CC BY
81Copyright © 2021 by Academic Publishing House Researcher s.r.o.
★ ★ ★
★ * ★ Published in the Slovak Republic
* ★ ★
International Journal of Media and Information Literacy
International Journal of Media and Information Literacy
★ Has been issued since 2016.
E-ISSN: 2500-106X 2021, 6(1): 17-33
DOI: 10.13187/ijmil.2021.1.17 www. ej ournal4 6.com
A Comparative Analysis of the Reportage of Covid-19 During the First and Second Wave: A Case of the Egyptian and Jordanian Newspapers
Miral Sabri AlAshry a , *
a Faculty of Economics and Political Science, Political Mass Media Department, Future University in Egypt (FUE), Egypt
This study investigated online newspaper coverage of COVID-19 in Egypt and Jordan, with particular attention to the depth of coverage. The main objective of the study was to examine the content of news covering COVID-19 posted online concerning Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers, to know which countries were more interested and committed to covering health crises. A content analysis of 4202 news articles by four news media organizations: Al-Ahram, youmy, Al-Rai, and Addustour was done. The findings of the study indicated that the Al-Ahram, youmy in wave one was in-depth coverage, as compared to Al-Rai and Addustour coverage. In addition, Al-Rai and Addustour used a negative panic tone in presenting COVID-19 pandemic-related stories, in contrast to the Al-Ahram, youmy. Finally, Al-Rai and Addustour focused on reporting stories and raising awareness in waves one and two more than Al-Ahram and youmy. Based on these findings: the following recommendations were made: the media should focus more on sensitising the public on the necessary steps to take in curbing the virus. They should refrain from over usage of a negative tone to panic the public in presenting the stories of the COVID-19 pandemic in both countries.
Keywords: COVID-19, pandemic, online news media, outbreak, prevention, public health.
1. Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic began in Wuhan, Hubei Provence, China, in December of 2019. In March 2020, Egypt and Jordan had their first fatality cases of the coronavirus outbreak that affected the People's in the Middle East, with initial reports indicating that the virus had originated from tourism or travellers who passed through the airports. The rapid spread of the disease was further confirmed in Egypt and Jordan, with 151,723 and 309,846 confirmed cases of COVID-19 respectively (Worldometers, 2021).
Accordingly, the media rushed to report the disease outbreak, highlighting the different aspects of the pandemic (Tejedor et al., 2020). During the period of the pandemic, online journalism platforms became the main sources of information since they present a wealth of information and also have a large impact on the public (Mansour, 2016). In the past, online newspapers in Jordan and Egypt used information as a tool to instill panic and chaos within society, but during the pandemic, the media houses played an important role to return the credibility from disinformation (Bennett, Livingston, 2018), with trust towards legacy media and politics without polarization, and the configuration of a high-choice media environment (Van-Aelst et al., 2017).
* Corresponding author
E-mail addresses: [email protected] (M. AlAshry)
Abstract
Providing information to the public on emergent, complex and rapidly changing health threats is no easy task, even for public health experts. Previous studies found that the coverage of health topics is very complicated, especially in the Middle East because the governments did not provide information sources that enriched public awareness of the pandemic (Aalberg et al.,2013; Ahmadi, Amp, 2018). In this context, in both countries, the political information played a key role but after the pandemic, they focused on public health and not negligible, as online journalism functioned as a social link that united communities in the Middle East (Fletcher and Nielsen, 2017).
The coverage focuses on two aspects the first about Egyptian newspaper coverage pandemic, since the announcement of the first case in March 2020, the government started multidisciplinary national coordination between different ministries; they decided to stop close airport travels, schools, or universities. Moreover, Egypt started to examine all tourists coming to Egypt, and they discovered cases of COVID-19 in a cruise ship in Luxor, after that, on March 8, Egypt announced that a 60 year-old German tourist died in the touristic town Hurghada, and this was the first German fatality from the virus (Medhat, El Kassas, 2020).
The escalation in the number of cases by the first wave to be 24.985 cases, accordingly the government take more strict arrangements imposed a curfew from 7 pm until 6 am, all means of public and private transportation are suspended during curfew hours, and all sports and many social activities were also banned to prevent the spread of COVID-19 (Abdelhafiz et al., 2020).
Then the situation changed in the second wave in November 2020, the government took lighter protective measures compared with the first wave which is more widespread and dangerous, the government opened airports and hotels for domestic tourism and transferred to the citizens the responsibility for their own safety by taking their own precautionary measures. In addition, schools and universities remained the priority for education (Elemerey, 2020).
The Egyptian media have remained an essential agent in the last event of a health epidemic during the Ebola, SARS, MERS, they did not play an important role in disseminating information whenever an outbreak occurs, but now with COVID-19 pandemic, the government and media houses changed their strategy and worked on the challenges that arose from the crises, while other independent media houses created a crisis when they published high mortality during the pandemic (Marzouq, 2020).
During covid-19 outbreaks, the Egyptian media houses played a pivotal role in the documentation of the number of cases and death, and also created an avenue for political and public debate on the handling of the health crises (Elemerey, 2020). Similarly, R. Marzouq (Marzouq, 2020) noted that the sooner the media coverage of a pandemic begins, the less the public would ultimately be infected, as the media provide information about pandemic infections and deaths.
The newspapers have a vital role in getting the data to the public during emergency situations than transfer it as a news story, after that delivering the appropriate message to make the issue more prominent (Borek, 2020). In Egypt, online newspapers began reporting the Egyptian policy measures and covering topics that respond to the emergency of the situation and taking safety measurements (Hart et al, 2020).
The news coverage generally focuses predominantly on the impact of the diseases by highlighting certain features such as victims and economic impact in the country (Leask et al, 2010; Lusk, 2020). In the past, the health media coverage in June 2013, about the joint mission of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) and the World Health Organization (WHO) met in Riyadh to assess the situation due to a new coronavirus in the Kingdom during the beginning of the pandemic, reporters wrote uncertainties about the pandemic and compared it with another Spanish flu of 1918-19 and Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)the coverage and they focusing on dramatic health stories about the number of deaths 40 have occurred in KSA rather than analysing the content (Abu Senna, 2015).
The differences in the coverage of the COVID-19 may be due in part, to the differences in newspapers' ideology messaging on the issue by using government's newspaper-like Al-Ahram to representation a vital role in following specific strategies in order to make audiences read the news and interact to make awareness about the pandemic (Hart et al, 2020). Elemere/s (Elemerey, 2020) argue the coverage in independent media houses realised frequently to COVID-19 as a "hoax" came from China and has been dismissive of the risks posed by the virus.
In addition, the media houses party media in Egypt were more likely to spread misinformation about COVID-19 during the first wave outbreak using amplified voices of political actors in the coverage (Marzouq, 2020).
The second aspect about Jordanian newspaper coverage pandemic, the first case of COVID-19 infection in Jordan was confirmed on March 2, 2020. On March 14, the government followed WHO recommendations with a series of preventive and control strategies in the country, the government implemented total lockdown measures relating to" travel, education, religious and social events"(Altamimi, 2020; Altammemi, 2020), national emergency law was declared with strict rules and extreme fines for violations in order to limit the spread of the virus, started to implement periodically revised strict rules.
