CC BY
10ECOLOGICAL MEANS OF FORMING ARCHITECTURAL ENVIRONMENT FOR MULTI-STOREY PARKING GARAGE IN LARGE CITIES
S. Kysil
Ukrainian Zonal Scientific and Research and Design Institute of Civil Engineering (PJSC «KyivZNIlEP»), Kyiv, Ukrane
Abstract
This paper examines the ecological aspects of forming of architectural environment for multistorey parking garages in large cities using landscape and ecological means. We describe modern methods of applying biotic and abiotic natural elements of urban design in forming architectural environment of multi-storey parking garages. Also we give recommendations for using these techniques. These aspects are not resolved in today's modern architecture practice.
Keywords: multi-storey parking garage, landscape and ecological resources, landscape planning, architectural environment, large city
ЛАНДШАФТНО-ЭКОЛОГИЧЕСКИЕ СРЕДСТВА ФОРМИРОВАНИЯ АРХИТЕКТУРНОЙ СРЕДЫ МНОГОЭТАЖНЫХ АВТОСТОЯНОК В КРУПНЕЙШИХ ГОРОДАХ
С.С. Кисиль
Украинский зональный научно-исследовательский проектный институт по гражданскому строительству, ПАО «КиевЗНИИЭП», Киев, Украина
Аннотация
В статье рассматриваются экологический и эстетический аспекты формирования архитектурной среды многоэтажных автостоянок в крупнейших городах с помощью ландшафтно-экологических средств. Описаны современные приемы использования форм живой и неживой природы, элементы городского дизайна в формировании архитектурной среды многоэтажных автостоянок.
Ключевые слова: многоэтажная автостоянка, ландшафтно-экологические средства, архитектурная среда, крупнейший город
Importance of ecological and aesthetic factors in regards to forming architectural environment for multi-storey parking garages was explored in works of two Russian authors. E. Golubeva [1] approached this problem in relation to structure of the entire city and M. Fakki [2] approached it in relation to high-rise apartment complexes.
External appearance of multi-storey parking garages has particular influence on the surrounding architectural environment. In this case, improvement of ecological sustainability happens by reducing negative impact of personal transport on the surrounding area [3].
The problem of storing personal vehicles clearly cannot be solved with technical and space -planning means alone. Ecological component is just as important, which points to multifaceted nature of interaction between a man and his surroundings. Not enough attention at the present stage of design is paid to art, esthetic, environmental and psychological problems of organization of the architectural environment of multi-storey parking garages. Ecological problems of organizing architectural environment for multi-storey parking garages currently don't receive as much attention as they deserve [4].
The purpose of this paper is to reveal importance of ecological and aesthetic aspects of forming architectural environment for multi-storey parking garages in large cities using landscape, ecological and visual means.
Problem statement
Multi-storey parking garages are closely connected with our living environment. They are placed close to residential and recreational areas, workplaces etc. Therefore architectural environment of multi-storey parking garages that are located in residential and public spaces must be paid just as much attention as for buildings with other functionalities. This is because all multi-storey parking garages have impact on forming opinion about an area, estate or public zone where they are located.
Ecological and aesthetic factors are very significant in forming architectural environment around multi-storey parking garages. Ecological approach is focused on realizing aesthetic potential of the territory by correlation of artificial and natural components in the urban environment. This reduces adverse impact on the architectural environment around multi-storey parking garages.
Landscape and ecological methods are focused on improving aesthetic potential of an area by combining artificial and natural urban environment components. This helps to reduce negative effects of building upkeep on the surrounding architectural environment.
Following methods can be used: placing plants on the exterior, interior, façades, roofs of multistorey parking garages, creating a sanitary green belt around multi-storey parking garages.
Also, ecological means of multi-storey parking garages architectural environment forming are: noise reduction (placing multi-storey parking garages on edges of residential areas protects residents from traffic noises) and creating sanitary protection green areas around multi-storey parking garages.
Landscape planning means of multi-storey parking garages architectural environment forming are: placing plants, site landscaping, terrain profiling, plant sculptures, roof gardens, vertical facade gardens, combination of linear and volumetric forms of plants, marking multi-storey parking garages boundaries with plant containers, terraced slopes with plants, artificial hills, coverage with grass areas and multi-storey parking garages combined with roads and located on steep terrain [5,6].
