CC BY
21
UDC: 351
Amer Al-Atti,
post-graduate student of the Interregional Academy of Personnel Management (MAUP), Ukraine, 03039, Kyiv, Str. Frometovska, 2, tel.: (093) 871 00 48
ORCID: 0000-0002-6094-8368 Aль-Aттi AMep,
астрант Мiжрeгioнальнoï Академп управлшня персоналом (МАУП), Украта, 03039 м. Кшв, вул. Фрoмeтiвська, 2, тел.: (093) 871 00 48
ORCID: 0000-0002-6094-8368 Лль-Ammu AMep,
аспирант Межрегиональной Академии управления персоналом (МАУП), Украина, 03039 г. Киев, ул. Фрометовская, 2, тел.: (093) 87100 48
0000-0002-6094-8368
ANALYSiS OF SCiENTiFiC iNVESTiGATiONS OF THE PUBLiC ADMiNiSTRATiON MANAGEMENT OF THE UKRAiNiAN ECONOMY OF DEVELOPiNG ECONOMY
Abstract. This article analyzes scientific research of mechanisms in public administration of outstripping development in the economy of Ukraine for the last five years (from 2011-2016). For determining the directions of development in the Ukrainian economy in the coming years.
Keywords: mechanisms of public administration, public administration, economic development, outstripping development, public management.
АНАЛ1З НАУКОВИХ ДОСЛ1ДЖЕНЬ ЩОДО МЕХАН1ЗМ1В ПУБЛ1ЧНОГО УПРАВЛ1ННЯ ВИПЕРЕДЖАЮЧИМ РОЗВИТКОМ
ЕКОНОМ1КИ УКРА1НИ
Анотащя. Проаналiзовано HayKOBi дослщження щодо MexaHÍ3MÍB пyблiч-ного управлшня випереджаючим розвитком економши Украши за ocTaHHi п'ять роюв (2011-2016 рр.) для визначення нaпрямiв розвитку економiки Украши найближчими роками.
K^40bí слова: мехaнiзми пyблiчного управлшня, пyблiчне yпрaвлiння, розвиток економiки, випереджаючий розвиток, державне yпрaвлiння.
АНАЛИЗ НАУЧНЫХ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЙ МЕХАНИЗМОВ ПУБЛИЧНОГО УПРАВЛЕНИЯ ОПЕРЕЖАЮЩИМ РАЗВИТИЕМ ЭКОНОМИКИ УКРАИНЫ
Аннотация. Проанализированы научные исследования механизмов публичного управления опережающим развитием экономики Украины за последние пять лет (2011-2016 гг.) Для определения направлений развития экономики Украины в ближайшие годы.
Ключевые слова: механизмы публичного управления, публичное управление, развитие экономики, опережающее развитие, государственное управление.
Target setting. In accordance with the order of the Ministry of Education and Science of November 6, 2015 № 1151 "On peculiarities of implementation range of disciplines and specialties, which trains candidates of higher education approved by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine dated April 29, 2015 № 266" from April 29, 2015 № 266 was approved by the table of correspondence of the list of scientific specialties (List 2011) and a list of areas of knowledge and specialties for which the preparation of candidates for higher education is being conducted (List of 2015). In this document, the branch of science "Public administration" and a group of specialties: theory and history of public administration (code 25.00.01), public administration mechanisms (code 25.00.02), public service (code 25.00.03), local government (code 25.00. 04) was changed to the "management and administration" area of the specialty "Public management and administration" (specialty code 074) [1].
In 2016, amendments were made to the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine No. 266 of April 29,
2015 "On the list of disciplines and specialties, which trains candidates Higher Education" where 074 "Public management and administration" from position 07 is excluded based on Cabinet of Ministers Resolution № 674 of 27.09.2016 [2].
In accordance with the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine of September 27, 2016 № 674 "Some of the reform of professional training of state officials and local government officials" supplemented by a list of positions "28 Public Management and Administration, 281 Public Management and Administration" [3].
Thus, the scientific branch of "Public Administration" is the founder of the formation of the third (educational and scientific) level of training in the field of knowledge 28 "Public Administration and Administration" specialty 028 "Public Management and Administration" qualifications Ph.D. in public management and administration.
Analysis of recent publications on issues. The source of information is the regulations, research findings [1-68].
The purpose of the article. Analyze scientific research of mechanisms
in public administration of outstripping development in the economy of Ukraine for the last five years (from 2011-2016) for determining the directions of development in the Ukrainian economy in the coming years.
The statement of basic materials. In this article, we will examine in more detail scientific research in the field of "Public Administration", those of them that, in our opinion, have received substantial scientific results on mechanisms of public management of outstripping development of the Ukrainian economy. To do this, we will analyze the doctoral and candidate dissertations, which were defended in the last five years (from 2011-2016), in order to determine the direction of development of the Ukrainian economy in the coming years.
In the work of D. Andrievsky "Formation and implementation of state industrial policy at the regional level" (2011) approaches are proposed: to the formation of state industrial policy as a strategy for avoiding non-competitive in world markets; to the implementation of state industrial policy at the regional level, through retrospective analysis. The mechanism for implementing state industrial policy at the regional level has been improved by building industrial clusters [4, p. 3-5].
V. Anikeenko in his research "State regulation of development of the regional agrarian market" (2011) for the first time proposed a scientific approach to the analysis of state regulation in the agrarian market development, which allows to increase the level of coordination of the target orientation mechanisms in state regula-
tion with the dynamics in the agrarian market development [5, p. 7-15].
In the work of L. Bezugla, "State Regulation of the Development of Small and Medium-Sized Entrepre-neurship in the Information Society" (2011), a complex of socio-economic functions of the state for the development of small and medium-sized businesses was analyzed, the current mechanism of state regulation of entre-preneurship in Ukraine was updated with innovative forms of entrepreneurial activity and Information (public services through the "e-government" system). The researcher submitted a structural model of the state-to-business system for state support of small and medium-sized businesses and the formation of a coordinating council for the development of entrepreneurship in Ukraine as a representative of the interests of the business sector of the economy for interaction with authorities [6, p. 4].