After that, on June 6, the Jordanian government announced that the level of severity in the number of local infection cases decreased by 10 cases per day, which led the country to open most of the service sectors, activities and facilities. Then on the first of November Jordan confirmed the second wave, the country witnessed an unprecedented increase in the number of case - 75,866 and deaths 866. The officials in Jordan warned of the collapse of the health sector due to the huge numbers of injured people. While a member of the country's epidemiology committee warned of the possibility that Jordan would enter an epidemic crisis and which recorded 8,000 cases per day (Eysenbach, 2020; Worldometers, January 13, 2021)
Accordingly, the government used Al-Rai and Addustour online newspapers during the crisis to alert citizens of the seriousness of the virus and its rapid spread. In addition, using news as a message to educate the public about how to protect themselves and measures to reduce its spread as many individuals (Habes et al., 2020).
Jordan received positive recognition internationally for the way they handled the ongoing pandemic in wave one and two, the government used media coverage to keep the public adequately informed with local, regional, state, and country's health. In addition, government success relies on mitigation measures related to drastic lockdown and cooperation with the public (Dardas et al., 2020).
Jordanian government relied heavily on promoting public awareness through collaboration with the Ministry of Health and Ministry of Information and the Crisis Center and they designed effective strategies to enhance public awareness. Information was delivered daily in televised press conferences to update the people about the ongoing pandemic. This gave updates on the latest figures (number of confirmed cases, tests, recovered patients), as well as for instructions that people should follow to reduce the exposure to COVID-19 (BalaEddy, 2020). Furthermore, the government tightened up efforts in the second wave with public attention, which could portend long-term transformations in Jordanian media habits and mark a turning point in transparency, by providing more information (Lynch, 2020).
An adequate public response to the pandemic depends on an informed community. Newspapers such as Al-Rai and Addustour are committed to investigating the regional responses to this crisis and the related public health issues and provides additional reporting about practical day-to-day tips and techniques for handling this quickly changing landscape includes school closures, social distancing, curfews, and working from home (Basch et al, 2020).
At the same time, the government imposed harsher limitations on journalism and the public, as a way to combat the spread of potentially false information online. In this view, government several online newspapers were blocked for spreading rumours about the virus, and the government statement carried across national newspapers raised troubling implications using cybercrime laws of those publishing any information regarding the virus's outbreak in Irbid, to combat rumours that can weaken the effectiveness of government response (Hussein, Aljamili, 2020).
For the first time in Jordan, unprecedented attention to government statements and policy also insisted the governments' visible efforts to share credible information, by effectively updating more successful policies while publishing information in the newspapers, the government has been able to overcome these early crises while retaining a high degree of citizen compliance with and support for stringent regulations (Management, 2020). The government announced that print newspapers would no longer be printed, and they implemented another alternative whereby the newspapers would be delivered electronically to subscribers, in order to minimise the transmission of infection (Abdelhafz, 2020).
The current study investigates the most popular and read Egyptian newspapers (Al-Ahram and youmy) and Jordanian (Al-Rai, and Addustour) newspapers to establish the depth of coverage of the COVID-19 pandemic during the first and second wave and which country from the sample
media coverage did more awareness with accurate information to inform public about the pandemic.
This study seeks to answer the following questions comparing between wave one and two, COVID-19 in Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers.
RQ1: What is the story format applied in the coverage?
RQ2: What is the depth of coverage?
RQ3: What are the dominant news and Journalist sources?
RQ4: What is the tone used in the coverage (positive, negative, or neutral)?
RQ5: What are the most notable themes in Egyptian and Jordanian in the sampled newspapers?
2. Materials and methods
Research design. The study employed a quantitative content analysis to assess online newspaper reportage of the COVID-19 scourge in Egypt and Jordan. A. Bryman defined content analysis as "an approach to the analysis of documents and texts, that seeks to quantify content in terms of predetermined categories and in a systematic and replicable manner" (Bryman, 2004: 177). The emphasis in most definitions has been on the systematic character of the analysis, meaning that coding is applied in a consistent manner to minimize any possible bias and to promote transparency.
B. Berelson adds the technique implies 'the objective of the quantitative description and the manifest content of communication' (Berelson, 1971: 18). Quantitative content analysis (CA) was applied to study online newspaper of the COVID-19 scourge. Four widely daily read two Egyptian and two Jordanian newspapers available online were selected for the study (see Table 1).
Newspaper sample. The Egyptian newspapers are Al-Ahram, founded on 5 August 1875, which is the most widely circulating; it is owned by the Egyptian government. The second newspaper is Youm7 meaning (The Seventh Day), founded on May 2011 as independent newspaper selected to be the Forbes Middle East as having the most effective news website in the Middle East. Third, Al-Rai meaning "The Opinion" founded in 1971, it is an independent newspaper. Fourth, Addustour, meaning the "Constitution" founded in 1967 and owned by Jordan Press and Publishing Company.
The study encompassed the first wave from 15 March 2020 to 31 May 2020 and the second wave from 1 November to 3 January (see Table 1).
Table 1. Newspapers' sample
Type of newspapers First wave from Second wave from 1
15 March to 31 May November to 3 January
Egyptian Al-ahram 598 694
newspapers http://gate.ahram.org.eg/
youm7 594 619
https://www.youm7.com/
Jourdan Al- Rai 205 233
newspaper www.alrai.com
Addustour 597 662
www.addustour.com
Techniques for selecting the stories. An online search using social bakers to download the news by keywords including 'COVID-19', 'Pandemic', 'Coronavirus in Egypt', 'Coronavirus in Jordan', 'death rates of Coronavirus', 'intervention on Coronavirus', 'policy measures in Egypt and Jordan'.
Unit of analysis. This study examined a total 4.202 newspaper articles (see Table 2).
Table 2. Types
Journalistic
Headline
photos/ videos Source Newspaper Sources Journalist sources
Newspaper tone The main major around the content
'news with video', 'editorials', 'feature', 'opinion' 'interview', 'report', and 'investigative'. Informative, expressive, or appellative
Archive image/ image, Videos, info Graphic, and Logo Agencies, Reporters, Reps Arab media outlets, and Foreign media
Government, Local county agencies and local public health Departments, International Health Organizations, and Internal media platform or source Positive, Negative, and Neutral frames Cases in Egypt and Jordan (who is contracted COVID-19 or those who treated, and Death rates)
• Government measures using the Ministry of Interior to apply the precautionary measures (lockdown schools and university / sectors of the institutional)
• Public enlightenment through online newspapers messages about the (risk, wearing face mask, social distancing, washing of hands, and using hand sanitizer )
• The abuses that occur by the people towards the precautionary measures
• Healthcare risk (inadequate isolation and treatment _hospital / the cost in the hospital )_
Data analysis. Data were further analyzed using SPSS Statistics for Windows, to descriptive statistics involving frequencies and percentages, to represent the sampled article characteristics. Assuredly, the data were collected subjected to T-Test and Chisquare, set at 0.05 significance level. Conclusively, all data were presented in the form of tables.
Table 3. Coverage of COVID-19
Waves Total
Newspaper wave 1 wave 2 Z test
598 694 1292 Z value -1.101
Al-Ahram p- value
30.00 31.40 30.70 0.312
594 619 1213 Z value 1.25
youm7 29.80 28.00 28.90 p- value 0.21
205 233 438 Z value -0.29
Al Rai 10.30 10.60 10.40 p- value 0.773
597 662 1259 Z value -0.03
Addustour p- value 0.976
29.90 30.00 30.00
1994 2208 4202
Total
100.00 100.00 100.00
3. Discussion
This study examined the Egyptian and Jordanian newspaper coverage of Covid-19 during the first and second waves. The findings of the study indicated that the media reported 4202 news articles the first wave (1994) and second wave (2208) stories.
