CC BY
38
UDC: 378.014 (477)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.32689/2617-2224-2019-17-2-186-197
Martyshyn Denys Serhiiovych,
candidate sciences in theology, Associate Professor, head of the Department of Ukrainian Studies, Orthodoxy and Theology, Interregional Academy of Personnel Management, 03039, Kyiv, Str. Frometivska, 2, tel.: (098) 561 65 63, e-mail: [email protected]
ORCID: 0000-0002-2770-7757
Мартишин Денис Сергшович,
кандидат наук з богослов'я, 3aeidyeau ка-федри укратознавства, православ'я та теологи, Мiжрегiонaльнa Акaдемiя управ-лтня персоналом, 03039, м. Кшв, вул. Фро-метiвськa, 2, тел.: (098) 561 65 63, e-mail: [email protected]
ORCID: 0000-0002-2770-7757
Мартышин Денис Сергеевич,
кандидат наук по богословию, заведующий кафедрой украиноведения, православия и теологии, Межрегиональная Академия управления персоналом, 03039, г. Киев, ул. Фрометовская, 2, тел.: (098) 561 65 63, e-mail: [email protected]
ORCID: 0000-0002-2770-7757
THE ROLE OF THE ORTHODOX CHURCH OF UKRAiNE iN THE CURRENT PROCESSES OF STATE FORMATiON
Abstract. The article shows the role of the Orthodox Church of Ukraine in strengthening the processes of statehood and unity of the Ukrainian people in the context of political, economic and cultural changes in the life of Ukraine. The real problems and possible ways of spiritual unity of the Ukrainian people are analyzed, as well as the main aspects of state formation in the national theological and political thought. It is substantiated that the dialogue between the Ukrainian Christian Churches and society will always be the basic element of social development and the platform of democratization processes in Ukraine.
From the point of view of the social doctrine of the Church we can conclude that the self-organizing spiritual and social processes that take place at the level of church parishes of horizontal ties effectively influence the development of the processes of state formation and the whole civil society in Ukraine. Taking into
account the situation as a whole, there is a need to reconsider the positions regarding the further development of the dialogue between the Church and the state in the process of state building, focusing on the motivation of self-organization processes in governance at the level of church communities, potential opportunities for cooperation between the institutes of the Church, state and civil society in the spiritual, educational spheres, achieving parity at the level of vertical-horizontal ties in order to balance: the interests of the subject and the object of public administration.
The author is convinced that in order to establish close relations between the state and the Church in the processes of state formation in management it is necessary not local and not fragmentary but constant and steady social self-organization of church parishes (social service, education, upbringing, preaching, communication) in conjunction with an effective state management. It should also take into account the fact that at the level of the church life of the Orthodox Church of Ukraine and the formation of the social doctrine of the Church it is necessary to form a general idea of the further development of relations between the state and the Church in management.
Keywords: state, Christianity, interaction, dialogue, unity, politics, globalization, economy, democracy, modernization.
роль православно! церкви украши в сучасних
ПРОЦЕСАХ ДЕРЖАВОТВОРЕННЯ
Анотащя. Висв^лено роль Православно! Церкви Украши у змщненш процеав державносп та еднання украшського народу у контекст пол^ич-них, економiчних та культурних змш у жита Украши. Проаналiзовано ре-альш проблеми та можливi шляхи духовного еднання украшського народу, а також головш аспекти державотворення у вггчизнянш богословськш й поли толопчнш думщ. Обгрунтовано, що дiалог Украшських Християнських Цер-ков та сусшльства постшно буде базисним елементом сустльного розвитку та платформою процеав демократизаци в Украшь
З точки зору сощального вчення церкви, можна дшти висновку, що са-мооргашзацшш духовш та сощальш процеси, яю вщбуваються на рiвнi цер-ковних парафш горизонтальних зв'язюв, ефективно впливають на розвиток процеав державотворення та громадянського сусшльства в УкраШ. Зважаю-чи на ситуащю в щлому, виникае потреба переглянути позици щодо напрямiв подальшого розвитку дiалогу церкви та держави у процеа державотворення, акцентуючи увагу на мотиваци самооргашзацшних процесiв в управлiннi на рiвнi церковних громад, на потенцiйних можливостях ствпращ шститу-тiв церкви, держави та громадянського сусшльства в духовнш, культурнш, освiтнiй сферах, на досягненш паритету на рiвнi вертикально-горизонталь-них зв'язюв з метою збалансування штереав суб'екта та об'екта державного управлшня.
