CC BY
0Scholarly Publisher RS Global Sp. z O.O.
ISNI: 0000 0004 8495 2390
Dolna 17, Warsaw, Poland 00-773 Tel: +48 226 0 227 03 Email: editorial_office@rsglobal.pl
JOURNAL p-ISSN e-ISSN PUBLISHER
World Science
2413-1032
2414-6404
RS Global Sp. z O.O., Poland
ARTICLE TITLE AUTHOR(S)
ARTICLE INFO
DOI
RECEIVED ACCEPTED PUBLISHED
EXPLORING THE POSSIBILITIES OF SOME CONTEMPORARY PHYSICAL THERAPY METHODS FOR THE CONSERVATIVE TREATMENT OF CARPAL TUNNEL SYNDROME
Evgeniya Vladeva
Evgeniya Vladeva. (2024) Exploring The Possibilities of Some Contemporary Physical Therapy Methods for The Conservative Treatment of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. World Science. 1(83). doi: 10.31435/rsglobal_ws/30032024/8108
https://doi.org/10.31435/rsglobal_ws/30032024/8108 02 February 2024 09 March 2024 12 March 2024
LICENSE
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
© The author(s) 2024. This publication is an open access article.
EXPLORING THE POSSIBILITIES OF SOME CONTEMPORARY PHYSICAL THERAPY METHODS FOR THE CONSERVATIVE TREATMENT OF CARPAL TUNNEL SYNDROME
Evgeniya Vladeva
Department оf Physiotherapy, Rehabilitation and Thalassotherapy Faculty оf Public Health, Medical University оf Varna, Bulgaria
DOI: https://doi.org/10.31435/rsglobal_ws/30032024/8108
ABSTRACT
Carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) is the most common compression neuropathy, affecting nearly 5% of the general population. The modern approach to its treatment is complex and includes early diagnosis, prevention and treatment of all conditions and diseases leading to its manifestation.
Many authors have worked on the problems related to the possibilities of physical therapy in treating CTS, but the question of optimal treatment and rehabilitation remains relevant to this day. In practice, various rehabilitation programs are constantly being implemented and developed. Many have demonstrated positive outcomes, but work in this area persists. Every novel approach or integration of established physiotherapeutic and rehabilitation techniques enhances the current methods and expands the potential for more comprehensive functional recovery of the impaired limb, as well as the patient's restoration to their previous lifestyle.
Physical therapy has advanced significantly in recent decades due to the introduction of numerous new techniques and technologies. The article offers a brief literature overview of several contemporary physical medicine approaches that can be applied in the conservative treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome based on their physiological and therapeutic effects. Modern physical therapy approaches can be a viable alternative to established physical therapy methods like ultrasound, low-level laser, iontophoresis, magnetotherapy, TENS, and others. It is crucial to conduct additional qualitative and comprehensive investigations to verify the effectiveness of physical therapy in treating CTS, identify the most efficient ways, and create improved protocols for its conservative treatment.
Citation: Evgeniya Vladeva. (2024) Exploring The Possibilities of Some Contemporary Physical Therapy Methods for The Conservative Treatment of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. World Science. 1(83). doi: 10.31435/ rsglobal_ws/30032024/8108
Copyright: © 2024 Evgeniya Vladeva. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) or licensor are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
Introduction.
First described by Paget in 1854, carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) is the most common compression neuropathy with an incidence of between 125-515/100,000. CTS occurs due to the compression of the median nerve by the transverse ligament of the wrist. (Conway, 1994) (Corvin, 2006). It occurs in 2 to 5% of the overall population. In the Netherlands, a general population study revealed an incidence of 1% for men and 7% for women. The population prevalence of carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) in southern Sweden was 3%, with a 95% confidence interval ranging from 2% to 3%.
ARTICLE INFO
Received: 02 February 2024 Accepted: 09 March 2024 Published: 12 March 2024
KEYWORDS
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, Tekar, Deep Oscillations, High Energy Laser Therapy, Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy, Polarised Light Therapy, High-Intensity Electromagnetic Field, Electrotherapy.
Typically, the prevalence is higher in women than in males, with a male-to-female ratio of 1.0:1.4. (Ashworth, 2016). Any factors causing a reduction in the width of the carpal tunnel or an enlargement of its components result in nerve compression and related complications. CTS develops because of the compression of the median nerve in the carpal tunnel caused by increased pressure.
