CC BY
4Peremennye Zvezdy ( Variable ¡Stars) 43, No. 4, 2023
Received 11 May; accepted 23 May.
DOI: 10.24412/2221-0474-2023-43-27-32
Type II-L Supernova SN2019tua: Second Outburst in a Dwarf Galaxy
D. Yu. Tsvetkov, N. N. Pavlyuk, A. A. Belinski, N. P. Ikonnikova, M. A. Burlak, V. M. Lipunov
M.V. Lomonosov Moscow State University, Sternberg Astronomical Institute, Universitetskii pr. 13, 119234 Moscow, Russia
Photometric observations of SN 2019tua, spanning 350 days of its evolution, show a linear light curve with a rate of brightness decline slower than for most SNe II-L. The maximum absolute magnitude of SN 2019tua, Mr = -18m0, is close to the mean value for SNe II-L. SN2019tua is the second type II SN in a dwarf galaxy UGC 11860. The two SNe were discovered with interval of 5 years, while the mean outburst SN frequency in such galaxies is about 1 event in 1300 years.
1 Introduction
Explosions of high-mass stars (M >~ 8M©) with hydrogen envelopes due to the gravitational collapse of their cores are classified as type II Supernovae (SNe). Barbon et al. (1979) proposed to divide SNe II into two major groups: SNe II-P, which have nearly constant luminosity for a time interval of ~ 100 days after maximum, and SNe II-L, which are characterized by linear decline (in magnitudes) after maximum. When more data had become available, objects with intermediate parameters between SNe II-P and II-L were also found, and it was supposed that these classes presented the utmost cases of a continuous distribution (Anderson et al., 2014).
Explosions of two or more SNe in the same parent galaxy, which are called Supernova siblings, present special interest due to possibilities of exploring some characteristics of the host galaxies and testing distance estimation methods using SNe.
SN2019tua (ATLAS19zjt, Gaia19ezc) in the galaxy UGC 11860 was discovered by ATLAS on 2019-10-31.33 UT at mc = 18m72 ± 0m 10. The Supernova was offset by 2/3 South, 7/3 East from the center of its host galaxy, and was located at a = 21h58m00/28,8 = +24°15'57". 1, 2000.0 (Srivastav et al., 2019).
Spectra of SN2019tua were obtained on 2019-11-01.38 UT at the Faulkes Telescope North, the best fit was found to SNe II at early phases. The expansion velocity was found to be about 17000 km s_1 from the Ha absorption and from the HeI 5876 A line (Burke at al., 2019).
SN 2019tua is the second SN outburst in UGC 11860: five years earlier, SN ASASSN-14dq was discovered in this galaxy. ASASSN-14dq was a transitional event between the type II-P and type II-L SNe (Singh et al., 2018; Valenti et al., 2016).
The nearly simultaneous outbursts of two SNe are surprising because UGC 11860 is a low-luminosity type Sdm dwarf galaxy, its luminosity being only ~ 1.5 x 109L© (Singh et al., 2018). Using the mean values of SN frequency from Li et al. (2011), we can estimate the SN II rate for this galaxy as ~ 1 SN in 1300 years. Of course, the real time interval between the explosions of two SNe is unknown, but still we consider this a very rare event.
Table 1: BVRI photometry of SN2019tua
JD—2458000
B a b V ay R gR
I a j Tel.
