CC BY
26
PRE-CHROMATOGRAPHY CRUDE SEPARATION OF LIGHT FULLERENES BY POLY-TERMICAL (RE)CRYSTALLIZATION METHOD
V. A. Keskinov31, N. A. Charykov1'3, M. V. Keskinova1, Yu. V. Murashkin3'1,
A.A. Blokhin3'1, K.N. Semenov2'1
ILIP Ltd. (Innovations of Leningrad Universities and Enterprises),
Saint Petersburg, Russia
Saint Petersburg State University, Saint Petersburg, Russia
Saint-Petersburg State Technological Institute (Technological University),
Saint Petersburg, Russia
keskinov@mail.ru
PACS 61.48.+c
The pre-chromatography method of crude separation of light fullerenes (C6o and C70) is based on multistage processes of (re)crystallization — the solution of fullerenes solid solutions in liquid solvent (o-xylene) or in liquid o-xylene solutions at high temperature (85 ° C) and crystallization of solid solutions from saturated liquid solutions at low temperature (-20 °C). As a result, for example, the initial standard fullerene extract may be efficiently divided into two different solid solutions — the first, considerably enriched in C60 fullerene and the second, considerably enriched by the C70 fullerene. In this separation process, the concentrate enriched by C60, is also enriched in Cg4. In that process, 98.6 mass % of C60 was contained in the C60-enriched concentrate (from the sum content of C60 in the initial extract), simultaneously, 65.9 mass % of C70 contained in the C70-enriched concentrate (from the sum content of C70 in the initial extract).
Keywords: light fullerenes, heavy fullerenes, o-xylene, separation, solution, (re)crystallization, temperature, counter-current, pre-chromatography, high efficiency.
1. Introduction
The most important current technological process of fullerenes production of consists of 3 consequent stages: synthesis of fullerene soot, extraction of fullerenes from the soot and separation of the extract into individual fullerenes [1-3]. Fullerene soot is usually provided by the sublimation of carbon electrodes in an inert atmosphere. Extraction of fullerenes from this soot usually is accomplished with the use of aromatic solvents. The fullerenes extract, which consists of light fullerenes (C6o and C70) and heavy (high) fullerenes (C76, C78 and C84 etc) may be separated into individual fullerenes with discrete molecular masses by different methods. For separation and production of individual fullerenes, the following methods are used: chromatography [4], crystallization [5], combined method, which can include additional stages, such as thermal vacuum sublimation [6-8]. Only light fullerenes (C60 and C70) may be provided using these methods. Heavy fullerenes are distributed in some different products or by-products [6] or stay in activated carbon, used as the absorbent in separation processes for light fullerenes [7, 8].
In this work, we were interested in processes for the (re)crystallization of fullerene extracts with the aim of separating the initial extract into two concentrates (all light and heavy fullerenes in such process will be naturally distributed between these concentrates).
Fig. 1. Solubility of the C60 fullerene in o-xylene (S) against temperature (T)
Fig. 2. Solubility of the C70 fullerene in o-xylene (S) against temperature (T)
In the final processes of chromatographic separation and purification of concentrates, the latter may be provided with an efficiency considerably higher than in the initial processes of extract separation and purification [9]. In different patents and papers, the processes which were realized during the interaction of the fullerene extract (or fullerene mixture) with aromatic solvents, for example o-xylene, are named differently and the titles of the stages depend on the conditions and goals of the experiments: crystallization [5], fractional concentrating at 80 to 85 °C [6-8], fractional crystallization at -20 to -24 °C [8], (re)crystallization [10, 11] and polythermal (re)crystallization [11]. Phase processes, realized in such cases are the following:
— solution of fullerene solid solutions in aromatic solvent or unsaturated liquid solutions,
— crystallization fullerenes solid solutions from saturated liquid solutions.
2. Experiment and results discussion
The (re)crystallization processes of fullerene extracts are based on the different solubilities of light fullerenes (C60 and C70) in o-xylene at different temperatures [12-14]. An actual description of the processes for fullerene extract (re)crystallization was the investigation of solubility diagrams in ternary systems of C60-C70 — o-xylene at 80 ° C and -20 ° C [15]. The dependence of individual fullerenes C60 and C70 solubilities in o-xylene on temperature is represented in Fig. 1 and Fig. 2, correspondingly [13].
