CC BY
38
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT OF HEALTH INDICATORS OF WOODY PLANTS IN NATURAL AND MAN-MADE CONDITIONS
© 2020
Siraeva Irina Salavatovna, postgraduate student of Botany and Ecology Department Saratov State University (Saratov, Russian Federation) Larionov Maxim Viktorovich, doctor of biological sciences, associate professor, professor of Biology and Ecology Department Balashov Institute of Saratov State University (Balashov, Saratov Region, Russian Federation) Larionov Nikolai Viktorovich, candidate of biological sciences, director Secondary School № 2 of Kotelniki (Kotelniki, Moscow Region, Russian Federation) Soldatova Valeria Viktorovna, postgraduate student of Botany and Ecology Department Gromova Tatyana Sergeevna, postgraduate student of Botany and Ecology Department Ermolenko Anna Sergeevna, postgraduate student of Botany and Ecology Department Saratov State University (Saratov, Russian Federation) Kulagina Ekaterina Yurievna, candidate of biological sciences, associate professor of Biology and Ecology Department Vladimir State University (Vladimir, Russian Federation)
Abstract. The indicators of the sanitary condition of woody plants in the conditions of natural and artificial ecosystems of the Voronezh and Saratov Regions were established and analyzed. In suburban ecosystems of the research area, the state of woody plants is determined at the level of weak damage. In suburban areas of Balashov with the greatest economic and technosphere potential, woody plants reach an average (moderate) degree of damage. In remote relatively preserved ecosystems (control parameters), the state of these organisms corresponds to a weak ecological diagnostic criterion. According to the identified average arithmetic sanitary indicators in the Voronezh Region, the best condition is characterized by woody plants in the ecosystems of Novohopersk and Gribanovsky, in the Saratov Region - in Turki and Samoylovka. There were also significant differences in the arithmetic mean parameters of the sanitary condition of this group plants representatives differentiated by functional zones. The highest damage values are typical for woody plants in the urban ecosystems of industrial zones. The maximum danger to woody plants was observed within these zones in Povorino, Borisoglebsk, and Balashov with high-level average values of damage to these organisms. Significant concern is also caused by the defeat of the analyzed group of organisms in these cities as part of the ecosystems of the settlement zones. The results of the assessment of the sanitary condition of woody plants should be used as a scientific basis for landscaping, environmental protection and reforestation. Measures are proposed to improve the condition of woody plants in various types of ecosystems in the research area. According to the sanitary state of these organisms, it is possible to determine the limits of sustainability of ecological frameworks and differentiate the parameters of environmental comfort for the local population in different territorial categories.
Keywords: municipal districts of Voronezh Region; municipal districts of Saratov Region; natural ecosystems; artificial ecosystems; recreation zones; settlement zones; industrial zones; sanitary condition of woody plants; values and levels of plant degradation; territorial differences in plant viability; trends in plant biological stability; environmental quality; values of environmental comfort for residents; relevance of measures for plant protection.
■к -к -к
УДК 595.772
DOI 10.24411/2309-4370-2020-11117
Статья поступила в редакцию 23.01.2020
LEGS MORPHOMETRIC CHARACTERS OF THE DOLICHOPUS LATREILLE SPECIES, 1796 (DIPTERA, DOLICHOPODIDAE)
© 2020
Chursina Mariya Alexandrovna, candidate of biological sciences, senior lecturer of Biology of Plants and Animals Department
Voronezh State Pedagogical University (Voronezh, Russian Federation) Negrobov Oleg Pavlovich, doctor of biological sciences, professor of Ecology and Systematics of Invertebrate Animals Department
Voronezh State University (Voronezh, Russian Federation)
Abstract. A comparative analysis of 30 species of the Dolichopodidae family in a phylogenetic context was conducted to examine interspecific variation in the legs morphometry. Five relative traits of legs from 12 and seven absolute traits from nine showed significant phylogenetic signal. A set of traits, such as relatively short hind tibia and relatively long fore and middle tibia and the first segments of the hind legs allowed to allocate Dolichopus species from the other ones. The projection of the phylogenetic tree of Dolichopus species into the morphospace allowed us to divide it into four individual areas: not closely related species, but species having similar modifications of males' legs tended to cluster. This suggests that the legs morphometric traits should be mainly under pressure of sexual selection. It has also been revealed that the elongation of the first segment of hind tarsi in Dolichopus species is associ-
ated with the distal displacement of the insertion point of dm-m with M4 and the decrease of the length of R4+5. The functional significance of these characters set is discussed.
