CC BY
24
ОРИГИНАЛЬНАЯ СТАТЬЯ
УДК 616.31-083-053.2 МРНТИ 76.29.55
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CHILDREN'S DENTAL HEALTH AND PARENTAL
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT ORAL HYGIENE
A. OMARGALI1, R. URAZ1, P. CAMPBELL2
'West Kazakhstan Marat Ospanov Medical University, Aktobe, Kazakhstan 2Heidelberg Institute of Public Health (HIPH), Heidelberg, Germany
Azamat Omargali - https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7341-5325 Raisa Uraz - https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6620-4490
Information about authors/ авторлар туралы аппарат/ информация об авторах: Omargali A. - master, assistant of the Department of Dentistry internship and postgraduate education of WKMOMU;
Uraz R. - c.m.s., associate professor of WKMOMU;
Campbell P. - MBBS MSc, lecturer, Heidelberg Institute of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine.
Citation/
библиографиялыщ сттеме/ библиографическая ссылка:
A. Omargali, R. Uraz, P. Campbell Relationship between children's dental health and parental knowledge about oral hygiene
West Kazakhstan Medical journal 2019;61(1):65-70.
вмарFали Азамат, Ураз Раиса, Кэмпбелл Питер
Балалардын ауыз ^уысынын, сауль^ы мен ата-анасынын ауыз ^уысынын, гигиенасы жайындаFы бшштшпжн арасындаFы байланысы West Kazakhstan Medical journal 2019;61(1):65-70.
Омаргали Азамат, Ураз Раиса, Кэмпбелл Питер
Взаимосвязь между здоровьем зубов у детей и родительскими знаниями по гигиене полости рта West Kazakhstan Medical journal 2019;61(1):65-70.
Relationship between children's dental health and parental knowledge about oral hygiene
A. Omargali1, R. Uraz1, P. Campbell2
1.West Kazakhstan Marat Ospanov Medical University, Aktobe, Kazakhstan;
2. Heidelberg Institute of Public Health (HIPH), Heidelberg, Germany
Purpose. The purpose of the recent study conducted in Aktobe City Children's Dental Clinic, Kazakhstan is to investigate association between level of parental knowledge about oral hygiene and dental caries prevalence of their children.
Methods. Mixed method was used. Overall, 164 parents were interviewed by questionnaires to ascertain their knowledge and practice of oral hygiene care, their children were examined for evidence of caries, and the results were compared.
Results. 98% children attending the clinic had dental caries with a severity index score (DMFT index) of 5.5. From the parents' statements it was found that 28% of their children brush their teeth only once a day (in contrast to the international recommendations for twice a day) and these children have a higher prevalence rates of caries. In addition, 12% of children were stated to brush their teeth for 1 minute each time (in contrast to the international recommendations for 2-3 minutes) and these children also showed a trend towards a higher prevalence of caries. 3.7% parents do not believe that oral health is associated with diet and 38.4 % parents do not know about this.
Conclusion. These results highlight the need to make further efforts to educate parents on international standards for oral hygiene.
Keywords: children, parents, caries, knowledge, teeth, diet, hygiene.
Балалардын ауыз куысыньщ саульны мен ата-анасынын ауыз куысыньщ гигиенасы жайындаFы бШктши'шщ арасындаFы байланысы
А. вмаргали', Р. Ураз1, П. Кэмпбедд2
'Батыс ^азакстан Марат Оспанов атындагы медицина университета, Актебе, ^азакстан
2Гейдельберг кргамдьщ денсаульщ сактау институты (HIPH), Гейдельберг, Германия
Мацсаттары. А;тебе каласындагы балаларга арналган Стоматологиялык клиникада журпзшген сощы зерттеудщ максаты - ата-аналардыц ауыз куысыныц гигиенасы жайында бЫмдершщ децгеш мен олардыц балаларыныц стоматологиялык кариесшщ таралуы туралы аныктау.
Эдктерь Аралас эдю колданылды. Жалпы алганда, 164 ата-ана ауыз куысыныц гигиенасы туралы бiлiмi мен тэжiрибесш аныктау ушш сауалнама журпзд^ ал олардыц балалары кариес туралы куэлжгерге тексергвд жэне нэтижелер салыстырылды.