The solubility of the individual fullerene C60 in o-xylene at temperatures T-28-30 ° C crosses through the maximum, and further warming decreases the solubility. Simultaneously, the solubility of the individual fullerene C70 in o-xylene at the same experimental conditions monotonously increases along with temperature. The first experiments concerning the solubility of heavy fullerenes in o-xylene were made at 28 ° C and 84 ° C. It is well-known that the fullerene extract composition (when fullerene soot is provided by the method of carbon rods sublimation with the help of an electric arc in He-plasm) can vary widely, for example (in mass %): C60 - 55-88, C70 - 10-45, heavy fullerenes Cn>70 > 1 [16]. The fullerene extract used in these studies had the following composition: (in mass %): C60 - 73.3, C70 - 24.9, C76 - 0.90, C78 - 0.26, C84 - 0.64. The fullerene extract, representing a solid solution of fullerenes in each other, and o-xylene was magnetically stirred (at 28 ° C, the time of saturation was 3 hours). Then, the temperature was
increased to 84 ° C and mixing was continued for a longer period (for example 24 hours), during which the fullerene concentration in the solution was continuously monitored by express spectrophotometry. For more exact analysis of light fullerenes (C6o and C70) and heavy fullerenes content, HPLC analysis was used. Experiments were done at different combinations of quantitative characteristics of Liquid and Solid phases (L:S), where L — is volume of o-xylene in ml, S — is mass of fullerene extract in grams. In Table 1 the data are shown for the dynamics of the selective solution-extraction of light fullerenes from the initial fullerene extract at the temperatures T ~ 28 °C and T ~ 84 ° C at L:S = 10 and L:S = 50 ml/g.
Table 1. Dynamics of the selective solution-extraction of light fullerenes from the initial fullerene extract at L:S = 10 and L:S = 50 ml/g
Extraction into liquid solution Extraction into liquid solution
Time (min) T°C at L:S = 10 ml/g, % at L:S = 50 ml/g, %
C60 C70 C60 C70
30 28 21.3 37.3 54.7 81.8
60 28 22.6 37.9 56.9 83.3
120 28 22.5 38.5 54.6 77.0
180 28 23.4 39.9 54.2 75.8
235 84 8.4 46.5 52.5 77.6
295 84 7.9 45.4 54.7 83.5
355 84 9.6 47.9 53.8 79.2
In the first case, the fullerene extract was treated with o-xylene at 28 ° C and L:S = 10 ml/g, into liquid solution were extracted not more than 25 mass % of C60 and 40 mass % of C70, other light fullerenes remained in the solid state. During treatment of the heterogeneous system at 84 ° C, (re)crystallization of fullerene solid solutions was realized, the solid solution was enriched by C60 and liquid solution was enriched by C70. In the second case, the fullerene extract was treated with o-xylene at 28 °C and L:S = 50 ml/g, one can get a more concentrated liquid solution of C60 and C70, but (re)crystallization, unfortunately, practically did not occur. According to literature data, the high temperature (re)crystallization of fullerenes in o-xylene is done, using the following conditions — at L:S = 30 g/g [5], L:S = (11±1) ml/g [8]. In Table 2, data are represented concerning the change of the fullerene (including heavy fullerenes) liquid soutions' compositions in the treatment of the fullerene extract with o-xylene at L:S = 10 ml/g.
