CC BY
35
СТРОИТЕЛЬСТВО СIVIL AND INDUSTRIAL ENGINEERING
DOI: 10.21122/2227-1031-2017-16-2-93-103 UDC 691.32:539.3/4.001.57
Structural Modification of New Formations
in Cement Matrix Using Carbon Nanotube Dispersions and Nanosilica
B. M. Khroustalev4, S. N. Leonovich1), G. I. Yakovlev2), I. S. Polianskich2), O. Lahayne3), J. Eberhardsteiner3), G. Skripkiunas4), I. A. Pudov2), E. A. Karpova2)
1)Belarusian National Technical University (Minsk, Republic of Belarus),
2)Kalashnikov Izhevsk State Technical University (Izhevsk, Russian Federation),
3)Vienna University of Technology (Vienna, Austria),
4)Vilnius Gediminas Technical University (Vilnius, Lithuania)
© Белорусский национальный технический университет, 2017 Belarusian National Technical University, 2017
Abstract. Complex nanodispersed systems with multi-walled carbon nanotubes and nanodispersed silica have a significant impact on the processes of hydration, hardening and strength gain of construction composites predetermining their durability. While using a scanning electron microscope with an attachment for X-ray microanalysis and a device for infrared spectral analysis investigations have shown that the main effect of the cement matrix modification in the case of adding complex nanodispersed systems is provided by direct influence of hydration processes with subsequent crystallization of new formations. It has been noted that while adding carbon nanotube dispersion and nanosized silica a binding matrix is structured in the form of an extremely dense shell from crystalline hydrate new formations on the surface of solid phases that provides strong binding matrix in cement concrete. The addition effect of carbon nanotubes has been analyzed and quantitatively assessed through an investigation for every case of one sample with nanotubes and one sample without them with the help of a nanoindenter and scanning electron microscope. It is necessary to solve rather complicated challenging task in order to assess quantitatively the addition effect of CNT on material characteristics at a micromechanical level. At the same time it is possible to investigate surface of a concrete sample with one-micron resolution. In this case it is necessary to prepare samples for nanoindentation with exclusion of all CNT defectable effects that have been shown by a SEM. So in this case more adequate method for assessment must be a picoindenter , which combines a test method for nanoindentation with an optical SEM potential. Such equipment is in the stage of in-situ testing process at the Vienna University of Technology. The investigation is based on the fact that the main modification effect of mineral binding matrix while using incorporated complex nanodis-persed systems and nanosilica is ensured by a direct influence of hydration processes and subsequent crystallization of new formations. Scanning electron microscopy and X-ray microanalysis with detection in IR spectra have revealed that adding of multi-walled carbon nanotubes dispersion together with nanodispersed silica provides structuring of rather dense shell of hydrated new formations along cement matrix on the surface of solid phase. The structured interfacial layers form separate cells in the modified cement matrix that ensures a formation of extremely filled system and predetermines structural strengthening of the modified cement matrix due to formation of spatial packaging. Consequently, the main factor increasing characteristics of cement concrete which is modified with carbon nanotubes and nanosilica is a structural modification of calcium hydrosilicates with relation to composition and morphology of new formations.
Keywords: nanodispersed system, multi-walled carbon nanotubes, nanosilica, scanning electron microscope, Х-ray micro-analysis, hydration, cement concrete
For citation: Khroustalev B. M., Leonovich S. N., Yakovlev G. I., Polianskich I. S., Lahayne O., Eberhardsteiner J., Skripkiu-nas G., Pudov I. A., Karpova E. A. (2017) Structural Modification of New Formations in Cement Matrix Using Carbon Nanotube Dispersions and Nanosilica. Science and Technique. 16 (2), 93-103. DOI: 10.21122/2227-1031-2017-16-2-93-103
Адрес для переписки
Хрусталев Борис Михайлович
Белорусский национальный технический университет
просп. Независимости, 65,
220013, г. Минск, Республика Беларусь
Тел.: +375 17 292-77-52
rector@bntu.by
Address for correspondence
Khroustalev Boris M.
