CC BY
23
Injj
МЕЖДУНАРОДНЫЙ НЕВРОЛОГИЧЕСКИЙ ЖУРНАЛ
ОРИГШАЛЬШ ДОСЛЩЖЕННЯ
/ORIGINAL RESEARCHES/
UDC 616.71007.234:577.161.2 DOI: 10.22141/2224-0713.16.4.2020.207345
S.P. Moskovko1, D.O. Fiks1, A.V. Shayuk2
1National Pirogov Memorial Medical University, Vinnytsia, Ukraine
2Zhytomyr Ivan Franko State University, Zhytomyr, Ukraine
Assessment of compliance with current clinical guidelines on clinical and hardware diagnosis of stroke according to the data of the Vinnytsia register
for the period of 2017-2019
Abstract. Background. Carrying out comparative analysis of representative regional data on the level of diagnosis at the hospital stage of stroke management for a certain period of time and between different medical establishments allows us to form correctly a set of medical and preventive measures and to develop consistent recommendations for their improvement. The purpose: to assess the dynamics of quality indicators of clinical and hardware diagnosis of stroke for the period of2017—2019 and to conduct a comparative analysis between the studied health care institutions. Materials and methods. According to the case histories, a comparative analysis was carried out on the level of organization of clinical and hardware diagnosis in the Municipal Non-Profit Enterprise "Academician O.I. Yush-chenko Vinnytsia Regional Clinical Psychoneurological Hospital of Vinnytsia Regional Council" (VRCPNH) and Vinnytsia City Clinical Emergency Hospital (VCCEH) in 2017—2019. Statistical processing of the results was performed using Statistica 5.5 package. Results. Significant differences were found in the number of VRCPNH and VCCEH patients who underwent evaluation of stroke severity on the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale at hospital stage, neuroimaging in the first hours of the disease, ultrasound of the neck vessels, atrial fibrillation and dysphagia screening, consultations of speech therapist and physiotherapist. In each hospital, there was a positive trendfor three years after the completion of all diagnostic measures and procedures. Conclusions. The results of the study confirmed the adequacy of the studied quality indicators and the feasibility of further implementation of the hospital registry method in other regions of Ukraine to assess and control the quality of care, including the analysis of the effectiveness of new technologies.
Keywords: stroke; computed tomography; dysphagia screening; atrial fibrillation; speech therapist; physiotherapist
Introduction
According to the World Federation of Neurology, more than 15 million strokes are registered annually. Acute cerebral circulatory disorders (ACCD) is a major medical and social problem, they occupy the leading position in the structure of general disability and mortality, both in Ukraine and worldwide [1].
To confirm the presence of stroke, its origin and nature, it is necessary to carefully collect anamnesis, assess the
neurological status, general condition of the patient and to ensure timely use of diagnostic examination methods [2]. Given the heterogeneous pathogenesis of stroke, the accuracy and timeliness of diagnosis of its nature is the most important task, since diagnostic manipulations that enter the therapeutic window affect the outcome and prognosis for this pathology [3, 4].
When a patient with a clinical picture of stroke is taken to a medical institution, the primary task of the doctor is to
© «Ммнародний невролопчний журнал» / «Международный неврологический журнал» / «International Neurological Journal» («Mezdunarodnyj nevrologiceskij zumal»), 2020 © Видавець Заславський О.Ю. / Издатель Заславский А.Ю. / Publisher Zaslavsky O.Yu., 2020
Для кореспонденци: Московко Серпй Петрович, доктор медичних наук, професор, завщувач кафедри нервових хвороб, Вшницький нацюнальний медичний ушверситет iM. М.1. Пирогова, вул. Пирогова, 56, м. Вшниця, 21018, УкраТна; факс: +38(0432)661393; е-mail: spmoskovko@gmail.com; контактний тел.: +38(050)3138464
For correspondence: Sergiy Moskovko, MD, PhD, Professor, Head of the Department of Nervous Diseases, National Pirogov Memorial Medical University, Vinnytsia, Pirogov street, 56, Vinnytsia, 21018, Ukraine; fax: +38(0432)661393; е-mail: spmoskovko@gmail.com; phone: +38(050)3138464
assess the severity of the patient's condition with subsequent fixation in the medical record. The use of diagnostic scales (Glasgow Coma Scale, National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS), Orgogozo, etc.) allows you to form an adequate understanding of the condition of a particular patient, helps reasonably determine the strategy of therapy, evaluate the potential risks and benefits of specific treatments in extremely difficult cases [5].