Визначено, що для налагодження тюних взаемовiдносин держави i церкви у процесах державотворення в управлшш потрiбна не локальна i не фрагмен-
тарна, а постшна та стшка сустльна самоорганiзацiя церковних парафiй (со-щальне служiння, освiта, виховання, проповiдь, стлкування) у поeднаннi з ефективним державним управлшням. Слiд також зважити на ту обставину, що на рiвнi церковного життя Православно! Церкви Украши та формуван-ня соцiального вчення церкви потрiбно сформувати загальне уявлення щодо подальшого розвитку взаeмовiдносин держави та церкви в управлшш.
Ключовi слова: держава, християнство, взаeмодiя, дiалог, соборнiсть, ед-нiсть, полiтика, глобалiзацiя, економiка, демократiя, модернiзацiя.
РОЛЬ ПРАВОСЛАВНОЙ ЦЕРКВИ УКРАИНЫ В СОВРЕМЕННЫХ ПРОЦЕССАХ ГОСУДАРСТВЕННОГО СТРОИТЕЛЬСТВА
Аннотация. Показана роль Православной Церкви Украины в укреплении современных процессов государственного строительства и единства украинского народа в контексте политических, экономических и культурных изменений в жизни Украины. Проанализированы реальные проблемы и возможные пути духовного единства украинского народа, а также главные аспекты государственного строительства в отечественной богословской и политологической мысли. Обосновано, что диалог Украинских Христианских Церквей и общества постоянно будет базисным элементом общественного развития и платформой процессов демократизации в Украине.
С точки зрения социального учения церкви, можно прийти к заключению, что самостоятельные организационные духовные и социальные процессы, которые происходят на уровне церковных приходов горизонтальных связей, эффективно влияют на развитие процессов создания государства и всего гражданского общества в Украине. Принимая во внимание ситуацию в целом, возникает потребность пересмотреть позиции относительно направлений дальнейшего развития диалога церкви и государства в процессе создания государства, акцентируя внимание на мотивации самостоятельных организационных процессов в управлении на уровне церковных общин, на потенциальных возможностях сотрудничества институтов церкви, государства и гражданского общества в духовной, культурной, образовательной сферах, на достижении паритета на уровне вертикально-горизонтальных связей с целью балансирования интересов субъекта и объекта государственного управления.
Обозначено, что для налаживания тесных взаимоотношений государства и церкви в процессах создания государства в управлении нужна не локальная и не фрагментарная, а постоянная и стойкая общественная самоорганизация церковных приходов (социальное служение, образование, воспитание, проповедь, общение) в сочетании с эффективным государственным управлением. Следует также обратить внимание на то обстоятельство, что на уровне церковной жизни Православной Церкви Украины и формирования социального учения церкви необходимо сформировать общие представления относительно дальнейшего развития взаимоотношений государства и церкви в управлении.
Ключевые слова: государство, христианство, взаимодействие, диалог, соборность, единство, политика, глобализация, демократия, модернизация.
Statement of the problem in general outlook and its connection with important scientific and practical tasks.
Social development on the threshold of the 21 century is accompanied by global changes in the spheres that determine the living conditions of people at the global and national levels. Increasingly church figures, scholars, politicians, and government officials point out that it is necessary to deepen the dialogue between the Church and the state, actively involving believers in the processes of state-building. The question of finding a constructive interaction between the Church and the state never loses its relevance. The preservation and development of Ukrainian statehood and democratic civil society is impossible without the support of the spiritual and moral values of modern Christianity, which sanctified church-state relations during the centuries-long history of the Ukrainian people. Christianity itself became the spiritual foundation of the spiritual culture of Ukraine. Therefore, today, among the numerous massive state decision-making processes, the state-building processes, the strengthening of the security of society's life in dialogue with religious organizations take on a special place. The interaction between the Church and the state will be the key to strengthening Ukrainian statehood, stability in public life, religious, cultural and historical heritage for future generations.
It is known that the Ukrainian Orthodox Churches: the Ukrainian
Orthodox Church (UOC); the Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the Kyiv Patriarchate (UOC-KP); the Ukrainian Autocephalous Orthodox Church (UAOC) having come a long way to overcome the split, with the blessing of the Apostolic Constantinople and His All Holiness the Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew (Arhondonis) on December 15, 2018 created a new united — The Orthodox Church of Ukraine (OCU), choosing a new Primate — His Beatitude Metropolitan of Kyiv and of all Ukraine Epiphanius. On January 6, 2019 the Orthodox Church of Ukraine received from the Ecumenical Council Tomos of auto-cephaly.
