CC BY
49
PREPAREDNESS OF EDUCATORS TO IMPLEMENT MODERN INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES IN THEIR WORK WITH PRESCHOOL CHILDREN
Dr. Sonja Velickovic, College for Preschool Teachers, Aleksinac, Serbia E-mail: [email protected] Dr. Lazar Stosic, College for Preschool Teachers, Aleksinac Serbia E-mail: [email protected]
A R T I C L E I N F O
Original Article Received: April, 28.2016. Revised: June, 01.2016. Accepted: June, 05.2016. doi:10.5937/IJCRSEE1601023V UDK
004:373.21(497.11) 371.694
Keywords:
modern Information Technologies, educator
professional pedagogical methodological competence, professional development.
and
A B S T R A C T
This study explores the issue of the preparedness of educators to realize the contents of the PPP (Preschool Preparatory Program) from the point of view of digitalization and informatization of the society The authors are in favour of the implementation of modern educational technology in the process of educating preschool children with the aim of improving the quality of educational work. By this we primarily mean the use of computers and didactic programs in kindergartens which are seen as institutions which carry out a systematic and planned education of preschool children. With this objective have the results of the research of the degree to which the educators are prepared to use computer in the process of realization of the contents of the Preparatory preschool program been presented. The results show that educators are interested in implementing ICT (Information and Communication Technology) within the process of educating preschool children who live and grow up in an era of Information Technology. The use of computers can surely help in the process of realization of the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program; however, the truth is that they are not properly trained and qualified to do so, or to be more precise, they do not possess adequate pedagogical and methodological competence to be able to implement modern Information Technologies in their work with preschool children.
© 2016 IJCRSEE. All rights reserved.
1. INTRODUCTION
The implementation of modern technologies is becoming an essential part of modern education. Global exchange of information, movement towards the informatics system, as well as numerous tendencies of modern technologies, bring about the need to adjust the educational system and with that also the educators' environment. The changed role of educators in the era of digitalization has become the imperative of the society and their life-
Corresponding Author
Dr. Sonja Velickovic, College for Preschool Teachers, Aleksinac, Serbia
E-mail: [email protected]
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. The article is published with Open Access at www.ijcrsee.com
long learning and professional development have become the priority. Professional development of educators implies "... the raising of consciousness of educators in terms of what, how and in what way they can improve the educational process"' (Stosic and Velickovic, 2011:305).
The quality of educational work with preschool children can be improved and become better by means of studying the possibility of implementing Information and Communication Technologies and especially by means of focusing on the importance of the possibility of implementing modern education technology in the process of educating preschool children. Familiarization with the great creative potential which Information Technology possesses in the process of raising the quality of educational work, represents motivational factor which can encourage educators to broaden their informatic knowledge.
The implementation of Information
Technology in preschool education should be realized through its application and integration within the educational work of educators, the main aim of which would be to create numerous possibilities of significant improvement of the quality of educational work and maximum involvement of children in the learning process. The use of ICT in work with preschool children is difficult to accept and the reason for that is most frequently the lack of education and information on the part of educators (Stosic, 2011), as well as the fear of the unknown. Within educational activity all over the world, as well as in our country, the introduction of various innovations is still facing strong resistance of educators' traditionalism, indifference and inertness and it also provokes fear, rejection and irrational hostility. Up to a certain point, this is even understandable because older generations of educators were not trained to use modern technology in preschool teaching. Unlike older generations, new generations are coming fully or partially prepared to properly guide children into the world in which computers are used, and those computers are becoming their everyday companions. Thus "... as educators improve their knowledge related with the use of various technologies, the accompanying hardware equipment and with programs that can be used in their work with children, they will gain more confidence in their work, broaden their horizons in terms of possibilities offered by new media and Information and Communication Technologies and increase creativity with their implementation in everyday educational work" (Arsenijevic and Andevski, 2011:29).