Therefore ecological approaches can be categorised as landscape methods of forming architectural environment around multi-storey parking garage (Fig. 1).
For architectural environment of ground multi-storey parking garages following methods are used: placing plants, site landscaping, combination of linear and volumetric forms of plants, terrain profiling of territory (creating terraced slopes with static plants) (Fig. 2B). And for ground multi-storey parking garage buildings following methods are used: vertical facade gardens; roof gardens (Fig. 2A).
For architectural environment of semi-underground multi-storey parking garages (Fig. 2C) following methods are used: placing elements of pavements with grass areas and marking borders of multi-storey parking garage territory with potted plants. And for semi-underground
building of multi-storey parking garage same methods as for the ground building of multi-storey parking garage are used (Fig. 2A).
1 ECOLOGICAL APPROACHES ► LANSCAPE METHODS FORMING 1
METHODS FUNCTIONS
GENERAL SCHEME AESTHETIC NATURAL NOISE REDUCTION LANDMARK
PLACING PLANTS ß-m Ä m • •
SITE LANDSCAPING m
Wfihrmr. J k ■j TT
TERRAIN PROFILING i iîjfcv m - , * • •
PLANT SCULPTURES <5 •
ROOF GARDENS J L,, m • •
1 O I «f 1 1 ® L
VERTICAL FACADE GARDENS c c c C E 1 • • •
CREATING TERRACED SLOPES WITH VEGETATION FIXED kfay m •
Fig. 1. Ecological approaches categorised as landscape methods of forming architectural environment around multi-storey parking garages (Grey circles show types of functions)
Usually plants are the main focus of creating architectural environment around multi-storey parking garages, because it offers following benefits:
- aesthetics function;
- natural function - it improves external ecology and internal ecology. Chemical composition of air in the area is improved.
- noise reduction.
Planting methods for multi-storey parking garages are: ground greenery, green roofs and vertical green walls (Fig. 3).
Ground greenery. External ground greenery is the most effective strategy of protecting against heat build-up and control ambient temperatures on macro level. External landscaping on ground level can be done using trees, palms, shrubs and turfing. Landscaping plans of multi-storey parking garages sometimes include waterbodies such as fountains to add «blue architecture» to overall «green» effect of the development.
Landscape elements (trees, shrubs, lawns, flower beds, ponds) combine elements with different functions located near multi-storey parking garages. Figure 4 shows an example of trees planted in line in front of a Santa Monica Place Mall multi-storey parking garage. Adding a green
buffer makes a monotonous building facade more expressive. This method can be used to demarcate buildings that vary in functionality, including areas around multi-storey parking garages. Trees in a transport space composition are a factor of ecological stabilization [7].
Fig. 2. Ecological approaches in forming architecture of multi-storey parking garages in large cities
PLACING PLANTS METHODS OF FORMING MULTI-STOREY PARKING GARAGES
__ ——
GROUND GREENERY GREEN ROOFS VERTICAL GREEN WALLS
IHllfe *4A4A rff i 4 h t M -M & - M
Fig. 3. Landscape and ecological means of forming architectural environment around multistorey parking garages
Vertical green walls. Vertical facade gardens are important for forming architectural environment of multi-storey parking garages.
As multi-storey parking garages grow higher, facade area also increases. Placing plants on external walls not only reduces heat transmission inside, especially if installed on east and west faсades but also protects the facade from weathering and express creativity. Planning for vertical green walls requires early consideration of maintenance, structural safety, irrigation and long-term durability of the backing wall [8].
Open grid paving tile that allow plants should be considered for ground multi-storey parking garages. This allows grass to grow over as well as surface rainwater runoff to infiltrate into the ground. Both reduce heat build-up in the hard surface.
a)
b)
Fig. 4 (a,b). A green buffer along the facade of an MCP. Multi-storey parking garage at Santa Monica Place Mall. «Brooks + Scarpa», Santa Monica, USA, 2011: a) façade 1 - 2, typical floor plan; b) general view
Architectural structure of a typical multi-storey parking garage is a suitable support for vining plants. This method not only serves for an aesthetic purpose, but also for natural and noise reduction purposes. A good example is Blackrock Hospital Garage in Dublin (Fig. 5) and Shinjuku Gardens in Tokyo (Fig. 6).
