CC BY
42УДК 159.9:343.8
DOI 10.33463/2712-7737.2020.02(1-3).3.139-144 Bindasova O. V.
БиндасоваО. В.
PSYCHOLOGICAL STUDY OF THE CONVICT'S PERSONALITY DEPENDING ON THE NUMBER OF CRIMINAL RECORDS
ПСИХОЛОГИЧЕСКОЕ ИЗУЧЕНИЕ ЛИЧНОСТИ ОСУЖДЕННОГО В ЗАВИСИМОСТИ ОТ КОЛИЧЕСТВА СУДИМОСТЕЙ
Abstract. The article is devoted to an empirical analysis of diagnostics problems study of personality traits among convicts serving sentences in prison.On the basis of the obtained data, the psychological characteristics of negative personal traits of convicts in the aspect of psychological support of educational impact on them are determined. The author of the article used the «Dark triad» questionnaire developed in 2002 by Canadian researchers Delra Paulhus and Kevin Williams. This questionnaire is aimed at measuring the subclinical personality traits included in the so-called «Dark triad»: narcissism, psychopathy and machiavellianism. This method has shown its effectiveness in the diagnostic work of prison psychologists. The key task of the study was to identify statistically significant differences in the groups of convicts serving their first sentence and those who had previously been convicted several times.The study involved 200 convicts. Comparing the differences in the groups of convicts, the author notes their specificity. In particular, high levels of dark constructs were identified from a group of repeatedly serving sentences in places of liberty deprivation.The presence of pronounced negative personality traits form a single global index of «dark personality». Scales of the «Dark triad» that reflect the negative personal core allow to quickly get the necessary indices and identify the mechanisms of convicts' functioning serving sentences in correctional institutions.Prison psychologists need to take into account the high rates of negative constructs in order to implement psychological support measures for convicts throughout the entire period of serving their sentence.
Keywords: dark triad, narcissism, psychopathy, machiavellianism, psychological support, psychological support of educational impact.
Аннотация. В статье представлен эмпирический анализ исследования проблемы диагностики личностных черт осужденных, отбывающих наказания в местах лишения свободы. На основании полученных данных определена психологическая характеристика негативных личностных черт осужденных в аспекте психологического обеспечения воспитательного воздействия на них. Автором статьи
© Bindasova O. V., 2020 © БиндасоваО. В., 2020
The article is licensed under the license
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0
в ходе проведенного исследования использован опросник «Темная триада», раз -работанный в 2002 г. канадскими исследователями Делрой Полхаус и Кевином Уильямс. Данный опросник направлен на измерение субклинических личностных свойств, входящих в так называемую «Темную триаду» - нарциссизм, психопатия и макиавеллизм. Указанная методика показала свою эффективность в диагностической работе пенитенциарных психологов. Ключевая задача проведенного исследования состояла в выявлении статистически достоверных различий в группах осужденных, впервые отбывающих наказание и ранее неоднократно судимых. В исследовании приняли участие 200 осужденных. Сравнивая различия в группах осужденных, автор отмечает их специфичность. В частности, высокие уровни темных конструктов были выявлены у группы неоднократно отбывающих наказание в местах лишения свободы. Наличие выраженных негативных личностных черт образуют единый глобальный индекс «темной личности». Шкалы «Темной триады», отражающие негативное личностное ядро позволяют быстро получить необходимые индексы и выявить механизмы функционирования осужденных, отбывающих наказание в исправительных учреждениях. Пенитенциарным психологам необходимо учитывать высокие показатели негативных конструктов с целью осуществления мероприятий психологического сопровождения осужденных на протяжении всего периода отбывания наказания.
Ключевые слова: темная триада, нарциссизм, психопатия, макиавеллизм, психологическое сопровождение, психологическое обеспечение воспитательного воздействия.
Information about author / Сведения об авторе
Ol'ga Vladimirovna Bindasova, leading specialist of the department of ideological work and personnel support, Department of punishment execution of the MIA of the Republic of Belarus for the Mogilev region, Mogilev, Republic of Belarus, e-mail: bindasova. [email protected].
Ольга Владимировна Биндасова, ведущий специалист отдела идеологической работы и кадрового обеспечения, Управление Департамента исполнения наказаний МВД Республики Беларусь по Могилевской области, г. Могилев, Республика Беларусь, e-mail: [email protected].
Recommended citation / Для цитирования
Bindasova, O. V. 2020, 'Psychological study of the convict's personality depending on the number of criminal records', International penitentiary journal, vol. 2(1-3), iss. 3, pp. 139-144, doi: 10.33463/2712-7737.2020.02(1-3).3.139-144.
