Post-fire restoration of plant communities with Paeonia tenuifolia in the Khvalynsky National Park (Russia) Текст научной статьи по специальности «Биологические науки»

POST-FIRE RESTORATION OF PLANT COMMUNITIES WITH PAEONIA TENUIFOLIA IN THE KHVALYNSKY NATIONAL PARK (RUSSIA)

Guzyaliya F. Suleymanova1,2*, Vladimir A. Boldyrev2**, Victor A. Savinov1

lKhvalynsky National Park, Russia *e-mail: suleymanovagf@mail.ru 2Saratov State University, Russia **e-mail: boldyrev52@bk.ru

Received: 20.11.2018. Revised: 25.05.2019. Accepted: 06.06.2019.

The paper considers indicators of the dynamics of plant communities with Paeonia tenuifolia before and after fire impact. Studies were conducted in the Khvalynsky National Park (forest-steppe zone of Russia) in 2008-2018. The authors conducted a complex study in burned and unburned plant communities. An assessment of the effects of fire impact and the development of a post-fire action plan were considered in the Protected Area. The plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis - Potentilla volgarica burned down in 2009. The plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Stipa pennata + Adonis vernalis - Anemone sylvestris was unburned. To characterise plant communities with Paeonia tenuifolia and its coenopopulations, we used standard geobotani-cal description methods. Sixty seven vascular plant species were part of the post-fire phytocoenosis. Of them, 14 species are included in the Red Data Book of the Saratov region. Changes in the post-fire plant community have occurred in the following order: 1) Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis - Stipa pennata (in 2008) ^ 2) Paeonia tenuifolia + Elymus repens + Stipa pennata + Adonis vernalis + Thalictrum simplex (in 2010) ^ 3) Paeonia tenuifolia - Stipa pennata - Calamagrostis epigejos + Festuca valesiaca +Phleum pratense + Poa bulbosa + Prunus tenella (in 2011) ^ 4) Paeonia tenuifolia + Adonis vernalis + Stipa pennata (in 2015, 2017, 2018). After the fire influence on a plant community, the following changes took place: 1) annuals and ruderal plant species appeared and increased their abundance; 2) the ratio of dominant species has changed. In 2012-2018, the phytocenotic role of Calamagrostis epigejos decreased, while the coverage and abundance of Stipa pennata increased at the same period. The abundance dynamics of Paeonia tenuifolia decreased in 2010, while in 2015-2018, its value gradually increased. The species richness of the post-pyrogenic plant community varied from 20 species in the first post-fire year to 38 species in the last study year. In the first post-fire year, the families Poaceae (six species), Leguminosae plants (three species), Rosaceae plants (three species) occupied the leading positions. During the post-pyrogenic succession, the dominant position of the listed families was not changing. Species of Composi-tae, Poaceae, Ranunculaceae families prevailed in the unburned plant community. Steppe plants dominated in the post-fire plant community: Stipa pennata, Adonis vernalis, and Paeonia tenuifolia. The leading ecologic-coenotic groups were steppe plants (70%), meadow plants (16%), forest plants (5%), and ruderal plants (9%). Weed-steppe plants were indicators of habitat disturbance by human activities. Among weed-steppe plants, there were Arenaria serpyllifolia, Viola rupestris, Erysimum canescens, Verbascum lychnitis. Gradient analysis of environmental conditions showed that the highest value of the vitality index (IVC = 1.15) corresponds to the best conditions for the growth and survival of the Paeonia tenuifolia population in the post-fire community. In the control site, the vitality index (IVC = 0.85) corresponded to unfavourable conditions for plant development. We studied the age spectra of the natural Paeonia tenuifolia populations in the burned and unburned communities. We showed that both populations were normal, complete, and young. The fire-damaged populations were younger than the populations in the unburned communities. We suggest the need of comprehensive monitoring studies to properly assess the fire effects and subsequent management actions for the vegetation restoration after fire influence.

Key words: age spectrum, forest-steppe zone, plant community, plant population, Protected Area, pyrogenic succession, rare species, Stipa pennata

Introduction

The factors of negative impact on ecosystems in Protected Areas (PAs) are well known. These are wildfires (Batista et al., 2018; Brooke et al., 2018), logging (Remis & Jost Robinson, 2012; Slaght & Surmach, 2016), pollution (Kataev, 2017; Rodri-guez-Jorquera et al., 2017), mining (Ferreira et al., 2014; Armendariz-Villegas et al., 2015), road network development and construction (Garriga et al., 2012; Slaght & Surmach, 2016). The pyrogenic effect is long-term and has had an adverse effect on

biological diversity for decades. It changes the composition and ratio of the areas of natural complexes (Lukyanova & Lukyanov, 2004; Perevoznikova et al., 2007). It also affects the abundance of many plant and animal species (Kuleshova & Korotkov, 2010; Goud, 2017). Fires are often catastrophic phenomena. They cause the death of plant and animal populations, ecosystems as a whole (Stepanitskiy & Shestakov, 2005; Pereira et al., 2016; Batista et al., 2018). Fires pose especially a serious threat to rare and protected (i.e. included in Red Data Books)

plant species, the number of which is usually small (Bystrushkin, 2018). For a long time, Russian programmes of environmental monitoring included the studies of the natural ecosystem dynamics and their separate components associated with wildfires in PAs. In particular, they focused on the populations of Red Data Book species. And this topic has not lost its relevance until the present days (Isaeva, 2000; Malysheva & Malakhovsky, 2000; Kulesho-va & Korotkov, 2010; Ilyina, 2011; Maslennikov & Maslennikova, 2011). The fire-caused change of the ecosystem is a pyrogenic succession (Komarova, 1980, 2009; Rozanov, 1999; Berezina & Afanasye-va, 2009). There are numerous studies focusing on the processes of pyrogenic succession of plant communities at different stages (Morozov, 1912; Curry & Fons, 1940; Korchagin, 1954; Belov, 1973; Rodin, 1981; Komarova, 1991, 1999, 2011; Agee, 1993; Isaeva, 2000; Popov, 2000; Oparin & Opa-rina, 2003; Ishutin, 2004; Golubtsova, 2012; Dusae-va, 2017). There is a lack of published data on this issue. According to some authors (e.g., Smelyanskiy et al., 2015), a fire in the steppe ecosystems does not lead to pyrogenic succession, but only changes the coenotic activity. It also causes pyrogenic fluctuations of the plant community including the projective cover of some species. There is especially little information about the attitude to the fire impact on population status of certain plant species.

The flora of the Saratov region consists of 1741 species of vascular plants (Elenevskiy et al., 2008). Of them, 285 species are listed in the Red Data Book of Saratov region (2006), including 42 species included in the Red Data Book of the Russian Federation (2008). Plant communities, which include Red Data Book species, are unique, sometimes one of a kind. Paeonia tenuifolia L. is one of the rare and protected species. This is a tuberiferous short-rhizome herbaceous perennial plant, optional calciphile, and a representative of Mediterranean steppe vegetation (Red Data Book of Saratov region, 2006). It is included in the Red Data Book of Saratov region (2006) with category 2 (V) - vulnerable, and listed in the Red Data Book of the Russian Federation (2008) with category 2B -declining in number. The species is also listed in the Appendix 1 of the Bern convention (Belousova et al., 2008). Paeonia tenuifolia has a discontinuous distribution area (Nosova, 1973). In the southeast of European Russia, its natural range is limited by the River Volga. In the south, its range borders with the North Caucasus and the Crimean peninsula. In the west, the distribution area is interrupted,

and Paeonia tenuifolia can be found in Ukraine and Central Europe (Romania, Bulgaria), in the southwest of Eurasia, in Asia Minor and Iran. The peculiarities of the ecological-phytocenotic organisation and the island character of the range indicate its relictness.

Along the southern limits of the forest-steppe on the right bank of the River Volga, the species inhabits open areas, pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) forests on the limestone outputs, chalky-covered sods on slopes with a northern exposure (Nosova, 1973). In the Saratov region, Paeonia tenuifolia is distributed in some districts located on the right bank of the River Volga: Atkarsky district, Balashovsky district, Volsky district, Kalininsky district, Krasno-armeysky district, Khvalynsky district, Saratovsky district. The most significant localities of this Red Data Book species are known on the Volsky-Kh-valynsky ridge (Red Data Book of Saratov region, 2006; Elenevskiy et al., 2008). Paeonia tenuifolia grows in Stipeta pennatae - Festucosa valesiaca -Herbosa plant communities, steppe meadows, forest edges, shrub communities and on the sides of valleys, and on sandy steppes and hills (Red Data Book of Saratov region, 2006).

One of the necessary measures for the Paeonia tenuifolia protection is the study of its population status, implemented through the monitoring programme of plant communities in the Khvalynsky National Park. Since 2007, in the Khvalynskiy district, the studies of the status of Paeonia tenuifolia populations have been carried out (Suleymanova, 2010).

The aim of this current study was to identify the post-fire restoration patterns of plant communities with Paeonia tenuifolia. The following tasks were to be solved: 1) to characterise the natural plant communities after fire impact; 2) to analyse the plant community dynamics in 2008-2018; 3) to investigate the morphological traits of Paeonia tenuifolia individuals, floristic and coenotic composition of the plant community, age structure of the Paeonia tenuifolia population; 4) to estimate the conservation significance of the studied fire-damaged communities in comparison to the similar unburned plant community.

Material and Methods

Field studies have been carried out in 20082018. In order to characterise plant communities with Paeonia tenuifolia and its coenopopulations (Fig. 1), we used standard methods of geobotani-cal description (Tarasov, 1981; Matveev, 2006; Mirkin & Naumova, 2012).

Portugal

Ireland

United Kingdom

Norwegian Sea

/ North See

France Norway

' P^ I

Denmark

Germany

r

Vf^B

Ш

„ Latvia st-ыо Belarus

lay

Sweden

Greenland Sea

|SfVÀL8ARI>

Arctic Ocean

Barents Sea

Kara Sea

Chukchi Sea

Bering Sea

East Siberian Se«

Laptev Sea

Moscow

oeiarus

9щ \ vT-,

геесе Москва

Ukraine

Sea of Okhotsk

Turkey

Egypt 4 . ' \ -

\ Azerbaijan

re"

Sudan

ЧвА

Fig. 1. Location of study sites in the Khvalynsky National Park, Saratov region, Russia. Site 1 - the post-fire plant community

Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis - Potentilla volgarica on the southern slope of mountain Piche-Panda in the vicinity of the village Staraya Lebezhayka, Khvalynsky district. Site 2 - unburned plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Stipa pennata + Adonis vernalis - Anemone sylvestris, Sosnovo-Mazinskoe forestry.

The Khvalynsky National Park is located in the northern part of the Saratov region in Khvalynsky district at the border of the Middle Volga region and Lower Volga region. It occupies the remnant massif of Khvalynskye hills of the Volga Upland and part of the River Tereshka Valley in the vicinity of the town of Khvalynsk (Makarov, 2008). In accordance with the botanical-geographical division, the region under the study belongs to the Central Russian (Upper Don) subprovince of the Eastern European forest-steppe province of the Euro-Asian steppe region. Zonal vegetation types are deciduous forests and meadow steppes (Tarasov, 1977). Forests are confined to the highlands, on the plains yielding to the meadow steppes. The National Park area is 260.37 km2. It is covered mainly by forests. The buffer zone of the National Park «Khvalynsky» is 1148.0 km2.