Analysis of latest research where the solution of the problem was initiated. Studying a large number of scientific monographs, theological sources, various articles on state-building, spiritual unity of the Ukrainian people, it becomes clear that this actualizes the need for a scientific-theological and secular dialogue on the issues of the development of the state and the nation. The scientific development of this problem was carried out both by foreign-ersresearchers (M. Weber, R. Niebuhr, N. Wright, A. Storki, T. Bremer, G. Kung, D. Carson, etc.), as well as domestic researchers (K. Govorun, V Bad, M. Marinovich, P. Tolochko, V. Lubsky, P. Yarotsky, A. Kolodniy, V. Bondarenko, L. Filipovich, J. Cher-nomorets, V. Yelensky, A. Derkach, V. Kirilenko, O. Sagan, O. Shuba,
M. Piren, M. Palinchak, V. Bebik, V. Petrenko, M. Cherenkov, A. Zinchen-ko, J. Kannish, S. Plokhii, A. Subtelny, V. Ulyanovskii, M. Kudryakov, I. Isi-chenko, O. Drabinko, I. Matselyukh, S. Golovin, I. Znechkov).
In recent decades, the problem of state-building, the unity of the Ukrainian Orthodoxy attracted special attention of church figures and many secular scholars. But today there are practically no comprehensive studies devoted to the consideration of the processes of constructive dialogue between the state and the Church, spiritual state-building in the field of state administration. It should be noted that today there is a lack of fundamental and special scientific papers on public administration that would be devoted to the theological analysis of the multi-faceted process of relations between the Orthodox Church of Ukraine and the Ukrainian state.
Aims of paper. Formulating the goals of the article (statement of the task). The purpose of the article is to solve a scientific and theoretical task of disclosing the role of the Orthodox Church of Ukraine in the processes of state formation and the search for ways of spiritual unity of the Ukrainian people.
The purpose of the research led to the setting and solving of the following tasks:
• to characterize the process of formation and development of the main directions of interaction between the state power and the Orthodox Church of Ukraine in the processes of state building;
• to reveal the ways of spiritual unity of the Ukrainian people;
• to suggest ways to improve the main directions of interaction between the Ukrainian state and the Ukrainian Christian Churches.
Exposition of main material of research with complete substantiation of obtained scientific results. It is known that the spiritual and cultural revival in post-totalitarian countries became possible only after the elimination of the wicked communist regime, when the freedom-loving Ukrainian people chose a democratic form of life. In spite of failed economic reforms, political manipulation, and comprehensive corruption, society has grown from communist stagnation to civic engagement. Man began to be interested in issues of spiritual culture, religion, theology, philosophy, rights and freedoms, entrepreneurial activity, modernization and problems of transformation of social consciousness.
It is easy to see that the role of religious institutions in the transformation of all aspects of the life of the post-totalitarian countries of the former Soviet Union has undeniably increased. If in Soviet society religious life was limited, focused exclusively on the internal spiritual issues of Christian life and temple worship, then with the onset of democratic reforms, religion became a significant force in shaping the processes of state building and the building of civil society.
Religious communities try to become a harmonious integral part of the Ukrainian state, society, recognized spiritual and moral strength, which has a high social authority. For the first time after many centuries Ukrainian Christian churches have acquired the right independently, without interfe-
rence from secular authorities, to determine their place in society, to build their relations with the state and civil society. The cardinal transformations in the Ukrainian state, socio-political reforms, new challenges of the modern world create new conditions for the development of a comprehensive religious life. Indeed, the clergymen's active position became more and more noticeable. They are actively involved in public discussion on the main issues of the present: state building, strengthening of national security of the state, politics, economy, business and formation of civil society. Nowadays, in the context of the reformation of Ukraine, a real dialogue between the Church, the state and civil society becomes of fundamental importance. An example of this is the constructive cooperation of the state with the All-Ukrainian Council of Churches and Religious Organizations(UCCRO) [1], which is a representative inter-confessional consultative and advisory body and operates on a voluntary basis. The members of the Council are religious centers of religious associations (confessions) operating in Ukraine, whose statutes are registered in accordance with the procedure established by the legislation of Ukraine, presented by their leaders at the Council.
