CC BY
66
DOI https://doi.org/10.18551/rjoas.2017-02.26
GROWING POPULARITY OF MAIZE CULTIVATION IN RANGPUR DISTRICT OF BANGLADESH: AN EVIDENCE FROM GANGACHARA UPAZILA
Moumita Roy, Lecturer BBA Professional Program, Habibullah Bahar College, Dhaka, Bangladesh E-mail: [email protected]
Md. Touhidul Alam, Lecturer Dhaka School of Economics, University of Dhaka, Dhaka, Bangladesh E-mail: [email protected]
Md. Sajib Hossain, Senior Assistant Secretary Research and Development Cell, Bangladesh Knitwear Manufacturers and Exporters Association, Dhaka, Bangladesh E-mail: [email protected]
ABSTRACT
Maize cultivation has been gaining popularly in the rangpur district of Bangladesh in recent years. The study is mainly an attempt to explore the reasons for the growing popularity of maize cultivation in the Gangachara upazila (Sub-district) of Rangpur district. It also examines the future viability of maize cultivation in this area. For data collection, three-stage cluster sampling method has been used to determine the setting of the study selecting 110 farmers who have been involving themselves in maize cultivation for at least ten years, by replacing traditional crops like tobacco and boro rice. Benefit-cost (ratio) analysis is carried out in the study for its purpose and it is found that the cultivation of maize is more profitable than that of boro rice and tobacco. Furthermore, water table data analysis in the study also reveals that the ground water level is depleting in the study area in rabi season and causing groundwater scarcity. Therefore, it would be viable to cultivate maize in the near future at the backdrop of the scarcity of the ground water as maize is less water-intensive crop than other traditional crops grown in this region.
KEY WORDS
Maize, crop diversification, cost- benefit ratio, water table, groundwater.
The replacement of traditional crops with the new profitable one is no longer a new phenomenon in the agricultural sector of Bangladesh. In this process, farmers tend to switch to a new profitable crop from their traditional crops and maize is such one of these switched crops, which is pivotal of this study. The cultivation of maize is gaining popularity among the farmers in the Rangpur district of Bangladesh. Both the area of cultivation and production of maize are increasing gradually because of its huge market demand for poultry, fish feed industry, bakery as well as other human consumer products. Maize provides food, feed, and fuel in rural areas of Bangladesh (OXFAM, 2013) and hence is creating its own demand.
According to Karim (1992), "Calorie yield per hectare of maize is one of the highest and cost per 1000 Calories from maize is one of the lowest among the crops".
Moniruzzaman et al .(2009) calculate the Benefit-cost ratios of maize cultivation in the major maize growing areas, namely Chuadanga, Dinajpur, Bogra, and Lalmonirat districts of Bangladesh during 2006-2007 to know the profitability level of maize production and finally, the study finds that maize cultivation is more profitable than other existing crops. Moreover, some recent studies conducted by (Ali et al., 2009; Hasan, 2008; Karim et al., 2010 and Mohiuddin et al, 2007) show that the cultivation of maize is increasing, being more profitable than other crops such as boro rice, wheat and so on. But, so far, there is probably, no quantitative study behind the growing maize cultivation in Rangpur District, particularly at
Gangachara upazila. For this reason, the study tries to fill the said gap. The main objective of the study is to explore the reasons for the growing popularity of maize cultivation in this area.
Overview of boro, tobacco, and maize production in Rangpur district. Boro rice is the most important and single largest crop in Bangladesh with respect to the volume of production and is transplanted in the winter season (December to February). Boro rice contributes to more than 55% to the total rice production during 2008-09 and its yield depends on a considerable part of irrigation and fertilizer management practices (Basak, 2011).
(a) Area under tobacco production
1500000 1000000
500000 0
■Area
1111111111111111111111111
MH^-NO
ooctctcto
miOCTrM OOO^H
ooctctctctooo*h ctctctctctoooo
(b) Tobacco production
35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0
• Production
■ 1111111111111111111111111
00
m CT fO
CT CT CT
id 00
CT CT CT ct
o ^r ct ct
00 (N
ct o
o
HD
0
00 22
(c) Area under boro production
(d) Boro production
1400000 1200000 1000000 800000 600000 400000 200000 0
Area
00*-I^I^OrOlOCT(N ooctctctoooo*h r^óróiÓCTiNuSoó ooctctctctooo ctctctctct
2000000 1500000 1000000 500000 0
826048
00 CT en o o o U^ CT no r^ 00 CT CT CT o o CT CT CT CT o o 111122
Production
(e) Area under maize production
(f) Maize production
120000 1
Area
i^omiOCTrMmoo ooctctctctooo UDCTINLnOOTH^r^ ooooctctctooo ctctctctctooo 11111222
400000 300000 200000 100000 0
M 111111111
m CT fO
00 CT CT CT
604
00 CT CT CT CT CT
9
ub ó 01 00 222
82 CT o
Production
Source: Various issues of Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics of Bangladesh, 1990-2012.
