UDC 631.523.4:633.31/37 HAC Code 06.01.05
| DOI: 10.32417/1997-4868-2021-204-01-46-50
g Patterns of thousand-seed weight inheritance inF.andF.pea « hybrids
о
ю F. A. Davletov1*, K. P. Gaynullina1, 2, A. V. Pleshkov1
S 1 Bashkir Research Institute of Agriculture - Subdivision of the Ufa Federal Research Centre of the Russian
g Academy of Sciences, Ufa, Russia
q 2 Institute of biochemistry and genetics - Subdivision of the Ufa Federal Research Centre of the Russian
§ Academy of Sciences, Ufa, Russia
^ *E-mail: [email protected]
Abstract. The research aim is to study the inheritance of a thousand-seed weight trait by Fj and F2 hybrids peas. Research methods. The study was conducted at the Chishminskiy plant breeding center of the Bashkir Research Institute - the Subdivision of the Russian Science Academy, located in the Cis-Ural steppe zone, in 2017-2019. The paper describes hybridization with two parental pairs, reciprocal crosses, and resulting pea hybrids. Five varieties were analyzed: Shikhan, Chishminskiy 75, Chishminskiy 80, Chishminskiy 95, Melkosemyannyy 2. The resulting seeds were divided into groups: large, medium-large, medium, medium-small, small. The standard deviation (a), the coefficient of variation (Vc, %), heritability estimate (H2), and the degree of dominance (hp) were determined. Statistical data were analyzed in Microsoft Office Excel 2010 using Statistica 7.0. Results. As a result of the conducted experiments, Fj hybrid peas showed lower thousand-seed weight than the large-seeded parent plants. Whereupon, the large-seeded genotype of a mother plant had a greater effect on the manifestation of this trait in hybrids. F2 hybrid peas expressed a thousand-seed weight trait in an intermediate fashion. However, the average values of this trait were much lower than in Fj hybrids. The coefficient of variation Vc in F2 plants was 24.3-33.3%, the degree of dominance hp was 0.20-0.32 (incomplete dominance of the trait). Scientific novelty. The inheritance of a thousand-seed weight in regional varieties that distinctly differ on this trait and in hybrids obtained by crossing was studied for the first time in conditions of the Republic of Bashkortostan. New large-seeded and small-seeded sources for pea breeding were identified. Keywords: peas, breeding, crossing, hybrid, thousand-seed weight, seed size, heritability estimate, degree of dominance.
For citation: Davletov F. A., Gaynullina K. P., Pleshkov A. V. Patterns of thousand-seed weight inheritance in Fj and F2 pea hybrids // Agrarian Bulletin of the Urals. 2021. No. 01 (204). Pp. 46-50. DOI: 10.32417/1997-4868-2021-204-01-46-50.
Paper submitted: 04.06.2020.
Introduction
The selection of new varieties is of primary importance in ensuring increased productivity of pea grains [1, p. 604], [2, p. ^ 21]. Currently, intervarietal hybridization plays the most im-o portant role among other plant breeding methods as remote 2 hybridization, physical and chemical mutagenesis, experimen-jg tal polyploidy, and the use of cell, tissue, and organ cultures | [3, p. 145].
However, it has some limitations in creating high yielding, ;> readily producible varieties adaptive to local conditions. The ^ way hybrids inherit quantitative traits, and the degree parent ^ genotypes influence their manifestation, are not well under-• S stood [4, pp. 21-22]; [5, p. 947], [6, p. 208]. This paper pres-3 ents the results of research on specific aspects of this problem. ¡^ The target is to study the inheritance of a seed size trait O (thousand-seed weight) in pea hybrids, and the degree parent ^ plants affect its expression. ^ Methods
g" The experiments were conducted at the Chishminskiy plant ju breeding center of the Bashkir Research Institute - the Subdi-^ vision of the Russian Academy of Sciences, in 2017-2019.
S 46
Five pea varieties (Shikhan, Chishminskiy 75, Chishminskiy 80, Chishminskiy 95, Melkosemyannyy 2) were used as a material to analyze the way a seed size trait is inherited.
