CC BY
10УДК 796/617 ББК Ч74
FEATURES OF MEDICAL REHABILITATION OF PATIENTS WITH FRACTURES OF TIBIA OLDER THAN 55 YEARS
V. A. Schurov, L. V. Melnikova
Ilizarov Research Center for Rehabilitating Traumatology and Orthopedics, Kurgan, Russia
The goal is the analysis of the dynamics of micromotion of bone fragments and duration of treatment by Ilizarov patients older than 55 years with fractures of the Shin bones (220 people) in the conditions of outpatient treatment.
Method. Definition of micromotion of bone fragments was performed with a strain gauge assessment of changes in the distance between the spokes of the Ilizarov emerging from the tibia above and below the area of bone regenerate during the tests with stepwise increasing the axial load on the limb 10 kgs. The linear velocity of blood flow through the vessels in the area of bone regenerate along the anterior-abdominal surface of the tibia was determined by using an ultrasonic Doppler installation. Radiographs after treatment planimetrically determined the amount periosteal blood of callus.
Results. At transition of patients with injuries of a Shin on an outpatient mode of treatment practically in 2 times micro mobility of bone fragments and duration of the period of fixing increased. Indicators significantly increased in patients with increasing age to 30-55 years, and then tended to decrease. Compaction of bone regenerate during the fixation period contributed to the reduction of micro-mobility and normalization of blood flow rate in the regeneration zone. The reason for the reduction of treatment in older people we see in a more gentle motor mode.
Keywords: Ilizarov apparatus, the rigidity of fixation of bone fragments, fracture of leg bones, parietalna reaction.
The most important distinctive features of the treatment of patients with bone fractures by Ilizarov is the possibility of accurate reposition and reliable fixation of bone fragments, which allows to create optimal conditions for the implementation of reparative bone regeneration and for the restoration of locomotor activity of patients with functional loading of the injured limb.
In vivo study of the axial deformation of the regenerate to an accuracy of 1 ^m is possible by the mutual convergence of the Ilizarov apparatus spokes emerging from the bone fragments under functional loading of the limb [1]. The use of circular fixation by Ilizarov in surgical treatment of limbs in comparison with fixation by rod monolateral devices that do not have the necessary rigidity of fixation of fragments is accompanied by a much smaller number of clinical errors and complications (regenerate deformation, dislocation in the joints) (5-8 % compared to 25-33 %) [2; 3].
The aim of this work was the comparative analysis of the influence of the rigidity of fixation of bone fragments at different stages of the compression osteosynthesis for the duration of the treatment period in patients older than 55 years.
Material and methods
The study included 64 patients aged 20 to 84 years (42±1.7 years) with closed Shin bone fractures treated
on an outpatient basis after 2 weeks of hospital stay.
In all patients, a sample with a stepwise increasing axial load on the limb with a force of 10 kgf was carried out, while tensometrically determined the changes in the distance between the spokes of the Ilizarov apparatus emerging from the tibia above and below the bone regenerate zone, which allowed to determine the micro-mobility of bone fragments [1]. On radiographs after removal of the device, the diameter of the diaphysis of the maternal bone in the fracture zone, as well as the maximum diameter of the bone in the periosteal zone, the difference in diameters, and the length of the periosteal reaction were determined. The area of periosteal growth was estimated as half of the product of the height and length of the formation.
Using ultrasonic Doppler unit «Angiodin-2KM» (Russia) was estimated linear systolic blood flow rate through the vessels in the area of bone regenerate, on the anterior surface of the tibia.
Statistical processing of research results was carried out using the data analysis package «Microsoft Exell-2010». The average values of the indicators and the standard error (M±m) are given. In the analysis of the dynamics of changes in indicators, the methods of correlation and linear regression analysis (C denotation of the R2 determination index) were used. To as-
sess the statistical significance of differences between the results of two independent samples, student t-test was used.
Research result
In the treatment of patients after osteosynthesis after 15 days of inpatient treatment for outpatient treatment, there was a period of increase in the micro-mobility of bone fragments due to an increase in the functional load on the injured limb. The duration of the fixation period increased from 59±1.4 to 98±3.8 days (p<0.001).
A significant impact on the timing of fixing the fragments had an increase in the age of patients (Fig. 1). The duration of the fixation period increased during the first 35 years of life (as the strength of the bones and, accordingly, the force of traumatic effects increased). After 55 years, there was a decrease in the time of fixation of bone fragments. In patients from 21 to 55 years (37±2,9 years) the average duration of fixation was 115±11, and in patients 62± years — 81±12 days.