In most specialized hospitals, computed tomography (CT) is initially performed as the gold standard and a faster study that excludes cerebral hemorrhage, tumors, and other diseases. The information obtained from the results of neuroimaging in the first hours of the disease serves a basis for deciding on the feasibility and the indications for continuing the work of the multidisciplinary team for thrombolysis [6].
Ischemic strokes account for up to 80 % of all ACCD
[7]. More than half of ischemic strokes are to some extent associated with atherosclerotic lesions of extracranial arteries. With carotid artery stenosis exceeding 70 % of vessel diameter, the annual incidence of ipsilateral stroke is 10—15 %
[8]. The use of ultrasound duplex scan of the neck vessels allows us to detect atherosclerotic plaques, to assess their condition and hemodynamic disorders due to their presence. The revealed changes in hemodynamics make it possible to evaluate objectively the level of cerebral ischemic disorders
[9]. Therefore, all patients need this study.
Dysphagia is one of the major neurological dysfunctions in ischemic stroke. This disorder is a risk factor for aspiration and pneumonia, increasing disability and mortality after stroke. Currently, dysphagia screening protocols are widely used to identify patients with low risk of aspiration, allowing safe feeding and oral therapy [10]. The effectiveness of screening for dysphagia to reduce the incidence of mortality or aspiration pneumonia has been demonstrated [11].
Stroke and diseases such as atrial fibrillation, diabetes mellitus, myocardial infarction, thrombosis of the lower extremities, systemic diseases of the connective tissue, and others are regarded as interrelated nosologies, because on the one hand, the risk of stroke in patients with these diseases is higher than in the population, and on the other hand, the course of stroke is mostly complicated due to them [12]. Therefore, it is important to conduct screening for the presence of this pathology and to isolate a group of patients in the hospital registry on its basis.
The work of speech therapist as a part of multidisci-plinary team is an important component of the entire stroke management measures. Logopedic care begins with the early rehabilitation stage in the intensive care unit or stroke unit where patients with ACCD are admitted. In the most acute and acute period of stroke, speech therapist-defectologist deals with not only neuropsychological problems, but also with severe swallowing disorders, which require special skills and qualified assistance [13].
One of the main consequences of stroke is impaired locomotor activity, problems with motor coordination, muscle hypertonia, etc. Full rehabilitation is not possible without physiotherapy, and in this case, it is a priority. Exact infor-
mation about a rehabilitation plan involving several techniques can only be provided by a physiotherapist, a rehabilitation specialist during an in-person consultation with each patient [14].
Upon acquisition of the above data, it becomes available to identify certain gaps in the work and to provide guidance on planning interventions to improve the care of stroke patients. The realization of this task is possible only with the creation of hospital and regional registers to assess on their basis the situation with ACCD in a particular hospital and region, and subsequently, in repeated epidemiological studies, — to determine the effectiveness of the preventive and organizational measures [15].
The purpose of the study: to evaluate the dynamics of quality indicators of clinical and hardware diagnosis of stroke for the period of 2017—2019 and to carry out comparative analysis between the studied medical and preventive establishments.
Materials and methods
Medical establishments, which are typical enough for the given region of Ukraine, were selected for maintaining the register. The work is based on the results of a retrospective analysis of case histories of patients, urgently hospitalized to the stroke unit of the Municipal Non-Profit Enterprise "Academician O.I. Yushchenko Vinnytsia Regional Clinical Psychoneurological Hospital of Vinnytsia Regional Council" (VRCPNH) and Vinnytsia City Clinical Emergency Hospital (VCCEH) in 2017-2019 with a diagnosis of acute cerebral circulation disorder (Table 1). The RES-Q report form, a special report forms in the international program developed by the ESO-EAST initiative of the European Stroke Organisation, used by the vast majority of stroke clinics in Europe, was completed on a case-by-case basis at the end. Since 2017, Vinnytsia hospitals surveyed by us are participating in this program. RES-Q (version 1.0) provides information not only on the clinical parameters of a stroke, but also on the timing of individual procedures, which characterizes the work of the institution and serves as an indicator of the quality of work.
The mean age of VRCPNH patients was: in 2017 — 62.40 ± 0.59 years for men and 66.48 ± 0.79 years for women; in 2018 — 60.85 ± 0.59 years for men and 65.54 ± 0.65 years for women; in 2019 — 61.24 ± 0.57 years for men and 64.41 ± 0.84 years for women. The mean age of VCCEH patients was: in 2017 — 67.18 ± 0.60 years for men and 72.53 ± 0.54 years for women; in 2018 — 67.10 ± ± 0.64 years for men and 72.01 ± 0.59 years for women; in 2019 — 67.66 ± 0.78 years for men and 72.67 ± 0.82 years for women.
