ТЕХНОЛОГИЯ И ОРГАНИЗАЦИЯ СТРОИТЕЛЬСТВА. ЭКОНОМИКА И УПРАВЛЕНИЕ В СТРОИТЕЛЬСТВЕ
RESEARCH PAPER I НАУЧНАЯ СТАТЬЯ UDC 69.051
DOI: 10.22227I1997-0935.2024.3.436-455
Using Building Information Modelling (BIM) by studying building orientation during design to achieve more sustainable buildings
Jamal Younes Omran, Moustafa Ali Wassouf
Tishreen University; Lattakia, Syria
ABSTRACT
Introduction. Energy is one of the most important issues that attract the attention of the whole world, and this in turn is reflected in the increase in energy consumption in residential and industrial buildings Therefore, the process of assessing the efficiency and quality of interior spaces is an important step from which the process of developing and upgrading these spaces begins to reach a sustainable model from an environmental, economic and social point of view. Materials and methods. The research aims to study the distribution patterns of residential divisions and their reflection on the energy of a residential suburb consisting of twenty residential buildings in Tartous Governorate, through the development of a software tool using Dynamo, which is one of the visual programming methods used in (BIM) using a programming language (Python) with the addition of studying heating and air conditioning loads for current orientation with comparison with loads after directing the building at different angles in order to reduce consumption and benefit from solar radiation sources through Revit. An analytical approach was used, through the analysis and extrapolation of the literature and referai ^ ences related to the study, in addition to the deductive approach by deducing problems in the current situation and providing suggestions for solutions that can be followed in the management and analysis of energy.
Results. The BIM approach contributed to the study of the building orientation and its reflection on thermal loads, taking into pj pj account all the factors causing this load, which can be adjusted according to any requirements or code.
Conclusions. Studying the building orientation during the design stage contributes to reducing the total annual heat load by £ more than 20 %, and this percentage varies according to the way buildings are assembled.
E J2
KEYWORDS: Building Information Modelling, Visual programming, building orientation, design phase, sustainability, shadow
study, the building envelope, building orientation ® ®
FOR CITATION: Jamal You.O., Moustafa А.W. Using Building Information Modelling (BIM) by studying building orientation O — during design to achieve more sustainable buildings. Vestnik MGSU [Monthly Journal on Construction and Architecture].
H £ 2024; 19(3):436-455. DOI: 10.22227/1997-0935.2024.3.436-455 (rus.).
■(u <u Corresponding author: Moustafa Ali Wassouf, [email protected].
■fl .
U cn
O É¿
----
о I g<
3 =
z ■ i от* ОТ E
.E о
X
Использование информационного моделирования строительных
объектов (BIM) с целью изучения ориентации здания при проектировании для достижения их большей устойчивости
Джамал Юнис Омран, Мустафа Али Вассуф
cl и Университет Тишрин; г. Латакия, Сирия
I
££ о Введение. Энергетика — один из наиболее актуальных вопросов. В связи с увеличением потребления энергии в жи-
АННОТАЦИЯ Введение. Эн
лых и промышленных зданиях оценка эффективности и качества внутренних помещений является важным шагом, 2 £ с которого начинается процесс разработки и внедрения новых технологий. Модернизация данных пространств при-
w g водит к созданию устойчивой модели с экологической, экономической и социальной точек зрения.
— 2 Материалы и методы. Цель исследования — изучение закономерностей распределения жилых кварталов и их от-
' ражение на энергетике жилого пригорода, состоящего из двадцати жилых зданий в провинции Тартус, благодаря раз-
О J5 работке программного инструмента с использованием программы Dynamo, который служит одним из методов визуаль-
g О ного программирования, используемых в BIM, с применением языка программирования Python. Исследованы нагрузки
iÉ S на отопление и кондиционирование воздуха для данной ориентации в сравнении с нагрузками после проектирования
S £ здания под разными углами, чтобы снизить потребление и извлечь выгоду из источников солнечного света с помощью
_ Revit. Использованы аналитический подход, основанный на анализе и экстраполяции литературы, связанной с иссле-
Ф ¡2 дованием; дедуктивный подход путем определения проблем и предоставления предложений по решениям, которым
U > можно следовать при управлении и анализе энергии.
Результаты. BIM-подход способствовал изучению ориентации здания и ее отражения на тепловых нагрузках с уче-
©43Y&J.O. Jamal, А.W. Moustafa, 2024
Распространяется на основании Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial (CC BY-NC)
том всех факторов, вызывающих эту нагрузку, которые могут быть скорректированы в соответствии с требованиями или нормами.
Выводы. Исследование ориентации здания на стадии проектирования способствует снижению общей годовой тепловой нагрузки более чем на 20 %, этот процент варьируется в зависимости от способа сборки зданий.
КЛЮЧЕВЫЕ СЛОВА: информационное моделирование строительных объектов, визуальное программирование, ориентация здания, этап проектирования, устойчивость, изучение расположения тени, ограждающая конструкция здания
ДЛЯ ЦИТИРОВАНИЯ: Джамал Ю.О., Мустафа А.В. Using Building Information Modelling (BIM) by studying building orientation during design to achieve more sustainable buildings // Вестник МГСУ. 2024. Т. 19. Вып. 3. С. 436-455. DOI: 10.22227/1997-0935.2024.3.436-455
Автор, ответственный за переписку: Мустафа Али Вассуф, [email protected].