It is clear that this dialogue is connected with all components of life — political, religious, economic, legal, organizational and other cultures. The task of Christian theology is to preach about God, it actualizes the understanding that religious faith carries the absolute truth about God, state, man, society, politics, business and the challenges of modern civilization.
And, finally, the most important thing. In our opinion, one of the most global problems of contemporary Ukrainian society is not only war, poverty and corruption, but also spiritual hatred. It is compelled to state that the scale of this problem ultimately demonstrates the low level of social and humanitarian policy of the state, the educational and social service of the Christian Churches. Strangely enough, scientific discussions about the national idea, culture, language of worship, ecclesiastical autocephaly, freedom of religious communities and the modernization of Ukrainian society are not suppressed today.
It would be more accurate to speak about the spiritual principles of the Ukrainian nation. These are the values of human freedom, the ideals of democracy, the movement towards modernization, success, prosperity, unity and understanding. It is worth to understand that the formation of a national idea is not an end in itself, but an effective, practical and constructive path to the prosperity of the state and all citizens of Ukraine. The realization of the national idea is a practical attempt to create such a social system that would harmonize the interests of all Ukrainian citizens on the principles of freedom, religious pluralism, economic prosperity, fraternal understanding, tolerance, respect, unity and Christian love.
It is known that the Christian Church, which develops its own spiritual culture, conducts missionary activity, carries out education, primarily on the basis of its own spiritual ideal, that is, in the unity of being with the Living Christ. And such a spiritual ideal cannot be formulated in isolation from the
spiritual life of a Christian with God, be something artificially thought up by scholars, political scientists, image makers and desirable exclusively for politicians. The purpose of the Church is the transformation of humanity's life in the light of Christ's love, the conversion of entire nations into the disciple-ship of Christ, which of course, have the right to have their own Church and are able to provide the full spiritual life of modern democratic countries. It is under such conditions that ecclesiastical autocephaly fully fulfills its historical mission and evolves into a true spiritual path to God. Although the path of a believer to a true and complete life in Christ is long and complicated, it's necessary to become well the way more and more solid and confident in it now, every day, because, in our opinion, we are going rather vaguely and uncertainly.
It should be noted that the most prominent figure in the life of the Ukrainian Orthodoxy of the second half of the 20th - the beginning of the 21st century — the Primate of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church, His Beatitude Metropolitan of Kiev and All Ukraine Volodymyr (Sabodan) (1935-2014), reflecting on the ministry of the Church, emphasized that there were times, when everything was solved by the verbal preaching of the church ambon. But today the task of the modern theologian is both the explanation and the development of the social doctrine of the Church. "Modernity requires a dynamic, but at the same time, deep, Orthodox understanding of the problems of the life of society. Orthodox theologians, taking into account all the transformations of the modern world,
must now pay special attention to social problems, and church and secular media provide our theologians with an opportunity to convey their thoughts and views to society" [2, p. 368-371]. That is why, according to Professor Yuri Chornomorets, the Church, which has its own initiatives for the family, the educational sphere, the economy and the state, is influential in society [3]. "In the local community, the Christian social doctrine sees the likeness of the family, the likeness of the parish. Without living local communities, without self-government, a healthy social organism of the nation is impossible. The rule of law state from above, social solidarity from below, the maintenance of human rights everywhere — here are three maxims that will save Ukraine"
[4].
Obviously, Ukrainian Churches, along with Ukrainian society, are looking for answers to a number of critical issues of human existence. For the sake of justice, it should be noted that today it is not always easy for a priest and a theologian to respond to criticism: "Why does the Church silence the fact that the people are dying?" "Why is Ukraine lacking church unity and understanding?" In what society we live, which state we build, where we are moving, what future our children will have, how far away are we from true Christian values? Reflections on these issues should form the main content of the social doctrine of all Christian churches, political theology in dialogue with state administration. It is known that the history of mankind and the Church, in particular, suggests that building a strong state, overcoming mass poverty, breaking corruption
cannot be without law, a fair model of a high-performing economy and moral responsibility of society. It is fundamentally important for the Church to speak of missionary work, education, enlightenment, education, social responsibility of the Church, state, business, charity and help to our neighbor. Thus, the Church must have a purposeful constant spiritual and social work with society. This work involves the formation of social activity of parishioners in the life of modern society. Not only secular scholars, but also church leaders have to admit that the sphere of modern education, youth and information policy have been most severely affected by the false isolationist model of the development of parish life.