Нэтижелерi. Тртастай алганда, клиникага баратын балалардыц 98% -ында 5,5-тен ауырлык индексi бар диагноз койылды (DMFT индексi). Ата-аналардыц мэлiмдемесiнде балалардыц 28% -ы тэултне бiр рет кунгне бiр рет (тек KYнiне екi рет халыкаралык ^сыныстардан айырмашылыгы бар) тiстерiн тазартады
¿ЯЪк Omargali A. f4—"j e-mail: omargaliazamat@ gmail.com Received/ Kелiп tyctí/ Поступила: 04.02.2019 Accepted/ Басылымра к,абылданды/ Принята к публикации: 01.03.2019 ISSN 1814-5620 (Print) © 2019 The Authors Published by West Kazakhstan Marat Ospanov Medical University
А. Омаргали, Р. Ураз, П. Кэмпбелл
жэне б^л балалар кариесшщ таралу ;арк;ыны жогары болган. Сонымен ;атар, балалардыц 12% -ы эрб1р минутына 1 минуткд тю щеткаларын (2-3 минут;а дейн халыкаралы; ^сынымдардан айырмашылыгы бар) тазалап, б^л балалар кариесшщ таралуыныц жогары Yрдiсiн керсетп. А;ырында, ауызша денсаулыгыныц диетамен байланысты екенш страды, ата-аналардыц 3,7% -ы сенбедi жэне 38,4% -ы бiлмейтiнiн айтты.
Е^орытынды. Б^л нэтижелер ауыз куысыньщ гигиенасына арналган халыкаралы; стандарттар непздерше ата-аналарды тэрбиелеу бойынша одан эрi KYШ-жiгер ж^мсау ;ажетпгш керсетедi.
Негiзгi свздер: балалар, ата-аналар, тiсжегi, бтм, тктер, диета, гигиена.
Взаимосвязь между здоровьем зубов у детей и родительскими знаниями по гигиене полости рта
А. Омаргали1, Р. Ураз1, П. Кэмпбелл2
■Западно-Казахстанский медицинский университет имени Марата Оспанова, Актобе, Казахстан
2Институт общественного здравоохранения Гейдельберга (Н1РН), Гейдельберг, Германия
Целью данного исследования, проведенного в Актюбинской городской детской стоматологической поликлинике, было изучение взаимосвязи между уровнем знаний родителей о гигиене полости рта и распространенностью кариеса зубов у их детей.
Методы. В данном исследовании был использован смешанный метод. В целом, 164 родителей были опрошены с помощью анкет для выяснения их знаний и практики гигиены полости рта, а их дети обследованы на наличие признаков кариеса, позже полученные результаты были сопоставлены.
Результаты. У 98% детей, которые посещают стоматолога, был кариес с индексом тяжести (индекс DMFT) 5,5. Из заявлений родителей было установлено, что 28% детей чистят зубы только один раз в день (в отличие от международных рекомендаций до двух раз в день), и эти дети имеют более высокий уровень распространенности кариеса. Кроме того, было заявлено, что 12% детей чистят зубы каждый раз в течение 1 минуты (в отличие от международных рекомендаций в течение 2-3 минут), и у них также наблюдается тенденция к более высокой распространенности кариеса. На вопрос связано ли здоровье полости рта с диетой, 3,7% родителей ответили - не связно, а 38,4% -не смогли дать ответ на данный вопрос.
Заключение. Эти результаты подчеркивают необходимость прилагать дальнейшие усилия по обучению родителей основам международных стандартов гигиены полости рта.
Ключевые слова: дети, родители, кариес, зубы, диета, гигиена.
Introduction
The most common oral diseases among children are gingivitis and dental caries. The latter affects 60-90% of children globally [1]. The prevention of childhood dental caries mainly relies on adherence to key behavioural messages, including twice daily tooth brushing for 2-3 minutes, using a soft toothbrush of age-appropriate size from an early age with fluoride toothpaste [2] and reducing the frequency of consuming sugary foods and drinks [3].
Nevertheless, awareness about these simple principles are not enough and require more complex efforts which are largely determined by a broad scope of psychosocial, economic and environmental factors [4]. A child's family plays an influential role in forming the perception to oral hygiene. Oral health knowledge, behaviour and beliefs that children gain in the family will follow them their entire lives. Early on, delivering correct information
on oral hygiene prevents oral diseases [5]. Therefore, parental knowledge and skills about oral hygiene can be a reliable indicator of child dental caries development and increasing their awareness should lead to an improvement in the oral health status of their children.