INTRODUCTION
Modifying existing buildings offers great opportunities to reduce energy consumption and carbon emissions because buildings consume the most energy [1]. The research methodology based on Building Information Modelling (BIM) technology is considered one of the new technologies for retrofitting buildings to achieve low energy housing and reduce environmental impact [2]. The construction trend in sustainable design is defined as the way a building is placed on its position relative to the path of the sun and how the building handles the sun and how the glass openings are identified can have a significant impact on the energy efficiency of the building's systems and the comfort of the residents. Because the right orientation prepares the building to optimize passive solar-based and sometimes wind-based strategies, it naturally creates less energy solutions for lighting, heating and cooling [3]. Building Information Modelling (BIM) has the potential to help designers evaluate different design alternatives and select bioenergy strategies and systems at the design stage of proposed projects [4]. Linking the energy analysis tool to the BIM model helps speed up the energy analysis process, provide more detailed and accurate results, as well as provide energy-efficient buildings [5]. This research attempts to shed light on the issue of energy cost savings in construction projects during the design phase within the BIM environment with the aim of reaching sustainable energy-efficient buildings that benefit from sunlight and reduce fossil energy consumption, especially in residential buildings, which rank second in consumption [6]. Building energy use is expected to increase by 32 % by 2040 [7]. Where the most effective decisions regarding the sustainable design of a building can only be made at the design and pre-construction stages [8].
Many researchers have studied the effects of using BIM in examining project performance in terms of sus-tainability, and some research has focused on studying the possibility of BIM in supporting the design team to make the right design decisions early in the design phase and providing a model for a working mechanism to integrate building performance simulation for energy in the design phase [9]. In addition to correlation analysis of factors affecting cooling energy demand
in residential units, energy use for heating, ventilation and air conditioning is often the main contributor to operational energy demand, which ranges between 5070 % in most developed countries [10]. Some research has conducted energy analysis of residential buildings and various facilities at the end of the design phase, and once the building components and elements are selected from the orientation, shape, height, type and thickness of walls, type of glass, and thickness of ceilings and floors, however, the analysis of the energy consumption of these components at the conceptual design stage is very useful for designers to make decisions regarding the selection of the most appropriate design alternative that will lead to an energy-efficient construction [4]. Research has shown that design decisions have a significant impact on energy consumption in residential buildings, as the results showed a significant decrease in the energy consumed as a result of changing the orientation of the building, the area of windows and the addition of insulation layers to the external walls. The results also showed that the penetration of direct sunlight into the voids is the main source of heat and the first responsible for the high energy consumption in this sector of buildings. It showed that this source is responsible for 55 % of energy consumption followed by thermal conductivity through the building's outer sheath materials [11]. After reviewing the results of previous studies, the research localizes a global technology and shows the strong features of BIM in the field of building energy analysis and studying the impact of changing building distribution patterns and methods of assembly and direction on the total energy consumption costs.
Purpose of the study
Propose a methodology that allows the designer to study the percentage of utilization of natural solar radiation (during winter) or protection from it (during summer), in order to predict the thermal performance of the building, through an additional tool developed using visual programming, as well as calculate the necessary thermal loads (for heating and air conditioning). With the reorientation of the building at different angles in order to study the impact of the orientation of the building on energy consumption costs, up to the proposal of suitable materials for the building envelope that provide good thermal insulation, and thus contribute
< n iï kK
G Г
S 2
0 œ
t CO
1 »
y 1
J со
u-
^ I
3 °
» 3
о »
oî
о 3
со со
3 м » §
Г §6
» ) iï
<D
<0
. DO
■ T
s У с о
(D Ж WW
M 2 О О 10 10
N N
o o
tv tv
fifi
* (V
U 3
> in
E M
to en
. r
№ <u
<D <u
O S
o
o g<
o
co
™ O
o
ro
o
E o
CL ° c
Ln O
s «
o E
CD ^
ü w
i*
o iñ
to reducing the annual thermal load. To achieve this, the following steps were followed:
• building a 3D model using Revit that represents the case studied (residential buildings);
• designing a tool to predict the rates of utilization of solar radiation by nature (during the winter season) or protection from it (during the summer season) and using it on the studied situation;
• calculation of the loads necessary for heating and air conditioning of the studied residential buildings in the case of real orientation with recalculation of this load after changing the orientation by 5 and 10 degrees counterclockwise from the current situation;
• proposing and designing an additional tool by Dynamo and Python to achieve the building envelope for the design requirements of the thermal insulation code in oider to reduce thermal leakage, because the materials used in this envelope have high thermal transfer coefficients.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Collection of research data
All the data and plans necessary for the research were collected from the residential suburb project (Sheikh Saad node), consisting of twenty buildings, located in Tartous Governorate, and each building consists of a ground floor and sixteen repeated floors with a total height of (55.7 m). The floor area is (745 m2). Each floor consists of eight apartments with a floor area per apartment (70 m2). The following is the projection of the general location of the studied residential suburb Fig. 1.
Data analysis
The study tools were used, namely.
The use of BIM helps reduce the cost of sustainable buildings [12], where Software developers have integrated the visual programming language into BIM
programmes [13], and it is important to develop energy simulation methods at the early design stage and this is done using the latest tools, the newly developed VP (Visual Programming) (Dynamo) along with the Autodesk Revit design tool [8]:
• where Dynamo is used within Revit to automatically extract asset management data from the form and export the data to a special format required by the facility owner [14];
• Autodesk Revit 2020: BIM application tool helps to 3D modelling and simulation of the building energy modelling (BEM) in addition to calculating thermal loads for heating and air conditioning;
• Dynamo 2020 Autodesk: A visual programming tool integrated into the Revit programme, which was used to facilitate the energy analysis process;
• Python language: It is a programming language that was used in visual modelling as it is compatible with Dynamo;
• Insight 360: which is an addition within the Revit programme was used to calculate the amount of solar radiation falling on the facades of buildings for the studied case. Linking the energy analysis tool to the BIM model helps speed up the energy analysis process, provide more detailed and accurate results, as well as provide energy-efficient buildings [8].
Analytical Study of the Project in the Environment (BIM)
Based on the data collected, the following figure shows the results of modelling the residential suburb in the Revit programme (Fig. 2).
"Shadow Study" results
The following figure shows the nodes of the tool used to study the formed shadows and their effect
Fig. 1. Description of the general site with the placement of buildings (organizational scheme)
Fig. 2. Revit modelling results
Fig. 3. Shadow Study node components in Dynamo software
on neighboring buildings every hour of the year for Continuous assembly of buildings
each type of denominator (continuous and alternating) of the studied case (Fig. 3).