Therefore, cooperation between the Church and the state in influencing the spiritual and cultural life of society, which includes morals, culture, language, literature, spirituality, religious values of man, family, and labor collective, is especially important. The elite of the society, the state, political parties, public and religious organizations should carry out preventive and educational work on the reduction of the social base of destruction, violation of human rights, corruption, etc. The problem of determining the ways of the spiritual unification of the Ukrainian people is due, on the one hand, to understanding the processes of state formation, national politics, geopolitical strategies, and, on the other, the adequacy of theological reflection on the challenges of modern civilization, on which the future mission of Christianity in the world depends to a large extent. It should be emphasized that the idea of spiritual unity of the
Ukrainian people is in demand in society, "since there is an objective need for the self-knowledge of the people themselves, their essence, and accordingly, the substantiation of self-worth and self-importance of their existence" [5, p. 37]. However, the search for the spiritual model of Ukraine's development and national idea is complicated by the fact that the modern man is unduly burdened with political manipulation, ideologization of culture in the context of exclusively material values of the development of mankind. The global dominance of financial interests, the so-called philosophy of success, the total commercialization of being, on the basis of which the social life is built, destroys the most important thing — the attraction of man to the sphere of spirit, culture and religion.
We emphasize that from the standpoint of Christianity, nourishing and effective form, the national idea of the spiritual development of Ukrainian society acquires through the prism of Christian values that form the spiritual foundation of religious, moral, spiritual, cultural, historical, national, political and social life in the Ukrainian state, and determine spiritual vectors of orientation of a Christian. It should also be noted that in the history of mankind Ukraine was formed as a kind of Christian democratic republic.
Of course, Christian values are not necessary to idealize the church's sphere of life, including the attitude of the people towards the Church. But in general, the Church, in the light of its own shortcomings, of weakness, of inertia, of a certain social passivity, tries to "reach" the consciousness, the mind of the people, calling on it to become a path of respon-
sibility towards God, state creation, understanding, forgiveness, democracy and modernization. Consequently, not only the rapid pace of destruction of the principles of the rule of law, distortion of the judicial system, restriction of freedom of speech, contempt for human dignity, and above all the question of the spiritual integrity, strength and spiritual unity of the Ukrainian people were and today are threatened factors for the Ukrainian nation. It should be noted that the psychology of the split, the mythologization of history [6], the Soviet mentality, the provincial, peasant thoughts of some church hierarchs, the politicization of church life, on the basis of which politicians build their election campaigns, restrict the most important — the ability of the Church of Christ to bear the joyous news of the renewal of being in unity with Live God, and also introduce the real power of social and spiritual transformation of all mankind.
In our opinion, it is Christianity that occupies a special place in the concept of the unification of the Ukrainian people, which must be realized as a factor in stabilizing the moral and ethical state of the people and the state. The light of the doctrine of Christ illuminates a different form of human activity — politics, culture, economics, art, literature, painting, journalism. The proposed theological concept of the unity of the Ukrainian people in principle and in essence forms the methodological basis of the unifying basis for the consolidation of different denominations into a united, harmonized social community — the Ukrainian people [2; 9]. "Without prejudice to the national and religious sentiments of other peoples,
the Ukrainian christological national idea initiates the spiritual aspirations of the mystical knowledge of Genesis; respect for the human person, ethnic and religious communities; the establishment of peace-loving ties based on the mutual understanding of peoples" [5, p. 43]. The Christian idea of unity is characterized by openness. Practically all confessions of Ukraine can join it. Moreover, it proceeds from the possibility of its perception by other peoples at any depth of penetration into the essential basis of Christian doctrine. One cannot but agree with the reflections of the many-year prisoner of the Soviet camp system, the confessor of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, Cardinal Josyf Slipyj (1892-1984): "Lack of feeling and understanding of unity in the basic issues of the life of the Church and the people is our misfortune, this is our original sin!" [7, p. 49]. "Our common national flaws are divisions and breakdowns, quarrels and strife. We gladly conquer and rely on strangers to compete with each other and to harm our native cause. God would give us all the opportunity to come to our senses from the mountain to the floor and think about the future of the goodness of Ukraine and its Church in order to cast their ambitions and selfish wishes and benefits, and God and Ukraine were put forward as the leading idea of our lives, thoughts and deeds!" [7, p. 19].