Keywords: Diptera; Dolichopodidae; Dolichopus; legs morphometry; ornaments; phylogenetic signal; morphometric characters; morphological characters; femora; tibia; tarsi; sexual dimorphism; wing shape; modification of legs; modification of tibia; modification of tarsi; COI gene; phylogeny; phylogenetic tree.
Introduction
Morphometric methods linked with DNA-based molecular genetic analysis represent a powerful new approach for taxonomic issues resolving and evolutionary process study [1, p. 11]. Currently it becomes quite obvious that to reveal evolutionary trends it is necessary to analyze a wide range of traits and evaluate their phylo-genetic signal, because morphological similarity does not necessary mean a common origin, but may be the result of parallel evolution, especially in functional morphostructures, for example, wings or legs which are developed under intense selection pressure.
Ornamented legs are commonplace in the Dolichop-odidae and they, as shown for certain species, can be used in courtship or in male-male interactions. Such traits are widely used for taxonomic identification of the species [2, p. 146] and classification of their functional significance can be found in the literature [3, p. 145]. For instance, male Neurigona quadrifasciata (Fabricius, 1781) demonstrates its plumed fore tarsi to female, approaching from the rear [4, p. 32]. Male Hydrophorus praecox (Lehmann, 1822) uses spines on femora to keep riding a female [5, p. 14] Male Dolichopus plumipes (Scopoli, 1763) uses bilateral feathering first segment of middle tarsi in courtship as follows. Male approaching female and vibrating with his wings slowly raises the middle legs parallel to the abdomen and stretches them horizontally [6, p. 43]. However, for most species legs modifications are not well understood yet.
One less explored area is morphometric characters of legs, although sometimes differences in sizes of legs segments are used for identification species (for example, in the genera Argyra Macquart, 1834, Camp-sicnemus Haliday, 1851, Tachytrechus Haliday, 1851) [2, p. 190]. To investigate differences between species in legs morphometric characters and to indicate evolutionary trends a detailed comparative analyses is required.
Species of the genus Dolichopus Latreille, 1796 represent a suitable model group for morphometric traits variation study for the following reasons: firstly, according to recent studies based on molecular and morphological traits, it is a single evolutionary unit [7, p. 21; 8, p. 310], and, secondly, leg modifications in males of this genus are diverse: there are extensions (for example, Dolichopus claviger Stannius, 1831 and D. migrans Zet-terstedt, 1843), plumage of certain legs segments (Dolichopus remipes Wahlberg, 1839) or their silver colorings (Dolichopus argyrotarsus Wahlberg, 1850), sometimes there are ornamented tibia (Dolichopus lepidus Staeger, 1842), or ornamented tibia combined with a modified tarsi shape (Dolichopusplumipes (Scopoli, 1763)).
Thus, the purpose of this paper is a comparative study of the legs morphometric diversity of Dolichop-odidae species and the estimation of their phylogenetic signal by molecular phylogeny mapping.
Material and methods
This study is based on 1240 specimens from 21 species of the Dolichopus genus. Nine species belonging to Dolichopodinae, Diaphorinae and Sympycninae subfamilies were chosen as outgroup (table 1). Males of eleven species from 21 studied ones had obvious leg modifica-Самарский научный вестник. 2020. Т. 9, № 1 (30)
tions. The material was obtained from the collections of Ecology and Zoology of Invertebrates Department, Voronezh State University.
The legs were separated from the body, placed on a microscope slide under a cover slip and photographed with Levenhuk C310 NG microscope digital camera. To eliminate digitizing error, all wings were digitized two times. Measurement repeatability was very high.
Nine traits were measured using ImageJ software: length of fore, middle and hind femora (F1, F2, F3), length of fore, middle and hind tibia (T1, T2, T3) and length of the first segment of fore, middle and hind tarsi (tarl, tar2, tar3) as well. Then twenty relative characters were calculated: the ratios of fore femora and fore tibia (Fl/Tl), fore femora and first segment of fore tarsi (Fl/tarl), fore femora and middle femora (F1/F2), fore femora and hind femora (Fl/F3), fore tibia and the first segment of fore tarsi (Tl/tarl), fore tibia and middle tibia (Tl/T2), fore tibia and hind tibia (Tl/T3), middle femora and middle tibia (F2/T2), middle femora and the first segment of middle tarsi (F2/tar2), hind femora and hind tibia (F3/T3), hind femora and the first segment of hind tarsi (F3/tar3).
A multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) and post-hoc Tukey's test were performed to examine differences represented among species, sexes, and sides (left and right legs). All statistical analyses were made with the Statistica software [9].
Phylogenetic relationships among the species were derived from an analysis of mitochondrial gene sequences - the cytochrome oxidase subunit I (COI) gene (8l0 characters), previously submitted to GenBank [l0; ll, p 455; l2, p. 605]. Suitability of COI gene for resolving phylogenetic relationships has been repeatedly confirmed for a wide range of insects' taxa [13, p. 2; l4, p. 566].
Sequences from GenBank were aligned using Clus-talW software [l5]. The phylogenetic reconstruction was provided with maximum parsimony analysis in MEGA software [l6]. The significance of the inner branching pattern was estimated by a bootstrap analysis with l000 pseudo-replicates.
As a measure of phylogenetic signal of legs mor-phometric characters, we used Pagel's lambda (X) [l7, p. 680]. A Pagel's lambda value close to 1 indicates the presence of an explicit phylogenetic signal, while a value closer to 0 indicates the absence of a phylogenetic signal of the trait [l8, p. 7l4]. To calculate Pagel's lambda, the picante package [l9] was used in R environment [20]. For testing purpose the indications of differences of the metric from 0, a p-value was obtained by randomizing the trait data 999 times. The P value was calculated as the proportion of cases the value of X for randomized trait data exceeded the real data meanings [2l].
Principle Component Analysis (PCA) was performed on the legs morphometric traits to detect and to describe the differences among taxa. The Pearson correlation coefficient was applied to reveal a set of interdependent characters. For this objective, the dataset of Procrustes Coordinates, describing the wing shape of Dolichopodi-dae species and obtained using geometric morphometrics methods (more detailed described in [22]) was used. The nomenclature of wing venation carried out as per
Grichanov and Brooks [23, p. l288]._
Table 1 - Studied species
№ Species Specimens Males ornamented legs
1 Dolichopus acuticornis Wiedemann, 1817 20 33, 46 22 without modification
2 Dolichopus arbustorum Zetterstedt, 1843 20 33, 20 22 without modification
3 Dolichopus argyrotarsis Wahlberg, 1850 12 33, 2 22 3th-5th segments of middle tarsus silvery-white, slightly enlarged
4 Dolichopus brevipennis Meigen, 1824 18 33, 16 22 5th segments of fore tarsus enlarged
5 Dolichopus campestris Meigen, 1824 22 33, 24 2 2 without modification
6 Dolichopus cilifemoratus Macquart, 1827 30 33, 32 22 segments of fore tarsus curved, covered with erected hairs
7 Dolichopus claviger Stannius, 1831 20 33, 16 2 2 5th segments of fore tarsus enlarged
8 Dolichopus discifer Stannius, 1831 18 33, 14 22 5th segments of fore tarsus enlarged
9 Dolichopus latilimbatus Macquart, 1827 50 33, 46 22 without modification
10 Dolichopus lepidus Staeger, 1842 50 33, 41 22 hind tibia thickened
11 Dolichopus linearis Meigen, 1824 24 33, 20 2 2 without modification
12 Dolichopus longicornis Stannius, 1831 32 33, 52 22 without modification
13 Dolichopus longitarsis Stannius, 1831 50 33, 79 22 hind tibia thickened
14 Dolichopus meigeni Loew, 1857 12 33, 2 22 without modification
15 Dolichopus migrans Zetterstedt, 1843 18 33, 20 2 2 5th segments of fore tarsus enlarged
16 Dolichopus pennatus Meigen, 1824 50 33, 38 22 1st-2nd segments of middle tarsus hardly plumate, 4th-5th segments silvery-white
17 Dolichopusplumipes (Scopoli, 1763) 54 33, 14 2 2 Middle tibia thin and 1st segment of middle tarsi hardly plumate
18 Dolichopus remipes Wahlberg, 1839 6 33, 30 2 2 3rd and 4th segments of hind tarsi plumate
19 Dolichopus ringdahli Stackelberg, 1930 36 33, 14 2 2 without modification
20 Dolichopus simplex Meigen, 1824 40 33, 40 2 2 without modification
21 Dolichopus ungulatus (Linnaeus, 1758) 50 33, 42 22 without modification
Outgroup
22 Poecilobothrus chrysozygos (Wiedemann, 1817) 28 33, 4 2 2 1st-2nd segments of fore tarsus with white rings
23 Poecilobothrus regalis (Meigen, 1824) 24 33, 50 22 without modification
24 Ethiromyia chalybea (Wiedemann, 1817) 10 33, 4 22 without modification
25 Sybistroma binodicornis Stackelberg, 1941 14 33, 46 2 2 without modification
26 Sybistroma crinipes Staeger, 1842 20 33, 20 2 2 without modification
27 Argyra diaphana (Fabricius, 1775) 22 33, 40 2 2 without modification
28 Argyra leucocephala (Meigen, 1824) 11 33, 16 22 without modification
29 Chrysotus cilipes Meigen, 1824 6 33, 54 2 2 without modification
30 Sympycnus pulicarius (Fallen, 1823) 50 33, 110 2 2 without modification
Results
Results of MANOVA indicated legs morphometric traits significant differences among species (table 2), but not between sides. Sexes showed significantly lower differences in legs morphometry in comparisons with species. The most significant effect of «species^sex» interaction suggests that there should be differences in the patterns of sexual dimorphism among species. The The results of post-hoc Tukey's test indicate that the difference between the largest numbers of species are observed in the following relative traits: F1/tar1, T1/tar1, F2/T2. The lowest degree of variation was observed in F1/F2.