This method is characterized by peripheral aspects from all sides around the residential building, and
£ n
tT iH
H
G !
S 2
O œ
§ U)
z z
y 1 3
a 3
o a ^^ —
§ 2 a g
a
•v.
r ; t (
ui e e
cd cd
{?
W 9
. n
1 J
s 3
« «<
c o № W
2 2 O O (O (O
4 4
Fig. 4. North-South continuous assembly axis
Fig. 5. East-West continuous assembly axis
N N
o o
N N WW
* (V
U 3
> in
C M
to en
. r
w <u
H
<D <1J
o £
o
o g<
o
co
™ O
o
ro
o
E o
CL ° c
lt> O
s H
o E
CD ^
■8
0 (0
the residential sections are adjacent from two or three sides, and this grouping affects the buildings that will be built within these sections through.
When the longitudinal direction of this grouping, as in Fig. 4 is north-south, it will lead to the fact that the buildings located within the partitions that are located on the southern side, which will benefit from the winter sun, are few in number because the percentage of buildings located in the shadow area will be large.
When the longitudinal orientation of the assembly method is towards east-west Fig. 5 the buildings located within the residential complex, which are reached
Fig. 6. East-west alternating assembly axis 440
by the sun's rays in winter on the southern side, will be half of the buildings, since the buildings located on the northern side will be located in the shadow area thrown by the southern buildings.
Grouping of buildings alternately
This method is characterized by the fact that the front divider is displaced from the rear divider by half the length of the divider, and this displacement helps in the arrival of the sun's favoured rays from the southern side when the longitudinal direction of the assembly is east-west to the rear buildings through the distances between the front buildings as in Fig. 6.
When the longitudinal direction of the alternating assembly is towards the north-south, the buildings located within the front sections of the southern side are exposed to the winter sun, while the buildings located on the northern side are not exposed in the southern facade to sunlight in the winter because of the shadow of the building on it, as in Fig. 7.
RESULTS
Calculation of heat loads for heating and air conditioning using Revit
We will calculate the heat load for each type of divider in its current state and then we will redirect these blocks at certain angles provided that the rotation angle does not exceed 10 degrees [3] because this will affect the system of partitions adopted in the division. The direction of the building should be seriously considered, especially in the equatorial zone according to the interaction of the building envelope with solar radiation as well as the direction of the wind [15].
Fig. 7. North-south alternating assembly axis
After completing the modelling, we defined the spaces into rooms, which would be cooled and heated, and include living rooms and bedrooms, and then we defined the vertical zones, which is the group of space located in one plane, where all the data and special parameters necessary to calculate the heat load were entered in the Revit programme, shown in Table 1.
After defining all the parameters of the building, we will define the properties of the space for each room as shown in Fig. 8. Most of the previous properties and parameters are calculated by the Revit when determining the type of space, such as the space allocated per
person, the number of people, the heat emitted from them, the thermal energy from electrical appliances, the rate of ventilation and the required lighting, as these values have been modified according to the Syrian thermal insulation code, in addition to developing room occupancy plans, which greatly affects the heat load, so the presence of the person within the room means the need to achieve comfort for him, i.e. the operation of air conditioning or heating systems, and the following are the occupancy plans for the rooms (Fig. 9, 10).
After completing the definition of the properties of all spaces, the last step is to define the properties and parameters of the zone (Fig. 11).
Table 1. Parameters of calculating the heat load on the Revit programme
Parameter Value Explanation
Building Type Multi Family It is important to determine the type of building for which the load is to be calculated because this affects its occupancy rate and the number of operating hours
Location Tartous (34.9-35.9) When you select the location, the programme imports weather data from the daily temperature and the degree of clarity of the atmosphere
Ground Plane Level 1 The programme takes into account the floors adjacent to the soil when determining the ground floor level
Sliver Space Tolerance 12 m The programme asks for special tolerance limits between buildings, i.e. whether there are buildings adjacent to the studied building
Building Envelope Split System(s) with Natural Ventilation Type of air conditioning and heating system to be installed
Schematic Types <Building> The type of building structure, is it resistant to heat transfer due to insulation or not because this will affect the heat transfer with the external medium
Building Infiltration Class Medium The degree of immunity of the building and takes three values (heavy, medium, low) if the type of building is heavy and the peak hour is one in the afternoon, the building will need time to transfer heat (it will trap the maximum external temperature) and the peak hour inside the building is at three o'clock in the afternoon and this factor relates to the type of structure and the degree of insulation
< DO
iiï kK
O M
c
0 œ t co
1 »
y 1
J to
u-
^ I
» 3
0 »
01
o 3
co co
l\J CO
o
r §6
o o
0)
o
C 3
» ) ÎÏ
<D
<0
. DO
■ T
s □
s y c o <D * WW
M 2 O O 10 10
Space Type Settings
Filter: I Enter Search Words C^ |
Bank Customer Area Banking Activity Area - Office Barber and Beauty Parlor Card File and Cataloguing - Library Classroomyiecture/Training ClassroomAecture/Training - Penitentiary Conference Meeting/Multipurpose Confinement Cells - Courthouse Confinement Cells - Penitentiary Corridor/Transit on
Corridor /Transition - Manufacturing Facility
Corridors with Patient Waiting Exam - Hospital/Health
Court Sports Area - Sports Arena
Courtroom - Courthouse
Department Store Sales Area - Retail
Detailed - Manufacturing Facility
Dining Area
Dining Area - Civil Services
Dining Area - Family Dining
Dining Area - Hotel
Dining Area - Lounge/Leisure Dining
Dining Area - Motel
Dining Area - Penitentiary
DiningArea^Transportetor^^^^^^^^^^^^ Dormitory Study Hall
Dressing/Locker/Fitting Room - Auditorium Dressing^ocker/Fitting Room - Courthouse
Dressing/Locker/Fitting Room - Exercise Center < >
й го и a
Fig. 8. Properties of Space
Parameter Value
Energy Analysis «
Area oer Person [HJ 'JUU n 1
Sensible Нес: jcin per person tiJt VV
1 .it put Hr.it iw • |мч j'pisim ¿14:- W
1 z" -g 1 Mil Der^ity 1 <)S W/m2
Power Load Density 5.81 W/m"
Infiltration Airflow per area 0-1'J L/(s m';
Plenum Lias.i rva Cuntiibutwn ¿ü'JOOJ'/t
О: с u[>rin: у S: liedule Hi une D: i upaiH y ■ ?A H:-ui4
1 Э-* "Э r..-h*dule Office 1 iqhtmq ■ 6 AM to 11 PM
Power Schedule Wee Liqhtmq ■ b AM to 11 PM
Outdooi An pci Pcimhi 23Ь 1л
Gutdmn An per Апч O.VI 1 ,'iviir-}
Ait f harvges r>er ■ lour n.nononn
Outdoor Air Method bv People and by Area
(Ж I Cancel
Fig. 9. 24-hour space occupancy chart for bedroom
Fig. 11. Properties and parameters of the zone
Here we will specify the information on heating and air conditioning devices, which are Table 2.