In the acute period and in the dynamics of stroke, the NIHSS is used to determine the severity of the disease, for scheduling thrombolysis. The scale allows us to detect the affected vessels, to carry out differential diagnosis; its use is a preparatory stage in predicting disease outcomes and features of the course [16].
Due to the need for neuroimaging in differentiated treatment of acute cerebral circulation disorders [17], the percentage of patients who underwent CT scans was determined.
Inj
OpHriHaflbHi gociiigffieHHi /Original Researches/
Table 1. Distribution of patients with acute stroke in the VRCPNH and VCCEH stroke unit in 2017-2019
Health care institution Sex 2017 2018 10 months of 2019
Total IS HS Total IS HS Total IS HS
VRCPNH Male 307 269 37 312 267 45 287 248 39
Female 209 184 25 187 166 21 175 152 23
VCCEH Male 351 308 42 310 276 34 182 162 20
Female 335 296 39 306 282 24 163 153 10
Notes: IS — ischemic stroke; HS — hemorrhagic stroke.
When analyzing the duration of neuroimaging examination, the number of stroke patients is most indicative for assessing the quality of care in the first hours from the moment of admission to the hospital [18].
Given the multidisciplinary nature of the stroke problem [19], the presence of a speech therapist, a physiotherapist during the patient's stay in the hospital, the use of stroke-related procedures and measures (dysphagia screening, atrial fibrillation, ultrasound of the neck vessels) were evaluated.
Bioethics Committee of National Pirogov Memorial Medical University in Vinnytsia (protocol no. 6 dated 23.03.2017) found that the conducted studies did not contradict the basic bioethical standards of the Declaration of Helsinki, the Council of Europe Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine (1977), the relevant provisions of the World Health Organization and laws of Ukraine.
Statistical processing of the results was performed with the help of Statistica 5.5 package (license number AXXR910A374605FA) using parametric estimation methods.
Results
An analysis of the NIHSS use in general indicates a frequent neglect of these data in VCCEH (in 2017, the procedure was not performed: for 7.1-8.4 % of men, 7.1-9.3 % of women; in 2018: for 7.1-8.0 % of men, 10.1-10.6 % of women; in 2019: for 48.4-48.8 % of men, 58.8-58.9 % of women; p < 0.01-0.001) compared to VRCPNH (in 2017, the procedure was not completed: for 0-0.3 % of men; 0-1.4 % of women; in 2018: for 0.30.4 % of men, 0 % of women; in 2019: for 0 % of men and women; p < 0.01-0.001).
Moreover, if a comparison is made between the years studied, the percentage of patients who underwent this procedure in VRCPNH is fairly high (no difference between 2017, 2018 and 2019) (p > 0.05). The situation with the application of this scale for all patient groups in VCCEH in 2018 and 2019 is even worse than in 2017 (p < 0.05-0.001), which implies the need to improve organizational arrangements, training and awareness of nursing staff on this issue.
CT diagnosis of stroke was insufficient in VCCEH (survey conducted in 2017: 85.8-95.5 % of men; 84.8-94.9 % of women with ischemic stroke and stroke in general, p < 0.01-0.001; in 2018: 79.2 % of women with hemorrhagic stroke, p < 0.05; in 2019: 95.1-95.7 % of men with
ischemic stroke and stroke in general, p < 0.05-0.001) compared to VRCPNH, which had enough objective reasons: staffing problems, the inability to conduct the examination 24/7 for a certain period of time (repair, technical malfunction), refusal of the patient and his relatives from the examination.
Despite the absence of the tomograph directly in VCCEH, the overall percentage of patients examined in this hospital for the period of 2017-2019 increased significantly (p < 0.05-0.001). It is worth noting that organization of CT for ischemic strokes was good in VRCPNH over all three years (no difference between 2017, 2018, and 2019; p > 0.05), and situation with neuroimaging in hemorrhagic strokes has improved (no survey conducted: 8.1 % of men in 2017, and 0 % of men in 2018 and 2019; p < 0.05).
In VRCPNH, the number of patients who underwent neuroimaging during the therapeutic window is significantly higher (procedure performed in 2017: for 83.8-98.9 % of men; 76.0-98.9 % of women; in 2018: for 96.2-95.6 % of men, 93.4-95.6 % of women; in 2019: for 97.4-98.0 % of men, 94.1-100 % of women; p < 0.001) compared with VCCEH (procedure performed in 2017: for 15.3-21.4% of men; 10.3-11.5 % of women; in 2018: for 29.3-38.2 % of men, 34.0-41.7 % of women; in 2019: for 55.0-56.8 % of men, 53.6-80.0 % of women; p < 0.01-0.001).