Five relative traits from 12 ones showed a high phy-logenetic signal, both males and females (table 3). Length of the first segments of fore and middle tarsi indicates the lowest phylogenetic signal for any studied traits.
Based on PCA results, performed on morphometric data, the position of all species in the morphospace mainly was determined by the two of the first principle components, accounted more than 98% of the total variance. The first principle component (PC1), explaining the most proportion of variance (85,83%), was associated with changes in the length of T3, T2, and T1. The second principal component (PC2), representing 12% of total variation, reflects changes in the length of tar3.
The mapping of the phylogenetic tree into the mor-phospace indicated that along PC1 species tended to di-
vide into two clusters: Dolichopus species (specimens with shortened T3 and elongated T1 and T2), that were clustered together in the area of negative values of PC1, and the outgroup species (specimens with elongated T3 and shortened T1 and T2). The PC2 axis described a variation from a relatively short tar3 to a little long one (from Poecilobothrus regalis to Dolichopus claviger) (fig. 1).
Only one relative trait was found with a statistically significant amount of phylogenetic signal in the leg morphology of Dolichopus species (without outgroup) -T1/T2 (X = 0,755, P = 0,07). In this case, PCA also indicated the fact most legs variation was concentrated in two dimensions. The PC1 and PC2 are calculated for about 84% of total variance. The PC1 explained 65,89% of the total variations and described a variation from Dolichopus claviger (species with elongated tar3 and shorter T1) to Dolichopus plumipes and D. linearis (species with shorted tar3 and elongated T1). The PC2 explained 19% of the total variations and associated with separation among species with shorted T2 length (Doli-chopus longicornis) and with elongated T2 ones (D. plu-mipes) (fig. 2). A permutation test for the hypothesis of phylogenetic signal absence as for the legs morphomet-ric data indicates the probability of finding a shorter tree on level P < 0,0001, which demonstrates the presence of a significant phylogenetic signal in the studied traits.
As for legs morphology, the projection of the phy-logeny into the morphospace of Dolichopus species showed a possibility to identify it for individual areas. The first area, located in the upper right corner, presented males with enlarged or plumage segments of middle legs (Dolichopus plumipes, D. pennatus and D. argyro-tarsis). The second area is located in the morphospace in the zone of negative PC1 values, it is characterized by
the largest spread. It includes the species, the males of which have modified segments of the forelegs (Dolichopus brevipennis, D. discifer, D. claviger and D. cili-femoratus). The third area positioned in the central part of the diagram presented species with modifications of the hind legs (Dolichopus lepidus, D. longitarsis h D. remi-pes). The species with long apicoventral bristle on fore tibia tended to be clustered in the lower right corner.