Table 2. Information of heating and air conditioning devices
Heating Information
Fig. 10. 24-hour luminance usage rate diagram for bedroom 442
Heating Set Point 23 °C The room temperature at which the heating device will stop working
Heating Air Temperature 33 °C The temperature of the air coming out of the heating device
Cooling Information
Cooling Set Point 23 °C The room temperature at which the air conditioner will stop working
Cooling Air Temperature 16 °C The temperature of the air coming out of the air conditioner
Fig. 12. Continuous assembly in real mode
Results of the loads for the continuous assembly method of buildings
Continuous assembly with East-West axis
The loads of each method of assembling buildings were studied in three orientation positions, the first in the real current situation (Fig. 12), the second when rotating at an angle of 5 degrees, and the third when rotating at an angle of 10 degrees, and we will compare the results with each other to reach the best orientation.
After calculating the load in the previous real situation, these buildings were rotated by 5 degrees (the second case) (Fig. 13) and 10 degrees (the third case) (Fig. 14) counterclockwise so that the longitudinal
axis (east-west) and this in turn will increase the area of the facades exposed to sunlight [16].
We note that the air conditioning loads of the ground floors decreased when directing the buildings at an angle of 5 degrees counterclockwise, where the availability in the load reached (26.8 kW), while when steering by 10 degrees, the availability reached (15 kW) and the third block in which the loads increased significantly as a result of the exposure of the bulk of its outer cover to sunlight (Fig. 15).
We note that the heating loads of the ground floors decreased when directing the buildings at an angle of 5 degrees counterclockwise, where the savings
< n iiï
O M
c
0 œ t </>
1 »
y 1
J to
u-
^ I
3 °
» 3
o »
o
o
co co
l\J CO
o
CD§
r §6
o o
0)
o
C 3
CD ) ÎÎ
<D
<0
Fig. 13. Continuous assembly after steering 5 degrees counterclockwise
. DO
■ T
s □
s y c o <D * WW
M 2 O O 10 10
Fig. 14. Continuous assembly after steering 10 degrees counterclockwise
N N
o o
N N WW
* 0
U 3
> in
E M
to en
. r
№ <u
<D <u
O £
o o
66 I6
o
co
™ O
o
ro
o
E o
ÔL °
LT> O
s H
o E
CD ^
sjs
O (0
in load reached (49.73 kW), while when steering by 10 degrees, the savings reached (46.36 kW) (Fig. 16).
The savings in the total heat load when directing the four buildings by 5 degrees counterclockwise (778.41 kW) and compared with the availability resulting from directing the buildings 10 degrees counterclockwise, which amounted to (957.85 kW) (Fig. 17) with attention to the difference in savings on each floor of the building and the reason for this difference is due to the effect of height as a result of changing the intensity of radiation falling on the building with the change in height (Fig. 18, 19) where this was concluded by calculating the intensity of radiation falling on the building using the Insight programme, which is an addition to the Revit programme.
Continuous assembly with a north-south axis The loads were studied in three orientation modes: the first in the real current situation (Fig. 20, a), the second when rotating 5 degrees clockwise (Fig. 20, b), and the third when rotating 10 degrees clockwise (Fig. 20, c) and we will compare the results with each other to reach the best orientation.
The percentage of savings in the total heat load when directing the four buildings by 5 degrees clockwise (16.4 %) and compared with the percentage of savings resulting from directing buildings 10 deg-rees with the clock, which amounted to (20.2 %) The reason for this is that the rotation will allow an increase in the solar radiation falling on the southern facades so that the long axis of each block becomes east-west
Cooling Load For The Ground Floor
121
28.3
18.8 18.5
I The current situation Rotating the building at an angle 5° Rotating the building at an angle 10°
36.9
¿1? 5
49 47
Peak Cooling Load Fourth , kW Peak Cooling Load
THRID, kW
24.5 24 24.5 24
Peak Cooling Load SECOND, kW
Peak Cooling Load , kW
Fig. 15. Cooling load of ground floors in each block with three steering positions
Heating Load For The Ground Floors
113.2
34.13
19.85 19
■ ■I
■ The current situation Rotating the building at an angle 5° Rotating the building at an angle 10°
48.5
46
imI II
Peak Heating Load Fourth,kW Peak Heating Load THRID,kW Peak Heating Load SECOND,kW Peak Heating Load,kW Fig. 16. Heating load of ground floors in each block with three steering positions
direction. Below is a table showing the heat load for each floor in the four blocks in the three positions (Table 3).
Proposing an additional tool by Dynamo to achieve the building envelope to the design requirements of the Syrian thermal insulation code
The study of thermalloads by the Revit indicated that the heat load in all types of distribution of partitions is directly affected by the outer shell
Table 3.Total heat load per floor in the four blocks in kW
of the building from external walls, floors, ceilings, windows and even the glass used in it, where The building envelope can save energy and adapt to the surroundings and the external environment in order to provide internal comfort [17] and the table shows the components of the heat load for heating and adaptation and thecontribution of each element to this load (Tably 4).