We emphasize that the unity of the people can really be built only on the principles of unity, pluralism of thought, freedom of speech, national accord, love, forgiveness, respect and tolerance — this is an indisputable truth. It is the Orthodox Church of Ukraine that
have to do their utmost to prevent the Ukrainian people from confronting any interethnic misunderstandings, provocations, hostility, political manipulation, and above all — military conflicts.
In our opinion, the experience of parish life shows that only the orientation towards the own ways of development, formation and establishment of the Gospel can be effective and aimed at the implementation of the universal sacred mission of the Orthodox Church of Ukraine. Therefore, in order to adapt national models of catechism, enlightenment, missionaries to the challenges of the modern world, an important task is the formation of a self-sufficient system of church communities, which, despite the unity with all the Orthodox Churches of the world, despite the universal openness to all nations and peoples, has been guided by its own history, mentality, culture and theological tradition. "Ukrainian theological thought has always focused on the real problems of man, his suffering, aspirations and interests. The fate of a particular person is more important than the question of the borders of the empire, the geopolitical strategies of the future world. State imperial interests are always secondary in comparison with the questions of Christian anthropology.
Human personality — the highest value in the eyes of God. The life of mankind — in the captivity of political speculation, the totalitarian model of the development of society destroys the very man created in the image and likeness of God. Conquest of the will of a free person through party strife, state contradictions, ideological contradictions by informational manipulation of some earthly external authority, na-
tional or imperial, must be regarded by a Christian as a violation of God established order. To live in love, harmony, respect for one another convinces us that this is the eternal, self-evident truth of Christianity. To the modern Orthodox Christian it is important to destroy the ambitious imperial ideological and narrow-minded patterns of perception of Orthodoxy" [8, p. 26].
Conclusions. Thus, there are all prerequisites to state that state formation and the spiritual idea of Ukraine's development, which corresponds to the history, culture and mentality of the Ukrainian people, must be based on a unchanging religious basis. [9, p. 18]. Summarizing the above, it should be noted that the struggle of spiritual ideas is concentrated in the mind and heart of each human [10, p. 126]. Christianity appeals to the heart, mind, consciousness, conscience of every modern person. In other words, today the Orthodox Church of Ukraine under the direction of Metropolitan Epiphanius (Dumenko) needs to make a lot of effort in order to re-emerge in the hearts of contemporaries the light of the religious faith and to burn the fire of Christian hope. Only then it will be possible to talk about qualitative transformations in politics, economy and genuine modernization in the Ukrainian society.
It should be noted that while investigating the religious culture of a country, scholars and future civil servants must remember the existence of many regional and national variations of religious culture. By studying the church history, psychology, culture and mentality of the Ukrainian people, assessing the geopolitical position of Ukraine, taking into account the real aspirations
of church parishes to their own cultural and social identity, the issue of updating the peculiarities and uniqueness of the religions of Ukraine becomes more and more obvious.
REFERENCES -
1. Informatsiia pro VRTsiRO [Information about "All-Ukrainian Council of Churches and Religious Organizations"]. (2016). vrciro.org.ua. Retrieved from http://vrciro.org.ua/ua/ council/info [in Ukrainian].
2. Volodymyr (Sabodan), Metropolitan of Kiev and All Ukraine. (2011). Dopovidi, promovy, zvernennia [Reports, speeches, appeals]. Kyiv: Vy-davnychyi viddil Ukrainskoi Pravo-slavnoi Tserkvy [in Ukrainian].
3. Chornomorets Yu. (2018). Ideal Khrystyianskoi Ukrainy yak vymoha sotsialnoho vchennia khrystyian-skykh Tserkov [The ideal of Christian Ukraine as a requirement of the social doctrine of the Christian Churches]. risu.org.ua. Retrieved from http://risu.org.ua/ua/index/ expert_thought/ analytic/47555/ [in Ukrainian].
4. Chornomorets Yu. (2018). Vidpovidal-nist Tserkov za maibutnie Ukrainy [Responsibility of the Churches for the future of Ukraine]. risu.org.ua. Retrieved from http://risu.org.ua/ ua/index/studios/materials_confe-rences/56445/ [in Ukrainian].
5. Khvesyk M. A., Bystriakov I. K., Levkovska L. V., Pylypiv V. V. (2012). Stalyi rozvytok: svitohliadna ideolohi-ia maibutnoho [Sustainable development: outlook ideology of the future]. Kyiv: Derzhavna ustanova "Instytut ekonomiky pryrodokorystuvannia ta staloho rozvytku Natsionalnoi akademii nauk Ukrainy" [in Ukrainian].