According to the results of the experiment one can conclude the following: during (re)crystallization at 84 ° C, the liquid solution is enriched by the fullerene C70 (light) and C76, C78 (heavy), and simultaneously, the solid solution is enriched by the fullerene C60 (light) and C84 (heavy). On the basis of previous experimental data, the method for crude high-efficiency pre-chromatography separation of fullerenes was developed. As a result of these methods, the initial fullerene extract was separated into two fullerenes extracts basically and unequivocally enriched by light fullerenes C60 and C70, but also differently enriched by various heavy fullerenes. The main processes in these methods are: high temperature (re)crystallization (further high temperature process — HTP), low temperature (re)crystallization (further low temperature process — LTP). The high temperature process was developed in stages by mixing for 60-120 min at 70 to 90 ° C, while the low temperature process utilized stirring for 10-30 hours at -25 to -15 °C. Separation
Table 2. Dynamics of the change of the composition of fullerene liquid solutions in the process of treatment of fullerene extract by o-xylene at L:S = 10 ml/g
Time (min) T°C Concentration in liquid solution (mg/liter) Mass fraction of fullerene in the relation to sum mass of all
fullerenes in solution (mass %)
C60 C70 C76 C78 C84 C60 C70 C76 C78 C84
30 28 15628 9281 256 56 87 61.8 36.7 1.00 0.20 0.30
60 28 16546 9436 221 78 147 62.6 35.7 0.84 0.30 0.56
120 28 16457 9596 213 74 164 62.1 36.2 0.80 0.28 0.62
180 28 17179 9923 202 34 152 62.5 36.1 0.73 0.12 0.55
235 84 6118 11570 150 44 28 34.2 64.6 0.8 0.25 0.15
295 84 5763 11306 149 44 25 33.3 65.4 0.9 0.25 0.15
355 84 7025 11925 149 58 22 36.6 62.2 0.8 0.3 0.1
of liquid and solid fullerene solutions in HTP was effected by filtration at the temperature of HTP, however, for separation in LTP simple decantation was used. The multistage process of fullerene separation was accomplished by producing concentrates, enriched by C60, and enriched by C70 at each stage of the whole process. The movement of fullerene liquid solutions formed in LTP, countercurrent to the direction of the movement of solid solutions formed in HTP, was organized also. In the first stage of HTP, was pure solvent — o-xylene was used. In subsequent stages of HTP, the solid fullerene extract was mixed with the liquid fullerene solution from the previous stage of HTP. If such scheme of technological process is realized, one does not need any additional intermediate products, and all fullerenes are distributed between the two concentrates. Correction of the o-xylene volume used in the case of the change of the initial fullerene extract composition or in the case of technical losses was developed mainly in the last stage of HTP. Fig.3 shows the scheme of the n-stage of the fullerene separation process with 2-stage HTP, while in Fig. 4, the scheme of n-stage of the fullerene separation process with 3-stage HTP is depicted.
The following example highlights the data concerning the realization of the n-stage of fullerene separation with the production of the concentrate, enriched by the light fullerenes C60 and C70. For analysis of fullerene-containing phases we used chromatography — HPLC (Shimadzu LC-20 with spectrophotometric detection at 300 and 315 nm).
The composition of the initial extract was slightly different from the previous one: (in mass %): C60 ~ 73.5, C70 ~ 22.8, C76 ~ 1.09, C78 ~ 0.37, C84 ~ 1.83 (some "oxides" of fullerene C60 were also determined — C60O ~ 1.07, C60O2 ~ 0.16. There was no information, concerning the "oxides" of the second light fullerene C70Ora or "semi-oxides" of light fullerenes (C60)2O and (C70)2O, because the content of the last ones in initial fullerene extract was comparatively low (^ 0.03 mass %). The first HTP stage was the mixing of 100 g of the initial fullerene extract in the returned from the second HTP stage previous (n-1)-stage solution at 85 °C over 90 min. The volume of the returned solution was 1000 ml. After filtration, we got solid fullerene product enriched by C60 and a liquid fullerene solution which was then subjected to LTP. LTP was performed for 20 hours at -20 ° C. After decantation, we obtained the C70-enriched concentrate and a solution, which was then used in the second HTP stage. The second HTP stage was performed with mixing of solid fullerene product after the first HTP stage and the liquid fullerene solution after
Fig. 3. Scheme of n-stage of the process of fullerene separation with 2-stage HTP
Fig. 4. Scheme of n-stage of the process of fullerene separation with 3-stage HTP
LTP again at 85 ° C over 90 min. After filtration, we obtained the C6o-enriched concentrate and the solution which was given for the first HTP stage of the next (n+1)-stage. So, as a result of the n-stage separation process, we were afforded two concentrates: a C70-enriched concentrate, consisting of 84.2 mass.% C70, 5.6 mass.% C60 and enriched by heavy fullerenes in comparison with the initial fullerene extract and a C60-enriched concentrate, consisting of 9.4 mass.% C70, 88.3 mass.% C60, while the heavy fullerenes content in it was considerably lower than the previous concentrate. Characteristics of fullerene products in n-stage of process of fullerene separation are represented in Tables 3-5.
