CC BY
39
Original scientific paper
UDK: 37.064.1 159.922.7
doi: 10.23947/2334-8496-2022-10-1-29-34
Received: March, 01.2022. Revised: March, 28.2022. Accepted: April, 07.2022.
Check for updates
Partnership of Parents of Children who Need Additional Support in Learning and Preschool Teachers in Preschool Institutions from the Perspective of the Integrated Approach to Learning
'University of Novi Sad, Faculty of Education in Sombor, Serbia, e-mail: mrbiljana@gmail.com 2University of Pristina - Kosovska Mitrovica, Faculty Teacher of Education in Prizren - Leposavic, Serbia,
e-mail: zivorad.milenovic@pr.ac.rs 3University of Nish, Faculty of Philosofy, Serbia, e-mail: jelena.petrovic@filfak.ni.ac.rs
"Preschool Teacher Training College of Applied Studies in Kikinda, Serbia, e-mail: zagorka.markov@gmail.com
Abstract: This research focuses on the collaboration between preschool teachers and parents of children who need additional support in learning in kindergarten through the prism of the integrated approach to learning. The research was based on a general assumption that the success of the cooperation between preschool teachers and parents of children who need additional support in learning is inconsistent and with varying efficacy. The research was conducted in the 2019/2020 school year, on a sample group of 52 preschool teachers. The data collected by the Scaler Family involvement questionnaire (a = .086) were analysed using descriptive statistics that showed that there are significant differences in preschool teachers' assessment of mutual information sharing and activities of parents within the family, while there are none regarding parents' participation in kindergarten activities. The results of the research are presented in the form of the conclusion, with pedagogical implications provided alongside.
Keywords: kindergarten activities, music, educational activities, interdisciplinary team, pedagogical competencies of
parents.
The integrated approach to learning is the functional connection and coordination of educational fields and programs that are similar or that complement each other in the realization of planned objectives. That means that being knowledgeable in one area of educational work contributes to and helpswiththe better acquisition of content of the other educational area (Pravilnik o osnovama programa predskolskog vaspitanja i obrazovanja „Godine uzleta" iz 2018; Pravilnik o blizim uputstvima za utvrdivanje prava na individualni obrazovni plan, njegovu primenu i vrednovanje iz 2018.). Based on these facts, a preschool teacher should be "...a participant in an innovative educational process, with the aim of tracking and achieving professional and scientific goalsin order to improve his/her practice." (Jeremic, 2012a, p. 99). They are expected to be an innovator in this process and a coordinator in an interdisciplinary team that works to improve the educational profession and preschool education in general. They should not be a marginal person but a professional who ".uses an integrated and interdisciplinary approach to implement, research, and improve the education process." (Jeremic, 2012a, p. 101). This learning model strives to achieve a ".stronger connection of different education areas without a clearly recognizable boundary in the realization of planned goals and objectives, whereas the knowledge that is adopted and applied in different situations becomes more permanent and easier to apply" (Micanovic and Novovic, 2018, p. 630). The integrated approach to learning emphasizes the intellectual, social, emotional, and aesthetic development, supports the overall development of the child and does not focus solely on individual and mainly cognitive aspects.
The principles of collaboration between the preschool institution and the preschool teacher with the
'Corresponding author: zivorad.milenovic@pr.ac.rs
© 2022 by the authors. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.Org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Biljana Jeremic1 , Zivorad Milenovic?" , Jelena Petrovic3 , Zagorka Markov4
Introduction
family and children' parents are based on honesty, trust, gradualness and bidirectionality and diversity. (Pavlovic Breneselvic and Krnjaja, 2017). Under the conditions in which the child has a chance to express their idea, interest, etc., children who need additional support in learning will receive support from their peers or another solution that will branch the topic into additional directions, which will encourage preschool children to think, cooperate, and participate in other kindergarten activities. Just as the parents need to be familiar with their child's stay in the kindergarten and their participation in activities, communication with other children, their psychophysical progress, so too the preschool teacher needs to be familiar with the circumstances in the child's family, with the aim of the child's overall wellbeing. As a multidimensional process, this cooperation requires additional time and patience by all participants and a partnership between the preschool teacher and parents, including the competencies of the preschool teacher to cooperate with the parents (Milenovic and Jeftovic, 2012a), but also the pedagogical competencies of parents to cooperate with preschool teachers (Milenovic and Jeftovic, 2012b). The collaboration between parents and preschool teachers using the integrated approach to learning finds its application in music activities as well. Children develop functional abilities by performing music through singing and playing instruments. Musical activities are also important because music can point out certain developmental disabilities of preschool children (Jeremic and Markov, 2015). This is indicated by the results of some studies that prove that music can be used to identify certain indicators that hint at possibilities of different developmental disabilities (Ilic, 2010). That way, music can be a tool to identify symptoms in children with Down's syndrome (Pienaar, 2012), autism, ADHD (McFerran, 2009), and other disorders in children's development and obstacles in education and learning.