The mastering of basic skills related with operating a computer on the part of educators is the priority which precedes the introduction of Information Technology into educational work and the development of technical culture of preschool children. However, the first obstacle turned out to be the preconceptions regarding the age of educators and their insufficient knowledge related with the use of computers. Although older educators guess the possible usefulness and purpose of the use of Information Technology, the younger ones are aware of its benefits, especially when it comes to handling pedagogical documentation, professional development and obtaining information; however, they do not have programs and sufficient equipment for educational work.
The new media and the ICT can, if used, fundamentally change the system and the design of educational work, which is why their proper implementation requires pedagogical
knowledge of working with children in such conditions, as well as the knowledge of the methodology of their use.
That is the reason why, in recent years, more attention has been paid to the training of future educators in terms of introducing Information Technologies into the educational system. In Preschool Teacher Training Colleges of Vocational Studies, there are subject programs within the field of Information Technology which require user-level knowledge acquisition (operative system, Internet, text processing programs, drawing programs, presentation-making programs, video and sound processing programs, getting to know the ready-made educational software, the use of various hardware components - printer, scanner, cameras, etc.).
1.1. Professional Competence of Educators in Implementing Modern Information Technologies
Modern Information Technologies have found their use in all the spheres of society, including the sphere of education. Within new educational technologies, multimedia didactic programs represent the treasury of teaching aids and resources which contribute to the modernization of educational work.
The changes in Information Technologies and changes within the society caused by those changes, recognize that educators should be able to modernize their work and to acquire new competence. New competence refers to informatic knowledge necessary in the 21st century, which means that educators should be able to make didactic materials independently in electronic form and use computers more often as a modern tool in the process of realization of program contents with preschool children, replacing overhead projectors, tape recorders, slide projectors, movie projector, episcopes and other obsolete devices and aids.
A 21st century educator should have professional, pedagogical and methodological competence. As stated by Arsenijevic & Andevski, „expert ICT competences are those competences of educators which are necessary for the direct use of these technologies in teaching or otherwise and for their areas of application. Pedagogical and methodological competences are those competences which enable educators to use new media and technologies in their work with children in an ad-
equate way, as teaching aids, as well as teaching subjects'" (Arsenijevic and Andevski 2011: 28).
Pedagogical intuition, sensibility, creativity and computer literacy are all qualities of crucial importance for educators' profession, which is why they should be constantly improved and developed through a permanent learning process, cooperation with colleagues, parents and most importantly with children. In their work with children educators must be able to use computers and computer programs, but they can also create computer programs because only they have practical experience working with children.
With the aim of developing professional competence of educators for the purpose of achieving better quality of their work and further professional development, as Grandic and Stipic state "professional development should be seen as a requirement of general importance for the profession, as well as an inner need of an individual' (Grandic and Stipic, 2011:199). Apart from that, educators have the obligation to attend and participate in seminars approved by the Ministry of Education listed in the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Teachers, Educators and Associates. The first issue of the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Teachers, Educators and Associates started being used during the school year 2006/2007 and it was published every year, but starting from the school year 2012/2013, the Catalogue is authorized every two years and it is only available in electronic form. Everyone working in the area of education, has the obligation to achieve 120 points in a period of five years - 100 points for attending the approved programs, (60 hours from the list of mandatory subjects and 40 hours from the list of elective ones), and up to 20 points for participating in approved professional seminars (Article 12. of the Law on the Basics of Educational System, 2013).
Based on the analyses of the Catalogue, it can be concluded that the number of accredited programs is increasing year after year, including the area of preschool education. The first issue of the Catalogue of the Program for Professionals in the Area of Education included a total of 173 accredited programs, 7 of which were related with the area of preschool education, whereas the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Professionals in the Area of Education for the school years 2012/2013 and 2013/2014 included 1021 accredited programs, 80 of which were
related with the area of preschool education.
