CC BY
31
UDK 547.917:547.458.1;579.222 https://doi.org/10.15407/biotech9.04.028
LIGNOCELLULOSIC BIOMASS AFTER EXPLOSIVE AUTOHYDROLYSIS AS SUBSTRATE FOR BUTANOL OBTAINING
O. O. Tigunova1 N. E. Beiko1 D. S. Kamenskyh2 T. V. Tkachenko2 V. O. Yevdokymenko2 V. I. Kashkovskiy2 S. M. Shulga1
1 SO "Institute of Food Biotechnology and Genomics" of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Kiyv
2Institute of Bioorganic Chemistry and Petrochemistry of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Kiyv
E-mail: [email protected]
Received 24.04.2016
The aim of the investigation of the effect of the explosive autohydrolysis on lignocellulosic biomass (saving, switchgrass biomass) for consequent use as a substrate to produce biofuels such as butanol. Butanol-producing strains, switchgrass Panicum virgatum L. biomass and its components after autohydrolysis were used in the study. The thermobaric pressure pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass was carried out using specially designed equipment. The effect of explosive autohydrolysis on lignocellulosic biomass for further use in producing biofuels using microbial conversion was studied. Components of lignocellulosic biomass were fractionated after undergoing thermobaric treatment. The possibility of using different raw material components after using explosive autohydrolysis processing to produce biobutanol was found. Products of switchgrass biomass autohydrolysis were shown to need further before fermentation purification from furfural formed by thermobaric pretreatment and inhibiting the growth of microorganisms. The ability of strains of the genus Clostridium to use cellulose as a substrate for fermentation was proved. It was found that using explosive autohydrolysis pretreatment to savings allowed to boost the butanol accumulation by 2 times.
Key words: explosive autohydrolysis, butanol, lignocellulosic biomass, biofuels.
Lignocellulose is one of the virtually unlimited sources by the number of substrates for microbial conversion. A lot of lignocellulosic waste is produced in forestry and agriculture, pulp and paper and wood industries, which poses a serious environmental problem, the increasing pollution. Unfortunately, most of the waste is not recycled although it can be used, for example as biofuels. An effective biological conversion requires pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass [1]. One of the methods of its complex pretreatment is explosive autohydrolysis. This method provides almost total destruction of the biomass and allows to separate components of lignocellulosic material [2]. Later lignocellulosic biomass components can serve as a substrate for microbial conversion, including microorganisms of
the genus Clostridium, and as a source for obtaining biofuels such as butanol [3].
The aim of the study was to explore the effect of explosive autohydrolysis on lignocellulosic biomass (saving, switchgrass biomass) for consequent use as a substrate to produce biofuels such as butanol.
Materials and Methods
For the study we used butanol producing strains Clostridium acetobutylicum 1MB B-7407 (IFBG C6H), Clostridium sp. 1MB B-7570 (IFBG C6H 5M) from "Collection microorganism's stains and plants line for food and agriculture biotechnology" of the Institute of Food Biotechnology and Genomics of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine; biomass of switchgrass Panicum
virgatum L., and components of switchgrass after autohydrolysis (cellulose, lignin and arabinogalactan); savings of Obukhiv pulp and paper mill.
Moisture mass fraction in initial samples and in products of reaction was determined according to [4], crude ash mass fraction according to [5], lignin's by [6], soluble carbohydrates' by [7], resins' and fats' by [8]. Mass fraction of cellulose was conducted by nitrogen-alcoholic method [9].
Thermobaric preprocessing of lignocellulosic materials was performed by [2] on specially constructed equipment at a temperature of 200 °C for 10 min. Mush-like mixture was received and directly used as substrate or fractionated (Fig. 1).