Figure 1 - Area (in Acre) and Production (in MT) of tobacco, boro rice, and maize
respectively in Rangpur district
Tobacco is a non-food crop and its cultivation requires a huge amount of fertilizers, pesticides, seeds, irrigation water and labor. Tobacco cultivation has been being introduced into the cropland of Testa-silt in Rangpur district since the mid-sixties of the past century and has been pushed by a multinational company named British American Tobacco and some local companies after the liberation of Bangladesh (Sarkar and Haque, 2001).
In contrast to boro rice and tobacco, maize is a food grain, which is a year-round crop. In Bangladesh, maize is cultivated mostly in rabi1 and kharif-12 season. The production of maize doesn't require an extensive amount of water as is required for boro rice and tobacco production. But, quality of maize production, rather, requires the best quality of seeds and an appropriate amount of fertilizers at the right time.
To get an insight into the production scenario of boro rice, tobacco, and maize in the Rangpur district, secondary data for FY 1987-88 to 2011-12 are collected from the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) and analyzed. It is found that both the cultivated area and production for boro rice are in overall increasing trend over the time period [Figure-1 (c & d)]. As boro rice is a staple food of our country and so production and area are quite large in comparison to other crops. High-yield varieties seeds, availability of fertilizers, underground irrigation system, pesticides as well as new machinery have brought revolutionary change in boro production.
Despite Rangpur district is a drought- prone area, irrigation water supply from Barind Multipurpose Development Authority (BMDA) and application of deep tube well to bore water have made it possible to produce a huge amount of boro rice. At the same time, a production boom in maize has also been observed since the start of the new century [Figure 1e,f]. From 2000 to till now, both production and cultivation areas of maize have shown an overall increasing trend. On the other hand, areas under tobacco production have found to be increased over the period but its production has remained almost the same over the same period [Figure 1a,b] due to, perhaps, loss of soil fertility.
Similarly, for Gangachara upazila, it is found that the cultivation area of maize production stood at 3,200 acres, with an increase of 6% in FY2010-11, which was 3000 acres in 2009-10 while the production increased to 6,400 MT from 6,000 MT, 6% more than in the previous fiscal year. In the case of tobacco, the area of cultivation arrived at 13300 acres from 13250 acres with an increase in only around 0.4% increase while production reached to 7692MT with an increase in only around 1% from FY 2009-10 to FY 2010-11. And for boro rice, the production increased to 47800 MT with an increase of around 10% and the cultivation land is increased by only about 2% in FY 2010-09, compared to the previous fiscal year. It indicates that the cultivation of maize is gaining ground in this area (Based on Rangpur district Statistics, 2011).
MATERIALS AND METHODS OF RESEARCH
Selection of study area, sampling design, and data collection. Gangachara upazila of Rangpur district is selected as the study area, which is reputed for its tobacco cultivation for long. The upazila consists of 10 union parishads3, 92 mouzas4, and 128 villages. The total cultivable land in the study area is 38598 acres. Apart from maize, rice, tobacco, potato, and other vegetables are the main crops of the area. However, it is known that many farmers in that area have replaced their important traditional crops (i.e. tobacco, boro rice) with maize.
Keeping this view in mind, to examine the reasons for the increasing popularity of maize cultivation, the study is mainly carried out based on primary data with a sample size of 110 maize farmers. For selecting the farmers, three-stage random sampling is used in it. In its first stage, from among 10 (ten) union parisads (UPs), 2(two) UPs are selected randomly. From the selected UPs, in the second stage, 3 villages are randomly selected. And from those selected villages, a sampling list of 200 farmers, who have been cultivating maize by replacing boro rice and tobacco for at least ten years, is formed. Finally, from the sampling list, a total of 110 farmers are selected randomly for face to face interview from 15 to 25 November 2015 through a pre-designed semi-structured interview schedule.