Table 2 - The results of MANOVA of 12 relative legs morphometric traits for 30 dolichopodid species
Effect Wilk's lambda F Effect df Error df P
Species 0,0001 59,0 336 15653 <0,00001
Sex 0,6866 10,7 12 1439 0,001
Species x sex 0,0598 13,7 324 15257 <0,00001
Side 0,9934 1 12 1410 0,67
Table 3 - Pagel's lambda value and P values, calculated from 999 randomizations, of twenty relative and nine absolute traits of legs morphometry in 27 Dolichopodidae species
Trait Both sexes Female Male
1 P 1 P 1 P
F1/T1* 0,999 0,0004 0,999 0,0540 0,999 0,0010
F1/tar1 0,044 1,0000 0,674 0,5460 0,044 1,0000
F1/F2 0,802 0,4700 0,525 0,2860 0,044 1,0000
F1/F3* 0,736 0,0002 0,667 0,0003 0,740 0,0010
T1/tar1 0,270 0,3900 0,925 0,0970 0,044 1,0000
T1/T2* 0,937 0,0210 0,967 0,0540 0,920 0,0170
T1/T3* 0,772 0,0001 0,789 0,0510 0,705 0,0001
F2/T2 0,044 1,0000 0,044 1,0000 0,330 0,8070
F2/tar2 0,051 1,0000 0,041 1,0000 0,044 1,0000
T2/tar2 0,047 1,0000 0,210 0,7600 0,033 1,0000
F3/T3 0,044 1,0000 0,044 1,0000 0,044 1,0000
F3/tar3 * 0,999 0,0030 0,999 0,0009 0,999 0,0040
F1* 0,999 0,0045 0,999 0,0128 0,999 0,0168
T1* 0,999 0,0020 0,999 0,0041 0,999 0,0135
tar1 0,044 1,0000 0,999 0,2445 0,044 1,0000
F2* 0,999 0,0030 0,999 0,0089 0,999 0,0183
T2* 0,994 0,0070 0,999 0,0086 0,982 0,0454
tar2 0,651 0,3130 0,635 0,2426 0,192 0,7386
F3* 0,999 0,0250 0,999 0,1041 0,999 0,0806
T3* 0,999 0,0414 0,999 0,0619 0,999 0,1041
tar3* 0,999 0,0003 0,999 0,0601 0,999 0,0017
Note. X - Pagel's lambda, P - P-value. Asterisks (*) mark traits showed statistically significant phylogenetic signal.
0.00 0.03
PCI (85.83%)
Figure 1 - Mapping of the legs morphometric trait variation of 30 Dolichopodidae species on the phylogenetic tree
Figure 2 - Displacement of 18 Dolichopus species in the morphospace of the first two principal components of legs morphometric variation. For each species, modified segments of the legs of males are marked: tarl - modification of fore tarsi, tar2 - modification of middle tarsi, T3 - modification of hind tibia, tar3 - modification of hind tarsi; +av - a long apicoventral bristle on males' fore tibia
Spearman rank correlation coefficient (between legs morphometric traits and Procrustes coordinated of nine landmarks among 27 Dolichopodidae species) indicates a strong link between the length of tar3 with the displacement of the insertion point of dm-m with M4 (rs = -0,59, P < 0,05) and lengths of tar3 and R4+5 (rs = -0,65, P < 0,05). Spearman rank correlation coefficient also demonstrates a moderate relationship level between the length of T1 and the presence of the long apicoventral bristle (rs = 0,58, P < 0,05).
Discussion
The recent studies of morphologic characters of insects are focused on the wing shape as follow: discrimination of cryptic species [24-26], evaluation of developmental instability [27; 28], identification of both geographical and ecological variation [29-31] and evolutionary transitions [32]; so there are not many kinds of research on legs morphometry field.
As an example, a comparative analysis of morpho-metric characters of two dipteral species indicates that change patterns in the body shape associated with sexual dimorphism had a similar character for two non-closely related species (Prochyliza xanthostoma and Telostylinus angusticollis). The elongation of antennae and legs was associated with a decrease of head width and wing length, but the functional significance of these relationships remains uncertain [33, p. 609]. Moreover, based on the study of Titmus and Badcock [34, p. 535], the anterior segment of the tarsi became shorter in individuals Benthalia carbonaria (Meigen, 1804) (Chironomidae) infected by parasitic nematodes of the Mermitid family.
We have already tried to find a diagnostic significance of legs morphometric characters [35]; however, the present study is the first of the kind with a comparand
tive analysis of variations in legs morphometric traits with the phyletic relationships between species. Our data indicate that several legs morphometric traits tend to have high phylogenetic signal.
A set of traits, such as relatively short hind tibia and relatively long fore and middle tibia and the first segments of the hind legs, allowed to allocate Dolichopus species from the outgroup ones. A clear sign of Doli-chopus species is consistent with the molecular data indicating the genus as a monophyletic group as well as an independent evolutionary unit [8, p. 310].
