CC BY
46
366
KiMYA PROBLEML9RÎ № 4 2016
UDC: 541.138.3
ENHANCEMENT OF CATHODIC HYDROGEN EVOLUTION REACTION THROUGH THE USE OF PROTON CARRIERS (A BRIEF-REVIEW)
N.Vaszilcsin, A.Kellenberger, M.Medeleanu
University Politehnica Timisoara, Faculty of Industrial Chemistry and Environmental Engineering, 300006 PiataVictoriei, Timisoara, Romania, nicolae.vaszilcsin@,upt.ro
The paper is a mini-review on the enhancement of the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) through the use of proton carriers. Results obtained based on the research of the catalytic effect of amines on cathodic HER have been presented. The best results have been obtained on Pt in 0.5 M H2SO4, where aniline as proton carrier was used. In this case, an emphasis was laid on the increase of exchange current density io from 2.9 A m~2, in blank H2SO4, to 67.6 A m~2 in the presence of 10-2 M aniline. At the same time, the Gibbs absorption energy goes to show that proton carriers are adsorbed on the metal surface by weak physical bond. Also, correlations between catalytic effect and molecular parameters of proton carrier molecules have been accomplished.
Keywords: hydrogen evolution, proton carriers, aniline, catalytic effect, electro-catalysis.
INTRODUCTION
Approaches to the topic are explained as being due to the fact that hydrogen is still considered to be an excellent energy carrier and fuel of the future. The point is that in the combustion process of hydrogen inside engines there is just water without carbon dioxide. Unfortunately, most widely used methods for hydrogen production are based on coal gasification, or cracking and reforming of hydrocarbons, processes that produce not only hydrogen, but huge quantity of carbon dioxide as well. For example, if hydrogen is obtained by steam reforming of methane per each 1 ton of H2, a quantity of 5.5 tons of CO2 is discharged into atmosphere [1]. Moreover, in coal gasification technology, 11 tons of CO2 are emitted into environment per each 1 ton of H2 produced [2].
It should be noted that water splitting
by electrolysis is a green procedure; however, it is limited by essential electric energy consumption. That's why the research into the cathodic hydrogen evolution is still important. There is a great number of studies into the enhancement of water electrolysis process with due regard for electro-catalytic effect of electrode materials on both anodic and cathodic processes, including various aspects of oxygen and hydrogen evolution. From this point of view, a question of the enhancement of hydrogen evolution with the help of catalysts in the electrolyte solution remains to be little-studied.
The aim of the paper is to present a mechanism of catalytic effect of proton carriers on cathodic hydrogen evolution reaction HER in acid solutions, as well as the latest achievements on this track.
PRINCIPLES OF ELECTROCATALYSIS BY PROTON CARRIERS
The catalytic effect of proton carriers on HER has been noted many years ago, particularly in polarographic studies into dropping mercury electrode where an essential shift of polarographic wave of HER towards
more positive potentials was revealed to result from high hydrogen over-potential [3]. Albumin was one of the first organic bases analyzed as proton carriers. Its effect on HER was initially interpreted as proton transfer
bridge between electrolyte solution and mercury surface [4]. Later on, studies touched upon other organic compounds, including peptides and proteins [5-7]. Similar phenomenon was reported by Tamamushi et al. conformably to methylviologen [8].
Frumkin was the first to have suggested a consistent mechanism of this catalytic effect [9]. In his view, organic bases are directly involved in the cathodic process, and the charge transfer step is a reversible reaction as is seen from the equation below (1):
H3O+(aq) ^ H3O+(ads)
BASE-H+ + e- ^ [BASE-H], (1) where BASE is the organic compound (proton carrier).
Neutral chemical species [BASE-H], which are adsorbed on the metal surface, release molecular hydrogen in an irreversible reaction (2).
2[BASE-H] ^ H2 + 2BASE (2)
Further, neutral molecules BASE pass over to the solution, where they are protonated again.
Stackelberg et al. proposed a more elaborate mechanism, unfolded in four steps [10-12]:
BASE(ads) + H3O+(ads) ^ [BASE-H]+(ads) + H2O [BASE-H]+(ads) + e- ^ BASE-H(ads)
2BASE-H(ads) ^ H2 + 2BASE(ads)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
The above mentioned authors assumed that at low current densities the rate determining step is the charge transfer (5), whereas at high current densities the organic base protonation (4) becomes the slow step.
Stackelberg mechanism differs essentially from Frumkin one. In Stackelberg mechanism, organic base molecules are permanently blocked on the metal surface by adsorption, while Frumkin mechanism assumes that proton carrier molecules are desorbed after the charge transfer and protonated in the electrolyte solution. Therefore, only Stackelberg mechanism may be considered as heterogeneous catalysis, whereas Frumkin mechanism has a homogeneous step.
