CC BY
62
UDC 616-022:616.983-08
SUSTAINABLE THERAPY OF UROGENITAL CHLAMYDIOSIS
Irkutsk State Medical University, Irkutsk Regional dermatovenerologic dispensary, Irkutsk
I.O. Malova, I.A. Sidorova
There is presented the comparative characteristic of 2 methods of treatment of urogenital chlamydiosis in women of reproductive age: doxycycline monohydrate monotherapy and combination of doxycycline monohydrate with interferon inducer Meglumini acridonacetas. In 2 groups of comparison there was performed the analysis of indicators of neutrophils functional activity (phagocytic index, phagocytic number, NBT-test - spontaneous and induced) and also the rate of T-lymphocytes producing gamma interferon in the total pool of T-lymphocytes in peripheral blood and concentration of gamma interferon in the blood serum during treatment. Key words: urogenital chlamydiosis, neutrophils functional activity, T-lymphocytes, gamma interferon, doxycycline, Meglumini acridonacetas.
Urogenital chlamydial infection is one of the most spread sexually transmitted infections [20, 21]. According the World Health Organization (WHO), in the world there are annually registered about 100 mln new cases [23, 24].
Chlamydial infection (CI) is widely spread among persons of reproductive age, while young age in women is one of the basic factors of infection risk. Due to cylindrical epithelium tropism, C. trachomatis effects urogenital organs and presents one of the important reasons of reproductive function disorder.
Inflammation by urogenital chlamydiosis (UGC) often lacks symptoms. The absence of timely diagnosis and, consequently, therapy leads to the development of complications in women - such as inflammatory diseases of pelvic organs (POID), extra-uterine pregnancy and tubal infertility. A special problem are the cases of CI persistence, when POID proceed without symptoms of inflammation [9, 23].
Basic factors of non-specific antimicrobial protection of organism are phagocytosis and complement system. Chlamydia can persist in phagocytes (neutrophils and macrophages). In patients with chronic CI there was registered the reduction of digestive function of peripheral blood neutrophils [2].
The influence of chlamydia suppresses not only phagocytic system, but also T-cell segment. Patients with urogenital chlamydiosis showed the decrease of total T-lymphocytes (CD3+) in peripheral blood with the disorder of their functional activity [7].
The activator of macrophages is y-interferon (y-IF), which is mainly produced by T-lymphocytes. Low concentration of y-IF is the main condition for persistence development [4]. The factors of persistent chlamydial infection are also sub-therapeutic doses of antibiotics and treatment with drugs of low chlamydia activity [17].
It is known, that high doses of y-IF inhibit growth of chlamydia. Low doses, on the contrary,
induce the development of morphologically aberrant forms of inclusions [8].
Sufficient production of y-IF leads to the suppression of C. trachomatis growth due to the induction of intracellular enzyme - 2,3-dioxygenase indolamine destroying tryptophan, which is necessary for chlamydia reproduction. As a result, this mechanism leads to the disorder of cell wall synthesis. Moreover, y-IF boosts the activity of nitrogen oxide forming synthase in macrophages and epithelial cells, which results in releasing of nitrogen and bactericidal effect [12, 14].
For many years, clinicians have been widely using various combinations of etiotropic drugs with immunotropic agents in order to increase the efficiency of CI therapy [2, 3, 18, 19].
It is known, that y-IF stimulates the functional activity of macrophages due to the intensification of digestive ability of phagocytising cells, complete process of phagocytosis and lytic decomposition of chlamydia. Consequently, the level of y-IF is one of the key components determining the type of infectious process [4].
Interferon inducers are drugs causing the formation of endogenous interferon. They lead to the synthesis of the genuine interferon, which, in contradiction to most widely used recombinant IF, lacks antigenicity. Medications of this group are able to stimulate immune reactivity of organism increasing phagocytosis and antibody production [10].
According to immunologists, intervention into the immune system is possible only in case of correspondent indications, specifically, in case of immune deficiency. Thus, the prescription of such drugs is rational only after additional immunolog-ical tests. There is still no consensus on the rationality of combination of etiotropic drugs with im-munotropic agents by urogenital chlamydiosis [1].
