CC BY
80І ПЕДАГОГІКА І та медико-біологічні
проблеми фізичного
ПСИХОЛОГІЯ
виховання і спорту
Stressful situations in teaching profession - causes and consequences
Romanowska-Tolloczko Anna
University School of Physical Education in Wroclaw
Annotations:
Purpose. Determination which areas of teacher's work are primary sources of stress, denomination of the extent to which disciplinary problems with students were stress inducing, and what was the frequency and intensity of these situations. Material and methods. The study involved 180 teachers from junior high schools, among which two groups were selected: physical education teachers (74 persons) and teachers of other subjects (106 persons). The reason for this division was the necessity of identifying the groups of teachers differing in specifics of school subjects, studies which they graduated from, and determine the typical areas of difficulty experienced. The research was based on a diagnostic survey and a questionnaire. Results. Teaching profession is considered as psychologically challenging occupation due to numerous occurrences of stressful situations. Yet it is not equally aggravating for everyone - there are well-functioning teachers who cope easily, but on the other hand, there are cases of serious psychosomatic consequences caused by frequent and prolonged pressures. Abilities of dealing with difficult situations largely depend upon one's individual predispositions, resistance to stress, way of assessing a situation and resulting type of action. Conclusions. The ability (or lack of it) of coping with range of educational activities may determine the intensity of experienced difficulties, and therefore the frequency of occurring stressful situations. Lack of skills in the area of interpersonal relations translates to inability to coping with problematic situations with pupils. This leads the teacher to awareness of own inefficiency and helplessness, which increases the intensity of experienced stress.
Key words:
teacher, stress, difficult situations, educational, skills.
Романовська-Толлочко Анна. Стресові ситуації в роботі вчителів - причини і наслідки. Мета: визначити, які складові праці вчителя є основними джерелами стресу. Також у якому ступені навчальні проблеми з учнями ведуть до виникнення стану стресу і яка їх частота та інтенсивність. Матеріали: у дослідженні взяли участь 180 вчителів із загальноосвітніх шкіл, серед яких були відібрані дві групи: вчителі фізичної культури (74 особи) і викладачі інших предметів (106 осіб). Причиною такого поділу була необхідність визначення групи вчителів, що відрізняються специфікою викладання предметів, специфікою завершення вивчення та визначення типових для них напрямків перешкод. Дослідження було проведено методом діагностичного зондування допомогою опитувальни-ка. Результати. Професія вчителя є професією, що визначається як психологічно важка, у зв'язку з наявністю численних стресових ситуаціях. Не для всіх однаково впливають зазначені чинники - частина вчителів має добрий функціональний стан і інша частина вчителів в результаті частого і тривалого стресу несе серйозні психосоматичні наслідки. Здатність справлятися з важкими ситуаціями в значній мірі обумовлена індивідуальною схильністю особистості, його стійкістю до стресу, способом оцінки ситуації і відповідною реакцією на неї. Висновки: спроможність або невміння вчителя діяти відповідно до освітньої ситуації може мати вирішальне значення при прийнятті вірних рішень і тим самим змінювати частоту стресових ситуацій. Відсутність навичок у міжособистісних стосунках призводить до не спроможності вчителя вирішувати проблемні ситуації з учнями. Така неефективність діяльності вчителя та його безпорадність збільшує інтенсивність стресу.
вчитель, стрес, важкі ситуації, уміння, виховання.