A. Butnik in his research "Development of the state investment policy at the regional level" (2011) improves the conceptual approach to the functions of the state investment policy and the formation mechanisms for the implementation of the state investment policy at the regional level with the help of the tourism sector. Strategic goals are proposed in three stages: preliminary (one year), basic (3 years), development (5 years) [7, p. 3].
The work of E. Vlizlo "Forming an effective mechanism of state regulation of investment potential in Ukraine" (2011) has resulted in the development of a mechanism for the regulation of the investment management in the region, taking into ac-
count investor interests, as a priority for the management of a certain territory. The system for the development and implementation of a mechanism for the management in regional activities has been improved. On the basis of economic and mathematical modeling, the methodology for assessing the efficiency of investment has been improved [8, p. 15-16].
V Devyatka in the work "Formation of interrelations and interactions of small business with the public in the system of public administration" (2011). Consider ways to improve the effectiveness of relationships and interaction between the public and small business. The author proposes the creation of a network of business incubators on the basis of universities for the employment of students, the creation of a Regional Center for Support of Small Business Development to support and develop small business in Ukraine [9, p. 3].
In the dissertation research by A. Dovgan "Improving the mechanism of state management of special monopolies (alcoholic and tobacco sector of the economy)" (2011). The main scientific result is determined by the approach to redistribution of rights and duties of state and non-state economic entities in the alcoholic and tobacco sectors, and possible scenarios for the nationalization of enterprises producing alcoholic beverages are also presented [10, p. 3-4].
In the work of V. Dolgalov "Tax control in the system of state management of social and economic development of the region" (2011), the theoretical and methodological results of the study substantiate the specific
features of applying tax control in the system of state management of the social and economic development of the region to increase the tax potential [11, p. 14-17].
In the work "State Regulation of the Social and Economic Development of Depressive Territories" (2011), A. Eroshkin proposed the use of an algorithm for constructing a forecast and scenarios for regulating the socio-economic development of depressed areas based on the patterns of uneven socioeconomic development of individual regions [12, p. 2-4].
T. Malafeev in the dissertation research "State regulation of the food industry of Ukraine" (2011) on the basis of the analysis of the state of the food industry, taking into account the priorities of development and analysis of state regulation in the food industry, suggests a mechanism for making managerial decisions on improving state regulation in the food industry in Ukraine [13, p. 3-5].
In the work of G. Maretsky "State regulation of the shipbuilding complex in the context of restructuring the Ukrainian economy" (2011), mechanisms for state regulation of structural changes in the shipbuilding complex of the national economy, as well as conceptual and methodological bases for the development in the domestic shipbuilding complex of state holding companies and other Types of integrated corporate structures. Based on the grouping of the main factors of production and scientific and technical potential using SWOT analysis, the author analyzed the competitive advantages of the shipbuilding complex of Ukraine [14, p. 7-16].
N. Mirko in the work "State regulation of development of the domestic market of light industry products" (2011). Explores a comprehensive approach to activate the domestic market of light industry products using scientific and methodological approaches [15, p. 3-6].
The results of the work of A. Prik-hodko "State regulation of the development of the agro-industrial complex of the region" (2011). There are proposals of state support for the use of innovations in the agroindustrial complex. To this end, the author has improved the regional resource potential assessment and the pricing mechanism, the financial and credit mechanism, the mechanism of cooperation and integration in the agro-industrial complex [16, p. 4].
Y. Svetlichnaya in her work "State Regulation of Foreign Trade Activity in Ukraine" (2011) considered practical aspects of the mechanisms of state regulation of foreign trade. The work substantiates the formation of effective mechanisms of state regulation of the country's foreign trade activities [17, p. 10-15].
In the dissertation N. Stavtika "State regulation of agricultural sector productivity in Ukraine" (2011) on the basis of stimulating production and socio-economic factors in agribusiness growth, within the framework of the target development trajectory, the formation of a mechanism for state regulation of the productivity in the agrarian sector of the economy in Ukraine were presented. The author also presents the concept of state regulation in agricultural sector productivity as a source of economic growth, developed a methodological approach and a reasonably
systematic approach to agricultural sector productivity [18, p. 4-7].
According to the results of the study, V. Tkachenko "The external economic strategy of the state as a means of ensuring the competitiveness of the national economy" (2011) generalizes the mechanism for the formation of a single external economic strategy of the state in the form of integrated strategies for the development of national production and regulation of foreign economic relations on the basis of competitive advantages. The author developed a model of the differentiated external economic strategy of the state, where national production is classified by industry with the definition of priorities in the state's foreign economic strategy. For the formation of the external economic strategy of the state (domestic model), the author has improved the international rating assessments of competitiveness [19, p. 4].
The results of the research T. Fili-penko "The mechanism of public administration of the currency market in Ukraine" (2011) is the substantiation of the existence of internal and external factors of the currency market management, where the public administration of the currency market is considered as the monetary policy of the state. It is determined and proven that the world financial space creates both new opportunities and new threats for the development of the national economy in the country. Also, the work improves the methods of currency regulation and mechanisms for identifying, preventing crimes and offenses in the financial sphere [20, p. 5, 31-33].
The most important results of N. Shevchenko research "Development
of the regional investment policy of the state in the agrarian sector of the economy: theory, methodology, practical implementation mechanisms" (2011) are theoretical provisions of the development of the state investment policy in the agricultural sector of the economy. Practical tools of introduction of the state investment policy in the agrarian sector of the economy are offered. The study has improved approaches to analyzing the investment attractiveness of the region, shaping the investment strategy of the region, determining the period of investment support for the agrarian sector of the region, as well as mechanisms to increase the investment attractiveness of the agricultural sector and investment activity [21, p. 5].