Research objective: to perform comparative analysis of the results of urogenital chlamydiosis treatment and dynamics of particular immuno-
logical indexes in two groups of patients: exposed to doxycycline monohydrate monotherapy (DM) and combination therapy with doxycycline monohydrate with interferon inducer Meglumini acrid-onacetas (MA).
Materials and methods
The study included 60 women with urogenital chlamydiosis. The diagnosis was based on clinical data confirmed by PCR method.
Other urogenital infections (UGI) were revealed by means of microscopic, cultural and molecular-biological (PCR) methods. Patients with trichomonas and gonococcal infection and also pregnant women were not included into the study.
The disease prescription constituted: up to 2 months - in 14 (23,3%) patients, from 2 to 6 months - in 19 (31,7%) patients, from 6 months to 1 year -in 16 (26,7%), over 1 year - in 11(18,3%) patients.
The age of patients varied within the range of 18-46 years, there prevailed the group of patients at the age of 21-3o years, the average age of patients constituted 25,4±7,2 years.
Depending on the therapy type, the women were divided into 2 groups. Patients of the first group (DM) received doxycycline monohydrate monotherapy (Unidox Solutab) in the dose 100 mg 2 times a day during 7 days. Patients of the second group (DM+MA) received cycloferon in the dose of 2 ml intravenously 10 times during the course together with doxycycline monohydrate in analogous daily doses.
Doxycycline monohydrate is a broad-spectrum antibiotic. It inhibits synthesis of proteins in the microbial cell breaking the connection of aminoacyl-t-RNA with 30S subunit of ribosom-al membrane. It is recommended by the treatment of urogenital chlamydial infection as the drug of choice [5, 6, 22].
Meglumini acridonacetas (Cycloferon) - a 12,5% solution for injections) is a low-molecular interferon inducer with the broad spectrum of biological activity (antiviral, immunomodulatory, anti-inflammatory, etc.). According to the medication instructions, the drug can be used by UGC treatment [10, 16].
The clinical-laboratory control of recovery was performed in 4 weeks after the end of treatment.
The blood sampling in patients for immuno-logical examinations was conducted three times: before treatment, after the course of antibiotics and also upon the control of recovery in 4 weeks.
The phagocytic activity of neutrophils were determined according to their ability to grasp latex particles by counting the rate of active phagocytes (phagocytic index - PI) and average number of bacteria absorbed by one phagocyte (phagocytic number - PN). The metabolic activity of leucocytes was studied by NBT-test - spontaneous and induced [11, 15].
The rate of T-lymphocytes producing gamma interferon in the total pool of T-lymphocytes (CD-3) (Tl-IF) was determined by means of flow cytometry with cytofluorometer Beckman coulter cytomics FC 500 with the automatic hematological analyzer Sysmex XT 2000i (Roche, Switeerland). The y-IF concentration in blood serum was determined by means of EIA with the immunoenzymo-metric kit for quantitative determination of human y-IF in blood serum (Bender Med Systems CmbH, Austria).
Analogous studies were performed in the control group - 30 practically healthy women of reproductive age (average age - 25,8 years).
The research was approved by the Ethics Committee of ISMU, all patients were previously informed about the examination, diagnosis, treatment and confirmed their participation in the study by voluntary written consent.
The statistical processing of obtained results was conducted by means of STATISTICA 6.1. The statistical analysis included Mann-Whitney test. Considering the small size of groups, the average means and standard deviation are presented only for better understanding of obtained results. Differences between compared values were considered statistically significant by p<0,05 [13].
Results and discussion
Monochlamydeous infection was registered in 18 (30%) patients, in 42 (70%) patients, C.tracho-matis was combined with other infectious agents: with U. urealiticum - in 25 (41,7%), with M. genitali-um - in 5 (8,3%), with M. hominis - in 18 (30%), with HPV- in 15 (25%), with Candida fungi - in 7 (11,7%), with Herpes simplex - in 4 (6,7%). Clue cells were observed in 10 (16?7%) patients.
The disease duration constituted: up to 2 months - in 14 (23,3%) patients, from to 2 to 6 months - in 19 (31,7%), from 6 months to 1 years -in 16 (26,7%), over 1 year - in 11 (18,3%).