Романовска-Толлочко Анна. Стрессовые ситуации в работе учителей - причины и последствия. Цель: определить, какие составляющие труда учителя являются основными источниками стресса. Также - в какой степени учебные проблемы с учениками ведут к возникновению состояния стресса и какова их частота и интенсивность. Материал: в исследовании приняли участие 180 учителей из общеобразовательных школ, среди которых были отобраны две группы: учителя физической культуры ( 74 человека ) и преподаватели других предметов ( 106 человек ). Причиной такого разделения была необходимость определения группы учителей, отличающихся спецификой преподавания предметов, спецификой завершения изучения и определения типичных для них направлений препятствий. Исследование было проведено методом диагностического зондирования помощью опросника. Результаты. Профессия учителя является профессией, которая определяется как психологически тяжелая, в связи с наличием многочисленных стрессовых ситуациях. Не на всех одинаково влияют указанные факторы - часть учителей имеет хороший функциональное состояние и другая часть учителей в результате частого и длительного стресса несет серьезные психосоматические последствия. Способность справляться с трудными ситуациями в значительной степени обусловлена индивидуальной предрасположенностью личности, ее устойчивостью к стрессу, способом оценки ситуации и соответствующей реакцией на нее. Выводы: способность или неумение учителя действовать в соответствии с образовательной ситуации может иметь решающее значение при принятии верных решений и тем самым изменять частоту стрессовых ситуаций. Отсутствие навыков в межличностных отношениях приводит к не способности учителя решать проблемные ситуации с учениками. Такая неэффективность деятельности учителя и его беспомощность увеличивает интенсивность стресса.
учитель, стресс, тяжелые ситуации, умение, воспитания.
Introduction
The occupation of a teacher bases on direct subjective relation which implies cooperation and emotional exchange. The role of pedagogue requires personal engagement, particular care and the ability of creating and sustaining interpersonal interactions [1]. Because of that, the role of a teacher is burdened with above-average difficulties [2].
To describe the modern profile of a teacher Konarzewski defines it as a vague, internally inconsistent, psychologically difficult and incompatible with other important roles [3].
The ambiguity of teacher’s role stems from the fact that it is difficult to find consensus concerning the criteria for evaluating it. It is linked with the absence of predetermined
© Anna Romanowska-Tottoczko, 2014 doi: 10.6084/m9.figshare.923518
and simultaneously measurable indicators of professional excellence in areas of didactics, education and care. The expectations towards a teacher are evidence of lack of integrity as they are often contradictory or very difficult to meet. Following factors influence the psychological difficulties of teaching profession: responsibility for the other person, relative irreversibility of the decision, the difficulty of correcting own mistakes, necessity to work at a pace and rhythm forced by specific conditions, need to constantly confront the expectations of students and readiness to respond quickly [1]. Inconsistency with other roles occurs when the meeting the expectations linked with given role impedes or prevents meeting the expectations imposed by other roles. In the case of a teacher conflict can occur in two ways - professional and non professional [3].
Another difficulty with the teaching profession is a requirement of having a broad spectrum of diverse
competencies that should be continually developed and improved rapidly due to the cultural transformations taking place and changing social needs [4].
The teacher is expected not only to impart knowledge but also to possess educational, organizational and creative the teacher is expected to not only imparting knowledge but also educational skills, organizational and creative, while the effects of his work are indirect, and gratuities usually very uncertain and deferred. In Polish conditions, there are additional factors resulting from the current sociopolitical and economic situation. For example: low wages, insecurity, underestimation of the teaching profession.
Consequently, teachers too often experience stressful situations, which are not without effect on their health, social relationships and careers. The stress connected with the profession of a teacher is of great interest of pedeutology, psychology and sociology. Borg’s application of factor analysis led to the isolation of the root causes of stress in the teaching profession:
Factor 1 - incorrect behavior of students: difficult classes, arrogance and audacity of students, noise, difficulty in maintaining discipline, lack of sufficient interest in school work by students, too numerous classes.
Factor 2 - time pressure as a source of difficulties: lack of time for individual work with children, poorly designed textbooks, lack of adequate equipment and labor saving devices, the need to perform a variety of administrative work, numerous substitutions, the continuation of work at home (preparation for lessons, checking notebooks, tests).
Factor 3 - difficulties in achieving the needs of professional satisfaction: small chance of making a career, awareness of insufficient pay, lack of recognition and gratification for the work.
Factor 4 - insufficient collegial relationships as a source of bad relationships among teaching staff, pressure from the headmaster or education authorities, pressure from parents [5].
