CC BY
0
SAYAT-NOVA'S OEUVRE IN THE LIGHT OF INTERPRETATION AND TRANSLATION BY V. BRYUSOV
This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
© 2024. Luiza A. Gasparyan, Zaruhi G. Hayryan
Abeghyan Institute of Literature of the RA National
Academy of Sciences,
Yerevan, Armenia
Received: March 27, 2023
Approved after reviewing: May 31, 2023
Date of publication: March 25, 2024
Studia Litterarum, vol. 9, no. 1, 2024
Abstract: Each national literature is a part of national history. It presents the features of the
national culture and the people who live and develop in specific cultural and traditional conditions. Each nation has its unique genius that sings the national beauty. Armenian ashug Sayat'-Nova's creativity has had a significant influence on Armenian literature. Sayat'-Nova, as a national poet, had created poetry with its genre subdivisions. We can consider such categories as spiritual, patriotic poetry, glamorous social poetry, and folk-gusan songs. The present research has been carried out along the lines of Sayat'-Nova's verbal creativity through the interpretive prism of theorists and literary critics with special reference to Valeri Brusov, who highlighted the exclusive richness of Sayat'-Nova's artistic devices, the peculiar features of his literary genre, style, and language. The article focused on the relevance of Russian-Armenian literary relations, which became particularly crucial with the publication of Valeri Brusov's anthology "Poetry of Armenia" in 1916. The outstanding Russian writer, critic, and translator has highly appreciated the exceptional richness of Armenian literature and interpreted each piece of verbal creativity with great accuracy. His opinion is that Sayat'-Nova name deserves to be a part of world literature. Armenian ashug has to stand next to the honored names and glorified works of Western literature. bywords: Russian-Armenian literary relations, Valeri Brusov, anthology "Poetry of Armenia,"
Sayat'-Nova, ashugh, Armenian literature, translation, critical interpretation. Information about the authors: Luiza A. Gasparyan, PhD in Philology, Researcher,
Abeghyan Institute of Literature of the RA National Academy of Sciences, 15 Grigor Lusavorich St., 0019 Yerevan, Armenia. ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6023-2861 E-mail: luisa.gasparyan83@gmail.com
Zaruhi G. Hayryan, PhD in Philology, Associate Professor, Abeghyan Institute of Literature of the RA National Academy of Sciences, 15 Grigor Lusavorich St., 0019 Yerevan, Armenia. ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7558-5889 E-mail: zara.hayryan@isec.am
For citation: Gasparyan, L.A., and Z.G. Hayryan. "Sayat-Nova's Oeuvre in the Light of
Interpretation and Translation by V. Bryusov." Studia Litterarum, vol. 9, no. 1, 2024, pp. 168-185. (In English) https://doi.org/10.22455/2500-4247-2024-9-1-168-185
ТВОРЧЕСТВО САЯТ-НОВЫ В СВЕТЕ ИНТЕРПРЕТАЦИИ И ПЕРЕВОДА В. БРЮСОВА
© 2024 г. Л.А. Гаспарян, З.Г. Айрян
Институт литературы им. М. Абегяна Национальной академии наук, Ереван, Армения Дата поступления статьи: 27 марта 2023 г. Дата одобрения рецензентами: 31 мая 2023 г. Дата публикации: 25 марта 2024 г. https://d0i.0rg/10.22455/2500-4247-2023-9-1-168-185
Аннотация: Каждая национальная литература является частью национальной истории. В ней представлены особенности национальной культуры и народа, жившего и развивавшегося в специфических культурно-традиционных условиях. У каждого народа есть свой гений, воспевший национальную красоту. Творчество армянского ашуга Саят-Нова оказало значительное влияние на армянскую литературу. Саят-Нова как народный поэт создал поэзию с ее жанровыми подразделениями. Мы можем рассматривать такие категории, как религиозно-патриотическая поэзия, гламурная социальная поэзия и народно-гусанские песни. Настоящее исследование проведено в русле словесного творчества Саят-Нова сквозь интерпретационную призму теоретиков и литературоведов с особым обращением к Валерию Брюсову, подчеркнувшему исключительное богатство художественных приемов Саят-Нова, особенности его литературного жанра, стиля и языка. В статье акцентируется внимание на актуальности русско-армянских литературных связей, которые приобрели особую остроту с изданием в 1916 г. сборника Валерия Брюсова «Поэзия Армении». Выдающийся русский писатель, критик и переводчик высоко оценил исключительное богатство армянской литературы и интерпретировал каждое произведение словесного творчества с большой точностью. По его мнению, имя Саят-Нова по праву должно войти в мировую литературу. Армянский ашуг должен стоять рядом с почитаемыми именами и прославленными произведениями западной литературы.
Ключевые слова: Российско-армянские литературные связи, Валерий Брюсов,
антология «Поэзия Армении», Саят-Нова, ашух, армянская литература, перевод, критическая интерпретация.