8809.10
8815.96 8816.29 8817.00 8817.06
8838.97
9033.50 9047.48 9050.47 9057.44 9058.46 9067.44
9079.51 9085.39 9103.29 9116.24 9129.39 9146.27 9163.31
15.41 0.05
15.40 0.03
15.43 0.04
15.44 0.04 15.43 0.05 15.91 0.02
M70 M40 M40 M40 M40 M40
19.27 0.06 18.32 0.03
20.10 0.07 19.55 0.04 18.52 0.03
20.15 0.08 19.51 0.05 18.48 0.04
20.25 0.07 19.55 0.07 18.52 0.04
20.44 0.06 19.57 0.04 18.53 0.02
19.82 0.06 18.66 0.03
20.74 0.06 19.94 0.05 18.78 0.03
19.90 0.08 18.79 0.04
20.36 0.06 19.09 0.06
20.88 0.05 19.44 0.03
19.47 0.06
21.20 0.10 19.93 0.05
20.27 0.04
18.02 0.03 K60
18.16 0.04 K60
18.17 0.04 K60 18.16 0.05 K60 18.26 0.03 K60 18.46 0.04 K60 18.63 0.07 K60 18.66 0.07 K60 19.12 0.06 K60 19.32 0.07 K60
K60 K60 K60
2 Observations and reductions
We obtained images of SN 2019tua in the R band with the 70-cm telescope in Moscow on 2019-11-21.6 UT. The observations with MASTER telescopes (Lipunov et al., 2010) were carried out at Tunka, Amur, SAAO. and OAFA sites. Unfiltered images were obtained on 5 epochs, from 2019-11-28 to 2019-12-21. Photometric monitoring at the 60-cm RC600 telescope of the Caucasus Mountain Observatory of Sternberg Astronomical Institute (Berdnikov et al., 2020), in the BVRI bands, was performed between 2020-07-03 and
The standard image reductions and photometry were performed using IRAF1. Photometric measurements of the SN were made relative to local standard stars using PSF fitting with the IRAF DAOPHOT package. The galaxy background was subtracted using images of the host galaxy obtained at the RC600 telescope on 2022-05-30, when the SN had faded. The magnitudes of the local standard stars were taken from Singh et al. (2018). The unfiltered MASTER images were calibrated using the R-band magnitudes of local standards. The photometry is presented in Table 1, the identification of telescopes is given by the following codes: M70, the 70-cm reflector in Moscow; M40, 40-cm MASTER telescopes; K60, the 60-cm RC600 telescope of the Caucasus Mountain Observatory.
3 Results and conclusions
The light curves of SN 2019tua are presented in Fig. 1, we also plotted the magnitudes in Gaia G-band2 and the discovery magnitude from ATLAS (Srivastav et al., 2019).
The maximum light was reached on about JD 2458812 with Rmax ~ 15m35. After maximum, the brightness decline was nearly linear, with a rate 0.013 mag day-1 in the R
1IRAF is distributed by the National Optical Astronomy Observatory, which is operated by AURA under cooperative agreement with the National Science Foundation
2 http://gsaweb.ast.cam.ac.uk/alerts/alert/Gaia19ezc/
2020-11-09.
16
CD T5
. i—i fl
tlO cd
20
1 1 1 I I IS I I I I 1 1 1 1 •B
•V "
o ° •R
•1-1 ~
°MASTER
- © °GAIA "
o •ATLAS
D ■
•I
•
§
— @ i ~~
• i
• • —
i "
I
• i -
I _
i i •
i
9
i i i i i i i I I 1 1 i ill
800
900 1000
JD—2458000
1100 1200
Figure 1: The light curves of SN 2019tua
band. Gaia G magnitudes demonstrated nearly the same rate, 0.015 mag day-1. During the time interval of our continuous monitoring (JD 24589033-34589163), the rate of decline was 0.015 and 0.017 mag day-1 in the R and V bands, respectively. Thus, the linear phase of photometric evolution continued for about 350 days.
The absolute R-band light curve of SN2019tua is presented in Fig. 2, it is compared with the light curve of ASASSN-14dq, which occurred in the same galaxy UGC 11860, and with five SNe II-L: 1998S, 2014G, ASASSN-15nx, 2016gsd, 2020mmz (Fassia et al., 2000, Bose et al., 2016, Bose et al., 2018, Reynolds et al., 2019, Tsvetkov et al., 2022).
We plotted the magnitudes from Singh et al. (2018) for ASASSN-14dq, and also an upper limit from images obtained at the MASTER Tunka telescope on 2014-07-01.66 UT, 7 days before discovery.
We accept the distance modulus j = 33.25 for UGC 11860 from Singh et al. (2018). We consider the extinction in the host galaxy to be negligible for both SNe, because the interstellar lines of NaI were not detected in the published spectra (Singh et al., 2018; Burke et al.. 2019). We also note that both SNe occurred at similar projected distances from the center of the host galaxy: 1.9 and 1.7 kpc for ASASSN-14dq and 2019tua, respectively. The projected distance between the sites of the two SNe is 2.4 kpc.
We applied to both SNe only the galactic extinction E(B — V) = 0m06 according to Schlafly and Finkbeiner (2011). The distances and extinctions for the SNe from the comparison sample were adopted from the references above.