At the same time, positive changes in the percentage of patients examined in the first hours of the disease (p < 0.05-0.001) were observed in both medical institutions from 2017 to 2019.
When comparing the two wards, a statistically significant prevalence was found in the number of patients undergoing dysphagia screening in VRCPNH (procedure performed in 2017: 83.1 % of men in total and 89.2 % of men with hemorrhagic stroke; 85.3 % of women with ischemic stroke, p < 0.05; in 2018: 97.8-98.5 % of men, 100 % of women; in 2019: 99.7-100 % of men, 98.7-98.9 % ofwomen with ischemic stroke and stroke in general, p < 0.05-0.001) compared to VCCEH (procedure performed in 2017: 76.1 % of men in total and 71.4 % of men with hemorrhagic stroke; 77.0 % of women with ischemic stroke, p < 0.05; in 2018: 85.3-91.3 % of men, 83.3-89.7 % of women; in 2019: 90.7-91.4 % of men, 92.6-92.8 % of women with ischemic stroke and stroke in general, p < 0.05-0.001).
Given the availability of the procedure and the equal ability to screen for dysphagia in the inpatients under study, VCCEH may assume either an inadequate level of orga-
nization of diagnostic measures or a lack of knowledge to identify signs of dysphagia that necessitates training of nursing staff.
For the period of 2017—2019, there is a significant positive trend in each of the two wards regarding dysphagia screening in patients of all groups. So, the number of patients who were not screened decreased in VRCPNH (2017: 8.1—17.8 % of men; 14.1—20.0 % of women, compared to 2018: 0-0.4 % of men; 0 % of women, p < 0.05-0.001, and to 2019: 0 % of men; 0-0.7 % of women, p < 0.05-0.001). A similar situation was observed in VCCEH (2017: 22.123.8 % of men; 12.8-23.0 % of women, compared to 2018: 6.9-8.3 % of men; 0-9.9 % of women, p < 0.05-0.001, and to 2019: 5.8-8.6 % of men; 0-6.5 % of women, p < 0.05-0.001).
When comparing the number of patients who were consulted by a speech therapist and a physiotherapist, significant differences were found between the two wards. So, significantly (p < 0.05-0.001) higher number of patients were consulted by these specialists in VRCPNH (2017: 87.9 % of men in general and 87.4 % of men with ischemic stroke; 2018: 99.7 % of men in general, 96.6 % of men with ischemic stroke, 100 % of men with hemorrhagic stroke; women in general and with ischemic stroke — 100 %) compared to VCCEH (2017: 80.1 % of men in general and 80.2 % of men with ischemic stroke; 2018: 90.3 % of men in general, 91.3 % of men with ischemic stroke, 82.4 % of men with hemorrhagic stroke; women in general and with ischemic stroke — 90.3 %).
From 2017 to 2019, the number of patients consulted by a speech therapist and physiotherapist increased significantly in VRCPNH (2017: 87.4-91.9 % of men; 85.988.0 % of women compared to 2018: 99.7-100 % of men; 100 % of women, p < 0.05-0.001, and to 2019: 96.8-100 % of men; 96.6-96.9 % of women (except for hemorrhagic stroke), p < 0.05-0.001). VCCEH also showed a significant increase in this indicator (2017: 80.1-80.2 % of men; 80.0-80.1 % of women in total and with ischemic stroke compared to 2018 (similar comparison groups): 90.391.3 % of men, 94.4-94.7 % of women, p < 0.05-0.001, and to 2019: 94.4-94.5.0 % of men, 95.1-95.4 % of women, p < 0.05-0.001).
It was found that in VRCPNH, ultrasound of the neck vessels was performed: in 2017, for 66.1-77.5 % of men and
60.3-75.5 % of women; in 2018, for 77.6-90.6 % of men and 70.6-78.9 % of women; in 2019, for 76.7-88.7 % of men and 71.4-82.2 % of women, which is significantly higher (p < 0.05-0.001) compared to VCCEH: in 2017 — 13.415.3 % of men and 5.1-5.7 % of women; in 2018 — 5.25.8 % of men and 2.0-2.1 % of women; in 2019 — 8.29.3 % of men and 8.0-8.5 % of women.
