CC BY
74
ê Andrei B. Lebedev, Vladimir A. Utkov, Akhded Abrakhim Khalifa
Sintered Sorbent Utilization fortbS Removal...
UDC 669.712.1.002.68
Sintered Sorbent Utilization for H2S Removal from Industrial Flue Gas in the Process of Smelter Slag Granulation
Andrei B. LEBEDEV», Vladimir A. UTKOV, Akhded Abrakhim KHALIFA
Saint-Petersburg Mining University, Saint-Petersburg, Russia
Authors suggest removing hydrogen sulfide from the hot industrial gas at temperatures 200-300 °C and its subsequent interaction with Fe2O3. For this purpose the following sorbents have been proposed: a mixture of iron oxide and fly ash; iron oxide and pumice; different samples of red mud (bauxite treatment residues containing iron oxide). To prevent dusting and loss of absorbing capacity, the sorbents were shaped into porous granules with other metallic oxides. Materials utilized in the study were obtained the following way: mixing of Fe2O3 with fly ash; sintering of the mixture with red mud. The blend contains aluminum oxide and silica, which can act as matrix shapers, alkali oxides and fluxing agents that reduce the temperature during metal sintering. After the samples had been saturated with sulfur, they were positioned in a venting reservoir, where under the temperature 600-700 °C desorption to the initial state occurred by means of passing an air flow through the sorbent layer. In the process of this operation, sulfur dioxide was released and reactive metal oxides re-emerged. Desorption also generated a small amount of elemental sulfur and sulfuric acid. Absorbing capacity was assessed at higher temperatures, efficiency of H2S removal reached 95-99.9 %. Proposed technology of air cleaning is recommended to use in metallurgic processes with elevated atmospheric pollution, e.g. granulation of melted blast-furnace slag.
Key words: red mud; industrial flue gas; pumice; absorbing capacity; sorbents; smelter slag
Acknowledgements. The study has been performed with financial support from the Ministry of Education and Science of Russian Federation (project register number 11.4098.2017/PCh from 01.01.2017).
How to cite this article: Lebedev A.B., Utkov V.A., Khalifa A.A. Sintered Sorbent Utilization for H2S Removal from Industrial Flue Gas in the Process of Smelter Slag Granulation. Journal of Mining Institute. 2019. Vol. 237, p. 292-297. DOI: 10.31897/PMI.2019.3.292
Introduction. In numerous literary sources on flue gas cleaning in the temperature interval 540-800 °C there is information about flue gas desulfurization in the interval 20-700 °C with iron oxide of fineness -16+100, the same sources contain data on static layers of sorbent pulp in the interval 320-400 °C [18].
Static sorbent layers have been tested at volume speed (100 units of gas volume passing through 1 unit of sorbent volume in an hour). Agentt absorbing capacity accounted for 30 % of sulfur mass. At higher temperatures efficiency of H2S absorption increased from 95 to 99.9 %. Such production unit can process up to 100 billion liters of coke gas per day.
Iron oxide absorbs sulfur in the layer of sorbent pulp at temperatures between 200 to 300 °C. General functioning of the unit demonstrated satisfactory results due to the fact that large gatherings of finely-dispersed oxide dust were detected in various part of the environment. Authors present their results of study on solid substances that can remove H2S from hot industrial flue gases generated in the process of slag granulation. The following solid substances have been used: 1) sintered blend of iron oxide (Fe2O3) and ash; 2) pumice covered with melted Fe2O3; 3) sintered granules of red mud, alumina processing residue, which contains around 50 % Fe2O3 [6].
Problem statement. The industry widely applies clean compressed gas, as it perfectly satisfies consumer demands. However, treatment of flue gas is a problematic issue, as it contains sulfur compounds that contaminate the environment, damage the equipment and degrade performance when entering the atmosphere of the plant. One possible solution is to utilize the energy of hot flue gas for a wide range of industrial purposes, which can have a dramatic effect on the economy of smelting [2].
ê Andrei B. Lebedev, Vladimir A. Utkov, Akhded Abrakhim Khalifa
Sintered Sorbent Utilization fortbS Removal...
The temperature of industrial flue gases from the slag granulation area with a large share of H2S equals 150-400 °C. Hence, the use of flue gas heat can carry an economic significance for energy production. For this purpose, the gas must be preliminary cleaned from H2S. An important factor is whether it is possible to rule out liquid sorbents and limit the application of solid sorbents that can react with H2S at high temperatures. Sorbent material must be air-regeneratable, so that it could be repeatedly used in several cycles of H2S absorption [10].