Биндасова, О. В. Психологическое изучение личности осужденного в зависимости от количества судимостей / О. В. Биндасова // Международный пенитенциарный журнал. - 2020. - Т. 2(1-3), № 3. - С. 139-144. - DOI :10.33463/2712-7737.2020.02(1-3).3.139-144.
Currently, every convicted person serving a sentence in a correctional institution has the right to receive psychological assistance. The organization of psychological support for convicts is implemented through a set of psychological and pedagogical measures aimed at improving the effectiveness of educational impact. An urgent problem is to conduct a qualitative study of convicts' personality, which will determine the totality of socio-psychological characteristics, views and values that are causes and conditions of existing behavior problems.
In recent years, there is a tendency to reduce the number of convicts serving sentences repeatedly: for the second, third time or more. However, at the same time, according to the census of convicts, the number of crimes committed for the first time has increased over the past 5 years. Today, a new generation of criminals gets into the institutions of the penal system, which is affected by the modern negative consequences of the last decades. The interrelated socio-psychological complex of various features that directly or indirectly caused the criminal behavior of the individual focuses on explaining the causes of the crime. Knowledge of psychological characteristics of the convicts' personality provides the necessary basis for individual corrective impact.
The use of psychodiagnostic methods should focus primarily on identifying the personality structure that defines its basic elements and stable aspects. When creating a personal profile of a convicted person, the prison psychologist analyzes the psychological characteristics that led to a violation of the normal functioning of the individual. The impact on the personality of a convicted person without taking into account their individual characteristics increases the psychotraumatic factors of isolation, roots the criminological characteristics of convicts, generates conflict situations and levels the quality of educational influence and correction of convicts.
The list of psychological methods used by prison psychologists includes the main
diagnostic methods for determining the typological structure of the convict's personality (Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory MMPI, California Psychological Inventory CPI, Multi-level personal questionnaire MPQ of A. G. Maklakova, characterological questionnaire of G. Eysencketc). However, at present there is a need for a high-quality and compact measuring tool that does not take much time for convicts and is easily included in sets of techniques. Developed in 2002 by canadian researchers Delra Paulhus and Kevin Williams, the "Dark Triad" questionnaire aims to measure the subclinical personality traits included in the so called "Dark Triad": narcissism, psychopathy, and machiavellianism. It is non-clinical psychological traits such as narcissism, psychopathy and machiavellianism that form a kind of complex of personality traits aimed at measuring the negative "dark" side of the convict's personality. The narcissism scale defines a stable long-term state of the individual, which arose on the basis of a distorted view of the individual about himself, and also characterizes the personal trait of his own unlimited and omnipotence. Psychopathy scale includes personality traits such as high impulsivity, thoughtlessness, a desire for risk and thrills, and low empathy for others. The machiavellian scale characterizes the general ability of an individual to manipulate behavior for personal purposes. Machiavellians are those who are more have a tendency to manipulate others, often without their knowledge, and achieve their own goals. In our opinion, the study of the dark sides of the convict's personality should provide an exhaustive answer to the main question of the prison psychologist: what is the "dark" type of convict's personality in front of us, as well as determine the further trajectory of psychological correction with him.
The penitentiary system is carrying out a huge amount of work aimed at finding effective ways of psychological and pedagogical influence on persons who have committed crimes, in order to correct them and prevent recidivism in the future. A significant difference
in approaches to personality correction is the formation of the attitude of convicts to law-abiding prosocial behavior of persons serving their sentences for the first time, as well as those serving their sentences repeatedly. The second group of convicts is characterized by exposure to criminogenic deformation, remoteness from legal ways of regulating relations between people. They are difficult to educate and change their own antisocial attitudes and traits.
The key task of this study was to identify statistically significant differences in the groups of convicts serving their sentences for the first time and those who had previously been convicted several times.200 convicts took part in this study. The survey included men serving their first sentence in a correctional colony, as well as persons serving their sentences repeatedly for crimes of varying severity (tables 1-2).
Further, to identify significant differences in the groups of convicted men, depending on the number of convictions, a comparative analysis was performed using the Student's t-test, the results of which are presented in table 3.
As a result of mathematical data processing, differences in the indicators "psychopathy" and "machiavellianism" were revealed. In both groups of convicts, according to the "Dark Triad" questionnaire, a low level of narcissism was found in 56% of convicts serving their sentences for the first time, while 48% of convicts repeatedly serving their sentences had a high level of narcissism. It can be assumed that narcissism as a stable long-term state is characteristic of antisocial individuals who tend to consider themselves leaders, demonstrate their own superiority and are difficult to adjust their own behavioral strategies. Narcissism is typical for people who are repeatedly serving sentences, since narcissistic strategies worsen volitional self-regulatory characteristics; therefore, there is no ability to critically analyze the consequences of their own behavior.