The classic carpal tunnel syndrome manifests with sensory and motor impairments in the area of the median nerve, often accompanied by pain. Symptoms worsen with physical exertion on the affected limb. During the initial stages of CTS, the clinical presentation is primarily associated with the involvement of sensory fibres. It is characterised by dull and burning pain in the area of the wrist, extending from the palm to the elbow. The pain typically intensifies at night and is often associated with paresthesia in the second and third fingers of the hand upon awakening. Relief is felt when shaking the hand and letting it hang outside the bed. (Vladeva E, 2014).
The modern approach to managing carpal tunnel syndrome is comprehensive and includes prompt identification, prevention, and treatment of all underlying disorders and diseases contributing to its development. Physical therapy techniques are an effective alternative for the conservative management of this medical condition.
The role of physical therapy in the treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome.
Many authors have worked on the problems related to the possibilities of physical therapy in the treatment of CTS. However, the question of optimal treatment and rehabilitation remains relevant today. In practice, various rehabilitation programs are constantly being implemented and developed. Many have demonstrated positive outcomes, but work in this area persists. Every novel approach or integration of established physiotherapeutic and rehabilitation techniques enhances the current methods and expands the potential for more comprehensive functional recovery of the impaired limb, as well as the patient's restoration to their previous lifestyle (Vladeva E, 2014).
Regardless of the choice of physical treatment modalities for CTS, the physiotherapist is faced with the following tasks:
1. Treatment of pain and other subjective symptoms experienced by the patient (such as reduced sensitivity, abnormal sensations, and trouble gripping objects).
2. Treating oedema and enhancing blood circulation in the affected hand.
3. Enhancing nerve conductivity and promoting regenerative processes.
4. Improving sensory perception, increasing muscle strength, and restoring compromised functions of the affected limb.
5. Preventing fibrotic processes and other potential problems.
6. Treatment targeting the causes and mechanisms of the disease.
The physiotherapist must choose and customise tools and methods based on a functional assessment, neurological and functional status data, results from tests like ENG, ultrasound diagnostics, CT, or MRI, and the patient's psychosomatic condition for best outcomes.
The neurorehabilitation course is tailored to address the patient's motor and sensory problems to resolve their current functional issues.
The neurorehabilitation program should be customised to the specific clinical form and stage of the disease, considering any accompanying conditions that may be part of the cause. It should be personalised, with minimal societal investment to maximise results for the patient's quality of life, regardless of the funding source.(KoneBa, 2009).
Physical therapy for carpal tunnel syndrome.
Ultrasound therapy is a frequently utilised approach. Some authors suggest that the impact of phonophoresis with corticosteroids is similar to that of corticosteroid injections, making phonophoresis a non-invasive approach that preserves the skin's integrity (Bilgici, 2010) (Rük§en, 2011). Sonicating for a brief period (4-5 min) can enhance the impact of the following electrophoresis using known skin-absorbing capabilities improved by ultrasound's heat and mechanical impacts (Vladeva E, 2014).
Physiotherapy treatment may include low-level laser therapy, acupuncture, magnetic therapy, ultra-high frequency currents, interference currents and TENS (Karjalanen T, 2022). These physical factors do not address the aetiology and etiopathogenesis of CTS. They are used as a symptomatic treatment, mainly targeting pain and paresthesias.
Physical therapy has advanced significantly in recent decades due to the development of numerous new treatments and technologies.
MLS (Multiwave Locked System) high-energy laser therapy is a precise and safe treatment that is highly effective in alleviating pain, with noticeable results from the initial session. This technology offers quick treatments combining constant and pulse modes to accomplish a triple effect: simultaneously reducing swelling, inflammation, and pain. The device allows for working on a greater region using scanning mode or focusing on trigger points, acupuncture, or painful points. The techniques are appropriate for treating pain from different sources, post-traumatic problems, swelling, joint diseases, spinal issues, nerve disorders, skin conditions, and post-surgery rehabilitation.
Improving blood circulation in the outer layer of the skin is thought to affect the level of blood circulation within the inner layer of nerves. Blood vessels and nerves exhibit similar principles and signals for differentiation and growth, resulting in a coordinated reaction to shared stimuli, including laser treatment. The laser improves peripheral nerve function by boosting blood circulation to the nerves. (Yosifova L, 2023).