Belаrusian National Technical University
65 Nezavisimosty Ave.,
220013, Minsk, Republic of Belarus
Tel.: +375 17 292-77-52
rector@bntu.by
Наука
иТ ехника. Т. 16, № 2 (2017)
Структурная модификация новообразований в цементной матрице с использованием дисперсии углеродных нанотрубок и нанокремнезема
Акад. НАН Беларуси, докт. техн. наук, проф. Б. М. Хрусталев1), доктора техн. наук, профессора С. Н. Леонович1^ Г. И. Яковлев2), канд. техн. наук, доц. И. С. Полянских2), канд. наук О. Лахайн3), докт. наук, проф. Й. Эберхардштайнер3),
докт. наук, проф. Г. Скрипкинас4), канд. техн. наук, доц. И. А. Пудов2), студ. Е. А. Карпова2)
^Белорусский национальный технический университет (Минск, Республика Беларусь),
2)Ижевский государственный технический университет имени М. Т. Калашникова (Ижевск, Российская Федерация),
3)Венский технический университет (Вена, Австрия),
^Вильнюсский технический университет имени Гедиминаса (Вильнюс, Литва)
Реферат. Комплексные нанодисперсные системы с многослойными углеродными нанотрубками и нанокремнезе-мом имеют значительное влияние на процессы гидратации, твердения, набора прочности строительных композитов, предопределяя их долговечность. Исследования с использованием сканирующего электронного микроскопа и Х-лучевого микроанализа с обнаружением в инфракрасном спектре показали, что главный эффект модификации в случае добавления комплексных нанодисперсных систем обеспечивается направленным влиянием процессов гидратации с последующей кристаллизацией новообразований. Установлено, что при добавлении дисперсии углеродных нанотрубок и нанокремнезема формируется структурная матрица в виде чрезвычайно плотной оболочки из кристаллогидратных новообразований на поверхности твердой фазы, что обеспечивает прочную вяжущую матрицу в цементном бетоне. Эффект добавления углеродных нанотрубок анализировался и количественно оценивался исследованием в каждом случае одного образца с нанотрубками и одного без них с помощью наноиндентора и сканирующего электронного микроскопа. Чтобы количественно оценить эффект добавки углеродных нанотрубок на характеристики материала на микромеханическом уровне, необходимо решить сложную задачу. В то же время возможно исследовать поверхность бетонного образца с разрешением в 1 микрон. При этом необходима подготовка образцов для наноиндентирования с исключением всех эффектов дефектности углеродных нанотрубок, показанных сканирующим электронным микроскопом. Вместе с тем более адекватным методом оценивания в данном случае должен быть пикоиндентор, который комбинирует испытательный метод наноиндентирования с оптическим потенциалом сканирующего микроскопа. Такое оборудование находится в стадии полевых испытаний в Венском техническом университете. Исследование основано на том, что главный эффект модифицирования минеральной вяжущей матрицы с использованием включенных комплексных нанодисперсных систем и нанокремнезема обеспечивается непосредственным влиянием процессов гидратации и последующей кристаллизацией новообразований. Сканирующий электронный микроскоп и Х-лучевой микроанализ с обнаружением в инфракрасном спектре показали, что введение дисперсии многослойных углеродных нанотрубок совместно с нанокремнеземом обеспечивает построение вдоль цементной матрицы очень плотной оболочки вновь образованных гидратов на поверхности твердой фазы. Структурированные поверхностные слои формируют отдельные ячейки в модифицированной цементной матрице, что обеспечивает формирование предельно наполненной системы и предопределяет структуры модифицированной цементной матрицы благодаря формированию пространственной упаковки. Следовательно, основным фактором, повышающим характеристики цементного бетона, модифицированного углеродными нанотрубками и нанокремнеземом, является структурная модификация гидросиликатов кальция относительно композиции и морфологии новообразований.
Ключевые слова: нанодисперсная система, многослойные углеродные нанотрубки, нанокремнезем, сканирующий электронный микроскоп, Х-лучевой микроанализ, гидратация, цементный бетон
Для цитирования: Структурная модификация новообразований в цементной матрице с использованием дисперсии углеродных нанотрубок и нанокремнезема / Б. М. Хрусталев [и др.] // Наука и техника. 2017. Т. 16, № 2. С. 93-103. БО!: 10.21122/2227-1031-2017-16-2-93-103
Introduction
Carbon nanotubes (CNT) were first synthesized in 1952 (fig. 1) by the members of Institute of Physical chemistry and Electrochemistry of Russian Academy of Sciences, L. V. Radushke-vich and V. M. Lukyanovich [1]. The main properties of CNT were systematically described by Sumio Iijima who discovered them in 1991 as
a by-product of fullerene synthesis [2]. The authors of the given study have synthesized carbon nanotubes using an original technology presented in patent [3] the technique of which is described in article [4]. The produced nanostructures were used to modify the structure of non-autoclaved cellular concrete. It was also shown that CNT increase the strength of aerated concrete by 70 %, while the stabilization of the pore structure with
Наука
итехника. Т. 16, № 2 (2017)
their size and the decrease of the average density of aerated concrete are noted [5]. Further studies [6, 7] found that adding CNT changes not only the structure but also the composition of calcium hydrosilicates (CHS) that form the main values of the properties of dense cement concrete.