Vegetation helps reduce solar heat gain and improve the microclimate within any interior or exterior space. The incorporation of plants into multi-storey parking garages is a popular feature in bio-climatic design. Plants can mitigate the effect of urban heat islands, and may also reduce the energy demand of multi-storey parking garages. A new trend in urban greenery is the creation of urban farms - using green areas in buildings to grow crops and vegetables. Semi-outdoor spaces with vertical green screens can also provide shading from the sun and contribute to the garden ambience. Also, transpiration by plants extracts heat from the surrounding air and lowers the surrounding air temperature.
This not only helps to divide road surface into zones with different functions but also reintroduce elements of nature. Adding plants inside of buildings used for temporary or permanent personal vehicle storage may create a connection between nature and the building. A good example is 18 Kowloon East (Fig. 7). Division of facade elements contrasts well with scenic beauty of plants.
Green roofs. The greatest benefit of green roofs of multi-storey parking garages is that it provides thermal insulation to interior spaces below and also becomes a habitable space for people and animals, thereby promoting biodiversity. This also helps to slow down stormwater runoff and improve its quality. Creating a roof garden requires careful planning since roof space is traditionally also a highly sought-after location to for different services such as water tanks, cooling towers, plant rooms, etc [9].
Green roofs offer environmental and ecological benefits. In addition, green roofs also increase the thermal resistance of the roofs thereby reducing heat flux through the roof and into the spaces below. Roof top gardens have been measured to reduce surface temperatures of roof by more than 10°C.
Fig. 5. Blackrock Hospital multi-storey parking garage, Rock Rd, Blackrock, Co Dublin, 2005 - 2008
Traditional turfing on concrete flooring is enhanced by placing high plants and flower beds in multi-storey parking garages. It's not going against technical roof operations. By creating offsetting nature landscape elements for architectural multi-storey parking garage, we reproduce the lost balance between natural and artificial components of the environment.
An example of geoplastics usage and relief profiling in architectural environment of multi-storey parking garage is Pomona college parking (Fig. 1.8), which is placed on the roof of a stadium, and the whole area near is demarcated with decorative coating combined with plants.
The idea of enhancement of composite space culminating points visual impact using plants, including changes in the geometry of relief, plastic and color modeling of plants, construction of water devices and surfaces, leads to possibility of management of space in multi-storey parking garages [10].
Landscape and environmental resources can include natural elements into the interior, making multi-storey parking garages more ecological. Landscape and ecological resources are binding elements of spatial management in architectural environment of multi-storey parking garages and urban structure as a whole. They are a guarantor of environmental wellbeing [11].
Environment sustainability increasing and its aesthetic improvement in projects of multi-storey parking garages using landscape and ecological resources happens due to reduction and minimization of negative impact of transport on the inner circle of human habitat.
a) b)
Fig. 6 (a,b). «Shinjuku Gardens», open multi-storey parking garage, Christoph Vogl, Tokyo, 2010: а) interior, green roofs, general view; b) façade 1 - 10, section 1-1, typical floor plan
In addition, environment wellbeing elements can change microclimate, protect multi-storey parking garages from noise, dust and gases that vehicles produce.
Conclusions. Global experience of multi-storey parking garages building and usage provides a set of methods, including landscape-ecological ones, for forming architectural environment of the parking garages from convenience point of view.
Forming of multi-storey parking garages architectural environment must correspond to modern aesthetical and ecological requirements and help to extend views of a modern man about comfortable habitat.
Multi-storey parking garages must be orientated on special approaches to landscape, ecological and visual methods of expression. Greening is the most important one.
a) b) c)
Fig. 7(a-c). 18 Kowloon East multi-storey parking garage, Aedas, Kowloon Bay, Hong Kong, 2010: a) main facade; b) general view; c) detail
Fig. 8. Pomona College multi-storey car park, 2008, USA. General view
References
1. Golubeva, E. A. Gumanizacija arhitekturnoj sredy parkingov v strukture goroda: na primere Yekaterinburga (avtoref. kand. dis.) [Humanization of the architectural environment of multistorey parking garages in city structure: the example of Yekaterinburg (Cand. Dis. Thesis)]. Yekaterinburg, 2007, 20 p.