Worse situation with atrial fibrillation screening was noted in VCCEH: 49.2-56.1 % (2017), 54.2-60.9 % (2018), 52.2-58.0 % (2019) of men and 44.5-55.5 % (2017), 41.8-45.0 % (2018), 48.5-51.6 % (2019) of women were not covered (p < 0.05-0.001) compared with VRCPNH:
17.4-19.5 % (2017), 0.3-0.4 % (2018), 1.0-1.2 % (2019) of men and 16.7-19.5 % (2017), 1.1-1.2 % (2018), 0.6-0.7 % (2019) of women. The high number of patients who were not
screened for atrial fibrillation at the time of hospitalization justifies the fact that in some of them, data on cardiac arrhythmias had been specified earlier.
During the study period, the proportion of patients not screened for atrial fibrillation (p < 0.05-0.001) decreased significantly in VRCPNH. VCCEH from 2017 to 2019 showed a significant increase in the percentage of patients who had been screened before and at the time of hospitaliza-tion (p < 0.05-0.001).
Discussion
The results obtained confirm the current data on the prospects and reliability of the register method, the main conditions of which are the availability of complete information, personalized data and reliability of diagnosis. The method allows us to obtain information about the quality of medical care, morbidity, mortality, etiology and risk factors of stroke in climatic, socio-demographic and economic conditions of individual cities and regions [20].
Considering that significant advances have been achieved in reducing the medical and social consequences of stroke in those countries where reliable epidemiological data have been collected and analyzed during the formation of regional population registers on stroke [21], it becomes relevant to study the regional register in Vinnytsia region.
Due to the lack of representative population epidemio-logical studies, official statistics do not fully reflect the state of the problem of cerebral stroke in our country. Currently, the creation of registers for the entire territory of Ukraine is limited by the complexity, duration and lack of targeted funding for such studies [22]. In fact, the results of our study can only be compared with those of foreign colleagues.
In specialized neurological clinics of North America, Western Europe, Japan and other developed countries, in cases of suspected stroke, brain CT is performed in the first 1-2 hours, and if necessary — magnetic resonance imaging, perfusion CT, diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance imaging, which can fully confirm or exclude ischemic stroke diagnosis. Unless neuroimaging is performed with suspected ischemic stroke, the diagnosis of ischemic stroke is erroneously established in peripheral vestibular dizziness or, on the contrary, ischemic type stroke is treated as a "hypertensive cerebral crisis" [23].
Thus, in the departments we studied, the situation with neuroimaging was significantly different. In VRCPNH, CT was performed on the day of hospitalization of a patient suspected of having a stroke, usually within 24 hours of its development (2017), and in most cases it was possible to do so within 6 hours of the onset of the disease (2018-2019). This medical establishment has a 24/7 computed tomograph.
In VCCEH, despite the fact that no thrombolysis was performed at the time of the study, the percentage of patients who underwent a CT scan within the therapeutic window indirectly confirms or excludes the hospital's readiness to implement the indicated method of treatment. Unfortunately, during the first hours of hospitalization, the study was conducted only in isolated cases (although the number of patients examined increased from 2017 to 2019), which
BÑJI
OpnrÍHaqbHÍ gocaigffieHHi /Original Researches/
clearly limited the scope for any differentiated treatment [24]. A similar situation is observed with the coverage of patients with ultrasound examination of the vessels of the neck, which is also explained by insufficient logistic conditions in this hospital. The analysis of neck ultrasound confirms the need for much greater coverage of patients in both hospitals, especially in VCCEH, where the situation is critical. In 2019, the percentage of patients examined in this hospital is even smaller than in previous years (p < 0.05-0.001). Ignoring this method of study makes it impossible to establish a pathogenetic diagnosis of ischemic stroke, and therefore limits the differentiation and secondary prevention of this pathology [25].
Given the unequal availability of ultrasonic Doppler and CT scanner (they are not available in VCCEH), it is possible to explain to some extent the insufficient level of organization of diagnostic measures. However, if we analyze indicators such as dysphagia screening, atrial fibrillation screening, the use of the NIHSS, which does not require diagnostic equipment, it is obvious that they can be improved only if the medical staff are informed of the importance of these procedures and trained in the methods of conducting them. Ignoring these indicators is associated with a high risk of medical complications and increases the risk of sudden death in patients with ACCD [11, 26].
In Ukraine, more than 1.5 million patients have atrial fibrillation. It is known that the presence of atrial fibrillation 5 times increases the risk of developing cardioembolic stroke. Therefore, this type of arrhythmia is a potentially dangerous condition and requires the recording and analysis of its presence in patients with ACCD [27]. It is noteworthy that the percentage of patients who had been diagnosed with atrial fibrillation earlier in the two hospitals was virtually the same. The latter fact indirectly testifies to the poor quality of primary and secondary prevention of arrhythmia in the region as a whole, which has been confirmed in a number of authoritative studies [28].