There are both true steppes and meadow steppes in the buffer zone of the Khvalynsky National Park. The steppe component dominates (60%) in the forest-steppes of the Khvalynsky National Park. Forests and meadow steppes extend from the northeast to the southwest of the Protected Area. In meadow steppes, zonal plant communities are phytocoenoses with domination of Stipa pennata L., Stipa capillata L. These plant communities are Stipeta pennatae -Bromopsisosa riparia - Pluriherbosa, Stipeta capil-latae - Festucosa valesiaca - Herbosa, and Stipeta

pennatae - Festucosa valesiaca - Herbosa. They form the narrow belts, which are almost always located directly near the forest areas, occupying dry ec-otopes along slopes on chernozems. Sometimes they are distributed along small areas in the lower parts of the slopes. Meadow steppes have a rich species composition (60-70 species). These plant communities have a complex horizontal and vertical structure. Shrubs play a significant role in some of these plant communities. However, they usually do not form a layer. The main coenose-forming species are Stipa pennata and Stipa capillata and rhizomatous cereals (Bromopsis riparius Rehmann, Poa angustifolia L.). There are the following steppe cereals: Festuca valesiaca Schleich. ex Gaudin, Koeleria pyramidata P. Beauv., Phleum phleoides (L.) H. Carst., but their role is not high in formation of plant communities. The meadow-steppe herbaceous species (Fragaria viridis Weston, Securigera varia (L.) Lassen, Galium verum L., Salvia nemorosa L.) are widely represented (Malysheva & Malakhovsky, 2008).

The climate of the Khvalynsky National Park is continental. The summer is warm and dry. The winter is moderately cold and snowless. Daily, seasonal and annual fluctuations in the temperature of air and soil are typical for the weather conditions. The average annual temperature ranges from 5.2°C to 7.9°C. The average January isotherm is -13°C. The average

July temperature is +20.5°C. The relative humidity is 70%, the average annual precipitation is 425-450 mm (Anikin, 2013). To study pyrogenic changes, the following plant communities were selected:

1) Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epige-jos (L.) Roth + Adonis vernalis L., with Potentilla volgarica Juz. microgroups occupied the middle and lower parts of the southern slope of the mountain Piche-Panda in the vicinity of the village Staraya Leb-ezhayka, Khvalynsky district (52.65478 N, 47.86317 E), 185 m a.s.l. The total projective cover was 70%. The projective cover of Paeonia tenuifolia was 40%. The species number in the plant community was 67. The phytocoenosis was polydominant. The following co-dominants were found: Stipa pennata, Paeonia tenuifolia, Adonis vernalis. The soil is sod-calcareous.

On 8 May 2009, 3 km west of the village Staraya Lebezhayka (Khvalynsky district of the Saratov region), a fire broke out in the forest. The cause of the ignition was an unextinguished picnic campfire. A crown fire lasted for several hours and spread over an area of 0.5 km2. It reached the height of about 20 m. The wildfire was also caused by steady dry weather conditions for almost two weeks, as the last precipitation (1.3 mm) before the fire dates back to 22 April. The average daily air temperature on 7 May was +16.7°C. The maximum value reached +22.7°C. The wind was 6-12 m/s. It also contributed to the fire spread. The consequences of the fire impact were catastrophic. The forest on the west of the mountain Piche-Panda (Volskoe forestry) was burned down. The fire spread to the east was stopped by the field road and the guard service of the Khvalynsky National Park. A botanical description of the burned steppe area was made a week later. Since 2008, a permanent study plot has been located on this site to monitor the status of the plant community with Paeonia tenuifo-lia. Therefore, we had an opportunity to compare its status before and after fire influence.

2) Unburned plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Stipa pennata + Adonis vernalis -Anemone sylves-tris L. is located on a site 300 m from the forest of the Sosnovo-Mazinskoe forestry (52.32602 N, 47.92722 E). The fire break was located from the north of the plant community. The total projective cover was 80%, including up to 30% projective cover of Paeonia tenuifolia. The plant community consisted of 69 species. This plant community is polydominant with the following co-dominants: Stipa pennata, Paeonia tenuifolia, Adonis vernalis, Anemone sylvestris. The soil is sod-carbonate. The unburned plant community was located under similar physical-geographical conditions with the unburned one. Therefore, we used

these data for its comparison with the burned plant community vegetation.

We studied the plant communities according to the standard methodics (Yaroshenko, 1969; Voronov, 1973; Mirkin & Rosenberg, 1983; Mirkin & Naumo-va, 2012). We estimated the species participation in each plant community by indicating the percentage of projective cover (Tarasov, 1981). To estimate the frequency of occurrence/coverage of a species, we used the scale of Drude (1890). The symbols are as follows: soc (socialis) -dominant species, frequency of occurrence/coverage exceeds 90%; cop3 (copiosus) -abundant species, frequency of occurrence/coverage is up to 80%; cop2 -species is represented by numerous individuals, frequency of occurrence/coverage is up to 20%; cop1 - frequency of occurrence/coverage is up to 4%; sp (sparsus) - frequency of occurrence/ coverage about 0.8%; sol (solitarus) - scanty individuals, frequency of occurrence/coverage not exceeds 0.16%; un (unicum) - single individual.

We defined phenophases and phenological events (Haggerty & Mazer, 2008) using the BBCH-scale (Zadoks et al., 1974; Meier, 2001; Meier et al., 2009; Polikarpova & Makarova, 2016). This system is used in Europe for a uniform coding of phenologically similar plant growth. For each Paeonia tenuifolia individual, we determined the following morphological parameters: plant height, corolla diametre, number of leaves, leaf length.

We determined the following coenotic groups according to Belgard (1950), and Albitskaya (1960): stepants (steppe plants), sylvants (forest plants), pa-ludants (marsh plants), pratants (meadow plants), ru-derants (wasteland plants), stepants-ruderants (weed-steppe plants), silvants-ruderants (weedy forest plants), pratants-ruderants (weedy meadow plants).

To estimate the demographic characteristics of Paeonia tenuifolia in a population, we defined the follow indices: recovery index - I (Glotov,

J recovery v '

1998), replacement index - I , t, age index - I

/' r replacement' & age

(A) (Uranov, 1975), efficiency index - Iefficiency (ro) (Zhivotovsky, 2001), index of species plasticity - ISP (iVC / IVC .) (Ishbirdin & Ishmuratova, 2004).

v max mm-7 v ' '

To assess the species similarity of the studied phytocoenoses, we used the Jaccard similarity index (Jaccard, 1901). For protected species (i.e. listed in the Red Data Book of Saratov region (2006)), we calculated the value of conservation significance R according to Bednova (2004). We visually determined the ontogenetic status of Paeonia tenu-ifolia individuals by determining the following age classes based on morphometric traits: juvenile (j), immature (im), virginile (v), generative (g0, g1, g2,

g 3) and post-generative senile (s), and subsenile (ss) age classes (Rabotnov, 1983; Mozgovaya et al., 2007; Serikova et al., 2013).

The statistical analysis has been processed by conventional methods using Statistica 6.0 software. We used Maevskiy (2014) for identifying plants. Scientific names of the plant species are given according to The Plant List (2019).

Results and Discussion

During the fire on 8 May 2009, dry grass, dead ground cover and aboveground parts of shrubs got

burnt. It seemed that the fire caused irreparable damage to the plant community. On 15 May 2009, we found that an aspect was black with bright-green large dots represented by vegetative and flowering plants on the study plots. These were mainly represented by short-rooted perennials Thalictrum simplex L., Vincetoxicum hirundinaria Medik., Potentilla incana P. Gaertn., B. Mey. & Scherb., and Potentilla volgarica. The floristic composition of the plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Cal-amagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis before the fire impact is demonstrated in Table 1.

Species Abundance Cover, % Height, cm Growth stage

BBCH code Phenological event title

Shrubs

Prunus tenella Batsch. sol < 1 20-25 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Cerasus fruticosa (Pall.) Woronow. un < 1 20-30 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Semishrubs

Alyssum lenense Adams. sol < 1 5-10 65 Full flowering

Onosma simplicissima L. sol 1 20-25 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Perennial herbs

Astragalus buchtormensis Pall. sol < 1 18-10 65 Full flowering

Adonis vernalis L. sP 3 20-25 86 / 10b First ripe fruits

Achillea setacea Waldst. & Kit. un < 1 5-10 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Securigera varia (L.) Lassen un < 1 10-15 12 3 leaves unfolded

Calamagrostis epigejos (L.) Roth. coP, 5-15 15-20 12 3 leaves unfolded

Carex praecox Schreb. sol < 1 5-10 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Psephellus marschallianus (Spreng.) K. Koch un + 5-10 60/13 First flower open, 5 leaves unfolded

Eremogone longifolia (M. Bieb.) Fenzl. sol < 1 31 69-71 End of flowering, witery ripe

Euphorbia esula subsp. tommasiniana (Bertol.) Kuzmanov sol < 1 15 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Galium octonarium (Klokov) Pobed. sol < 1 15-20 12 3 leaves unfolded

Potentilla volgarica Juz. sol < 1 10-30 65 Full flowering

Plantago urvillei Opiz sol < 1 5 11 Leaf unfolded

Paeonia tenuifolia L. coP3 25-50 5-25 / 20-40 81-86 First ripe fruits

Polygala nicaeensis subsp. mediterranea Chodat un < 1 15-20 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Salvia tesquicola Klok. & Pobed. sol < 1 5-10 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Salvia nutans L. sol < 1 5-10 12 3-5 leaves unfolded

Seseli libanotis (L.) W. D. J. Koch. un < 1 5-10 12 3-5 leaves unfolded

Stipa pennata L. sol 5 30-55 65 Full flowering

Taraxacum campylodes G. E. Haglund. sol < 1 5-10 11 Leaf unfolded

Thalictrum simplex L. sol < 1 25 11 Leaf unfolded

Vincetoxicum hirundinaria Medik. sol < 1 25-30 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Veronica spicata subsp. incana (L.) Walters un < 1 15 11 Leaf unfolded

Biennials

Erysimum aureum M. Bieb. sol < 1 10-25 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Verbascum lychnitis L. sol < 1 5-10 11 Leaf unfolded

Table 1. The floristic composition and characteristics of the plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis - Stipapennata before the fire impact (15.05.2008), Khvalynsky National Park, Saratov region, Russia

Table 1 shows that the species richness of the plant community was 26-28 species before the fire impact. The species density was not exceeding 7-12 species (Fig. 2A). Paeonia tenuifolia was the most abundant species. Its projective cover was 40-50%. Calamagrostis epigejos made an aspect with a projective cover of 15-20%. The remaining species had a low abundance and pro-jective cover (Table 1). The general aspect was bright-green. We determined three layers in the plant community (Fig. 2B).

The first layer was 40-60 cm in height, consisting mainly of the generative shoots of Paeonia tenuifolia (30-40 cm) and Stipa pennata (50-60 cm). The projective cover was about 50%. The second layer (20-30 cm in height) was the most productive and viable. It was represented by a large species number of different life forms. Of them, there were shrubs Prunus tenella Batsch, Cerasus fruticosa Pall.; semishrubs: Onosma simplicissima L., Alyssum lenense Adams; perennials: Adonis vernalis, Potentilla volgarica, Thalictrum simplex, Vincetoxicum hirundinaria. There were no annual plants. The projective cover was about 30%. The third layer was 5-10 cm in height. It was represented mainly by leaf rosettes of perennial herbs (Plantago urvillei Opiz, Salvia tesquicola Klok. & Pobed., Salvia nutans L., Seseli libanotis (L.) W.D.J. Koch, Taraxacum campylodes G.E. Haglund). The projective cover was 15-20%.

In 2009, single vegetative shoots of Potentilla volgarica, Thalictrum simplex, Vincetoxicum hirundinaria, and flowering shoots of Potentilla

incana were found on this study site seven days after the fire impact. The projective cover was 3%. The aspect was black with bright-green spots of vegetating herbs.