Ezzati et al. conducted a double-blind, randomised, controlled research with 98 patients aged 20 to 60. They demonstrated the advantages of high-energy laser radiation at 1.6 W and low fluence of 8 J/cm2 over low-intensity laser therapy (Ezzati, 2020 ).
Yigit, et al.'s study, evaluates the impact of high-intensity laser therapy (HILT) on pain, functional status, grip strength, and median nerve cross-sectional area (evaluated using ultrasonography) in individuals with carpal tunnel syndrome. The study included sixty patients diagnosed with carpal tunnel syndrome. Participants in the trial were randomly allocated into two groups, each consisting of 30 patients. The first group received exercises, splinting, and HILT treatment for 10 sessions over two weeks, with specific parameters for the HILT treatment. The second group received splinting, exercises, and sham laser treatment for the same period. The study's findings support the conclusion that hand grip strength rises and the cross-sectional area of the median nerve decreases when a high-intensity laser is applied. The effect has only been shown in the short term, with no evidence of its long-term retention. (Yigit, 2023).
Extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT) is recognised as a non-invasive and evidence-based physical therapy method for treating CTS. The device utilises pneumatically produced shock waves operating at a low frequency of 5-20 Hz and a pressure ranging from 1 to 5 bar. Extracorporeal shock wave therapy (ESWT) addresses injuries by enhancing local metabolic activity, promoting the reabsorption of tendon calcifications, and triggering natural healing mechanisms in tissues. Stimulating the healing process involves releasing growth factors in tendons and bones, which results in the development of new blood vessels. Enhancing microcirculation through the formation of new blood vessels leads to the encouragement of tissue regeneration and repair. The shock wave therapy process can be described as the body's reaction to acute trauma, triggering inflammation, new tissue development, and regeneration. The wide range of indications of shock wave therapy is determined by its mode of action. The application for carpal tunnel syndrome is focused locally in the area of the transverse carpal ligament. The treatment regimen includes 4-6 sessions, with one or two sessions per week. Therapy is more beneficial during the early phase of the disease and in younger individuals whose carpal tunnel syndrome is linked to excessive work demands. (Soyuer, 2021) (Zaralieva, 2020).
Yujie Xie and colleagues systematically reviewed ten studies involving 433 patients (501 hands). They concluded that shock wave therapy effectively alleviates symptoms and enhances hand function in individuals with carpal tunnel syndrome. They also found that radial shock wave therapy is more effective than focused shock wave therapy in terms of symptom relief and functional recovery. (Yujie Xie, 2022).
A double-blind clinical trial conducted by Vahdatpour et al. involved 60 patients with moderate CTS divided into two groups. Both groups received conservative treatment, which included wrist immobilisation at night for three months, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs for two weeks, and oral intake of vitamin B1 for one month. The initial group received Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy (ESWT) once a week for four weeks. The authors recommend applying ESWT as a conservative treatment for patients with CTS due to its positive impact on reversing clinical symptoms, Energy-dispersiveX-ra y spectroscopy results (EDX), and its lack of adverse effects (Vahdatpour, 2016).
Tecar therapy, also known as targeted radiofrequency therapy or TECAR, is an electrotherapeutic non-invasive treatment that utilises high-frequency currents. The current creates heat inside the tissues by penetrating them via electromagnetic energy. This effect leads to a slow and regulated rise in internal temperature within the tissues. (Kumaran B, 2019). This action results in cellular activation and dilatation of blood vessels, initiating a natural regeneration process. This mechanism stimulates the release of natural painkillers, compounds that promote biological stimulation and regeneration (primarily cortisol and endorphins), elimination of cellular waste products, reduction of outflow, and inflammatory processes. Endogenous heat produced has a strong anti-inflammatory effect and speeds up tissue repair. The devices combine two modes of operation: capacitive and resistive (Zaralieva, 2020). Various tissues possess unique structures, resulting in distinct tissue resistance. This suggests utilising a different approach to produce heat in each of them selectively. Targeted radiofrequency therapy offers accurate and effective treatment by combining two modes of operation to heat certain tissues at varying depths. Athermic efficiency is achieved by using low-intensity radio frequency to heat the surface tissue layers more efficiently and enhance the function of the lymphatic system. This leads to decreased acute or chronic swelling, enhancement of anti-inflammatory mechanisms, and notable enhancement of cellular and interstitial metabolism. (Binoy Kumaran, 2017).