The modern development of medical science constantly leads to the introduction of rehabilitation technologies in the structure of intensive care of stroke. ACCD rehabilitation in the acute period is a new trend in classical rehabilitation that has evolved over the past 3-5 years. This is possible only with the involvement of speech therapists, neurorehabilita-tion therapists, physiotherapists as members of the multidis-ciplinary rehabilitation team [29].
Researchers from different countries compared the level of functional activity of patients in hospitals where early rehabilitation was implemented and where it was not available at all or was performed during a subacute stroke period. At the time of discharge from the first group of hospitals (early rehabilitation), a smaller percentage of patients in need of assistance were identified, including those in nursing homes and hospices [30].
The low number of VCCEH patients consulted by physiotherapists and speech therapists may predict an increased need in third-party caregivers, with poorer functional outcomes at discharge.
Thus, the use of the register method is best suited to solve the above problems, since it provides an opportunity to study
a representative (at least for a certain region) group of patients and to generalize (extrapolate) to a much wider range of persons than those included in the register.
Conclusions
The results of the study substantiated the information and adequacy of the studied quality indicators and the feasibility of further implementation of the register method in different regions of Ukraine. Despite the progress made in recent decades in developing new methods for the diagnosis and treatment of strokes, there is a lack of common standards and approaches to patient management. The identified shortcomings can be used in planning the measures to improve the medical care of patients with stroke in the investigated hospitals and allow specific recommendations to be considered with the deviations detected.
Conflicts of interests. Not declared.
Information on the contribution of each author:
S.P. Moskovko — research concept and design; D.O. Fiks — collection and processing of materials, description and analysis of the obtained results; A. V. Shayuk — literary analysis of the state of the problem, technical design of the article.
References
1. Starodubtseva O.S., Begicheva S.V. Analiz zabolevaemosti insultom s ispolzovaniem informatsionnyih tehnologiy. Fundamental-nyie issledovaniya. 2012. 8(2). 424-427(in Russian).
2. Musuka T.D, Wilton S.B., Traboulsi M, Hill M.D. Diagnosis and management of acute ischemic stroke: speed is critical. CMAJ. 2015. 187(12). 887-893.
3. Tong E, Hou Q., Fiebach J.B., Wintermark M. The role of imaging in acute ischemic stroke. Neurosurg. Focus. 2014. 36(1). E3.
4. Davis S, Donnan G.A. Time is penumbra: imaging, selection and outcome. Cerebrovasc. Dis. 2014. 38(1). 59-72.
5. Khanal K, Bhandari S.S., Shrestha N, Acharya S.P., Mar-hatta M.N. Comparison of outcome predictions by the Glasgow coma scale and the Full Outline of UnResponsiveness score in the neurological and neurosurgical patients in the intensive care unit. Indian J. Crit. Care Med. 2016. 20(8). 473-476.
6. Aldatov R.H., Trufanov G.E, Fokin V.A. Neyrovizualizatsiya ostrogo ishemicheskogo insulta: sovremennoe sostoyanie. Translyatsi-onnaya meditsina. 2019. 6(2). 12-17(in Russian).
7. O'Donnell M.J, Chin S.L., Rangarajan S. et al. Global and regional effects of potentially modifiable risk factors associated with acute stroke in 32 countries (INTERSTROKE): a case-control study. The Lancet. 2016. 388(10046). 761-775.
8. Feigin V.L., Norrving B., George M.G., Foltz J.L, Roth G.A., Mensah G.A. Prevention of stroke: a strategic global imperative. Nature Reviews Neurology. 2016. 12(9). 501-512.
9. Bokeriya L.A. Natsionalnyie rekomendatsii po vedeniyu patsientov s z,abolevaniyami brahiotsefalnyih arteriy. M.: Meditsina, 2013. 72 s. (in Russian).
10. Smith E.E, Kent D. V, Bulsara K.R. et al. Effect of dysphagia screening strategies on clinical outcomes after stroke: a systematic review for the 2018 guidelines for the early management ofpatients with acute ischemic stroke. Stroke. 2018. 49(3). e123-e128.
11. Newman R., Vilardell N, Clavé P., Speyer R. Effect of bolus viscosity on the safety and efficacy of swallowing and the kinematics of
Оригшальш дослщження /Original Researches/
fiNJI
the swallow response in patients with oropharyngeal dysphagia: White Paper by the European Society for Swallowing Disorders (ESSD). Dysphagia. 2016. 31(2). 232-249.
12. Murashko N.K., Shklyaeva O.N. Kliniko-nevrologichni os-oblivosti rozvitku ishemichnogo insultu u hvorih zfibrilyatsieyupered-serd. Likarska sprava. 2013. 1. 77-81 (in Ukrainian).