With regards to the story format used in the coverage, we found that more than a third of the total news with video was used in the coverage and it was the first time all of the newspapers
incorporated video in order to attract the public. This finding is consistent with the study by A. Elemerey (Elemerey, 2020). Consequently, the Egyptian newspapers used video news more than interviews to report the news about COVID-19 with percentage (88 %).
During the coverage, Al-Ahram and youm7 used informative headlines to report the information about the pandemic in waves one and two. During the coverage, the newspapers play an important role to deliver the stories about COVID-19, for example Egypt has witnessed increased cases but the original data were not published for fear of creating panic, unlike in Jordan's newspapers which worked to create terror among the citizens by using headlines bearing the meanings of financial fines, curfews, breaching the curfew and imprisonment for those who violated the curfew. The regular strategy adopted in the newspaper has been to make fine-grained descriptive distinctions using diff erent types of news headlines to interact with the public. This result concurs with D. Dor (Dor, 2003) who noted that newspaper headlines help readers to get the maximum out of this informational flood—for the minimal cognitive investment, as Al-Rai and Addustour provide the readers with an optimally relevant presentation of their stories, they guide readers to those specific stories about COVID-19, which would be worth reading.
The newspapers from both countries used photos and videos in the coverage of the COVID-19. In addition, we found that more than half of the total percentage used infographics to support their stories for the first-time infographics witnessed a boom in the newsroom's use of infographics to describe visualizations that use various graphics to display data and ideas about pandemic especially in youm7 adding graphics along with the text, which brings in perspectives and depth to the news story. This result concurs with by A. Elemerey (Elemerey, 2020). during an outbreak of a pandemic infographics play an important role in shaping public opinion more than news text.
Researchers indicate that the public understands risks and crosses better when the media houses presented the news with visuals (AbuSenna, 2015; Hart et al., 2020; Marzouq, 2020), as they fear that they have limited threat about the pandemic, as well as the fear of being hazardous to the family (Zidan, 2020). Also, other research affirmed that the public can change their attitude and behaviour when they see visuals news shape about COVID-19 (Mahmoud, 2020; Abdelhafz, 2020).
With regards to newspaper coverage, most of the stories used 500 words and above (long articles), especially in wave two, which reflects in-depth writing to explain the details and cover different aspects of the pandemic. This is consistent with research by C. Rachul and T. Caulfield (Rachul, Caulfield, 2015) that analysed Canadian newspaper coverage of health policy decisions and found that the news articles covered diseases (22.6 %) with long articles to explain the discussion of a range of conditions and issues relevant to diseases, conditions, or access.
Prior research has shown that news and journalist sources play an important role in the coverage. In this study, we found that in the news sources coverage, newspapers depend on foreign media in the first wave, then they shifted the depth to agencies during the second wave. We observed that the least sources were newspaper reporters during wave one and Reps Arab media outlets articles in the second wave. Moreover, about the journalist sources, most of the newspapers sourced from the government, and then the percentage was almost the same at Local county agencies and local public health, departments, International Health Organizations, and internal media platform.
This result is slightly different from A. Zidan (Zidan, 2020) who found that Reps Arab media outlets are the most generally cited sources in the media coverage. We reason that youm7 in wave one reported "Egyptian channels have provided comprehensive coverage and a responsible message between directing and mobilizing in the face of danger" by using Reps Arab media outlets (Saeed, 2020). In addition, the most telling part of analysis concerns the tone, given the immense focus on "Neutral tone" to support increasing access to healthcare, Addustou in wave two used "Negative tone". This is represented in Jordanian government which implemented the curfew, and whoever violates this ban would be punished by imprisonment.
Regarding the most notable themes used in the coverage, the study observed that most of the stories induced panic among the public, while others raised awareness among the people.
4. Results
The story format applied in the coverage in Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers (comparing between wave one and two, COVID-19)
Tables 4 and 5 are presentations of the story format of online newspaper coverage of the COVID-19, comparing between wave one and two. Coronavirus-related information occupies wave one (38.4 %; 37.3 %; 36.5 %; 36.0 %) and wave two (31.1 %; 35.3 %; 24.0 %; 20.0) of the news with video. Precisely, editorials (25.9 %) in the wave one in Al-Ahram, more than wave two (17.0 %). On the other hand the percentage was the same with Al-Rai in the wave one and youm.7; Al-Rai; Addustour (10.7 %). In addition, Al-Rai, and Addudtour did not focus on the investigative except, while Al-Ahram in wave two focused on the pandemic spared in Egypt more than wave one (1.4 %) also youm7 did not release that in wave one( 2.5 %).
To compare the Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers coverage first and second wave, in the Al-Ahram and youm7 newspaper (N= 2465; M=2.95; SD; 2.127) and Al-Rai and Addustour (N= 1651; M= 3.55; SD; 2.301), the differences significant for Al-Rai and Addustour (T=-8.571; DF= 4114; p< 0.000). To realize the depth of coverage between Al-Ahram and youm7, first wave (N=1192; M=2.60; SD= 1.865) in the second wave (N=1273; M=3.28; SD=2.299), we pointed out that most of the journalists for the second wave T=-7.994; DF=2463, p< 0.000.
To point the depth of coverage between Al-Rai and Addustour in the first wave (N= 802; M=3.36; SD= 2.324), in the second wave (N=849; M=3.73; SD=2.265) & (T= -3.339; DF=1649, p< 0.000), so the differences for the second wave. Furthermore, to recognize the coverage on the first wave, Al-Ahram and youm7 (N=1192; M=2.60; SD=1.865) than Al Rai and Addustour (N=802; M=3.36; SD=2.324) the differences for the second wave (T=-8.014; DF=1992, p< 0.000). In the second wave, Al-Ahram and youm7 (N=1313; M=3.28; SD= 2.299) than, Al-Rai and Addustour (N=849; M=3.73; SD=2.265) the differences significant to Al-Rai and Addustour (T=-4.496; DF=2120, p< 0.000) .We can observe that the most common of the newspapers used video to interact public, then editorials have high profound insight and context about the pandemic. On the other hand, most of the newspaper did not focus on feature especially Al-Ahram in wave one youm7; Al Rai and Addustour in wave two.