Jeremic and Markov (2015, p.796) ask the question: how can we adjust the education process to children who need additional support in learning so that they feel pleasant and accepted? The answers are precisely in music,which affects people, especially preschool children, through emotions (Vickhoff, 2008). Music also triggers communication in which messages are transmitted with singing and/or playing, and communication happens through emotions (Jeremic, 2012b). The messages transmitted by music should be adjusted to the needs and cognitive abilities of children that need additional support in learning, whereby it is important to consider the social aspect of project activities that are realized in preschool institutions (socialising, group work), as well as the feeling of altruism and empathy in these children (helping, self-respect, a sense of personal worth) as important factors of their motivation. This is confirmed by additional more recently published studies on this topic (Jeremic and Milenovic, 2020; Milenovic and Minic, 2021).
Materials and Methods
The research aims to determine whether there are differences in the beliefs of preschool teachers about the quality of their collaboration with parents of children who need additional support in learning and the preschool institution within the integrated approach to learning. The research started from the general assumption that the success of cooperation between preschool teachers and parents of children who need additional support in learning varies, that not all preschool teachers cooperate equally with the parents of these children, so for this reason, the different assessments of preschool teachers about the educational efficiency of their cooperation with the parents of children who need additional support in learning are understandable. The research was also based on special assumptions that the research will identify the differences in preschool teaches' assessments about the mutual information sharing between the parents of children who need additional support in learning and the preschool institution, as well as the inclusion of parents of these children in the activities in preschools.
Sample and Procedure
The research covered 52 preschool teachers who worked with children who need additional support in learning, and who assessed the collaboration between the preschool institution and parents of children who need additional support in learning during the 2019/2020 school year.
Instrument
A standardized combined instrument was used to assess the abovecollaboration - Parental Involvement Scaler with two sub-scales: 1) Mutual information-sharing between parents and preschool teachers(MI) and 2) Parental involvement in kindergarten (PIK) that was partially adjusted for this research (Fantuzzo, Tighe and Childs, 2000). After a correction, the reliability of the instrument was tested using Cronbach's alpha coefficient, which showed a very good value («= .086). The scaler consists of 14 items
with a three-level scale of frequency intensity: 1) always, 2) often and 3) rarely. In addition to choosing one of the answers for each item, there is also an option to leave a short comment regarding the reasons for choosing the particular answer.
Statistical analysis
The data collected for the research purposes were analysed using descriptive statistics in the statistical software IBM SPSS 24.0, and the results of the research are shown in the form of tables.
Results and Discussions
Table 1 shows the results of the x2 test that was used to assess the differences in answers given by preschool teachers on the subscale MI.
Table 1
Mutual information-sharing between parents and preschool within the integrated approach to learning from the point of view of the preschool teacher
¡jtms Always Often Rarely
(The partnr of this child...) F % / % / % * r P
al Talks to the preschool teacher
about how their child gets along 29 55.16 17 32.69 6 11.53 15.269 .000
with other children in the
kindergarten.
al Is interested in pedagogical
education in order to improve their 10 13.24 14 26.92 2S 53.S4 10.308 .005
parental competencies.
a3 Informs me about the interests
and affinities of the child so that I 27 51.92 IS 34.61 7 13.46 11.577 .003
can get to know them better.
a4Is familiar with the extent to
which the child participates in 32 51.53 IS 34.62 12 23.OS 19.077 .000
everyday tasks in the kindergarten.
a5 Attends parent meetings to stay
informed about the child's success 31 59.61 16 30.77 5 9.62 19.654 .000
and behavior in kindergarten.
a6Exchanges information about the
child with the preschool teacher in 29 55.77 14 26.92 9 17.31 12.50 .001
writing as well.
a7 Initiates a conversation with the
preschool teacher when there is a
problem or they need a detailed IS 34.61 14 26.92 20 3S.47 1.077 .583
explanation in regards to the child's
education.