For several decades, the influence of proton carriers on HER has been studied specifically on dropping mercury electrode given that the surface of this kind of electrode is perfectly reproducible, and the overpotential for HER is significant. However, from practical standpoint, metals displaying higher over-potential for HER are improper as cathodes in water electrolysis. In this circumstance, for some time past studies on
catalytic effect of organic bases like amines have been extended on metals with lower over-potential for HER. Systematic studies started with the effect of benzylamine (BA) on HER on copper [13]. Further, studies embraced various aromatic amines: aniline (A), N-methylaniline (MA), N-ethylaniline (EA), N,N-dimethylaniline (DMA), N,N-diethylaniline (DEA), 2-toluidine (oT), 3-toluidine (mT) and 4-toluidine (pT) at low current densities [14], and also at high current densities similar with those applied in commercial water electrolysers [15].
The volcano curve for HER shows that the strength of Au-H bond is close to that of Fe-, Ni- and Co-H bonds, and consequently Au should present a similar effect on the recombination of hydrogen atoms like iron group metals [16]. It offers the possibility to use Au in order to develop a bifunctional catalyst for HER in acid media. That's why, the effect of methylamine (MAm), aniline (A) and 4-chloroaniline (PCA) as proton carriers has been studied conformably to gold [17]. The most interesting results, taking into account practical insights, have been obtained on platinum, using BA and A [18].
KINETICS OF HER CATALYZED BY PROTON CARRIERS
As a rule, the rate determining step in the cathodic HER is the charge transfer, even at higher current densities. In this circumstance, parameters that characterize the kinetics of the cathodic process are the exchange current density io and cathodic transfer coefficient 1- a, usually determined by Tafel slope method. Useful information about the kinetics of cathodic HER may be obtained by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). Experimental data provided by EIS provide directly charge transfer resistance Rct, which is a function of over-potential, cathodic transfer coefficient and exchange current density.
Results obtained on Cu, Au and Pt, in 0.5 M H2SO4 in the absence/presence of amines (10-4 M) are shown in Table 1 [13,14,17-20].
According to Table 1 results, it transpires that in the presence of proton carriers the values of 1-a decrease. This may be explained as being due to the fact that 1-a is a measure of coordinates that characterize the activated complex at metal - solution interface. The decrease of the 1-a is unfavorable for the kinetics of electrode process, according to Butler-Volmer equation, however, this effect is offset by significant rise
in the exchange current density io.
Data presented in Table 1 show that the catalytic effect of examined amines depends essentially on their molecular structure, following which molecular parameters of protonated amines have been identified (Table 2) [13,15, 18,20]. Quantum calculations were carried out in order to evaluate molecular volume and dipole moment, as well as coverage surface and frontier orbital energy (highest occupied molecular orbital - HOMO and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital -LUMO). For this purpose, GAUSIAN 09 package was used [21, 22].
The coverage area of methyl ammonium is the smallest, and consequently much greater is the number of these ions to be adsorbed on the electrode. This fact gives weight to higher concentrations of protons at the interface metal-electrolyte solution, and as a result, higher exchange current density. Even if coverage area of AH+ and PCAH+ is very close, io in the presence of PCAH+ is higher than in the presence of AN+, because Cl atom has an electron-withdrawing inductive effect which produces a supplementary charge separation. As a result, the dipole moment for PCAH+ is larger together with higher ordered orientation of PCAH+ [18].
Table 1. Kinetic parameters of HER.
Proton carrier Cathode 1-a io[A m-2] ^ct-104 [Q m2] Overpotential [V] Reference
Blank Cu 0.64 2.0110-5 47.2 -0.75 14, 19
BA Cu 0.43 (10-2 M) 1.7810-2 5.7 -0.50 13, 19
A Cu 0.48 2.8510-3 23,6 -0.50 14, 19
MA Cu 0.56 6.5310-4 33.7 -0.50 14, 19
EA Cu 0.58 6.8010-4 32.5 -0.50 14, 19
DMA Cu 0.58 7.6310-4 31.1 -0.50 14, 19
DEA Cu 0.46 1.9110-3 28.2 -0.50 14, 19
oT Cu 0.50 2.7010-3 27.4 -0.50 14, 19
mT Cu 0.50 2.8110-3 24.8 -0.50 14, 19
pT Cu 0.51 1.5110-3 30.2 -0.50 14, 19
Blank Au 0.52 0.29 52.3 -0.20 17, 20
A Au 0.44 8.00 7.5 -0.20 17, 20
MAm Au 0.37 33.3 0.6 -0.20 17, 20
PCA Au 0.41 20.5 3.4 -0.20 17, 20
Blank Pt 0.68 2.98 0.43 -0.25 18, 20
A Pt 0.54 (10-2 M) 67.6 2.58 -0.25 18, 20
BA Pt 0.57(10-2 M) 22.9 2.35 -0.25 18, 20
Table 2. Molecular parameters of protonated amines.
