О ПРОБЛЕМАХ ИСПОЛНЕНИЯ РЕШЕНИЯ СУДА ПО АДМИНИСТРАТИВНОМУ ДЕЛУ О ГОСПИТАЛИЗАЦИИ ГРАЖДАНИНА В МЕДИЦИНСКУЮ ПРОТИВОТУБЕРКУЛЕЗНУЮ ОРГАНИЗАЦИЮ В НЕДОБРОВОЛЬНОМ ПОРЯДКЕ Текст научной статьи по специальности «Право»

--

OL

B' $ j *E

z599KM23HXO:264816PIHJ249Q31M2M5MKGH O0 */

$

g_`+

Qg eWeb

bb hxb

bZ QhZhZ

bQ eb

N),-5J5N5JMNJ51(56+J5

'< $<$,'$,@,

65:12723UHY:5,NMM01kffH:J2VH:[f//+ c/+*cc

&&'()*+,- j$ "D <? %D= !, <?D=

= <% "< " < " < < ? "/

%? ?<%$"<<"</

= <%= " <, = "<$ < !$, /

?$,,<,@"<#

< <"<, < , " =

" %< < ? "$ <$/

<

./01231 4.'2)5 < <"<, <% " <, </

" <,"<$," ,"" ,"$<?/

D=,<%$"<

6., *+(+7'2)&+,5 ` j ; ^ "%= " ! < " </

< " < < ? "%? ?

<%$"<ffB' $ R *E

t:2[23494:M2J9K

$#n$!%w #%n #f

f nn!y

% yf !#$ #!y

!#&

\BF=;@;8?C;[<@;

OK:8IM4MKG4M2H349TK1K4:JN{32SK:12MP,OK:8,T51124,65:12723UHY:5, NMM01kffH:J2VH:[f//+ c/+*cc

89:;<=:-WNK4:M2J9K21VKSHMKVMHMNK1M5VPHX1HJ249:K94M2H31MN4MVKSK9H0Z2MN23MNKX:48KZH:6HXL5/

V2J2490:HJKKV23[123J41K1HXNH102M492}4M2H3HX4J2M2}K3MH48KV2J49M5UK:J59H121H:[432}4M2H3234323SH953/

M4:P 8433K: WNK 1NH:MJH823[1 HX MNK 9K[49 :K[594M2H3 HX 4V82321M:4M2SK 43V L5V2J249 0:HJKV5:K1 :K94MKV MH

JH80591H:P8KV2J4923MK:SK3M2H3:K8423435:[K3MMH02J,123JK,H3MNKH3KN43V,MNK:KXH:8HXMNK4V82321M:4/

M2SKL5V2J2491P1MK8JH3M235K123T51124,H3MNKHMNK:N43V,MNK2115K1HX:K1M:2JM2H3HXJH31M2M5M2H349:2[NM143V

X:KKVH8149Z4P1J451K41J2K3M2X2J:K10H31K43VJ9H1K4MMK3M2H323MNK:K1K4:JNK3S2:H38K3M

l`j;,

O

G 6I

>?@A;B95 4V82321M:4M2SK 0:HJKKV23[1, L5V2J249 0:HJKV5:K1, 4V82321M:4M2SK 0:HJKV5:K1, JH80591H:P

M:K4M8K3M,NH102M492}4M2H3,04M2K3M:2[NM1,V43[K:MHHMNK:1,23SH953M4:PH:VK: A;=C:<:CAD5“5:46234IQxUH5MMNK0:HU9K81HXKYKJ5M2H3HXMNKJH5:MVKJ212H323434V82321M:4M2SK

J41K H3 MNK NH102M492}4M2H3 HX 4 J2M2}K3 MH 4 8KV2J49 M5UK:J59H121 H:[432}4M2H3 23 43 23SH953M4:P 8433K:

,,3H ,00 */ Q3T511

B$+*` @d< *<"=/

<$ < ? "D$,$, ", %/

$<$< ?"D$"%D#/

<<$=#<$=""="?</

$,"<%<"$!%%/

D < "D$?, "<

<= #%$,<?D=<</

$?<

B ` @ d< <" $

<$="%<<"<=#<$

= ` ", = %, % =

"=,&(<"<%

< ="

p","<%<<"<<"$

?$==" $",/

?D < = "$

"%<<<"

€< < &%( ""$ " <Q| `<

< <"< @ d< `Fj@d " <$

!$<$""<%

<<<=,<"%"$""=

p <$ < !%= "% , "

=!<?D<<$/

,"<?D#<<"</

‰*Š^!$="%=""/

<$" @d

j<$,"`<<<"<@d

" "<$" <$"<

"b*`Fj@d&'<"<<" /

< < ? "%? ? <%$ "<(

=""<%=<,%$,"</

D?,%<!"<

? <%$ " < . ^< ""/

$""<<$$<,B=j<

@d"%=<"$")%* &^="/

=,?D=<<=<"/

<< ?"%? ?<%$"/

* ` @ d< " * < * , <% =< %D

*?ff^# /""# k{TykNMM0kff0:4SH[HS:5fJH31M2M5M2H3f<%Dk+c

`<<<"<@d< .* */di<*c#ffj%/

<$@d< * *j**^"<"<"%@d< k#<

*.?*cc/di< <ffj%<$@d< *)j .*

j,"k@!`<F=F=%$c#"<F/.*fffj/

<%@dk{TykNMM01kff15V4JM:5f:K[594:fVHJf‹xW”4LTySf<%Dk+c

--

O%

<(*,"<$"=""<%=<%=

! ` ", <$ " "*+ *)

", %$ <% !/

,<D$" ,"<"/

< , , < < "D <

< ?"%? ?'C"D?"<

<<?D? ?

` , " " $ ! < "<=<k

"$, ! < , <

D$ " , $ < " ! ‰Š B

<<$="%$&%(<"

B/"=,?D,!<,?<$/

" ,$<$""'

B=j<@d< """<$" ,

% "D $ < ` ", "<

" ,%=<$"$ " C=<

=<%=<="$ƒ‰Š

B/=,"< "<"%ƒ=,/

= %$ " <? %$= " <

="!<"<<"<$"/

‰+ Šh,#<$%c&^%"$/

"<(,<%"/"$"?" </

"% =< < ""

"$ < " %< "$ "/

< ^< <% "/"$ " D

< , "C " $ " < /

<"<%€<,"**#<$

c#**&^" (,"<%="<

" B" $%!$$</

< %D<<%$"

< 'C,!<,%"#/

< =< <%="""%"/

<%=<%=j< B€!,%=<

#<$= = &^% "$ "<(

&^" (,"<%!%"<%"/

/","$<" <<< /

%D<%$" ‰Š

B/$=,"%< /

",%$%""$?%,<D/

?<$?"<?<,<"/

<,C##$"?D<%!‰ Š

`,!<,""<"=/

< ,%.`Fj@dk

*^="=,?D=<<=<" << /

?"%? ?<%$"<k"'B=j<@d)%*

ffp?$B=j<@d*

^%"$"<k#<c/di<)"ffj%<$@d</

c+*j+.+

^" k#<c#**/di<)#ffj%<$@d< **cj

ON

G 6I

&*j<$63\*)31?,.3?P6;!"""<</

" < < ? "%/

? ?<%$"<(!EEY

†$ % $ <$ < #, "$ "

&<$"?(,<"/

<$ ! < #, ? < %$

%!,?'C<<!<$

< "< %< $ "<? *

.`Fj@d %=<$<$?D"</

ƒ%D**c`Fj@d""/

<"<=<<"/

" < < '

"). `Fj@d&<("!<""<$"/

, C ! "< "<$ "? < "

? , $ !? " , "