It has also been revealed that the elongation of the first segment of hind tarsi in Dolichopus species is associated with the distal displacement of the insertion point of dm-m with M4 and the decrease of the length of R4+5. The functional hypothesis forwarded to explain the relationship of these traits should be ground on further researches of the wing shape variability in the family.
The position of the insertion point of dm-m with M4 indicates the most variance among dolichopodid species. This fact may prove the importance of its position for certain flight characteristics of the wing to be created. Furthermore, there are no significant differences in the position of the R4+5 apex among the representatives of the family [22, p. 697]. In addition, it is obvious that the increase of the length of the first segment of hind tarsi in Dolichopus species is combined with the presence of one or more strong dorsal setae on it. The last character is no more found inside the family Dolichopodidae, except for some species, for example, Poecilobothrus regalis (Meigen, 1824).
As for field observations, dolichoidid flies use hind tarsi to clean the wings' membranes. The shortening of hind tibia (in combination with the elongation of the first segment of hind tarsi and the appearance of strong dorsal Самарский научный вестник. 2020. Т. 9, № 1 (30)
bristles on it) may be some adaptation for more efficient wing cleaning and for improved flight characteristics as well.
The elongation of fore tibia in some species of Dolichopus (D. latilimbatus, D. linearis, D. longicornis) correlated with the presence of a long apicoventral bristle. This fact was demonstrated by the Spearman's rank correlation coefficient and greater proximity of these species in the morphospace. However, it is difficult to say about the functional purpose of this combination of traits at this stage; further research on the behavioral traits associated with this bristle of dolichopodid flies is needed for it.
A significant interspecific variation in legs mor-phometry of Dolichopus species was demonstrated with the PCA and indicate a variation of the lengths of the first segment of hind legs and the middle and hind tibia. Dolichopus claviger and D. plumipes keep extreme positions in morphospace. The males of these species are characterized by obvious leg modifications: the thin middle tibia and the densely feathered first segment of the middle tarsi of Dolichopus plumipes and an enlarged black fifth segment of fore tarsi of Dolichopus claviger. Species with the males without obvious modifications of the legs have an isolated location in the morphospace.
Having considered the distribution of species, we conclude that the similarity of legs morphology in studied Dolichopus species is not always the result of common origin. Dolichopus longicornis and D. acuticornis is the only example in our study - closely related species were close to each other in the morphospace. In other cases, the distribution of species leads to the conclusion for morphometric similarity caused by a similar pressure of selection. This is confirmed by the selection on the plot of clusters with not closely related species, but with species having similar modifications of males' legs. Whereas, clusters allocated on the basis of molecular data are both monomorphic and dimorphic species (for instance, Dolichopus plumipes and D. simplex, D. brevi-pennis and D. ungulatus).
The most parsimonic phylogenetic tree indicates that the monomorphism is a plesiomorphic state for the family, as well as the presence of several parallel episodes of the occurrence of similar leg modifications (for example, the appearance of the enlarged fifth segment of fore tarsi in Dolichopus claviger and D. discifer). The total morphometry of the legs seems to be depended on the modifications of the males' legs as it was documented that some Dolichopus male species used modified legs to attract females and compete for their attention with other males [6, p. 43], it should be concluded that the legs morphometric traits are mainly under pressure of sexual selection.
References:
1. Васильев А.Г., Васильева А.И., Шкурихин А.О. Геометрическая морфометрия: от теории к практике. М.: Товарищество научных изданий КМК, 2018. 471 с.
2. Негробов О.П., Штакельберг А.А. Dolichopodidae // Определитель насекомых европейской части СССР. Двукрылые, блохи. Л.: Изд-во «Наука». 1969. Т. 5, Ч. 1. С. 670-752.
3. Sivinski J. Ornaments in the Diptera // Florida Entomologist. 1997. Vol. 80, № 2. P. 142-164._
4. Smith K.G.V. A note on the court ship and preda-ceous behavior of Neurigonia species (Dipt., Dolichopodidae) // Entomologist's Monthly Magazine. 1959. Vol. 95. P. 32-33.
5. Вихрев Н. Зачем мухе шип // Троицкий вариант - Наука. 2018. № 9 (253), 08 мая 2018 года. С. 14.
6. Stubbs A. Courtships of Dolichopus plumipes (Scop.) Dolichopodidae) // Diptetists Digest. 1988. Vol. 1. P. 43.
7. Brooks S.E. Systematics and phylogeny of Doli-chopodinae (Diptera: Dolichopodidae) // Zootaxa. 2005. Vol. 857. P. 1-158.