Calcium hydrosilicates are the main components of set cement at the nanoscale. The nature of their structure determines the values of strength and durability of cement concrete. There are some works which present the results of the studies of the changes in the morphology of crystalline hydrates based on calcium hydrosilicates due to adding nanodispersed modifiers based on carbon nanosystems to the hardening cement matrix [8-10]. Using a nanodispersed modifier can control the kinetics of the interaction between cement minerals and mixing water, influence the composition and structure of CHS, increase the degree of polycondensation of silicon-oxygen anions of calcium hydrosilicates. Thus, in the process of modification of cement matrix with CNTs one of the main issues is the directed regulation of the processes of polycondensation of silicon-oxygen anions in order to strengthen the borders of the contact areas and provide the increased strength, water- and frost-resistance of concrete.
Fig. 1. Carbon nanotubes found in 1952 by the members of Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry of Russian Academy of Sciences, L. V. Radushkevich and V. M. Lukyanovich [1]
Calcium hydrosilicates are the main components of set cement at the nanoscale. The nature of their structure determines the values of strength
and durability of cement concrete. There are some works which present the results of the studies of the changes in the morphology of crystalline hydrates based on calcium hydrosilicates due to adding nanodispersed modifiers based on carbon nanosystems to the hardening cement matrix [8-10]. Using a nanodispersed modifier can control the kinetics of the interaction between cement minerals and mixing water, influence the composition and structure of CHS, increase the degree of polycondensation of silicon-oxygen anions of calcium hydrosilicates. Thus, in the process of modification of cement matrix with CNTs one of the main issues is the directed regulation of the processes of polycondensation of silicon-oxygen anions in order to strengthen the borders of the contact areas and provide the increased strength, water- and frost-resistance of concrete.
In the review of the works about the use of CNTs [11-13] it is noted that most researchers limit the role of nanotubes to the nanoreinforcing of the set cement structure considering the microstructures containing carbon nanotubes, which are in physical contact with CHS or located in microcracks. The amount of the modifying nanotubes exceeds 0,05 % of weight of the binder, which is apparently caused by their insufficient dispersing, despite using various dispersing methods and applying surfactants for aqueous dispersions.
A lot of works suggest using two or more nanosystems for the modification of cement concrete, nanosilica being used as the second additive in most cases [14-17], which due to the synergistic effect from being used with CNTs intensifies the processes of CHSs forming, densifying the structure of set cement. At the same time, these systems can significantly change the structure of the interphase boundaries in cement composites due to the crystallization of new CHS formations on the surface of the solid phase with the formation of dense shells that connect the components of cement concrete. This dramatically increases the role of nano-silica which binds calcium hydroxide to form CHS contributing to extra densifying of lowly cohesive new formations.
Thus, adding nanosized particles to the concrete composition enables the control of the processes of hydration and formation of the hardening cement structure at the nanoscale, providing the directed formation of the required macrostructure to achieve the required properties of concrete.
HayKa
ut exHUKa. T. 16, № 2 (2017)
At the same time the nature of self-organization of the cement concrete microstructure is not clear, nanosystems being added, especially CNT that provide the formation of high-strength set cement from the originally lowly cohesive new crystalline hydrate formations.
Materials and Methods
Multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNT) were used as an aqueous dispersion of Vulvek 100 "No-vyy Dom", LLC (Izhevsk) prepared on the basis of Graphistrength™ Masterbatch CW2-45 premix produced by Arkema Group Co. French company. The premix containing 55 % of carboxymethyl-cellulose and 45 % of MWCNT was dispersed in a high-speed bead mill mixer.
The binder used was Portland cement of CEM I 42.5N JSC "Nevyansky Cementnik"; the fine aggregate - ditch sand from Selychinskoye deposit (Udmurtia) meeting the requirements of GOST 8736; coarse aggregate - ballast stone from river gravel of 5-20 mm fraction meeting GOST 8267 from Kama deposit.
The amorphous finely-dispersed silica includes a mixture comprising 90 % of microsilica MK-85 (Tula) with an average particle size of 300 nm and 10 % of synthetic nanosilica Nanosilika (Cairo) with an average particle size of 15 nm.