We note from the previous two figures (Ftg. 21,22) that the ceilings contribute about 50 % of the air
< DO
tT iH
kK
g !
S 2
O œ
§ S
y ->■
J CD
^ I
3 °
a 3
o a
oî
o §
Floor The current situation Rotating the building at an angle 5° Rotating the building 3tan angle 10° Percehtag ecrf savings in the first case Second ca se saving percentage
Ground floor 424.87 3 8(5.76 364.16 10.03 15.05
First floor 380.96 290.4 269.9 241.11 29.15
Second floor 328.3 230.92 221.6 29.66 32.50
Third floor 305.06 231.5 211.15 24.11 30.78
Fourth floor 354.86 299.38 292.75 15.63 17.50
Fifth floor 463.35 409.69 394.68 11.58 14.82
Sixth floor 460.3 408.46 385.07 11.26 16.34
Seventh floor 345.66 295.64 263.87 14.47 23.66
Eighth floor 465.7 417.5 405 10.35 13.03
Ninthfl oor 43 6 372.3 358.5 34.61 17.78
Tenth fl mr 388.61 321.77 296.97 17.21 22!.59
Eleventh floor 341.34 290.54 243.64 14.88 24.52
Twelfth floor 366.8 281.9 aon.8 2(842 17.99
Thirteenth floor 392.26 325.46 325.46 17.03 17.03
Fourteenth floor 440.65 381.95 373.05 13.32 15.34
Fifteenth floor 551.51 491.32 433.03 10.91 21.48
Sixteenth floor 451.81 325.81 352.55 27.89 21.97
Total 6,903.1 5,771.3 5,507.18 16.4 20.2
en </>
a 3 a g
a ;
r ; o o
a
o
C §
CD ) ff
<D
<0
. DO ■ £
s 3
s y c o <D * WW
2 M O O 10 10
Comparison of loads with building orientation change
76.53 80
22 o o
N N WW
K 0
U 3
> in
C M
HQ en
. r
№ <u
<D <u
O £
----
§ I g<
s =
2. °
CO E —
e §
CL ° c
Ln O
s H
o E c5 o
a> ^
s
CO °
68.54 64.46
60.7 61.3 60.3
63.03
47.74
36.25
ee.7
53.8
50.7 50.7
48.6
44.3 44.3
44.3 44.3
I
44.3 44.3 44.3
553 53.58 55.22
56.86
58.5
ft
61.36
44.6
42.13 42.13
37.9
1.13
36.68
42.42
u
70
60
50
30 ^
tal
I
20
10
¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI ¿jliJI
^¿LJI ^-oL^JI JjbJI ÙJI5JI ^¿WI jilsJI g^ljJI j-oljJI ^jL^JI ^¿LJI ^-oLi-JI JjbJI ÙJI5JI J^VI
Rotating the building at an angle 5° Rotating the building at an angle 10°
Fig. 17. Resulting savings per floor in the four blocks
Table 4. Components of convection with the contribution of building elements
Components Cooling Heating
Loads, W Percentage of total, % Loads, W Percentage of total, %
Wall 13,018 20.65 34,955 48.70
Window 752 1.19 1,066 1.49
Door 751 1.19 1,812 2.53
Roof 31,438 49.88 15,820 22.04
Skylight 0 0.00 0 0.00
Partition 0 0.00 0 0.00
Infiltration 7,910 12.55 10,003 13.94
Ventilation 3,430 5.44 3,880 5.41
Lighting 2,054 3.26 -2,054 -2.86
Power 1,001 1.59 -1,001 -1.40
People 1,179 1.87 -1,179 -1.64
Plenum 0 0.00 0 0.00
Fan Heat 1,491 2.37 0 0.00
40
0
Fig. 18. A study of the solar radiation falling on the ground floor using Insight in Revit
conditioning loads and 22 % of the heating load, while the walls contribute about 50 % of the heating loads and 20 % of the air conditioning loads, and returning to the reason for this rise, we note that these elements are more interactive with the external enviromnent as a result of the occurrence of heat exchange between the internal enviromnent of the building with the heat of the air. As the total heat transfer coefficient of these elements is large and the value of the total heat transfer coefficient for building elements depends on several factors, including the properties of the material or materials that make up the elements, their thicknesses and the degree of exposure of their external surfaces to weather factors, and with the increase in the value
of the total heat transfer coefficient for building elements, the amount of heat lost in winter and gained in summer increases. Thus, an increase in energy consumption necessary to heat and air conditioning and thermal insulation is one of the best long-term means to ensure energy savings, reduce utility bills and improve the indoor air quality of the building [18, 19]. The building Revit programme helps to calculate the values of the total thermal transfer coefficient for the elements of the building, once the materials are introduced with their thickness, the programme gives both the values of thermal resistance and the total transition coefficient of the modeled element and the following are the values of the thermal coefficients extracted
1.000.000.0 900.000.0 ^ 800.000.0 I 700.000.0 g 600.000.0 a 500.000.0 I 400.000.0
m
5 300.000.0
CS
£ 200.000.0 100.000.0 0.0
Total Surface Insolation Value 868.657.5 664.384.2 667.783.2 667.783.5 667.784.0 667.784.3 667.789.3 Average Surface Insolation Value 584.3 566.5 567.6 567.6 567.6 567.6 567.6
Floor
590.0
585.0
580.0 Si
575.0
570.0 a
565.0 m
560.0 2
555.0
Total Surface Insolation Value
Average Surface Insolation Value
< DO
= ï
O I
W 2
o œ =! CO
z z
y ->■ Ü- CD
° S
I
is
o cj1
O?