T= -3,13x' + 35, 5x + 8,02 R2 = 0,801
\
17 27 35 45 55 59
Age (yars)
Figure 1. Age dynamics duration of the fixation period in the treatment of patients on an outpatient basis
One of the reasons for the reduction of the duration of the fixation period in elderly patients could be a decrease after 55 years of micro-mobility of bone fragments, which increased with age in young patients (Fig. 2).
L = -0,000e*3 - 0,074x2 +11,Sx -159,7
R2 = 0,646
60 70
It turned out that the magnitude of the micro-mobility of bone fragments depends on the intensity of blood supply to the corn. As the micro-mobility increased to 20-60 (im, the blood flow rate increased for each 10 kg of load. However, with large values of micro-mobility, typical for patients during treatment in outpatient settings-steadily decreased (Fig. 3).
• 1
• R2 = 0,856
/ •
/
Figure 3. The relationship of micro-mobility of fragments in the elongation of the lower leg and the speed of blood flow through the vessels of bone regenerate
With the excessive force of compression and the lack of rigidity of bone fragments fixation is an increase in the periosteal monolaterale (Fig. 4), it is a compensatory reaction, contributing to an increase in the cross-sectional area of the regenerate and reduce the specific pressure on it at rest and under functional loading of the limb, which is important to improve blood supply to the ends of the fragments [4].
E 400
y = -0,0023x3 + 0,58x2 - 37,3x + 723 R2 = 0,946
C
/ f
/
O/
o o —
Figure 2. Age dynamics of micro-mobility of bone fragments under functional load on the limb
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 Mikromotion (nm)
Figure 4. The relationship between the stiffness of bone fragments fixation and the size of periosteal regenerate
The size of the periosteal regenerate increased in the treatment of patients in outpatient settings as the age increased to 55 years, and at an older age began to decrease (Fig. 5).
V. A. Schurov, L. V. Melnikova
Age (years)
Figure 5. Age dynamics of the periosteal regenerate size in the treatment of patients
Discussion of results
The transfer of patients with Shin bone fractures to outpatient treatment mode helps to increase the "bed turnover", increase the surgical activity of traumatologists, creates conditions for increasing the availability of high-tech treatment for the population of the country's regions. However, in the treatment of Ilizarov significantly (almost 2 times) increased the time of fixation of the limb. The dependence of the treatment period on the age of patients was clearly manifested. It would seem that the most unfavorable conditions should be people of retirement age with limited mobility.
However, it was found out that in the treatment in outpatient conditions in patients older than 55 years, the micro-mobility of bone fragments decreases less, the periosteal reaction of the bone is less pronounced and the treatment period is relatively shorter.
A possible cause of the observed phenomena in older patients with this form of treatment is relatively less reactivity of the body, motor activity and functional load on the damaged limb.
The need for functional loading of the limb to stimulate osteogenesis is not in doubt. Currently, even when using the locking plate structures provides the possibility of dynamic modification during loading of the limb [5].
If the micromotion increased up to 40-50 ^m increase the blood flow to the affected limb, which is favorable to reparative regeneration, with increase of the micromotion to 80-140 ^m, and very slow compaction of callus and increase periosteal layers. This
Поступила в редакцию 7 июня 2018 г.
is a compensatory reaction to the reduction of fixation stiffness, since it helps to reduce the specific pressure on the regenerate during locomotion, that is, to increase a painless load on the limb, while excluding a violation of the blood supply to the bone marrow.
It should also be noted such a positive phenomenon as the lack of increase in the duration of the period of disability with the extension of the period of fixation for more than 65 days. In cases of such lengthening of the fixation period, a compensatory reduction of the subsequent period of functional rehabilitation occurs.
Conclusion
In the treatment of fractures, the micro-mobility of bone fragments, which determines the duration of the fixation period, increased during the transition of patients to outpatient treatment.
In patients with increasing age to 55 years, increases the micro-mobility of bone fragments, periosteal layers in the regenerate and the duration of the period of fixation. In patients older than 55 years in terms of age-related reduction of motor activity, the transition to outpatient treatment is not accompanied by such pronounced changes in the mobility of the fragments and in the terms of treatment.
References
1. Schurov V.A. Uprugoye sootvetstviye i pritok kro-vi k distraktsii regenerata [Elastic compliance and blood flow to the distraction of regenerate]. Rossiyskiy zhurnal biomehaniki [Russian journal of biomechanics], 2014, vol. 18, no. 4, pp. 471-478. (In Russ.).
2. Pouliquen J.C. La strategie: Traitement des inegalites de longueur des membres inferieurs et des sujets de petite taille chez l'enfant et l'adolescent: symp. Sous dir. De J. Caton. Rev, Chir. Orthop, 1991, vol 77, suppl. 2, pp. 53-54.