The analysis of the results presented in Table 1 shows that most parents of children who need additional support in learning (53.84%) are rarely interested in pedagogical education with the aim of improving their parenting competencies with the support frompreschool teachers. According to the observations of preschool teachers in the context of the integrated approach to learning, a total of 23.08% of parents rarely show interest regarding the degree to which their child participates in everyday activities in kindergarten.
The results of the conducted research are in line with some other studies that also points out the importance of pedagogical education of parents from the aspect of support children receive from their family environment (Milenovic and Jeftovic, 2012b). The presented results of the research also indicate the need for parents to gain trust in all preschool employees with the aim of developing a partnership between the parents and the preschool institution, in order to be able to openly communicate any problems. Pedagogically trained parents will be able to cooperate more efficiently with their children's preschool teachers. They will also have a more consistent educational effect on their children in the family environment, all in cooperation with preschool teachers. This achieves an additional effect that refers to greater connection and cooperation between the parents of all children, both in a certain educational
group and in the entire kindergarten, which is especially indicated by the results of the research shown in Table 2.
Table 2
Parents involvement in kindergarten activities within the integrated approach to learning from the point of view of preschool teachers
Items Always Often Rarely
(The parent of this child...) / % / % / % P
al Volunteers in different activities
organized in their child's 11 21.15 12 23.08 29 55.77 11.808 .002
educational group.
a2 Participates in social activities
that are organized for socializing of all parents. 9 17.31 11 21.15 32 61.54 18.731 .000
a3 Participates in planning group activities. 14 26.92 17 32.70 21 40.38 1.423 .490
a4 Participates in kindergarten activities as a spectator. 10 19.23 9 17.31 33 63.46 21.269 .000
a5 Plans and programs activities
with the preschool teacher 14 26.92 6 11.54 32 61.54 20.462 .000
a6 Supports other parents, 12 23.08 16 30.77 24 46.15 4.308 .116
a7 Participates in activities related to
fiuidraisme in the kindergarten. 14 26.92 20 38.47 18 34.61 1.077 .583
By analysing the results presented in Table 2, based on the observations of the preschool teacher, we can see that the parents of children who need additional support in learning participate in kindergarten activities in a smaller percentage. We observe that a large percentage of parents rarely attends kindergarten activities as spectators (63.46%), participate in planning and programming of activities with preschool teachers (61.54%) and activities that are organized for parental socialization (61.54%).
The results of the research show that a smaller percentage of parents and children of the mass population is ready to participate in kindergarten activities; therefore, with that in mind, preschool institutions should take steps that would encourage parents to participate in planning and programming of learning activities together with preschool teachers and other professionals (Milenovic and Jeftovic, 2012a). If parents see that they are respected by preschool teachers and professional associates they will more eagerly particicpate in kindergarten activities. Encouraging families to engage within the integrated approach to learning also means inviting family members to attend kindergarten activities. The preschool teacher should encourage parents to relax and play and to emphasize that winning is of secondary importance and that in early childhood the process of learning is much more important than the outcomes and results. Preschool teachers and professional associates should talk to parents about how they can guide the child's behaviour by presenting them with specific strategies useful for achieving positive results. The collaboration between parents and the preschool institution can be further encouraged by the support from special educators and speech therapists, which is specifically defined by the Rulebook on additional educational, health and social support for children and students from 2018. The Rulebook stipulates that special educators and speech therapists provide support to both parents and preschool teachers. It is exactly the following of the recommendations of special educators and speech therapists and their consistent application in kindergarten and the family environment that will contribute to the strengthening of cooperation between preschool teachers and parents.
Conclusion
This research concludes that the collaboration between preschool teachers and parents of children who need additional support in learning in preschool institutions from the perspective of the integrated approach to learning in the realization of project activities is achieved with varying intensity and inconsistently, depending on individual preschool teachers. That is why the expected educational efficiency of this cooperation is missing. It is precisely the integrated approach to learning that enables families to actively participate in the education of their children in public, to become aware of their latent needs and capacities, and to develop parenting competencies. The integrated approach implies that, in addition to children and preschool teachers, parents are equal participants in the education process; in that sense,
they should be informed about the development of their child at all times by professionals employed in the preschool institution. Additionally, it helps parents by allowing them to get involved in kindergarten activities, because by participating in the activities they will spontaneously acquire pedagogical knowledge that will improvetheir parenting competencies.