Method. To investigate sorption properties of the materials, samples with preliminary sintered structure have been used in order to facilitate porosity generation. At temperatures 200-300 °C the samples absorbed H2S from artificially generated flue gas. Sorption samples were represented in three varieties: the first two were iron oxide mixtures with ash and pumice respectively; the third material was a red mud sample (alumina processing residue, contains up to 50 % of Fe2O3).
For laboratory conditions a gas mixture was modeled, so that its sulfur-containing component was obtained by means of elemental sulfur combustion and its subsequent addition to the gas under investigation (2 % of the total volume). Gas mixture is fed at a fixed speed to create an imitation of a gas flow, taken from the atmosphere of the granulation area. The gas does not contain ash, its H2S content equals approximately 1.5 %.
The gas mixture passes through the layer of test sorbent in a burette, positioned in a vertical pusher furnace, where the heating temperature of absorbing agent can be regulated depending on the process (adsorption or desorption) (Fig. 1).
The sorbent was preliminary heated to 200, 250 and 300 °C, after which the sulfur-containing gas mixture was fed through it. The flow rate of gas mixture was approximately 500 ml/s. H2S content was 15-20 mg/l. After sulfur absorption was completed, the temperature became stable in desorption mode. Further tests have been completed for the temperatures of 500, 650 and 800 °C. Experiments continued until H2S concentration in the flow of effluent gas settled around the mark of 2 mg/l. After that desorption could be considered completed. Agent's absorbing capacity was calculated using the values of H2S concentration, flow speed and test duration.
H2S concentration in the gas flow was estimated with Tutwiler method and tested using indication tubes and gas chromatography. An optimal combination of these methods has been identified [1, 5, 8, 17]. Sorbents regenerated by means of passing an air flow through the burette at temperatures 500-800 °C. In the course of first several tests, released SO2 got absorbed 2.5 times quicker.
In the solution of caustic soda, the liquid was acidized with HCl and titrated with iodine until the starch was fully bleached. A mass of regenerated sulfur was compared to the calculated mass of
Fig. 1. Conceptual chart of regeneration unit
1 - furnace; 2 - sulfur dose; 3 - vertical furnace; 4 - granulated sorbent; 5 - refrigerator; 6 - manometer; 7 - pump; 8 - gas sensor
ê Andrei B. Lebedev, Vladimir A. Utkov, Akhded Abrakhim Khalifa
Sintered Sorbent Utilization fortbS Removal...
absorbed sulfur to estimate the error in sulfur balance. Dispersion can be explained by the fact that in the course of regeneration a part of sulfur was emitted in a free state, gathered in the rear end of the reaction tube and therefore was not taken into account. Later SO2 concentration was measured with silica gel punch tubes.
Research subject. The tests were performed on the following samples: iron oxide promoted with chromium; calcinated granules of dolomite; alkalized granules of aluminum oxide. All of them decomposed in the process of desorption at temperatures 500-800 °C. To obtain satisfactory results several other sorbent samples have been prepared. The first material was composed of fly ash of -4+6 fineness from a bituminous coal power plant (sample 1, see Table) and pure Fe2O3.
Chemical composition of sintered ash dust, utilized for H2S sorption
Sample SiO2 AI2O3 Fe2O3 CaO MgO Na2O K2O TiO2 Other
1 (sintered ash dust) 44.6 23.5 15.1 4.4 1.5 2 2.1 2.5 4.3
2 (granulated pumice) 63.8 13.8 1.4 3.1 2.6 7.3 5.4 0.1 2.5
3 (red mud BAZ) 8.3 18.3 42.5 5.5 2.7 5.7 4.6 0.2 12.2
4 (red mud UAZ) 23.4 6.6 7.6 46.6 2.4 3.8 3.5 0.2 5.9
5 (red mud VAZ) 3.7 12.6 53.3 7.8 2.2 2.3 7.3 1.1 9.7
6 (red mud PAZ) 6.7 13.8 18.4 34.8 5.9 2.8 6.1 1.2 10.3
Fly ash and iron oxide have been thoroughly mixed, blended with water, shaped into granules and sintered at temperature around 980 °C. Beside that, sinter tests on taconite and pure Fe2O3 have been performed.
The second sorbent was composed of granulated pumice of fineness -4+8 and Fe2O3 content of 99 % (sample 2, see Table). Pumice granules were covered with iron oxide the following way: moistened granules were put into the glass, then dry oxide was added and the contents were subsequently stirred until the granules were uniformly covered. Then for 2 hours they were heated to 950 °C to sinter the materials. Some shrinkage did occur during heating, but the granules remained porous and iron oxide stuck to pumice surface. Excessive shrinkage and loss of porosity occurred at heating temperature of 1030 °C.