Scientific results of the research V. Bliznyuk "Development of state regulation of the banking system in the context of globalization" (2012) is a scientific and methodical approach to the development of the banking system and state regulation of the banking system by combining analytical blocks into the interaction of economic agents, state and society institutions. By consolidating economic, scientific, technological, information, organizational, institutional, communication, social, and marketing innovations, the author proposes a mechanism for state support for the innovative development of the institution in banking services [22, p. 3].
A. Gindes in his work "Formation and implementation of mechanisms for ensuring the economic stability of Ukraine" (2012) reveals the state-managerial mechanisms of ensuring economic security and stability in the
country as an integrated system interacting with subsystems of public administration, and in the globalization of a market economy with mechanisms self-regulation. The approaches to the prevention of threats to the economic stability of the state are described. Based on the results of the analysis of external and internal contradictions, the methodological aspects of the optimal model of the correlation of state regulation and self-regulation for economic stability were determined [23, p. 2-4].
A. Dyenkov, in his work "The mechanism of state regulation of the development of ferrous metallurgy in Ukraine" (2012) first revealed the patterns of interaction between the part and the whole, which made it possible to propose a conception of the state regulation mechanism of the development in ferrous metallurgy in Ukraine and to improve methodological approaches to ensure the sustainable development in the national economy [24, p. 16].
A. Kalyuga in the study "Mechanisms of state regulation of the stock market in Ukraine" (2012) scientifically substantiates the choice of the vector of development in state regulation of the stock market in Ukraine towards a modern European model where a full-fledged banking system takes center stage in the redistribution of financial flows in the country. The provisions of the Program for the Development of the Stock Market in Ukraine for 2012-2014 have been updated, by replacing the rating evaluation formula and guaranteeing investments in the stock market in the mechanism for assessing the issuing companies of securities [25, p. 3-4].
The most important results of the work of A. Kolizhuk "Public administration of foreign economic activity in Ukraine in the conditions of European integration" (2012) is the model of the public administration optimization, which built on an integrated approach to the formation and implementation of the Strategy of public administration of foreign economic activity in Ukraine. The author developed a number of program documents on the development of the state export-import policy and improved priority areas for customs and tariff regulation for certain groups of goods [26, p. 3-5].
According to the results of the scientific research, M. Meleshko "Mechanisms of state regulation of the grain market of Ukraine" (2012), have been thoroughly investigated the mechanisms of state regulation in the grain market through the levers: organizational, administrative, legal, financial and economic. The introduction of a state agent for the export and import in grain (processed products) is considered. Economic mechanisms of the grain msrket regulation and factors of formation of a price policy, price regulation are analyzed [27, p. 3-4].
In the dissertation of B. Nagorskiy "State regulation of foreign economic activity of the mining and metallurgical complex in Ukraine" (2012) an innovative mechanism of state regulation of the MMC in Ukraine, including mini-Mili technologies for economic benefits, competitiveness and export of domestic steel products, was applied. The author has improved the mechanisms of the IRO (Initial public offering) as an opportunity to attract investment in the MMC in Ukraine, as
well as for Ukraine's accession to the Kyoto Protocol, methods for determining environmental priorities have been improved [28, p. 9-16].
In the work of A. Panin "Public administration of investment and construction activity in the conditions of economic crisis" (2012) for the development of free competition in the construction market in the conditions of the economic crisis on the basis of public-private partnership, the new approaches to the implementation of investment-building activities public sdministrartion have been formed. During the downturn phase of business activity, the anti-crisis mechanism for stimulating the investment activity of the construction complex and the organizational and economic mechanism for state management of investment and construction activities are revealed [29, p. 3-6].
A. Pozhidaev in the dissertation "Mechanism of state stimulation in agro-food sector development: strategic aspect" (2012) defines the conceptual components of the mechanism of state stimulation in the agro-food sector by applying modified PEST-analysis and evolutionary forecast and competitiveness analysis of M. Porter and technology IDEF 0; The strategy for the development of the industry is built on the provisions of the theory of systems within the framework of a holistic view of the world [30, p. 2-6].
M. Sjomich in the dissertation research "Mechanisms of increasing the efficiency in state economic policy in the system of ensuring the welfare of the population in Ukraine" (2012) offers a model for interaction of mechanisms to improve the efficiency in
state economic policy in the system of ensuring the welfare of the population in Ukraine. The model provides for globalization economic relations, Ukraine's integration and liquidation of the consequences of the global financial crisis. The author systematizes the indicators of the effectiveness of the implementation in the state economic policy, the classification of methods in state regulation of the economy [31, p. 12-16].
The results of scientific research Y. Shpak "Mechanisms of state regulation in the agrarian sector of the national economy in the context of the markets globalization" (2012) is a model of the system of mechanisms for state regulation of the development in the agrarian sector of the national economy in the markets globalization. It is built on the interaction of organizational, innovative, regulatory and legal components. The work predicts the development in the agricultural sector, the program for the formation of the country's food security, caused by the markets globalization. Evaluation of the internal food market is systematized as special mechanisms of state regulation in the agrarian sector of the national economy. According to the results of the research, the author developed mechanisms of anti-crisis state regulation in the agrarian sector of the national economy [32, p. 12-31].
V. Shpachuk in the dissertation research "Public administration of the banking system: anti-crisis aspect" (2012) analyzes five stages of evolution and development in the management of the banking system in Ukraine. The study methodologically formed an approach to the multi-vector develop-
ment of the state anti-crisis management in the banking system, which focuses on the implementation of anticrisis measures for the management and impact of public authorities on the banking system. The study substantiates the approach to the specialists rotation in banking supervision in the National Bank of Ukraine, the launching of automation and prevention of corruption among the staff in the National Bank of Ukraine [33, p. 20-34].