The anamnesis of 1 (1,7%) patient included cystic ovaries, of 2 (3,3%) - frequent cystitis, of 1 - chronic pyelonephritis. Among the examined women, 5 (8,3%) had irregular menstrual cycle, 4 (6,7%) complained about painful menstruations, 5 - about excessive menstruationro
The anamnesis of 36 (60%) women included pregnancy, of 35 )58,3%) - delivery, of 5 (8,3%) -miscarriage, in 1 patients there was previously registered missed miscarriage.
Out of 60 patients, 35 (58,3%) presented problems of vaginal discharge, 12 (20%) - of itching, 14 (23,3%) - discomfort in the area of external sex organs. Painful urination was registered in 2 (3,3%) women, lower abdominal pains - in 11 (18,3%), dyspareunia - in 3 (5%) patients.
The examination revealed signs of cervicitis in 56 (93,3%) patients. A typical symptom was cervical discharge, primarily mucoid - in 55 (91,7%).
In 1 (13,3%) patients there was observed purumuc-uos cervical discharge caused by concomitant infection with M. genitalium and aerobic potentially pathogenic microbiota - Staphylococcus spp., Streptococcus spp. in high titer (>105 CFU\ml).
In four patients by the lack of clinical symptoms of inflammation, there was revealed C.trachomatis DNA in the cervical canal.
By microscopic examination of cervical canal discharge, the leukocytic reaction constituted: in 36 (60%) patients - up to 20 cells per field of view, in 17 (28,3%) - from 20 to 40, in 7 (11,7%) - 41-50.
Symptoms of urethritis (hyperemia, urethral sponge edema and mucous discharge) were revealed in 2 women, there was revealed C.tracho-
matis DNA in their urethral material and increase of leucocytes up to 25-30 per field of view.
The analysis of functional activity of peripheral blood neutrophils in comparison with the women with UGC showed the reduction of neutro-phil ability to absorb foreign substances (PI), PN before treatment was also low. In the DM group, the spontaneous NBT-test was insignificantly increased, while in the group DM+MA, on the contrary, it had the tendency to decrease, the induced NBT in both groups before treatment was lowered. This indicates low absorbing and metabolic activity of the phagocytic system, h.e. low phagocytic response to the infection (Table 1).
Table 1
Indexes of functional activity of peripheral blood neutrophils in women with urogenital chlamydiosis during doxycycline monohydrate monotherapy and combination of doxycycline monohydrate with Meglumini acridonacetas
Groups PI (%) PN spontaneous NBT (%) induced NBT (%)
Control group (n=30) 64,87±7,29 5,30±1,83 37,3±6,27 51,0±6,26
DM group before 57,73±10,77 4,87±2,10 37,87±6,43 47,23±6,65
treatment (n=30) p=0,005 p=0,237 p=0,756 p=0,049
DM group after 57,63±9,91 4,97±2,09 39,96±7,71 49,47±8,51
treatment (n=30) Pj=0,836 P^0,952 Pj =0,214 Pj=0,201
DM+MA group before treatment (n=30) 54,87±12,62 5,20±2,14 35,03±5,97 43,30±6,15
p=0,001 p=0,506 p=0,156 p=0,00005
DM+MA group after treatment (n=30) 53,27±12,44 5,23±1,70 35,13±6,11 43,27±6,83
Pj=0,668 Pj=0,756 Pj =0,941 Pj=0,976
Note: p - level of statistical significance by comparison of indexes before treatment with the control group; Pj - level of statistical significance by comparison of indexes before treatment and after treatment.
After the treatment in the group of patients receiving doxycycline monohydrate monotherapy, the rate of neutrophils got into phagocytosis remained practically the on the same level (Table 1), other indexes of functional activity of neutrophils insignificantly increased: PN - by 1,02 times, spontaneous NBT - by 1,06 times, induced NBT -by 1,05 times.
In the group of patients receiving doxycycline monohydrate with Meglumini acridonace-tas, the change of indexes of functional activity of neutrophils after the treatment was identical: PN, spontaneous and induced NBT-test remained practically on the previous level, while PI even slightly decreased (by 1,03 times).