The microstructure of the produced samples was studied with a scanning electron microscope JSM-7600F of JEOL company and Phenom G2 Pure. The analysis of set cement by means of infra-
red spectroscopy was conducted with a FT-IR spectrometer of Spektrum One in the frequency range of 4000-650 cm-1.
The water resistance of the samples was determined by means of a "wet spot" test on the certified unit, as well as "VIP-1.2" device concerning the air permeability of the concrete samples. The frost-resistance tests were carried out by means of accelerated method using heat-cold chamber KTH-74.
Results and Discussion
The main task, the solution of which determines further development of technology of cement concrete modification by means of carbon nanotubes, is to produce a stable dispersion that would not be broken down for a long time due to the CNT coagulation. This task is solved by dispersing CNTs in aqueous solutions of surfactants when exposed to ultrasound [9, 18]. Using highspeed bead mill can improve dispersing MWCNT and apply the produced dispersions on an industrial scale [7]. At the same time, in such dispersion the amount of nanotubes does not exceed 20-25 %, the remaining volume of the particles is located in the range of several micrometers (fig. 2a). The additional processing of this dispersion with ultrasound provides dispersing nanotubes to nanometer size (the average particle size is 25 nm). Thus, according to the average particle size (fig. 2b), nano-tubes do not only separate, but also are destructed and possibly broken down.
100
in volume/uhdersize
80
x1
o4
60
40
О
20
0.04 0.1
0.06
0.04
a 0.02
Intensity
1.0 10.0 x(Diameter)/|_im
Fig. 2. Distribution of multi-walled carbon nanotubes in aqueous dispersion: a - after processing in a high-speed bead mill; b - after additional ultrasound processing
10 Diameter, nm
Наука
итехника. Т. 16, № 2 (2017)
b
a
0
The analysis of the influence of dispersion on mechanical properties of set cement in the composition of fine concrete shows the increase in strength, which is in direct proportion to the duration of ultrasonic processing of dispersion (fig. 3). The conducted studies show that the concentration of nanotubes in the set cement matrix can be limited to 0.001 % from the weight of Portland cement, and the strength values of the set cement will not yield to the values shown in fig. 3.
ra 40
Ol
E о О
30
20
10
0 0,00125 0,0025 0,00500 Dispersion ratio, % from the weight of cement
Fig. 3. Compressive strength of cement concrete modified with MWCNT dispersion: - produced with high-speed bead mixer; - after ultrasound processing of the dispersion for 20 min
Taking into account the destruction of multi-walled CNTs with such combined dispersing technology, it is necessary to interpret the strength increase of the cement matrix as in this casethe traditional reference to nanoreinforcing of the cement matrix by means of carbon nanotubes is not correct enough. The main effect of the modification of set cement in this case is provided by structuring the new crystalline hydrate formations based on CHS. At the same time due to the contact interactions of the structured boundary layers the spatial frame
1
cells are formed in the structure of the modified matrix. A large number of point contacts ensure the formation of extremely filled system in which the collective transfer to adhesion in a short-range order leads to the hardening of the structure of the modified binding matrix due to the formation of spatial packing of CHS (fig. 4). This leads to a dense and strong mineral matrix that provides durable composite material for construction purposes.
Therefore, it is necessary to pay attention to the microstructure of the new formations in the set cement matrix and, above all, to the composition and morphology of CHS. In the process of cement setting crystalline hydrates cover the surface of the solid phase in the composition of cement concrete with a thin layer of 3-10 microns of dense new formations (fig. 5a, b) forming high-strength shells that combine the components of concrete in a frame. Carbon nanotubes being denuded, in the case of formation of shrinkage cracks, the nano-tube surface is overgrown with calcium hydrosilicates (fig. 5c). In certain cases carbon nanotubes can provide "self-healing" of cracks with new formations, crystallization of which is stimulated with nanotube surface.
To determine the composition of the cement matrix adjacent to the surface of basalt fiber, X-ray microanalysis of new formations was conducted. Its results are presented in fig. 6. Based on the results of X-ray microanalysis, it can be argued that around the basalt fiber there are dense structured shells from the new formations of sheet structure (calcium hydroxide) coated with amorphous calcium hydrosilicates. The presence of carbon in the composition confirms the presence of carbon nanotubes in the studied microvolume.
