same way, Sychev proved that the material exhibits a less pronounced and broad weight loss about 3 wt % between 698 and 923 K which most probably reflects the dehydroxylation of pillars [25]. Roula concluded too, after preparation from the samples by different methods that clay pillared with Cr (III) oligomers using the BAR and BA methods as well as clays pillared with Cr (III) monomeric solution were heated at various temperatures under nitrogen, It seems that the first thermal event to occur, in all cases, is the loss of bulk (interlayer) water, which is the most loosely bound, as indicated by the intense non reversible endo-thermic peak at 373K [18]. On heating under nitrogen the above peak is shifted to about 423K and this has also been observed by Tzou and Pinnavaia [14].
T emp erature, ° C
20 meq (Chlorite)
T emp erature,0 C 0 2G0 400 600
S00 1000
40 meq (Chlorite) Temperature, °C 0 200 400
Ö0G 8Q0
T emp erature, ° C 0 200 400
600
800
-IS
20 meq (Nitrate) T emp erature,0 C
£
O
E
ri
QJ
X
Temperature, °C
O
H
T e mp erature, ° C
Fig. 3.D.t.a. profiles of chromium pillared clays
Temperature 0 = 42-250°C 0 = 250-350°C 0 = 350-550°C
Purified clay (Hp) Weight loss (%) 8.08 4.12
Nitrate anion
Hp 20 (Ni) Weight loss (%) 8.93 0.83 4.967
Hp 40 (Ni) Weight loss (%) 7.562 0.914 5.545
Hp 60 (Ni) Weight loss (%) 9.009 1.465 6.03
Chlorite anion
Hp 20 (Cl) Weight loss (%) 7.98 0.636 5.09
Hp 40 (Cl) Weight loss (%) 9.23 1.27 5.21
Hp 60 (Cl) Weight loss (%) 9.33 1.65 5.367
b
Fig. 4.The TEM micrograph of unpillared clays and chromium pillared clays
Scanning electron microscopy
The untreated clay exhibits a distinctively lamellar structure, as the silicate leaves pack after drying (Fig.4,a). The clay also exhibits lamellar structure into the particles.
In the other hand pillaring of the smectite causes significant disordering of the stacking structure making the interparticle voids smaller (Fig. 4b).
Due to the insertion of the Cr (III) oligomers, in pillared clays produced, the face-to-face stacking structure of the clay (Fig. 4b) is destroyed and a more sponge-like texture appears showing that edge-to-face and edge-to-edge interactions have been developed causing that disordering. These findings are consistent with the broadening of the peaks in the XRD patterns and the decrease of the intensity because of the weakness of scattering along the z-axis, observed during pillaring.
The prepared intercalated clays still retain a lamellar structure as indicated in (Fig.4b).
Conclusion
Chromium pillared clays are prepared by incorporating Cr (III) oligomeric into the interlamellar space of smectite. Pillaring solution was prepared by addition of Na2CO3 to a chromium chlorite solution or chromium nitrate with different concentration.
XRD diffractograms and chemical analysis proved that clays intercalated with Cr (III) oligomers prepared from nitrate intercalating solution presented with a concentration of 60meq /g present the most important gallery height (21.13 Á).
BET surface and micropore analysis demonstrated that the texture of the smectite clay is mostly changed during pillaring. In fact, these pillared clays presented increased BET surface and higher micropore volume. The microporosity is attributed to the Cr oligomers in the interlamellar space and increases with the gallery height.
All Cr-pillared materials are more stable than natural clay (up to 550°C).
REFERENCES
[1]. Urabe K., Sakurai H., Izumi Y. J.Chem.Soc. Chem.Commun. (1986) 1074.
[2]. OccelliM.L. J.Mol.Catal. 35(1986)377.
[3]. Lin J.T., Jong S.J., Cheng S. Microporous Mater. 1(4) (1993) 287.
[4]. Doff D.H., Gangas N.H.J., Allan J.E.M., Coey J.M.D. Clay Miner. , 23(1988) 367.
[5]. Volzone C., CesiioM., Torres Sanchez R.M., Pereirra E. Clays Clay Miner., 41(1993)702.
[6]. Drljaca A., Aderson J.R., Spiccia L., Turney T.W. Inorg.Chim.Acta, 254(1997)219.
