CC BY
0
ARTICLE INFO
PSYCHOLOGICAL AND PEDAGOGICAL PROBLEMS IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENTIFIC AND CREATIVE ABILITIES. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF EDUCATIONAL MODELS IN
THE EAST AND WEST Babajanova Fatima Farmanovna Gulistan State University Senior lecturer in the Department of pedagogy and psychology
tel+998930632269 babajanovafotima@gmail.com https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.11191713
ABSTRACT
This scientific article explores the psychological and pedagogical challenges encountered in nurturing scientific and creative abilities within the educational models of the East and West. The East and West represent distinct cultural and educational paradigms, each with its own approach to fostering intellectual and creative potential. By conducting a comparative analysis, this article aims to shed light on the similarities, differences, and challenges faced in the development of scientific and creative abilities in these two educational models. Understanding these challenges can inform educators and policymakers in designing effective strategies to foster scientific and creative thinking across diverse educational contexts.
Received: 06th May 2024 Accepted: 13th May 2024 Online: 14th May 2024 KEYWORDS
Psychological challenges, pedagogical challenges, scientific abilities, creative abilities, educational models, East, West, comparative analysis, cultural paradigms,
intellectual growth,
educational practices, rote learning, critical thinking, standardized testing, application-based assessment, conformity, individual expression, teacher-centered approaches, student-centered approaches, recommendations, curriculum design, teacher training, professional development.
In today's rapidly evolving world, the development of scientific and creative abilities is of utmost importance. These abilities are essential for fostering innovation, problem-solving, and intellectual growth in individuals. The educational models of the East and West have traditionally taken different approaches to cultivating these abilities, rooted in their unique philosophical, cultural, and pedagogical orientations.
This article aims to examine the psychological and pedagogical challenges within the educational models of the East and West, with a specific focus on the development of scientific
EURASIAN JOURNAL OF ACADEMIC RESEARCH
Innovative Academy Research Support Center UIF = 8.1 | SJIF = 7.899 www.in-academy.uz
and creative abilities. By comparing these approaches and identifying common challenges, this study seeks to provide valuable insights for educators, researchers, and policymakers who are interested in enhancing educational practices.
The East, represented by countries such as China, Japan, and South Korea, has a longstanding tradition of emphasizing rote memorization, discipline, and a strong focus on academic achievement. This approach aims to develop foundational knowledge and technical skills, but it may place less emphasis on fostering creativity and critical thinking.
On the other hand, the Western educational model, exemplified by countries like the United States and many European nations, often prioritizes individualism, student-centered learning, and the cultivation of creative and critical thinking skills. These approaches aim to encourage curiosity, independent thinking, and problem-solving abilities.
While both the Eastern and Western educational models have their strengths, they also face unique challenges in effectively nurturing scientific and creative abilities. By examining these challenges, this article seeks to shed light on potential areas for improvement and the importance of incorporating a balanced approach to education.
By understanding the psychological and pedagogical challenges within these educational models, educators, researchers, and policymakers can gain insights into how to create more effective educational systems. By integrating the strengths of both models and addressing common challenges, educators can provide students with a well-rounded education that fosters scientific and creative abilities, preparing them for success in the modern world.
2.1 Eastern Educational Model:
The Eastern educational model is often characterized by a strong emphasis on discipline, rote learning, and the acquisition of foundational knowledge. Students are expected to memorize large amounts of information and demonstrate mastery of subject matter through rigorous testing. Academic achievement is highly valued, and there is often significant pressure on students to excel academically.
Conformity and respect for authority are important aspects of the Eastern educational model. Students are expected to follow rules and adhere to established norms. This approach aims to instill discipline, order, and a sense of responsibility in students.
While the Eastern educational model excels in developing strong foundational knowledge and technical skills, it may place less emphasis on fostering creativity, critical thinking, and independent inquiry. The focus on rote memorization and adherence to established procedures may limit opportunities for students to explore their own ideas, think critically, and develop innovative problem-solving skills.
2.2 Western Educational Model:
The Western educational model, found in countries like the United States and many European nations, emphasizes critical thinking, creativity, and independent inquiry. It encourages students to question, analyze, and evaluate information, fostering a spirit of curiosity and independent thinking.
In the Western educational model, there is a strong emphasis on holistic development, recognizing the importance of nurturing students' social, emotional, and cognitive growth.
Student-centered learning approaches are often utilized, allowing students to take an active role in their education and pursue their interests.
Creativity and innovation are highly valued in the Western educational model. Students are encouraged to think creatively, solve problems independently, and express their unique perspectives. This approach aims to develop well-rounded individuals who can adapt to change, think critically, and contribute to society in diverse ways.