In terms of the accredited programs related with training educators to use Information Technologies in their work with preschool children, we can say that there is a really paradoxal situation there, namely, there was no accredited program with the stated topic in the first issue of the Catalogue. The next issue of the Catalogue for the school year 2007/2008, had one accredited program named "Child in the World of Computers", and all the following issues of the Catalogue contained the "Virtual Kindergarten" accredited program as a mandatory program. According to the statistics of the Institute of Improvement and Development of Education, for the school year 20l 1/2012, there were three seminars, and a total of 47 educators attended the "Virtual Kindergarten" accredited program. In the school years 2012/2013 and 2013/2014 and up to the present moment, there was no interest whatsoever. This tells us that the issue of introducing modern Information Technologies in preschool education is not treated with much enthusiasm, and that there is no "sound and systematic support to the professional development of educators with the aim of realizing Preparatory Preschool Program with more quality" (Velickovic, 2014:120), which also implies greater degree of the ability of educators to implement modern Information Technologies in their work with preschool children.
It is obvious that our educators are, in terms of computer literacy, far behind their colleagues from EU countries. For example, the Swedish government has, in its attempt to fulfill its ambition and become IT leader in the whole world (which it actually achieved), put the introduction of new media and ICT to all levels of educational system as the top priority on the list of priorities, seeing them as an overall function which facilitates all other activities. That is the reason why the educational institutions in Sweden are highly technologically equipped, including the preschool institutions. More than half of the teaching staff (around 75,000) included in education of children and adults alike, is attending at least one kind of training provided by the government itself, and carried out with the help of specially trained informatic consultants.
1.2. The Implementation and Integration of ICT in Educational Work with Preschool Children
The acceptance of the specific nature of educational work with preschool children, as well as of the principles and of long-term aims in that work, requires special approach of Information Technology in preschool educational system.
Information Technology in education offers the possibility of using new methods and new organization of educational work, which would reduce the limitations of the traditional way of work to a tolerable level. Education technology should not only be understood as a simple use of computers (which is, due to numerous possibilities that they offer, inevitable nowadays), but rather as the implementation of diverse forms, ways and methods of work within the educational process which are enabled by means of various devices, such as different forms of television, videos, satellites, telecommunications, educational networks and services, optical technologies and the like (Danilovic, 2010).
The implementations of Information Technologies are numerous, however, theoreticians and researchers single out three most important ones:
1. the acquisition of new knowledge -the use of educational programs,
2. revision and repetition of the acquired knowledge,
3. different leisure activities: games, drawings (Recicki and Girtner, 2002).
Children should experience enormous possibilities which Information Technologies offer. It is essential that educators use their numerous potentials and thus achieve positive effect in all the areas of child development, raise the quality of all the segments of educational work and develop media culture of children.
There were some opinions that claimed that computers are not suitable for preschool children, because they are very complex machines which require certain level of intellectual development, especially a high level of abstract thought. However, the development of the so called user-friendly approach, which is directed towards making the technology available to users, has in great measure dismantled the myth which lead us to believe that only trained adults can use them (Pribisev Be-leslin, 2007:20).
Information Technology (which includes computer games) offers stimulation
of the senses through pictures, sounds, tones, films etc. This kind of multimedia representation increases children's attention and speeds up the learning process. In The Basics of the Preschool Education Program it has been determined that computers have their own place in various music, art, perceptive, logic and other activities. Generally speaking, computer games are great fun for children. At a very early stage of their development, using computer programs, children discover cause and effect relations of their own actions. Didactic programs enable improvement in accordance with children's abilities, generating, at every stage that a child reaches, the feeling of competence , and with that, it encourages children's self-confidence, self-respect and self-consciousness. Playing and dealing with programs which were specifically made for them, children have the opportunity to be creative, to direct their thoughts towards finding solutions and overcoming obstacles.
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS
The aim of the research was to determine the level of competence of educators in terms of their ability to use computers in the process of carrying out the Preparatory Preschool Program. The tasks related with the objectives of the research were the following:
- Exploring the level of competence of educators in terms of their ability to use computers,
- Finding out whether the educators are familiar with programs from the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Professionals in the Area of Education regarding the use of ICT,
- Finding out whether the educators are sufficiently trained to use computers in the process of implementing the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program,
- Finding out to what extent the educators are interested in education within the area of education technology,
- Exploring the situation of educators with the aim of finding out whether educators have support from the director and the administration department of their preschool institution regarding the implementation of computers in their work with preschool children.