One year later, the plant community had recovered. However, the weather conditions in 2010 were extreme for the steppe and forest vegetation (Chub, 2011; Lewis et al., 2011a,b; Report, 2011; Solovyov et al., 2011; Polyakova & Melankholin, 2013). Table 2 provides a description of the burnt site one year after the fire.

The plant community showed a greenish aspect with strawy hue and burgundy spots of Paeonia tenuifolia. In general, the flora of the plant community consisted of 20 species. There were no annual plants, despite the fact that the fire impact stimulated their germination, and the substrate was updated (Malysheva & Malakhovsky, 2008). The floristic composition decreased quantitatively and changed qualitatively. The shrubs (e.g. Prunus tenella) and semishrubs (e.g. Onosma simplicissima) recovered. At the same time, the Volga-Don endemic Asperula tephrocarpa Czern. ex Popov & Chrshan. appeared. We found that rhizomatous plants, bulbous plants and seeds of annual plants are fire-resistant, with a density of 7-8 species per 1 m2. The dominant Paeonia tenuifolia and co-dominant Elymus repens (L.) Gould had a maximum projective cover. Other plant species have low values of both abundance and projective cover. The newly formed vegetative cover was fairly uniform. The vertical structure of the plant community was on an initial development stage. The total projective cover was 60%.

Fig. 2. Horizontal (A) and vertical (B) projections of herb cover in the plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis before the fire impact (15.05.2008) in the Khvalynsky National Park, Saratov region, Russia (area: 1 m2). Designations: 1 - Paeonia tenuifolia, 2 - Astragalus buchtormensis, 3 - Erysimum aureum, 4 - Verbascum lychnitis, 5 - Onosma simplicissima, 6 - Adonis vernalis, 7 - Stipa pennata, 8 - Calamagrostis epigejos.

Table 2. Floristic composition and characteristics of the plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Elymus repens + Stipa pennata + Adonis vernalis + Thalictrum simplex investigated one year after the fire impact (12.05.2010), Khvalynsky National Park, Saratov region, Russia

Species Abundance Cover, % Height, cm Growth stage

BBCH code Phenological event title

Shrubs

Prunus tenella Batsch. sol < 1 15 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Semishrubs

Onosma simplicissima L. sol < 1 20 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Asperula tephrocarpa Czern. ex Ledeb. un < 1 8 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Perennial herbs

Adonis vernalis L. sp-gr 2 20 81 / 10a First ripe fruits

Astragalus buchtormensis Pall. un < 1 10-20 65 Full flowering

Psephellus marschallianus (Spreng.) K. Koch un < 1 8 60, 13 First flower open, 5 leaves unfolded

Securigera varia (L.) Lassen sol 1 10 12 3 leaves unfolded

Carex praecox Schreb. sol < 1 20 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Elymus repens (L.) Gould соРз 30 20 11 Leaf unfolded

Gagea bulbifera (Pall.) Salisb. un < 1 10-15 81-86 First ripe fruits

Galium tinctorium L. un < 1 20 11 Leaf unfolded

Galium verum L. un < 1 10-15 60 First flower open, 5 leaves unfolded

Paeonia tenuifolia L. соРз 35 10-25/ 20-50 65, 19 Full flowering / 9 or more leaves unfolded

Potentilla incana P. Gaerth., B. Mey. & Scherb. un < 1 10 65 Full flowering

Potentilla volgarica Juz. sol < 1 15-25 65 Full flowering

Salvia nutans L. sol 1 10 51, 15-16 First flower buds visible / 6 or more leaves unfolded

Stipa pennata L. соР, 10 20-60 65 Full flowering

Thalictrum simplex L. sol 2 30 51, 15-16 First flower buds visible / 6 or more leaves unfolded

Vincetoxicum hirundinaria Medik. sol < 1 25-35 51, 19 First flower buds visible / 9 or more leaves unfolded

Biennials

Verbascum lychnitis L. sol < 1 15 10 Leaf unfolded

Thus, the first post-fire restoration stage was manifested by the change of the 2008 plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis - Stipa pennata into the 2010 plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Elymus repens + Stipa pennata + Adonis vernalis + Thalictrum simplex. However, this phytocoenosis was not richer in species richness and had all the features contributing to the formation of a more productive plant community. However, further 2011 observations demonstrated a start of changes in this phytocoenosis. So, in 2011 the species composition of the fire-damaged plant community increased to 31 species (Table 3).

The aspect was straw hue-greenish with burgundy spots. It was formed by dead cereals (straw colour) and Paeonia tenuifolia (green colour with burgundy spots). According to lifeform classification, there were one shrub (Prunus tenella), two semishrubs (Onosma simplicissima,

Asperula tephrocarpa), and 24 perennial species. The cereals were represented by various values of a projective cover. For example, the projective cover of Phleum pratense L., Poa bulbosa L., and Festuca valesiaca was 10-15%, while the projective cover of Stipa pennata, and Calamagrostis epigejos was 30-40%. Annual plants appeared (Draba nemorosa L., Androsace maxima L., Alyssum linifolium Stephan ex Willd.). In this plant community, the density was 8-13 species per 1 m2 (Fig. 3).

We found a high projective cover for the dominant Calamagrostis epigejos. The impact of both fire and drought caused the elimination of the biennial Erysimum aureum M. Bieb., and the perennials Veronica spicata subsp. incana (L.) Walters, Salvia tesquicola, Plantago urvillei, Seseli libanotis, Polygala nicaeensis subsp. mediterranea Chodat, Psephellus marschallianus (Spreng.) K. Koch, and Alyssum lenense.

Table 3. Floristic composition and characteristics of the plant community Paeonia tenuifolia - Stipa pennata - Calamagrostis epigejos + Festuca valesiaca + Phleum pratense + Poa bulbosa + Prunus tenella investigated two years after the fire impact (20.05.2011), Khvalynsky National Park, Saratov region, Russia

Species Abundance Cover, % Height, cm Growth stage

BBCH code Phenological event title

Shrubs

Prunus tenella Batsch. sol 5 20 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Semishrubs

Onosma simplicissima L. sol 5 20 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Asperula tephrocarpa Czern. ex. Popov & Chrshan. un + 10 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Perennial herbs

Adonis vernalis L. sol 3 30 19 All leaves unfolded

Astragalus buchtormensis Pall. sol < 1 15 65 Full flowering

Achillea setacea Waldst. & Kit. sol < 1 10 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Calamagrostis epigejos (L.) Roch. COP3 35-40 20 12 3 leaves unfolded

Carex praecox Schreb. sol < 1 20 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Eremogone longifolia (M. Bieb.) Fenzl. sol < 1 31 69, 81-86 End of flowering, First ripe fruits

Euphorbia esula subsp. tommasiniana (Bertol.) Kuzmanov sol < 1 15 19 All leaves unfolded

Gagea bulbifera (Pall.) Salisb. un + 11 69, 81-86 End of flowering, First ripe fruits

Globularia punctata Lapeyr. sol < 1 10 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Gypsophila altissima L. un + 10 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Festuca valesiaca Schleich. ex. Gaudin COP1 10-15 28-29 69, 81-86 End of flowering, First ripe fruits

Hedysarum grandiflorum Pall. sol 5 10 19 All leaves unfolded

Origanum vulgare L. sol < 1 10-15 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Phleum pratense L. COP1 10-15 24 12 3 leaves unfolded

Poa bulbosa L. COP1 10-15 15-26 69, 81-86 End of flowering, First ripe fruits

Potentilla volgarica Juz. sol < 1 30 51/19 Fist flower bud visible, all leaves unfolded

Potentilla incana P. Gaerth., B. Mey. & Scherb. sol < 1 15 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Paeonia tenuifolia L. COP3 35 10-30,25-55 69, 81-86 End of flowering, First ripe fruits

Salvia nutans L. sol 1 15 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Securigera varia (L.) Lassen sol < 1 15 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Stipa pennata L. COP3 30 30-60 65 Full flowering

Taraxacum campylodes G. E. Haglund sol < 1 10-15 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Thalictrum simplex L. sol < 1 30 3-5 leaves unfolded

Vincetoxicum hirundinaria Medic. sol < 1 30 51/19 Fist flower bud visible, all leaves unfolded

Biennials

Verbascum lychnitis L. sol < 1 15 12-13 3-5 leaves unfolded

Annuals

Draba nemorosa L. un + 25 69, 81-86 End of flowering, First ripe fruits

Androsace maxima L. sol < 1 15 19 All leaves unfolded

Alyssum linifolium Stephan ex. Willd. un + 20 65 Full flowering

Fig. 3. Horizontal (A) and vertical (B) projections of herb cover in the plant community Paeonia tenuifolia - Stipa pennata -Calamagrostis epigejos + Festuca valesiaca + Phleum pratense + Poa bulbosa + Prunus tenella at the burned site two years after the fire impact (20.05.2011), Khvalynsky National Park, Saratov region, Russia (area: 1 m2). Designations: 1 - Paeonia tenuifolia, 2 - Astragalus buchtormensis, 3 - Draba nemorosa, 4 - Verbascum lychnitis, 5 - Salvia nutans, 6 - Androsace maxima, 7 - Stipa pennata, 8 - Calamagrostis epigejos.

The monocarpic herbaceous Seseli libanotis has polycyclic monopodally growing shoots with vertical rhizomes. Due to the peculiarities of its life cycle, this species has a cyclical participation in the composition of plant communities (Rabotnov, 1972; Knapp, 1974). Perhaps, a fire destroyed a few virginile Seseli libanotis individuals, which would be consequently turn into a generative stage and produce seeds. So, the cycle of the Seseli libanotis development ended on the study site in 2011. Outside the study plot, Polygala nicaeensis subsp. mediterranea, Psephellus marschallianus, Alys-sum lenense were found. Therefore, they are likely to recover on this study site. A sharp decrease in the competition caused by the fire impact, was contributing to an appearance of R-strategy plants (Grime, 1979) in the burnt area. They are the little competitive vegetatively mobile perennials (e.g. Euphorbia esula subsp. tommasiniana (Bertol.) Kuzmanov), annuals and biennials (e.g. Draba nemorosa, An-drosace maxima, Alyssum linifolium Stephan ex. Willd., Verbascum lychnitis L.), as well as weeds, like Vincetoxicum hirundinaria and Taraxacum campylodes. The presence of R-strategy species indicated a habitat disturbance and possible subsequent changes in structure of the plant community toward reducing the number of R-strategy plants, and ratio of the main phytocoenosis components (Rabotnov, 1972). We also noted the appearance of the following perennials: Phleum pratense, Poa bulbosa, Festuca valesiaca, Eremogone longifolia (M. Bieb.) Fenzl, Potentilla incana, and Origanum vulgare L.. Layers were well distinguishable (Fig. 3B). The first layer consisted of Stipapennata (60 cm in height), vegetative shoots of Calamagrostis epigejos, generative shoots of Paeonia tenuifolia (30-50 cm in height). The second layer was formed by Paeonia tenuifolia vegetative shoots and perennial herbs in both vegetation and flowering stages. The third layer consisted of leaf rosettes of perennials and ephemeral annuals. The total projective cover was 65-70%.

The competition strongly limited the participation of some species in the plant community. The fire-caused competition reduction affected the increase of a coenose-forming role of Calamagrostis epigejos in the plant community. Table 4 shows the 2008-2018 plant community dynamics with indication of the species composition and their projective cover.

Over the study years, we found 67 plant species. In 2015, the total projective cover was 70%. The projective cover of Paeonia tenuifolia was 35%, while a value of this indicator for Adonis

vernalis was 8%. The general aspect was whitish-green with blooming spots of Paeonia tenuifolia. This plant community was named as Paeonia tenu-ifolia + Adonis vernalis + Stipa pennata (Herbo-sae - Stipapennatae). In 2017, the total projective cover was 70%, whereas the projective cover of Paeonia tenuifolia was 37%. In 2018, the total projective cover of the plant community was 80%, including 35% of projective cover of Paeonia tenui-folia. The general aspect was green with a white mosaic of flowering Vincetoxicum hirundinaria. The species composition was the richest in 2017 with 38 plants. In 2018, the number of species in the plant community was 33.