13. Tibekina L.M., Ashurko O.A. Osobennosti rabotyi logopeda v sosudistom tsentre mnogoprofilnogo statsionara. Zdorove — osnova chelovecheskogo potentsiala: problemyi i puti ih resheniya. 2014. 2. 547-549 (in Russian).
14. Pollock A., Baer G, Campbell P. et al. Physical rehabilitation approaches for the recovery offunction and mobility following stroke. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2014. (4).
15. Lekander I., Willers C, Ekstrand E. et al. Hospital comparison of stroke care in Sweden: a register-based study. BMJ Open. 2017. 7(9). e015244.
16. Karabiyik L. Intensive care scoring systems. Turkish Journal oflntensive Care Medicine. 2010. 9(3). 129-143.
17. Bill O, Zufferey P., Faouzi M, Michel P. Severe stroke:patient profile and predictors of favorable outcome. J. Thromb. Haemost. 2013. 11. 92-99.
18. Gao J., Parsons M.W., Kawano H. et al. Visibility of CT early ischemic change is significantly associated with time from stroke onset to baseline scan beyond the first 3 hours of stroke onset. J. Stroke. 2017. 19(3). 340-346.
19. Jauch E.C., Saver J.L., Adams H.P. et al. Guidelines for the early management of patients with acute ischemic stroke: a guideline for healthcare professionals from the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association. Stroke. 2013. 44(3). 870-947.
20. Peltola M., Seppälä T.T., Malmivaara A. et al. Individual and regional-level factors contributing to variation in length of stay after cerebral infarction in six European countries. Health Econ. 2015. 24(2). 38-52.
21. Rost N.S., Bottle A., Lee J.M. et al. Stroke severity is a crucial predictor of outcome: an international prospective validation study. J. Am. Heart Assoc. 2016. 5(1). e002433.
22. Bacigalupe A., Escolar-Pujolar A. The impact of economic crises on social inequalities in health: what do we know so far? International Journal for Equity in Health. 2014. 13(1). 52.
23. Kamalian S., Lev M.H. Stroke imaging. Radiol. Clin. North Am. 2019. 57(4). 717-732.
24. Zerna C, Thomalla G, Campbell B.C., Rha J.H., Hill M.D. Current practice and future directions in the diagnosis and acute treatment of ischaemic stroke. The Lancet. 2018. 392(10154). 1247-1256.
25. Saqqur M, Khan K., Derksen C, Alexandrov A., Shuaib A. Transcranial Doppler and transcranial color duplex in defining collateral cerebral blood flow. J. Neuroimaging. 2018. 28(5). 455-476.
26. Ringborg A., Nieuwlaat R., Lindgren P. et al. Costs of atrial fibrillation in five European countries: results from the Euro Heart Survey on atrial fibrillation. Europace. 2008. 10(4). 403-411.
27. Myimrenko S.N. Fibrillyatsiya predserdiy: voprosyipatogene-za, algoritmyi diagnostiki, klinicheskaya znachimost, strategii lech-eniya. Chast 1. Liki Ukrayini. 2014. 2. 27-33 (in Russian).
28. Paciaroni M, Agnelli G., Caso V. et al. Causes and riskfactors of cerebral ischemic events in patients with atrial fibrillation treated with non-vitamin k antagonist oral anticoagulants for stroke prevention: the RENo study. Stroke. 2019. 50(8). 2168-2174.
29. Wortman-Jutt S., Edwards D. Poststroke aphasia rehabilitation: why all talk and no action? Neurorehabilitation and Neural Repair. 2019. 33(4). 235-244.
30. Tong Y, Cheng Z, Rajah G.B. et al. High intensity physical rehabilitation later than 24 h post stroke is beneficial in patients: a pilot randomized controlled trial (RCT) study in mild to moderate ischemic stroke. Front. Neurol. 2019. 10. 113.
Received 04.04.2020 Revised 17.02.2020 Accepted25.02.2020 ■
Московко С.П.1, Фкс Д.О.1, ШаюкА.В.2
1Внницький нацюнальний медичний у^верситет iм. М.1. Пирогова, м. Внниця, Украна 2Житомирський державний у^верситет iM. I. Франка, м. Житомир, Украна
Оцшка дотримання сучасних кл^чних рекомендацм щодо клшко-апаратноТ Aiarnoc^^ шсульту
за даними реестру м. Вшниця за перюд 2017-2019 рр.