In accordance with the proposed research tasks, the following hypothesis and sub-hypothesis have been postulated. The general hypothesis of this research is: It is presumed that educators are not sufficiently
trained and prepared to use computers in the process of realizing the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program.
The instrument used in the research was the Likert scale, made especially for the purpose of this research; it consisted of 12 items which represented indicators of the competence of educators in terms of their ability to use ICT in their work.
The sample used in the research consisted of educators from the preschool institution ''Nasa radost'', as well as of the educators from the preschool groups in ''Branko Radicevic'' primary school in Bujanovac. The research was conducted with the teaching staff at the beginning of the year 2015.
In our sample of 50 (100% valid sample) subjects, the value of Cronbach's Alpha Quotient= 0,805, shows high level of reliability and internal compliance of the scale for this sample, which completely satisfies the reliability criteria.
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table 1. shows the opinions of educators as to whether or not kindergartens should have IT rooms for preschool children computer training.
Table 1. Opinions of educators as to whether or not kindergartens should have IT rooms
Valid Cumulative Frequency Peice:it£?e _ _
^ J_" Percentage Percentage
I mostly agree 11 22% 22% 22%
I agree 25 50% 50% 72%
I totally agree 14 2S % 2S % 100 %
Total 50 100% 100%
The results above show that 11 educators (22%) mostly agree, 25 educators (50%) agree and 14 educators (28%) totally agree that kindergartens should have IT rooms for preschool children computer training.
The obtained results show that educators are very interested in having an IT room in their kindergartens for preschool children computer training.
Graph 1. shows the results of the claim which states that Educators are not sufficiently trained and prepared to use computers in the process of realizing the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program''.
Graph 1. Opinions of educators related with their computer competence in the process of realizing the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program
Out of the total number of subjects, 31 educators, that is 62 % of them agree that educators are not sufficiently trained and prepared to use computers in the process of realizing the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program, 9 educators responded that they mostly agree, which represents 18 % of subjects, 8 subjects totally agree with the claim, whereas only 2 educators disagree with the claim stating that educators are not sufficiently trained and prepared to use computers in the process of realizing the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program.
Chi-squared test=7.654, obtained by means of statistical analyses, for 6 degrees of freedom, p=0,265, which is not statistically significant, indicates that educators are not sufficiently trained and prepared to use computers in the process of realizing the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program. If we take into account the level of education, we can conclude that the results are not statistically very different.
Table 2. shows the structure of samples according to the level of education of educators.
Table 2. The structure of samples according to the level of education of subjects
Valid Cumulative
Frequency Percentile
- percentage percentage
College 20 40% 40% 40%
University IS 36% 36% 16%
Applied Studies 12 24% 24% 100 %
Total 50 100 % 100%
Out of the total number of subjects in the study, 20 (40%) subjects had a college degree, 18 educators, that is 36%, had a university degree and 12 subjects, or 24% of them, had obtained the Applied Studies degree for preschool teachers.
Graph 2. shows the structure of the samples according to the years of service of educators.
4% 14% ■ u p to 10 years
^^^n J 26% £ A 56% . from 10 to 20
years
from 20 to 30
years
Graph 2. Structure of the samples according to the years of service of the subjects
When it comes to the years of service, the greatest number of subjects (56%) belongs to the category of lowest number of the years of service, up to 10 years, 26% of educators belong to the category 10-20 years of service, 14% educators belong to the category 20-30 years of service and 4% of educators are those with more than 30 years of service.
We believe that "younger" educators, younger in terms of years of service, agree more that computers should be used, because younger generations live and grow in a digi-talized environment, which is why they are more open to and also use more, on a daily basis, some of the forms of modern Information Technologies (social networks, e-banking, chip IDs and cards, etc.), and are thus aware of the usefulness of computers when it comes to educational work. Therefore, this research showed that "younger" educators, younger in terms of years of service, have positive attitude towards modern Information Technologies.