In the study, the total production cost of maize per 25 decimal of land (locally known as
1 Winter/dry season, typically spanned along mid-October through mid-March.
2 Summer or wet or rainy season, conventionally spread over the period of mid-April to mid-October.
3 Union Parishad is the smallest administrative rural geographic unit comprising of mauzas and villages and having union parishad institution.
4 Mauza is the lowest administrative unit having a separate jurisdiction list number (J.L. number.) in revenue records.
don, which is a unit of measurement of land) and selling price of produced maize from that 25 decimal are collected from the 110 sampled farmers for the year 2005, 2010 and 2015. And finally, the arithmetic mean value of total production cost of maize and their selling price is taken. On the other hand, two FGDs are conducted separately to find out the average total cost of boro rice and tobacco production for 25 decimal of land and their selling prices from that 25 decimal are collected for the year 2005, 2010 and 2015. Each FGD has contained 15 farmers who involved in boro rice and tobacco cultivation for long. Furthermore, secondary data are collected from different research reports; journal articles and the published books to achieve the study objectives.
Analytical Framework. For the study, the general form of the benefit-cost ratio is used. In determining the cost, the total production cost is considered while net return is as the benefit. The cost of labor (own and hired), fertilizer, land preparation, irrigation, pesticide, land rent, and threshing per acre5 of land are considered in calculating total production costs. To do the benefit-cost ratio analysis, the following formulas are considered:
Total cost = Cost of Labor + Cost of Fertilizer + Cost of Land Preparation + Cost of Irrigation + Cost of Pesticide + Cost of Land Rent + Cost of Threshing
Total Revenue = Selling Price * Production Total Benefit = Total Revenue - Total Cost Benefit-Cost Ratio = Total Benefit
Total Cost
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Descriptive Analysis:
Cropping pattern in the study Area. From the interview, it is observed that farmers are very careful in the selection of their round crops so that they can be able to get the maximum benefit. In the study area, two types of crop pattern are found and they are Potato-Maize-Aman and Maize-Aus6-Aman7. Potato-Maize-Aman crop pattern is found to be the most popular among the farmers as it is reported by about 82% of the respondents, because Potato-Maize-Aman crop pattern is economically beneficial which, requires less land, less organic fertilizer and plow as well. Maize-Aus-Aman crop pattern is followed by the rest of the 18% [Figure 2a].
Tobacco is found to be the major replaced crop by maize which is reported by 76% respondents. On the other hand, 26 respondents (24%) report that they have replaced Boro rice with Maize [see Figure 2b].
(a): Year-round crop pattern in the study area (in percentage)
(b): Main replaced crops by maize in the study area (in percentage)
18
76 24
Potato-Maize-Aman
Mize-Aus-Aman
Tobacco
Boro rice
Source: Field Survey, 2015.
Figure 2 - Year-round crop pattern and main replaced crops in the study area
To get per acre of production cost, collected production cost for 25 decimal is multiply by 4.
6 Aus, a type of rice grown in summer months.
7Aman, a type of winter rice.
Production cost of maize, boro rice, and tobacco. The production cost of maize is quite lower (if we consider own labor cost) than that of boro rice and tobacco. Maize requires less water as well as fertilizers. The data reveals that for 25 decimal of land, the total cost of maize cultivation is about Tk.5, 000-6,000 And the majority of the cost goes to fertilizer, which is about 30% of the total cost. On the other hand, physical labor; land rent, threshing, land preparation, seed, irrigation, and pesticide account for 24%, 19%, 7%, 6%, 6%, 4%, and 4% of the total cost respectively (Figure 3).
Land preparation, 6 Thresing, 7
Source: Field Survey, 2015.
Figure 3 - Production cost of maize (in percentage) in 2015
The production cost of boro rice is quite higher than maize. Most of the costs are alike maize, except for labor and irrigation. According to the interview data, it is found that per acre production cost of boro rice is around Tk.40, 000 and the lion's share of the cost go to labor, which accounts for 29% of the total cost. The cost of fertilizer, irrigation, and manure is about 16%, 15%, and 10% respectively. While Seedbed, seed, and pesticide account for 3% each of total cost. Finally, other costs which include: threshing, packaging, etc. responsible for 15% of the total cost.
Seedbed, 3
Source: Field Survey,2015.