In the dissertation V. Barvinenko "Mechanisms of state regulation of sustainable development in the food market in Ukraine" (2013) state regulation of sustainable development in the food market is considered comprehensively through the application of a conceptual-holistic mechanism. In the organizational and economic mechanism of state regulation of the sustainable development in the food market, the organizational and economic component is specified separately, which has made it possible to improve the institutional mechanism for state regulation of the sustainable development in the food market and the concept of state support for sustainable development in the food market [34, p. 3-5].
In the dissertational study A. Bo-risenko "Formation of the state foreign economic policy in Ukraine and the mechanisms for its implementation" (2013) scientifically substantiated the concept of foreign economic activity in Ukraine, which is built on the interaction of public administration tools for regulation of priority commodity markets. The author developed the Strategy for the Formation and Realization of Foreign Economic Activity in Ukraine, based on the paradigmatic
combination of existing strategies and the stimulation of enterprise development through state regulation of foreign trade activities. To implement the strategic objectives, the motivational mechanism of state program-targeted financing is given. Based on the methodology of controlling in system of state regulation in the sphere of foreign trade the authors recommend the introduction of the principle of "management control". Theoretical and methodological results of the study is to analyze FEA using systemic synergies in the study of problems of state regulatory policy in the sphere of foreign economic activity. With the help of an integrated institutional matrix systematize governance process defined governance mechanisms and regulates FEA [35, p. 5, 18-32].
In the work of N. Gvazava "Local budgets as a factor in the development of the territorial communities of Ukraine" (2013) it is about the implementation of the local development budget, where the methodology of local economic policy is improved using the concept of "New Public Service" and on the basis of the independent functioning of the relationships between levels Budgetary system. The system of local finances of all economic entities of the territorial community that form this budget for the development of the territory is scientifically grounded [36, p. 3-4].
In the work of S. Dvigun "State regulation of foreign economic activity in the conditions of Ukraine's integration into the world economic space" (2013), it is noted that the balanced basis of state and sectoral program-target management is the theoretical basis of
state regulation of foreign economic activity. In the direction of Ukraine's integration into the world economic space, it is necessary to expand the reproduction of the national economy. The relationship between the rate of development of exports and the level of added value in the work is presented in the form of a matrix of sectoral priorities of the production and economic subsystem of the state's external economic complex. This makes it possible to have scientifically sound state-management decisions on export regulation [37, p. 14-17].
N. Zubritskaya in her work "Mechanisms of state regulation of the banking sphere in Ukraine" (2013) introduced in the system of investment support in Ukraine an innovative mechanism of state regulation of banking services development on the basis of syndicated lending and public-private partnership. On the principles of free capital flow, the Maastricht criteria and the cooperation of central banks, the development of mechanisms for European integration of the banking sector in Ukraine was investigated [38, p. 2-4].
The most important research results of G. Ryabtsev "Conceptual bases of the state policy of market development in Ukraine" (2013) is the development of the state policy of market development in Ukraine, which changes the approach to the implementation of the state policy on reactive to preventive. The work proposes a model of the oil products market in Ukraine, where production, import, export and consumption of oil products and macro-economic indicators have close interrelations. Using the integrated real-time information and analytical system Real
FEC, a mechanism for monitoring the products and consequences of the state policy of market development has been developed. The author also proposes the mechanism of a flexible strategic energy reserve, such as combining the stock of various fuels and energy and taking into account the structure of energy consumption and seasonal loads [39, p. 26-32].
Within the framework of V. Fedo-rov's study "Improving the mechanisms of public administration of Ukraine's tax system" (2013), mechanisms of public administration of the tax system in Ukraine on the principles of the tax security system were developed. The author suggests an organizational mechanism of public administration of the tax system in Ukraine, which provides: 1) solving financial and economic problems of the national economy;
2) ensuring the growth of tax revenues to budgets and extra-budgetary funds by increasing production volumes;
3) monitoring and tracking the dynamics of financial and economic processes;
4) introduction of the institution of responsibility of business entities [40, p. 3-5].
In the work of V. Kharchenko "Improving the mechanism of public administration of the coal mining industry innovative development" (2013), the development of the coal industry in Ukraine with the participation of venture financing is being considered. The author explores the possibilities of innovative and investment levers of the state for reproduction and renewal of fixed assets of extractive enterprises. Also taking into account international experience, the methodology of modernization in the coal
mining industry has been improved [41,
p. 4].
V. Tsvok in his work "State regulation of the resource potential using in industry in the conditions of macro-economic instability" (2013) determines the principles of state regulation under macroeconomic instability on an innovative investment basis, taking into account available resources and developing the resource potential of the industrial complex. By introducing an integrated indicator of the resource potential of industry, the author improves the methodology for the integrated assessment of state regulation in the resource potential of industry [42, p. 2-5].
In the dissertation research N. Cha-ly "Mechanisms of public administration in the economic development of Ukraine in the context of globalization" (2013) for the first time highlighted the paradigm of the country's economic development taking into account the dynamic transformations of the external environment. Based on the results of the study, a global environment model is constructed, consisting of supranational institutions and individual countries. With the aim of leveling out risks and enhancing the advantages of the country's economic system, the author proposes a systematic approach to assessing the state and perspective directions of Ukraine's integration. On the basis of game theory, factor analysis and the value chain model, the possibility of introducing the concept of advantages of a hierarchy of approach models into public administration is substantiated [43, p. 3-6].
In the work of T. Vader "State regulation of innovative development in the
Ukrainian economy" (2014), taking into account the fundamental features of integration processes, determined the main provisions of state regulation strategy of innovative development in the national economy. The author has improved the transformational directions of state regulation of innovative development in the Ukrainian economy and the mechanism of state regulation of innovative development in the economy on the basis of public consensus between the state, the private sector, educational and scientific organizations, the public [44, p. 2-4].