Table 4. Story format (first wave coverage)
Newspaper news with editorials Feature opinion interview investigative report Total video
# % # % # % # % # % # % # %
Al-Ahram 230 38.4 155 25.9 25 4.1 63 10.5 32 5.3 43 7.1 50 8.3 598
youm7 222 37.3 143 24.0 122 20.5 33 5.5 22 3.7 15 2.5 37 6.2 594
Al Rai 75 36.5 22 10.7 14 6.8 15 7.3 16 7.8 18 8.7 45 21.9 205
Addustour 215 36.0 66 11.5 74 12.3 55 9.2 45 7.5 41 6.8 101 16.9 597
Chi2= 21 1.621 & DF= 18 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.139 & p- value= 0.023
Table 5. Story format (second wave coverage)
Alahram 216 31.1 118 17.0 126 18.1 33 7.4 36 5.1 10 1.4 115 16.5 694
youm7 219 35.3 68 10.9 56 9.0 55 8.8 35 5.6 55 8.8 131 21.1 619
Al Rai 56 24.0 25 10.7 22 9.4 31 13.3 15 6.4 16 6.8 67 28.7 233
Addustour 133 20.0 134 20.2 45 6.7 122 18.4 20 3.0 32 4.8 131 19.7 662
Chi2= 215.14 & DF = 18 & p- value= = 0.000 & Pearson's R= = 0.1 & p- value= 0.021
Headlines are very important for the readers, their location on the online page colour, type and size of the title contributes to underlining the topic that includes a lot of information. In relation to these Tables 6 and 7, most of the headlines were informative especially in Al-Ahram and youm7 (65.5 % & 67.8 %) in the second wave (65.5 %) but in the first wave, youm7 got (52.1 %) Al-Ahram (34.2 %) compared with Jordanian newspapers Addustour (46.8 %) Al-Rai (130 %) in the second wave; half of the percentage decreased with Al-Rai (31.7 %) in the first wave. This means that Al-Rai newspaper found disease risk to have increased in the second wave, and the rates of warnings with fear-topped the headlines. Both the Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers used headlines of an appellative nature to raise awareness about the pandemic, in wave one more than wave two.
The expressive headlines are one of the most important elements of the newspaper; as attention is paid in order to make them more colourful, intriguing and catching (Oden, 2019). The percentage was almost the same with expressive in Al-Ahram and Addustour in wave one (24.2 %; 23.9 % ) than the percentage change in wave two Al-Ahram dropdown with 100 points, and the percentage was almost the same with youm.7 and Al-Rai (21.0 %; 22.7 %). This reduced number emphasizes that the newspapers in both countries did not draw more attention to the public because this might fear emotions. To compare the Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers coverage of the first and second wave, in the Al-Ahram and youm7 newspaper (N=2585; M = 1.72; SD= 0.851) and Al-Rai and Addustour (N=1651; M=1.76; SD= 0.818), (T=-1.5073; DF=4234; p< 0.1318|), signifying no significant difference in the nationality of the newspapers of the headlines. To realize the depth of coverage between Al-Ahram and youm7, first wave (N=1192; M=1.91; SD=0.877) in the second wave (N=1393; M=1.56; SD=0.794) T=-10.572; DF=2583, p< 0.000 so that the different for the first wave.
The depth of coverage between Al-Rai and Addustour in the first wave (N= 802; M=1.87; SD=0.859) in the second wave (N=849; M=1.66; SD=0.765) & (T= 5.2743; DF=1649, p< 0.000), so the differences for the first wave. Furthermore, the coverage on the first wave: Al-Ahram and youm7 (N=1192; M=1.91; SD=0.877) than Al Rai and Addustour (N=802; M=1.87; SD=0.859) There are no significant differences (T=9842; F=1992, p<0.3251). In the second wave, Al-Ahram and youm7 (N=1313; M=1.56; SD=0.794) than Al-Rai and Addustour (N=849; M=1.66; SD=0.765) the differences significant to Al-Rai and Addustour.
The main characters that appear infographic on the coverage Table 8 and Table 9 show important differences between the Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers, for the first time all of the newspapers depend on the infographic to describe the story about COVID-19 with an overwhelming number of facts, figures, statistics, scientific data and medical advice sprawled across the newspapers.
Table 6. Headline (first wave coverage)
Newspaper Informative Expressive Appellative Total
# % # % # %
Al-Ahram 205 34.2 145 4.2 248 41.4 598
youm7 310 52.1 122 0.5 162 27.2 594
Al Rai 65 31.7 55 6.8 85 41.4 205
Addustour 288 48.2 143 3.9 166 27.8 597
Chi2= 63.084 & DF = 6 & p- -value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.175 & p-value= 0.000
Table 7. Headline (second wave coverage)
Al-Ahram 455 65-5 120 7.2 199 26 694
youm7 420 67.8 130 1.0 69 11.1 619
Al Rai 130 55.7 53 2.7 50 214 233
Addustour 310 46.8 203 0.6 103 155 662
Chi2= 105.062 & DF= 6 & p-value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.212 & p-value = 0.000
The highest percentage with youm7 (54.3 %) Addustour (55.4 %) in wave one, they used different types of visuals proving successful message data visualizations, charts, maps, and cartoons. Then the percentage change in wave two with Al-Rai (30.0 %) which used important content to the public with infographics, animations, and illustrations.
The newspapers also used video in the fight against COVID-19 in second place, in wave two more that wave one (46.1 %; 53.7 %; 51.5 %). Addustour realized that in the second wave, the image is very important and absorbs the most attention they used celebrities with public figures (25.6 %) and Al-Ahram used logo in the second wave (17.2%) this aspect emphasizes the importance type to give information and awareness of the pandemic.
To compare between Egyptian and Jordanian newspaper, Al-Ahram and youm7 are (N=2557; M=2.71; SD=1.053) and Al Rai and Addustour (N=1695; M=2.69; SD=i.o89) T=0.555; DF=4250, and p< 0.579, significance, there are no significant level between Egyptian and Jordanian coverage. In addition, about Al-Ahram and youm7 coverage in the first wave (N=1244; M=3.05; SD=i.oo6) and in the second wave (N=1313; M =2.39; SD; 0.997) So T=16.478; DF=2555, p< 0.000 significance level. But Al-Rai and Addustour coverage in the first wave (N=802; M=3.01; SD=1.010) second wave (N=893; M= 2.40; SD= 1.076) So T=11.957; DF=1693, and p<0.000 significance level, to observe the difference for first wave.
In considering all the newspaper coverage during the first wave, Al-Ahram and youm7 coverage (N=1244; M=3.05; SD; 1.006) and Al-Rai and Addustour coverage (N=802; M=3.01; SD; 1.010) So (T=0.7307; DF=2044) and p<00.465 significance, there are no significant differences. Moreover, the coverage in the second wave Al-Ahram and youm7 coverage (N=1313; M=2.39; SD; 2.39) and Al-Rai and Addustour coverage (N=893; M=2.40; SD; 1.076) So T= 0.252; DF=2204 and p<0.801, there are no significant differences were found.
Table 8. Photos and videos (first wave coverage)
Newspaper Image Videos Logo Info graphic Total
# % # % # % # %
Al-Ahram 33 .5 20 6.7 5 .19 90 8.4 98
youm7 13 .1 244 1.0 6 1.1 23 4.3 94
Al Rai 11 .3 02 9.7 3 6.0 9 8.7 05
Addustour 13 .1 30 38.5 3 .8 31 5.4 97
Chi2= 76.91 & DF= 9 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.19 & p- value= 0.000
Table 9. Photos and videos (second wave coverage)
Al-Ahram 153 2.0 20 6.1 20 7.2 01 4.5 94
youm7 60 .9 33 3.7 5 .2 81 9.2 19
Al Rai 22 .4 20 1.5 9 .20 0 0.0 33
Addustour 170 5.6 45 7.0 00 5.1 47 2.2 62
Chi2= 151.214 &DF = 9 & p- value = 0.000 & Pearson's R = 0.253 & p- value= 0.000
The depth of coverage in Egyptian and Jordanian in the sampled newspapers (comparing between wave one and two, COVID-19)
Tables 10 and 11 examined the percentage words per article. Words per article was analysed and categorized as long, medium and short, in order to know what information includes COVlD-19. We observed that most of the stories described using 500 words and above (long articles), as well as 300-499 (medium articles). Al-ahram; youm7; and Addustour got the same percentage in wave one (35.1 %; 35.8 %and 41. 8 %) but the percentage increased in wave two, with 100 points (44.6 %; 53.3 %; 70.8 %; and 50 %) with long words. The lowest percentage Al- Rai described using 1-299 (short) 199 words (9.8 %) had shorter stories in the second wave.