Purpose
Stressful situations occurring in the teaching profession have been discussed in many works devoted to the specifics of the profession and professional burnout, which is regarded as a consequence of the strong, chronic stress experienced in the context of their work [6,7,8]. In these studies, however, little space is devoted to the educational competence of teachers, who in their work primarily deal with the difficulties of educational nature. The ability or lack of ability to cope with this scope may be critical in severity of experienced difficulties, and thus the frequency of stressful situations.
The aim of the research was to pay particular attention to the sphere educational influence of teachers, and to determine to what extent the educational problems of the students lead to the emergence of a state of stress.
The research focused on the following issues: Which areas of teacher’s work are primary sources of stress? What is the frequency of experienced difficult situations? How teachers define the intensity of experienced stress? Does professional stress have influence on family lives of the teachers?
32014
H
Material and methods
The study involved 180 teachers from junior high schools, among which two groups were selected: physical education teachers (74 persons) and teachers of other subjects (106 persons). The reason for this division was the necessity of identifying the groups of teachers differing in specifics of school subjects, studies which they graduated from, and determine the typical areas of difficulty experienced. The study was conducted using a questionnaire, which was one of the research tools used in the comprehensive study carried out in terms of teacher professional burnout.
Results
Areas of the work of teachers which are the main sources of stressors
To obtain information relating to the stressors that are specific to individuals, examined teachers were asked open-ended question, not to suggest areas that could be a source of stress in their work. It was assumed that, in the first place frequently recurring, and most problematic situations will be listed. Through their annoyance they are the most vivid and settled in the perception of people experiencing them.
Among the stressful events mentioned by the teachers, the vast majority concerned educational situations. Difficulties in maintaining discipline in the classroom repeated most frequently (73%), followed by rude (arrogant or disrespectful) behavior of students (61%). Physical education teachers equally often mentioned the noise in the classroom, and therefore the need for increased tone of voice (52%). A further, though at a much less mentioned source of stress was enormous amount of responsibilities and pressure of time to cope with them (29%). Few teachers have identified as stressful relationships with management (7%) and teaching staff (5%).
On the basis on the results of previously conducted studies, that showed significantly lower levels of educational competence of teachers in relation to their substantive and methodological expertise [9], it was assumed that the sphere of educational interaction may be the area most stressful for teachers, causing strong emotional reactions. Therefore, an attempt find out how often teachers react in a raised voice or shout to students hampering the lesson. It turns out that this phenomenon is quite common and frequent, because this type of reaction is admitted by 57% of teachers. A raised voice is on the one hand a way of intimidating the other person and exerting pressure, a sign of aggression. On the other hand it is an expression of helplessness. The above behaviors of teachers indicate some important aspects that could provide the cause of such proceedings:
• Teacher’s lack of awareness of the impact of verbal aggression on their students, which triggers its further escalation,
• Ignorance of constructive supportive methods in the maintenance of discipline and proper relationship education,
• Too impulsive responding resulting from the inability to cope with emotions and lack of understanding of the essence of this mechanism.
І ПЕДАГОГІКА І та медико-біологічні
проблеми фізичного виховання і спорту
The frequency of difficult situations and intensity of the experienced stress.
Difficult situations are perceived subjectively - what for one person is troublesome, annoying or threatening, for another may not be a problem. The evaluation of these situations and individual perception depends largely on personal predispositions and skills of coping with stress, which also determines its intensity.
To learn the specifics of difficult situations that cause stress reactions of varying severity, three levels of intensity of stress were adopted:
a). low intensity - a short and moderate anxiety
b). medium intensity - a nervousness persisting for about an hour, with a significant level of anxiety
c) high intensity - a tension lasting a few hours, which is characterized by strong psycho physiological responses.
The determination of the frequency was also clarified: very rarely means once a month or less, rarely 1-2 times a week, often - once a day, very often - several times during the day. On the basis of obtained results it can be concluded that teachers often and very often experience stress of low intensity. They are somehow placed in vocational routine and relate to almost all teachers (90%). Stress of medium intensity, often and very often is experienced by nearly half of the respondents, which is already a concern. However, strong stress reactions are experienced (with varying frequency) by 1/3 of the study group (Table 1).