While the Western educational model excels in fostering creativity, critical thinking, and independent inquiry, it may face challenges in providing a strong foundation of knowledge and technical skills. The emphasis on individualism and student-centered learning approaches may sometimes result in a lack of structure or insufficient attention to foundational knowledge.
Overall, both the Eastern and Western educational models have their strengths and challenges. The Eastern model emphasizes discipline and mastery of foundational knowledge, while the Western model focuses on creativity, critical thinking, and independent inquiry. Integrating the strengths of both models can contribute to a more balanced and effective educational approach that nurtures scientific and creative abilities.
3.1 Rote Learning vs. Critical Thinking:
One of the challenges in developing scientific abilities within the Eastern educational model is the emphasis on rote learning. Rote learning involves memorizing information without necessarily understanding the underlying concepts. While rote learning can be effective in acquiring foundational knowledge, it may hinder the development of critical thinking and problem-solving skills.
Critical thinking is essential for scientific inquiry and experimentation. It involves the ability to analyze information, evaluate evidence, and apply logical reasoning to solve problems. By encouraging students to question, think critically, and engage in scientific inquiry, the Western educational model fosters the development of scientific abilities.
To address this challenge, the Eastern educational model could incorporate more opportunities for critical thinking and problem-solving. This can involve promoting inquiry-based learning approaches, encouraging students to ask questions, and providing opportunities for hands-on experimentation and exploration.
3.2 Standardized Testing vs. Application-Based Assessment:
Another challenge in developing scientific abilities lies in the difference in assessment methods between the Eastern and Western educational models. The Eastern model often relies heavily on standardized testing, which places a strong emphasis on memorization and recall of information. While standardized testing can assess students' knowledge, it may limit opportunities for them to apply scientific concepts in real-world contexts.
In contrast, the Western educational model often utilizes application-based assessments that require students to demonstrate their understanding of scientific concepts through practical application. This approach encourages creativity, problem-solving, and the application of scientific knowledge to real-life situations.
To address this challenge, the Eastern educational model could incorporate more application-based assessments that require students to apply scientific concepts in practical
settings. This can include activities such as experiments, projects, and problem-solving tasks that encourage creativity, critical thinking, and the application of scientific knowledge in real-world contexts.
By recognizing and addressing these challenges, educators within both the Eastern and Western educational models can create a more balanced approach that combines the strengths of both models. This can foster the development of scientific abilities by integrating rote learning with critical thinking, and standardized testing with application-based assessments.
4.1 Conformity vs. Individual Expression:
One of the challenges in developing creative abilities within the Eastern educational model is the emphasis on conformity and adherence to societal norms. This can create a learning environment that discourages individual expression and limits opportunities for creative thinking. Students may feel pressured to conform to established standards and may hesitate to explore alternative ideas or perspectives.
In contrast, the Western educational model places a greater emphasis on individualism and encourages students to express their unique perspectives. This approach fosters a climate of creativity and supports students in developing their own ideas and solutions.
To address this challenge, the Eastern educational model can incorporate activities and assignments that encourage individual expression and divergent thinking. Providing opportunities for students to engage in creative projects, express their opinions, and explore alternative viewpoints can help nurture their creative abilities.
4.2 Teacher-Centered vs. Student-Centered Approaches:
Another challenge in developing creative abilities lies in the difference in teaching approaches between the Eastern and Western educational models. The Eastern model often follows a teacher-centered approach, where the teacher plays a central role in delivering information and guiding learning. This approach may limit opportunities for students to engage in creative problem-solving and independent thinking.
In contrast, the Western model often adopts a student-centered approach, where students are encouraged to take ownership of their learning and actively participate in the educational process. This empowers students to explore their own ideas, ask questions, and engage in critical thinking and creative problem-solving.
To address this challenge, the Eastern educational model can incorporate more student-centered approaches. This can involve encouraging students to actively participate in class discussions, work collaboratively on projects, and engage in independent research. Providing opportunities for students to explore their own interests, pursue creative projects, and think critically can enhance their creative abilities.
By recognizing and addressing these challenges, educators within both the Eastern and Western educational models can create a more balanced approach that fosters creative abilities. This can involve promoting individual expression, divergent thinking, and student-centered learning approaches. By doing so, students can develop their creative potential and become innovative thinkers in their respective fields.
5. Recommendations for Enhancing Scientific and Creative Development
5.1 Integration of Approaches
Drawing on the strengths of both models, educators and policymakers can integrate aspects of the Eastern and Western approaches to create a balanced educational environment that promotes scientific and creative abilities.
5.2 Curriculum Design and Assessment
Developing a curriculum that blends theoretical knowledge with practical application can provide students with opportunities to engage in scientific inquiry and creative expression. Assessment methods should evolve beyond standardized testing to incorporate performance-based assessments that encourage critical thinking and creativity.