To compare between the Egyptian and Jordanian coverage, Al-Ahram and youm7 coverage (N=2505; M=2.18; SD=o.797) and Al-Rai and Addustour coverage (N=1737; M=2.27; SD=o.789) & T= 3.673012; DF=4240, and p<0.000 significance, and yet the difference between the one group Jordanian coverage. Then, to compare between Al-Ahram and youm7 coverage in the first wave (N=1192; M=2.o8; SD=o.787) and second wave (N=1313; M=2.27; SD=o.796) T=-5.838; DF=2503, and p<0.000 significance. Then Al-Rai and Addustour coverage, in the first wave (N=802; M=2.13; SD=o.846) second wave (N=935; M=2.39; SD=o.715) T=-7.107; DF=1735, and p<0.000 significance. There is a no statistically significant difference between the newspapers during the second wave.
Moreover, about Egyptian, and Jordanian coverage during the first wave, Al-Ahram and youm7 coverage (N=1192; M=2.08; SD=0.787) and Al-Rai and Addustour coverage (N=802; M=2.13; SD=0.846) T=-1.202; DF=1992, and p<0.2296 significance, there is a no statistically significant difference between the newspapers. During the second wave (N=1313; M=2.27; SD=0.796) Al-Rai and Addustour coverage (N=935; M=2.39; SD=0.715) T=-3.85; DF=2246, p<0, set at 0.0001 significance, yet the difference between the Jordanian newspaper is not statistically significant.
Table 10. Words in the articles (first wave coverage)
Newspaper 500 words 300-499 1-299 (short Total
above (long (medium articles) articles) articles)
# % # % # %
Al-Ahram 10 35.1 215 35.9 73 28.9 598
youm7 13 35.8 231 38.8 50 25.2 594
Al- Rai 5 46.3 60 29.2 0 24.3 205
Addustour 50 41.8 155 25.9 92 32.1 597
Chi2= 31.721 & DF= 6 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.125 & p- value= 0.000
Table 11. Words in the articles (second wave coverage)
Al-Ahram 10 4.6 01 8.9 83 6.3 694
youm7 30 3.3 85 9.8 04 6.8 619
Al- Rai 65 0.8 6 9.7 2 .8 233
Addustour 31 50 66 40.1 05 5.8 662
Chi2= 87.106 & DF= = 6 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.193 & p- value= 0.000
The dominant news and Journalist sources in Egyptian and Jordanian in the sampled newspapers (comparing between wave one and two, COVID-19)
By analyzing the newspaper sources' reports pandemic, Tables 12 and 13 examined, Addustour and youm7 depend on foreign media 30.1 % & 29.1 %) in wave one. Then youm7, and Addustour used agencies, (22.7 % & 22.3 %) in wave one , but in wave two the percentage increased with youm7 (40.3 %). Al-Ahram depend on reporters during wave two with, followed by Republic of Arab media outlets with Al-Ahram and youm7 (25.9 % & 25.7 %) during wave one, while Addustour got (24.0 %) in wave two.
To compare between Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers coverage, Al-Ahram and youm7 (N= 2487; M=2.47; SD; 1.141) and Al-Rai and Addustour (n= 1697; M=2.55; SD; 1.141) T=-2.298; DF=4182, and p< 0.0216) so the difference between Jordanian coverage is not statistically significant. To realize the depth of coverage between Al-Ahram and youm7, during the first wave (N=1174; M=2.67; SD=1.131) and second wave (N=1313; M=2.29; SD=1.120).
To understand the depth of coverage between Al-Rai and Addustour, in the first wave (N=802; M=2.63; SD=1.124) and second wave (N=895; M=2.47; SD=1.076), (T=3.0508; DF=1695, p< 0.0023), there is not statistically significant.
With regards to the coverage of the first wave, Al-ahram and youm7 (N=1174; M=2.67; SD=1.131) than Al Rai and Addustour (N=802; M=2.63; SD =1.124) there no significant differences were found. (T=0.6488; DF=1974, p< 0.5166), second wave, Al-ahram and youm7 (N=1313; M=2.29; SD=1.120) than Al Rai and Addustour (N=895; M=2.47; SD=1.076) the differences for the Al Rai and Addustour (T=-3.852; DF=2206, p< 0.0001).
Table 12. News sources (first wave coverage)
Newspaper Agencies Reporters Reps' Arab foreign Total Sources media outlets media
# % # % # % # %
Al-Ahram 22 0.4 35 2.5 55 5.9 86 1.1 598
youm7 33 2.3 11 8.6 153 25.7 79 0.1 594
Al Rai 0 9.5 7 7.8 45 21.9 3 0.7 205
Addustour 36 2.7 22 0.4 165 27.6 74 9.1 597
Chi2= 9.912 & DF= 9 & p- value= 0.358 & Pearson's R= 0.071 & p- value= 0.358
Table 13. News sources (second wave coverage)
Al-ahram 55 2.3 10 4.6 20 7.2 09 5.7 694
youm7 50 0.3 00 6.1 5 15.3 74 8.1 619
Al Rai 5 9.3 5 3.6 5 27.8 8 9.1 233
Addustour 60 4.1 10 1.7 59 24.0 33 0.0 662
Chi2= 195.032 & DF= 9 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.285 & p- value= 0.000
Tables 14 and 15 indicate the journalists' sources of reports. The intention was to realize the most important sources government with Al-Ahram and Addustour (30.7 %; 31.4 %) the common percentage in wave two Al-Ahram, youm7, and Addustou (289 %, 252 %, and 215 %). However, Al-Ahram got the same percentage (International Health Organizations) (20.5 %). Most of the Al-Ahram and Addustour depend on internal media platform (28.8 % & 26.5 %) in wave two.
In comparing the Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers coverage, Al-Ahram and youm7 coverage (N= 2505; M=2.26; SD; 1.160) and Al-Rai and Addustour coverage (N= 1697; M=2.42; SD; 1.178), there is not statistically significant (T= 4.507; DF=4200; p< 0.000). To realize the depth of coverage between Al-Ahram and youm7, first wave (N=1192; M=2.36; SD=1.111) second wave (N=1313; M=2.17; SD=1.196), we pointed that the difference for the first wave was not statistically significant (T=4.178; DF=2503, p< 0.000). The depth of coverage between Al-Rai and Addustour, in the first wave (N=802; M=2.42; SD=1.152) and second wave (N=895; M=2.43; SD=1.202) & (T=-0.154; DF=1695, p< 0.877) indicates no significant differences.
Furthermore, the coverage during the first wave, Al-Ahram and youm7 (N=1192; M=2.36; SD=1.111) than Al Rai and Addustour (N=802; M=2.42; SD=1.152) indicates no significant differences (T—1.155; DF=1992, p< 0.248),while during the second wave, Al-Ahram and youm7 (N=1313; M=2.17; SD=1.196) than, Al-Rai and Addustour (N=895; M=2.3; SD=1.202), the differences for the Al Rai and Addustour (T=-5.035; DF=22o6, p< 0.000).