In work E. Vaysman "Formation of mechanisms of public administration in the development of the investment potential in the regions of Ukraine" (2014) is characterized the systematic approach by the determines, the direction of development in public-private partnership in the sphere of entrepre-neurship in Ukraine through the system of state insurance, public control, implementation of technology of crowd-sourcing, technological modernization National economy. With the aim of developing public-private partnership in the field of entrepreneurship, foresight technology for informatization of public administration and methodological approaches to assessing the investment cluster interaction of business entities with public authorities are being improved [45, p. 3-5].
In the dissertation V. Kutkov "Marketing mechanism of public administration in the development of the region" (2014) the content, purpose and structure of the marketing mechanism of public administration for regional development are specified. To meet the needs of consumers and increase
the competitiveness of the region, the author, on the principles of marketing, has improved the methodology for attracting investment in the region, the mechanism for developing a program for the social and economic development of the region, and the structural and functional support for the public administration of the region [46, p. 2-5].
Theoretical and methodological results of the work of A. Mashkov "Mechanisms of state regulation of foreign economic activity in Ukraine in conditions of innovative development" (2014) is the development of a system of means for implementing strategic directions of state regulation in Ukraine's foreign economic activity on the functional relationships principles, taking into account existing and potential resources and attracting necessary resources in Ukraine. The cluster architecture of innovative development of foreign economic activity, the mechanism of interrelations and coordination of interests of participants in clusters of foreign trade activities was improved [47, p. 2-5].
N. Pilipenko in the work "Mechanisms of public administration in financial resources through the treasury system" (2014) explored the design and structure of an integrated mechanism for public administration in financial resources through the treasury system. This allowed him to propose an optimal administration system, strengthen the stability, reliability and transparency of the state's financial system. Based on the use of the rating grouping of objects, the author suggests an approach to the implementation of treasury control [48, p. 3-4].
Important results of the research A. Pinchuk "Formation of effective mechanisms of state regulation in financial services in Ukraine" (2014) are disclosed in the following provisions:
1) establishment of the institution of financial ombudsman and the Supervisory Board as a special body for monitoring the activities of the ombudsman;
2) the definition of a single state megaregulator in the sphere of non-banking financial services as a central executive body with a special status on the basis of the National Commission. Taking into account the influence of the state on the markets of financial services, taking into account the institutional and regulatory provisions, the author first formed the features of state regulation in the sphere of non-banking financial services for periods [49, p. 3-5].
D. Scriabina in her work "Mechanisms of state regulation of foreign economic activity in Ukraine" (2014) formed an approach to state regulation of foreign economic activity in the conditions of multi-vector development of foreign economic activity in the country by means of mechanisms: the introduction of priority integration courses, the implementation of the state strategy for the development of foreign economic activity, priority sectors of the national economy [50, p. 3-6].
M. Hiramagomedov in the work "State regulation of the grain market development in Ukraine" (2014) analyzed and improved the state regulation of the agrarian sector development in the Ukrainian economy. He characterized the transformation of state regulation in grain market development in Ukraine towards integration into the global market [51, p. 2-6].
D. Baranova in the work "Institutional basis for the development of financial control in the system of public administration in Ukraine" (2015) examines the system of strategic institutional development of state financial control based on the principle of an integrated system of second-hand control functions. The introduction of a single information and analytical system of state financial control over the country's economic development is proposed, as well as the introduction of a model for the organization of external state financial control [52, p. 3-5].
The results of dissertation research A. Bondarenko "The mechanism of public financial control in Ukraine" (2015) is to determine the priorities of the mechanism in public financial control on the principles of self-organization of the control system in combination of participants interests and potential resource. The formation of financial and management relations between all business entities formed priorities for the implementation of the mechanism in public financial control. The study considers the use of reflexive influence on the subjects of financial control and rating grouping of financial control objects, providing for the introduction of a single information database [53, p. 3-6].
The most important scientific results, revealing the content of the thesis work Y. Kazyuk "Public administration of budgetary resources in conditions of decentralization" (2015) is the concept of public administration of budgetary resources on the basis of a decentralized management model. In the study, it is about creating a resource self-sufficiency of local budgets
and reducing tax pressure. The mechanism of introduction of various rates of the profit tax with the purpose of modernization and stimulation of regional manufacture is offered. The author has improved the method of treasury services for local budgets and the need for public-private partnership in the forms of concessions as BOOT and BOO has been proved by the projects of three parties: the state, representatives of the Ukrainian business and foreign business entities [54, p. 28-37].
Positions of the O. Kulik's work results "Improving the mechanisms of state regulation in the development of agrarian entrepreneurship in Ukraine" (2015) concretize approaches to implement the model of interaction in the agrarian entrepreneurs at the national level. The work introduces new principles regarding the functioning of mechanisms for state regulation of the development of integrated formations in the agrarian entrepreneurship in the context of economic clustering. The author also developed programs for the integration development in agrarian tourism, improves the mechanisms for state regulation of the development in the agrarian entrepreneurship [55, p. 2-4].
The main scientific result of the work L. Rudalevoi "State regulation of banking activities in the stock market in the context of the national economy modernization" (2015) is a comprehensive study of the state regulation mechanism on the stock market of banks. On the principles of a new domestic depository system with new powers, the features of the National Bank of Ukraine functioning are scientifically justified. The tasks of state
regulators of the National Bank of Ukraine and the National Commission for Securities and Stock Market were analyzed for the innovations of the depository system, which made it possible to disclose the need to strengthen the state regulatory function of the participants in the domestic depository system [56, p. 3-6].
B. Tyurus in his study "Mechanisms of the modernization processes in public administration in the Ukrainian economy in the context of globalization" (2015) improved the modernization mechanisms in public administration of the economy, including modernization of the state economic policy, industrial and technological base of the economy and the system of social protection of the population. The interrelation of quantitative and qualitative indicators in the modernization of the economy is scientifically substantiated, taking into account the correlation dependence of the given indicators [57, p. 2-4].