Информация об авторах: Луиза Ареговна Гаспарян — кандидат филологических наук, научный исследователь, Институт литературы им. М. Абегяна Национальной академии наук, ул. Григора Лусаворича, д. 15, 0019 г. Ереван, Армения. ORCID ID: https://0rcid.0rg/0000-0002-6023-2861
E-mail: luisa.gasparyan83@gmail.com
Заруи Геворковна Айрян — кандидат филологических наук, доцент, Институт литературы им. М. Абегяна Национальной академии наук, ул. Григора Лусаворича, д. 15, 0019 г. Ереван, Армения. ORCID ID: https://0rcid.0rg/0000-0002-7558-5889
E-mail: zara.hayryan@isec.am
Для цитирования: Гаспарян Л.А., Айрян З.Г. Творчество Саят-Новы в свете
интерпретации и перевода В. Брюсова // Studia Litterarum. 2024. Т. 9, № i. С. 168-185. https://d0i.0rg/10.22455/2500-4247-2024-9-1-168-185
Научная статья / Research Article
https://elibrary.ru/DAMRUI УДК 821.19.0 + 821.161.1.0 ББК 83.3(5Арм)5 + 83.3 (2Рос=Рус)6 + 83
Sayat'-Nova's creativity had significant and profound roots in Armenian literature [1], as well as its unique place in the cultural-traditional heritage, aesthetics, and literary values of world literature [2]. In this connection, Sayat'-Nova's life and creativity made a unique impact not only on the Armenian literary circles but also on Russian and Western experts of verbal creativity, who appreciated and evaluated the Armenian writer and initiated the translation of its best pieces of verbal creativity into Russian, English and other languages.
According to Russian theorists [3; 4; 5; 6; 7; 8] the parallel between the original and the translation can be established not only by conveying the form and the content but also by portraying the impressionistic feelings. Both the reader of the original and the reader of the translation should understand the internal implicit context of the work, its atmosphere, and spirit; in other words, the essence of the original and its impact on the reader's lifestyle. Consequently, the quality of translations should be judged not so much by the number of successfully equivalent transpositions of the original, but how the translators managed to achieve the unity of content and form, objective and subjective and to convey the gist of the utterance. Not less important is the lingo-cultural communication of people and their mutual relations in the spheres of art and literature.
Being a complex mental procedure, the translation process presupposes multifaceted strategies involving the linguistic and extra-linguistic awareness of the practitioner, profound contextual interpretative capacity and the possibility of interconnecting two cultures: the source culture and the target culture [9; 10; 11; 12].
The research aims to shed light on some aspects of V. Brusov's critical interpretations and translation mechanisms of the Armenian ashugh — Sayat'-No-
va's artistic lyrics, which took their honorable place in the anthology. Although many theorists discussed the essence of Sayat'-Nova's valuable artifacts, there is still a necessity to outline a special theoretical and practical framework in this sphere.
In this vein, the following objectives are set up:
• To underline the importance of Russian-Armenian cultural connections.
• To illustrate Sayat'-Nova's literary activity within the framework of Valeri Brusov's interpretation and draw parallels with other theorists.
• To analyze V. Brusov's translation mechanisms of culturally-marked units and expressions which will open new vistas for equivalent and adequate translation.
• To emphasize the relevance of Sayat'-Nova Studies in Armenian and World literary circles as a cultural heritage.
The comprehensive study of the fundamental principles and mechanisms of the art of literary interpretation and translation of Armenian literary works leads to the further development of the philological discipline, cross-cultural communication, philosophical literature, and literary relationships. The research materials were the Russian anthologies of Armenian poetry done by Russian Armenist, translator, and writer V. Brusov.
The research illustrates a detailed account of methodological treatment given to the data collected for the study, both in qualitative and quantitative terms. The qualitative research aims at revealing the extra-linguistic perspectives and factors of Sayat-Nova's era of activity and lifestyle: a particular social-political situation, historical events, communicative role or interaction by comparing, contrasting, cataloguing, and classifying the subject under study, seeking to comprehend the genre and epoch of the time. On the other hand, the quantitative method attempts to explain Sayat-Nova's artistic creativity by collecting data and analyzing it through the light of proficient experts' and theorists' interpretations. Consequently, it has a solid background for objective conclusion, which permits the researcher to predict outcomes.