The tone used in the coverage by the Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers
The main tone used in the coverage, as displayed in Tables 16 and 17 show important differences between the newspapers in both countries. The negative tone is the one that gets the most attention, with Addustour (119.3 %) wave one but the percentage increased in wave two (35.1 %).
To explain the negative tone in the first wave with both countries, for example, with the stakes are from the King of Jordan and the Egyptian President using army to intervene.
Al-Ahram focused on "The Prime Minister: The plan to coexist with the" COVID-19 includes penalties for those who are not compliant." (Hassan, 2020, May 14). , General Mohamed Farid reviews the measures of the armed forces to confront the effects of the spread COVID-19" (Salem, 2020, April 7). And "Security campaigns to control those who violate the deadlines for closing shops and commercial centers to reduce" COVID-19" (Attia, 2020, April 1). But Youm7 online newspaper focused on injury and death rates "Health: 54 positive cases of COVID-19, 5 deaths" (Abdel Salam, 2020, March 31) and "Health: 33 new positive cases of COVID-19, 4 deaths" (Abdel Salam, 2020, March 29). On the other hand, Al- Rai newspaper used "An important security statement regarding compliance with the orders and instructions issued for violating the curfew" (Alrai, 2020, March 31).
Table 14. Journalist sources (first wave coverage)
Newspaper government Local county International Internal media Total
Sources agencies and Health platform
local public Organizations
health
departments
# % # % # % # %
Al-Ahram 184 30.7 166 27.7 123 20.5 125 20.9 598
youm7 165 27.7 146 24.5 160 26.9 123 20.7 594
Al Rai 40 19.5 90 43.9 30 14.6 45 21.9 205
Addustour 188 31.4 125 20.9 123 20.6 161 26.9 597
Chi2= 59.76 & DF= 9 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.171 & p- value= 0.000 Table 15. Journalist sources (second wave coverage)
Al-Ahram 289 41.6 155 22.3 50 7.2 200 28.8 694
youm7 252 40.7 161 26.0 101 16.3 105 16.9 619
Al Rai 45 19.3 22 9.4 66 28.3 100 42.9 233
Addustour 215 32.2 245 37.0 26 3.9 176 26.5 662
Chi2= 253.238 & DF= 9 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.321 & p- value= 0.000
About the Positive tone, youm7 and Addustour has got the same percentage (24.2 %) in wave one, then growing up to (46.8 %) in wave two, with Addustour and youm7. For example, the positive tone in the first and second wave reassuring related to COVID-19 to downscale the risk. For example, 'How did Egypt prepare for the second wave of the COVID-19 crisis?' (Hassan, 2020, December 12). 'Health: Manufacturing COVID-19 vaccines locally as part of the state's plan to confront the virus '(Abdel Salam, 2020, November 26), and in Jordanian newspapers, "Experts: Jordan needs a comprehensive economic plan that overcomes the consequences of the COVID-19".
Then, the neutral tone the highest percentage with youmy (43.0 %) wave one, then Al-Ahram (37.1 %) in wave two. For example, Addustour newspaper focused on "Governmental measures to confront COVID-19, suspending educational institutions" (Addustour, 2020, March 15).
In the second wave the tone changes with Jordan more than Egypt Addustour newspaper focused on "Warning sirens sounded at 12 o'clock and once, before the start of the comprehensive curfew at 1 pm for a period of 48 hours (Addustour, 2020, October 15). About the neutral tone, the tow counter used the same way for example, "Lectures by 350 citizens who violated the instructions for wearing the muzzle" (AlBassel, 2020, April 1). And "Experts: The effect of wearing a "muzzle" is equivalent to the vaccine" (Elsaid, 2020, November 26).
In comparing Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers coverage, Al-Ahram and youmy (N= 2387; M=1.93; SD; 0.845) and Al-Rai and Addustour (N= 1573; M=1.89; SD; 0.799), there are no significant differences (T=-1.756; DF=3958; p< 0.079). The depth of coverage with Al-Ahram and youmy, first wave (N=1074; M=2.12; SD=0.813) second wave (N=1313; M=2.17; SD=1.196) & (T=4.178; DF=2503, p< 0.000).
Then, the depth of coverage between Al-Rai and Addustour, in the first wave (N= 678; M=2.04; SD=0.775), second wave (N=895; M=1.77; SD=0.798), (T=-6.793; DF=1571, p< 0.000), we noted that the there are no statistically significant.
Furthermore, the coverage on the first wave by the Al-Ahram and youmy (N=1074; M=2.12; SD=0.813) than Al Rai and Addustour (N=678; M=2.04; SD=0.775) indicate no significant differences (T=-1.893; DF=1750, p< 0.059), while during the second wave, Al-Ahram and youmy (N=1313; M=1.78; SD=0.842) than, Al-Rai and Addustour (N=895; M=1.77; SD=0.798) also indicates no significant differences. (T= 0.441; DF=2206, p< 0.659).
Table 16. Tone used in the coverage (first wave coverage)
Newspaper tone Positive Negative Neutral Total
# % # %
# % # % # %
Al-Ahram 55 5.9 65 7.5 68 8.0 598
youm7 45 4.4 85 1.1 56 3.0 594
Al Rai 5 1.9 5 1.7 5 6.3 205
Addustour 45 4.2 205 119.3 23 0.6 597
Chi2= 49.018 & DF= 6 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.165 & p- value= 0.000
Table 17. Tone used in the coverage (second wave coverage)
Al-Ahram 15 5.3 21 6.8 58 7.1 694
youm7 22 2.0 01 2.4 6 5.5 619
Al Rai 02 3.7 5 9.3 6 6.9 233
Addustour 10 6.8 33 5.1 19 7.9 662
Chi2= 144.179 & DF = 6 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.248 & p- value= 0.000_
The most notable themes in the Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers
This part of the study aimed to establish the main topics related to COVID-19 in both countries. Table 18 and Table 19 shows, Cases (who is contracted COVID-19 or those who treated, and Death rates) Alahram and Addustour got (36.0 % & 35.1 %) in wave one, then the proportion decreases with Addustour (18.5 %).
Moreover, the (Government measures using the Ministry of Interior to apply the precautionary measures (lockdown schools and university / sectors of the institutional), the percentage the same Al-Ahram (17.5 %) in wave one and two.
About the abuses that occur by the people towards the precautionary measures the percentage is the same youm7 and Addustour (22.2 %) during wave one. In addition, Public enlightenment through online newspapers messages about the (risk, wearing face mask, social distancing, washing of hands, and using hand sanitizer) were the most common topics, with Al-Ahram and Addustour having (10.5 %) during wave one, then increased in wave two with Addustour (26.4 %).
Regarding healthcare risk (inadequate isolation and treatment hospital/the cost in the hospital), the percentage was the same for Alahram and youm7 (8.5 %) then increased in wave two Addustour (14.1 %).
The Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers' coverage of the first and second waves, as indicated in the Al-Ahram and youm7 (N= 2505; M=2.52; SD; 1.293) and Al-Rai and Addustour (N= 1697; M=2.73; SD; 1.425) showed some differences significant for Al-Rai and Addustour (T=-4.907; DF=4200; p< 0.000).