Thus the fire was not so catastrophic, as we expected earlier. Moreover, it had rather positive consequences for the steppe vegetation. The fire impact caused the change from Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis - Stipa pennata in 2008 to Paeonia tenuifolia + Elymus repens + Stipa pennata + Adonis vernalis + Thal-ictrum simplex in 2010. Then the plant community transformed into and the Paeonia tenuifolia - Stipa pennata - Calamagrostis epigejos + Festuca vale-siaca + Phleum pratense + Poa bulbosa + Prunus tenella in 2011. The phytocoenotic role of Calamagrostis epigejos started decreasing from 2012 to 2018. In contrary, the projective coverage of Stipa pennata increased twice. Although the projective coverage of Paeonia tenuifolia decreased directly after the 2010 fire impact, in 2015-2018 both the projective cover and abundance of Paeonia tenui-folia increased. Thus, the Paeonia tenuifolia restoration was characterised by an increase in projec-tive cover, abundance and vitality.

Xerophytic and mesoxerophytic plant species of different life forms turned out to be resistant to fire impact. Among them, there are Prunus tenella, Onosma simplicissima, Adonis vernalis, Astragalus buchtormensis Pall., Calamagrostis epigejos, Potentilla volgarica, Paeonia tenuifolia, Stipa pennata, Securigera varia, Thalictrum simplex, Vincetoxicum hirundinaria, and Verbascum lych-nitis. These species have been present in the plant community both before and after the fire impact for ten years. These species are called pyrophytes.

Some species participated in the plant community structure from time to time, being present at certain years and being absent in other years. Among them, there are the xeromesophyt-ic hemicryptophytes Psephellus marschallianus, Eremogone longifolia, and Galium octonarium (Klokov) Pobed.

Table 4. Changes of the projective coverage in the plant community Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis - Potentilla volgarica during study years (2008-2018) in the Khvalynsky National Park, Saratov region, Russia

Species Projective cover of species per study year, %

2008 2009 2010 2011 2015 2017 2018

Shrubs

Prunus tenella Batsch. < 1 - < 1 5 3 - < 1

Cerasus fruticosa (Pall.) Woronow. < 1 - - - - - -

Semi-shrubs

Alyssum tortuosum Willd. - - - - < 1 < 1 < 1

Alyssum lenense Adams. < 1 - - - < 1 - -

Onosma simplicissima L. 1 - < 1 5 < 1 1 < 1

Asperula tephrocarpa Czern. ex. Popov & Chrshan. - - < 1 + - < 1 < 1

Perennials

Asparagus officinalis L. - - - - - < 1 -

Adonis vernalis L. 3 - 2 3 8 8 1

Astragalus buchtormensis Pall. < 1 - < 1 < 1 1 0.9 < 1

Astragalus testiculatus Pall. - - - - - 0.9 -

Arenaria serpyllifolia L. - - - - - - < 1

Achillea setacea Waldst. & Kit. < 1 - - < 1 - < 1 -

Bromus inermis Leyss - - - - - - 1

Calamagrostis epigejos (L.) Roth. 5-15 - - 35-40 - < 1 1

Carex praecox Schreb. < 1 - < 1 < 1 < 1 0.3 -

Psephellus marschallianus (Spreng.) K. Koch + - < 1 - < 1 - < 1

Elymus repens (L.) Gould - - 30 - - - -

Eremogone longifolia (M. Bieb.) Fenzl < 1 - - < 1 - + -

Euphorbia esula subsp. tommasiniana (Bertol.) Kuzmanov < 1 - - < 1 - - -

Euphorbia glareosa Pall. ex M. Bieb. - - - - - - < 1

Gagea bulbifera (Pall.) Salisb. - - < 1 + - 0.9 < 1

Galium tinctorium L. - - < 1 - < 1 - < 1

Galium octonarium (Klokov) Pobed. < 1 - - - - 0.4 < 1

Galium verum L. - - < 1 - - - -

Globularia punctata Lapeyr. - - - < 1 - < 1 < 1

Gypsophila altissima L. - - - + < 1 - -

Gypsophila volgensis Krasnova - - - - - < 1 < 1

Festuca valesiaca Schleich. ex Gaudin - - - 10-15 - 1 < 1

Filipendula vulgaris Moench - - - - - < 1 < 1

Hedysarum grandiflorum Pall. - - - 5 - < 1 < 1

Koeleria pyramidata P. Beauv. - - - - - - -

Medicago lupulina L. - - - - < 1 - -

Nonea pulla (L.) DC. - - - - - < 1

Origanum vulgare L. - - - < 1 - < 1 -

Oxytropis pillosa (L.) DC. - - - < 1 - -

Phleum pratense L. - - - 10-15 < 1 - < 1

Plantago urvillei Opiz. < 1 - - - - - -

Poa bulbosa L. - - - 10-15 - - -

Potentilla volgarica Juz. < 1 - < 1 < 1 - < 1 < 1

Potentilla incana P. Gaertn., B. Mey. & Scherb. - + < 1 < 1 - < 1

Potentilla recta L. - - - - - < 1 < 1

Polygala nicaeensis subsp. mediterranea Chodat. < 1 - - - - - -

Polygala sibirica L. - - - - - < 1 -

Paeonia tenuifolia L. 25-50 - 35 35 35 37.3 40

Salvia nutans L. < 1 - - 1 1 0.9 2

Salvia nemorosa L. < 1 - - - - - -

Seseli libanotis (L.) W.D.J. Koch < 1 - - - - - -

Securigera varia (L.) Lassen < 1 - < 1 < 1 - < 1 < 1

Stipa pennata L. 5 - - 30 2.4 1.3 2

Stachys recta L. - - - - - < 1 1

Taraxacum campylodes G. F. Haglund. < 1 - - < 1 - < 1 -

Thalictrum simplex L. < 1 + - < 1 - < 1 < 1

Trinia multicaulis (Poir.) Schischk. - - - - - 1 -

Vincetoxicum hirundinaria Medik. < 1 + < 1 < 1 - < 1 < 1

Veronica austriaca L. - - - - < 1 - < 1

Veronica spicata subsp. incana (L.) Walters < 1 - - - - - -

Veronica verna L. - - - - - < 1 -

Viola rupestris F.W. Schmidt. - - - - < 1 - 1

Biennials

Erysimum aureum M. Bieb. < 1 - - - - - -

Erysimum canescens Roth. - - - - - < 1 -

Verbascum lychnitis L. < 1 - < 1 < 1 - < 1 < 1

Verbascum orientale (L.) All. - - - - - < 1 -

Annuals

Draba nemorosa L. - - - + - < 1 -

Androsace maxima L. - - - < 1 - < 1 -

Alyssum linifolium Stephan ex. Willd. - - - + - - -

Total 28 4 20 31 18 38 33

Some species were eliminated from the plant community after the impact of the fire and drought. These are perennials (Salvia nemorosa, Polygala nicaeensis subsp. mediterranea, Plan-tago urvillei, Seseli libanotis, Veronica spicata subsp. incana), and the shrub Cerasus fruticosa. Most of them were meso-xerophytic and xero-mesophytic hemicryptophytes.

The analysis of the coenotic groups showed the predomination of steppe plants (stepants) (60.85%) in the studied post-fire plant community. Among them, Stipa pennata, Adonis vernalis, Paeonia tenuifolia, Onosma simplicissima, and Galium ver-um had the highest projective cover. The meadow plants (pratants) were represented by 17.60% of the species in the plant community. Among them, there are cereals (Calamagrostis epigejos, Bromus inermis Leyss., Phleum pratense), herbaceous perennials (Securigera varia, Thalictrum simplex, Filipendula vulgaris Moench, Asparagus officinalis L.). The presence of forest species (sylvants) (6.21%) was to be expected, as the plant community was located near the forest massif. The forest species were represented by the shrub Prunus tenella, the herbs Erysimum aureum, Origanum vulgare, and Gagea bulbifera (Pall.) Salisb.

In their study of steppe plant communities with Hedysarum grandiflorum Pall. in the Volga Upland region, Lavrentiev & Boldyrev (2016) indicated the following species groups ratio: 64.05% of stepants (steppe plants), 7.84% of pratants (meadow plants), 9.15% of sylvants (forest plants), 18.96%

of ruderants (ruderal plants), ruderants-stepants, ruderant-pratants, rudrants-sylvants. Hedysarum grandiflorum inhabited a chalky substrate, where disturbance factors were more pronounced and more complex than under intact conditions. These factors were wind and water erosion, soil freezing in winter due to the absence of dry grass remnants, possible soil salinisation.

The presence of ruderal species (16.80%) (Vincetoxicum hirundinaria, Viola rupestris F.W. Schmidt, Arenaria serpyllifolia L., and Nonea pulla (L.) DC.) in the studied plant community with Paeonia tenuifolia indicated a certain level of habitat disturbance. The latter resulted of the fire impact and its consequences, moderate grazing, and natural factors (water and wind erosion). The effect of these factors is reduced due to an increase in the general projective cover of the vegetation, soil fertilisation with ash elements, and the general mesophytisation of the Paeonia tenuifolia habitat.

In 2018, we found 14 more species new for the plant community: Alyssum tortuosum Willd., Asparagus officinalis, Euphorbia glareosa Pall. ex M. Bieb., Gypsophila volgensis Krasnova, Festuca valesiaca, Hedysarum grandiflorum, Filipendula vulgaris, Nonea pulla, Stachys recta L., Potentilla incana, Trinia multicaulis (Poir.) Schischk., Veronica austriaca L., Viola rupestris, and Verbascum orientale (L.) All. Although the floristic composition of the studied phytocoenosis had changed, the ratio of coenotic groups remains the same as it was in 2008, i.e. before the fire impact (Table 5).

Table 5. The species number of each coenotic group in the studied plant communities in the Khvalynsky National Park (Saratov region, Russia) in 2008-2018

Coenotic groups Number of plant species per study year

2008 2009 2010 2011 2015 201l 2018

number of species % of total number of plant species number of species % of total number of plant species number of species % of total number of plant species number of species % of total number of plant species number of species % of total number of plant species number of species % of total number of plant species number of species % of total number of plant species

Stepants 1б 5l 2 50 13 б5 18 58 13 l2 25 бб 19 58

Pratants 4 15 1 25 3 15 4 13 3 1l 5 13 l 21

Sylvants 2 l 0 0 2 10 3 10 1 5.5 2 5 2 б

Ruderants 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Stepants-ruderants 2 l 0 0 1 5 3 10 0 0 4 11 3 9

Pratants-ruderants 3 11 0 0 0 0 2 l 0 0 1 2.5 0 0

Silvants-ruderants 1 3 1 25 1 5 1 3 1 5.5 1 2.5 2 б

Total 28 100 4 100 20 100 31 100 18 100 38 100 33 100

Semi-shrubs, tap-root perennials, short-root perennials, and long-root perennials determined the structure of the post-fire plant community for a number of years. Before the fire impact (i.e. in 2008), short-root perennials had a leading position (29.63%) in the plant community. They retained this position for a number of post-fire years: 25% in 2010, 26% in 2011, 35.14% in 2017, 36.36% in 2018. In 2015, tap-root perennials occupied a dominant position in the studied plant community with 33% of the total species number. In other years, they occupied the second position: 22% in 2008, 15% in 2010, 13% in 2011, 16% in 2017, 21% in 2018. Before the fire impact, the long-root perennials occupied the third position (11.11%). Subsequently, they demonstrated a resistance to pyrogenic effects, and an ability to quickly occupy the vacant space after the fire impact. In the 2010-2011 growing season, these plants, similarly to short-root and tap-root perennials, had a leading position in the plant community: 25% in 2010, 13% in 2011, 11% in 2015, 11% in 2017, 9% in 2018. Our results are in accordance with published data. For example, Marenina & Maslennikov (2014) demonstrated that in the Arsk forest-steppe (north of Ulyanovsk region, Russia), tap-root perennials (25.4%), long-root perennials (19.8%), and short-root perennials (10.8%) domianted in the post-fire plant communities. The same authors also noted a fire-caused increase a the proportion of root-sucker perennials (14.5%) and biennials (8.4%) in the ratio of life forms in the plant community.