3. Pouliquen J.C., Glorion Ch., Langlais J. Allongement de membres par la metode du callotasis. Cahiers d'enseignement de la SOFCOT. Paris: Expansion Sienti-fique Française, 1996. Pp. 293-302.
4. Schurov V.A., Mesnard M. Otsenka biome-hanicheskoy i funktsionalnoy zrelosti kostnogo regenerata [Evalution of the biomechanical and functional maturity of the bone regenerate]. Fiziologiya cheloveka [Human Physiology], 2018, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 102-107. (In Russ.).
5. Laurence M., Frelman M. A.R., Swenson S. A.V. Engineerung consideration in the internal fixation of fractures of the tibial shaft. J. Bone It. Surg., 1999, 51-b, no. 4, pp. 754-769.
Для цитирования: Щуров, В. А. Особенности медицинской реабилитации больных с переломами большеберцовой кости старше 55 лет / В. А. Щуров, Л. В. Мельникова // Физическая культура. Спорт. Туризм. Двигательная рекреация. — 2018. — Т. 3, № 2. — С. 70-73.
Сведения об авторах
Щуров Владимир Алексеевич — доктор медицинских наук, профессор, главный научный сотрудник лаборатории коррекции деформаций и удлинения конечностей, Российский научный центр «Восстановительная травматология и ортопедия» имени академика Г. А. Илизарова. Курган, Россия. shchurovland@mail.ru
Мельникова Людмила Васильевна — врач отделения травматологии № 1, Российский научный центр «Восстановительная травматология и ортопедия» имени академика Г. А. Илизарова. Курган, Россия. shchurovland@ mail.ru
Особенности медицинской реабилитации больных с переломами большеберцовой кости старше 55 лет
Проанализирована динамика микроподвижности костных отломков и длительности лечения пациентов Российского научного центра «Восстановительная травматология и ортопедия» старше 55 лет с переломами костей голени (220 человек) в условиях амбулаторного лечения.
Метод. Определение микроподвижности костных отломков проводилось с тензометрической оценкой изменения расстояния между спиц Илизарова, выходящих из большеберцовой кости выше и ниже зоны костного регенерата в ходе испытаний со ступенчато возрастающей осевой нагрузкой на конечность 10 кг. Линейная скорость кровотока по сосудам в зоне регенерации кости вдоль переднебрюшной поверхности большеберцовой кости определялась с помощью ультразвуковой доплеровской установки. После лечения планиметрически определяли количество периостальной крови каллуса с помощью рентгенограммы.
Результаты. При переходе пациентов с травмами голени на амбулаторном режиме лечения микроподвижность костных отломков и длительности периода фиксации увеличивается практически в 2 раза. Показатели достоверно увеличивались у пациентов в возрасте до 30-55 лет, а затем имели тенденцию к снижению. Уплотнение костного регенерата в период фиксации способствовало уменьшению микроподвижности и нормализации скорости кровотока в зоне регенерации. Причину сокращения лечения у пожилых людей мы видим в более щадящем двигательном режиме.
Ключевые слова: аппарат Илизарова, жёсткость фиксации костных фрагментов, перелом костей голени, париетальная реакция.
Список литературы
1. Щуров, В. А. Упругое соответствие и приток крови к дистракции регенерата / В. А. Щуров // Рос. журн. биомеханики. — 2014. — Т. 18, № 4. — С. 471478.
2. Pouliquen, J. C. La strategie: Traitement des inégalités de longueur des membres inferieurs et des sujets de petite taille chez l'enfant et l'adolescent: symp. Sous dir. De J. Caton / J. C.Pouliquen // Rev. Chir. Orthop. — 1991. — Vol 77. — Suppl. 2. — P. 53-54.
3. Pouliquen, J. C. Allongement de membres par
la metode du callotasis / J. C. Pouliquen, Ch. Glorion, J. Langlais // Cahiers d'enseignement de la SOFCOT no. 58. — Paris : Expansion Sientifique Française, 1996. — P. 293-302.
4. Щуров, В. А. Оценка биомеханической и функциональной зрелости костного регенерата / В. А. Щуров, М. Меснард // Физиология человека. — 2018. — Т. 4, № 1. — С. 102-107.
5. Lаurencе, M. Engineerung consideration in the internal fixation of fractures of the tibial shaft / M. Lаurencе, M. A. R. Frelman, S. A. V. Swenson // J. Вош It. Surg. — 1999, 51-b. — № 4. — Р. 754-769.