The process of fractionation can be described by following stages. Mixture of products (620 g) after autohydrolysis was transferred to a Buchner funnel and filtered out liquid fraction (310 g). Air-dry residue was placed in a conical flask of volume 500 ml, and hot water was added (300 ml), liquor ration 50 (solid phase to liquid ratio). Extraction of soluble carbohydrates was done for three hours on water bath at 100 °C, then the second filtration in a Buchner funnel. The resulting solid residue was dried. To prevent the destruction of soluble sugars, the filtrate was steamed at water bath at 50 ± 5 °C, with simultaneous extraction of furfural with water. Arabinogalactan was precipitated by ethanol with liquor
ration 5. The residue was filtrated, washed with ethanol and dried. The ethanol was removed from the filtrate solution on rotary evaporator (Rotadest, Hungary). The result was a concentrated solution of soluble sugars.
The presence of furfural after explosive autohydrolysis (almost non-waste technology to separate plant material into three main components: lignin, cellulose and hemicellulose by applying high temperature (100-200 °C) water vapor to wooden complex; reaction time is 1-10 min) was determined by gas chromatography. We used gas chromatograph Agilent-7890A (USA) with flame ionization detector; silica intermediate polar capillary column HP-5 (length 30 m, inner diameter 0.320 mm, film thickness 0.25 pm); carrier gas: helium (300 mL/min); programmed temperature from 40 °C to 280 °C in increments of 5 °C / min; temperature of evaporator 250 ± 5 °C; temperature of detector 280 ± 5 °C. The volume of the sample was 1.0 pl.
Results of the analysis were processed using the method of absolute calibration by chromatographic peak areas.
The savings and switchgrass biomass were dried at 30 ± 1 °C for 168 hours. The dried biomass was ground using mill Cyclone MSh 1 (Ukraine) to particles sized 200 mesh. The moisture was determined by moisture analyzer RADWAG MA 50/C/1 (Poland).
Fig. 1. Scheme of fractionation of lignocellulosic biomass after explosive autohydrolysis
Winogradsky medium and slices of potatoes smeared with chalk were used as activation medium for butanol producing strains. To ascertain the purity of culture, MAV medium was used [10]. To prepare mash's leavens (out of switchgrass, savings), samples of 50.0 g of the substance were taken per 1 l of water, and sterilized for 2 hr at a pressure of 0.2 MPa. To confirm the properties of cellulolytic strains, solid medium of the following composition was used: (NH4)2SO4 — 0.6 g/dm3; (NH4)2HPO4 — 1.6 g/dm3; agar — 30 g/dm3; рН 6.2. It was sterilized during 30 min at 0.1 MPa. Discs of filter paper (1.0 g), previously sterilized for 30 min at 0.2 MPa, were inserted in medium. On the discs, relevant strains were put in droplets of liquid medium.
Culture of microorganisms at solid medium was performed following [11] in anaerobic culture apparatus AE 01 (RF) under a nitrogen atmosphere. The apparatus was kept in thermostat at 35 ± 1 °С. In five days, the fermentation was stopped and the cells were precipitated using ultracentrifuge Labofuge 400R (Germany), then the supernatant was distilled and fermentation products defined.
Presence of ethanol, acetone and butanol in culture liquid was determined using gas chromatograph "Kristall-5000 lux" (RF) with flame-ionization detector and packed column (3 m in length), phase Carbowax 1500 on chromaton NAW-DMSC (0.20-0.25 mm). The column temperature was 60 ± 2 °C, the evaporator's 160 ± 5 °С, Nitrogen: Hydrogen: air ratio was 1:1:10.
Statistical data analysis was performed using Microsoft Excel program. All experiments were done in triplicate. The difference between the two averages was considered probable by P <0.05 (significant results marked with *).
Results and Discussion
One of the promising renewable raw materials are lignocellulosic materials, including switchgrass Panicum virgatum L. biomass. The possibility of conversion of switchgrass biomass to produce butanol was shown previously [11]. To enhance butanol production by strains IFBG C6H and IFBG C6H 5M, switchgrass was pretreated by explosive autohydrolysis. The components of switchgrasss biomass before and after autohydrolysis are given in Table 1.