Sayat-Nova
The Armenian literature of the I7th-i8th centuries was abundant with impeccable literary gems [13], the predominant of which was poetry with its genre
subdivisi0ns like: religi0us patri0tic p0etry, glam0r0us s0cial p0etry, and folk gusan s0ngs [i; 15; 16]. The main types 0f folk (gusan — qnLuufo) s0ngs were ashugh p0etry. Ashughs were c0mm0n pe0ple wh0 wr0te the lyrics for folk (gusan) s0ngs, c0mp0sed the music, and performed them in front 0f the public 0n fdk h0lidays, weddings, ashugh c0mpetiti0ns, etc. Ashugh p0etry was especially the befoved genre 0f the c0mm0n pe0ple, as it illustrated the human w0rldview and underlined the aesthetic taste 0f Armenian pe0ple. One 0f the fam0us Armenian ashughs 0f the time — Sayat'-N0va (Ill. i) lived in the 18th century and wrote his lyrics simultane0usly in three languages (Armenian, Ge0rgian, and Turkish), which reflected the p0et's humanism, c0sm0p0litan thinking, and artistic creativity. Sayat'-N0va was evaluated n0t 0nly in Armenian s0ciety, but als0 in Ge0rgia and the wh0le 0f Transcaucasus: he was ch0sen as the c0urt p0et 0f King Hera-clius II. Sayat'-N0va preserved the valuable s0ngs in his 0wn manuscript named Davtar (Ч-шЦршр), which n0wadays is kept in the Natfonal Museum 0f Literature and Art in Yerevan, Armenia [16; 17].
Illustration 1 — Sayat'-Nova: Rachya Ruhkyan, National Gallery of Armenia
Sayat'-Nova's poetic creativity was fundamental for the further development of the Armenian poetic genre, which organically combined the elements of folklore, church hymns, medieval Armenian songs, and folk-gusan lyrics, as well as the poetry of the Eastern people. Sayat'-Nova's poetry responded to the ques-
tions of both the intelligentsia and the common people and its sociopsychological, moral, and religious concerns. The characteristic feature of Sayat'-Nova songs is philanthropy. The theme of his songs revolved around love, its sweet sufferings, spiritual sensitivity, and passion. In his poetry woman had a divine image, high dignity, and an amazing charm and beauty (Ill. 2).
Illustration 2 — Grigor Sharbabchyan, National Gallery of Armenia
According to literary theorists, Sayat'-Nova embraced the scope of multilingual composition thus expanding the geographical area of Armenian ashugh fame from Constantinople to the Armenian Plateau, then to Tiflis, Isfahan, and its surrounding Armenian communities [16].
In Sayat'-Nova's poems, the feeling of love is associated with the sun, moon, stars, flowers, and precious stones, which contributes to a deeper manifestation of the poet's feelings. However, in his poems, the feeling of love is described not only in joyful colors and positive overtones, but there is a profound human suffering, sometimes with a vivid expression of sorrow and anxiety (Ill. 3).
Naturally, Sayat'-Nova's touching songs were translated in different languages and one of the first translations was done in 1851, when Iakov Polonskii with the help and assistance of Georg Akhverdyan translated some of ashugh's songs into Russian.
The most famous Russian translator of Sayat'-Nova's melodious songs was undoubtedly Valeri Brusov (Ill. 4). In his valuable and comprehensive anthology Armenian Poetry from the Most Ancient Time to Our Days published in Moscow, 1916, V. Brusov illustrated Sayat'-Nova's artistic creativity and translated twelve songs [18; 19].
Illustration 3 — Eduard Isabekyan, 1964; Armenia
Illustration 4 — Portrait of V.Ya. Brusov: S.V. Malyutin, 1913; State Literary Museum, Moscow
In the c0nstellati0n 0f Armenian ashugs, Sayat-N0va, a p0et 0f the 18th century 0ccupied its unique place. V. Brus0v evaluated him as majestic and diverse, sensitive in Tyutchev's way, passi0nate as Musset. Russian the0rist and p0et c0nsidered Sayat'-N0va as 0ne 0f th0se "first-class" p0ets wh0, by the p0wer 0f their genius, ceased t0 be the property 0f a separate nati0n, but became the fav0rite 0f all nati0ns. The name of Sayat'-N0va can rightfully stand next t0 the h0n0red names and gl0rified creati0ns 0f Western literatures [20] (Ill. 5).
Illustrati0n 5 — Editi0n 0f 1916, P0etry 0f Armenia, V.Ya. Brus0v
Sayat'-Nova is the pseudonym of the poet. The father sent his little son to study the craft of a weaver, but from an early age the boy dreamed of becoming an ashugh: in his free time, he admired and listened to singers' competitions and learned to play different musical instruments, as kamancha, chongur and tar.
For some time, like his famous ancestor Nagharsh Hovnatan, Sayat-Nova served in the palace of King Heraclius II of Georgia. Later, he left a brilliant life at court and entered the monastery, took the holy orders, and became a married parish priest of Surb Nishana, in Agbad. This decision had multiple interpretations among historians and literary critics, still all the evidence came to prove that the event was associated with the poet's connection with the church and his faith in Christianity.
But even behind the monastery walls, Father Stepanos (Sayat-Nova) continued to write his melodic poetry and was inspired by public ashugh competitions. There is even a widespread assumption that he sometimes dressed in the
clothes of ashugh, secretly left the monastery, made his way towards Tiflis, and transferred his unique masterpieces to the people.