The high prevalence of caries among the population is due to neglect and leads to severe complications including, eventually, loss of the teeth. This can have a great impact on the health and lifestyle of the young population. For instance, 'In 1988, the severity level of caries' prevalence was low: over a decade ago the decayed missing and filled teeth (DMFT) index was 2.0 in Kazakhstan [1]. However, recent data reveals that it has now risen 80% with a DMFT of 2.6 [14]. Confirming this problem, according to a recent study conducted in Almaty, "out of 100 children examined at the age of 12, 76 of them had dental caries with overall DMFT 3.4 score" [6]. These facts clearly indicate
that, caries prevalence among the young population of Kazakhstan dramatically increasing over the last few decades.
However, little is known in Kazakhstan about parents' attitudes towards the importance of oral hygiene practices regarding their children nor on the impact of children's oral hygiene on their quality of life.
The aim of the recent study conducted in Aktobe City Children's Dental Clinic was to investigate relationships between level of parental knowledge about oral hygiene and prevalence of dental caries of their children.
Methods
Ethical approval
Approval for this study was obtained from the Ethics Committee of the University of Heidelberg, Germany ( registration number S-138/2017). To conduct the study in Kazakhstan, approval was obtained from the head of the dental service in Aktobe, and from the head of the Aktobe Children Dental Clinic who are responsible for ethical questions on this topic according to the local regulations. Prior to data collection, all participating parents provided written informed consent to participate in the study and to use the data for publication. Additionally, participating parents were informed that they were free to withdraw from the study at any time and that all data would be handled with full regard to confidentiality and anonymity.
Research design and sampling procedure
A mixed method approach was used, incorporating both qualitative and quantitative methods. The study was carried out between April and August 2017 in Aktobe City Children's Dental Clinic.
The study had three objectives, which were to:
1. evaluate the prevalence of dental caries among children attending the clinic for routine check-ups
2. determine the level of parental awareness about their child's oral hygiene
3. define any correlations between the two.
First, a literature review was carried out of similar studies from peer-reviewed western journals, as well as research from Kazakhstan, in order to identify a logical framework for the area of study. Then a questionnaire was developed based on previously conducted studies in order to gain relevant information to determine parental awareness about their child's oral hygiene and its associated factors.
The study population were selected according to WHO recommended indicator age groups for dental survey among the visitors of the clinic. In order to reduce bias, inclusion/exclusion criteria were set:
• Inclusion of children in age groups recommended by WHO, and who attend only for a routine physical examination of oral cavity, with one of the parents to give informed consent and to answer the questionnaire.
• Exclusion of the child if parent is not available to give consent, if the parent refuses to give consent, or if the
child is able to understand and refuses to give consent. Either the child or parent may also refuse later even after giving initial consent.
164 children and their parents were included in the study.
Data collection
The data about parental level of knowledge and awareness of their children oral health status were collected via questionnaire, which contain quantitative and qualitative questions. Prior to the survey, all participating parents obtained information sheet and consent form. Purpose of the study were explained orally for each person and were asked to sign consent form if they agreed to participate. In parallel, dentists collected data about the condition of children oral health status in the Aktobe City Children's Dental Clinic. Dental caries was assessed in accordance with the DMFT index ( D- decayed; M- missed; F- filled; T- teeth) recommended by WHO for dental examination.
Data analysis
Results of both data sets were transformed into numerical data in order to simplify and accelerate data entrance in spreadsheet. Then the relationship between the values, including the time of day for toothbrushing, frequency of toothbrushing, dietary habits of the children and frequency of sweets consumption were compared with caries prevalence of each children age group through figures and graphs in Microsoft Excel.
Results
Oral Examination Findings
164 children who came for routine dental check-ups (and their parents) were eventually included in the study. The oral examination used the DMFT+dmft index, which is the standard method to record the severity of dental caries, where DMFT is used for the older children describing the number of Decayed, Missing due to caries, and Filled Teeth in the permanent dentition, while dmft is used for younger children to describe their primary dentition [7]. Table 1 gives the overall examination findings with 15 (9%) children having a DMFT index above 6.5, the level above which the WHO considers severe [7]. In total, 97.5% of the children had dental caries (Table 2), with a mean DMFT index of 5.5, and a standard deviation of 3.3. The highest mean number of dental caries was 7.27, among 5-year-old children. The second highest mean of 5.85 was among children up to 7 years of age. Questionnaire findings
42.1% of parents either did not believe that diet affects oral health (3.7%) or stated that they did not know (38.4 %), and acknowledged that 77.5% of their children eat sweets on a daily basis.