6. Holovatyi M. F. (2006). Politychna mi-folohiia [Political mythology]. Kyiv: MAUP [in Ukrainian].
7. Ferents T. (Eds.). (2017). 125 dumok Patriiarkha Yosyfa Slipoho [125 views of Patriarch Yosyf Slipyi]. Lviv: Svi-chado [in Ukrainian].
8. Martyshyn Dionisii, protoiereus. (2013). Zustrich iz Zhyvym Bohom: dukhovni besidy na pravoslavni svi-ata [Meeting with the Living God: Spiritual Conversations on Orthodox Feasts]. Kyiv: Dukhovno-prosvit-nytskyi Tsentr imeni Sviatykh Apos-toliv [in Ukrainian].
9. Viktor (Bed), archimandrite. (2010). Konstytutsiino-pravovi aspekty re-alizatsii prava liudyny na svobodu sovisti ta virovyznannia [Constitutional and legal aspects of the implementation of human rights to freedom of conscience and religion]. Uzhhorod: Informatsiino-vydavnychyi tsentr "UUBA-KaU" [in Ukrainian].
10. Martyshyn D. S. (2017). Dialoh Ukrai-nskoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvy ta suspilst-va u protsesi politychnykh transfor-matsii Ukrainy [Dialogue of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church and Society in the Process of Political Transformations in Ukraine]. Kyiv: DP "Vyd. dim "Personal" [in Ukrainian].
СПИСОК ВИКОРИСТАНИХ ДЖЕРЕЛ -
1. 1нформащя про ВРЩРО // 1нтернетпортал "Всеукрашська Рада Церков i релтйних оргашзацш" [Електронний ресурс]. — 2016. — Режим доступу: http://vrciro.org. ua/ua/council/info — Дата доступу: 12.05.2016.
2. Володимир (Сабодан), Митрополит Кшвський та Bdei Украши. Доповь д^ промови, звернення. — К.: Видав. вщдш Украшсь^ Православноi Церкви, 2011. — 422 с.
3. Чорноморець Юрш. 1деал Христи-янсько! Укра!ни як вимога сощ-ального вчення християнських Церков // 1нтернет-портал "Р1СУ. Релiгiйно-iнформацiйна служба Укра!ни" [Електронний ресурс]. — 2018. — Режим доступу: http://risu. org.ua/ua/index/expert_thought/ analytic/47555/ — Дата доступу: 25.12.2018.
4. Чорноморець Юрш. Вщповщаль-шсть Церков за майбутне Укра!-ни // 1нтернет-портал "Р1СУ. Рель гiйно-iнформацiйна служба Укра!-ни" [Електронний ресурс]. — 2018. — Режим доступу: http://risu.org. ua/ua/index/studios/materials_ conferences/56445/— Дата доступу: 25. 12. 2018.
5. Сталий розвиток: свггоглядна щео-логiя майбутнього: [монографiя] / [М. А. Хвесик, I. К. Бистряков, Л. В. Левковська, В. В. Пили-шв];за ред. акад. НААН Укра!ни М. А. Хвесика. — К.: Державна уста-нова "1н-т економши природокорис-
тування та сталого розвитку Нац. акад. наук Укра!ни", 2012. — 465 с.
6. Головатий М. Ф. Полггична мiфо-лопя: навч. посiб. — К.: МАУП, 2006. — 144 с.
7. 125 думок Патрiярха Йосифа Си-пого / Упоряд. Тереза Ференц. — Львiв: Свiчадо, 2017. — 144 с.
8. Мартишин Дютсш, прот. Зустрiч iз Живим Богом: духовш бесiди на православнi свята / Д. Мартишин. — К.: Духовно-просвггницький Центр iменi Святих Апостолiв, 2013. -104 с.
9. Вжтор (Бедь), архiм. (Бедь В. В.). Конституцiйно-правовi аспекти ре-аизацп права людини на свободу совiстi та вiровизнання. — Ужгород: 1нформащйно-видавничий центр "УУБА-КаУ", 2010. — 278 с.
10. Мартишин Д. С. Дiалог Укра!нсько! Православно! Церкви та сусшль-ства у процесi полггичних тран-сформацiй Укра!ни: монографiя / Д. С. Мартишин. — Ки!в: ДП "Вид. дiм "Персонал", 2017. — 272 с.