5.3 Teacher Training and Professional Development
Providing teachers with training and professional development opportunities focused on fostering scientific and creative abilities is essential. This includes equipping teachers with pedagogical strategies that encourage inquiry-based learning, critical thinking, and creative problem-solving.
6. Conclusion
In conclusion, while the Eastern educational model emphasizes discipline, rote learning, and mastery of foundational knowledge, the Western educational model promotes critical thinking, creativity, and independent inquiry. Each model has its strengths and challenges in developing scientific and creative abilities. The challenges include balancing rote learning with critical thinking, standardized testing with application-based assessment, conformity with individual expression, and teacher-centered approaches with student-centered approaches.
To enhance scientific and creative development, it is recommended to integrate approaches from both models, design curricula that incorporate practical application and performance-based assessments, and provide teacher training and professional development focused on fostering scientific inquiry and creative problem-solving. By addressing these challenges and implementing the recommendations, educators and policymakers can create a balanced educational environment that nurtures scientific and creative abilities, preparing students for success in an ever-evolving world.
References:
1. Babajanova Fotima Farmanovna. SYSTEM OF IMPROVING PSYCHOLOGICAL PREPARATION OF STUDENTS FOR PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITY. International Engineering Journal For Research & Development Teacher of the Department "Psychology" E-ISSN: 2349-0721 https://internationalbulletins.com/intjour/index.php/ibet/article/view/790
2. Babajanova Fotima Farmanovna. The early juvernile age is the sensitive perlod for displaying scientific and creative abilities. Austrian Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences. Scientific journal № 3-4 2015 (March-April) https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/sposoby-emotsionalnogo-vozdeystviya-na-proyavlenie-nauchno-tvorcheskih-sposobnostey-lichnosti-v-yunosheskom-vozraste
3. Mirzayev Jamshid Turdalievich. "Social and psychological opportunities of information and psychological security in adolescents" International Conference on Developments in
EURASIAN JOURNAL OF ACADEMIC RESEARCH
Innovative Academy Research Support Center UIF = 8.1 | SJIF = 7.899 www.in-academy.uz
Education. Hosted from Bursa, Turkey. https: econferencezone.org July 15th 2022 45-48 p https://econferencezone.org/index.php/ecz/article/view/1279
4. Мирзаев, Д., & Наргулова, А. (2022). «Лечение интернет-зависимости. Современные инновационные исследования актуальные проблемы и развитие тенденции: решения и перспективы» Современные инновационные исследования актуальные проблемы и развитие тенденции: решения и перспективы 1(1), 498-500. извлечено от https://inlibrary.uz/index.php/zitdmrt/article/view/5217
5. Мирзоев, Д. (2022). "Internet qaramligini shakllanishning sabablari, mexanizmlari va diagnostikasi." Современные инновационные исследования актуальные проблемы и развитие тенденции: решения и перспективы, 1(1), № 1 (2022) 500-503. извлечено от https://inlibrary.uz/index.php/zitdmrt/article/view/5218.
6. Jamshid Turdaliyevich Mirzayev. Yoshlar ijtimoiy hulq-atvoriga internet muloqoti ta'sirining psixologik jihatlari. Tashkent Medical Academy Volume 4 | TMA Conference | 2023 Integration of Science, Education and Practice in Modern Psychology and Pedagogy: Problems and Solutions. Volume 4 | TMA Conference | 2023. May 6. 812-816 p. https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/yoshlar-ijtimoiy-hulq-atvoriga-internet-muloqoti-ta-sirining-psixologik-jihatlari/viewer
7. Mirzayev Jamshid Turdialiyevich. "Psychological aspects of influence of the internet -communication on the social behavior of the youth" / INTELLECTUAL EDUCATION TECHNOLOGICAL SOLUTIONS AND INNOVATIVE DIGITAL TOOLS. International scientific-online conference. 2023. Part 18. JUNE 3rd. 1295-1300 p. https://interonconf.org/index.php/neth/article/view/5386
8. Mirzayev Djamshid Turdalievich/ PSYCHOLOGICAL ASPECTS OF INTERNET-COMMUNICATION IN SOCIAL SOCIETY OF YOUTH. The results of the study of Internet addiction on the method of Kimberly-Yang. NEUROQUANTOLOGY | October 2022 | VOLUME 20 | ISSUE 12 | PAGE 3409-3416| DOI: 10.14704/NQ.2022.20.12.NQ77350https://www.proquest.com/openview/c0c46eaeba7bf0e 04fd82a955955a4dd/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=2035897
9. Mirzayev Djamshid Turdalievich / Psychological aspects of the influence of internet communication on the social behavior of young / PEOPLE SCIENCE AND INNOVATION INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFIC JOURNAL VOLUME 3 ISSUE 4 APRIL 2024 ISSN: 2181-3337 | SCIENTISTS.UZ B volume 3 issue 4 - 359p https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.11032109