As follows from the data, after the explosive autohydrolysis, the content of basic components changed, due to the restructuring of biomass components [12, 13]. The growing portion of water-soluble substances was primarily due to destruction of hemicelluloses [12]. A slightly increased lignin content, according to [13], was due to the lowered pH of the reaction medium. At the same time, during fractionation after autohydrolysis (delignification of cellulose) there was a chemical effect on lignin, which induced its polymerization, and therefore the amount of insoluble in acid lignin decreased. Therefore, for the fermentation of substrate after autohydrolysis it was necessary to use active producers of cellulases. Bacteria of the genus Clostridium can serve as such [1]. Chosen strains IFBG C6H and IFBG C6H 5M were precipitated to filter paper to confirm the possibility of cellulose fermentation (Fig. 2).
After 72 hours of culturing on filter paper, clear areas appeared, and after 120 hours destruction of paper around the colonies was observed. Results of the study demonstrated the presence of cellulases in both cultures and the ability of these strains to use cellulose as a carbon source. To test whether lignocellulose was used as a substrate, culturing of microorganisms on individual components of switchgrass after explosive autohydrolysis was performed (Fig. 3).
As a result of studies it was found that the content of furfural increased in plant biomass after autohydrolysis, inhibiting the bacterial growth. To avoid the inhibitory effect, furfural was removed and biomass components were separated. In this study it was found that cultured strains-producers using the biomass components produced butanol with different levels of accumulation. The highest concentration of butanol (2.8 g/dm3) was in the case of the strain IFBG C6H 5M cultured on switchgrass biomass after autohydrolysis and extraction of furfural. These data suggest that the explosive autohydrolysis is a promising way of preparing lignocellulosic biomass before fermentation.
Another possible substrate are savings, paper industry waste product. To establish the impact of autohydrolysis on savings, its component composition was studied before and after autohydrolysis (Table 2).
The data show that nearly half of savings consists of inorganic components that cannot serve as a culturing medium for microorganisms. As savings are waste of
Table 1. Switchgrass biomass content after autohydrolysis
Components The initial biomass, % Biomass after hydrolysis, %
Cellulose 46.7±0.5 53.9±0.5
Hemicellulose 23.0±1.0 10.6±1.0
Water soluble substances 7.7±0.5 11.5±0.5
Lignin 13.8±0.2 14.7±0.2
Resins and fats 2.0±10 2.0±10
Ash 5.4±0.5 5.4±0.5
Other 1.4±0.2 1.9±0.2
Total 100.0 100.0
5 mm
Fig. 2. Colonies of IFBG C6H 5M (1) and IFBG C6H (2) on filter paper
pulp and paper industry, 75% of organic components consist of cellulose, the amount of which after thermobaric treatment slightly increases similarly to switchgrass (Table 1). But savings are depleted in sugars and soluble substances and are preferably used in processes that need cheap raw material containing cellulose.
To study the ability of microorganisms for bioconversion of savings as a substrate, IFBG C6H and IFBG C6H 5M strains were cultured in an environment with different pretreatment (Fig. 4.)
According to the data, strains IFBG C6H 5M and IFBG C6H converted to butanol even raw savings, but the accumulation of the desired product was low, 0.3 and
0.1 g/dm3 respectively. Grinding of raw materials led to increased production of butanol to 0.6 to 0.8 g/dm3 respectively, but the preferred method of pretreatment of raw materials was autohydrolysis. In the case of savings processed by explosive autohydrolysis, accumulation of butanol in the culture liquid was 1.6 and 1.1 g/dm3. It should be noted that in explosive autohydrolysis, furfural formed in small amounts and did not affect the activity of microorganisms.