According to a study by Vahdatpour et al. TECAR can be considered an effective non-invasive treatment for patients, reducing clinical symptoms and enhancing daily activities in patients with mild to moderate carpal tunnel syndrome (Vahdatpour B, 2023). Future research with a bigger sample size and longer follow-up are required to validate these results, providing more significant insights into nerve conduction changes and enhancing the understanding of the clinical effectiveness of TECAR CTS therapy.
Deep oscillations are a modern physical therapy modality with anti-edematous, fibrinolytic, analgesic, and anti-inflammatory properties. While still being validated for treating CTS, it could be considered for conservative treatment of the syndrome. The deep oscillation (DO) approach relies on the Johnson-Rahbek effect, which occurs when an electric potential is supplied at the junction of a metal surface and a semiconductor material surface. Under these conditions, electrostatic attraction and friction forces occur in biological tissues, causing the generation of an oscillation that penetrates deeply up to 8 cm, affecting all tissue components in the applied area (skin, connective tissue, muscles, blood, and lymphatic vessels). The intermittent electrostatic field generated has low intensity (I = 150 A), ranging from 100 to 400 V, and low frequency (f = 5-250 Hz) (Locheva, 2019). Deep oscillations have been clinically proven to provide substantial pain relief and anti-inflammatory effects in both acute and chronic pain conditions. They can also help prevent and reduce lymphedema, aid in fibrous remodelling, reduce fibrosis, promote muscle relaxation, mobilise fascia, and improve range of motion. Hernandes S. et al. proved the fibrinolytic and tissue tension-reducing action of DO in an experimental prospective case-control research. Deep oscillations have been found to induce tissue relaxation, exhibit mild vasoconstrictor action, promote local lymphatic resorption, and decrease fibrosis. (Hernández Tápanes S., 2018). The over twenty-year history of therapeutic use of DO demonstrates their pain-relieving effectiveness in chronic pain associated with certain musculoskeletal and neurological system disorders. As confirmed by objective measurements, the significant enhancement in lymphatic circulation and decreased lymphedema are undeniable. The impact of enhanced tissue nourishment has been demonstrated. Studies have confirmed the anti-inflammatory impact of deep oscillations. (Locheva, 2019). Deep oscillations have demonstrated physiological and therapeutic benefits that suggest they could positively impact the reversal of carpal tunnel syndrome symptoms. Although deep oscillation devices have established programs for treating CTS, additional studies are needed to prove their beneficial effect in patients with this disease.
Biofield therapy is used to manage pain for patients with cancer and chronic pain. Research regarding the impact of biofield treatment on particular somatic illnesses needs to be more comprehensive. Mohammad Reza Nourbakhsh studied the impact of oscillating biofield therapy (OBFT) on carpal tunnel syndrome symptoms. (Mohammad Reza Nourbakhsh, 2016). Participants were randomly assigned to either the active or placebo treatment groups. The active treatment group underwent six sessions of OBFT within a 2-week timeframe. Patients in the placebo group had an equivalent number of sessions. A significant drop in the number of patients testing positive in the Phalen test (87%; p = 0.000), the Tinel test (73%; p = 0.000), and experiencing hand paresthesia (80%;
p = 0.000) was observed in patients receiving active treatment. After six months, 86% of patients in the therapy group were still free of pain and had no functional limitations. The authors determined that OBFT could be a beneficial therapy for enhancing the symptoms and limitations of function linked to chronic carpal tunnel syndrome.
Physiotherapy utilising high-intensity electromagnetic fields through Super Inductive System (SIS) therapy has demonstrated effects on pain reduction, muscle relaxation, muscle activation, and joint mobilisation. SIS focuses on neuromuscular tissue, where the electromagnetic field interacts with the muscles to produce controlled and repetitive contractions. This process helps remove joint obstructions, improve circulation and tissue metabolism, and enhance muscle tone.
Many specialised studies have been developed in recent decades analysing different conservative techniques (https://files.btlnet.com/cor/documents/af40969e-4070-4864-bf4e-b84545dfed99/BTL-6000_SIS_CAT_ELITE_EN103_preview_1473426747_original.pdf). Joint mobilisation is accomplished by repeatedly contracting the muscles that surround the joint capsule. This repeated contraction replaces manual joint mobilisation, resulting in the restoration of joint play. When the electromagnetic field interacts with neuromuscular tissue, it causes neuron depolarisation and muscle contractions. Muscle facilitation or strengthening can be obtained depending on the chosen stimulation frequency. An observational prospective study by Diana Jimbu et al. conducted in 2021-2022 followed 56 patients receiving three SIS therapy sessions per week with the BTL-6000 equipment and daily physical therapies. The study showed that the high-intensity electromagnetic field produced by SIS therapy is effective and safe for treating patients with CTS. It offers substantial advantages by reducing pain and paraesthesia and improving patients' quality of life. (Jimbu D., 2023).