O =;
CO CO
5 M » g
l§
cd ^d fï
<D
<0
Fig. 19. The value of solar radiation on the first block of each floor
<0 DO ■ T
ÜT 5 » «<
c o <D X WW
10 10 o o 10 10
Вестник МГСУ • ISSN 1997-0935 (Print) ISSN 2304-6600 (Online) • Том 19. Выпуск 3, 2024 Vestnik MGSU • Monthly Journal on Construction and Architecture • Volume 19. Issue 3, 2024
Щ ■
! Г
fu
I.flfr
* Щ i
E|C | { m i с
s
в f
л
0
from the programme for the elements of the building (Fig. 23, 24).
The building elements must be designed so that the value of the total heat transfer coefficient is within the permissible limits according to the Syrian Arab code for insulation, and according to this code, the value of the total heat transfer coefficient for each building element must not exceed the values mentioned in Table 5.
The values of the total thermal transfer coefficient of the elements of the building envelope do not achieve the code, so an additional software tool was designed by Dynamo and the Python language (Fig. 25) to achieve the building envelope to the design requirements of the Syrian thermal insulation code in order to reach sustainable energy-saving buildings that benefit from sunlight and reduce fossil energy consumption.
Table 5. Maximum allowable values of the total heat transfer coefficient of building elements
Maximum total heat transfer coefficient, W/m2 K Structural element
0.5 u f roof The last ceiling
0.8 U ow Exterior walls without openings
5.2 U . win Glass openings when they are:
A . <0.2 A facade WUl —
Glass openings when they are:
3.5 U . win A . > 0.2 A facade WUl
1.5 ^facade Exterior facades include all openings
1 uG Floors adjacent to the soil
1 UF Floors between floors
0.5 Exposed flooring
Awin: Window & Door Space A, j: Facade space jacade 1
< DO
G) (A C
Heating -2.86% -L64%
5.41 %
13.94%
0.00 %
22.04 %
48.70 %
Cooling
1.87%
1.59% 2.37%
3.26%
5.44% 12.55 %
20.65 %
0.00 %
1.19%
1.19%
2.53 %
1.49%
Wall Window Door Roof Skylight Partition Infiltration Ventilation Lighting Power People Plenum Fan Heat
Fig. 21. Contribution of building elements to heating loads
49.88 %
Wall B
Window ]
Door ] Roof
Skylight □
Partition ]
Infiltration H
Ventilation □
Lighting H
Power □
People B
Plenum □
Fan Heat ]
Fig. 22. Contribution of building elements to air conditioning loads
o œ =! CO
Z z y ->■
Ü- CD
° S
I
iiS
o cj1
O?
O =;
CO CO
l\J co
o
o o
0)
o
a °
cd ^d il
<D
<0
<0 DO ■ T
ÜT 5 » «<
c o <D * WW
10 10 o o 10 10
Fig. 23. Thermal properties of roofs extracted from Revit
N N
o o
N N
« «
U 3
> in
E M
to en
. r
№ <u
<D <u
O £
o
o g<
o
CO
™ O
o
ro
o
E o
CL ° • c Ln O
S «
o E c5 o
CD ^
Ü w * i
Fig. 24. Thermal properties of walls extracted from Revit
This tool first imports the elements of the outer shell of the studied building, which are (walls and floors adjacent to the soil, ceilings and floors between floors and windows) and then the thermal information integrated inside these elements, which is the total thermal transfer coefficient, thermal resistance and structural composition, is obtained in order to compare the transition coefficient resulting from modelling with what is allowed within the code and stipulated in (Table 5) using the Python language. If the results of the investigation node for the elements are not realized, the programme will add a new material (polystyrene) that increases
thermal resistance [20] and decreases the total transition coefficient by a specific thickness that can be changed, and the following is a (Fig. 26) showing the mechanism of work of the node to introduce a new material to the building elements using the Python language.
The aim is to reach the elements of a building that meet one of the most important design requirements of the thermal insulation code, and after adding the new material, we notice a decrease in the thermal transfer coefficients so that they become within the acceptable limits stipulated in the code (Fig. 27, 28).
Fig. 25. Components of Dynamo nodes
S
2 S
§2
il
i ■
<0 DO
■ V s 3
s y
c o ■■
J,.,
M 2
o o
K3 K3 4 4
Fig. 26. Contract for introducing new material using Python
Fig. 27. Thermal properties of the walls of the building after adding the new material
N N
o o
N N
pípí
* 0
U 3
> in
E M
to en
. r
w <u
?!
<D <u
O 3
o
o g<
o
co
™ O
o
ro
o
E o
CL ° c
Ln O
S «
o E
CD ^
CO CO
if
ü (ñ
Fig. 28. Thermal properties of the floor of the building after adding the new material
CONCLUSION
The BIM methodology is an effective technology in the field of energy management in projects, which has many advantages that contribute to reducing annual energy consumption and reaching environmentally friendly buildings, and we conclude from this the following:
Building Information Modelling (BIM) contributes to predicting the amount of energy consumed annually and spent on heating and air conditioning through the tools that it provides easily and quickly, as building information is integrated into the building elements from heat transfer coefficient, thermal resistance, thermal mass and even climatic information of the site. They are taken from the nearest weather observatory without having to be collected or predicted by the site.
Studying the orientation of the building during the design stage contributes to reducing the total annual
heat load by more than 20 %, and this percentage varies according to the method of assembling the partitions, as the orientation of the buildings in the continuous quadrilateral assembly method achieved a percentage of savings in consumption exceeding 24 %, while in the alternating assembly method it reached Savings 10 %.
Using the Shadow Study tool designed with the help of Dynamo within the work environment of the Revit contributed significantly to the study of the distribution of residential partitions in terms of the extent of benefit from natural solar radiation, which is a source of renewable energy, as the research indicated that the longitudinal axis of the method of distributing buildings towards east — west, when the building is in a rectangular shape because this allows the southern facades to benefit from sunlight.