The results showed the possibility of using lignocellulosic materials as substrate for the production of biofuels and converting cellulose into butanol by microorganism strains IFBG C6H and IFBG C6H 5M. The
1
2
Fig. 3. Culturing of producer strains on biomass and separate components of lignocellulosic raw materials
Here and later * signifies the significant difference between strains
Table 2. Composition of savings after autohydrolysis
Components The initial biomass, % The composition after hydrolysis, %
Cellulose 34.0±0.5 37.0±0.5
Hemicellulose 3.7±1.0 1.5±1.0
Water soluble substances 3.2±0.5 6.9±0.5
Lignin 8.5±0.2 3.5±0.2
Resins and fats 2.3±10 2.3±10
Ash 47.8±0.5 48.0±0.5
Other 0.5±0.2 0.8±0.2
Total 100.0 100.0
increase in accumulation of butanol is 2 times in the case of explosive autohydrolysis as a method of pretreatment of raw materials. It is established that under autohydrolysis only the hemicellulose is partially destroyed to form a large number of water-soluble substances. After autohydrolysis, cellulose and lignin are separate components which can be compared quantitatively with their content in the original raw material. A direct dependence between formation of furfural in
the products of explosive autohydrolysis on the amount of hemicellulose in the original biomass is observed. This is because under the hydrolyzing agent at elevated temperatures, sugars can hydrolyze to form furfural and oxymethylfurfural. Withdrawal of furfural and oxymethylfurfural from products of explosive autohydrolysis of switchgrass millet made it possible to achieve an increase in the accumulation of butanol in the fermentation process.
О IFBG C6H ■ IFBG C6H 5M
Fig. 4. Strains cultured on medium with differing pretreatment of savings
REFERENCES
1. Shulga S. M., Tigunova O. O., Blume Y. B. Lignocellulose as an alternative source for obtaining of butanol. Biotechnol. acta. 2013, 6 (2), 9-21. (In Ukrainian).
2. Kamenskykh D. S., Tkachenko T. V., Yevdokymenko V. O, Kashkovskyi V. I. Explosive autohydrolysis of pentosan-containing raw material. Catalysis and Petrochemicals. 2015, 24, 90-95. (In Ukrainian).
3. Tigunova O. O., Shulga S. M. Using by mutant strains C. acetobutylicum ligno-cellulosic material as a substrate. Microbiol. and biotechnol. 2015, 3, 35-44.
4. GOST 13496-92. Mixed feeds, mixed fodder raw materials. Methods for determination of moisture. 1.1.93. (In Russian).
5. GOST 26226-95. Feed, mixed feeds, feed raw materials. Methods for the determination of crude ash. 10.12.95. (In Russian).
6. GOST 26177-84. Feed, mixed feeds. Method for the determination of lignin. 12.1.99. (In Russian).
7. GOST 26176-91. Feed, mixed feeds. Methods for determination of readily soluble and carbohydrates. 1.1.93. (In Russian).
8. GOST 6841-77. Cellulose. Method for determination of tar and fats. 01.07.98. (In Russian).
9. Obolenskaia A. V., Elnytskaia Z. P., Leono-vych A. A. Laboratory work on the chemistry of wood and cellulose. Moskwa: Chemistry, 1977, 232 p. (In Russian).
10. Tigunova O. O., Shulga S. M. New producer strains of biobutanol. I. Isolation and identification. Biotechnol. acta. 2013, 6 (1), 97-104. (In Ukrainian).
11. Tigunova O. O., Shulga S. M. New producer strains of biobutanol. III. Methods increased accumulation of butanol from switchgrass Panicum virgatum l. biomass Biotechnol. acta. 2015, 8 (4), 65-68. (In Ukrainian).
12. Trofymova N. N., Babkyn V. A., Chemerys M. M. Kataliziruemyj parovzryvnoj gidroliz celloligninovogo ostatka drevesiny listvennicy. Himija rastitel'nogo syr'ja. 2002, 2, 53-56. (In Russian).
13. Kumar Y. S., Negi J. S. Upadhyaya Studies on characterization of corn cob based nanoparticles. Adv. Mat. Lett. 2010, 1 (3), 246-253.