In the general group of patients the rates of Tl-IF in the common pool of T-l and the level of y-IF in blood serum did not differ significantly from the analogous indexes in the group of healthy people. In this regard, patients were divided into 3 subgroups: 1 subgroup - the level of Tl-IF and y-IF is increased, 2 subgroup - the level of Tl-IF and y-IF
is normal, 3 subgroup - the level of Tl-IF and y-IF is is decreased (Table 2).
The analysis of studied parameters in the group of patients receiving doxycycline monohydrate monotherapy showed, that in the 2nd subgroup of patients, both indexes after the treatment and upon control of recovery practically did not change. In the 1st subgroup of patients both indexes increased before the treatment decreased after the treatment up to normal values and remained this level upon control of recovery. In the 3-rd subgroup of patient, both indexes after the treatment and upon control of recovery remained practically on the same level (Table 2).
The analysis of studied parameters in the group of patients receiving doxycycline monohydrate with Meglumini acridonacetas showed, that in the 2nd subgroup, both indexes after the treatment and upon control of recovery practically did not change staying normal. In the 1st subgroup, there was registered slight increase of Tl-IF rate and y-IF level after the treatment and further re-
duction upon control of recovery, while in comparison with the control group, the studied indexes remained high. In the 3rd subgroup there was registered the increase of Tl-IF rate and y-IF level after the treatment and upon control of recovery. The difference of the degree of index increase is the following: the rate of T-lymphocytes pro-
ducing y-IF grew y 1,96 times after the treatment and by 3,34 times in 4 weeks after the end of treatment. However, in spite of the positive dynamics in terms of Tl-IF, the level of y-IF in blood serum increased by only 1,3 times after the treatment and by 1,5 times upon control of recovery (Table 3).
Table 2
Rate of Tl-IF and level of y-IF in peripheral blood of UGC patients during doxycycline monohydrate monotherapy
Indexes Control General group of UGC patients Subgroup 1 Subgroup 2 Subgroup 3
(n=30) (n=30) (n=12) (n=7) (n=11)
Tl-IF (%) 4,46±3,53 p=0,574 8,03±2,43 3,32±1,51 1,29±1,09
before treatment 4,34±1,94 p=0,01 p^0,0006 p=0,278 Pj=1,000 p=0,00003 Pj=0,818
Tl-IF (%) 4,51±0,88 3,33±1,32 1,31±1,30
after treatment p2=0,248 p2=0,949 p2 =0,006
Tl-IF (%) upon control of recovery 4,21±0,88 p3=0,003 3,47±1,12 p3=0,848 1,30±1,12 p3=0,002
(n=11) (n=7) (n=12)
Y-IF (pg/ml) 2,81±0,89 p=0,631 3,79±0,48 2,68±0,12 1,98±0,39
before treatment 2,67±0,47 p=0,00001 Pj=0,0007 p=0,713 Pj=0,749 p=0,0008 Pj=0,194
Y-IF (pg/ml) 2,73±0,53 2,62±0,36 2,01±0,50
after treatment p2=0,555 p2=0,848 p2=0,100
Y-IF (pg/ml) upon control of recovery 2,85±0,56 p3=0,001 2,61±0,32 P3=0,701 2,03±0,35 p3=0,004
Note: p - level of statistical significance by comparison of indexes before treatment with the control group; Pj _ - level of statistical significance by comparison of indexes before treatment and after treatment; p2 - level of statistical significance by comparison of indexes after treatment and upon control of recovery; p3 _ level of statistical significance by comparison of indexes before treatment and upon control of recovery.