8. Germann C., Pollet M., Wimmer C., Bernasco-ni M.V. Molecular data sheds light on the classification of long-leg flies (Diptera: Dolichopodidae) // Invertebrate Systematics. 2011. Vol. 25. P. 303-321.
9. StatSoft Inc. STATISTICA - data analysis software system. Ver. 12. 2012 [Internet] // http://documentation. statsoft.com.
10. GenBank. National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI). 2016 [Internet] // https://ncbi.nlm. nih.gov.
11. Bernasconi M.V., Pollet M., Varini-Ooijen M., Ward P.I. Molecular systematic of Dolichopodidae (Diptera) inferred from COI and 12S rDNA gene sequences based on European exemplars // Invertebrate Systemat-ics. 2007. Vol. 21. P. 453-470.
12. Bernasconi M.V., Pollet M., Varini-Ooijen M., Ward P.I. Phylogeny of European Dolichopus and Gym-nopternus (Diptera: Dolichopodidae) and the significance of morphological characters inferred from molecular data // European Journal of Entomology. 2007. Vol. 104. P. 601-607.
13. Caterino M.S., Cho S., Sperling F.A.H. The current state of insect molecular systematics: a thriving Tower of Babel // Annual Review of Entomology. 2000. Vol. 45. P. 1-54.
14. Smith-Caldas M.R., Mcpheron B.A., Silva J.G., Zucchi R. Phylogenetic relationships among species of the fraterculus group (Anastrepha: Diptera: Tephritidae) inferred from DNA sequences of mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase I // Neotropical Entomologica. 2001. Vol. 30, № 4. P. 565-573.
15. Thompson J.D., Higgins D.G., Gibson T.J. CLUSTAL W: improving the sensitivity of progressive multiple sequence alignment through sequence weighting, position-specific gap penaltiesand weight matrix choice // Nucleic Acids Research. 1994. Vol. 22. P. 4673-4680.
16. Kumar S., Stecher G., Li M., Knyaz C., Tamu-ra K. MEGA X: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis across computing platforms // Molecular Biology and Evolution. 2018. Vol. 35. P. 1547-1549.
17. Pagel M. Inferring the historical patterns of biological evolution // Nature. 1999. Vol. 401. P. 677-884.
18. Freckleton R.P., Harvey P.H., Pagel M. Phyloge-netic analysis and comparative data: a test and review of evidence // American Naturalist. 2002. Vol. 60, № 6. P. 712-726.
19. Kembel S.W., Cowan P.D., Helmus M.R., Morlon H., Ackerly D.D., Blomberg S.P., Webb C O. Picante: R tool for integrating phylogenies and ecology // Bio-informatic. 2010. Vol. 26. P. 1463-1464.
20. R Development Core Team. 2016. R: a language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation
for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria [Internet] // https://R-project.org.
21. Kamilar J.M., Cooper N. Phylogenetic signal in primate behaviour, ecology and life history // Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B. 2013. Vol. 368, N 1618. P 20120341. DOI: 10.1098/rstb.2012.0341.
22. Chursina M.A., Negrobov O.P. Phylogenetic signal of the wing shape in the subfamily Dolichopodinae (Diptera, Dolichopodidae) // Zoological Journal. 2018. Vol. 97, № 6. P. 688-700.
23. Grichanov I.Ya., Brooks S.E. Dolichopodidae (Long-legged flies) // Manual of Afrotropical Diptera. Vol. 2. Nematocerous Diptera and lower Brachycera. Su-ricata 5. Pretoria: South African National Biodiversity Institute. 2017. P. 1265-1320.
24. Yee W.L., Chapman P.S., Sheets H.D., Unruh T.R. Analysis of body measurements and wing shape to discriminate Rhagoletis pomonella and Rhagoletis zephyria (Diptera: Tephritidae) in Washington State // Annals of the Entomological Society of America. 2009. Vol. 102, № 6. P. 1013-1028.
25. Schutze M.K., Jessup A., Clarke A.R. Wing shape as a potential discriminator of morphologically similar pest taxa within the Bactocera dorsalis species complex (Diptera: Tephritidae) // Bulletin of Entomological Research. 2012. Vol. 102. P. 103-111.