Л1ГНОЦЕЛЮЛОЗНА СИРОВИНА П1СЛЯ ВИБУХОВОГО АВТОГ1ДРОЛ1ЗУ ЯК СУБСТРАТ ДЛЯ ОТРИМАННЯ БУТАНОЛУ
О. О. ТЬгунова1, Н. G. Бейко1, Д. С. Каменських2, Т. В. Ткаченко2, В. О. бвдокименко2, В. I. Кашковський2, С. М. Шульга1
1ДУ «1нститут харчово! бмтехнологп та геномши НАН Укра!ни», Ки!в 21нститут б^оргашчно! xiMii та нафтохiмil НАН Укра!ни, Ки!в
E-mail: [email protected]
Метою роботи було визначення впливу ви-бухового автогiдролiзу на л^ноцелюлозну си-ровину (скоп, б^маса дротоподiбного проса) з подальшим використанням ll як субстрату для отримання бшпалива — бутанолу. Для дослщжень використовували штами-проду-центи бутанолу, б^масу дротоподiбного проса Panicum virgatum L., компоненти дротоподiб-ного проса шсля автогiдролiзу. Паробаричну попередню обробку л^ноцелюлозно! сиро-вини виконували на спещально створеному обладнаннi. Дослiджено вплив вибухового автогiдролiзу на лiгноцелюлозну сировину з використанням надалi для одержання б^па-лива за допомогою мшроб^лопчно! конвер-сп. Проведено фракцiонування л^ноцелю-лозно! бiомаси на складовi компоненти шсля термобарично! обробки. Показано можли-в^ть застосування отриманих компонентiв пiсля оброблення л^ноцелюлози вибуховим автогiдролiзом як субстрату для мшроб^ло-гiчного синтезу бутанолу. Встановлено, що перед ферментацieю продукмв автогiдролiзу дротоподiбного проса !х необхщно додатково очищати вiд фурфуролу, який утворюеть-ся пiд час термобарично! обробки i е шпбь тором розвитку мiкроорганiзмiв. Шдтвер-джено здатшсть штамiв-продуцентiв роду Clostridium використовувати целюлозу як субстрат у процесi ферментацп. З'ясовано, що в разi використання вибухового автопд-ролiзу для попередньо! обробки скопу нако-пичення бутанолу зб^ьшилось у 2 рази.
Ключовi слова: вибуховий автогiдролiз, бута-нол, л^ноцелюлозна сировина, бiопаливо.
ЛИГНОЦЕЛЛЮЛОЗНОЕ СЫРЬЕ ПОСЛЕ ВЗРЫВНОГО АВТОГИДРОЛИЗА КАК СУБСТРАТ ДЛЯ ПОЛУЧЕНИЯ БУТАНОЛА
Е. А. Тигунова1, Н. Е. Бейко1, Д. С. Каменских2, Т. В. Ткаченко2,
В. А. Евдокименко2, В. И. Кашковский2, С. М. Шульга1
1ГУ «Институт пищевой биотехнологии и геномики НАН Украины», Киев 2Институт биоорганической химии и нефтехимии НАН Украины, Киев
E-mail: [email protected]
Целью работы было определение влияния взрывного автогидролиза на лигноцеллю-лозное сырье (скоп, биомасса стеблевидно-го проса) с дальнейшим использованием его как субстрата для получения биотоплива — бутанола. Для исследований использовали штаммы-продуценты бутанола, биомассу сте-блевидного проса Panicum virgatum L., компоненты стеблевидного проса после автогидролиза. Паробарическую предварительную обработку лигноцеллюлозного сырья проводили на специально созданном оборудовании. Исследовано влияние взрывного автогидролиза на лигноцеллюлозное сырье с дальнейшим использованием для получения биотоплива с помощью микробиологической конверсии. Проведено фракционирование лигноцеллю-лозной биомассы на составляющие компоненты после термобарической обработки. Показана возможность использования полученных компонентов после обработки лигноцеллюло-зы с помощью взрывного автогидролиза как субстрата для микробиологического синтеза бутанола. Установлено, что перед ферментацией продуктов автогидролиза стеблевидно-го проса их необходимо дополнительно очищать от фурфурола, который образуется при термобарической обработке и является ингибитором развития микроорганизмов. Подтверждено свойство штаммов-продуцентов рода Clostridium использовать целлюлозу как субстрат в процессе ферментации. Установлено, что при использовании взрывного автогидролиза для предварительной обработки скопа накопление бутанола увеличилось в 2 раза.
Ключевые слова: взрывной автогидролиз, бутанол, лигноцелюлозное сырье, биотопливо.