By the clinical-laboratory control of recovery, the C. trachomatis elimination constituted: by doxycycline monohydrate monotherapy - 100%, by combined therapy - 96,7%. In 1 patient receiving combined therapy, upon control of recovery in 4 weeks after the end of therapy by the lack of clinical inflammatory symptoms there was revealed C.tra-chomatis DNA in the cervical canal by leukocytosis 15-20 cells per field of view. Upon the examination of patient in 2 weeks, the clinical-laboratory picture remained the same. It should be noted, that before the treatment, in patient, there was registered asymptomatic chlamydial infection of cervical canal by analogous leukocytosis. The level of y-IF in blood serum was reduced to 1,34 pg/ ml by the Tl-IF rate reduced to 0,98% in the common pool of T-lymphocytes. In 2 days after the end of treatment, these indexes slightly (and insignificantly) increased up to 1,38 and 1,0% respectively, remaining practically on the same level in the beginning of the 5th week after the treatment upon control of recovery.
After the treatment, the microscopy of urogenital discharge showed the absence of leukocytosis in the cervical canal, urethra and urine in 59 women out of 60.
The comparative analysis of the results of im-munological study in the most problematic group of patients - with lowered parameters before the treatment - showed, that the addition of Me-glumini acridonacetas to doxycycline monohydrate generally leads to the growth of % concentration of T-lymphocytes producing y-IF and increase of its level in blood serum. However, the etiological and clinical efficiency of doxycycline monohydrate monotherapy in combination with the immuno-tropic drug in these groups of patients turned out to be nearly identical: by doxycycline monohydrate monotherapy - 100%, by combined therapy - 91,7% (in 11 out of 12 patients).
Table 3
Tl-IF rate and y-IF level in peripheral blood of UGC patients during combined tretamnet with doxycycline
monohydrate with Meglumini acridonacetas
Indexes
Tl-IF (%) before treatment
Tl-IF (%) after treatment
Tl-IF (%) upon control of recovery
Y-IF (pg/ml) before treatment
Y-IF (pg/ml) after treatment
Y-IF (pg/ml) upon control of recovery
Control (n=30)
4,34±1,94
2,67±0,47
General group of UGC patients
(n=30)
4,80±4,45 р=0,751
2,73 ± 0,93 р=0,515
Subgroup 1 Subgroup 2
(n=12)
7,84±5,02 р=0,034 р1 =0,525
8,45±5,17 р2=0,237
5,63±2,01 Р3=0,453
(n=10)
3,85±0,43
р=0,00002
р1=0,650
3,95±0,48 р2=0,002
2,99±0,41 р3=0,001
(n=7)
4,92±2,51 р=0,616 р1=0,753
4,76±1,0 Р2=0,141
5,54±0,77 Р3=0,294
(n=8) 2,59±0,10 р=0,720 р1=0,002
2,76±0,17 р2=0,753
2,79±0,15 р3=0,012
Subgroup 3
(n=11) 1,07±0,65 р=0,00003 р1=0,009
2,10±0,93 Р2=0,010
3,57±1,05 Р3=0,0002
(n=12)
1,88±0,40 р=0,00004 р1 =0,004
2,44±0,37 р2=0,013
2,81±0,33 р3 = 0,0001
Note: p - level of statistical significance by comparison of indexes before treatment with the control group; Pj - level of statistical significance by comparison of indexes before treatment and after treatment; p2 - level of statistical significance by comparison of indexes after treatment and upon control of recovery; p3 level of statistical significance by comparison of indexes before treatment and upon control of recovery.
Conclusion
Consequently, the results of the current study allow to conclude, that the main chain in the treatment is the etiotropic therapy. In our research, the interferon inducer did not have the expected effective influence on the system of phagocytosis and cytokine segment and did not increase the etiological efficiency of treatment. Moreover, the implementation of this drug significantly increased the duration of therapy and unreasonably increased its price.
References
1. Akovyann V.A. Urogenital chlamydial infection: 25 years later. Gynecology. 2004; 6(2): 14-22.
2. Allenov S.N., Ivanov O.L., Lomonosov K.M. et al. Immunological aspects of the use of polyoxidonium in the complex therapy of complicated urogenital chlamydiosis. Russian Journal of Skin and Venereal Diseases. 2002; 2: 58-61.
3. Barinov A.N., Plavinsky S.L. Use of immune response modulators by urogenital chlamydial infection. Mathematical modeling of the epidemic process of morbidity with urogenital chlamydia. Vestnik dermatologii i venerologii. 2010; 2: 96-100.