By participating in the activities, parents can see the abilities of their children in relation to other children and understand that their child progresses at their own pace or that the child requires support from preschool teachers and other professionals. Preschool teachers and professionals will determine which learning style is most suitable for the child with developmental disabilities and further adapt it to the child. Encouraging parents to participate in kindergarten activities will contribute to parents understanding that they are welcome in the preschool because, by participating, they confirm that they are equal participants in the education process. Through more frequent contact with preschool teachers and other practitioners, parents will start a collaboration based on sincere trust, as this process has the child's well-being and achieving its functionality for the next level of education and everyday life as the ultimate goal. All of that indicates the need for providing guidelines and implementing practical procedures that would contribute to better cooperation between the preschool institution and the parents of children who need additional support in learning within the integrated approach to learning.
Acknowledgements
This paper was written as part of science projects which have been funded by the of a Shortterm Project of Special Interest for Sustainable Development in AP Vojvodina in 2021: Digital Kindergartens in the Pandemic Age ID142-451-2384/2021-01/02.
This paper was written as part of science two projects which have been funded by the Ministry of Education, Science and Technological Development of Republic of Serbia.1) Material and spiritual culture of Kosovo and Metohija, ID 178028; and 2) Implementation of teaching contents from Didactics in study ^ programs for educators in preschool institutions in changed conditions of preschool education and learning, approved for financing by the Sector for Higher Education, within projects from program activities Development of Higher Education in 2021. ID 612-00-01187/2021-06/29.
This paper was written as part of science two projects funded by the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Srpska (Bosnia and Herzegovina): 1) The development of software for identifying talent in students, ID 19/6-020/961- 26/1; and 2) Software support for prediction of student success in studying, ID 19/6-020/961-27/18.
The work is also the result of research within a scientific internal junior project The contribution of doctoral studies of class teaching of the home faculty for teacher education: state, dilemmas and perspectives of classroom teaching methods, ID IJP 001, which in the period 2021 - 2022. financially supports Faculty of Teacher Education in Prizren - Leposavic, Univeristy in Pristina - Kosovska Mitrovica.
Conflict of interests
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Reference
Christenson, S. (2004).The family-school partnership: An opportunity to promote the learning competence of all students.
School Psychology Review, 33(1), 83-104. https://doi.org/10.1521/scpq.18A454.26995 Fantuzzo, J, Tighe, E. & Childs, S. (2000). Family involvement questionnaire: a multivariate assessment of family participation in early childhood education. Journal of Educational Psychology, 92(2), 367-376. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0663.92.2.367
Ilic, M. (2010). Inkluzivna nastava [Inclusive teaching].Univerzitet u Istocnom Sarajevu, Filozofski fakultet na Palama. Retrieved
from: https://pdfcoffee.com/dr-mile-ili-inkluzivna-nastava-pdf-free.html Jeremic, B. (2012a). Integrativni pristup u radu sa decom predskolskog uzrasta u okviru muzicke kulture [An integrative approach in working with preschool children within music culture]. Zbornik VSSSOV, 2(2), 98-113. Retrieved from: http://vaspitacka.edu.rs/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/305-36opHMK-paflOBa-6p.2-2012.pdf Jeremic, B. (2012b). Emocionalne reakcije dece predskolskog uzrasta u toku slusanja muzike [Emotional reactions of preschool children while listening to music]. U: T. Grujic (ured.). Metodicki dani - kompetencije vaspitaca za drustvo znanja [Methodical days - competences of educators for societ], (str. 211-220). Visoka strukovna skola za obrazovanje vaspitaca u Kikindi. Retrieved from: http://vaspitacka.edu.rs/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/255-TeMaTCKM-36opHMK-HayHHO-CTpyHHa-KOH$epeHL(Mja-MeTOflMHKM-flaHM-2012.pdf Jeremic, B. & Markov, Z. (2015). Muzika kao podsticaj deci sa smetnjama i teskocama u razvoju [Music as an incentive for children with disabilities]. Ucenje i nastava, 1(4), 795-810. Retrieved from: http://www.klettobrazovanje.org/ Casopis/4%202015%20U%C4%8CENJE%20I%20NASTAVA.pdf