Light therapy has been used since the late 1960s for treating various conditions such as neonatal jaundice, joint discomfort, psoriasis, and vitiligo. The most common forms of phototherapies are low-level laser therapy (LLLT) and ultraviolet (UV) radiation, which differ based on the physical characteristics of the light used.
Recently, it has been proposed that polarisation and a broad light spectrum are crucial components of light therapy. Light waves are filtered to oscillate uniformly, producing polarised light (PL). Polarised Light Therapy (PLT) uses polarised light to penetrate deeper into tissues and stimulate various biological processes. Photobiomodulation (PL) differs from other forms of light therapy by utilising a broader range of wavelengths compared to Low-Level Laser Therapy (LLLT) or Ultraviolet (UV) light (M. Allam N, 2022). The light produced by the Bioptron light therapy system is polarised, low-energy, polychromatic (with wavelengths ranging from 480 to 3400 nm), and incoherent (not in phase unlike laser light) (Raeissadat SA, 2014). Bioptron works by activating cellular processes, improving blood flow, reducing pro-inflammatory cytokines, and increasing plasma levels of antiinflammatory and fibroblast growth factors. (Zhevago, 2004) (O'Connor, 2003). However, there is limited research assessing the impact of bioptron therapy on symptom alleviation in CTS.
A randomised clinical trial with forty-four patients with mild to moderate carpal tunnel syndrome evaluated the impact of Bioptron on pain symptoms and electroneurographic parameters with splinting for eight weeks. The scientists determined that the therapeutic benefits achieved by using the Bioptron are comparable to those achieved by using a splint (Raeissadat SA, 2014).
An uncontrolled experimental study by Stasinopoulos et al. found that nocturnal pain and paresthesias associated with mild to moderate idiopathic carpal tunnel syndrome were relieved during treatment with polarised polychromatic incoherent light (Bioptron light), and the results were sustained up to six months. Bioptron, polarised polychromatic noncoherent light, was applied perpendicularly to the carpal tunnel area. Each session lasted 6 minutes and took place at a distance of 5-10 cm from the carpal tunnel area. This was done three times a week for four weeks (D. Stasinopoulos, 2005). The authors believe the Bioptron Light is a dependable, secure, and efficient treatment for patients with CTS. However, using alternative therapeutic protocols and light characteristics than those in this study could lead to varying outcomes favouring Bioptron therapy. Controlled clinical trials are necessary to determine this treatment's definitive and comparative efficacy.
GUNA injectable collagen stimulates collagen production by targeting specific anatomical areas using 13 different vials. Gunaphoresis using collagen ampoules enhances the perineural collagen structure and alleviates localised neural pain. This novel physical therapy strategy is currently being verified for its efficacy in treating CTS and can be regarded as part of its conservative treatment. Tropocollagen, supplied by Guna Collagen Medical Devices, undergoes a process of assembly at the
extracellular matrix (ECM) level via the enzyme lysine hydroxylase into collagen; thus, it functions as a bioscaffold (Milani, 2010). The application of MDs results in the deposition of neosynthesised collagen fibres in the damaged region. This process substantially enhances the mechanical properties of the injured tissue, specifically by restoring its anisotropic characteristics. Proper mechanical support is achieved for optimal operation due to the alignment of collagen fibres in a single direction (Milani, 2019).
This approach offers deep penetration, a high product absorption rate, and no heat effects, making it safe for use on nerve tissues without overheating. All of this occurs without causing any adverse effects and with remarkable tolerability (Brunato, 2021). No research in the scientific literature has conclusively demonstrated the efficacy of this therapy. Considering the established physiological impacts of gunaphoresis, it is essential to recognise its possible beneficial effects in managing clinical symptoms of CTS.