b c
2
3
4
Fig. 4. Scheme of the structuring of the set cement modified with CNTs: a - distribution of CNT in the set cement after tempering; b - structuring the new crystalline hydrate formations based on CHS; c - forming of the special packing from CHS; 1 - particles of cement clinker; 2 - carbon nanotubes; 3 - new formations based on CHS; 4 - structured boundary layers
Наука
иТ ехника. Т. 16, № 2 (2017)
0
a
Fig. 5. Microstructure of the cement matrix modified with carbon nanotubes in cement concrete with dense new formations: a - on the surface of quartz sand; b - the surface of basalt fiber [19]; c - carbon nanotubes in a shrinkage crack coated with calcium hydrosilicates
0 0.5 1 15 2 25 3
F J scale 653 mp. Ciirscr 0.000 heV
Fig. 6. Results of X-ray microanalysis of new formations on the surface of basalt fiber [19]
Using an complex additive comprising MWCNT dispersion along with nanosilica leads to the densifi-cation of the structure of set cement in the space between the structured shells (fig. 7a), new hydrosilicate formations appearing as clusters in the presence
of silica fume (fig. 7b), and additionally densifying the binding matrix in the composition of cement concrete (fig. 7c). Such structure leads to a significant increase in the cement strength in the composition of the modified concrete.
b
а
c
Fig. 7. The microstructure of cement concrete modified with the complex additive ("DC-5" with 8 % of nanosilica): a - densification of crystalline structure with new hydrosilicate formations; b - fragment of microstructure with densifying bunch-like new formations; c - fragment of microstructure with a particle of nanosilica
98
Наука
итехника. Т. 16, № 2 (2017)
Infrared spectral analysis of the check sample (fig. 8a) and the samples modified with a complex additive (fig. 8b) confirms the intensification of hydration of Portland cement along with the formation of additional calcium hydrosilicates (increase in the intensity of the absorption lines 1085 and 1089 cm-1). The formation of calcium hydrosilicates of different basicity is also confirmed with an additional absorption line of 1033 cm-1.
Thus, the use of complex additives with multi-walled carbon nanotubes and nanosized silica significantly changes the set cement structure in the modified concrete due to the directed crystallization of new formations based on calcium hydrosilicates, stimulating their crystallization of the surface of solid phase components of concrete. At that, not only the morphology of new formations, but their mineralogical composition changes, as well as the basicity of calcium hydrosilicates, which in its turn determines their strength characteristics [20].
Experimental Results
To check the actual influence of the CNTs on the characteristics of the concrete, samples
without CNTs (type A) and with CNTs (type B) were subjects to several series of experiments performed at the Institute for Mechanics of Materials and Structures at Vienna University of Technology: They were examined by the help of a nanoindenter and with a scanning electron microscope (SEM).
Results of nanoindentation on two concrete samples. For this test series, one sample of type A and B have been used. One each of the two samples an extensive test series was performed with a Hysitron Triboindenter, analogous to test series conducted before on other concrete samples [21, 22]. For each single measurement, the force was increased over 10 s up to a maximum value of approximately 1200 ^N, kept constant for 5 s and then again linearly decreased over 10 s. If the force is plotted as a function of the depth, we get curves as in fig. 9.
Actually, the indentation depth h is a function of the force F, which is given by the indenter, but usually F(h) is plotted instead of h(F). The elastic material parameters, such as Young's modulus E and the hardness H can be calculated based on the curve sector with decreasing force [23].
Fig. 8. IR-spectra of the cement matrix in the check sample (a) and the sample modified with a complex additive (b) (MWCNT dispersion with nanosilica)
Наука qq
иТ ехника. Т. 16, № 2 (2017) 99
Indentation depth as function of indentation force 1200
F [HN]
800 600 400 200
Constant force (5 s)
^¡f
J //
//
I )epth [nm
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270
Fig. 9. Force as a function of the indentation depth for one indent on concrete
For performing the indents, first the top side of each sample was polished to get a smooth test surface, which is necessary as a reference for measuring the indentation depth as precise as possible. As can be seen in fig. 10, the remaining height fluctuations in the pictured area were in the range of a few microns. (It was only possible to reduce the roughness to a certain degree, because during the polishing smaller parts of the material, but also parts in the range of 1 mm and more crumbled away from the samples. This way, not only the roughness was increased locally, but also the whole sample became smaller and smaller.)
With every indent, Young's modulus E as well as the hardness H of the material is quantified at the respective reading point. An area of 100x100 ^m was examined on both samples with a grid of 40x40 indentations, resulting in a total sum of 1600 measurement on every sample. (Each of these test series took about 3 days.) Fig. 11a shows the results for sample type A and fig. 11b shows the analogous results for sample type B. In the
same way the hardness can be plotted, but the pattern for this parameter is rather similar to the pattern of the modulus, though the variation of the results is even higher, as demonstrated in tabl. 1.