Plant crossing was performed according to the scheme: Shikhan x Melkosemyannyy 2, Chishminskiy 75 x Melkosemyannyy 2, Chishminskiy 80 x Melkosemyannyy 2, Chishminskiy 95 x Melkosemyannyy 2. Backcrossings were carried out as well.
First- and second-generation hybrids were sown using an SKS-6-10 seeder. The predecessor is winter rye. Farming methods are generally accepted for the zone. The area of plant alimentation is 20 x 5 cm. The plot size was determined by the seed presence. Hybrids were planted next to their parent forms.
The inheritance of the seed size trait was studied on Fj and F2 hybrids. Bundles of hybrid swarms were selected for analysis. Seeds were weighed on laboratory scales. As a result of weighting, seeds were divided into groups according to their sizes, shown in table 1.
The analysis involved finding standard deviation (c), the coefficient of variation (Vc, %), heritability estimate (H2), and the degree of dominance (hp). Statistical processing of data resulted from field experiments was conducted following the generally accepted method of B. A. Dospekhov. It was done with the Statistica 10.0 and Microsoft Office Excel 2010 software packages. Each indicator was handled in terms of the mean value (M), standard error (±SEM), and confidence interval (t005 x SEM).
Results
Little is understood on the inheritance of a thousand-seed weight trait, although some studies are devoted to this problem. In 1912, while crossing small-seeded pea samples with large-seeded ones, Tschermak found an intermediate character of a thousand-seed weight inheritance in Fj and a large variety in size in F2. The ratio of small seeds to all other transitional types was 1:264, close to the 1:255 tetrahybrid segregation model. Based on this, the Austrian scientist concluded that the small-seeded parent form used in crosses had four recessive genes responsible for the formation of small seeds, the large-seeded parent form had four dominant genes, and the intermediate forms are the result of a combination of recessive and dominant genes [7, p.18], [8, pp. 401-402], [9, p. 64]. Subsequently, Wellensiek used Sgp Sg2, Sg3, Sg4 symbols in 1925, and Yarnell applied Sp S2, S3, S4 signs in 1964 [7, p. 19], [10, p. 15], [11, p. 23].
In 1969-1970 V. H. Khangildin and V V Khangildin, using the Sewall Wright formula, calculated the smallest possible number of non-allelic genes responsible for varietal differences in seed size. Dispersion analysis of the thousand-seed weight in varieties with different seed sizes and their hybrids showed that large-seeded varieties differ from Melkosemyan-nyy 2 variety in the presence of two dominant gene alleles [7, p. 19; 11, p.23]. Melkosemyannyy 2 variety (thousand-seed weight is 80-110 g) has five recessive seed size genes. Large-seeded pea varieties have 4-5 dominant genes involved in the formation of high weight of 1000 seeds. Seed size is mostly determined by the internal genetic potential of the variety and the conditions of its cultivation [12, p. 63], [13, p. 7], [14, pp. 71-72].
The literature indicates that first-generation hybrids are characterized by an intermediate manifestation of the trait with a bias towards the parent form with larger seeds when crossing samples that distinctly differ in a thousand-seed weight. In the second filial generation, there is trait segregation with a predominance of plants with intermediate values of a thousand-seed weight [15, pp. 36-37], [16, p.607].
In our experiments, Fj hybrids from direct and reverse (reciprocal) crossing being significantly different in the thousand-seed weight were characterized by intermediate values of this trait with a bias towards the large-seeded parent form. However, their thousand-seed weight was lower. Thus, hybrids from large-seeded varieties of mother plants had lower the thousand-seed weight by an average of 15.4%. Hybrid offspring from large-seeded varieties of father plants were 19.8% inferior to them (table 2).
As the experiment results show, the manifestation of the thousand-seed weight trait in Fj pea hybrids is mostly influenced by the genotype of a large-seeded variety, regardless of whether it is used as a mother or father form. However, it should be noted that in our studies, the manifestation of this trait in pea hybrids was greater when a large-seeded variety was of a mother form.
In our studies, F2 hybrid offspring were characterized by lower average weight values of 1000 seeds than Fj hybrid offspring (table 3).