The new addition, using the visual programming language, meets the design requirements of the building envelope from the Syrian thermal insulation code, as it
contributed to reducing the thermal leakage resulting from the interaction of the outer shell of the building with the atmosphere, by returning the heat transfer
coefficient of these elements from rejected values to acceptable values. Thus reducing the annual total convection.
REFERENCES
1. Malkov I.I. Energy saving in housing construction : passive and smart home. Gomel, BelSUT, 2012; 18. (rus.).
2. Khudhaire H.Y., Naji H.I. Management of Abandoned Construction Projects in Iraq Using BIM Technology. International Journal of Engineering. 2021; 34(3). DOI: 10.5829/ije.2021.34.03c.08
3. Omran J. How to achieve sustainable building design and operation with building information modeling. Tishreen University Journal for Research and Scientific Studies. 2020; 42(2):217-232.
4. Jalaei F., Jrade A. Integrating BIM with Green Building Certification System, Energy Analysis, and Cost Estimating Tools to Conceptually Design Sustainable Buildings. Electronic Journal of Information Technology in Construction. 2014; 19:140-149. DOI: 10.1061/9780784413517.015
5. Egwunatum S., Joseph-Akwara E., Akaig-we R. Optimizing energy consumption in building designs using building information model (BIM). Slovak Journal of Civil Engineering. 2016; 24(3):19-28. DOI: 10.1515/sjce-2016-0013
6. Golovanova L.A. Basics of project management of investments in improving energy efficiency of buildings. Bulletin of Pacific State University. 2017; 4(47):193-202. EDN YPJGOZ. (rus.).
7. Watfa M.K., Hawash A.E., Jaafar K. Using building information & energy modelling for energy efficient designs. Journal of Information Technology in Construction. 2021; 26:427-440. DOI: 10.36680/j.itcon.2021.023
8. Egwunatum S., Joseph-Akwara E., Akaig-we R. Optimizing energy consumption in building designs using building information model (BIM). Slovak Journal of Civil Engineering. 2016; 24(3):19-28. DOI: 10.1515/sjce-2016-0013
9. Alsaud Y.A. Analyze the performance of sustainable buildings using BIM software — evaluating simulation accuracy. Elias Acetic AAA Canaanite, 2019.
10. Geekiyanage D., Ramachandra T. A correlation analysis of factors influencing cooling energy demand of condominiums in Sri Lanka. National Energy Symposium 2017. 2017.
Received March 27, 2023.
Adopted in revised form on January 19, 2024.
Approved for publication on January 19, 2024.
Bionotes: Jamal Younis Omran — PhD in Construction Project Management Engineering, Professor, Dean of Faculty of Civil Engineering; Tishreen University; Lattakia, Syria; Scopus: 57194594127, ResearcherID: ABF-2210-2021, ORCID: 0000-0002-8429-6210; [email protected], [email protected];
11. Ayyad T.M. The impact of building orientation, opening to wall ratio, aspect ratio and envelope materials on buildings energy consumption in the tropics. The British University in Dubai (BUiD), 2011.
12. Jannat N., Hussien A., Abdullah B., Cot-grave A. A comparative simulation study of the thermal performances of the building envelope wall materials in the tropics. Sustainability. 2020; 12(12):4892. DOI: 10.3390/su12124892
13. Mengana S., Mousiadis T. Parametric BIM: Energy performance analysis using Dynamo for Revit. 2016.
14. Thabet W., Lucas J., Srinivasan S. Linking life cycle BIM data to a facility management system using Revit Dynamo. Organization, Technology and Management in Construction: an International Journal. 2022; 14(1):2539-2558. DOI: 10.2478/otmcj-2022-0001
15. Prasad K., Anchan S.S., Shambavi Kamath M., Akella V. Impact of building orientation on energy consumption in the design of green building. International Journal of Emerging Research in Management & Technology. 2017; 6(2):8-11.
16. Ashour H. The environmental role of urban system (separate residences) in residential neighborhoods. Aleppo as a case study. Aleppo University Faculty of Architecture, 2014.
17. Ibrahim N.A., Elsayed E., Saleh O.M. Towards a contemporary formulation of smart envelopes in the local environment. Engineering Research Journal — Faculty of Engineering (Shoubra). 2022; 51(3):191-206. DOI: 10.21608/ERJSH.2022.252297
18. Divin N.V. BIM by using Revit API and dynamo : a review. AlfaBuild. 2020; 2(14):1404. DOI: 10.34910/ALF.14.4.EDNCGPPSX.
19. Mishra S., Usmani J., Varshney S. Energy saving analysis in building walls through thermal insulation system. International Journal of Engineering Research and Applications. 2012; 2(5):128-135.
20. Cai S., Zhang B., Cremaschi L. Review of moisture behavior and thermal performance of polystyrene insulation in building applications. Building and Environment. 2017; 123:50-65. DOI: 10.1016/j.build-env.2017.06.034
< DO
i i
k K
G !
S 2
0 œ t co
1 i
y 1
J to
u-
^ I
3 o
i 3
o i
oí
o 3
co
co
3 M i
r §6
i ) ¡í
<D
(O
. DO ■ £
s □
s y c o <D * WW
M 2 O O 10 10 «> i»
Moustafa Ali Wassouf — civil engineer Department of Construction Management, engineer, graduate student with master's degree at the Faculty of Civil Engineering; Tishreen University; Lattakia, Syria; ResearcherID: HSF-7867-2023, ORCID: 0000-0002-3001-5030; [email protected], [email protected].
Contribution of the authors:
Jamal Eunice Omran — scientific guidance, concept of research and development of methodology, text review, final conclusions.
Moustafa Ali Wassouf— participate in the development and implementation of curricula, develop and implement
a software tool, write code in (python.)
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
СПИСОК ИСТОЧНИКОВ
N N
о о
сч сч
ci ri
к <u и з
> (Л
с и
m en
. г
№ (U
?!
ф <u
о ё
о
о g<
о со
™ О
о
го
о
Е о
CL ° ^ с
ю о
S «
о Е
СП ^ т- ^
<л
(Л
1. Малков И.И. Энергосбережение в жилищном строительстве. Пассивный и умный дом : учебно-методическое пособие. Гомель : БелГУТ, 2012. 18 с.