One cannot but observe that Sayat'-Nova's songs sometimes illustrate autobiographical nuances and one of the most striking examples is ashugh's reference to his parents and nationality: like in the songs number 65 and 69 [21]. The songs shed light on Sayat'-Nova's nationality and parents' origin by emphasizing that his native place was Tiflis (Georgia), his mother was from Havlabar (Armenian Havlabar), which even nowadays is the name of the major Armenian residential area in Tiflis and his father was from Aleppo, his religion is Christianity and he is Armenian.
Sayat'-Nova was in Tiflis on the day when the city was besieged by Persians. He, together with a crowd of people, prayed on his knees in the temple. The Persians demanded that everyone leave the church and convert the religion, but Sayat'-Nova answered with one verse which was illustrated both by V. Brusov and Ch. Dowsett, like:
Изъ храма, нптъ! не выйду я, не отрекусь я отъ Христа! [22]
I shall not leave the Church!
I shall not turn away from Jesus! [23]
A thorough analysis of Sayat'-Nova's songs reveals also some biblical allusions and quotations and interestingly these Christian allusions are not illustrated only in the Armenian language. Hence, in th no. 84 song Sayat'-Nova utters: Whoever does not say "Jesus is God"/Even if his tongue gets tied, he would not repent.
He was martyred and a marble monument was erected in this place, on which the dates of Sayat'-Nova's birth and death are carved.
Sayat'-Nova's Songs Translation
One cannot but observe that historical and cultural relations between people are multi-layered, full of fascinating events, and abundant with valuable historical and philological materials. In this connection, the process of translation is pivotal for bridging the gap between cultures and traditions. Any piece of verbal creativity is culture-oriented, which intertwines the identity of the nation, its spiritual values, and cognitive procedures. Of course, translation plays a key role in
popularization of the nation's literary treasury and Sayat'-Nova's melodic songs are no exception. One of the prominent Russian translations of Sayat'-Nova's songs is the great Russian poet of the i9th-20th centuries V. Brusov's translations, which were reflected in a unique anthology of Poetry of Armenia thus initiating the dynamic cultural relations between Russia and Armenia. Thanks to laborious and faithful work and of utmost devotion V. Brusov comprehensively and objectively illustrated Armenian poetry of all times to the Russian-speaking audience, which was highly appreciated by literary critics, poets, and aristocracy.
It was M. Gorki who recommended V. Brusov for originating and supervising the committee for translation of the Armenian poetry, as V. Brusov's translations were highly appreciated and famous in Russian society. He translated the works of Virgil, Dante, O. Wilde, and other classics.
By observing the Russian translations of Sayat'-Nova's songs, one cannot but feel the style and language of genius, who transmitted Sayat'-Nova's beautiful songs with the utmost care and accuracy. Let's introduce a couple of fragments of the original and Russian translation.
The first is the extract from the poem "I Will not Let Out a Sigh in My Life":
IhqnLm 2Ш£шр, ^nn2QS qmbrç, U^nbfQm иШр£р|"1т ш|_ЦШи t Ou^nL Jb^Qb фЪш шршЬ, ш^|^рQm Ц^Ъш^шщ рши t: ^шт^ш^шЪ шЪфЪ рш^ш^р,
Язык твой — сахар, мед — уста; а зубы — жемчуг и алмаз; Твой взор, — эмалевый сосуд, где
жемчуг, изумруд, топаз. Ты — бриллиант! Бесценный лал Индийских стран ты для меня!.. (song i)
The second fragment is from the poem "Kamancha":
UJbb umq^ Jb^Qb qni^mb qnLb ршЦш^ тшиЬ |iu,
Ъш£шq Цшрр f|iq ^шЬш mbub|i, qnLb bQpш щшиЬ |iu, £шЦшЪ^ш Т.шит шрш' t|_ [ш^ opbpnLb tq|n4Qb 1"1шиЪ|-|и £шЦшЪ^ш.
Из всех людьми хваленных лир полней звучишь ты, каманча!
Кто низок, не иди на пир: пред ним молчишь ты, каманча!
Но к высшему стремись: весь мир всех покоришь ты, каманча!
The comparative analysis of the original and translations has shown the dialectical unity of the usage of domestication and foreignization mechanisms to provide both the scientific and aesthetic approach to the utterance abundant with rhythmic organization, poetic image and cultural-traditional atmosphere. In the first extract Brusov preserved the rhythmical form and the poetic meaning of the song, where Sayat'-Nova elegantly compared the inner and outer beauty of his beloved woman: her manners and speech with sugar and honey, the teeth with pearl and brilliant, her gaze is like a unique jar decorated with precious stones from India. Though Sayat'-Nova's songs predominantly devoted to the description of his beloved's physical beauty and appearance, elegance, etc., he praised the worldwide concept of "beauty" and "aesthetics."
The Russian translation of the second song differs from its special rhythm flavoured with repetition of the transliterated culturally-marked unit — kaman-cha, the musical instrument.