The third material consisted of red mud. It is normally dispatched either in powder or in granules, therefore it had to be grinded before use. The powder was moistened with sufficient amounts of water to form a yielding mass, subsequently heated to 260 °C, divided into 8 mm-granules and then soaked for 10-20 minutes at the temperature 1100 °C to get a solid sediment. Chemical analysis of red mud from different plants is presented in the Table (samples from 3 to 6).
Experimental results. All the sorbents were subject to regeneration to the state close to their initial one, air was passed through the sample volume at temperatures 500-800 °C. Sulfide dioxide was released and reactive metal oxides re-emerged. Desorption also generated a small amount of elemental sulfur and sulfuric acid.
Ash (75 %) and Fe2O3 (25 %) produced a sediment with a high absorbing capacity of sulfide, which did not decompose under conditions of the experiment. Experiments on one batch of the sor-bent confirm absorption capacity of the mixture ash - Fe2O3 and contain results of nine consequent regeneration cycles of the air cleaned from H2S. Obtained data demonstrated that there were no losses in absorbing capacity or visible decomposition of granules. Sorbents with a high Fe2O3 content (37 % and higher) were difficult to test because of their decomposition and mutual sintering of granules.
Results of experiment on composite materials, based on pumice covered with iron oxide, are presented in Fig.2. They are decomposition-resistant but have a tendency to sinter together into larger particles [3, 11, 12].
Sample of ash - Fe2O3 formed a very resistant structure and had the highest capacity compared to other tested samples of the same base.
ê Andrei B. Lebedev, Vladimir A. Utkov, Akhded Abrakhim Khalifa
Sintered Sorbent Utilization fortbS Removal...
3 1= & °
M o
■ 5
■6 S
m r-1
* £ on o
K 00 Fe2O3 Pumice
20
10
0 100
10 90
20 30 40 50 80 70 60 50 Absorbing substance, %
Fig.2. H2S absorbing capacity of sintered pumice 1 - 200 °C; 2 - 250 °C; 3 - 300 °C
40 r
60 40
cN
<u
J
13 >
'o
iS 13
K
30
20 -
10 -
200
250 Temperature,
300
'C
Fig.3 demonstrates the capacity of various ¡^ +¿30 r /
mixtures to absorb sulfur without decomposition of ^-e 2
the grain structure or sintering of several granules s M /3
into one, which are the main characteristics demanded from materials used as H2S sorbents.
In the process of regeneration of all sorbents at volume speed 57,000 m3/h, calculated under standard conditions (20 °C, pressure 1 atm), moment concentrations of SO2 were measured using chemical detector tubes. Regeneration temperature varied between 600 and 700 °C. When the temperature reached 800 °C, the material merged with the mass, which regenerated no longer. Regeneration temperature 650 °C turned out to be optimal for all types of sorbents. Liberation of heat in the process of exothermic regeneration was enough to increase the temperature of the sorbent layer to 200 °C [14, 16, 19].
Full sorbent regeneration is nearly impossible, at the end of the procedure remains a small fraction of SO2, registered by the measurements after an 80 h holding time. Regeneration (from 6 to 10 % of SO2) occurs at a high speed in the first 30-50 min, then (after 1 h) drops to 1 % in volume, decreases quickly and slowly reaches zero. Fig.4 demonstrates a dependency of SO2 concentration on time. Here regeneration temperature equals 500, 650 and 800 °C, sorption temperature is around 250 °C.
Sulfur mass, regenerated in any of the three tests within the first hour, amounted to 80 % of the total mass involved in the reaction. Experiments on the material composed of 63 % ash and 37 % Fe2O3 were performed at regeneration temperature of 800 °C, which is enough for quick regeneration of sorbent granules with low sulfur content (around 8 %). However, this temperature did not initiate quick regeneration in granules with high sulfur content (up to 34 %). Apparently, low-sulfur granules (10 % and less), regenerated at a greater speed than the ones with sulfur content 30 % and above. It points to the fact that regeneration should be initiated before the threshold of absorbing capacity is reached.