2. Khudhaire H.Y., Naji H.I. Management of Abandoned Construction Projects in Iraq Using BIM Technology // International Journal of Engineering. 2021. Vol. 34. Issue 3. DOI: 10.5829/ije.2021.34.03c.08
3. Omran J. How to achieve sustainable building design and operation with building information modeling // Tishreen University Journal for Research and Scientific Studies. 2020. Vol. 42. Issue 2. Pp. 217-232.
4. Jalaei F., Jrade A. Integrating BIM with Green Building Certification System, Energy Analysis, and Cost Estimating Tools to Conceptually Design Sustainable Buildings // Electronic Journal of Information Technology in Construction. 2014. Vol. 19. Pp. 140-149. DOI: 10.1061/9780784413517.015
5. Egwunatum S., Joseph-Akwara E., Akaig-we R. Optimizing energy consumption in building designs using building information model (BIM) // Slovak Journal of Civil Engineering. 2016. Vol. 24. Issue 3. Pp. 19-28. DOI: 10.1515/sjce-2016-0013
6. Голованова Л.А. Основы проектного управления инвестициями в повышении энергоэффективности зданий // Вестник Тихоокеанского государственного университета. 2017. № 4 (47). С. 193-202. EDN YPJGOZ.
7. Watfa M.K., Hawash A.E., Jaafar K. Using building information & energy modelling for energy efficient designs // Journal of Information Technology in Construction. 2021. Vol. 26. Pp. 427-440. DOI: 10.36680/j.itcon.2021.023
8. Egwunatum S., Joseph-Akwara E., Akaigwe R. Optimizing energy consumption in building designs using building information model (BIM) // Slovak Journal of Civil Engineering. 2016. Vol. 24. Issue 3. Pp. 19-28. DOI: 10.1515/sjce-2016-0013
9. Alsaud Y.A. Analyze the performance of sustainable buildings using BIM software — Evaluating Simulation Accuracy. Elias Acetic AAA Canaanite, 2019.
10. Geekiyanage D., Ramachandra T. A correlation analysis of factors influencing cooling energy demand of condominiums in Sri Lanka // National Energy Symposium 2017. 2017.
11. Ayyad T.M. The impact of building orientation, opening to wall ratio, aspect ratio and envelope materials on buildings energy consumption in the tropics. The British University in Dubai (BUiD), 2011.
12. Jannat N., Hussien A., Abdullah B., Cot-grave A. A comparative simulation study of the thermal performances of the building envelope wall materials in the tropics // Sustainability. 2020. Vol. 12. Issue 12. P. 4892. DOI: 10.3390/su12124892
13. Mengana S., Mousiadis T. Parametric BIM: Energy performance analysis using Dynamo for Revit. 2016.
14. Thabet W., Lucas J., Srinivasan S. Linking life cycle BIM data to a facility management system using Revit Dynamo // Organization, Technology and Management in Construction: an International Journal. 2022. Vol. 14. Issue 1. Pp. 2539-2558. DOI: 10.2478/ otmcj-2022-0001
15. PrasadK., Anchan S.S., Shambavi Kamath M., Akella V. Impact of building orientation on energy consumption in the design of green building // International Journal of Emerging Research in Management & Technology. 2017. Vol. 6. Issue 2. Pp. 8-11.
16. Ashour H. The environmental role of urban system (separate residences) in residential neighborhoods. Aleppo as a case study. Aleppo University Faculty of Architecture, 2014.
17. Ibrahim N.A., ElsayedE., Saleh O.M. Towards a contemporary formulation of smart envelopes in the local environment // Engineering Research Journal — Faculty of Engineering (Shoubra). 2022. Vol. 51. Issue 3. Pp. 191-206. DOI: 10.21608/ERJSH.2022.252297
18. Divin N.V. BIM by using Revit API and dynamo : a review // AlfaBuild. 2020. No. 2 (14). P. 1404. DOI: 10.34910/ALF.14.4.EDNCGPPSX.
19. Mishra S., Usmani J., Varshney S. Energy saving analysis in building walls through thermal insulation system // International Journal of Engineering Research and Applications. 2012. Vol. 2. Issue 5. Pp. 128-135.
20. Cai S., Zhang B., Cremaschi L. Review of moisture behavior and thermal performance of polystyrene insulation in building applications // Building and Environment. 2017. Vol. 123. Pp. 50-65. DOI: 10.1016/j.buildenv.2017.06.034
Поступила в редакцию 27 марта 2023 г. Принята в доработанном виде 19 января 2024 г. Одобрена для публикации 19 января 2024 г.
Об авторах: Джамал Юнис Омран — доктор наук в области инженерии управления строительными проектами, профессор, декан факультета гражданского строительства; Университет Тишрин; г. Латакия, Сирия; Scopus: 57194594127, ResearcherlD: ABF-2210-2021, ORCID: 0000-0002-8429-6210; [email protected], [email protected];
Мустафа Али Вассуф — инженер-строитель кафедры управления строительством, инженер, аспирант со степенью магистра факультета гражданского строительства; Университет Тишрин; г. Латакия, Сирия; ResearcherlD: HSF-7867-2023, ORCID: 0000-0002-3001-5030; [email protected], [email protected].
Вклад авторов:
Джамал Юнис Омран — научное руководство, концепция исследования и разработки методологии, обзор текста, выводы.
Мустафа Али Вассуф — участие в разработке и внедрении учебных программ, разработка и внедрение программного инструмента, написание кода на Python. Авторы заявляют об отсутствии конфликта интересов.
< DO iiï
k к
G Г
S 2
0 сл
t СО
1 » y 1
J со
u-
^ I
» 3
о »
oî
о 3
со со
3 м » §
Г §6
cd cd
f!
®
<0
. DO
■ T
s У с о ® X WW
M 2
о о 10 10