The analysis of the morphometric traits of the Paeonia tenuifolia population before and after the fire impact showed, that the least variability of the trait is typical for the height of its generative shoots. The highest values of flowering shoot height were recorded in 2018 (47.13 cm). This is 36% more than in 2010. The smallest height of generative shoots was associated with unfavourable weather conditions of the spring and summer in 2017 (Syvorotkin, 2017). In general, the height of the vegetative and generative shoots of Paeonia tenuifolia remained at a constant level for a number of post-fire years (Fig. 4). Extremely low and high values of these parameters depend on meteorological factors.

The development of an action plan for fires in Protected Areas should be based on the results of the assessment of biological diversity and comprehensive studies over succession on the burnt areas in compare with undisturbed habitats. For comparison, we chose similar plant community with Paeonia tenuifolia, not fire-disturbed in the southwestern part of the Khvalynsky National Park (Sosnovo-Mazovskoe forestry).

In the unburnt plant community, the height of generative shoots (36.47 cm) was slightly lower than in the post-fire plant community (47.13 cm). The probable reasons for this were the weakening of competition between plants caused by the fire impact and the soil fertilisation with ash elements. In contrary, in the unburnt plant community, the average plant height and the height of vegetative shoots were 3 cm larger than in the post-fire plant community (Table 6).

Fig. 4. The average height of Paeonia tenuifolia shoots in the fire-damaged plant community in the Khvalynsky National Park, Mountain Piche-Panda, 2008-2018.

Table 6. Average values of morphometric traits of Paeonia tenuifolia individuals in Khvalynsky National Park, quarter 86 of the Sosnovo-Mazovskoe forestry (17.05.2018)

Trait N M ± m Limits

min max

Average height of the shoots, cm 140 25.94 ± 12.06 5 51

Height of vegetative shoots, cm 78 16.75 ± 7.35 5 46

Height of generative shoots, cm 62 36.47 ± 6.56 19 51

Number of leaves per vegetative shoot 61 4.69 ± 3.57 1 14

Diameter of a bud, cm 30 1.53 ± 0.55 0.2 2.6

Diameter of a flower, cm 26 4.53 ± 1.74 1.6 8.8

It is caused by a large number of pre-gener-ative Paeonia tenuifolia individuals, the height of which reached 11-17 cm. Individuals of juvenile, immature, and virginile age classes have vegetative shoots. In the post-fire plant community, the fire-stratificated seeds of Paeonia tenui-folia germinated well. In subsequent years, we observed a large number of Paeonia tenuifolia juveniles (first year individuals) with an average height of 4.5 cm. The determination of age structure for the Paeonia tenuifolia population is of great importance, as it allows to a better understanding of the mechanisms of post-fire succession. The distribution of individuals along age groups and the completeness of population age structure contribute to the species sustainability in the plant community, since each group has its own specific relationship with the habitat (Be-spalova & Popova, 1972). In addition, normal type populations are recognised as highly resistant (Rabotnov, 1983). If a plant population is incomplete or constist of indviduals of the same age, its resistance to unfavourable conditions decreases. There are three types of age classes of a population: growing population, stationary population, declining population (Zlobin, 1989). Maslennikov & Maslennikova (2011) noted that the natural Paeonia tenuifolia population is characterised as complete, stationary. At the same time, young individuals predominate as most of them will eliminate before reaching flowering and fruiting stages. Ilyina (2011) found that the pyrogenic effect changes the age structure of a threatened species population by shifting age class percentage towards old (senile) individuals. As a result, the initially mature normal populations could be gradually changed into populations of aging (regressive) type. And it thus can contribute to plant population extinction. However, based on comparison of the unburnt and post-fire Paeonia tenuifolia population in the study area, we showed that young pre-generative individuals dominated (67% of the total number

of individuals) in the age spectrum of the post-fire populations (Table 7).

We found Paeonia tenuifolia seedlings in the study plots in April. In the second decade of May, the plants passed into a juvenile age class. Within group of generative plants, middle-age generative (g2) individuals prevailed (13% of total number of individuals) in the post-fire plant community. Subsenile (6%) and senile (2%) individuals were also represented in the populations. In the age spectrum of the unburnt Paeonia tenuifolia population, generative individuals predominated (43%). Among them, generative individuals (g2) dominated (63%). The post-generative age classes were represented by a small number of individuals in the unburnt Paeonia tenuifolia population (Fig. 5).

Since the studies were carried out on sites with a different disturbance degree, we used recovery and replacement indices to compare the populations' status. In the post-fire plant community, the I of Paeonia tenuifolia population

J ^ recovery J A A

was Ir = 2.70. It indicates that this population is stable, and the pre-generative individuals are able to replace generative individuals. In the unburnt plant community, the I was lower (1.25). It

recovery

indicates a less stability of this Paeonia tenuifolia population, as a large number of pre-generative individuals are being eliminated and thus cannot sufficiently replace generative individuals. Based on the age index (A) of Uranov (1975) and the efficiency index (ro) of Zhivotovsky (2001), the post-fire population of Paeonia tenuifolia was estimated as younger (ro = 0.36) than the P. tenuifolia population in the unburnt site (ro = 0.54). According to the classification of normal type populations (Zhivotovsky, 2001), both populations were recognised as young full-membered populations. The post-fire plant community contained remarkably more juvenile and virginile individuals, than the population on the unburnt site. Both the recovery and replacement rates were higher in the burnt site than in the unburnt area.

Table 7. Age structure of the Paeonia tenuifolia population in steppe plant communities of Khvalynsky National Park in 2018

Plant community Number of individuals per age class Total Demographics data

p j im v g0 g1 g2 g3 ss s I recovery "^replacement д ю IVC

Post-fire plant community 0 199 28 81 4 50 60 0 22 11 461 2.70 2.01 0.26 0.36 1.15

Unburned plant community 0 14 39 25 3 40 90 0 1 1 142 1.26 1.22 0.29 0.54 0.85

Note: p - seedlings, j - juvenile, im - immature, v - virginile, g0, gp g2, g3 - generative, s - senile, ss - subsenile.

S -

£ а ¡X

P i im v g0 gl g2 g3 ss

Age classes

Opost-fire papulation »unburned population

Fig. 5. Age structure of the Paeonia tenuifolia population in both post-fire and unburned plant communities in Khvalynsky National Park in 2018. Designations: p - seedlings, j - juvenile, im - immature, v - virginile, g0, g1, g2, g3 - generative, s - senile, ss - subsenile.

The gradient analysis of environmental conditions showed that the Paeonia tenuifolia population in the fire-damaged plant community was characterised by the highest value of the vitality index (IVC = 1.15). It corresponded to the best conditions for population development. On the unburnt site, the vitality index (IVC) of the Paeonia tenuifolia population was 0.85. In indicated the unfavourable conditions for survival and development of this population. The index of species plasticity (ISP = 1.35) reflected a resistance of Paeonia tenuifolia to unfavourable conditions, in particular, to the fire effects. This is a low value in comparison with ISP values calculated for some other herbaceous plant species. For instance, the ISP of Tulipa gesneri-ana L. was 1.9 (Kashin et al., 2016, 2017). The ISP for Iva xanthiifolia Nutt. (as Cyclachaena xanthiifolia (Nutt.) Fresen.) was 4.95, and the ISP for Atriplex tatarica L. was 6.28 (Ishbirdin & Ishmuratova, 2004). The ISP value of Paeonia tenuifolia was within the limits of earlier obtained ISP values for perennial herbaceous plants (Ishbirdin & Ishmuratova, 2004). More specifically, its values are close to the ones calculated for Cephalanthera rubra (L.) Rich. with

ISP = 1.31 (Ishbirdin et al., 2005), and Allium denudatum F.Delaroche (as Allium albidum Fisch. et Bieb.) with ISP = 1.38 (Tkhazaplizhe-va & Shkhagapsoev, 2008). This ISP value suggests that Paeonia tenuifolia is characterised by narrow limits of ecological preferences.

We considered the number of reproductive shoots on the study sites as an objective indicator of the status of Red Data Book plant populations (Table 8).

The positive effects of a fire impact were manifested by the higher number of Paeonia tenuifolia shoots in the post-fire plant community in comparison to the unburnt site. This is probably caused by the substrate renewal, improvement of lighting conditions, soil fertilisation with ash elements, and the reduced competition from other plant species.

In the studied plant communities, we identified 113 vascular plant species from 34 families. In post-fire plant community, the following plant families were the richest in species: Poace-ae (13.43%), Leguminosae (11.94%), Rosaceae (8.95%), and Brassicaceae (8.95%). In the un-burnt plant community, we found another ratio of the leading plant families in term of species number: Compositae (18%), Poaceae (11.76%), and Ranunculaceae (8.69%). The families Allia-ceae, Asclepiadaceae, Asparagaceae, Dipsaca-ceae, Iridaceae, Geraniaceae, Globulariaceae, Liliaceae, Limoniaceae, Malvaceae, Onagra-ceae, Paeoniaceae, and Primulaceae were each represented by one plant species (Table 9).

Table 8. The number of shoots of Red Data Book plant species in both burnt and unburnt plant communities with Paeo-

Shoots Number of shoots

Burned site Unburned site

Paeonia tenuifolia

Vegetative, M i m 23.60 ± 13.43 10.25 ± 3.30

Generative, M i m 16.50 i 11.95 8.00 ± 3.74

Adonis vernalis

Vegetative, M i m 10.30 i 12.54 7.50 i 5.00

Generative, M i m 5.40 i 5.73 3.50 i 2.51

Note: M - average value, m - standard deviation of the average value.

Table 9. The ratio of the plant families richest by species on the study sites in the Khvalynsky National Park in 2009-2018

Family Post-fire plant community Family Unburnt plant community

number of species % of total species number number of species % of total species number

Poaceae 9 13.43 Compositae 12 18.00

Leguminosae 8 11.94 Poaceae 8 11.76

Rosaceae 6 8.95 Ranunculaceae 6 8.69

Brassicaceae 6 8.95 Rosaceae 5 7.35

Plantaginaceae 5 7.46 Leguminosae 4 5.88

Lamiaceae 4 5.98 Lamiaceae 4 5.88

Caryophyllaceae 4 5.98 Plantaginaceae 3 4.41

Rubiaceae 4 5.98 Rubiaceae 2 2.94

Compositae 3 4.48 Brassicaceae 2 2.94

Scrophulariaceae 2 3.00 Scrophulariaceae 2 2.94

Ranunculaceae 2 3.00 Caryophyllaceae 1 1.47

Others families 17 20.85 Others families 19 27.74

Total 67 100 Total 68 100

In the Arsk forest-steppe (central part of the Volga Upland), Marenina & Maslennikova (2014) obtained another ratio of plant families in the post-fire plant community: Composi-tae (16.6%), Poaceae (13.8%), Leguminosae (13.8%), Rosaceae (11.8%), Rubiaceae (5.5%), Apiaceae (5.5%), Lamiaceae (2.7%). A similar ratio was obtained in a result of study on the secondary succession dynamics in the fallow lands in the south of the Amur region (Nizkiy, 2014). Smelyanskiy et al. (2015) noted that the fire impact enhances bacterial and symbiotic nitrogen fixation in the soil, realised by Fabaceae plants. According to these authors, species of the families Poaceae (five species disappeared after fire), Rosaceae (three species), Rubiaceae (three species) were unstable to the fire factor under conditions of the South Ural steppes. On the contrary, the plant species number increased in the families Leguminosae (three species appeared after fire), Euphorbiaceae (two species), and Caryo-phylaceae (two species) after the fire impact in Ural steppes (Smelyanskiy et al., 2015). Our results showed that in the Khvalynsky National Park, the most unstable plants were assigned to the following families: Compositae (two species disappeared after fire), and Apiaceae (one species). After the fire impact, the species number increased in the families Poaceae (three species appeared after fire), Rubiaceae (two species appeared after fire), Rosaceae (one species appeared after fire) and Leguminosae (one species appeared after fire).