Thus, the obtained data are consistent with the opinion of other researchers regarding the intermediate inheritance of the studied trait in hybrids (fig. 1).
In our experiments, the coefficient of variation in the parent varieties ranged from 6.5 to 12.3%. In the hybrid combinations of the second generation, this indicator varied in the range of 24.3-33.3%. A sharp increase in the coefficient of variation in F2 hybrids indicates that in addition to environmental factors, there is genotypic segregation making hereditary variability 87-95%. The dominance degree hp = 0.20-0.32 demonstrates incomplete dominance of the thousand-seed weight trait.
Table 1
Classification of pea seeds by their size
i I—
l
CTQ
a
!=s a
b I—
o
rift)
0 b ¡3
1
CTQ h-1*
rt)
Vi
Seed size class Weight of 1 seed, g Weight of1000 seeds, g
I. Large 0.280-0.300 280-300
II. Semi-large 0.250-0.279 250-279
III. Medium 0.160-0.249 160-249
IV. Semi-small 0.130-0.159 130-159
V. Small 0.090-0.129 90-129
Table 2
Thousand-seed weight in F pea hybrids and their parents (2017)
Number of hybrids, pcs Weight of1000 seeds, g Deviation of the weight of1000 seeds in a hybrid relative to the best parent
Mother plant F, hybrid Father plant Absolute value, ± g Relative value, ± %
Direct crosses
4 253 ± 5.0 214 ± 3.8 105 ± 2.8 -39 -15.4
Reciprocal crosses
4 105 ± 2.3 203 ± 3.5 253 ± 5.0 -50 -19.8
s s
и
о к о к
и
<и н о S
\о
s «
s
и
о к о s
IQ
Table 3
Thousand-seed frequency distribution F2 pea hybrids and their parents (2018)
Varieties and hybrids Number of seeds assigned to the size class, pcs Weight of1000 seeds, g
I II III IV V
Direct crosses
Shikhan 352 605 43 0 0 270 ± 14.6
Shikhan x Melkosemyannyy 2 67 256 370 243 64 206 ± 7.8
Melkosemyannyy 2 0 0 9 840 151 110 ± 8.6
Chishminskiy 75 0 89 859 52 0 220 ± 9.0
Chishminskiy 75 x Melkosemyannyy 2 0 8 240 504 248 180 ± 3.8
Melkosemyannyy 2 0 0 9 840 151 110 ± 8.6
Chishminskiy 80 105 599 296 0 0 256 ± 10.0
Chishminskiy 80 x Melkosemyannyy 2 57 260 470 182 31 206 ± 7.8
Melkosemyannyy 2 0 0 9 840 151 110 ± 8.6
Chishminskiy 95 250 602 148 0 0 263 ± 10.0
Chishminskiy 95 x Melkosemyannyy 2 63 250 375 250 62 206± 8.0
Melkosemyannyy 2 0 0 9 840 151 110 ± 8.6
Reciprocal crosses
Melkosemyannyy 2 0 0 9 840 151 110 ± 8.6
Melkosemyannyyx Shikhan 60 260 373 233 74 201 ± 9.4
Shikhan 352 605 43 0 0 270 ± 14.6
Melkosemyannyy 2 0 0 9 840 151 110 ± 8.6
Melkosemyannyy 2 x Chishminskiy 75 0 13 234 491 262 173 ± 7.8
Chishminskiy 75 0 89 859 52 0 220 ± 9.0
Melkosemyannyy 2 0 0 9 840 151 110 ± 8.6
Melkosemyannyy 2 x Chishminskiy 80 70 245 459 192 34 211 ± 9.0
Chishminskiy 80 105 599 296 0 0 256 ± 10.0
Melkosemyannyy 2 0 0 9 840 151 110 ± 8.6
Melkosemyannyy 2 x Chishminskiy 95 72 266 361 255 46 217± 9.8
Chishminskiy 95 250 602 148 0 0 263 ± 10.0
Fig. 1. Seed size frequency distribution in F2 pea hybrids and their parents
Fig. 2. Pea seeds of different sizes
On the whole, the conducted study showed that crossing Reciprocal F2 hybrids by seed size (weight of 1000 seeds) local medium- and large-seeded pea varieties Shikhan, Chish- occupied an intermediate position between parent plants with ^ minskiy 75, Chishminskiy 80, Chishminskiy 95 with a con- a bias towards the best variety and slightly differed from F2 o'
trasting small-seeded Melkosemyannyy 2 resulted in interme- hybrids of the direct crossing. O
CfQ