Figure 4 - Production cost of boro rice (in percentage ) in 2015
Tobacco is a luxury product and production cost of it is quite high. It is extensively produced in Rangpur district and is responsible for supplying one-third of the total production in Bangladesh. It needs more care as well as labor. In a nutshell, tobacco is a labor-intensive crop. So, a major portion of the cost goes into labor, which accounts for 36% of total production cost. Fertilizer is the second highest and that accounts for 18%. Other costs include threshing, drying, packaging, storing etc. which account for 12 percent. Land rent is
the fourth highest cost 10%. The cost of manure and land preparation is only 7% and 5% respectively. The cost for seedbed, seed, pesticide and irrigation all account for around 3% each of the total cost of production (Figure 5).
Others, 12 Seedbed, 3
Source: Field Survey, 2015.
Figure 5 - Production cost of tobacco (in percentage) in 2015
Farmers' perception towards maize cultivation. From the field survey, it is found that about 16.36% of the respondents chose maize cultivation because they think maize requires a smaller amount of investment. Whereas about 25% of the respondents who once used to grow boro rice or tobacco on their farms, but now cultivate maize, has replied that maize is less water intensive. The statement that production of maize is quite stable is supported by 6.36% of respondents. Again, 25.45% of the respondents have agreed with this view that maize is a cash crop and quick return is possible in case of maize production. 60% of the respondents think that maize has gained popularity for its enormous market demand. In fact, this increasing market demand motivates the farmers to switch from their traditional crops to maize cultivation. On the other hand, about 11% of the farmers have agreed that the production cost of maize is low. About 31% of the respondents agree that there is an adequate level of maize production. Maize is less labor intensive, about 38% of respondents are agreed with this statement. But, around 85% of the respondents have considered the satisfactory profit level as the reason for maize cultivation (Figure 6).
Satisfactory profit level Less labor intensive Adequate Production Lower Production cost Enormous market demand Quick Return Production quite stable Less water intensive Need a smaller amount of investmnet
Source: Field Survey, 2015.
Figure 6 - Perception towards maize cultivation (in percentage) (multiple answers allowed)
Scenario of groundwater depletion in the study area. Farmers in Bangladesh are now experiencing groundwater depletion problem due to the extensive extraction of it. The northwestern part of Bangladesh also faces groundwater depletion problem because of its
84.55
24.55
16.36
drought-prone nature or being free from seasonal flooding due to water withdrawal from major rivers by upstream countries (Rahman et.al, 2012). Like other areas of the northern region, due to the unavailability of surface water, agricultural production at Gangachara upazila is totally dependent on the groundwater based irrigation system and groundwater is depleting gradually in robi season due to more extraction than its regenerating capacity. Boro rice, tobacco, maize, potato, mustard, spice, wheat, other vegetables are some major crops in the rabi season. And it is noted that cropping in rabi season is totally dependent on groundwater irrigation because it is a very dry season and rainwater is rarely found in this season. Furthermore, most of the farmers do not have an own irrigation system and have to depend on the rented irrigation supply by paying Tk.100 for 25 decimals of land for an hour as the irrigation cost. It is also known that there is no electricity connection in those villages of the study area and irrigation is totally fuel-based. So, the increase in the price of fuel is making the irrigation to be costly and ultimately hampers the boro rice cultivation. However, the study has, therefore, tried to show the scenario of ground water level on the basis of respondents' perception about it and water table data collected from the Bangladesh water development board.
Understanding the groundwater depletion from the farmer's perception. In the answer to the question whether the ground water level is depleting or not, most of the respondents (about 73%) say that the ground water level is depleting. And the remaining 27% respondents do not agree to or do not know whether the ground water level is depleting [Figure 7a].
(a) Groundwater level is depleting (in percentage)
(b) Pumps become disabled within a short interval (in percentage)
I Yes No
Yes No
(c ) Pipes has to bore in deep (in percentage)
(d) Pumps become unable to lift sufficient water in the dry season (in percentage)
Yes No
Yes No
Source: Field Survey, 2015.
Figure 7 - Understanding the groundwater level depletion from respondent's perception
In the case of pumps become disabled within a short interval as an indicator for depletion of ground water level, 40% of the respondents say yes and make excessive water extraction as responsible for this type of disability. But, 60% of the respondents don't show their concern [Figure 7b].