The fire impact, spatial remoteness of both plant communities, closeness of the forest mas-

sif affected floristic composition of both studied phytocoenoses with Paeonia tenuifolia. As a result, the post-fire and unburnt plant communities differed in floristic composition based on the Jacquard similarity index equaled of 28.3%. Of the total of 113 obtained species, 21 taxa were observed on both sites (e.g., Paeonia tenuifolia, Stipa pennata, Calamagrostis epigejos, Carex praecox Schreb., Elymus repens, Filipendula vulgaris, Hedysarum grandiflorum, Onosma simplicissima, Salvia nutans, Securigera varia, Thalyctrum simplex, Verbascum lychnitis, Vinc-etoxicum hirundinaria).

In the studied plant communities, we recorded the plant species (e.g., Anemone sylves-tris, Adonis vernalis, Alyssum lenense, Aspe-rula tephrocarpa) listed in the Red Data Book of Saratov region (2006). Globularia punctata Lapeyr., Hedysarum grandiflorum, Potentilla volgarica, Paeonia tenuifolia, Stipa pennata were listed in the Red Data Book of the Russian Federation (2008). In the studied plant communities, we additionally found species (Ajuga chamaepitys subsp. laevigata (Boiss.) P.H. Davis, Onosma simplicissima, Salvia nu-tans) included in the additional list of the Red Data Book of Saratov region (2006), of which populations need special attention. The dominant and edificator of the plant communities Paeonia tenuifolia is included on the list of protected species of the European flora (Be-lousova et al., 2008). We found that the unburnt plant community had the highest value of the coefficient of conservation significance (K = 67.20) (Table 10).

Table 10. The presence of Red Data Book plant species in plant communities with Paeonia tenuifolia in the Khvalynsky National Park (2009-2018)

№ Species Presence I absence (+ I -) of plant species

Post-fire community Unburned community

1 *Alyssum lenense Willd. + -

2 * Alyssum tortuosum Adams. + -

3 *Asperula tephrocarpa tephrocarpa Czern. ex. Popov & Chrshan. + -

4 ***Ajuga chamaepitys subsp. laevigata (Boiss.) P.H.Davis - +

5 *Astragalus cornutus (Pall.) Kuntze + -

6 * Adonis vernalis L. + +

7 *Anemone sylvestris L. - +

10 **Globulariapunctata Lapeyr. - +

11 *Gypsophila volgensis Krasnova + -

12 **Hedysarum grandiflorum Pall. + +

13 **Irispumila L. - +

14 *Linum ucranicum (Griseb. ex Planch.) Czern. - +

15 ***Onosma simplicissima L. + +

16 **Potentilla volgarica Juz. + -

17 **Paeonia tenuifolia L. + +

18 *Polygala sibirica L. + +

19 **Anemone pratensis L. - +

20 ***Salvia nutans L. + -

21 **Stipapennata L. + +

22 *Thymus cimicinus Blume ex Ledeb. + -

The coefficient of conservation significance 48.94 67.20

Note: * - species listed in the Red Data Book of Saratov region (2006); ** - species listed in the Red Data Book of the Russian Federation (2008); *** - species listed in Appendix 3 of the Red Data Book of Saratov region «Annotated list of taxa and plant populations, which require special attention to conditions of their natural environment» (Red Data Book of Saratov region, 2006).

It is well known that fires reduce the biodiversity of plant communities, and destroy the habitats of rare and threatened species (Ilyina, 2011; Bystrushkin, 2018). The fire impact caused remarkable damage to the populations of seven species of protected plants included in the Red Data Book of Saratov region (2006), three of which are listed in the Red Data Book of the Russian Federation (2008). The species represented by small populations with both small projective cover and abundance were in the most threatening situation. These plants are Alyssum lenense, Onosma simpli-cissima, Potentilla volgarica, Salvia nutans, and Stipa pennata. During the long-term monitoring, we found that four native plants of the studied plant community (Paeonia tenuifolia, Adonis ver-nalis, Potentilla volgarica, Onosma simplicissima) were pyrophytes. The semi-shrub Alyssum lenense disappeared from the plant community. The cereal Stipa pennata and tap-root perennial Salvia nutans recovered and strengthened their positions in the phytocoenosis structure as co-dominants. During the post-fire succession, we found six Red Data Book species (Alyssum tortuosum, Asperula teph-rocarpa, Globularia punctata, Gypsophila volgen-sis, Hedysarum grandiflorum, and Polygala sibiri-

ca L.) in the floristic composition of the studied plant community. Since the study site was at the edge of the burnt area at the time of a fire, most of the Red Data Book plants penetrated into the plant community from the surrounding unburnt vegetation. The perennial Paeonia tenuifolia turned out to be resistant to the fire impact. And the plant community with Paeonia tenuifolia had recovered ten years after the fire impact.

Conclusions

The species richness of the post-fire plant community varied from 20 species in the first post-fire year to 38 species in the last study year. In the first post-fire year, the families of Poaceae (six species), Leguminosae (three species), Rosaceae (three species) occupied the leading position. The dominant position of the listed families remained during the pyrogenic succession of the plant community. In the unburnt plant community, other families (Com-positae, Poaceae, Ranunculaceae) were richest in number of species.

After the fire impact, the plant community changed in the following order: 1) Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis - Stipa pennata (in 2008) ^ 2) Paeonia tenuifolia

+ Elymus repens + Stipa pennata + Adonis verna-lis + Thalictrum simplex (in 2010) ^ 3) Paeonia tenuifolia - Stipa pennata - Calamagrostis epige-jos + Festuca valesiaca + Phleum pratense + Poa bulbosa + Prunus tenella (in 2011) ^ 4) Paeonia tenuifolia + Adonis vernalis + Stipa pennata (in 2015, 2017, 2018). Over the study years the ratio of dominant species had changed, and the phyto-coenotic role of Stipa pennata had increased.

In the post-fire community steppe species dominated. In general, the full ecological-coenotical spectrum was represented by steppe plants (stepants) (70%), meadow plants (pratants) (16%), forest plants (sylvants) (5%), and ruderal plants (ruderants) (9%). At the same time, the ratio of coenotic groups remained the same before and after the fire impact. The only change was manifested in the appearance of new species in the studied phytocoenosis, most of which were steppe plants. During the post-fire succession, annuals and ruderals appeared and increased in abundance. This characterised an intermediate stage of pyrogenic transformation of the plant community with Paeonia tenuifolia.

The Paeonia tenuifolia populations in both the post-fire and unburned plant communities were normal, full-membered and young. Expectedfully, the age structure of post-fire Paeonia tenuifolia population was younger than its population in the unburnt plant community.

In the fire-damaged plant community, both the regeneration and growth processes of vegetative and generative shoots were more intense than in the unburnt plant community. This was caused by the substrate renewal and the decrease in species competition in the post-fire plant community

Species saturation and stabilisation in species richness have become remarkable signs of a final restoration stage of the plant community affected by a fire.

Phytocoenoses with Paeonia tenuifolia are valuable botanical sites. In this area, they had grown for a long-time and were greatly adapted to local conditions under the influence of different factors. The presence of other Red Data Book species increases the conservation significance of the plant communities. The fire impact caused significant damage to the populations of Red Data Book plants in the post-fire community. Nevertheless, peculiarly, abiotic conditions contributed to the increased vitality of the Paeonia tenuifolia population and the restoration of the plant community after the fire impact.

The buffer zone of the Khvalynsky National Park contains mainly areas of meadow steppes with populations of Paeonia tenuifolia and other Red Data Book plant species. Therefore, it is necessary to include these areas with populations of protected plant species into the main area of the Khvalynsky National Park to ensure a reliable protection of intact habitats and populations of threatened species. To properly assess the fire effects on nature and its components and to subsequently create the correct recommendations for the ecosystem restoration, additional studies are needed.

Acknowledgements

We thank G.S. Malysheva (V.L. Komarov Botanical Institute RAS, Saint-Petersburg, Russia) for methodological assistance in experimental field work and L.A. Serova (Educational and Scientific Center «Botanical Garden» of the N.G. Chernyshevsky Saratov State University, Russia) for help in determination of plants.

References

Agee J.K. 1993. Fire ecology of Pacific North west forests.

Washington, D.C.: Island Press. 93 p. Albitskaya M. A. 1960. The main laws of the formation of grass cover in artificial forests of the steppe zone of the Ukrainian SSR. In: Artificial forests of the steppe zone of Ukraine. Kharkov: Kharkov University Press. P. 155-208. [In Russian] Anikin V.V. (Ed.). 2013. Educational Atlas of the Saratov Region. Saratov: Publisher of the Saratov State University. 144 p. [In Russian] Armendáriz-Villegas E.J., Covarrubias-García M.D.L.T., Troyo-Diéguez E., Lagunes E., Arreola-Lizárraga A., Nieto-Garibay A., Beltrán-Morales L.F., Ortega-Rubio A. 2015. Metal mining and natural protected areas in Mexico: Geographic over laps and environmental implications. Environmental Science and Policy 48: 9-19. DOI: 10.1016/j.envsci.2014.12.016 Batista E.K.L., Russell-Smith J., Franga H., Figueira J.E.C. 2018. An evaluation of contemporary savanna fire regimes in the Canastra National Park, Brazil: Outcomes of fire suppression policies. Journal of Environmental Management 205: 40-49. DOI: 10.1016/j.jenv-man.2017.09.053 Bednova O.V. 2004. Monitoring of biodiversity of forest and urban ecosystems. In: O.V Bednova (Ed.): Monitoring of the state of forest and urban ecosystems. Moscow: MGUL. P. 39-51. [In Russian] Belgard A.L. 1950. Forest vegetation of the southeast of the Ukrainian SSR. Kiev: Kiev University Press. 264 p. [In Russian]

Belousova A.V, Milyutina M.L., Shilin N.I., Mezhnev A.P., Se-menov VB., Sobolev N.A., Varlygina T.I. 2008. Information and analytical materials on the protection of plants, animals and their habitats in the countries of Western Eu-

rope and Russia (on the example of the Bern Convention, the Directive on the protection of birds and the Directive on the protection of natural habitats and wild fauna and flora). Available from https://dront.ru/wp-content/up-loads/2017/03/infb-analitic-materials-2008.pdf Belov S.V. 1973. Controlled fire in the forest is a means of restoring pine and larch forests of the taiga zone. In: Burning andfires in the forest. Krasnoyarsk: Publishing House of the V.N. Sukachev Institute of Forest and Wood, Siberian Branch of AS USSR. P. 213-232. [In Russian]