Admiring the lyrics of the poet, Valeri Brusov emphasized that Sayat'-Nova managed to illustrate an inexhaustible variety of overtones in his songs. Almost everywhere the poet speaks about love, but how colorful its shades are in various poems, all these transitions from quiet tenderness to fiery passion, from despair to delight, from self-doubt to the proud self-awareness of the artist. Truly, Sayat-Nova can be called a "poet of shades." At the same time, how sharp, deep and juicy are the shades of Sayat'-Nova's songs flavoured with sweet charm and
painted with a thin and delicate brush [20].
Lexical b0rr0wings 0f the 0riginal entered the Russian verse by transliter-ati0n, thereby emphasizing the nati0nal identity 0f the 0riginal. T0 repr0duce the rich rhyming 0f ashugh s0ngs, their charming mel0di0usness, V. Brus0v ch0se the m0st significant, s0n0r0us w0rds, like guiJufo^ui — каманча, Ъшршр — набать, unLuuiJpuip — сусамбарь, s0 0n.
It is w0rth menti0ning that Sayat'-N0va's s0ngs are abundant with cr0ss-traditi0nal intertextuality, with special reference t0 Eastern historical characters, legendary images, etc. F0r example:
Привптъ! ведь ты сильна, какъ тотъ Ростомъ, сынъ Зала! — дочь царя?
Or an0ther fragment:
Съ чьмъ, милая, сравню тебя? — Все, все исчерпано давно.
Конь-Рашъ изъ огненныхъ зыбей, степная лань ты для меня! [23]
In this c0nnecti0n it is piv0tal t0 underline a British Armenist Charles D0wsett's achievements in Sayat'-N0va Studies (Sayat'-Nova: An i8th-centu-ry Troubadour, a Bi0graphical and Literary Study, by Charles D0wsett, Corpus Scriptorum Christianorum Orientalium, v0l. 561) wh0se c0mprehensive scientific study is en0rm0us. Embarking int0 lab0ri0us research 0n d0cumentary facts, Ch. D0wsett carried 0ut the profound hist0rical-phifofogical survey in the field and translated s0me Sayat'-N0va's s0ngs. Due t0 the linguist's survey Sayat'-N0-va's s0ngs, illustrated in three languages, are like "cultural schiz0phrenia," but n0t in a path0l0gical nature [23]. In 0ther w0rds, the s0ngs are the miniature picture 0f the Caucasus lifestyle flav0ured with culturally-marked units. F0r examples:
I am the jewel, worthy of a king's crown.
Like Shirin, I am the beloved of Ferhad.
From the very first I am the beloved of Sayat-Nova.
What you say is a different remedy [23].
Even the emperor (of Persia) did not arrange for Rustam son of Zal Such a betrothal and wedding for his own daughter, page 79.
In the first fragment, Sayat'-Nova illustrated the traditional folk story circle about "Khosrov and Shirin" and "Fehrad and Shirin." It was historian Sebeos, who first introduced faithful information about the Persian king Khosrov and his beautiful Armenian wife Shirin, a devoted Christian queen. If the history of Khosrov and Shirin is based on more historical and factual material, then Ferhad and Shirin's narrative has a folk oral tradition. Undoubtedly, the plot of the tragic love always attracts the reader's attention. Legends and many conversations have been woven about Fehrad and Shirin, which have bright and colorful nuances and overtones. In the passage, Sayat'-Nova made a parallel between his and Ferhad's love afflictions and unhappy ending. Alongside with analytical-literary interpretations, Ch. Dowsett translated some extracts from Sayat'-Nova's songs. On the one hand, the translator focuses on faithful translation procedures, on the other hand, he employs the method of domestication to make the ashugh's message more accessible to the reader and to maintain the naturalness of the translation, in a language perceptible to the English-speaking reader.
The intertextuality was organically introduced into the creative culture of the troubadour, giving a unique shine and charm, revealing the eternal fire of Sayat'-Nova's love. Intertextuality transfers original impulses to the context, revealing the creator's allegorical, inward message.
With great hope for the Armenian future prosperity and development, Brusov wrote his famous poems and creative works, like «К Армении» (1915) (Towards Armenia), «К армяном» (1916) (Towards Armenians), «Тигран Великий» (Tigran the Great), etc., where he praised the endurance, the will and the courage of the Armenian people despite the tragedy and cataclysmic periods in the history and soon the Armenians would overcome the disaster with the act of bravery.
Что бурю вновь преодолев Звездой ты выйдешь из тумана
Для новых подвигов созрев.
«К армяням» (1916)
V. Brusov's lectures on Armenian Literature and Studies were essential for enhancing Russian-Armenian cultural, social, and political relations. He had warm connections with Armenian literary society and intelligentsia in Trans-
caucasia. He got acquainted with various Armenian authors, mainly Hovhannes Hovhannisyan, Felix Bakhchinyan, Alexander Shirvanzade, Srbuhi Lisitsyan, Derenik Demirchyan, and others.