To realize the depth of coverage between Al-Ahram and youm7, first wave (N=1192; M=2.12; SD=0.813) second wave (N=1313; M=2.17; SD=1.196), we observe the difference for the first wave statistically significant (T=4.178; DF=2503, p< 0.000).
In terms of the depth of coverage between Al-Rai and Addustour during the first wave (N= 802; M=2.45; SD=1.386), as well as the second wave (N=895; M=2.98; SD=1.414) & (T= -7.763; DF=1695, p< 0.000), so that the differences of significant for the second wave.
Furthermore, the coverage on the first wave: Al-Ahram and youm7 (N=1192; M=2.38; SD=1.245) than Al Rai and Addustour (N=802; M=2.45; SD=1.386) indicates no statistically significant difference between the newspapers (T=--1.178; DF=1992, p< 0. 0.239), second wave, Al-Ahram and youm7 (N=1313; M=2.65; SD=1.324) than Al-Rai and Addustour (N=895; M=2.98; SD=1.414) the differences significant to Al-Rai and Addustour (T=-5.592; DF=22o6, p< 0.000).
Table 18. The most notable themes (first wave coverage)
Content
Cases (who is contracted COVID-19 or those who treated, and Death rates)
Government measures using the Ministry of Interior to apply the precautionary measures (lockdown schools and university / sectors of the institutional)
The abuses that occur by the people towards the precautiona ry measures
Public
enlightenment through online newspapers messages about the (risk, wearing face mask, social distancing, washing of hands, and using hand sanitizer)
Healthcare risk
(inadequate
isolation
and
treatment hospital / the cost in the hospital
Total
# % # % # % # % # %
Al-Ahram 210 35.1 122 20.4 152 25.4 63 10.5 51 8.5 598
youm7 152 25.5 210 35.3 132 22.2 48 8.0 52 8.7 594
Al Rai 65 31.7 55 26.8 22 10.7 30 14.6 33 16.0 205
Addustour 215 36.0 118 19.7 133 22.2 66 11.5 65 10.8 597
Chi2= 81.256 & DF = 12 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.198 & p- value= 0.000
Table 19. The most notable themes (second wave coverage)
Al-Ahram 215 0.9 22 17.5 36 9.5 145 20.8 6 10.9 694
youm7 142 2.9 56 25.2 23 9.8 162 26.7 6 5.8 619
Al Rai 65 7.8 2 13.7 3 4.1 35 15.0 8 29.1 233
Addustour 123 8.5 45 21.9 25 8.8 175 26.4 4 14.1 662
Chi2= 132.344 & DF= 12 & p- value= 0.000 & Pearson's R= 0.238 & p- value= 0.000
5. Conclusion
We conclude that the Egyptian and Jordanian newspapers paid attention to coverage COVID-19 at the expense of other stories. However, the coverage during wave two was more in-depth than during wave one and most of the stories were long, had news infused with video to interact with the public. In addition, the stories focused on death and cases of COVID-19 and how governments find solutions.
This research, which is one of the first to examine newspaper coverage of COVID-19 between the said countries, contributes to the body of knowledge. Second, a comparison of media coverage in many countries in the Middle East with governmental healthcare coverage may provide further insights into whether there are any similarities between policymakers in the Middle East. Finally, the time frame analysis only covered the first and second wave, thus, it is possible that there will be a change in health issues, especially in the face of vaccinations which are taking place the world over.
References
Aalberg et al., 2013 - Aalberg, T., Blekesaune, A., Elvestad, E. (2013). Media Choice and Informed Democracy. The International Journal of Press/Politics. 18(3): 281-303. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1940161213485990
Abdel Salam, 2020 - Abdel Salam, W . (2020). Health: 54 positive cases of Covid-19, 5 deaths. youmy. 31.03.2020.
Abdel Salam, 2020 - Abdel Salam, W. (2020). Health: 33 new positive cases of corona virus, 4 deaths. youm7. 29.03.2020.
Abdel Salam, 2020 - Abdel Salam, W. (2020). Health: Manufacturing Covid-19 locally as part of the state's plan to confront the virus. youm7. 26.11.2020.
Abdelhafiz et al., 2020 - Abdelhafiz, A.S., Mohammed, Z., Ibrahim, M.E., Ziady, H.H., Alorabi, M., Ayyad, M., Sultan, EA. (2020). Knowledge, Perceptions, and Attitude of Egyptians Towards the Novel Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19). Journal of Community Health. 45(5): 881-890. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10900-020-00827-7
Abdelhafz, 2020 - Abdelhafz, N. (2020). Attitudes of The Egyptian public towards. The new media Treatment of Emerging coronavirus Pandemic. Media Research Journal. 54: 2093-2168. DOI: https:/ / doi.org/https://jsb.journals.ekb.eg/ article_108274_a17234e68e790a1408f8e24ee0b6492e
Addustour, 2020 - Addustour. (2020). Governmental measures to confront Covid-19. Addustour. 15.03.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: addustour.com/articles/1138674--20-^l i89o6-^^«Jl-f2020-jlji-i5-6-alj-^-il-A-i44i-M^j?todaydate=15842268oo
Addustour, 2020 - Addustour. (2020). Warning sirens sounded once at 12 o'clock, before the start of the comprehensive curfew at 1 pm for a period of 48 hours. Addustour. 5.10.2020.
Ahmadi, Wohn, 2018 - Ahmadi, M, Wohn, D.Y. (2018). The Antecedents of Incidental News Exposure on Social Media. Social Media + Society. 4(2): 205630511877282. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2056305118772827
Al ashreen, 2020 - Al ashreen, R. (2020). The reality of health media coverage of the Corona pandemic in satellite news media (Jordanian media as a model for this coverage). Arab Democratic Center, 13: 77-90. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://democraticac.de/?p=70841
AlBassel, 2020 - AlBassel, MA.L. (2020). Lectures by 350 citizens who violated the instructions for wearing a mask ... and Farah was dispersed in one of the villages in Minya. Alahram. 1.04.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: http://gate.ahram.org.eg/News/2554288.aspx.
Alrai, 2020 - Alrai. (2020). An important security statement on compliance with orders and instructions issued. Alrai. 31.03.2020.
Altamimi, 2020 - Al Tammemi, A.B. (2020). The Battle Against COVID-19 in Jordan: An Early Overview of the Jordanian Experience. Frontiers in Public Health. 8. DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.3389/fpubh.2020.00188
Altamimi, 2020 - AlTamimi, KA.M . (2020) Coronavirus Effects on the Economy of Jordan. International Journal of Financial Research. 11(5): 129. https://doi.org/10.5430/ijfr.v11n5p129
Attia, 2020 - Attia, A.R.A. (2020). Security campaigns to control those violating the closing dates of shops and commercial centers to reduce COVID19. Alahram. 1.04.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: http://gate.ahram.org.eg/News/2390811.aspx
BalaEddy, 2020 - BalaEddy, P. (2020). Transparency and repression in Jordan's response to COVID-19. 24.04.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://pomeps.org/transparency-and-repression-in-jordans-response-to-covid-19
Basch et al, 2020 - Basch, C.H., Kecojevic, A., Wagner, V.H. (2020). Coverage of the COVID-19 Pandemic in the Online Versions of Highly Circulated U.S. Daily Newspapers. Journal of Community Health. 45(6): 1089-1097. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10900-020-00913-w
Bennett, Livingston, 2018 - Bennett, W.L., Livingston, S. (2018). The Disinformation order: Disruptive communication and the decline of democratic institutions. European Journal of Communication. 33(2): 122-139. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0267323118760317 Berelson, 1971 - Berelson, B. (1971). Content analysis in communication research. Borek, 2020 - Borek, A. (2020). The Role of Mobile Journalism in raising the awareness among the Saudi Public on the Developments of COVID-19 Pandemic Crisis - A Field Study. Media Research Journal. 54: 3587-3682. DOI: https://doi.org/https://jsb.journals.ekb.eg/article_110181_c561f3e94 ea6314b81c26acb5df17377.pdf
Bryman, 2004 - Bryman, A. (2004). Social Research Methods, 2nd ed. Oxford University Press.