Some differences were noted in determining the intensity of stress among teachers of physical education and other subjects. Physical education teachers mentioned mostly low and medium level of experienced stress. What is more, there are none who would experience high level of stress in their work. This is important information that requires further steps of research, in order to determine the factors that determine the occurrence of these differences.
Occupational stress and the sphere of family life
The specificity of the teaching profession is the need to perform some of the related duties at home, i.e. preparing for lessons, checking and evaluating the tests, filling in school documentation. These activities reduce the time that could be devoted to the family. For some of the teachers working hours almost never end, which is an additional and significant source of stress. Among the surveyed teachers one third believes that professional duties take them a lot of time and cause a permanent state of tension. This problem generally does not apply to physical education teachers. Another important issue
ПСИХОЛОГІЯ
is the transfer of negative emotions from the work onto the ground of family life. Groups of teachers were distinguished for specific types of behavior in reaction to the psychological burden associated with work:
• - Teachers, for whom work is not stressful - characterized by their inner calm in relations with students and family relationships.
• - Teachers who suppress negative emotions and manage to respond in a calm manner to students, but after returning home, give vent to their tension accumulated at work.
• - Teachers characterized by a certain impulsiveness of reactions in stressful work situations, but also in the family life. At this stage of research it is difficult to determine whether such behavior is conditioned by temperament, whether it is due to learned (habitual) ways of responding and low resistance to stress.
• - Teachers who react in stressful school relationships both impulsively and calmly, but consciously try not to carry negative emotional states to the sphere family life; they control their reactions towards household members, as they realize that the source of their arousal are different people and situations.
Conclusions
The ability to cope with difficult situations largely is conditioned by individual predispositions of a person, one’s resistance to stress and a way to assessing the situation and the consequent action. There are two typical patterns of addressing the stress: optimistic-realistic focused on the success, and the catastrophe pattern set to fail. The experience of stress is thus affected by subjective assessment of the situation. This evaluation may depend on the mood physical and mental forms, external influences and determinants of personality [10]. However, remember that you can also have an impact on the improvement of individual remedial measures and developing the skills limiting the frequency and intensity of the experienced stress, which means learn how to undertake preventive measures [11]. Therefore, in the teacher education system stress coping workshops should necessarily be included, which main purpose is to enrich the internal resources and improving the remedial skills of future teachers. Furthermore, it is essential to teach students relaxation techniques, assertiveness, social and emotional skills [12]. However, this type of course in Polish universities is not sufficient. This means that the development of personality predispositions of the students is neglected. Previous research conducted by the author
Table 1
The frequency and intensity of stress experienced by teachers
-— intensity of stress frequency ' '—-— of experience stress ~ '—-— low intensity medium intensity high intensity
very rarely - 4% 13%
rarely 15% 48% 10%
often 53% 32% 7%
very often 23% 16% 3%
of study showed that schools educating future teachers, prepare them for psycho-social performance in minimal extent, resulting in, among others, insufficient educational competencies that are necessary in this profession [13]. Moreover, other authors on the basis of the study concluded that greater importance in teacher training is applied to the substantive and methodical knowledge, while neglecting their training in parenting skills, which have a direct relationship with the social skills that are necessary for effective functioning in relationships with students [4,14,15].
As a result of these deficiencies in the competence, teachers encounter many educational problems to which they feel helpless, or act in an incorrect manner [16]. The result of such actions is the formation of abnormal and sometimes destructive relationships that are equally
32014
H
detrimental to the student and the teacher. A student subjected to an incorrect upbringing interactions react with aggression or withdrawal, whereas, a teacher not coping with difficult situations in the school is aware of its own inefficiency and helplessness which increases the intensity of experienced stress.
The teaching profession undoubtedly requires a certain personality predispositions that facilitate the exercise of the profession. According Tucholska [1] personal characteristics and social skills of teachers determine in a special way a proper fit to the profession and protect against excessive stress. However, their deficit carries the risk of exhaustion, discouragement, disappointment, or excessive professional withdrawal, accompanied by the whole range of psychosomatic symptoms and consequences in social relations in different aspects of life.