High-tone external muscle stimulation (HTEMS) or high-tone therapy is a novel form of electrotherapy. HTEMS differs from traditional electrotherapy by modulating frequency and amplitude simultaneously, resulting in more significant energy delivery to the tissues. High-tone therapy has gained significant focus for treating many diseases. Its primary effects include energising the body to stimulate cell activity, causing cells and tissues to vibrate and boost metabolism, and releasing pain and inflammation mediators to alleviate pain. High tone power therapy reduces pain and improves function in CTS patients, outperforming physical therapy alone (Abou Shady N, 2019). Despite a number of studies reporting that high-tone therapy significantly alleviated symptoms and signs, the insufficient number and substandard methodological quality of the included studies prevent definitive conclusions regarding the efficacy of HTEMS. This may be an important motivation for future research (Namvar H, 2022).
Kinesio taping involves applying elastic tape to generate small folds in the skin, lift skin tissue, enhance blood circulation, alleviate discomfort, and decrease compression. Application direction, duration, frequency, and tension level are crucial in kinesio taping. Kinesio taping technique has been shown to reduce pain and symptom severity and improve daily activities in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome. (Soyuer, 2021). Kinesio tape application on CTS relieves nerve pressure by elongating the transverse carpal ligament. It decreases muscle spasms, aids in the movement of tendons and fascia, and alleviates pain by suppressing neurological activity. Kinesio taping is suitable for mild to severe carpal tunnel syndrome as it does not disrupt daily activities like an immobilisation splint and has no adverse effects. (Soyuer, 2021).
Virtual rehabilitation for carpal tunnel syndrome Force Feedback utilises haptic devices to deliver effective and engaging feedback during physical treatment. (Tamayo, 2018). Patients interact with virtual apps and do activities within a 3D graphical environment. This can enhance the therapeutic process by increasing engagement and motivation and enabling more authentic and regulated motions. The exercises replicate typical daily activities, aiding patients in restoring the functional skills necessary for daily living. The system is created with the Unity3D game engine, providing a versatile and easy-to-use platform. The advantages of this rehabilitation approach lie in the following aspects:
1. Integrating tactile feedback and virtual environments and simulating daily tasks can enhance therapy by making it more interactive and entertaining for patients. This may result in improved adherence to the rehabilitation program.
2. The system can offer targeted exercises that address the root causes of CTS, perhaps resulting in quicker and more effective rehabilitation.
3. The system emphasises developing a collaborative relationship between the patient and technology, which may result in improved outcomes.
According to research along these lines, Force Feedback haptic devices may be an effective aid in treating carpal tunnel syndrome. Nevertheless, additional investigation is required to validate the long-term efficacy and applicability of this approach. (Tamayo, 2018) (De Paolis, 2018).
Conclusion.
Contemporary approaches of physical therapy such as targeted radiofrequency therapy (TECAR), high-energy laser therapy, extracorporeal shock wave therapy (ESWT), deep oscillation, polarised light therapy (PLT), collagen ampoule gunaforesis, high-tone therapy, virtual rehabilitation
system utilisation, and haptic devices can serve as a viable alternative to established methods of physical therapy like ultrasound therapy, low-level laser therapy, iontophoresis, magnetotherapy, TENS, and others. Although current scientific evidence supports the efficacy of contemporary physical therapy methods in treating carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS), further comprehensive comparative studies with larger patient groups are required to assess the long-term effectiveness of this treatment approach. It is crucial to conduct additional qualitative and comprehensive investigations to verify the effectiveness of physical therapy in CTS, identify the most efficient approaches, and create improved protocols for its conservative treatment. This will enhance awareness among patients and healthcare professionals regarding the advantages of physical therapy in managing the syndrome. Further research investment in this field could enhance the quality of life for many people suffering from carpal tunnel syndrome.
REFERENCES
1. Ashworth, N. L. (2016). Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. Am Fam Physician, Nov 15;94(10):830-831. PMID: 27929273.
2. Bilgici, A., H. Ulusoy, O. Kuru, F. Canturk. (2010). The comparison of ultrasound treatment and local steroid injection plus splinting in the carpal tunnel syndrome: a randomized controlled trial. Bratisl Lek Listy, 111(12): 659-665.
3. Binoy Kumaran, Anthony Herbland & Tim Watson. (2017). Continuous-mode 448 kHz capacitive resistive monopolar radiofrequency induces greater deep blood flow changes compared to pulsed mode shortwave: a crossover study in healthy adults. European Journal of Physiotherapy, 19:3, 137-146, DOI: 10.1080/21679169.2017.1316310.