Furthermore, 78% of the respondents say that in every year pipe of the pump is to set deeper because the pump is not able to lift sufficient water. To bore pipe in deep is one of
the signs that is ground water is continuously depleting. But, 22% of the respondents do not make any comment about it. On the other hand, 54% of the respondents say that in the dry season, the pump becomes unable to lift sufficient water and water contains sand and other materials. On the other hand, 46% of respondent do not agree with this matter [Figure 7c,d].
Water table analysis. Trend line forecasting of water table data reveals that in 2030, the ground water level will be about 4-meter depth from the surface in rabi season and that indicates severe water crisis for this season in the near future. In figure-8, the red line is the water table trend line (actual) and the black line is the possible scenario of the water level in 2030.
(Nm^u^i^l^coc^OTHtNfO^L^^l^coc^OiHtNm^u^^l^coc^OiHtNm
cococococococococnc^c^cnc^cncncnc^c^oooooooooorHrH*-)*-)
a >
.2
s s
m ®
5 E
■C c
c ïi
3
o UJ
Actual line
Forecasted line
Source: Authors' compilation based on data from Bangladesh water development board (BWDB), 2015.
Figure 8 - Water table scenario for rabi season at the study area
But, like rabi season, the ground water level is not depleting in kharif-1 season (Figure 9). This stability of water table can be attributed to the rain of the rainy season and regeneration thereby (mid April-mid October). In this season, farmers tend to cultivate water intensive aus rice. Kharif-2 season's data are also available but has been discarded from the analysis because it is found that aman rice is the main adopted crop for this season and almost every farmer commonly cultivate aman rice in this season.
-f.LOi.Or'^cO^OiH
cqcococOCO0?^^
<u a
■M -M
re a
5 E
T3 c
c ~
3
o
UJ
Source: Authors' compilation based on data from Bangladesh water development board (BWDB), 2015.
Figure 9 - Water table scenario for kharif-1 season at study area
Results of Benefit -Cost Analysis (Acre-based). In the study, the calculation of the B-C ratio is done for maize, boro rice, and tobacco cultivation respectively. From the analysis of the data, it is found that if the production cost of maize is Tk9 1(one) then it brings Tk. 1.40 from the market i.e. it creates a profit of Tk. 0.40 (forty paisa8) for the investment of Tk. 1(one) for the year 2015. Accordingly, maize brought a profit of Tk. 0.37 (thirty-seven paisa) and Tk. 0.29 (twenty-nine paisa) for the year 2005 and 2010 respectively (Table 1). So, it can be concluded that the profit of maize production is increasing gradually over the years.
' Paisa is a monetary unit of Bangladesh; 1 paisa equal to one hundredth of 1 (one) Tk.
0
In the case of boro rice production, for the investment of Tk. 1 (one), the incurred loss is Tk. 0.32 (thirty-two paisa) for the year 2015. On the other hand, for the investment of Tk. 1 (one), the incurred loss was Tk. 0.30 (thirty paisa) and Tk. 0.12 (twelve paisa) for the year 2010 and 2005 respectively (Table 2).
Table 1 - Results of benefit-cost ratio of maize cultivation
Particulars 2015 2010 2005
Production 61 maund9 53 maund 46 maund
Selling Pricea 615 525 475
Total Returna 37,515 27,825 21,850
Total production cost a 26,777 20,265 17,000
Net returna 10,738 7,560 4,850
B-C ratio 1.40 1.37 1.29
Source: Field Survey, 2015.
aSelling Price, aTotal and Net Return and aTotal production cost reported in Tk.
Table 2 - Results of benefit-cost ratio of boro rice cultivation
Particulars 2015 2010 2005
Production 50 maund 44 maund 42 maund
Selling Pricea 550 470 450
Total Returna 27,500 20,680 18,900
Total production costa 40,438 29,500 21,500
Net returna 12,938 (-) 8820 (-) 2600 (-)
B-C ratio 0.68 0.70 0.88
Source: Field Survey, 2015.
aSelling Price, aTotal and Net Return and aTotal production cost reported in Tk.
Table 3 - Result of benefit-cost ratio of tobacco cultivation
Particulars 2015 2010 2005
Production 18 maund 17 maund 14 maund
Selling Pricea 2,330 1790 1,445
Total Returna 41,940 30,430 20,230
Total production costa 55,935 42,833 39,500
Net returna 13995 (-) 12403 (-) 19270(-)
B-C ratio 0.75 0.71 0.51
Source: Field Survey, 2015.
aSelling Price, aTotal and Net Return and aTotal production cost reported in Tk.