2. Fakki, M. F. Gumanizacija arhitekturnoj sredy parkingov v structure vusotnuh giluh kompleksov [Humanization of the architectural environment of parking areas in the structure of high-rise multistory residential center]. Available at: www.marhi.ru/AMIT/2010/1kvart10/fakki/abstract.php.
3. Nefedov, V. A. Landshaftnyj dizajn i ustojchivost' sredy (Rekomendaciipo vneshnemu blagoustrojstvu i ozeleneniju gorodov, vkljuchaja malye formy arhitektury) [Landscaping and
environmental sustainability (Recommendations for external landscaping cities, including small architectural forms)]. Moscow, 1988, 50 p.
4. Koljasnikov V. A. Jekologicheskij podhod k formirovaniju kompozicii goroda [Ecological approach to the formation of the composition of the city: a tutorial]. Yekaterinburg, 1993, 230 p.
5. Shimko V. T. Arhitekturno-dizajnerskoe proektirovanie gorodskoj sredy [Architectural Design of the urban environment]. Moscow, 2006, 384 p.
6. Kurbatov Ju. I. Arhitekturnye formy iprirodnyjlandshaft: kompozicionnye osi [Architectural forms and natural landscape: compositional axis]. Leningrad, 1988, 134 p.
7. Desjatov V. G. Tipologija v arhitekture landshafta. Monografija [The typology in the architecture of the landscape. The monograph]. Ekaterinburg, 2006, 76 p.
8. Davydovich B. V. Vertikal'noe ozelenenie [Vertical gardening]. Kiev, 1971, 102 p.
9. Zabelina E. V. Poisk novyh form v landshaftnoj arhitekture (uchebnoe posobie) [In search of new forms of landscape architecture (a tutorial)]. Moscow, 2005, 160 p.
10. Zitte K. Hudozhestvennye osnovy gradostroitel'stva [Art Foundations of Urban Development]. Moscow, 1993, 256 p.
11. Henley S. The Architecture of Parking. - United Kingdom: Thames & Hudson, 2009. - 286 p.
Литература
1. Голубева, Е. А. Гуманизация архитектурной среды паркингов в структуре города: на примере г. Екатеринбурга : автореф. дис. ... канд. арх.: 18.00.01 / Е. А. Голубева. -Екатеринбург, 2007. - 20 с.
2. Факки, М. Ф. Методы формирования архитектурной среды паркинга // Международный электронный научно-образовательный журнал "АМ1Т" [Электронный ресурс]. - Режим доступа: http://marhi.ru/AMIT/2010/1 ^гИ0/fakki/abstract1.php
3. Нефедов, В.А. Ландшафтный дизайн и устойчивость среды (Рекомендации по внешнему благоустройству и озеленению городов, включая малые формы архитектуры). - М., 1988. - 50 с.
4. Колясников, В. А. Экологический подход к формированию композиции города. -Екатеринбург, 1993. - 230 с.
5. Шимко, В.Т. Архитектурно-дизайнерское проектирование городской среды. - М., 2006.
- 384 с.
6. Курбатов, Ю. И. Архитектурные формы и природный ландшафт: композиционные оси.
- Ленинград, 1988. - 134 с.
7. Десятов, В. Г. Типология в архитектуре ландшафта. Монография. - Екатеринбург, 2006. - 76 с.
8. Давидович, Л.Н. Проектирование предприятий автомобильного транспорта: Л. Н. Давидович. - М. : Транспорт, 1975. - 392 с.
9. Забелина, Е. В. Поиск новых форм в ландшафтной архитектуре: учебное пособие. -М., 1993. - 256 с.
10. Зитте К. Художественные основы градостроительства. - М., 1993. - 256 с.
11. Henley, S. The Architecture of Parking. - United Kingdom: Thames & Hudson, 2009. -286 s.
DATA ABOUT THE AUTHOR Kysil Svetlana
The Associate Scientist; Postgraduate Student of Ukrainian Zonal Scientific and Research Design Institute of Civil Engineering, PJSC «KyivZNIIEP», Kyiv, Ukraine e-mail: svit lana [email protected]
ДАННЫЕ ОБ АВТОРЕ Кисиль Светлана Сергеевна
Младший научный сотрудник, аспирантка ПАО «Украинский зональный научно-исследовательский и проектный институт по гражданскому строительству, ПАТ «КиевЗНИИЭП», Киев, Украина e-mail: svit lana [email protected]