Dardas et al., 2020 - Dardas, LA, Khalaf, I., Nabolsi, M, Nassar, O, Halasa, S. (2020). Developing an Understanding of Adolescents' Knowledge, Attitudes, and Practices Toward COVID-19. The Journal of School Nursing. 36(6): 430-441. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/10598
40520957069
Dor, 2003 - Dor, D. (2003). On newspaper headlines as relevance optimizers. Journal of Pragmatics. 35: 695-721. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0378-2166(02)00134-0
Elemerey, 2020 - Elemerey, A. (2020). The Role of infographics on the Egyptian government pages on Facebook in supplying university Young with information about the Corona virus. Media Research Journal. 54(7): 2496-2536. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://jsb. journals.ekb.eg/article_108839_40ac4b854ec52b3b238ba4d9cce89312.pdf
Elsaid, 2020 - Elsaid, S. (2020). Experts: The effect of wearing a "muzzle" is equivalent to the vaccine. Alrai. 26.11.2020.
Fletcher, Nielsen, 2017 - Fletcher, R., Nielsen, R.K. (2017). Are people incidentally exposed to news on social media? A comparative analysis. New Media & Society. 20(7): 2450-2468. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1461444817724170
Hart et al., 2020 - Hart, P.S., Chinn, S., Soroka, S. (2020) Politicization and Polarization in COVID-19 News Coverage. Science Communication. 42(5): 679-697. DOI: https://doi.org/
10.1177/1075547020950735
Hassan, 2020 - Hassan, K. (2020). How did Egypt prepare for the second wave of the Coronavirus crisis?. Alahram. 12.12.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: http://gate.ahram.org. eg/News/2542315.aspx.
Hassan, 2020 - Hassan, K. (2020). The Prime Minister: The plan to live with the "Corona" virus includes penalties for those who are not committed. Al-Ahram. 14.05.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: http://gate.ahram.org.eg/News/2406754.aspx
Hussein, Aljamili, 2020 - Hussein, A.T., Aljamili, L.N. (2020). COVID-19 humor in Jordanian social media: A socio-semiotic approach. 15.12.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2405844020325391
Leask et al., 2010 - Leask, J., Hooker, C., King, C. (2010). Media coverage of health issues and how to work more effectively with journalists: a qualitative study. BMC Public Health. 10(1). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2458-10-535
Lusk, 2020 - Lusk, D.S. (2020). Media Advocacy and Public Health. 12.11.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/media-advocacy-and-public-health/book4219
Mahmoud, 2020 - Mahmoud, S.M. (2020) Arab and international websites' usage of data journalism during the coronavirus epidemic: An analytical study. Media Research Journal. 54(7): 2755-2832. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://journals.ekb.eg/article_108844_98790d42f29413 de609acc8a91a62b56.pdf
Management..., 2020 - Management Systems International (2020). Jordan media assessment white paper: government and media outreach in the age of covid-19 Governance Integration for Stabilization and Resilience in the Middle East and North Africa (GISR MENA). 18.06.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00WQVK.pdf
Mansour, 2016 - Mansour, E. (2016). The adoption and use of social media as a source of information by Egyptian government journalists. Journal of Librarianship and Information Science. 50(1): 48-67. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0961000616669977
Marzouq, 2020 - Marzouq, R. (2020). The discussion of talk shows on the Egyptian governmental and private channels about the Coronavirus (Covid 19) crisis "(Analytical Study"). Media Research Journal. 4(54): 2291-2352. DOI: https://doi.org/https://jsb.journals.ekb .eg/article_108726_6095fb78c859cee22f7dded73cd1199c.pdf
Medhat, El Kassas, 2020 - Medhat, MA., El Kassas, M. (2020). COVID-19 in Egypt: Uncovered figures or a different situation? Journal of Global Health. 10(1). DOI: https://doi.org/10.7189/jogh.10.010368
Mohammed et al., 2020 - Mohammed, H., Mahmoud, A., Sana, A., Ahmad, S., Said, S. (2020). The Relation among Marketing ads, via Digital Media and mitigate (COVID- 19) pandemic in Jordan. International Journal of Advanced Mechatronic Systems. 29(7): 22-45. DOI: https://doi.org/ https://www.researchgate.net/publication/342735833_The_Relation_among_Marketing_ads_via_ Digital_Media_and_mitigate_COVID-_19_pandemic_in_Jordan/citation/download
Oden, 2019 - Oden, C. (2019). Newspaper Style: Stylistic Features of the Headlines.
1.09.2019. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://www.projecttopics.org/newspaper-style-stylistic-features-of-the-headlines.html.
Rachul, Caulfield, 2015 - Rachul, C., Caulfield, T. (2015). The media and access issues: content analysis of Canadian newspaper coverage of health policy decisions. Orphanet Journal of Rare Diseases. 10. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13023-015-0320
Saeed, 2020 - Saeed, M. (2020). Egyptian Media Recover in the Battle of "Covid-19" ... Egyptian Channels Have Provided Comprehensive Coverage and a Responsible Message between Directing and Mobilizing in the Face of Danger. 10.04.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://www.youm7.com
Salem, 2020 - Salem, M. (2020). Lieutenant General Mohamed Farid reviews the procedures of the armed forces to confront the effects of the spread of the Corona virus. AlAhram.
7.04.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: http://gate.ahram.org.eg/News/2393124.aspx
Tejedor et al., 2020 - Tejedor, S, Cervi, L, Tusa, F., Portales, M., Zabotina, M. (2020). Information on the COVID-19 Pandemic in Daily Newspapers' Front Pages: Case Study of Spain and Italy. 31.08.2020. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32878092/
Van-Aelst et al., 2017 -Aelst, P.V., Strömbäck, J., Aalberg, T., Esser, F., Vreese, C.D., Matthes, J.,... Stanyer, J. (2017). Political communication in a high-choice media environment: a challenge for democracy? Annals of the International Communication Association. 41(1): 3-27. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/23808985.2017.1288551
Worldometers, 2021 - Worldometers. 13.01.2021. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://www. worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/jordan/
Worldometers, 2021 - Worldometer. 13.01.2021. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://www.world ometers.info/coronavirus/country/egypt/
Zidan, 2020 - Zidan, A. (2020). The Egyptian elite assessment of the government's strategies and its official media in managing the Corona crisis. Media Research Journal. 54(4): 2353-2433. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://journals.ekb.eg/article_108729_41d5e1911b9f98fe3c7e004c 81b149ec.pdf