4. Brunato F. (2021). The Treatment of Rhisoartrosis with Colllagen Mmedical Device Small Joints. Physiological Regulating Medicine, 3-12.
5. Conway, H. R., S. R. Jones. E. (1994). Entrapment and compression neuropathies. Handbook of paim management. 2nd ed, ot CD Tollison, Baltimore: Williams and Wilkins.
6. Corvin, H. M. (2006). Compresiion neuropathies of the upper extremity. Clin Occup Environ Med, 333352.
7. De Paolis, L. T., & Bourdot, P. . (2018). Augmented Reality, Virtual Reality, and Computer Graphics: 5th International Conference, AVR. Otranto, Italy,: Proceedings, Part I (Vol. 10850). Springer.
8. Ezzati, K., Laakso, E., Saberi, A., Yousefzadeh Chabok, S., Nasiri, E., & Bakhshayesh Eghbali, B. (2020). AA comparative study of the dose-dependent effects of low level and high intensity photobiomodulation (laser) therapy on pain and electrophysiological parameters in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome: a randomized controlled trial. European journal ofphysical and rehabilitation medicine,, 56(6), 733-740.
9. Hernández Tápanes S., Marrilyn de Jesus Socas Fernandes, Yinet iturralde, Addiel Suares Fernandes. (2018). The Effect of Deep Oscillation Therapy in Fibrocystic Breast Disease. A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial. Physical Medicine & rehabilitation, ISSN : 1755-7682. Vol. 11, No.14.
10. Jimbu D., Oprea D., Petcu L.C. , Iliescu M.G., Caraban B.M, Bulbuc I., Obada B., Bordei P. (2023). Clinical Outcome of specific therapy using high intensity electromagnetic field in Patients with Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. Balneo andPRMResearch Journal, 14(3): 576.
11. Karjalanen T, Raatikainen S, Jaatinen K, Lusa V. (2022). Update on Efficacy of Conservative Treatments for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. Journal of Clinical Medicine, 11(4):950. https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm11040950.
12. Kumaran B, Watson T. T. (2019). Treatment using 448kHz capacitive resistive monopolar radiofrequency improves pain and function in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee joint: a randomised controlled trial. Physiotherapy., Mar;105(1):98-107.doi: 10.1016/j.physio.2018.07.004. Epub 2018 Jul 26. PMID: 30269963.
13. Locheva, V., Todorov, I., & Panayotova-Ovcharova, L. (2019). Therapy with Deep Oscillations-principle, biological effects, review. Varna Medical Forum (Vol. 8, No. 2, pp. 91-100)., 91-100.
14. M. Allam N, Eladl HM, Eid MM. (2022). Polarized Light Therapy in the Treatment of Wounds: A Review. The International Journal of Lower Extremity Wounds., doi:10.1177/15347346221113991.
15. Milani L. (2019). Guna Collagen Medical Devices 10 anni dopo. - Analisi ragionata di 2 recenti importanti ricerche e update della letteratura. La Med. Biol, 2; 3-18.
16. Milani L. (2010). A new and refined injectable treat- ment for muskoloskeletal disorders. Bioscaffold properties of collagen and its clinical use. Physological Regulating Medicine, 1: 3-15.
17. Mohammad Reza Nourbakhsh, Thomas J. Bell, Jason Benson Martin, and Amir Massoud Arab. T. (2016). The Effects of Oscillatory Biofield Therapy on Pain and Functional Limitations Associated with Carpal
Tunnel Syndrome: Randomized, Placebo-Controlled, Double-Blind Study. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine., 911-920.http://doi.org/10.1089/acm.2016.0083.
18. Namvar H, Olyaie G, Bagheri H, Naiemi E, Hoseinifar M, Sargolzehi M. (2022). Effect of High-Tone External Muscle Stimulation (High-Tone Therapy) in Neuro-Musculoskeletal Disorders: A Narrative Review. j. Journal of Modern Rehabilitation, 16(3):208-213.
19. Nawal Abou Shady, Mohamed H. Hussien, Walid A. Abdel Ghany Enas Elsayed4,Ahmed Magdy ElShimy, Nadia Mohamed Abdelhakiem. (2019). Effect of High Tone Power Therapy on Carpal Tunnel Syndrome PAatients:(Randomised control Trial). Turkish Journal of Physiotherapy and Rehabilitation, 32, 3.