Fig. 10. Scan of an area of 60x60 ^m of the polished surface of sample type B, as done with the imaging mode of the nanoindenter
Table 1
Mean values and standard deviation for Young's modulus and hardness, based on 1600 single measurements for each sample type
Type A Type B
Young's modulus E, GPa 47,80 ± 31,20 56,30 ± 38,70
Hardness H, GPa 2,56 ± 3,09 3,82 ± 6,04
While for the modulus, the standard deviation is in the range of 65 % of the mean values, for the hardness the standard deviation even exceeds the mean values, though test areas have been chosen, which appeared relatively homogeneous in the optical microscope attached to the nanoindenter, as shown in fig. 12.
b
a
Fig. 11. Young's modulus on sample type A (a) and type B (b), as calculated on the basis of a 40x40 grid of indents
100
Наука
итехника. Т. 16, № 2 (2017)
Fig. 12. Image of an optical microscope of the test area for type B (marked by the white square)
The distribution of E, as given in figs. 11a and 11b, suggests that it is not a mere statistical distribution. Instead there are areas with significantly higher (or lower) modulus, compared to the average. For example, there is a zone in the lower left part of fig. 4, where E is higher than 100 GPa throughout and reaches maximum values of 250 GPa.
These variations of E and H probably result from the spatial distribution of the various phases of the material. This distribution is also reflected in the histograms of Young's modulus, as given in fig. 13.
Histograms of Young's modulus, as detected dy Nanoindentation
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130
Fig. 13. Histograms of Young's modulus for the test results in fig. 11a and 11b
While there is a distinct global maximum for the distribution at approximately 30 GPa (type A) and 36 GPa (type B), it would be challenging to identify any local maxima and therefore to distinguish the various phases, based on this test series. There is also no systematic pattern in the distribution of E, and there are no significant structures visible in the optical images of the inspected areas, which clearly reflect the measured distribution of the modulus. Especially it wasn't possible to detect any elongated structures, which might have been caused by nanotubes. One reason for that might be
Наука
ит ехника. Т. 16, № 2 (2017)
the distance of 2,5 ^m between two indents, which is roughly the tenfold of the presumed diameter of the nanotubes. Other possible reasons will be discussed at the end of this paper.
To check if it is in principle feasible to detect nanotubes with the indenter, one concrete sample of each type has been inspected by the help of a Scanning Electron Microscope.
Results of microscopic determination of concrete samples. For this part of the work, an analytical high-resolution FEGSEM of the type FEI Quanta 200 FEGSEM has been used, which is available at the Vienna University of Technology [24]. Again, the two concrete cubes inspected by the SEM were both polished on the top side, but because of the roughness of the material and its tendency to brittle, only a part of the visible surface of the prepared side was effectively polished, while on the rest of the top side there was a relatively rough fracture surface left. These disparities are also visible of the images obtained by the SEM.
In the middle of fig. 14a there is a relatively smooth area, which is obviously the result of the polishing process. (On closer inspection, flimsy scratches are visible, all running in the same direction, which is a typical byproduct of the polishing process.) Contrary to that, the surface in fig. 14b is much rougher and completely irregular. A similar distinction was found for the sample of type B; see fig. 15a and 15b.
The images in fig. 15a to 15b were done with the same magnification (x1000) and also otherwise with the same parameters. While the polished area on the left half of fig. 15a has a similar appearance to the polished are in fig. 14a, there are elongated structures visible in the unpolished area of fig. 15a as well as in fig. 15b, which are not visible in fig. 14b. With higher magnification (x 10000), these structures can be identified as nanotubes (fig. 16a). While in the unpolished areas the nanotubes are clearly visible, especially in zones of cracks and pores, it seems that they are destroyed by polishing the surface, or that they are covered with attrition material and therefore neither visible in the SEM nor detectable by the nanoindenter.