Results and Discussion
One cannot fail to observe that Armenia is perceived as a quintessential bridge between East and West not only in the socio-cultural sphere, but also in historical and geopolitical order. Naturally the i8th-century Armenian ashugh Sayat'-Nova's artistic creativity embodies the whole palette of lingo-cultural peculiarities. Even nowadays the interpretation of Sayat'-Nova's style and language, rhythmical music genre, and his manner of musical instruments [24; 25] performance is on the agenda of literary and musical critics. In this vein, Sayat'-Nova's impeccable lyrics composed of different languages prove the unprecedented phenomenon — the universal singularity of his talent in creating rhythmic poetry gems and melodious music.
Dwelling upon further observation that the theorists do not doubt that Sayat'-Nova was not an average Provencal troubadour since he was an in-depth intellectual with elevated literary language and style. That was the reason that his masterpieces were close to an elite, well-educated readership and intelligentsia. Nowadays, his creative art and emotional melody are highly evaluated and quoted in different occasions [26].
The Armenian ashugh poetry reached its Golden Age thanks to Sayat-Nova, who had the power of penetrating the human souls through moral-philosophical and high humanitarian ideas. This fact was not neglected by Russian famous writer Valeri Brusov. His creation of The Armenian Poetry anthology accompanied with comprehensive critical analysis and the translation of Armenian poets, including Sayat'-Nova's lyrics, was a gigantic literary treasure. The anthology deepened and strengthened the intercultural relations between Russia and Armenia in the field of popularization and dissemination of Armenian and naturally Sayat'-Nova's literary heritage.
The analysis of Sayat'-Nova's poetry texture revealed the complex inter-twinement of rhetorical, philosophical, and religious utterances flavored with unique language forms, stylistic devices and melodic overtones which make it difficult and challenging for translators. Researchers underlined that translation is an indispensible part of literary criticism [27; 28]. Embarked into the laborious
procedure 0f translati0n V. Brus0v pr0ved his exclusivity in this field and illustrated pr0ficient and unrepeatable mechanisms.
Conclusions
Hence the present miniature study leads t0 the foll0wing c0nclusi0n:
• Sayat'-N0va's artistic creativity is highly evaluated by Russian and Western literary critics and is c0nsidered an indispensable part 0f w0rld literature and aesthetics. Armenian literature attained significant achievements due t0 Valeri Brus0v's Russian translati0ns and literary evaluati0ns which initiated the pr0cess 0f strengthening and enriching Russian-Armenian relati0nships.
• Sayat'-N0va's p0etry passed the r0ute 0f "Renascence" through Valeri Brus0v's translati0ns thus creating the dignified "afterlife" 0f ashugh's verbal creativity.
• Sayat'-N0va's talent was excepti0nal as he created his s0ngs in three different languages befonging t0 different families: Armenian — Ind0-European, Ge0rgian — Kartvelian, and Turkish — Turkic. His s0ngs remain as literary artifacts c0ndensed with spirituality and wisd0m and still need t0 be 0n the agenda 0f the0rists and experts.
• Sayat'-N0va's s0ngs are abundant with ethn0graphic realia referring t0 art and music, intertextuality, c0nn0tati0ns, stylistic devices and rhythmical 0vert0nes, biblical and literary allusi0ns which und0ubtedly represent the cul-tural-traditi0nal richness 0f the time. In this vein, V. Brus0v proficiently created the dialectical unity 0f the translati0nal mechanisms — l0cal and f0reign — t0 illustrate Sayat'-N0va's excepti0nal literary heritage.
Список литературы Исследования
1 Айрян З, Иванян Е. Стихотворение Г. Алишана «Раздан»: поливариантность смыслов, интерпретаций, переводов // Научный диалог. 2020. № 12. С. 133-150. https://d0i.0rg/10.24224/2227-1295-2020-12-133-150
2 Алексеева И. Введение в переводоведение. М.: Академия, 2018. 352 с.
3 Алимов В.В. Теория перевода: Пособие для лингвистов-переводчиков. М.: Ленанд, 2021. 240 с.
4 Жаткин Д. Художественный перевод и сравнительное литературоведение. М.: Флинта, 2019. 656 с.
5 Казакова Т. Практикум по художественному переводу. М.: Лань, 2016. 180 с.
6 Кашкин И. Для читателя-современника. М.: Сов. писатель, 1988. 560 с.
7 Комиссаров В. Теория перевода (Лингвистические аспекты). М.: Высшая школа, 1990. 248 с.
8 Лилова А. Введение в общую теорию перевода. М.: Высшая школа, 2020. 255 с.
9 Лотман Ю. Анализ поэтического текста. Л.: Просвещение, 2019. 271 с.
10 Мкртчян Л. Саят-Нова в переводах В.Я. Брюсова. Ереван: Айастан, 1964. 420 с.
11 НелюбинЛ., Хухуни Г. История и теория перевода в России. М.: Изд-во МГУ, 2018. 139 с.