Jeremic, B. & Milenovic, Z. (2020). Drustveni kontekst nastave muzicke kulture u funkciji negovanja tradicionalnog narodnog stvaralastva Srba [The social context of teaching music culture in the function of nurturing the traditional folk art of Serbs]. Баштина, 30(52), 441-461. https://doi.org/10.5937/bastina30-29205 Maric Jurisin, S, & Klemenovic, J.(2018). Stavovi roditelja dece predskolskog uzrasta prema sopstvenom pedagoskom obrazovanju. [Attitudes of parents of preschool children towards their own pedagogical education]. Nastava i vaspitanje, 67(1), 175-190. https://doi.org/10.5937/nasvas1801175M McFerran, K. (2009). Quenching a Desire for Power: The Role of Music Therapy for Adolescents with ADHD. Australasian
Journal of Special Education, 33(1), 72-83. https://doi.org/10.1375/ajse.33.172 Micanovic, V. & Novovic, T. (2018). Problemi primjene integrisanog pristupa u realizaciji programskih ciljeva u predskolskim ustanovama iz vizure vaspitaca [Problems of applying an integrated approach in the realization of program goals in preschool institutions from the point of view of educators]. Ucenje i nastava, 4(4),629-664. Retrieved from: http://www. klettobrazovanje.org/Casopis/Ucenje%20i%20nastava%204%202018%20za%20sajt.pdf Milenovic, Z. & Jeftovic, M. (2012a). Faktori najcescih socijalno-komunikacijskih kompetencija vaspitaca [Factors of the most common social-communication competencies of educators]. Radovi Filozofskog fakulteta 14(14/2), 287-301. Retrieved from: https://www.academia.edu/9227177/Radovi_Filozofskog_fakulteta_u_Istocnom_Sarajevu_knjiga_14_ sveska_2_
Milenovic, Z. & Jeftovic, M. (2012b). Pedagoske kompetencije roditelja [Pedagogical competencies of parents]. Zbornik radova Uciteljskog fakulteta u Uzicu, 15(14), 43-58. Retrieved from: https://scindeks.ceon.rs/article.aspx?query=ISSID%26an d%2610755&page=3&sort=8&stype=0&backurl=%2fissue.aspx%3fissue%3d10755 Milenovic, Z. & Minic, V. (2021). Topics related to Education in Bastina journal betwen 1991 and 2020. Bastina, 36(53), 1-14.
https://doi.org/10.5937/bastina31-31101 Pavlovic Brenesalovic, D. & Krnjaja, Z.(2017). Kaleidoskop - osnove diversifikovanih programa predskolskog vaspitanja i obrazovanja [Kaleidoscope - basics of diversified programs of preschool education]. Univerziteta u Beogradu, Filozofski fakultet, Institut za pedagogiju i andragogiju. Retrieved from: http://www.predskolci.rs/HTML/Dokumenta/vesti/Osnove-diversifikovanih-programa-PVO.pdf Pienaar, D. (2012). Music Therapy for Children with Down Syndrome: Perceptions of Caregivers in a Special School Setting.
Kairaranga, 13(1), 36-43. Retrieved from: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ976663.pdf Pomerantz, E. M., Moorman, E. A., & Litwack, S. D. (2007). The How, Whom, and Why of Parents' Involvement in Children's Academic Lives: More Is Not Always Better. Review of Educational Research, 77(3), 373-410. https://doi. org/10.3102/003465430305567 Vickhoff, B. (2008). A Perspective Theory of Music Perception and Emotion. Doctoral dissertation in musicology at the Department of Culture, Aesthetics and Media. University of Gothenburg. Retrieved from: https://gupea.ub.gu.se/ bitstream/2077/9604/2/gupea_2077_9604_2.pdf *** Pravilnik o blizim uputstvima za utvrdivanje prava na individualni obrazovni plan, njegovu primenu i vrednovanje iz 2018. [Rulebook on detailed instructions for determining the right to an individual educational plan, its implementation and evaluation from 2018.]. „Sl. glasnikRS", br. 74/2018. Retrieved from: https://www.pravno-informacioni-sistem.rs/ SlGlasnikPortal/eli/rep/sgrs/ministarstva/pravilnik/2018/74/4/reg ***Pravilnik o dodatnoj obrazovnoj, zdravstvenoj i socijalnoj podrsci detetu i uceniku iz 2018.[Rulebook on additional educational, health and social support for children and students from 2018.]. „Sl. glasnik RS", br. 80/2018. Retrieved from: https:// www.paragraf.rs/propisi/pravilnik-dodatnoj-obrazovnoj-zdravstvenoj-socijalnoj-podrsci.html ***Pravilnik o osnovama programa predskolskog vaspitanja i obrazovanja „Godine uzleta" iz 2018. [Rulebook on the basics of preschool education programs „Years of takeoff" from 2018.]. „Службени гласник РС", бр. 88/17 и 27/18 - др. Закон. Retrieved from: https://www.danubeogradu.rs/2018/10/novi-program-predskolskog-vaspitanja-obrazovanja/