20. O'Connor, D., & Marshall, S. C. Massy-Westropp, N., & Pitt, V. (2003). Non-surgical treatment(other than steroid injection) for carpal tunnel syndrome. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 1.
21. Raeissadat SA, Rayegani SM, Rezaei S, Sedighipour L, Bahrami MH, Eliaspour D, Karimzadeh A. (2014). The effect of polarized polychromatic noncoherent light (bioptron) therapy on patients with carpal tunnel syndrome. Journal of lasers in medical sciences,, 5(1): 39-46.
22. Reinhold J. (2017). Mechanisms of Deep Oscillation, Manual Lymphatic Drainage. UK, The Journal.
23. Rukçen, S., B. Oz, N. Olmez, A. Memiç. (2011). Comparison of clinical effectiveness of corticosteroid phonophoresis and local steroid injection treatment in carpal tunnel syndrome. Turkiye Fiziksel Tip ve Rehabilitasyon Dergisi, 57(3): 119-123.
24. Soyuer F. (2021). Effectiveness of current physiotherapy in carpal tunnel syndrome. Int J Fam Commun Med, E 5(3), 87-89.
25. Stasinopoulos D, Stasinopoulos I, Johnson M.I. (2005). Treatment of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome with Polarized Polychromatic Noncoherent Light (Bioptron Light): A Preliminary, Prospective, Open Clinical Trial. Photomedicine and Laser Surgery., 225-228.
26. Tamayo, M., Salazar, P.J., Bustamante, D.C., Silva, S.M., Escudero, V.M., Andaluz, V.H. (2018). Virtual Rehabilitation of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Through Force Feedback. In: De Paolis, L., Bourdot, P. (eds) Augmented Reality, Virtual Reality, and Computer. In Lecture Notes in Computer Science (pp. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-95282-6_11). Springer, Cham.
27. Vahdatpour B, Ghasemi H R, Taheri P. Middle. (2023). Effectiveness of TECAR Therapy on Clinical Symptoms and Neurophysiological Parameters of Patients with Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: A Randomized Clinical Trial. East JRehabil Health Stud., 10(3):e134171, doi.org/10.5812/mejrh-134171.
28. Vahdatpour, B., Kiyani, A., & Dehghan, F. (2016). Effect of extracorporeal shock wave therapy on the treatment of patients with carpal tunnel syndrome. Advanced biomedical research, 5, 120. https://doi.org/10.4103/2277-9175.186983.
29. Vladeva Е, al. (2014). Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Through the Eyes of the Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation Specialists. Physical Medicine, Rehabilitation and Health,, бр. 3, стр 18-25.
30. Yigit, F., Ordahan, B. (2023). Effects of high-intensity laser therapy on pain, functional status, hand grip strength, and median nerve cross-sectional area by ultrasonography in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome. Lasers Med Sci, 38, 248, https://doi.org/10.1007/s10103-023-03913-z.
31. Yosifova L, Vladeva E, Siderova M,. (2023). Effects of MLS-laser on neuropathic pain in diabetic sensîmotor neuropathy. J of IMAB, 29 (3):5079-5084. https://doi.org/10.5272/jimab.2023293.5079].
32. Yujie Xie, Chi Zhang, Bin Liang, Jianxiong Wang, Li Wang, Tenggang Wan, Fangyuan Xu & Lei Lei. (2022). Effects of shock wave therapy in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome: a systematic review and meta-analysis,. Disability and Rehabilitation, 44:2, 177-188.
33. Zaralieva, A., Georgiev, G. P., Karabinov, V., Iliev, A., & Aleksiev, A. (2020). Physical therapy and rehabilitation approaches in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome. Cureus, 12(3).
34. Zhevago, N. A., & Samoïlova, K. A. (2004). Modulation of proliferation of peripheral blood lymphocytes after irradiation of volunteers with polychromatic visible and infrared light. Tsitologiia,, 46(6), 567-577.
35. Колева, И., Г. Георгиев, Т. Троев, Р. Йошинов. Неврорехабилитация и компетенции на лекари- те-специалисти по физикална и рехабилитацион- на медицина. (2009). Неврорехабилитация и компетенции на лекарите-специалисти по физикална и рехабилитационна медицина. Физикална медицина, рехабилитация, здраве, 8-16.
36. https://files.btlnet.com/cor/documents/af40969e-4070-4864-bf4e-b84545dfed99/BTL-6000_SIS_CAT_ELITE_EN103_preview_1473426747_original.pdf.