Interestingly, 25 (15%) of the parents said that their children eats sweets more than 7 times every day, and maximum number of consumed sweets according to the parents response was 20 times per day.
In addition, 27% of parents said they have never had a conversation with their children about the dangers of sugar consumption.
The figure above illustrates the correlation between most frequent daily intake of the sweets with the children caries prevalence. According to this figure, the children who consume sweets 7 times per day had higher caries prevalence compared with children who consume less.
Table 1: Overall Oral Health Examination Results
The following data shows the relationship between length of tooth brushing and the DMFT scores.
Here, it can be seen that 12% of children were stated to brush their teeth for 1 minute each time (in contrast to the international recommendations for 2-3 minutes) and these children also showed a trend towards a higher prevalence of caries.
DMFT+dmf
Age of child (years) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Total Number
No % No % No % No % No % No % No % No % No % No % No % No % No % No % No % No %
5 0 0 0 0 4 2 3 2 4 2 2 1 4 2 4 2 11 7 2 1 2 1 1 1 5 3 1 1 0 0 1 1 44
7 2 1 2 1 2 1 3 2 6 4 4 2 6 4 3 2 3 2 3 2 2 1 1 1 3 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 40
12 3 2 2 1 13 8 3 2 4 2 8 5 2 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 2 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 40
15 1 1 3 2 2 1 8 5 7 4 3 2 8 5 1 1 3 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 40
Total 6 4 7 4 21 13 17 10 21 13 17 10 20 12 9 5 18 11 6 4 7 4 3 2 9 5 2 1 0 0 1 1 164
Average 2 1 2 1 5 3 4 3 5 3 4 3 5 3 2 1 5 3 2 1 2 1 1 0 2 1 1 0 0 0 0 0
Table 2: The prevalence and averages (mean) of caries among the 4 age groups
Age group Number Prevalence % Mean number of caries Standard deviation Min. Max.
5 Years 44 100 7.3 3.3 2 15
7 Years 40 95 5.9 3.3 0 12
12 Years 40 92.5 3.8 2.8 0 13
15 Years 40 97.5 4.9 2.8 0 12
TOTAL 164 97.5 5.5 3.3 0 15
Table 3: Response of the parents about importance of diet and frequency of sweets consumption by their children
N(Parents) %
Does the condition of oral health depend on diet (food habits)?
• Yes 95 57.9
• No 6 3.7
• I do not know 63 38.4
Total 164 100
How often does your child eat sweets?
• if daily, how often
• 1-3 times 90 54.9
• more than 3 times 37 22.6
Sub-Total 127 77.5
if weekly, how often?
• 1-3 times 24 14.6
• more than 3 times 13 7.9
Sub-Total 39 22.5
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 DMFT index score of children
Figure 1: Correlation between daily sweet consumption and caries prevalence
Figure 2: Comparison between the DMFT score and the number of minutes to brush teeth (% of all children)
Table 4: duration of tooth brushing in different age groups
Time 5 years 7 years 12 years 15 years Total %
1 minutes 3 9 3 5 20 12.2
2 minutes 19 14 18 15 66 40.2
3 minutes 11 10 9 10 40 24.4
4 minutes and over 11 7 10 10 38 23.1
Total 44 40 40 40 164 100
Discussion
The prevalence (98%) and severity of caries (overall mean DMFT score of 5.5, with 9% having a DMFT index above 6.5) of the children in the study in Aktobe, Kazakhstan is high in comparison with other countries. For instance, according to WHO Oral Health Countries Profile Programme, the DMFT index in the United Kingdom for 12 years old children in 2013 was 0.8. Similarly, in Germany in 2014, the DMFT index score for 12 years old children was 0.5 (Malmo University 2017, EURO Oral Health Database)
Another study conducted in Greece in 2012 showed that the mean DMFT value for 5, 12 and 15 age group was 1.77, 2.05 and 3.19 respectively [8]. In Asian countries such as Japan and Korea DMFT index in 2012, for 12 years old children was 1.2 and 1.8, respectively (Malmo University 2017, WPRO Oral Health Database)
This could be related to several factors, such as the availability of dental treatment, poor oral hygiene skills, as well as to parents' attitudes towards oral hygiene of their children [9]. In the present study an attempt was made to investigate some factors related with parents level of knowledge and attitudes toward oral hygiene.