Резюме. Актуальшсть. Проведення порiвняльного ана-лiзу репрезентативних регюнальних даних стосовно рiв-ня дiагностики на госштальному еташ ведення шсульту за певний перюд часу i м1ж рiзними лшувальними закладами дозволяе коректно сформувати комплекс лшувально-про-фшактичних заходiв та розробити послвдовш рекомендацй щодо & полшшення. Мета до^дження: оцшити динамшу показнишв якосп клшко-апаратно! дiагностики шсульту за перюд 2017—2019 рр. та провести !х порiвняльний анатз м1ж дослвджуваними лшувально-профшактичними закладами. Матерiалu та методи. За даними юторш хвороби викона-но порiвняльний анатз рiвня оргашзацй клшко-апаратно! дiагностики в комунальному некомерцшному пiдприемствi «Вшницька обласна клшчна психоневролопчна лшарня iм. акад. О.1. Ющенка Вшницько! обласно! ради» (ВОКПНЛ) i Вшницькш мюькш клшчнш лшарш швидко! медично! до-помоги (ВМКЛШМД) у 2017—2019 рр. Статистичну обробку результапв здшснено за допомогою статистичного пакета
<^1;а&11са 5.5». Результати. Встановлено вiрогiднi вщмш-носп у вщсотковш частщ пащенпв ВОКПНЛ i ВМКЛШМД, яким на госттальному етат проведено оцшку ступеня тяж-косп шсульту за Шкалою шсульту Нацюнальних шститупв охорони здоров'я США, нейровiзуалiзацiю в першi години захворювання, ультразвукове дослщження судин ши!, скри-ншг фiбриляцl! передсердь та дисфагй, консультацш логопеда й фiзiотерапевта. У кожному медичному закладi вщмчено позитивну динамшу за три роки за фактом проведення всгх дiагностичних заходiв i процедур. Висновки. Результати дослщження подтвердили адекватшсть вивчених шдикато-рiв якост i доцшьносп подальшого впровадження методу госпитального реестру в шших регюнах Укра!ни для ощнки i контролю якосп медично! допомоги, включаючи аналiз ефективносп нових технологш.
Ключовi слова: шсульт; комп'ютерна томографiя; скри-ншг дисфагп; фiбриляцiя передсердь; логопед; фiзiотера-певт
Inj
Оригшальш досл1дження /Original Researches/
Московко С.П.1, Фикс Д.А.1, Шаюк А.В.2
1Винницкий национальный медицинский университет им. Н.И. Пирогова, г. Винница, Украина Житомирский государственный университет им. И. Франю г. Житомир, Украина
Оценка соблюдения современных клинических рекомендаций относительно клинико-аппаратной диагностики инсульта по данным регистра г. Винница за период 2017-2019 гг.
Резюме. Актуальность. Проведение сравнительного анализа репрезентативных региональных данных по уровню диагностики на госпитальном этапе ведения инсульта за определенный период времени и между различными лечебными учреждениями позволяет корректно сформировать комплекс лечебно-профилактических мероприятий и разработать последовательные рекомендации по их улучшению. Цель исследования: оценить динамику показателей качества клини-ко-аппаратной диагностики инсульта за период 2017—2019 гг. и провести их сравнительный анализ между исследуемыми лечебно-профилактическими учреждениями. Материалы и методы. По данным историй болезни выполнен сравнительный анализ уровня организации клинико-аппаратной диагностики в коммунальном некоммерческом предприятии «Винницкая областная клиническая психоневрологическая больница им. акад. А.И. Ющенко Винницкого областного совета» (ВОКПНБ) и Винницкой городской клинической больнице скорой медицинской помощи (ВГКБСМП) в 2017— 2019 гг. Статистическая обработка результатов выполнена с
помощью статистического пакета «Statistica 5.5». Результаты. Установлены достоверные различия в процентной доле пациентов ВОКПНБ и ВГКБСМП, которым на госпитальном этапе проведены оценка степени тяжести инсульта по Шкале инсульта Национальных институтов здравоохранения США, нейровизуализация в первые часы заболевания, ультразвуковое исследование сосудов шеи, скрининг на предмет фибрилляции предсердий и дисфагии, консультация логопеда и физиотерапевта. В каждом медицинском учреждении отмечена положительная динамика за три года по факту проведения всех диагностических мероприятий и процедур. Выводы. Результаты исследования подтвердили адекватность изученных индикаторов качества и целесообразности дальнейшего внедрения метода госпитального регистра в других регионах Украины для оценки и контроля качества медицинской помощи, включая анализ эффективности новых технологий. Ключевые слова: инсульт; компьютерная томография; скрининг дисфагии; фибрилляция предсердий; логопед; физиотерапевт