26. Nedeljkovic Z., Acanski J., Mihajla D., Obreht-Vidakovic D., Ricarte A., Vujic A. An integrated approach to delimiting species borders in the genus Chrys-otoxum Meigen, 1803 (Diptera: Syrphidae), with description of two new species // Contributions to Zoology. 2015. Vol. 84, № 4. P. 285-304.
27. Klingenberg C.P., McIntyre G.S. Geometric mor-phometrics of developmental instability: analyzing patterns of fluctuating asymmetry with Procrustes methods // Evolution. 1998. Vol. 52, № 5. P. 1363-1375.
Общая биология
28. Hosken D.J., Blanckenhorn W.U., Ward P.I. Developmental stability in yellow ding flies (Scathophaga stercoraria): fluctuating asymmetry, heterozygosity and environmental stress // Journal of Evolutionary Biology. 2000. Vol. 13. P. 919-926.
29. Hoffmann A.A., Shirriffs J. Geographic variation for wing shape in Drosophila melanogaster // Evolution. 2002. Vol. 56, № 6. P. 1068-1073.
30. Griffiths J.A., Schiffer M., Hoffmann A.A. Clinal variation and laboratory adaptation in the rainforest species Drosophila birchii for stress resistance, wing shape and development time // Journal of Evolutionary Biology. 2004. Vol. 18. P. 213-222.
31. Henry A., Thongsripong P., Fonseca-Gonzalez I., Jaramillo-Ocampo N., Dujardin J.-P. Wing shape of dengue vectors from around the world // Infection, Genetics and Evolution. 2010. Vol. 10. P. 207-214.
32. Pepinelli M., Spironello M., Currie D.C. Geometric morphometrics as a tool for interpreting evolutionary transitions in the black fly wing (Diptera: Simuliidae) // Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society. 2013. Vol. 169. P. 377-388.
33. Bonduriansky B. Convergent evolution of sexual shape dimorphism in Diptera // Journal of Morphology. 2006. Vol. 267. P. 602-611.
34. Titmus G., Badcock R.M. A morphometric study of the effects of a mermithid parasite on its host, the Chi-ronomid midge Einfeldia dissidens (Walker) (Diptera) // Zeitschrift für Parasitenkunde. 1981. Vol. 65. P. 353357.
35. Negrobov O.P., Chursina M.A. Signs of the genus level in the legs morphology of Dolichopodidae (Diptera) // International Journal of Dipterological Research. 2013. Vol 24, № 2. P. 59-64.
Статья публикуется при поддержке гранта РФФИ и NSFC в соответствии с исследовательским проектом № 20-54-53005.
МОРФОМЕТРИЧЕСКИЕ ПРИЗНАКИ НОГ ВИДОВ РОДА DOLICHOPUS LATREILLE, 1796 (DIPTERA, DOLICHOPODIDAE)
© 2020
Чурсина Мария Александровна, кандидат биологических наук, старший преподаватель кафедры биологии растений и животных
Воронежский государственный педагогический университет (г. Воронеж, Российская Федерация) Негробов Олег Павлович, доктор биологических наук, профессор кафедры экологии и систематики беспозвоночных животных
Воронежский государственный университет (г. Воронеж, Российская Федерация)
Аннотация. Для оценки межвидовой изменчивости морфометрических признаков ног был проведён сравнительный анализ 30 видов из семейства Dolichopodidae с учётом их филогении. Пять из двенадцати относительных признаков ног и семь из девяти абсолютных продемонстрировали статистически значимый филогенетический сигнал. Был выделен комплекс признаков, который позволяет отделить виды Dolichopus от видов внешней группы: это относительно короткие задние голени и относительно длинные передние и средние голени, а также удлинённый первый членик задней лапки. Проекция филогенетического дерева видов Doli-chopus на морфопространство позволила разделить его на четыре области: были кластеризованы не близкородственные виды, а виды, имеющие сходные модификации ног самцов. Это говорит о том, что морфомет-рические признаки ног в основном находятся под давлением полового отбора. Также было выявлено, что удлинение первого сегмента задних лапок у видов Dolichopus связано с дистальным смещением точки слияния dm-m с M4 и уменьшением длины R4+5. Обсуждается функциональное значение этого сочетания признаков.
Ключевые слова: Diptera; Dolichopodidae; Dolichopus; морфометрия ног; украшения; филогенетический сигнал; морфометрические признаки; морфологические признаки; бёдра; голени; лапки; половой диморфизм; форма крыла; модификации ног; модификации голеней; модификации лапок; COI ген; филогения; филогенетическое дерево.