Parental knowledge about importance of healthy diet for their children investigated in the present study was moderate with 29% saying that they had not had a conversation with their children on this topic. This lack of interaction may be explained by the fact that 42.1% of the parents either did not believe that diet affects oral health (3.7%) or stated that they did not know (38.4 %).
The high sugar intake found among the children in the study (77.5% eat sweets daily, and 22.6% consume sweets more than 3 times per day), is echoed by the findings of another study by Olczak [10]. Numerous independent expert and consensus reports have concluded that sugars are the most important dietary factor in the development of dental caries [11-13]. According to the current WHO guidelines, sugar intake should be restricted to the amount providing less than 10% of the daily energy requirement, i.e., below 20 kg of sugar per year [13]. From this study it is highly likely that their children of Aktobe come close to, or exceed, the recommended maximum intake of sugar.
In addition to concerns about the level of parental knowledge about dietary habits, the study also highlights the lack of knowledge among parents concerning tooth-brushing techniques (length of time to brush teeth, and frequency) and reveals some correlation between these factors and the level of severity of caries in their children's teeth.
Conclusions
The present study conducted in the Aktobe City Children's Dental Clinic found that caries prevalence among the study population was very high and that there is some correlation between this and the awareness of the parents about importance of healthy diet and tooth-brushing techniques were moderate to low.
There is therefore a pressing need to review current practices in relation to efforts to build awareness and knowledge among parents (in addition to those taking place for the children themselves in school programmes etc) in order to change behaviours and reduce the prevalence and severity of caries among children of school age in Aktobe, and perhaps in other areas of Kazakhstan also. There have only been a few similar studies carried out in Kazakhstan, and almost none published in peer reviewed journals, so more needs to be done to clarify the situation and to begin to take the necessary steps.
It is to be hoped that this study will provide a good basis on which to build further research in Kazakhstan, in order to identify these and other factors which are influencing the prevalence and severity of dental caries among the youth of Kazakhstan.
Conflicts of interests
None.
Funding
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or non-for-profit sectors.
References:
1. Petersen PE. The World Oral Health Report 2003: continuous improvement of oral health in the 21st century--the approach of the WHO Global Oral Health Programme. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2003;(31 Suppl 1):3-23.
2. American Academy on Pediatric, D. and P. American Academy of, Policy on early childhood caries (ECC): classifications, consequences, and preventive strategies. Pediatr Dent. 2008;30(7 Suppl): 40-3.
3. Godson J. Delivering Better Oral Health 2014--what's new in the third edition? Community Dent Health. 2014;31(2): 66-7.
4. Watt RG. From victim blaming to upstream action: tackling the social determinants of oral health inequalities. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2007;35(1):1-11.
5. Shin BM, Park DY. Association between the prevalence of dental caries in children and factors related to their mothers. Int J Dent Hyg 2017 Nov;15(4):e173-e179. DOI: 10.1111/idh.12261. Epub 2016 Dec 6.
6. Esembaeva SS. Condition, problems and perspectives of dental service in Kazakhstan, in Vestnik of KazNMU. 2015.
7. World Health Organisation, W., Oral health surveys-basic methods, 5th edition 2013.
8. Oulis, CJ. et al. Caries prevalence of 5, 12 and 15-year-old Greek children: a national pathfinder survey. Community Dent Health 2012;29(1):29-32.
9. Razmiene J et al. The relation between oral hygiene skills and the prevalence of dental caries among 4 - 6-year-old children. Stomatologija 2011;13(2):62-7.
10. Olczak-Kowalczyk D et al., Dental Caries Level and Sugar Consumption in 12-Year-Old Children from Poland. Adv Clin Exp Med 2016;25(3):545-50.
11. Moynihan PJ, Kelly SA. Effect on caries of restricting sugars intake: systematic review to inform WHO guidelines. J Dent Res. 2014;93(1):8-18.
12. Sheiham, A., Dietary effects on dental diseases. Public Health Nutr. 2001;4(2B):569-91.
13. WHO/FAO, Diet, nutrition and the prevention of chronic diseases. World Health Organ Tech Rep Ser, 2003;916: p. i-viii, 1-149, backcover.
14. Yermukhanova GT, Kabulbekov A.A. THE PRINCIPLES OF PREVENTION OF DENTAL DISEASES AT CHILDREN IN MODERN CONDITIONS. Vestnik of KazNMU 2014;