References
1. Tucholska S. Teachre's professional burnout. Psychological analysis of the phenomenon and its personal predispositions, Lublin, 2009, pp. 92-95.
2. Fontana D. Psychology for teachers, Poznan 1998, p. 329.
3. Konarzewski K. The art of teaching, School, Warszawa, 2002, pp.148-179.
4. Matczak A. Questionnaire of social competence. Textbook, Warszawa 2001, p.12.
5. Grzegorzewska M.K. Stress in teacher's profession. Specificity, predispositions, consequences, Krakow, 2006, pp. 54-56.
6. S^k H. Teachers’ professional burnout. Social and subjective predispositions, In: Brzezinski J., Witkowski L. (ed.by), Education towards the social change, Poznan-Torun. 1994, pp.72-98.
7. Tucholska S. The risk of burnout in teacher's profession, Psychology at school [Psychologia w Szkole]. 2004, vol 2, pp. 95-108.
8. Gaida W. Mental weariness in the context of professional burnuot, Zielona Gora. 1998, 167 p.
9. Romanowska A., Golbik E. Professional competences in the perception of teachers of schools of different levels, In: Ogrodnik J., Przybyla E.,
Sas-Nowosielski K. (ed.by), Teacher in demanding times, Katowice, 2011, pp.197-217.
10. Kretschmann R. Stress in teacher's profession, Gdansk, 2003, pp. 28-30.
11. B^k K. & Co. Man and psychology, Bielsko-Biala, 2005, 183 p.
12. Goleman D. Emotional intelligence, Poznan, 1999, 34 p.
13. Romanowska-Tolloczko A., Miedzinska. B. Pedagogical and psychological pre-service teacher training in different types of higher education institutions, [Pedagogics, Psychology, Medical-Biological Problems of Physical Training and Sports], 2012, vol.6, pp.119-123.
14. Daszkowska J. Upbringing: inseparable component of education of future teachers, Society and Family [Spoleczenstwo i Rodzina]. 2012, vol.31, pp. 92-101.
15. Malory I. About educational helplessness — from theory and teachers' practical experiences, Everyday Education [Wychowanie na co dzien], 2012, vol.4-5, pp. 15-20.
16. Speck O. To be a teacher, Gdansk, 2005, 303 p.
Information about the author: Romanowska-Tolloczko Anna: ORCID: 000-0003-2236-7519; Anna. Romanowska-Tolloczko@awf.wroc.pl; University School of Physical Education in Wroclaw; Paderewskiego 35, 51-612 Wroclaw, Poland
Cite this article as: Anna Romanowska-Tolloczko. Stressful situations in teaching profession - causes and consequences. Pedagogics, psychology, medical-biological problems of physical training and sports, 2014, vol.2, pp. 72-75. doi:10.6084/m9.figshare.923518
The electronic version of this article is the complete one and can be found online at: http://www.sportpedagogy.org.ua/html/arhive-e.html
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited (http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/deed.en).
Received: 31.12.2013 Published: 28.12.2013
Информация об авторе: Романовска-Толлочко Анна: ORCID: 000-0003-2236-7519; anna. romanowska-tolloczko@awf.wroc.pl ; Университетская Школа Физического воспитания во Вроцлаве; Падеревсиего 35, 51-612, Вроцлав, Польша
Цитируйте эту статью как: Романовска-Толлочко Анна. Стрес -совые ситуации в работе учителей - причины и последствия// Педагогіка, психологія та медико-біологічні проблеми фізичного виховання і спорту. - 2014. - № 2 - С. 72-75. doi:10.6084/ m9.figshare.923518
Электронная версия этой статьи является полной и может быть найдена на с айте: http://www.sportpedagogy.org.ua/html/arhive.html
Это статья Открытого Доступа распространяется под терминами Creative Commons Attribution License, которая разрешает неограниченное использование, распространение и копирование любыми средствами, обеспечивающими должное цитирование этой оригинальной статьи (http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/deed.ru).
Дата поступления в редакцию: 31.12.2013 г. Опубликовано: 28.12.2013 г.