Table 3. Characteristics of fullerene solid products in n-stage of process of fullerene separation
Name of product Fullerenes content in products (mass.%)
C60 C70 C76 C78 C84 C60O C60O2
Initial fullerene extract 73.52 22.76 1.09 0.37 1.03 1.07 0.16
Solid fullerene product 79.4 17.4 0.8 0.3 1.0 1.0 0.1
after the first HTP stage
Concentrate, enriched by C60 88.3 9.4 0.1 0.2 1.0 0.9 0.1
Concentrate, enriched by C70 5.6 84.2 5.4 1.3 1.3 1.8 0.4
Table 4. Characteristics of fullerene liquid solutions in n-stage of process of fullerene separation
Individual fullerenes concentrations
Name of product in the sum fullerene mass (mass.%)
C60 C70 C76 C78 C84 C60O C60O2
Returned solution 36.1 56.7 3.4 0.9 0.8 1.9 0.2
Solution after the first HTP stage 17.4 74.0 4.4 1.0 1.0 1.8 0.4
Solution after LTP 58.2 38.8 0.6 0.2 0.1 1.9 0.2
In this process, as mentioned above, in HTP, the C6o-enriched concentrate is also enriched by C84. In our separation process, 98.6 mass % C60 was contained in that con-centrate(from the sum content of C60 in the initial extract), simultaneously, 65.9 mass % C70 was contained in the C70-enriched concentrate (from the sum content of C70 in the initial extract). "Oxides" of C60 were mainly isolated in the C70-enriched concentrate, which is natural, since the specific electronic configuration of the last one, for example has both higher asymmetry and electric polarizability than C60. The solutions after both HTP stages, after removing from the (re)crystallization system the C60-enriched concentrate, naturally contained less C60 than the initial fullerene extract and enriched by C70 and heavy fullerenes. The solutions after the LTP, after removing from the (re)crystallization system the C70-enriched concentrate, naturally contained less C70 than initial fullerene extract and was enriched by C60 but not by heavy fullerenes. The two-stage (re)crystallization process for producing the C60-enriched concentrate, with the returning of counter-current liquid fullerene solutions, permitted us to get a concentrate, considerably more enriched by C60 than was obtained for a one-stage (re)crystallization process. We could also considerably increase the mass of C70 obtained in the C70-enriched concentrate. One can easily understand that, using the (re)crystallization method of fullerene pre-chromatography crude
Table 5. Calculated characteristics of concentrates, got in the n-stage of fullerene separation
Characteristics Concentrate, enriched by C60 Concentrate, enriched by C70
Content of C60 (mg) 72520 1000
Content of C70 (mg) 7760 15000
Content of C76 (mg) 120 970
Content of C78 (mg) 139 231
Content of C84 (mg) 796 234
Content of 60 (mg) 750 320
Content of 602 (mg) 90 70
Mass (mg) 82175 17825
Distribution of C60 (mass.%) 98.6 1.4
Distribution of 70 (mass.%) 34.1 65.9
Distribution of 76 (mass.%) 11.0 89.0
Distribution of 78 (mass.%) 37.6 62.4
Distribution of 84 (mass.%) 77.3 22.7
fullerene separationdescribed above, we may produce fullerene concentrates with compositions, considerably varying from the above-described example. The factors, which can rule such (re)crystallization process are the following: composition of the initial fullerene extract, phases masses - L:S, temperature of HTP, temperature of LTP etc. Changing of other factors, such as time of HTP or LTP, regimes of mixing or saturation, to our opinion, make the process a-equilibrium, non-static and thus, not easily controlled.