%$ "<$ ", < ; , "<%

= `Fj@d, = " $ &(, < $"<$$

j<$, <`Fj@d?/

=" $="<,=&<$("$" ", $"*‰)cŠ

'<< , < <%$, % <$! < "/

! " * `< < <"<

@ d< , <$, <$ % "/

$"< !"<<,/

"<$" <@d

L+0M6+0,M'J+6MN

* j$š F F ^%D "% " <= <%=

" <,="<$< !$,%=<=ff q<<k<*j*E*{TykNMM01kff3U05U921NJH8f92U:4:PŒ:K4V

Œ4:M2J9K0N02VŽ)+<%Dkc)

€!Bj`"!"<!<</

=<" << ?"%? ?

<%$"<ffi@k",,"j+Ec

`%oBjƒ,?D<"<%$"/

%$= % ff F< k < {Tyk NMM01kffZZZ4VS[4}KM4:5f3HSH1M2f S1/:4}P41329/19H}N3H1M2/SH}3264P51NJN2K/5/15VHS/0:2/3KVHU:HSH93HP/[H102M492}4M122/UH93P6N/M5UK:659K}H8f

<%Dkc)

+ ioa' $%"<$" %$=/

#%ffB^?<**j)E))

j"$ _ B ^% " ! < " < <

"<$" ffF$"%<<</

"<k /# {Tyk NMM01kffJH3X12U95:5fH1HUK33H1M2/210H93K32P4/

:K1NK32P4/15V4/0H/4V82321M:4M2S3H85/VK95/H/0:235V2MK93HP/[H102M492}4J22<%Dk+c

) `Bq^="%=""<"<

" < < ? "%? ? <%$

"<ffi@k",,"*cj*E.

c jq_%<<"<`<</

<"< @ d< k < / ff > < </

"<j E

--

OO

BEBCB@_BD

*IH9HSPKSxxtU1NJN2K0:HU9K8P0:4SHSH[H:K[592:HS432P44V82321M:4M2S3P6N215VKU3P6N0:HM/

1KV5:,1SP4}433P6N10:235V2MK9]3P8 8KV2M1231628S8K1N4MK9]1MSH8,S}4:5UK}N3P6N [H15V4:1MS46N‰„K3/

K:49 0:HU9K81 HX 9K[49 :K[594M2H3 HX 4V82321M:4M2SK 43V L5V2J249 0:HJKV5:K1 :K94MKV MH JH80591H:P 8KV2J49

23MK:SK3M2H3 23 XH:K2[3 JH53M:2K1Š B' , , 3H*, 00*/* Q3T511 xS4294U9K 4Mk NMM01kff3U05U921NJH8f92U:4:PŒ:K4VŒ4:M2J9K0N02VŽ)+4JJK11KVc)

\2:H1N32JNK36H | I“ SH0:H15 H 1HSK:1NK31MSHS4322 0H:P4V64 :4}:K1NK32P4 15V482 4V82321M:4/

M2S3P6N VK9 H [H102M492}4M122 [:4}NV43234 S 8KV2M123165P5 0:HM2SHM5UK:659K}35P5 H:[432}4M12P5 S 3KVHU:H/

SH9]3H80H:P4V6K‰t3MNK2115KHX280:HS23[MNK0:HJKV5:KXH::K1H9S23[4V82321M:4M2SKJ41K1UPJH5:M1H3

NH102M492}4M2H3HX4J2M2}K32348KV2J4943M2M5UK:J594:H:[432}4M2H3234323SH953M4:P8433K:ŠBC #

`8$8,,3H,00+/cQ3T511

“H:HU64 r|I:4}‚P41329 19H}N3H1M2, SH}3264P51NJN2K 5 15VHS 0:2 3KVHU:HSH9]3HP [H102M492}4M122

UH9]3P6NM5UK:659K}H8‰WNKI50:K8KRH5:MHXMNKT511243vKVK:4M2H3KY09423KVMNKV2XX2J59M2K1MN4M4:21K23

JH5:M1 Z2MN 23SH953M4:P NH102M492}4M2H3 HX 04M2K3M1 Z2MN M5UK:J59H121Š Q3T511 xS4294U9K 4Mk NMM01kffZZZ4VS[4}KM4:5f3HSH1M2fS1/:4}P41329/19H}N3H1M2/SH}3264P51NJN2K/5/15VHS/0:2/3KVHU:HSH93HP/