This process would explain why the mean values of E and H, as identified by the test series with the nanoindenter and as listed in tabl. 1, are rather similar for concrete types A and B, since the absolute concentration of Nanotubes in the concrete material is only a fraction of a percent.
b
a
Fig. 14. Polished area of concrete sample type A (a) and Unpolished area of concrete sample type A (b) a b
Fig. 15. Polished area of concrete sample type B (a) and unpolished area of concrete sample type B (b) a b
Fig. 16. a - detail of fig. 15b with nanotubes from magnification (x10000); b - detail of fig. 15b with nanotubes from magnification (x20000)
CONCLUSIONS
1. The research has found that the main effect of the modification of mineral binding matrices using complex nanodispersed systems comprising MWCNT and nanosilica is ensured with the directed influence on the hydration processes and the subsequent crystallization of new formations. Scanning electron microscopy and X-ray micro-analysis confirmed with IR-spectra have revealed that adding multi-walled carbon nanotubes dispersion together with nanodispersed silica provides the structuring of the binding matrix along with the perfect dense shell of hydrated new formations on the surface of solid phases. The structured inter-
102
facial layers form the special frame cells in the modified cement matrix which ensures the formation of extremely filled system predetermining the strengthening of the structure of the modified binding matrix due to the formation of the spatial packaging. Consequently, the main factor increasing the characteristics of cement concrete modified with carbon nanotubes and nanosilica is the structural modification of calcium hydrosilicates concerning both the composition and the morphology of new formations.
2. To quantify the effect of the addition of the CNT on the characteristics of the material on a mi-cromechanical level proved to be a challenging
Наука
итехника. Т. 16, № 2 (2017)
task, though. While it is possible to inspect the surface of a concrete sample with a resolution in a range of 1 micron, the necessary process of preparation of the samples for the nanoindentation probably obliterates all detectable effects of the CNTs, as shown by a SEM. Therefore, a more adequate examination method in this case would be a so-called picoindenter, which basically combines the test method of a nanoindenter with the optical potential of a SEM. Such an instrument is right now at the stadium of field testing at the Vienna University of Technology, though, and hopefully will be available at a later date.
REFERENCES
1. Radushkevich L. V., Lukyanovich V. M. (1952) On the Structure of Carbon Produced at Thermal Decomposition of Carbon Monoxide on an Iron Contact. Zhurnal Fizi-cheskoi Khimii [Journal of Physical Chemistry], 26 (1), 88-95 (in Russian).
2. Iijima S. (1991) Helical Microtubulesof Graphitic Carbon. Nature, 354 (6348), 56-58. DOI: 10.1038/354056a0.
3. Babushkina S. N., Kodolov V. I., Kuznetsov F. P., Niko-laeva O. A., Yakovlev G. I. Method of Producing Carbon and Metal Containing Nanostructures. Patent of the Russian No 2169699 (in Russian).
4. Kodolov V. I., Shabanova I. N., Makarova L. G., Kho-khryakov N. V., Kuznetsov A. P., Nikolaeva O. A., Kere-ne J., Yakovlev G. I. (2001) Structure of the Products Simulated Carbonization of Aromatic Hydrocarbons. Journal of Structural Chemistry, 42 (2), 215-219. DOI: 10.1023/a: 1010562 914410.
5. Yakovlev G., Keriene J., Gailius A., Girniene I. (2006) Cement Based Foam Concrete Reinforced by Carbon Nanotubes. Materials Science, 12 (2), 147-151.
6. Yakovlev G., Pervushin G., Maeva I., Keriene Ja., Pudov I., Shaybadullina A., Buryanov A., Korzhenko A., Senkov S. (2013) Modification of Construction Materials with Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes. Proceedia Engineering, 57, 407-413. DOI: 10.1016/j.proeng.2013.04.053.
7. Yakovlev G. I., Pervushin G. N., Polyanskikh I. S., Senkov S. A., Pudov I. A., Mohamed A. E. (2014) Concrete of Increased Durability for Producing Transmission Line Poles. Stroitelnye Materialy [Construction Materials], (5), 92-94 (in Russian).
8. Ponomaryov A. N. Nanoconcrete - Conception and Issues (2007). Stroitelnye Materialy [Construction Materials], (7), 2-4 (in Russian).
9. Sobolkina A., Mechtcherine V., Khavrus V., Maier D., Mende M., Ritschel M., Leonhardt A. (2012) Dispersion of Carbon Nanotubes and its Influence on the Mechanical Properties of the Cement Matrix. J. Cement & Concrete Composites, 34, 1104-1113. DOI: 10.1016/j.cemconcomp. 2012.07.008.
10. Korolyov E. V. (2014) Nanotechnology in Construction Material Science. Analysis of the State and Achievements. Ways of Developments. Stroitelnye Materialy [Construction Materials], (11), 47-79 (in Russian).
11. Shama Parveen, Sohe Rana, Rau Fangueiro (2013). A Review on Nanomaterial Dispersion, Microstructure, and Mechanical Properties of Carbon Nanotube and Nanofiber Reinforced Cementitious Composites. Journal of Nano-materials, 2013, 1-19. DOI: 10.1155/2013/710175.