Bespalova I.V., Popova T.A. 1972. Dynamics of the number and age composition of the population of turf grasses in the desert steppes of Central Kazakhstan. Botanichesky Zhurnal 57(7): 779-793. [In Russian] Berezina N.A., Afanasyeva N.B. 2009. Plant Ecology. Moscow: Academy. 400 p. [In Russian] Bystrushkin A.G. 2018. Reduction of rare plants populations under the influence of fire in the Nature park «Reka Chusovaya». Vestnik of Orenburg State Pedagogical University. Electronic Scientific Journal 1(25): 1-8. [In Russian] Brooke C.F., Kraaij T., Venter J.A. 2018. Characterizing a Poacher-Driven Fire Regime in Low-Nutrient Coastal Grasslands of Pondoland, South Africa. Fire Ecology 14: 14010001. DOI: 10.4996/fireecology. 140101016 Chub VV 2011. Physiological aspects of plant response to abnormal weather conditions in 2010. Bulletin of S.A. Yes-enin Ryazan State University 32: 141-150. [In Russian] Curry J.R., Fons W.L. 1940. Forest-fire behavior studies. Mechanical Engineering 62(3): 219-225. Drude O. 1890. Handbuch der Pflanzengeographie. Stuttgart: J. Engelhorn. 582 p. Dusaeva G.Kh. 2017. Dynamics of steppe phytocenoses in the first years after fire (for example, monitoring section №1 in the «Burtinskaya Steppe» Reserve «Orenburg-sky»). Proceedings of the Samara Scientific Centre of RAS 19(5): 8-13. [In Russian] Elenevskiy A.G., Bulany Yu.I., Radygina V.I. 2008. Synopsis of the Saratov region flora. Saratov: Nauka. 232 p. [In Russian]

Ferreira J., Aragao L.E.O.C., Barlow J., Barreto P., Beren-guer E., Bustamante M., Gardner T.A., Lees A.C., Lima A., Louzada J., Pardini R., Parry L., Peres C.A., Pom-peu P. S., Tabarelli M., Zuanon J. 2014. Brazil's environmental leadership at risk. Science 346(6210): 706-707. DOI: 10.1126/science.1260194 Garriga N., Santos X., Montori A., Richter-Boix A., Franch M., Llorente G.A. 2012. Are protected areas truly protected? The impact of road traffic on vertebrate fauna. Biodiversity and Conservation 21(11): 2761-2774. DOI: 10.1007/s10531-012-0332-0 Glotov N.V. 1998. The estimating of the parameters of plant populations age structure. In: Life of populations in a heterogeneous environment. Yoshkar-Ola: Periodicals of Mari El. P. 146-149. [In Russian] Golubtsova O.S. 2012. Features of transpiration intensity in herbaceous plants at different stages of pyrogenic succession In: Modern Biology: Questions and Answers.

St. Petersburg: Discovery Scientific Publishing Centre. P. 139-143. [In Russian] Goud E.M. 2017. Diversity and abundance of litter-dwelling arthropods increase with time-since-burn in a Florida scrub ecosystem. Biodiversity 18(4): 151-155. DOI: 10.1080/14888386.2017.1407671 Grime J.P. 1979. Plant Strategies and Vegetation Processes. Chichester-New York-Brisbane-Toronto: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 222 p. DOI: 10.1007/BF02895358 Haggerty B.P, Mazer S.J. 2008. The Phenology Handbook: a guide to phenological monitoring for students, teachers, families, and nature enthusiasts. Santa BarbaraCalifornia. 87 p. Ilyina S.V. 2011. Pyrogenic impact on vegetation. Samar-skaya Luka: problems of regional and global ecology 20(2): 4-30. [In Russian] Isaeva L. K. 2000. Fire Ecology, Technogenic and Natural Disasters. Moscow: Academy of the State Border Service of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. 301 p. [In Russian]

Ishbirdin A.R., Ishmuratova M.M. 2004. Adaptive morphogenesis and ecological-coenotical strategies for the survival of herbaceous plants. In: Population Biology Methods. Part 2. Syktyvkar. P. 113-120. [In Russian] Ishbirdin A.R., Ishmuratova M.M., Zhirnova T.V 2005. Life strategy of Cephalanthera rubra (L.) Rich. cenopopu-lations in the territory of the Bashkir State Nature Reserve. In: Proceedings of the VIII Russian population seminar «Populations in space and time» (11-15 April 2005, Nizhniy Novgorod). Nizhniy Novgorod. P. 85-98. [In Russian]

Ishutin Ya.N. 2004. Reforestation on burnt sites in Altai pine forests. Barnaul: Altai State University. 112 p. [In Russian]

Jaccard P. 1901. Étude comparative de la distribution florale dans une portion des Alpes et des Jura. Bulletin de la Société Vaudoise des Sciences Naturelles 37: 547-579. Kashin A.S., Petrova N.A., Shilova I.V 2016. Some Features of the Environmental Strategy of Tulipa gesneriana L. (Liliaceae, Liliopsida). Biology Bulletin 44(10): 12371245. DOI: 10.1134/S1062359017100053 Kashin A.S., Petrova N.A., Shilova I.V. 2017. The Structure of Morphological Variability and Vitaliti in the Populations of Tulipa gesneriana L. in the Lower Volga Region and Adjacent Territories. Proceedings of the Saratov University. New series. Series: Chemistry. Biology. Ecology 17(1): 103-106. DOI: 10.18500/1816-97752017-17-1-103-110 [In Russian] Kataev G.D. 2017. The impact of industrial emissions of copper-nickel smelter complex on the status of populations and communities of small mammals in the Kola Peninsula. Nature Conservation Research 2(Suppl. 2): 19-27. DOI: 10.24189/ncr.2017.033 Komarova T.A. 1980. On some regularities of secondary successions (on the example of the post-fire reforestation process). Zhurnal Obshchei Biologii 3: 397-405. [In Russian]

Komarova T.A. 1991. Reforestation process after fires in the cedar forests of the Southern Sikhote-Alin. In: The

theory of the forest formation process. Krasnoyarsk. P. 69-72. [In Russian] Komarova T.A. 1999. Reforestation successions after fires in the forests of the Southern Sikhote-Alin. Russian Journal of Forestry 3: 53-56. [In Russian] Komarova T.A. 2009. Reforestation successions after fires in the forests of the Southern Sikhote-Alin. In: Plants in a monsoon climate. Vladivostok. P. 193-197. [In Russian] Komarova T.A. 2011. Successions and current issues of their study. Society. Environment. Development: Scientific-Theoretical Journal 1: 233-238. [In Russian] Korchagin A.A. 1954. The fire effect on forest vegetation and its post-fire restoration in the European North. Proceedings of the Botanical Institute of AS USSR. Series Geobotany 9: 75-149. [In Russian] Knapp R. 1974. Cyclic Successions and Ecosystem Approaches in Vegetation Dynamics. In: Knapp R. (Ed.): Vegetation Dynamics. Handbook of Vegetation Science. Vol. 8. Dordrecht: Springer. P. 85-99. DOI: 10.1007/978-94-010-2344-3_10 Kuleshova LV, Korotkov VN. 2010. Guidelines for the monitoring of pyrogenic changes in forest communities of state reserves and national parks. In: Conservation. Scientific-methodological notes of the Commission on the Conservation of Biological Diversity (section of nature conservation). Vol. 14. Moscow. P. 97-114. [In Russian] Lavrentiev M.V., Boldyrev V.A. 2016. Analysis of the floris-tic composition of phytocoenoses with the participation of Hedysarum grandiflorum Pall. in the southern part of the Volga Upland. Proceedings of the Saratov University. New series. Series: Chemistry. Biology. Ecology 16(1): 100-107. DOI: 10.18500/1816-9775-2016-16-1100-107 [In Russian] Lewis S.L., Brando P.M., Phillips O.L., van der Heijden G.M.F., Nepstad D. 2011a. The 2010 Amazon Drought. Science 331(6017): 554. DOI: 10.1126/science.1200807 Lewis S.C., Gagan M.K., Ayliffe L.K., Zhao J.-X., Hantoro W.S., Treble P.C., Hellstrom J.C., LeGrande A.N., Kel-ley M., Schmidt G.A., Suwargadi B.W. 2011b. Highresolution stalagmite reconstructions of Australian-Indonesian monsoon rainfall variability during Heinrich stadial 3 and Greenland interstadial 4. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 303(1-2): 133-142 DOI: 10.1016/j.epsl.2010.12.048 Lukyanova L.E., Lukyanov O.A. 2004. An Ecologically Destabilized Environment: Its Effect on Small-Mammal Populations. Russian Journal of Ecology 35(3): 181188. DOI: 10.1023/B:RUSE.0000025969.98937.e5 Maevskiy P.F. 2014. Flora of the middle belt of the European Russia. Moscow: KMK Scientific Press Ltd. 635 p. [In Russian]

Makarov V.Z. (Ed.). 2008. Protected Areas of the Saratov region: a national park, natural micro-reserves, natural monuments, arboretums, a botanical garden, protected geological areas. Saratov: Publishing House of the Saratov State Univercity. 300 p. [In Russian] Malysheva G.S., Malakhovsky P.D. 2000. Fires and their influence on the vegetation of dry steppes. Botanichesky Zhurnal 85(1): 96-103. [In Russian]

Malysheva G.S., Malakhovsky P.D. 2008. The meadow steppes of the Khvalynsky National Park, their dynamics and conservation problems. In: V.N. Khryanin, A.A. Chistyakova, N.A. Leonova, L.A. Novikova (Eds.): Biodiversity: issues and conservation perspectives (1316 May 2008). Part 3. Flora and vegetation. Penza. P. 268-269. [In Russian] Marenina S.V., Maslennikov AV 2014. Influence of the pyro-genic factor on the composition of forest and forest-steppe communities of the northern forest-steppe within the Volga Upland. In: Yu.K. Volodina, O.E. Borodina, VV Zo-lotukhin, D.A. Korepova, MV Korepov, VA. Mikheev, A.N. Moskvichev (Eds.): Nature of the Simbirsk Volga Region. Ulyanovsk: Publishing House «Promotion Technologies Corporation». P. 24-29. [In Russian] Maslennikov A.V., Maslennikova L.A. 2011. The status of populations of thin-leaved peony (Paeonia tenoifolia L.) on the northeast limit of distribution under conditions of the Volga Upland. In: Ecology and geography of plants and plant communities of the Middle Volga. Togliatti. P. 318-326. [In Russian] Matveev N.M. 2006. Bioecological analysis of flora and vegetation (on the example of a forest-steppe and steppe zone): study guide. Samara: Samara State University. 311 p. [In Russian] Meier U. (Ed.). 2001. Growing stages of mono and dicotyledonous plants (BBCH Monograph). Berlin and Braunschweig: Federal Biological Research Centre Agriculture and Forestry. 152 p. Meier U., Bleiholder H., Buhr L., Feller C., Hack Y., Heß M., Lancashire P.D., Schnock U., Stauß R., Van den Boom T., Weber E., Zwerger P. 2009. The BBCH system to coding thhe phenological growth stages of plants-history and publications. Journal fur kulturpflanzen 61(2): 41-52. Mirkin B.M., Naumova L.G. 2012. The current state of the basic concepts of the science of vegetation. Ufa: Academy of Sciences of Bashkiria, Gilem. 488 p.[In Russian] Mirkin B.M. Rosenberg G.S. 1983. Explanatory Dictionary of Modern Phytocoenology. Moscow: Nauka. 134 p. [In Russian]

Mozgovaya O.A., Semenova O.V., Sharonova I.V. 2007. Ontomorphogenesis Paeonia tenuifolia L. in terms of culture in the middle of the Volga region. Samarskaya Luka: problems of regional and global ecology 1-2 (19-20): 278-282. [In Russian] Morozov G.F. 1912. The Science on a Forest. St. Petersburg.