diate inheritance of the studied trait in the first generation of Studying regularities in the inheritance of quantitative y
hybrids. traits involved in the formation of pea productivity will im- n
In the second generation, the trait was split, and the propor- prove the efficiency of selection in segregated hybrid swarms. d
tion of small-seeded hybrids with 4-5 recessive genes in their This knowledge is essential when planning crossings, selec- i
genotype ranged from 3.1 to 6.4%. However, there were iden- tion of parent pairs, the choice of the breeding methodology. £
tified valuable small-seeded F2 hybrids. The analysis of the hy- The seed size trait, developed by polymeric genes, can vary C
brid population from a direct crossing of the medium-seeded greatly depending on the growing conditions. The given study n
Chishminskiy 75 and Melkosemyannyy 2 varieties resulted in showed that the calculation of the heritability coefficients and o
8 medium-large, 240 medium, 504 medium-small, 248 small- variability makes it possible to predict the manifestation of g
seeded samples (fig. 2). Moreover, small-seeded and medium- the desired genotypes when crossing varieties characterized e
small-seeded hybrids being of interest for breeding purposes by different seed sizes. It resulted in new large- and small- 73
were found with a frequency of 24.8 and 50.4%, respectively. seeded sources for pea breeding, which are being evaluated in
the breeding nursery.
References
1. Annicchiarico P., Nazzicari N., Pecetti L., Romani M., Russi L. Pea genomic selection for Italian environments // BioMed Central Genomics. 2019. Vol. 20. Iss. 1. Article number 603. DOI: 10.1186/s12864-019-5920-x.
2. Davletov F. A., Gaynullina K. P., Karimov I. K. Sravnitelnoe izuchenie morfobiologicheskikh i khoziaistvenno-tsennykh priznakov gorokha starodavnikh i sovremennykh sortov [Comparative study of morphobiological and economically valuable characteristics of peas of ancient and modern varieties] // Bulletin of Bashkir State Agrarian University. 2016. No. 40 (4). Pp. 21-30. (In Russian.)
3. Sekhon B. S., Sharma A., Katoch V., Kapila R. K., Sood V. K. Assessment of genetic diversity in advanced breeding lines derived from intraspecific crosses of garden pea (Pisum sativum L.) // Legume Research. 2019. Vol. 42. Iss. 2. Pp. 145-152. DOI: 10.18805/LR-3923.
4. Kotlyar I. P., Ushakov V. A., Krivenkov L. V., Pronina E. P. Izmenchivost' priznaka "massa 1000 semyan" kak osnovnogo elementa produktivnosti u gorokha ovoshchnogo [Variability of the thousand-seed weight trait as the main element of yielding in vegetable peas] // Vegetable crops of Russia. 2018. No. 2. Pp. 21-23. DOI: 10.18619/2072-9146-2018-2-21-23. (In Russian.)
5. Parihar A. K., Dixit G. P., Singh D. Gene interactions and genetics for yield and its attributes in grass pea (Lathyrus sativus L.) // Journal of Genetics. 2016. Vol. 95. Iss. 4. Pp. 947-956. DOI: 10.1007/s12041-016-0722-2.
6. Volkova L. V Nasleduyemost' i izmenchivost' priznakov produktivnosti u gibridov yarovoy myagkoy pshenitsy pervogo-chetvertogo pokoleniy [Inheritance and variability of productivity traits in hybrids of spring soft wheat of the first to fourth generations] // Agricultural Science Euro-North-East. 2019. T. 20. No. 3. Pp. 207-218. DOI: 10.30766/2072-9081.2019.20.3.207218. (In Russian.)