Subjects with a high level of psychopathy among the first-time offenders were 3%; while in the group of convicts repeatedly serving
sentences, 45% of them have an average level of the psychopathy construct. In the dark triad, psychopathy is a symptom that begins with extreme versions of the "norm" and reaches a specific personality disorder (asocial or dissocial). Psychopathic individuals are characterized by high impulsivity, risk, and low interpersonal sensitivity. We can say that those who have repeatedly served their sentences have such traits as selfishness, heartlessness, and ruthlessness.
The number of subjects with a high level of machiavellianism was 12% of those convicted for the first time, which is significantly less than among those who were repeatedly convicted - 64 this is significantly less than the number of previously convicted persons -64%. And to a lesser extent, convicted persons are repeatedly characterized by the ability to accept someone else's point of view, have a low degree of consciousness and personal responsibility.
M. S. Egorova (2009, p. 70) connects "high" machiavellianism with indicators of a dysfunctional personality, whose behavior is compensating, but not for the purpose of achieving power and leadership, but for the purpose of preserving the status of guo. It is assumed that people who repeatedly serve sentences are characterized by emotional coldness, lack of guilt, negativism and increased hostility. This may be due to reduced adaptation due to long-term stay in a correctional institution, well-established antisocial orientation and attitudes, or long-term exposure to the influence of the antisocial environment.
Thus, comparing the differences in the groups of convicts, we can note their specificity. In particular, high levels of dark constructs were identified among a group of repeatedly serving sentences in places of liberty deprivation. The presence of negative personality traits form a single global index of "dark personality". Scales of the "Dark triad" that reflect the negative personality core allow you to quickly get the necessary indices and identify the
Table 1
Results of descriptive statistics in the group of convicts serving their first sentence
Indicators of the "Dark Triad" method Number of subjects Average Median Mode Min. Max. Standard deviation Asymmetry Excess
Narcissism 100 10,3800 10,0000 14,00000 3,0000 20,0000 4,268229 0,096825 -0,913240
Psychopathy 100 6,3800 6,0000 4,000000 3,0000 20,0000 3,080666 1,666589 3,263570
Machiavellianism 100 7,5200 6,0000 4,000000 4,0000 20,0000 4,162070 1,196936 0,686386
Results of descriptive statistics in the group of convicts repeatedly serving their sentences
Table 2
Indicators of the "Dark Triad" method Number of subjects Average Median Mode Min. Max. Standard deviation Asymmetry Excess
Narcissism 100 9,320000 9,000000 4,000000 4,000000 20,00000 4,364411 0,543838 -0,468074
Psychopathy 100 8,030000 6,500000 4,000000 4,000000 20,00000 4,330897 1,051849 0,323026
Machiavellianism 100 9,030000 8,500000 4,000000 4,000000 20,00000 4,529265 0,600386 -0,463044
Results of descriptive statistics in the group of convicts repeatedly serving their sentences
Table 3
Indicators of the "Dark Triad" method GC GR Student's t-test value Significance level of the student's t-test
Narcissism 10,38000 9,320000 1,73640 0,824970
Psychopathy 6,38000 8,030000 -3,10453 0,000811
Machiavellianism 7,52000 9,030000 -2,45481 0,401686
Note. GC - group of convicts serving their first sentence, GR - group of repeatedly convicted persons.
mechanisms of functioning of convicts serving sentences in correctional institutions. Prison psychologists need to take into account the high rates of negative constructs in order to implement psychological support measures for convicts throughout the entire period of serving their sentences.
References
Egorova, M. S. 2009, 'Machiavellianism in the structure of personal properties', Bulletin of Perm State Pedagogical University, Series 10 Differential psychology, iss. 1/2, pp. 65-80.
Kornilova, T. 2015, 'Methods of personality traits diagnostics of the "Dark triad": approbation of the "Dark dozen" questionnaire', Psychological journal, vol. 36, iss. 2, pp. 99-112.
Paulhus, D. L. & Williams K. M. 2002, 'The Dark Triad of personality: Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy', Journal of Research in Personality, vol. 36, pp. 556-563.
Furmanov, I. A. 2001, Socio-psychological problems of behavior, Belarusian State University, Minsk.
Библиографический список
Егорова М. С. Макиавеллизм в структуре личностных свойств // Вестник Пермского государственного педагогического университета. Сер. 10. Диференциальная психология. 2009. № 1/2. С. 65-80.
Корнилова Т. Методика диагностики личностных черт «Темной триады»: апробация опросника «Темная дюжина» // Психологический журнал. 2015. Т. 36, № 2. С. 99-112.
Paulhus, D. L. & Williams K. M. 2002, 'The Dark Triad of personality: Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy', Journal of Research in Personality, vol. 36, pp. 556-563.
Фурманов И. А. Социально-психологические проблемы поведения:курс лекций. Минск : Белорусский государственный университет, 2001. 88 с.