12 Поэзия Армении с древнейших времен до наших дней — в переводах русских поэтов / под ред. В. Брюсова. Ереван: Айастан, 2016. 500 с.
13 Поэзия Армении с древнейших времен и до наших дней / под ред. В.Я. Брюсова. М.: Изд. Армянского комитета, 1916. 524 с.
14 Сдобников В., Петрова О. Теория перевода. М.: Восток-Запад, 2016. 448 с.
15 Тарковский А.А. Звезды над Арагацем. Ереван: Советакан грох, 1988. 236 с.
16 Топер П. Перевод в системе сравнительного литературоведения. М.: Наследие, 2020. 252 с.
17 Федоров А. Основы общей теории перевода. М.: Высшая школа, 1983. 412 с.
18 Asatryan A., Harutyunyan H., Khachatryan D. Armenian Ashugh Art of the 18th century // International Journal of Innovative Technologies in Social Science. 2021. Vol. 4, № 32. P. 1-3. DOI: i0.3i435/rsglobal_ijitss/30i2202i/7732
19 Bakhchinyan F. Armenia in Eduardas Mezhelaitis' Poetry // Review of Armenian Studies. 2020. № 1. P. 176-191.
20 Dowsett Ch. Sayat'-Nova: An 18th-century Troubadour: a Biographical and Literary Study. Louvain: Peeters, 1997. 507 p.
21 Dum-Tragut J. Armenian: Modern Eastern Armenian. London: John Benjamins Publ., 2009. 742 p.
22 Hashemipour S. Archetypal Heroes of The Epic of Kings and The Epic of Gilgamesh: Rostam and Gilgamesh are Mirroring Myths // International Journal of Linguistics, Literature and Translation. 2019. Vol. 2, № 3. P. 6-11. DOI: i0.32996/ijllt.20i9.2.3.2
23 Hovanessian M. Les récits de nos vies atteintes: une histoire arménienne inconcevable. Paris: L'Harmattan, 20i3. 308 p.
24 Levonyan G. Hay asuiner. Alexandrapol: Hratarakut'iwn "Sirak" Gravacaranoc'i, Tparan Georg S. Sanoyeanc'i, i892. i42 p.
25 Levonyan G.J. Ashughnery yev nranc arvesty. Yerevan: Haypethrat, i944. i3 p.
26 Lint T.M.V. The gift of poetry: Khidr and John the Baptist as patron saints of Muslim and Armenian'asiqs-asuls // Van Ginkel J.J., Murre-van den Berg H.L., Van Lint T.M. (eds.). Redefining Christian Identity. Cultural Interaction in the Middle East since the Rise of Islam. Leuven; Paris; Dudley: Peeters, 2005. P. 335-378.
27 Navratil B. Music in poetry and poetry in music: Tumanian's "Anush": PhD Dissertation. New York, 2015. 177 p.
28 YangX. Sayat'-Nova: Within the Near Eastern Bardic Tradition and Posthumous: PhD Dissertation. Los Angeles, 2016. 287 p.
Источники
29 Абулова Е.А. Великий песенный дар Саят-Новы // Вестник Пятигорского государственного лингвистического университета. 2014. № 1, Ч. 1. С. 111-117.
30 Henrik B. Sayat'-Nova: khakher. Yerevan: Yerevan State University, 1987. 241 p.
31 Sevak РЛ. Sayat'-Nova. Yerevan: Haykakan SSH GA Hrat, 1969. 183 p.
References
1 Airian, Z., and E. Ivanian. "Stikhotvorenie G. Alishana 'Razdan': polivariantnost' smys-lov, interpretatsii, perevodov" ["G. Alishan's Poem 'Hrazdan': Polyvariety of Meanings, Interpretations, Translations"]. Nauchnyidialog, no. 12, 2020, pp. 133-150. https://doi.org/10.24224/2227-1295-2020-12-133-150 (In Russ.)
2 Alekseeva, I. Vvedenie vperevodovedenie [Introduction to Translation Studies]. Moscow, Akademiia Publ., 2018. 352 p. (In Russ.)
3 Alimov, V.V. Teoriiaperevoda: Posobie dlia lingvistov-perevodchikov [Translation Theory: A GuideforLinguists-Translators]. Moscow, Lenand Publ., 2021. 240 p. (In Russ.)
4 Zhatkin, D. Khudozhestvennyiperevodi sravnitel'noe literaturovedenie [Literary Translation and Comparative Literary Studies]. Moscow, Flinta Publ., 2019. 656 p. (In Russ.)
5 Kazakova, T. Praktikum po khudozhestvennomu perevodu [Manual of the Literary Translate]. Moscow, Lan' Publ., 2016. 180 p. (In Russ.)
6 Kashkin, I. Dlia chitatelia-sovremennika [For the Contemporary Reader]. Moscow, Sovetskii pisatel' Publ., 1988. 560 p. (In Russ.)