[H102M492}4M122/UH93P6N/M5UK:659K}H8f4JJK11KVc)

+”K9K3164P4ryO:HM1K11549]3PKH1HUK33H1M20:235V2MK9]3HP[H102M492}4M122UH9]3P6N}4:4}3HPXH:/

8HP M5UK:659K}4 ‰O:HJKV5:49 XK4M5:K1 HX XH:JKV NH102M492}4M2H3 HX 04M2K3M1 Z2MN JH3M4[2H51 M5UK:J59H121Š

Ua ' % ' ,,3H**,00)/))Q3T511

I40K9326HS4 s | t1HUK33H1M2 210H93K32P4 :K1NK32P4 15V4 0H 4V82321M:4M2S3H85 VK95 H 0:235/

V2MK9]3HP[H102M492}4M122‰vK4M5:K1HXMNKKYKJ5M2H3HX4JH5:MVKJ212H3H3434V82321M:4M2SKJ41KH3JH8059/

1H:P NH102M492}4M2H3Š $^ ' ' ' ‰R5::K3M

0:HU9K81HXJ2S2943V4V82321M:4M2SK0:HJKKV23[1ŠQ3T511xS4294U9K4MkNMM01kffJH3X12U95:5fH1HUK33H1M2/

210H93K32P4/:K1NK32P4/15V4/0H/4V82321M:4M2S3H85/VK95/H/0:235V2MK93HP/[H102M492}4J224JJK11KV+c

)“5946HS4 | 5 t 3K6HMH:P6N 0:HU9K846N 0:4SHSH[H :K[592:HS432P4 0:H2}SHV1MS4 0H VK948 H

[H102M492}4M122 [:4}NV43234 S 8KV2M123165P5 0:HM2SHM5UK:659K}35P5 H:[432}4M12P5 S 3KVHU:HSH9]3H8 0H:P/

4V6K ‰xUH5M 1H8K 0:HU9K81 HX 9K[49 :K[594M2H3 HX 0:HJKKV23[1 H3 4V82112H3 HX 4 J2M2}K3 23 8KV2J49 43M2/

M5UK:J59H121 H:[432}4M2H3 23 23SH953M4:PŠ 8433K:Š BC # `8 $8 , *c, 3H,00*/.Q3T511

cIM4:29HS5Gs2165112P4HU4V82321M:4M2S3H815VH0:H2}SHV1MSK2“HVK61K4V82321M:4M2S3H[H15/

VH0:H2}SHV1MS4 TH112P16HP vKVK:4M122k [HV /P ‰s21J5112H3 4UH5M 4V82321M:4M2SK 0:HJKKV23[1 43V MNK

RHVK HX 4V82321M:4M2SK L5V2J249 0:HJKV5:K HX MNK T511243 vKVK:4M2H3k Š M $

',,3H,00 /Q3T511

&Q'7R)*+,'S)2('71

--_7)U+&)(4*61,1*.0/,1,23-4,56*7481;>36.8

1;>36.4*931/:.3;/,,,,-.;/,,+;-71*/-.<*,=/*<*

F3/)-4;+;+;-71*/-.<366;+;6*>,;6*?P6;+;,--?31;<*.3?P-4;+;76,<3/-,.3.*

DVA;W<:CAD<8AX::Y><X:YA;

"--X;<[CD<(L M8D 8

$ D " N BC8

! #

j$ "" < ? )c <% " .

""% ..

WNK 4:M2J9K Z41 15U82MMKV )c 400:HSKV 4XMK: :KS2KZ23[ . 4JJK0MKV XH: 05U92J4M2H3..