Result discussion. Mixtures of 75 % ash and 25 % Fe2O3 absorbed 8 % of sulfur at 200 °C and 43 % at 300 °C. Granules made of 40 % pumice and 60% Fe2O3 demonstrated their sulfur absorbing capacity to be 23 % at 200 °C and 30 % at 300°C. The most efficient sorbent was red mud: from 18 % at 200 °C to 45 % at 300 °C. This substance is a smelting residue and currently recycling of huge masses of red mud is a pressing issue. Obtained results open up an opportunity to use it as a sorbent to capture sulfur compounds in the process of blast furnace slag granulation (Fig.5). Sintered sorbent can substantially lower the costs of preparation and air regeneration [4, 7, 13, 15]. This is possible due to the fact that after thermal treatment the material can restore its properties without decomposition of the grain structure.
Fig.3. H2S absorbing capacity of the agents at 200-300 °C
1 - ash; 2 - 37 % Fe2O3, 63 % ash; 3 - 13 % Fe2O3, 87 % ash; 4 - 25 % Fe2O3, 75 % ash; 5- red mud
M
fl u
£ o o
o
K
300 200
100
10
0 10 20 30
Regeneration time, h
Fig.4. Dependency of SO2 concentration on regeneration time
1 - 500 °C; 2 - 650 °C; 3 - 800 °C
40
ê Andrei B. Lebedev, Vladimir A. Utkov, Akhded Abrakhim Khalifa
Sintered Sorbent Utilization fortbS Removal...
Fig.5. The graph of air cleaning from sulfur compounds in the granulation area 1 -granulated slag; 2 -gas trap; 3 - sintered sorbent; 4 - regeneration area
Spectrographic analysis of reaction products detected generation of troilite (FeS). Stoichiometric calculations point to generation of iron sulfide (Fe2S3) and pyrite (FeS2) as reaction products. Precise estimation of stoichiometry is impossible due to a variety of forms, in which iron sulfide can occur. Moreover, the reaction is complicated by the presence of other metallic oxides in the sorbent that can have a capacity to absorb H2S under conditions of the experiment.
Other possible ways of sulfur extraction from SO2 in the process of regeneration represent catalytic transition to SO3 with subsequent liberation of sulfuric acid or reaction between SO2 and a number of gases in the presence of a catalyst with liberation of elemental sulfur.
With the help of gas chromatographic analysis of inlet and flue gases (using sintered mixture of ash and iron oxide), the authors estimated whether reorganization of gas composition occurred and whether the formation of gaseous sulfur compounds took place that could not be detected by H2S titration. At the temperature of 200 °C water steam with a small concentration of methane (0.4 %) was detected.
Conclusion. All three materials have nearly fully recovered their absorbing characteristics after desorption. A sintered mixture of Fe2O3 (25 %) and ash (75 %) have been tested throughout nine cycles of regeneration with a full recovery of H2S absorbing capacity from the gas flow without visible decomposition of granules. The most efficient sorbent was red mud, which absorbs 18 % of sulfur at 200 °C and 45 % at 300 °C. Hence, it can be repeatedly used in the process of air cleaning in the granulation area.
H2S, present in the area of smelter slag granulation, can be removed from the residue of flue gases at temperatures 200-300 °C in a reaction with metallic oxides, such as Fe2O3. The optimal temperature, identified for sorbent regeneration, is 600-700 °C. However, the material must be included in the granulated porous structure from other metallic oxides to prevent dusting and decomposition of the sorbent grains. The study showed that such substance can be obtained by sintering red mud and be consequently used in the process of air cleaning in the area of blast furnace slag granulation.
REFERENCES
1. Glinskaya I.V., Gorbunov V.B., Podgorodetskii G.S., Teselkina A.E. Analytical Control of the Metallurgic Process of Red Mud Processing. Izvestiya vuzov. Chernaya metallurgiya. 2013. N 9, p. 25-29 (in Russian).
2. Arbuzov B.A., Isanova B.X., Belyakova M.O. Flue Gas Cleaning from Sulfur and Nitrogen Oxides at Power Plants. Lit'e i metallurgiya. 2009. N 3 (52), p. 99-103 (in Russian).
3. Bokovikova T.N., A.A.Nekrasova, N.M.Privalova Thermodynamic and Kinetic Sorption Characteristics of Heavy Metal Ions on a Modified Non-Organic Sorbent in the Sinks of Food Industry Plants. Izvestiya vuzov. Pishchevaya tekhnologiya. 2012. N 5-6, p. 85-89 (in Russian).
é Andrei B. Lebedev, Vladimir A. Utkov, Akhded Abrakhim Khalifa
Sintered Sorbent Utilization forH2S Removal...