12. Saptarshi Sasmal, B. Bhuvaneshwari, Nagesh R. Iyer (2013). Can Carbon Nanotubes Make Wonders in Civil Structural Engineering? Progress in Nanotechnology and Nanomaterials, 2 (4), 117-129. D01:10.5963/pnn0204003.
13. Smilauer V., Hlavâcek P., Padevet P. (2012) Microme-chanical Analysis of Cement Paste with Carbon Nanotubes. Acta Polytechnica, 52 (6), 22-28.
14. Mehmet Gesoglu, Erhan Güneyisi, Diler Sabah Asaad, Guler Fakhraddin Muhyaddin (2016). Properties of Low Binder Ultra-High Performance Cementitious Composites: Comparison of Nanosilica and Microsilica. Construction and Building Materials, 102, 706-713. DOI: 10.1016/j. conbuildmat.2015.11.020.
15. Anand Hunashyal1, Nagaraj Banapurmath, Akshay Jain, Sayed Quadri, Ashok Shettar (2014). Experimental Investigation on the Effect of Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotu-bes and Nano-SiO2 Addition on Mechanical Properties of Hardened Cement Paste. Advances in Materials, 3 (5), 45-51. DOI: 10.11648/j.am.20140305.13.
16. Péter Ludvig, José M. Calixto, Luiz O. Ladeira, Ivan C. P. Gaspar (2011). Using Converter Dust to Produce Low Cost Cementitious Composites by in Situ Carbon Nano-tube and Nanofiber Synthesis. Materials, 4, 575-584. DOI: 10.3390/ma4030575.
17. Sakthieswarana N., Sureshb M. (2015). A Study on Strength Properties for Cement Mortar Added with Carbon Nanotubes and Zeolite. International Journal of Engineering and Computer Science, 4 (6), 12402-12406.
18. Jyoti Bharj, Sarabjit Singh, Subhash Chander, Rabinder Singh (2014) Role of Dispersion of Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes on Compressive Strength of Cement. International Journal of Mathematical, Computational, Physical, Electrical and Computer Engineering, 8 (2), 340-343.
19. Saraykina K. A., Golubev V. A., Yakovlev G. I., Fedoro-va G. D., Alexandrov G. N., Plekhanova T. A., Dulesova I. G. (2015) Modification of Basalt Concrete with Nanodispersed Systems. StroitelnyeMaterialy [Construction Materials], (10), 64-69 (in Russian).
20. Karpova E. A., Ali Elsaed Mohamed, Skripkiunas G., Keriene Ja., Kicaite A., Yakovlev G. I., Macijauskas M., Pudov I. A., Aliev E. V., Senkov S. A. (2015) Modification of Cement Concrete by Use of Complex Additives Based on the Polycarboxylate Ether, Carbon Nanotubes and Microsilica. Stroitelnye Materialy [Construction Materials], (2), 40-48 (in Russian).
21. Lahayne O., Eberhardsteiner J., Yakovlev G., Leonovich S., Pervushin G. (2013) Nano-Tests on Concrete Samples with and Wiehout Nanotubes. Mekhanika Razrusheniya Betonov, Zhelezobetonov i Drugikh Stroitelnykh Materialov Sbornik Statei po Materialam 7-i Mezhdunarodnoi Nauchnoi Konfe-rentsii. Tom 2 [7th International Scientific Conference "Fracture Mechanics of Concrete, Reinforced Concrete and Other Building Materials ". Vol. 2], Voronezh, Voronezh State University of Architecture and Civil Engineering, 2013.
22. Eberhardsteiner J., Lahayne O. (2014) Nano-Tests on Concrete Samples with and without Nanotubes. Stroitel-nyeMaterialy [Construction Materials], (1-2), 21-24.
23. With an Account on www.hysitron.com, the Manual of the Nanoindenter Can be Downloaded by Using this Link. Available at: https://support.hysitron.com/downloads/User%20Ma nuals/TI%20900%20TriboIndenter%20User%20Manual.pdf.
24. Homepage of the USTEM (University Service Facilities for Transmissions Electron Microscopes), Vienna University of Technology, Austria. Available at: http://www.ustem. tuwien.ac.at/instrumentation/fei_quanta_200_fegsem/EN/.
Received: 22.12.2016 Accepted: 24.02.2017 Published online: 28.03.2017
Наука
иТ ехника. Т. 16, № 2 (2017)