[7]. Storaro L., Ganzerla R., Lenarda M., Zanoni R., Lopez A.H., Olivera-pastor P., Castellon E.R. J. Mol. Catal. A 115 (1997)329.
[8]. Ballantine J.A., Davies M., O’Neil R. M., Patel I., Purnell J. H., Rayanakorn M., Williams K. J. J. Mol. Catal. 26(1984)57.
[9]. Ballantine J. A., Purnell J. H., Thomas J. M. Clay Miner. 18 (1983) 347.
[10]. Bradley, M., Kydd, R.A. 1993. Ga13, Al13, GaAl12, and chromium pillared montmorillonites: acidity and reactivity for cumene conversion. Journal of Catalysis 141, 239.
[11]. Jagtap, N., Ramaswamy, V. 2006. Oxidation of aniline over titania pillared montmorillonite bentonites. Applied Bentonite Science 33, 89-98.
[12]. Oliveira L.C.A., Lago R.M., Fabris J.D., Solar C., Sapag K. 2003. Transition metals supported on al-pilcs as catalysts for C6H5Cl oxidation. Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering 20, 45-50
[13]. Sterte, J. 1988. Hydrothermal treatment of hydroxycation precursor solutions. Catalysis Today 2, 219-231.
[14]. TzouM. S. Pinnavaia, Catal. Today 2 (1988) 243.
[15]. Pinnavaia T.J., Tzou M.S., Landau S.D. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 107 (1985) 4783.
[16]. SychevM.V., De Beer V.H.J., Van Santen R.A. Micropor. Mater. 8 (1997) 255.
[17]. Arfaouia S., Srasra E., Frini-Srasra N. Application of clays to treatment of tannery sewages Desalination 185 (2005) 419-426S. Arfaoui et al. / Desalination 185 (2005) 419-426.
[18]. Roulia M. Synthesis and characterization of novel chromium pillared clays, Materials Chemistry and Physics 91 (2005) 281-288.
[19]. Volzone C. Pillaring of different smectite members by chromium species (Cr-PILCS); microporous and mesoporous .materials 49(2001)197-202.
[20]. Volzone C., Cesiio A.M., Torres R.M. Sanchez and E.Pereirra, Clays Clay Miner.,41(1993)702.
[21]. Pinnavaia T.J., Tzou M.S., Landau S.D. J.Am.Chem.Soc.,107(1985)4783.
[22]. Drljaca A., Anderson J.R., Spiccia L., Turney T.W. Inorg.Chem., 31(1992)4894.
[23]. Gregg, S. J., Sing, K. S.W. “Adsorption, Surface Area and Porosity,” 2nd ed. Academic Press. London, 1982.
[24]. Brunauer, S., Deming, L. S., Deming, W. S., Teller E. J. Am.Chem. Soc. 62, 1723 (1940).
[25]. Mikhail Sychev, V. H. J. (San) de Beery Alexander Kodentsov,y Eugene M. van Oers,y and Rutger A. van Santeny, Chromia- and Chromium Sulfide-Pillared Clays: Preparation,Characterization, and Catalytic Activity for Thiophene Hydrodesulfurization journal of catalysis 168, 245-254(1997) article NO.CA971618.
Received 25.02.09
Summary
Chromium pillared clays, in particular, have attracted the researchers attention after being tested as catalyst in a wide range of reactions, like catalytic conversion of hydrocarbons, ester formation and elimination of water from alcohols. The chromium oligomers used for intercalation were prepared by addition of Na2CO3 to a chromium nitrate solution or chromium chlorite solution and the mixture is heated at 80°C for 36h.The pillaring clay is obtained by heating intercalated bentonite at 360°C under vacuum. Several Techniques, X-ray diffraction, N2 adsorption-desorption isotherms and chemical analysis have been used to characterize and to compare the properties of the materials synthesized. Our study consists in determination of the influence of the intercalated OH-Cr group on the structure of Tunisian bentonite. The results showed that the interlamellar distances of pillared bentonite ranged from 17 to 21A. In addition, the synthesized clays exhibit increased BET surface areas and higher micro pore volumes compared with unmodified clay. On the other hand, the micro pore surface area, the micro pore volume and the d (001) spacing after pillaring increased with the amount of chromium retentions.