4. Zainullin L.A., Sukhobaevskii Yu.Ya., Davydov A.A. The Application of Pre-Furnace Granulation in Non-Ferrous Metallurgy. Stal'. 2000. N 3, p. 18-20 (in Russian).
5. Kuznetsov Yu.M., Zainullin L.A. New Approach to the Preparation of Limestone Suspension for the Systems of Wet Gas Desulfurization. Stal'. 2005. N 3, p. 118-120 (in Russian).
6. Ladygichev M.G., Chizhikova B.M. Raw Materials in the Iron and Steel Industry: Manual. 2 volumes. Ecology of Maetal-lurgic Production. Moscow: Teploenergetik. 2002, p. 448 (in Russian).
7. Li T.S., Choi I.S., Son V.E. Technology of Ladle Slag Recycling. Chernye metally. 2004. N 5, p. 28-33 (in Russian).
8. Memoli F., Guzzon M. Furnace By-Products Recycling by Injection into Electric Arc Furnace - Experience and Prospects. Chernye metally. 2007. N 4, p. 26-33 (in Russian).
9. Mozharenko N.M., Paranosenkov A.A., Evglevskii V.S. Slag-Forming Role of Red Mud. Fundamental'nye i prikladnye problemy chernoi metallurgii. 2004. N 9, p. 61-66 (in Russian).
10. Pegova S.A., Soloboeva I.S. Environmentally Friendly Production: Approaches, Estimation, Recommendations. Ekaterinburg: IRA-UTK. 2000, p. 392 (in Russian).
11. Sovetkin V.L., Yaroshenko Yu.G., Karelov S.V., Kobernichenko V.G., Khodorovskaya I.Yu. Environmental Measures in Metallurgy. Ural'skii tekhnicheskii universitet. Ekaterinburg, 2004, p. 240 (in Russian).
12. Sennik A.I., Milyukov S.V., Proshkina O.B. H2S Emissions in the Process of External Granulation of Blast Furnace Slag. VestnikMGTU im. G.N.Nosova. 2008. N 3, p. 75-79 (in Russian).
13. Sorokin Yu.V., Demin B.L. Environmental and Technological Aspects of Steel-Smelting Slag Recycling. Chernaya metal-lurgiya. 2003. N 3, p. 75-79 (in Russian).
14. Toropov E.V., Makarov D.P. Complex Management of Energy- and Resource-Saving Activities of the Metallurgic Plant. Vestnik Ural'skogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta. 80 let Ural'skoi teploenergetike. Obrazovanie. Nauka: Sb. tr. Mezhdunar. nauch.-tekhn. konf. UGTU - UPI. Ekaterinburg, 2003, p. 258-261 (in Russian).
15. Shkol'nik Ya.Sh., Shakurov A.G., Mandel' M.Z. New Technology and Equipment for Molten Slag Processing. Metallurg. 2011. N 10, p. 58-60 (in Russian).
16. Zainullin L.A., Bychkov A.V., Chechenin G.I., Reutov V.N., Prokofeva L.P. Energy-Saving Technology of Blast Furnace Slag Recycling. Metallurgicheskaya teplotekhnika: Sb. nauch. tr. Natsional'naya metallurgicheskaya akademiya Ukrainy. Dnepropetrovsk, 2002. Vol. 7, p. 166-168 (in Russian).
17. Utkov V.A., Petrov S.I., Nikolaev S.A. et al. Economic and Environmental Potential of Alumina Production in the Processing of Slag Tailings. Sovershenstvovanie tekhnologicheskikh protsessov polucheniya glinozema: Sb. nauch. tr.; RUSAL VAMI. St. Petersburg, 2005, p. 146-154 (in Russian).
18. Yusfin Yu.S., Leont'ev L.I., Chernousov P.I. Industry and Environment. Moscow: Akademkniga. 2002, p. 469 (in Russian).
19. Alípio Júnior, Américo Borges, Ayana Oliveira. Using a Multivariate Statistical in the Indentification of Alumina Loss in Red Mud. Brasil. Light Metalls. 2013. N 2, p. 87-89.
Authors: Andrei B. Lebedev, Postgraduate Student, [email protected] (Saint-Petersburg Mining University, Saint-Petersburg, Russia), Vladimir A. Utkov, Doctor of Engineering Sciences, Professor, [email protected] (Saint-Petersburg Mining University, Saint-Petersburg, Russia), Akhded Abrakhim Khalifa, Postgraduate Student, [email protected] (Saint-Petersburg Mining University, Saint-Petersburg, Russia). The paper was received on 10 January, 2019. The paper was accepted for publication on 26 March, 2019.