For tobacco production, the incurred loss is Tk. 0.25 (twenty-five paise) for the investment of Tk. 1 (one) in 2015. Similarly, the incurred loss was Tk. 0.29 (twenty-nine paisa) and Tk. 0.49 (forty-nine paisa) for the year 2010 and 2005 respectively for the same amount of investment (Table 3).
CONCLUSION
Maize has a huge potential market demand for its diversified uses and it can make a contribution to the overall socioeconomic development of its cultivation area. The study finds that the cultivation of maize is profitable whereas, other important traditional crops like boro and tobacco are incurring a loss in the study area. So, rational farmers in the study area prefer maize cultivation to other traditional crops due to its profitability.
The northern region of Bangladesh is totally dependent on the groundwater based irrigation system, but the soil of this region is gradually losing its soil moisture and the ground water level is alarmingly depleting. At the same time, surface water availability in this region is also found inadequate. Therefore, in this backdrop, less water intensive crop like maize is,
9 Maund is widely used in rural Bangladesh and India. 1 Maund equals to approx.37.32 kg.
possibly the best solution to reduce the pressure on the ground water in this region in general and the study area in particular.
The study, lastly, calls for encouraging maize production on a large-scale by ensuring maize growers' access to quality inputs at reasonable rates and remunerative prices for their products in the market.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Authors of this article would like to express their sincere gratitude to Palli Karma Sahayak Foundation (PKSF), Bangladesh for its funding that covered almost all the expenses for the field interview. All the authors are also indebted to Dr. Qazi Kholiquzzaman Ahmad, the Director of Dhaka School of Economics, who established Environmental Economics as a discipline in Bangladesh. Besides, authors are also grateful to Dr. A.K.M. Nazrul Islam, the Coordinator of Environmental Economics discipline, Dhaka School of Economics for providing us with this recent interesting topic.
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS
All the authors have written the paper but Moumita Roy and Md. Touhidul Alam were actively involved in designing the study design, data collection and in analyzing the results. Both, Md. Touhidul Alam and Md. Sajib Hossain have interpreted analyzed results.
REFERENCES
1. Ali, M.Y. et al. (2008). Maize-rice cropping systems in Bangladesh: Status and research needs. Journal of Agric Sci and Techn. 3(6), 35-53.
2. Basak J. K. (2011). Fertilizer Requirement for Boro Rice Production in Bangladesh. Unnayan Onneshan, Dhaka.
3. BBS (2013), Rangpur District Statistics, 2011. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistical Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People's Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka.
4. Hasan M. F (2008). Economic efficiency and constraints of maize production in the northern region of Bangladesh, j. innov.dev.strategy. 2(1), 18-32.
5. Karim, M. R., Moniruzzaman, M., & Alam, Q. M. (2010). Economics of hybrid maize production in some selected areas of Bangladesh. Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Research, 35(1), 83-93.
6. Karim, R. (1992). Studies on Maize in Bangladesh. International Food Policy Research Institute, BFPP, Dhaka, The Scientific World Journal.8.
7. Mohiuddin, M., Karim, M. R., Rashid, M. H., & Huda, M. S. (2007). Efficiency and sustainability of maize cultivation in an area of Bangladesh. International Journal of Sustainable Crop Production, 2(3), 44-52.
8. Moniruzzaman, M., Rahman, M. S., Karim, M. K., & Alam, Q. M. (2009). Agro-economic analysis of maize production in Bangladesh: a farm level study. Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Research, 34(1), 15-24. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3329/bjar.v34i1.5748
9. Oxfam International (2013). Report on Maize Value Chain in Northern Char area in Bangladesh. Dhaka, Bangladesh. Retrieved from http://www.mdfbd.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/Maize.pdf
10. Rahman, M. M., & Mahbub, A. Q. M. (2012). Groundwater depletion with the expansion of irrigation in Barind Tract: a case study of Tanore Upazila. Journal of Water Resource and Protection, 4(08), 567.
11. Sarkar and Haque, Tobacco Agricultural Research in Bangladesh in the 20th Century, Bangladesh Agricultural Research Council, Dhaka.
12. Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics of Bangladesh, Rangpur District. Various issues (19902012). Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistical Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People's Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka.