In work V. Tikhonovich "Mechanisms of public administration in the sphere of economic cooperation with European countries" (2015) with the aim of increasing the efficiency and effectiveness of national development proposed the economic cooperation as a theoretical basis for the influence of state authorities on Ukraine's economic relations with the EU. In the context of European integration of Ukraine, the system of principles for the implementation of economic cooperation is indicated [58, p. 3-5].
In work D. Bikulov "Formation of resource maintenance of development in local government in Ukraine" (2016) the concept of resource maintenance
of development in local government, local territorial community structure is developed and their economic functions are defined. The author suggested the main directions and sources of local self-government development in Ukraine [59, p. 4-6].
Conclusions. Thus, the article analyzes scientific research on mechanisms of public administration of outstripping development of the Ukrainian economy over the past five years (from 2011-2016). This makes it possible to determine the direction of development of the Ukrainian economy in the coming years.
references -
1. Order of the Ministry of Education and Science № 1151 dated November 6, 2015 "On the peculiarities of the introduction of a list of branches of knowledge and specialties, which provide training for applicants for higher education, approved by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine from April 29, 2015, № 266". Retrieved from: http:// zakon0.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/ z1460-15
2. Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine № 266 dated April 29, 2015 "On Approval of the List of Fields of Knowledge and Specialties under which Higher Education Institutions are Prepared". Retrieved from:: http:// zakon3.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/266-2015-%D0%BF
3. Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine № 674 dated September 27, 2016 "Some issues of reforming the system of vocational training for civil servants and officials of local self-government". Retrieved from: http://www.kmu.gov.ua/control/uk/ cardnpd?docid=249368547
4. Andriyevskyy D. Y. (2011). Formuvan-nya i realizatsiya derzhavnoyi promys-lovoyi polityky na rehional'nomu rivni [Formation and implementation of state industrial policy at the regional level]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
5. Anikeyenko V. M. (2011). Der-zhavne rehulyuvannya rozvytku rehional'noho ahrarnoho rynku. [State regulation of development of the regional agrarian market]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 19 [in Ukrainian].
6. Bezuhla L. S. (2011). Derzhavne re-hulyuvannya rozvytku maloho ta seredn'oho pidpryyemnytstva v umo-vakh informatsiynoho suspil'stva. [State Regulation of the Development of Small and Medium-Sized Entrepre-neurship in the Information Society]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
7. Butnyk O. O. (2011). Rozvytok der-zhavnoyi investytsiynoyi polityky na rehional'nomu rivni. [Development of the state investment policy at the regional level]. Mykolayiv: Black Sea State University named after P. Mo-hyla, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
8. Vlizlo Y. M. (2011). Formuvannya efektyvnoho mekhanizmu derzhavno-ho rehulyuvannya investytsiynoho po-tentsialu v Ukrayini. [Forming an effective mechanism of state regulation of investment potential in Ukraine]. Donetsk: Donetsk State University of Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
9. Dev'yatka V. V. (2011). Formuvan-nya vzayemovidnosyn ta vzayem-odiy maloho pidpryyemnytstva z hromads'kistyu v systemi derzhavno-ho upravlinnya. [Formation of interrelations and interactions of small business with the public in the system of public administration]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 21 [in Ukrainian].
10. Dovhan' A. S. (2011). Udoskonalen-nya mekhanizmu derzhavnoho up-ravlinnya spetsial'nymy monopoliy-amy (alkohol'no-tyutyunovyy sektor ekonomiky). [Improving the mechanism of state management of special monopolies (alcoholic and tobacco sector of the economy)]. Donetsk: Donetsk State University of Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
11. Dolhalov V. Y. (2011). Podatkovyy kontrol' v systemi derzhavnoho up-ravlinnya sotsial'no-ekonomichnym rozvytkom rehionu. [Tax control in the system of state management of social and economic development of the region]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
12. Eroshkina O. O. (2011). Derzhavne re-hulyuvannya sotsial'no-ekonomichno-ho rozvytku depresyvnykh terytoriy. [State Regulation of the Social and Economic Development of Depressive Territories]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
13. Malafyeyev T. R. (2011). Derzhavne rehulyuvannya rozvytku kharchovoyi promyslovosti Ukrayiny. [State regulation of the food industry of Ukraine]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 18 [in Ukrainian].
14. Maretskyy R. A. (2011). Derzhavne rehulyuvannya sudnobudivnoho kompleksu v umovakh restruktury-zatsiyi ekonomiky Ukrayiny. [State regulation of the shipbuilding complex in the context of restructuring the Ukrainian economy]. Kyiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
15. Mirko N. V. (2011). Derzhavne rehu-lyuvannya rozvytku vnutrishn'oho rynku produktsiyi lehkoyi promyslov-osti. [State regulation of development of the domestic market of light industry products]. Kyiv: Academy of Mu-
nicipal Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
16. Prykhodko O. M. (2011). Derzhavne rehulyuvannya rozvytku ahropro-myslovoho kompleksu rehionu. [State regulation of the development of the agro-industrial complex of the region]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
17. Svitlychna Y. O. (2011). Derzhavne rehulyuvannya zovnishn'otorhovel'noyi diyal'nosti v Ukrayini. [State Regulation of Foreign Trade Activity in Ukraine]. Kharkiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
18. Stativka N. V. (2011). Derzhavne rehu-lyuvannya produktyvnosti ahrarnoho sektora ekonomiky Ukrayiny. [State regulation of agricultural sector productivity in Ukraine]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 40 [in Ukrainian].