Graph 3. shows the results of the opinion of educators related with the issue of whether or not educators are familiar with programs of education technology from the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Professionals in the Area of Education, regarding the use of ICT.
I totally agree I agree I mostly agree I disagree I totally disagree
H
.-J
J 1 s
the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Professionals in the Area of Education
Regarding the results related with the claim that "Educators are familiar with programs of education technology from the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Professionals in the Area of Education ", 25 educators, or 50% of them, agree that educators are familiar with programs of education technology from the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Professionals in the Area of Education. Sixteen educators responded that they mostly agree, which represents 32% of subjects. Four educators, or 8% of them, totally agree, 3 educators, or 6% of them disagree, whereas 2 subjects, or 4% of them totally disagree with the claim that educators are familiarized with programs of education technology from the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Professionals in the Area of Education.
The presented results show that most of the subjects agree with the claim which states that educators are familiar with programs of education technology from the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Professionals in the Area of Education. The results are certainly encouraging, because they indicate that educators are interested in their own education and professional development.
Chi-squared test =14.051, obtained by means of statistical analyses, for 8 degrees of freedom, p=0,080, which is not statistically significant, indicates that educators are familiar with programs of education technology from the Catalogue of the Program for Professional Development of Professionals in the Area of Education.
Graph 4. shows the results of the opinion of educators regarding the issue of the extent to which educators are interested in im-em en ting ICT in kindergartens.
Graph 3. Educators are familiarized with programs of education technology from
18 17 16 15 14 13
17
15 18
/
I mostly agree
I agree
totally
agree
Graph 4. Interest of educators regarding the implementation of ICT in kindergartens
The obtained results related with the claim that "Educators are interested in education within the area of Information Technology" showed that 21 educators, or 42% of them, agree that educators are interested in education within the area of Information Technology. Twelve educators responded that they mostly agree, which represents 24% of the subjects, and 17 educators, or 34% of them, totally agree with the claim that educators are interested in education within the area of Information Technology.
The results clearly show that educators are very interested in implementing ICT in kindergartens.
Chi-squared test=5.806, obtained by means of statistical analyses, for 4 degrees of freedom, p=0,214, which is not statistically significant, indicates that educators are interested in education within the area of Information Technology.
Graph 5. shows the results related with the claim that "Educators have the support of the director and the administration department of their preschool institution regarding the implementation of computers in their work with preschool children''.
.11
I totally I disagree I mostly disagree agree
agree I totally agree
Graph 5. Opinions of educators related with the issue of whether or not educators have support from the director and the administration department of their preschool institution regarding the implementation of computers in their work with preschool children
The obtained results related with the claim that "Educators have support from the director and the administration department of their preschool institution regarding the implementation of computers in their work with preschool children", show that 19 educators, or 38 % of them, agree with the claim that educators have support from the director and the administration department of their preschool institution regarding the implementation of computers in their work with preschool children. Twenty-two educators responded that they mostly agree, which represents 44% of subjects. One educator, or 2% of them, totally
agrees, whereas 6 educators, or 12% of them disagree with the claim which states that educators have support from the director and the administration department of their preschool institution regarding the implementation of computers in their work with preschool children.
Chi-squared test=15.659, obtained by means of statistical analyses, for 8 degrees of freedom, p=0,048, which is not statistically significant, indicates that educators have support from the director and the administration department of their preschool institution regarding the implementation of computers in their work with preschool children.
4. CONCLUSION
Using theoretical research and analyses of the attitudes of educators regarding the implementation of modern Information Technologies in their work with preschool children, we wanted to find out opinions of educators as to whether the use of computers can help in the process of realization of the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program.
If we compare the results of this research with the results of previous ones, which the author, Stosic (2011), conducted with students who had rich working experience in preschool institutions, and who were attending the College of Vocational Studies for Preschool Teachers in Aleksinac for the sake of receiving additional education, we can conclude that the competence of educators in terms of their ability to implement ICT in their work with preschool children is at a very low level.