7. Davletov F. A. Selektsiya i tekhnologiya proizvodstva gorokha v Bashkortostane [Breeding and technology of pea production in Bashkortostan]. Ufa: Mir pechati, 2015. 164 p. (In Russian.)
8. Gliboff S. J. Breeding better peas, pumpkins, and peasants: the practical Mendelism of Erich Tschermak // New Perspectives on the History of Life Sciences and Agriculture / Denise Phillips, Sharon Kingsland. Springer, Cham, 2015. Pp. 395-413. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-12185-7.
9. Simunek M. V, Mielewczik M., Levit G. S., Hossfeld U. Armin von Tschermak-Seysenegg (1870-1952): physiologist and co-'rediscoverer' of Mendel's laws // Theory in Biosciences. 2017. Vol. 136. Iss. 1-2. Pp. 59-67. DOI: 10.1007/s12064-016-0236-8.
10. Kosterin O. E. Pri tsare gorokhe (Pisum sativum L.): neprostaya sud'ba pervogo geneticheskogo ob''yekta [Pea (Pisum sativum L.): the uneasy fate of the first genetical object] // Vavilov Journal of Genetics and Breeding. 2015. T. 19. No. 1. Pp. 13-26. DOI: 10.18699/VJ15.002. (In Russian.)
11. Ashiyev A. R. Iskhodnyy material gorokha (Pisum sativum L.) i yego selektsionnoye ispol'zovaniye v usloviyakh Predural'skoy stepi Respubliki Bashkortostan: dis. .. .kand. s.-kh. nauk [Initial material of pea (Pisum sativum L.) and its breeding use in the conditions of the PreUral steppe of the Republic of Bashkortostan: dissertation ... candidate of agricultural sciences]. Kazan', 2014. 184 p. (In Russian.)
12. Georg'yeva N., Nikolova I., Kosev V. Evaluation of genetic divergence and heritability in pea (Pisum sativum L.) // Journal of Biosciences and Biotechnology. 2016. Vol. 5. Iss. 1. Pp. 61-67.
13. Lakic Z., Stankovic S., Pavlovic S., Krnjajic S., Popovic V. Genetic variability in quantitative traits of field pea (Pisum sativum L.) genotypes // Czech Journal of Genetics and Plant Breeding. 2019. Vol. 55. Pp. 1-7. DOI: 10.3835/plantgen-ome2016.07.0072.
14. Shurkhayeva K. D., Fadeyeva A. N. Izmenchivost' elementov produktivnosti kollektsionnykh obraztsov gorokha [Variability of productivity elements of collection samples of peas] // Legumes and groat crops. 2015. No. 3 (15). Pp. 71-76. (In Russian.)
15. Ellis T. H. N., Hofer J. M. I., Swain M. T., Dijk P. J. Mendel's pea crosses: varieties, traits and statistics // Hereditas. 2019. Vol. 156. Pp. 33-43. DOI: 10.1186/s41065-019-0111-y.
16. Hama-Amin T. N. Half diallel analysis of seven pea cultivars for seed yield and its components for F4 generation under Sulaimani condition // Iraqi Journal of Agricultural Sciences. 2020. Vol. 51. Iss. 2. Pp. 600-610.
Authors's information:
Firzinat A. Davletov1, doctor of agricultural sciences, chief of the laboratory of selection and seed-growing of pulse crops, ORCID 0000-0002-7421-869Х, AuthorID 782015; +7 960 383-67-44, [email protected]
Karina P. Gaynullina1, 2, candidate of biological sciences, senior researcher of the laboratory of selection and seed-growing of pulse crops1, senior researcher of the laboratory of plant genomics2, ORCID 0000-0001-6246-1214, AuthorID 783611; + 7 989 953-15-00, [email protected]
Aleksandr V. Pleshkov1, agronomist of the laboratory of selection and seed-growing of pulse crops, ORCID 0000-0002-5513-2065, AuthorID 1039895; +7 917 344-04-50, [email protected]
1 Bashkir Research Institute of Agriculture - Subdivision of the Ufa Federal Research Centre of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Ufa, Russia
2 Institute of biochemistry and genetics - Subdivision of the Ufa Federal Research Centre of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Ufa, Russia