19. Tkachenko V. S. (2011). Zovnishn'o-ekonomichna stratehiya derzhavy yak zasib zabezpechennya konkurento-spromozhnosti natsional'noyi ekono-miky. [The external economic strategy of the state as a means of ensuring the competitiveness of the national economy]. Donetsk: Donetsk State University of Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
20. Filipenko T. V. (2011). Mekhanizm derzhavnoho upravlinnya valyutnym rynkom Ukrayiny. [The mechanism of public administration of the currency market in Ukraine]. Donetsk: Donetsk State University of Management, p. 36 [in Ukrainian].
21. Shevchenko N. O. (2011). Rozvytok rehional'noyi investytsiynoyi polityky derzhavy v ahrarnomu sektori ekono-miky. [Development of the regional investment policy of the state in the agrarian sector of the economy: theory, methodology, practical implementa-
tion mechanisms]. Donetsk: Donetsk State University of Management, Yuho-Vostok, p. 375 [in Ukrainian].
22. Blyznyuk V. V. (2012). Rozvytok der-zhavnoho rehulyuvannya bankivs'koyi systemy v umovakh hlobalizatsiyi. [Development of state regulation of the banking system in the context of globalization]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
23. Gindes A. V. (2011). Formuvannya ta realizatsiya mekhanizmiv zabezpe-chennya ekonomichnoyi stabil'nosti Ukrayiny. [Formation and implementation of mechanisms for ensuring the economic stability of Ukraine]. Mykolayiv: Black Sea State University named after P. Mohyla, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
24. Divenkov A. V. (2012). Mekhanizm derzhavnoho rehulyuvannya rozvy-tku chornoyi metalurhiyi Ukrayiny. [The mechanism of state regulation of the development of ferrous metallurgy in Ukraine]. Donetsk: Donetsk State University of Management, p. 21 [in Ukrainian].
25. Kalyuha O. O. (2012). Mekhanizmy derzhavnoho rehulyuvannya fondo-voho rynku Ukrayiny. [Mechanisms of state regulation of the stock market in Ukraine]. Kharkiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
26. Kolizhuk O. O. (2012). Derzhavne up-ravlinnya zovnishn'oekonomichnoyu diyal'nistyu Ukrayiny v umovakh yevropeys'koyi intehratsiyi. [Public administration of foreign economic activity in Ukraine in the conditions of European integration]. Kyiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
27. Meleshko M. I. (2012). Mekhanizmy derzhavnoho rehulyuvannya rynku
zerna Ukrayiny. [Mechanisms of state regulation of the grain market of Ukraine]. Kyiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
28. Nahors'kiy B. A. (2012). Derzhavne rehulyuvannya zovnishn'o-ekonomichnoyi diyal'nosti hirnycho-metalurhiynoho kompleksu Ukrayiny. [State regulation of foreign economic activity of the mining and metallurgical complex in Ukraine]. Donetsk: Donetsk State University of Management, p. 18 [in Ukrainian].
29. Panin A. H. (2012). Derzhavne up-ravlinnya investytsiyno-budivel'noyu diyal'nistyu v umovakh ekonomich-noyi kryzy. [Public administration of investment and construction activity in the conditions of economic crisis]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 21 [in Ukrainian].
30. Pozhydayev A. Y. (2012). Mekha-nizm derzhavnoho stymulyuvannya rozvytku ahroprodovol'choho sektora: stratehichnyy aspekt. [Mechanism of state stimulation in agro-food sector development: strategic aspect]. ]. Donetsk: Donetsk State University of Management, p. 21 [in Ukrainian].
31. Sjomych M. I. (2012). Mekhanizmy pidvyshchennya efektyvnosti der-zhavnoyi ekonomichnoyi polityky v systemi zabezpechennya dobrobutu naselennya Ukrayiny. [Mechanisms of increasing the efficiency in state economic policy in the system of ensuring the welfare of the population in Ukraine]. Mykolayiv: Black Sea State University named after P. Mohyla, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
32. Shpak Y. V. (2012). Mekhanizmy der-zhavnoho rehulyuvannya ahrarnoho sektoru natsional'noyi ekonomiky v umovakh hlobalizatsiyi rynkiv. [Mechanisms of state regulation in the agrarian sector of the national economy in the context of the markets globaliza-
tion]. Mykolayiv: Black Sea State University named after P. Mohyla, p. 36 [in Ukrainian].
33. Shpachuk V. V. (2012). Derzhavne up-ravlinnya bankivs'koyu systemoyu: antykryzovyy aspekt. [Public administration of the banking system: anti-crisis aspect]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 36 [in Ukrainian].
34. Barvinenko V. D. (2013). Mekhanizmy derzhavnoho rehulyuvannya stiykoho rozvytku prodovol'choho rynku v Ukrayini. [Mechanisms of state regulation of sustainable development in the food market in Ukraine]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
35. Borysenko O. P. (2013). Formuvan-nya derzhavnoyi zovnishn'oeko-nomichnoyi polityky Ukrayiny ta me-khanizmy yiyi realizatsiyi. [Formation of the state foreign economic policy in Ukraine and the mechanisms for its implementation]. Kyiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 36 [in Ukrainian].
36. Gvazava N. H. (2013). Mistsevi by-udzhety yak chynnyk ekonomichno-ho rozvytku terytorial'nykh hromad Ukrayiny. [Local budgets as a factor in the development of the territorial communities of Ukraine]. Kharkiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
37. Dvyhun S. M. (2013). Derzhavne rehu-lyuvannya zovnishn'oekonomichnoyi diyal'nosti v umovakh intehratsiyi Ukrayiny do svitovoho ekonomich-noho prostoru. [State regulation of foreign economic activity in the conditions of Ukraine's integration into the world economic space]. Mykolayiv: Black Sea State University named after P. Mohyla, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
38. Zubrytska N. B. (2013). Mekha-nizmy derzhavnoho rehulyuvannya
bankivs'koyi sfery Ukrayiny. [Mechanisms of state regulation of the banking sphere in Ukraine]. Mykolayiv: Black Sea State University named after P. Mohyla, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
39. Ryabtsev H. L. (2013). Kontseptual'ni zasady derzhavnoyi polityky rozvy-tku rynku naftoproduktiv v Ukrayini. [Conceptual bases of the state policy of market development in Ukraine]. Kyiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 36 [in Ukrainian].