4. Batyrshina S.V., Simbirtsev A.S., Yunuso-va Ye.I. Principles and technologies of treatment of patients with sexually transmitted infections. Treatment
of patients with urogenital chlamydia: Advanced medical technologies. 2006.
5. Kubanovoi A.A. Management of patients with sexually transmitted infections and urogenital infections (clinical recommendations). 2012.
6. Vorobyova N.V., Shipitsina Ye.V., Sokolovsky Ye.V., Savicheva A.M. Dynamics of detection of Chlamydia trachomatis by the treatment of urogenital chlamydial infection with doxycy-cline (Unidox Solutab). Difficult patient. 2006; 5(4): 31-33.
7. Galdava G. Some indices of cellular immunity by urogenital chlamydia. Theses of scientific works of the IX All-Russian Congress of Dermatoven-erologists. 2005; 2: 72.
8. Glazkova L.K. Practical aspects of persistent chlamydial infection. Venereologist. 2005; 2: 4-12.
9. Гинекология. Gomberg M.A. Reproductive health and infections caused by Chlamydia trachomatis. Gynecology. 2011; 1(13): 13-17.
10. Granitov V.M. Chlamydia. Medical book. 2000; 192.
11. Козлов B.A., Борисов А.Г., Смирнов C.B., Савченко A.A. Практические аспекты диагностики и лечения иммунных нарушений: руководство для врачей. Новосибирск: Наука, 2009. - 274 с.
12. Mavrov G.I., Chinov G.P. The role of cytokines in the pathogenesis of chlamydia. Ukrainian Journal of Dermatology, Venereology and Cosmetology. 2004; 1: 53-59.
13. Maksikova T.M., Kalyagin A.N., Piven D.V. The effectiveness of the use of dihydroquer-cetin in persons engaged in health groups. Siberian Medical Journal. 2011; 6: 127-130.
14. Plakhova K.I., Volkov I.A., Khayrullin R.F. et al. Methodology of studying molecular markers of individual genetic risk of complications of urogenital chlamydial infection. Bulletin of dermatology and venereology. 2011; 6: 41-48.
15. Potemkina Ye.Ye., Pozdnyakova R.Z., Ma-nukyan L.M. Manual for laboratory clinical immunology. Moscow: RUDN, 2003.
16. Vyshkovsky G.L., ed. Register of medicines of Russia: Encyclopedia of medicines. 16th issue. M.: RLS; 2008, 2007.
17. Ryumin D.V. Persistent chlamydial infection. Bulletin of postgraduate medical education. 2000; 2: 8-15.
18. Sidorova I.S., Aleshkin V.A., Afanasyev S.S. Efficience of complex therapy of urogenital chlamydiosis with the use of immunocorrecting drugs. Obstetrics and gynecology. 2002; 4: 38-41.
19. Yanova L.V. Immunomodulatory therapy in the complex treatment of urogenital chlamydiosis in women. [Synopsis of dissertation]. St. Petersburg, 2008.
20. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Sexually Transmitted Diseases Treatment Guidelines. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR) 2010; 12: 1-114.
21. Haggerty C. L., Gottlieb S. L., Taylor B. D., Low N., Xu F, and Ness R. B. Risk of sequelae after Chlamydia trachomatis genital infection in women. Journal of Infectious Diseases.2010; 2: 134-155.
22. Lau C.Y., Qureshi A.K. Azithromycin versus doxycycline for genital chlamydial infections: a meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. Sex. Transm. Dis. 2002; 29(9): 497-502.
23. No authors listed. CDC Grand Rounds: Chlamydia. MMWR Morbib. Mortal. Wkly Rep. 2011; 60(12): 370-373.
24. WHO. Prevention and control of sexually transmitted infections: draft global strategy, 2006. Available from: http://www.who.int/reproduc-tive-health/docs/stis_strategy.pdf.
Contacts:
Corresponding author: Malova Irina Olegov-na, Doctor of Medical Sciences, Professor, Head of the Department of Dermatovenerology of ATF and TS of Irkutsk State Medical University, Irkutsk. 664025, Irkutsk, ul. Rossiyskaya, 16. Tel.: (3952) 24-23-13. E-mail: [email protected]