If we add to that the fact that professional development of educators through informal forms of education, mostly training programs and projects aimed at implementing the modern Information Technology in educational work is not present enough, we can reach the conclusion that educators do not possess sufficient professional pedagogical and methodological competences in the area of realizing the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program which confirms the postulated hypothesis. This thesis is also supported by a one-time training through Virtual Kindergarten accredited program which the educators from the preschool institution ''Nasa Radost'' from Bujanovac had in 2013, which implies that educators need continuous and systematic support in the area of ICT, in order for them to be able to use all the advantages of the ICT, and also facilitate their everyday work in the
process. Above everything else, the number of professional seminars in which educators will have to prove or improve their knowledge should be increased.
The encouraging fact in our research is that educators are not passive when it comes to implementing computers in the process of realizing the contents of the Preparatory Preschool Program; they are rather interested in having an IT room for informatic training of preschool children in their institutions and most of the subject agree on that.
A successful implementation of Information Technologies within the system of educational work depends, primarily, on the awareness and responsibility of educators themselves regarding their very usefulness, for both professional development and technical culture of children.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Special thanks to the educators from the preschool institution ''Nasa radost'', as well as of the educators from the preschool groups in ''Branko Radicevic'' primary school in Bu-janovac. for their organizational help with this project. Also, we would like to thank Daniela Kraljic, the director of "Educamentis centar" from Nis for their translation and proofreading services.
Conflict of interests
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
REFERENCES
Arsenijevic, J., Andevski, M. (2011). Kompetencije vaspitaca za upotrebu novih medija i tehnologi-ja, Zbornik Visoke skole strukovnih studija za obrazovanje vaspitaca u Kikindi, br.2, 25-35. Danilovic, M. (2010). Tehnika, obrazovna tehnologija i informatika u funkciji povecanja efikasnosti ob-razovnog procesa ucenja, Tehnicka informatika u obrazovanju, 3. Internacionalna konferencija, Cacak: Tehnicki fakultet. Grandic, R., Stipic, M. (2011). Profesionalni razvoj nastavnika-put do kvalitetnog obrazovanja, Pedagoska stvarnost, br.3-4, 198-209. Katalog programa strucnog usavrsavanja zaposlen-ih u obrazovanju za skolsku 2012/2013. i 2013/2014., Beograd: Zavod za unapredivanje vaspitanja i obrazovanja, dostupno na: http:// www.zuov.gov.rs/novisajt2012/index.html Pribisev Beleslin, T. (2007). Susretanje u elektronskom svetu: Deca, vaspitaci, kompjuteri, vrtici, Banja Luka: Fakultet drustvenih nauka. Recicki, Z., Girtner, Z. (2002). Dete i komjuter, Beograd: Zavod za udzbenike i nastavna sredstva. Velickovic, S. (2014). Profesionalni razvoj vaspitaca
u funkciji unapredivanja kvaliteta Pripremnog predskolskog programa, Pedagoska stvarnost, LX.(1), 112-121. Zakon o osnovama sistema obrazovanja i vaspitanja,
(„Sl.glasnik RS", br. 52/2011 i 55/2013). Stosic, L., Velickovic, S. (2011). Education and professional development of educators of preschool education, Инновационный потенциал субъектов образовательного пространства в условиях модернизации образования, Россия, Ростов-на-Дону, pp. 305-312. Stosic, L. (2011). Pripremljenost vaspitaca u oblas-ti tehnickog i informatickog obrazovanja, Tehnologija, informatika i obrazovanje za drustvo ucenja i znanja, Cacak:Tehnicki fakultet dostupno na: http://www.ftn.kg.ac.rs/konfer-encije/tio6/radovi/7)%20Tehnicko%20i%20 informaticko%20obrazovanje/PDF/703%20 Lazar%20Stosic.pdf Каталог програма сталног стручног усавршавааа наставника, Retireved from http://www.zuov. rs/programi1/Odrzani.aspx