40. Fedorov V. V. (2013). Udoskonalennya mekhanizmiv derzhavnoho upravlinn-ya podatkovoyu systemoyu Ukrayiny. [Improving the mechanisms of public administration of Ukraine's tax system]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
41. Kharchenko V. V. (2013). Udoskon-alennya mekhanizmu derzhavnoho up-ravlinnya innovatsiynym rozvytkom vuhlevydobuvnoyi haluzi. [Improving the mechanism of public administration of the coal mining industry innovative development]. Donetsk: Donetsk State University of Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
42. Tsvok V. I. (2013). Derzhavne rehu-lyuvannya vykorystannya resursnoho potentsialu promyslovosti v umovakh makroekonomichnoyi nestabil'nosti. [State regulation of the resource potential using in industry in the conditions of macroeconomic instability]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
43. Chala N. D. (2013). Mekhanizmy der-zhavnoho upravlinnya ekonomichnym rozvytkom Ukrayiny v umovakh hlo-balizatsiyi. [Mechanisms of public administration in the economic development of Ukraine in the context of globalization]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 36 [in Ukrainian].
44. Vader T. M. (2014). Derzhavne rehu-lyuvannya innovatsiynoho rozvytku
ekonomiky Ukrayiny. [State regulation of innovative development in the Ukrainian economy]. Kharkiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
45. Vaysman E. Y. (2014). Formuvannya mekhanizmiv derzhavnoho upravlinn-ya rozvytkom investytsiynoho potent-sialu rehioniv Ukrayiny. [Formation of mechanisms of public administration in the development of the investment potential in the regions of Ukraine]. Donetsk: Donetsk State University of Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
46. Kutkov V. P. (2014). Marketynhovyy mekhanizm derzhavnoho upravlin-nya rozvytkom rehionu. [Marketing mechanism of public administration in the development of the region]. Kharkiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
47. Mashkov A. O. (2014). Mekhaniz-my derzhavnoho rehulyuvannya zovnishn'oekonomichnoyi diyal'nosti Ukrayiny v umovakh innovatsiynoho rozvytku. [Mechanisms of state regulation of foreign economic activity in Ukraine in conditions of innovative development]. Mykolayiv: Black Sea State University named after P. Mo-hyla, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
48. Pilipenko N. M. (2014). Mekhanizmy derzhavnoho upravlinnya finans-ovymy resursamy cherez systemu kaznacheystva. [Mechanisms of public administration in financial resources through the treasury system]. Kharkiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
49. Pinchuk A. P. (2014). Formuvannya efektyvnykh mekhanizmiv derzhavno-ho rehulyuvannya finansovykh posluh v Ukrayini. [Formation of effective mechanisms of state regulation in financial services in Ukraine]. Kyiv: Na-
tional Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
50. Scriabina D. S. (2014). Mekha-nizmy derzhavnoho rehulyuvannya zovnishn'oekonomichnoyi diyal'nosti Ukrayiny. [Mechanisms of state regulation of foreign economic activity in Ukraine]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
51. Hiramagomedov M. H. (2014). Der-zhavne rehulyuvannya rozvytku rynku zerna v Ukrayini. [State regulation of the grain market development in Ukraine]. Kharkiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
52. Baranova D. A. (2015). Instytutsiyni zasady rozvytku finansovoho kontro-lyu v systemi derzhavnoho upravlin-nya Ukrayiny. [Institutional basis for the development of financial control in the system of public administration in Ukraine]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
53. Bondarenko A. I. (2015). Mekhanizm upravlinnya derzhavnym finansovym kontrolem v Ukrayini. [The mechanism of public financial control in Ukraine]. Kharkiv: National Institute of Civil Protection of Ukraine, p. 21 [in Ukrainian].
54. Kazyuk Y. M. (2015). Derzhavne up-ravlinnya byudzhetnymy resursamy v umovakh detsentralizatsiyi. [Public administration of budgetary resources in conditions of decentralization]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 40 [in Ukrainian].
55. Kulik O. H. (2015). Udoskonalennya mekhanizmiv derzhavnoho rehulyu-vannya rozvytku ahrarnoho pidpryy-emnytstva v Ukrayini. [Improving the mechanisms of state regulation in the development of agrarian entrepre-neurship in Ukraine]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
56. Rudalyeva L. V. (2015). Derzhavne re-hulyuvannya bankivs'koyi diyal'nosti na fondovomu rynku v umovakh mod-ernizatsiyi natsional'noyi ekonomiky. [State regulation of banking activities in the stock market in the context of the national economy modernization]. Kyiv: National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
57. Tyurus B. Y. (2015). Mekhanizmy der-zhavnoho upravlinnya protsesamy modernizatsiyi ekonomiky Ukrayiny v umovakh hlobalizatsiyi. [Mechanisms of the modernization processes in public administration in the Ukrainian economy in the context of globalization]. Lviv: National Academy of Pub-
lic Administration under the President of Ukraine, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
58. Tikhonovych V. V. (2015). Mekhaniz-my derzhavnoho upravlinnya v sferi ekonomichnoho spivrobitnytstva z krayinamy Yevropy. [Mechanisms of public administration in the sphere of economic cooperation with European countries]. Kyiv: Academy of Municipal Management, p. 20 [in Ukrainian].
59. Bikulov D. T. (2016). Formuvannya resursnoho zabezpechennya rozvytku mistsvoho samovryaduvannya v Uk-rayini. [Formation of resource maintenance of development in local government in Ukraine]. Zaporizhzhya: Classical private university, p. 40 [in Ukrainian].