The maximum luminosities of SN ASASSN-14dq and SN 2019tua are similar, with SN2019tua only 0m3 brighter. The shape of the light curves is different. ASASSN-14dq shows typical photometric evolution for a transitional event between types II-P and II-L: three phases with different rates of decline. The light curve of SN2019tua exhibits monotonous decline. The comparison with the light curves of five SNe II-L shows that the decline rate of SN 2019tua is quite slow, at phase ~300 days it is brighter than other SNe from the sample. Only SN 2016gsd has similar luminosity at that epoch, but at maximim it was 1m7 brighter than SN2019tua. We also note that most SNe II-L and transitional objects show changes of decline rate, while for SN2019tua it is quite monotonous. The absolute magnitude MRmax = — 18m0 for SN2019tua is very close to the mean value for SNe II-L according to Richardson et al. (2014).
The comparison of two type II SNe that occurred in the galaxy UGC 11860 reveals that they had quite different luminosity evolution, although their maximum absolute magnitudes were quite close to each other. Singh et al. (2018) applied the SCM method to ASASSN-14dq to estimate the distance for the host galaxy, the result was close to that derived from the galaxy redshift. We cannot apply the same method to SN2019tua to verify its precision because of different nature of the light curve and insufficient set of observational data. Singh et al. (2018) did not reveal any peculiarity of the dwarf galaxy UGC 11860, we suppose that the nearly simultaneous outbursts of two SNe were rare occasional events.
Acknowledgements. This study was performed using the equipment purchased through the funds of the Development Program of the Moscow State University. The work was supported by the Scientific and Educational School of the Moscow State University "Fundamental and Applied Space Research".
References:
Anderson, J.P., Gonzalez-Gaitan, S., Hamuy, M., et al., 2014, Astrophys. J., 786, article id. 67
-20
"1 I I r
"1 I I r
-18
\>
\ ••
- N •• •
K
• • •V •
-16
%t I • •• *
. • • • • • • •
• •.
•«•v.
• •
-14
J_I_I_L
J_I_I_L
1 I I I
•2019tua _ •ASASSN14dq •1998S " 2014G
ASASSN15nx •2016gsd _ •2020mmz
•• •
J_I_I_L
0
100 200 Days after maximum
300
Figure 2: The absolute fl-band light curve of SNe 2019tua, compared to those for ASASSN-14dq and five SNe II-L.
Barbon, R., Ciatti, F., Rosino, L., 1979, Astron. & Astrophys., 72, 287 Berdnikov, L.N., Belinskii, A.A., Shatskii, N.I., et al., 2020, Astron. Reports, 64, 310 Bose, S., Kumar, B., Misra, K., et al., 2016, MNRAS, 455, 2712 Bose, S., Dong, S., Kochanek, C.S., et al., 2018, Astrophys. J., 862, article id. 107 Burke, J., Hiramatsu, D., Howell, D.A., et al., 2019, Transient Name Server Classification Report, 2244, 1
Fassia, A., Meikle, W.P.S., Vacca, W.D., et al., 2000, MNRAS, 318, 1093 Li, W., Chornock, R., Leaman, J., et al., 2011, MNRAS, 412, 1473 Lipunov, V., Kornilov, V., Gorbovskoy, E., et al., 2010, Advances in Astronomy, article id. 349171
Reynolds, T.M., Fraser, M., Mattila, S., et al., 2020, MNRAS, 493, 1761 Richardson, D., Jenkins, R.L., Wright, J., Maddox, L., 2014, Astron. J., 147, article id. 118
Singh, A., Srivastav, S., Kumar, B., et al., 2018, MNRAS, 480, 2475 Schlafly, E.F., Finkbeiner, D.P., 2011, Astrophys. J., 737, article id. 103 Srivastav, S., Smith, K.W., McBrien, O., et al., 2019, Transient Name Server AstroNote, 119, 1
Tsvetkov, D.Yu., Pavlyuk, N.N., Metlov, V.G., et al., 2022, Peremennye Zvezdy/Variable
Stars, 42, No. 8, 11 Valenti, S., Howell, D.A., Stritzinger, M.D., et al., 2016, MNRAS, 459, 3939