83 p. [In Russian] Nizkiy S.E. 2014. The dynamics of the phytocoenosis secondary succession on fallow lands in the south Priamur-ye agricultural zone. Bulletin of the Krasnoyarsk State Agrarian University 1: 53-55. [In Russian] Nosova L.M. 1973. Floristical-geographical analysis of the northern steppes of the European part of the USSR. Moscow: Nauka. 184 p. [In Russian] Oparin M.L., Oparina O.S. 2003. The influence of fires on the dynamics of the steppe vegetation. Privolzhsky Journal of Ecology 2: 158-171. [In Russian] Pereira P., Mierauskas P., Novara A. 2016. Stakeholders' Perceptions about Fire Impacts on Lithuanian Protect-

ed Areas. Land Degradation and Development 27(4): 871-883. DOI: 10.1002/ldr.2290 Perevoznikova VD., Ivanova G.A., Ivanov VA., Kovaleva N.M. 2007. Transformation of ground vegetation under the effect of fires in pine forests of Middle Siberia. Russian Journal of Ecology 38(6): 444-448. DOI: 10.1134/ S1067413607060124 [In Russian] Polikarpova N.V., Makarova O.A. 2016. A phenological atlas

of plants. Ryazan: Golos Gubernii. 235 p. Polyakova G.A., Melankholin P.N. 2013. The impact of the 2010 drought on the grass-shrub cover of the Moscow region forests. Russian Journal of Forestry 4: 43-51. [In Russian]

Popov S.Yu. 2000. Pyrogenic successions of sphagnum moss in Central Russia. Botanichesky Zhurnal 2: 89-93. [In Russian]

Rabotnov T.A. 1972. The study of fluctuations (variability of years) of phytocoenoses. In: E.M. Lavrenko, A.A. Korchagin (Eds.): Field geobotany.Vol. 4. Leningrad: Nauka. P. 95-136. [In Russian] Rabotnov T.A. 1983. Phytocenology. Moscow: Moscow

State University. 296 p. [In Russian] Red Data Book of Saratov region: Fungi. Lichens. Plants. Animals. Saratov: Publisher of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry Saratov Region, 2006. 528 p. [In Russian] Red Data Book of the Russian Federation (plants and fungi). Moscow: Partnership of scientific publications KMK, 2008. 855 p. [In Russian] Remis M.J., Jost Robinson C.A. 2012. Reductions in Primate Abundance and Diversity in a Multiuse Protected Area: Synergistic Impacts of Hunting and Logging in a Congo Basin Forest. American Journal of Primatology 74(7): 602-612. DOI: 10.1002/ajp.22012 Report on the state and protection of the environment of the Saratov region in 2010. Saratov: «PRINTING number 6», 2011. 270 p. [In Russian] Rodin L.E. 1981. Pyrogenic factor and vegetation of the arid zone. Botanichesky Zhurnal 12: 1673-1684. [In Russian] Rodriguez-Jorquera I.A., Siroski P., Espejo W., Nimptsch J., Choueri P.G., Choueri R.B., Moraga C.A., Mora M., Toor G.S. 2017. Latin American protected areas: Protected from chemical pollution? Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management 13(2): 360-370. DOI: 10.1002/ieam.1839 Rozanov S.I. 1999. Indicators of diversity in assessing the succession state of ecosystems. Successes of modern biology 119(4): 404-410. [In Russian]. Slaght J.C., Surmach S.G. 2016. Blakiston's Fish-owl Bubo blakistoni and logging: Applying resource selection information to endangered species conservation in Russia. Bird Conservation International 26(2): 214-224. DOI: 10.1017/S0959270915000076 Serikova V.I., Lepeshkina L.A., Voronin A.A., Kuznetsov B.I. 2013. Ontogenesis of Paeonia tenuifolia L.). In: L.A. Zhukova (Ed.): Ontogenetic Atlas of Plants: Vol. 7. Yoshkar-Ola: Mari State University. P. 216220. [In Russian] Smelyanskiy I.E., Buyvolov Yu.A., Bazhenov Yu.A., Bakirova R.T., Borovik L.P., Borodin A.P., Bykova

E.P., Vlasov A.A., Gavrilenko V.S., Goroshko O.A., Gribkov A.V., Kirilyuk V.E., Korsun O.V., Kreyd-lin M.A., Kuksin G.V., Lysenko G.N., Polchaninova N.Yu., Pulyaev A.I., Ryzhkov O.V., Ryabinina E.N., Tkachuk T.E. 2015. Steppe fires and fire situation management in steppe Protected Areas: ecological and conservation aspects. Analytical review. Moscow: Publisher of the Centre for Wildlife Conservation. 144 p. [In Russian] Solovyov A.N., Shikhova T.G., Busygin E.I. 2011. The influence of weather and climatic anomalies on plants in the eastern part of the mid-latitudes of the Russian Plain in 2010. Bulletin of Udmurt University. Series «Biology. Earth Sciences 4: 8-20. [In Russian] Stepanitskiy V., Shestakov A. (Eds.). 2005. Evaluating the effectiveness of Protected Areas management in Russia using the WWF methodology. Moscow: World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF). 37 p. [In Russian] Suleymanova G.F. 2010. Characteristics of plant communities with Paeonia tenuifolia L. in the Khvalynsky National Park. Proceeding of the Khvalynsky National Park. Vol. 2. Saratov: Saratov State Technical University. P. 74-81. [In Russian] Syvorotkin V.L. 2017. The condition of the ozone layer and weather anomalies in the Northern Hemisphere in spring and summer 2017. Space and Time 2-3-4(28-29-30): 253-266. Tarasov A.O. 1977. Main geographical patterns of the Saratov region vegetation. Saratov: Saratov State University. 24 p. [In Russian] Tarasov A.O. 1981. Field practice in environmental botany.

Saratov: Saratov State University. 90 p. [In Russian] The Plant List. 2019. The Plant List. Version 1.1. Available

from http://www.theplantlist.org/ Tkhazaplizheva L.H., Shkhagapsoev S.H. 2008. Ontoge-netic tactics and strategies for the survival of Allium albidum Fisch ex Bieb. in conditions of natural habitat (Kabardino-Balkaria). In: N.V. Glotov, V.V. Tuganayev, O.G. Baranova, N.E. Zubtsovsky, O.A. Kapitonov, B.G. Kotegov (Eds.): Current state and ways of population biology development: Proceedings of the X Russian Population Workshop. Izhevsk: Publishing House «Knigograd». P. 321-324. [In Russian] Uranov A.A. 1975. Age spectrum of phytocenopopulation as a time function and energy wave processes. High school scientific reports. Biological sciences 2: 7-34. [In Russian] Voronov A.G. 1973. Geobotany. Moscow: Vysshaya Shkola.

384 p. [In Russian] Yaroshenko P.D. 1969. Geobotany. Moscow: Prosveshche-

nie. 200 p. [In Russian] Zadoks J.C., Chang T.T., Konzak C.F. 1974. A decimal code for the growth stages of cereals. Weed Research 14: 415-421. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-3180.1974.tb01084.x Zhivotovsky L.A. 2001. Ontogenetic conditions, effective density and classification of plant populations. Russian Journal of Ecology 1: 3-7. [In Russian] Zlobin Yu.A. 1989. Principles and methods for studying coenotic plant populations. Kazan: Kazan University Press. 146 p. [In Russian]

ОСОБЕННОСТИ ВОССТАНОВЛЕНИЯ ФИТОЦЕНОЗОВ С УЧАСТИЕМ PAEONIA TENUIFOLIA ПОСЛЕ ПОЖАРА НА ТЕРРИТОРИИ НАЦИОНАЛЬНОГО ПАРКА «ХВАЛЫНСКИЙ» (РОССИЯ)

Г. Ф. Сулейманова1,2*, В. А. Болдырев2**, В. А. Савинов1

1Национальный парк «Хвалынский», Россия *e-mail: suleymanovagf@mail.ru 2Саратовский национальный исследовательский государственный университет им. Н.Г. Чернышевского, Россия

**e-mail: boldyrev52@bk.ru

В статье рассматриваются показатели динамики растительного сообщества с Paeonia tenuifolia до и после воздействия пожара. Исследования проводились в Хвалынском национальном парке (лесостепная зона России) в 2008-2018 гг. Авторы проводили комплексное исследование в горелых и ненарушенных пожаром растительных сообществах. Для особо охраняемых природных территорий были рассмотрены оценка воздействия пожара и разработка плана действий после пожара. Растительное сообщество Paeo-nia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis - Potentilla volgarica подверглось воздействию пожара в 2009 г. Растительное сообщество Paeonia tenuifolia + Stipa pennata + Adonis vernalis - Anemone sylvestris не было нарушено. Для характеристики растительных сообществ с Paeonia tenuifolia и его це-нопопуляций мы использовали стандартные методы геоботанического описания. Шестьдесят семь видов сосудистых растений входило в состав послепожарного фитоценоза. Из них 14 видов были занесены в Красную книгу Саратовской области. Преобразования в составе пост-пирогенного растительного сообщества происходили в следующей последовательности: 1) Paeonia tenuifolia + Calamagrostis epigejos + Adonis vernalis - Stipa pennata (в 2008 г.) ^ 2) Paeonia tenuifolia + Elymus repens + Stipa pennata + Adonis vernalis + Thalictrum simplex (в 2010 г.) ^ 3) Paeonia tenuifolia - Stipa pennata - Calamagrostis epigejos + Festuca valesiaca +Phleumpratense + Poa bulbosa + Prunus tenella (в 2011 г.) ^ 4) Paeonia tenuifolia + Adonis vernalis + Stipa pennata (в 2015, 2017, 2018 гг.). После воздействия огня на растительное сообщество в нем произошли следующие изменения: 1) появились и увеличили обилие малолетники и рудеральные виды; 2) изменилось соотношение доминирующих видов. С 2012 по 2018 гг. фитоценотическая роль Calamagrostis epigeios уменьшалась. Напротив, проективное покрытие и обилие Stipa pennata увеличились в этот период. Динамика обилия Paeonia tenuifolia характеризовалась уменьшением в 2010 г. (сразу после пожара) и постепенным увеличением в 2015-2018 гг. Видовое богатство пост-пирогенного сообщества менялось от 20 видов в первый год после пожара до 38 видов в последний год исследования. В первый год пирогенной сукцессии лидирующее положение по числу видов занимали семейства Poaceae (шесть видов), Leguminosae (три вида), Rosaceae (три вида). Виды растений семейств Compositae, Poaceae, Ranunculaceae преобладали в ненарушенном растительном сообществе. Степные виды доминировали в послепожарном растительном сообществе. Это Stipa pennata, Adonis vernalis, Paeonia tenuifolia. Основные эколого-ценотические группы были представлены степными (70%), луговыми (16%), лесными (5%) и сорными (9%) видами растений. Наличие сорно-степных видов растений стало показателем нарушен-ности местообитаний вследствие антропогенной деятельности. Среди сорно-степных видов зафиксированы Arenaria serpyllifolia, Viola rupestris, Erysimum canescens, Verbascum lychnitis. Градиентный анализ экологических условий показал, что наибольшее значение индекса виталитета (IVC = 1.15) соответствует наилучшим условиям для роста и выживания в популяции Paeonia tenuifolia в послепожарном сообществе. На контрольном участке показатель виталитета (IVC = 0.85) соответствует худшим условиям для развития растений. Мы изучили возрастной спектр природных популяций Paeonia tenuifolia в послепо-жарном и ненарушенном сообществах. Мы показали, что обе популяции нормальные, полночленные, молодые. Послепожарная популяция была моложе, чем популяция в ненарушенном пожаром сообществе. Комплексные мониторинговые исследования должны быть продолжены для правильной оценки последствий пожара и последующих действий по управлению восстановлением растительности после воздействия пожара.

Ключевые слова: Stipa pennata, возрастной спектр, лесостепная зона, особо охраняемая природная территория, пирогенная сукцессия, популяция растений, растительное сообщество, редкий вид