7 Komissarov, V. Teoriia perevoda (Lingvisticheskie aspekty) [Translation Theory (Linguistic Aspects)]. Moscow, Vysshaia Shkola Publ., 1990. 248 p. (In Russ.)
8 Lilova, A. Vvedenie v obshchuiu teoriiuperevoda [Introduction to the General Theory of Translation]. Moscow, Vysshaia shkola Publ., 2020. 255 p. (In Russ.)
9 Lotman, Iu. Analiz poeticheskogo teksta [The Analysis of the Poetic Text]. St. Petersburg, Prosveshchenie Publ., 2019. 271 p. (In Russ.)
10 Mkrtchian, L. Saiat-Nova v perevodakh V.la. Briusova [Sayat-Nova Translated by V.Ya. Brusov]. Erevan, Aiastan Publ., 1964. 420 p. (In Russ.)
11 Neliubin, L., and G. Khukhuni. Istoriia i teoriia perevoda v Rossii [History and Theory of Translation in Russia]. Moscow, Moscow State University Publ., 2018. 139 p.
(In Russ.)
12 Briusov, V., editor. Poeziia Armenii s drevneishikh vremen do nashikh dnei — vperevo-dakh russkikh poetov [Armenian Poetry from Ancient Times to the Present Day — in the Translation of the Russian Poets]. Erevan, Aiastan Publ., 20i6. 500 p. (In Russ.)
13 Briusov, V., editor. Poieziia Armenii s drevneishikh vremen i do nashikh dnei [Armenian Poetry from Ancient Times to the Present Day]. Мoscow, Izdatel'stvo Armianskogo komiteta Publ., i9i6. 524 p. (In Russ.)
14 Sdobnikov, V., and O. Petrova. Teoriiaperevoda [Translation Theory]. Мoscow, Vostok-Zapad Publ., 20i6. 448 p. (In Russ.)
15 Tarkovskii, A. Zvezdy nad Aragatsem [Stars over the Aragats]. Erevan, Sovetakan grokh Publ., i988. 236 p. (In Russ.)
16 Toper, P. Perevod v sisteme sravnitel'nogo literaturovedeniia [Translation in the System of Comparative Literary Studies]. Мoscow, Nasledie Publ., 2020. 252 p. (In Russ.)
17 Fedorov, A. Osnovy obshchei teoriiperevoda [The Basics of the General Translation Theory]. Мoscow, Vysshaia Shkola Publ., ^83. 4i2 p. (In Russ.)
18 Asatryan, A., H. Harutyunyan, and D. Khachatryan. "Armenian Ashugh Art of the i8th Century." International Journal of Innovative Technologies in Social Science, vol. 4, no. 32, 202i, pp. i-3. DOI: i0.3i435/rsglobal_ijitss/30i2202i/7732 (In English)
19 Bakhchinyan, Felix. "Armenia in Eduardas Mezhelaitis' Poetry." Review of Armenian Studies, no. i, 2020, pp. i76-i9i. (In English)
20 Dowsett, Charles. Sayat '-Nova: An i8th-Century Troubadour: A Biographical and Literary Study, vol. 56i. Louvain, Peeters Publ., i997. 507 p. (In English)
21 Dum-Tragut, Jasmine. Armenian: Modern Eastern Armenian. London, John Benjamins Publ., 2009. 742 p. (In English)
22 Hashemipour, Saman. "Archetypal Heroes of The Epic of Kings and The Epic of Gil-gamesh: Rostam and Gilgamesh are Mirroring Myths." International Journal of Linguistics, Literature and Translation, vol. 2 (3), 20i9, pp. 6-ii. (In English)
23 Hovanessian, Martine. Les récits de nos vies atteintes: une histoire arménienne inconcevable. Paris, L'Harmattan, 20i3. 308 p.
24 Levonyan, Garegin. Hay asulner. Alexandrapol, Hratarakut'iwn "Sirak" Gravacaranoc'i, Tparan Georg S. Sanoyeanc'i, i892. i42 p. (In Armenian)
25 Levonyan, Garegin J. Ashughnery yev nranc arvesty. Yerevan, Haypethrat, i944. i3 p. (In Armenian)
26 Lint, Theo Maarten van. "The Gift of Poetry: Khidr and John the Baptist as Patron Saints of Muslim and Armenian'asiqs-asuls." Van Ginkel, Jan Jacob, Hendrika Lena Murre-van den Berg, and Theo Maarten Van Lint, editors. Redefining Christian Identity. Cultural Interaction in the Middle East since the Rise of Islam. Leuven, Paris, Dudley, Peeters, 2005, pp. 335-378. (In English)
27 Navratil, Beata. Music in Poetry and Poetry in Music: Tumanian's "Anush": PhD Dissertation. New York, 20i5. i77 p. (In English)
28 Yang, Xi. Sayat'-Nova: Within the Near Eastern Bardic Tradition and Posthumous: PhD Dissertation. Los Angeles, 20i6. 287 p. (In English)