3. Conclusion
We have elaborated an original, highly efficienct method of pre-chromatography crude separation of light fullerenes (C60 and C70), based on the multistage processes of (re)crystallization — the solution of fullerenes solid solutions in liquid solvent (o-xylene) or in liquid o-xylene solutions and the crystallization of solid solutions from saturated liquid solutions. The process is developed in a poly-thermal regime in the temperature ranges from -20 ° C to 85 ° C. As a result, the initial fullerene extract (solid solution) may be efficiently divided into two different solid solutions — the first considerably enriched by fullerene C60 and the second considerably enriched by fullerene C70. Heavy fullerenes — C76, C78, C84 ... are distributed between these solid solutions.
Acknowledgement
The work was supported by Russian Found of Fundamental Researches — RFFI (Project No 09-03-00350—a).
References
[1] Sidorov L. N., Yurovskaya M. A. , et al. Fullerenes. Ekzamen, Moscow, 688 pp. (2005).
[2] Charykov N.A., Zuev V. V., Kuznetsova E.A. High-efficiency complex for fullerenes production. Petersburg Electronics Journal, 4, P. 16-31 (2007).
[3] Ermilov N. N., Charykov N.A., et al. Nanotechnology — from theory to practical application. Journal of Innovations (rus.), 12, P. 79-83 (2007).
[4] Tour J.M., Scrivens W. A., Bedworth P. V. Purification of fullerenes. United States Patent 5662876, C01B 31/00 (1997).
[5] Ng Ka Ming. Separation of fullerene C6o and C70 using crystallization. United States Patent 7875086, B01D 9/00 (2011).
[6] Bolstren N.N., Ojchenko V.M., Olejnik S.V. Method of obtaining fullerene C60. Patent RF 2327635, C01B 31/02 (2008).
[7] Glushko Yu.S., Sedov V. P., Kolesnik S.G. Method of producing fullerene C60. Patent RF 2456233, C01B 31/02 (2012).
[8] Sedov V. P., Kolesnik S. G. Method of producing fullerene C70. Patent RF 2455230, C01B 31/02 (2012).
[9] Blokhin A.A., Keskinov V.A.,Murashkin Yu.V. , et al. Method for chromatographic separation of fullerenes. Patent RF 2302372, C01B 31/02 (2007).
[10] Tsetskova L. V., Keskinov V. A., Charykov N.A., et al. Extraction of Fullerene Mixture from Fullerene Soot with Organic Solvents. Russian Journal of General Chemistry, 5, P. 920-926 (2011).
[11] Semenov K. N. Solubility of Light Fullerenes in Organic Solvents. Ph.D. Dissertation (Chem.Sci), St. Petersburg, 173 pp. (2009).
[12] Semenov K. N., Charykov N. A. Solubility of Light Fullerenes and Derivatives. LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing GmbH & Co. KG, Saarbrücken, Germany, 238 pp. (2011).
[13] Semenov K. N., Charykov N. A., Keskinov V. A., et al. Solubility of Light Fullerenes in Organic Solvents. J. Chem. Eng. Data, 55, P. 13-36 (2010).
[14] Arapov O.V., Aksel'rod B.M., Pronkin A.A., et al. Solubility in the fullerene C60-fullerene C70-o-C6H4(CH3)2 system. Russian Journal of Applied Chemistry, 76(1), P. 33-36 (2003).
[15] Ponomarev A. N., Aksel'rod B. M., Barchenko V. T., et al. Solution-solid phase equilibria in the fullerene C60-fullerene C70-C6H5CH3 and fullerene C60-fullerene C70-o-C6H4(CH3)2 systems at 25 and 80 ° C, respectively. Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry, 74(12), P. 1942-1945 (2000).
[16] Gruzinskaya E. A., Keskinov V. A., Keskinova M.V., et al. Fullerene soot Produced by Electric Arch. Nanosystems: Physics, Chemistry, Mathematics, 3(6), P. 83-90 (2012).