Protonated Molecular Dipole Molecular HOMO -LUMO Reference
amine volume [Â3] moment [D] coverage [Â2] [eV]
AH+ 95.3 7.12 30.9 -6.3 18, 20
BAH+ 106.8 9.85 51.5 -5.8 13
MAmH+ 36.1 2.22 21.5 -11.3 18, 20
PCAH+ 108.6 12.3 30.9 -5.7 18, 20
MAH+ 109.6 6.32 45.0 -6.5 15
DMAH+ 129.8 5.3 58.5 -6.6 15
Another fact that has to be taken into account with weak physical adsorption [15].
when revealing the electrode reaction Results presented above suggest an
mechanism is the Gibbs free energy of improved mechanism derived from
adsorption Gads. For example, in case of DMA, Stackelberg one [18]:
Gads calculated from Langmuir adsorption In the first step, ammonium is formed
isotherm is about -10 kJ mol-1. This value is by amine protonation in the bulk of solution:
consistent
H2N-X (aq) + H3O+(aq) ^ H3N+-X(aq) + H2O (7)
In the electrolyte solution, ammonium ions migrate towards cathode, where they are adsorbed on the metal surface together with
nitrogen atoms oriented toward the metal surface, according to the dipole moment. That means the best position for the charge transfer process:
(8)
H3N+-X(aq) ^ H3N+-X(ads)
Due to the adsorption process, a higher concentration of ammonium ions is achieved. In these conditions, at low current densities,
the hydrogen over potential is low and the charge transfer occurs according to the reaction:
H3N+-X(ads) + e- ^ H(ads) + HN-X(ads) (9)
The recombination step of HER could occur chemically [Tafel step (10)] or electrochemically [Heyrovsky step (11)]:
2H(ads) ^ H2(ads) (10)
H3N+-X(ads) + H(ads) + e- ^ H2(ads) + HN-X(ads) (11)
At higher current densities (high over potential), hydronium ions discharge becomes possible:
H3O+(ads) + e- ^ H(ads) + H2O (12)
followed by Tafel (10) or Heyrovsky desorption (13):
H(ads) + H3O+(ads) + e- ^ H2(ads) + H2O (13)
As a consequence, the hydronium ions values that allows hydrolysis of ammonium
discharge is characterized by local pH rise in ions: the solution adjacent to the cathode up to
H3N+-X(ads) + H2O ^ HN-X(ads) + H3O+(ads) (14)
This reaction helps to keep up high solution where the re-protonation reaction (11)
values of hydronium ions concentration. Note occurs. that neutral amines diffuse into the bulk
CONCLUSIONS
The catalytic effect of some protonated amines on HER has been compared through the use of kinetic parameters of the electrode process 1-a and io. The presence of protonated amines in the electrolyte solution predetermines a decrease of 1-a; however, this unfavorable effect is offset by essential growth of io. Thereby, an overall result of proton
carriers' effect is the diminution of hydrogen over-potential. The catalytic function of amines might be associated with molecular parameters of protonated amines, following which the dipole moment and coverage surface are instrumental in the process. Proceeding from the results above, an improved mechanism has been suggested.
REFERENCES
1. Press RJ, Santhanam KSV, Massoud JM, Bailey AV, Takacs GA. Introduction to Hydrogen Technology. John Wiley, Hoboken, New Jersey, 2009, p. 196.
2. Zuttel A, Borgschulte, Schlapbach L. Hydrogen as a Future Energy Carrier. Wiley-VCH Verlag,Weinheim - Germany, 2008, p. 154.
3. Mairanovskii SG. Theory of catalytic hydrogen waves. JElectroanal Chem. 1963, 6, 77-118.
4. Heyrovsky M. Research topic - catalysis of hydrogen evolution. Croat ChemActa. 2006, 79, 1-4.
5. Palacek E, Scheller F, Wang J. Electrochemistry of nucleic acids and proteins. Vol. 1, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 205, 657.
6. Zivanovic M, Aleksic M, Ostatna V, Doneux T, Palecek E.Polylysine-Catalyzed Hydrogen Evolution at Mercury Electrodes. Electroanalysis. 2010, 22, 2064-2070.
7. Heyrovsky M. Early polarographic studies on proteins..Electroanalysis, 2004, 16,1067-73.
8. Tamamushi R, Tanaka K. Effect of methylviologen on the hydrogen evolution at mercury electrodes in aqueous buffer solutions. J Electroanal Chem. 1987, 230, 177-188.
9. Frumkin AN. Advances in Electrochemistry and Electrochemical Engineering. Vol. 3, Interscience, New York, 1963, 65.
10. StackelbergM, Fassbender H. Undersuchungenzur Katalyse der Wasserstoffabscheidung. I. Allgemeine Untersuchungen. Z Elektrochem. 1958, 62, 834-838.
11. Stackelberg M, Hans W, Jensch W. Undersuchungenzur Katalyse der Wasser-stoffabscheidung. II. Die konstitutionellen Vorausstezungen. Z Elektrochem. 1958, 62, 839-845.
12. Mairanovskii SG. Theory of catalytic hydrogen waves in polarography. Russ Chem Rev. 1964, 33, 38-55.
13.Vaduva CC, Vaszilcsin N, Kellenberger A, Medeleanu M.Catalytic enhancement of HER on copper in the presence of benzylamine. Int J Hydrogen Energy. 2011, 36, 6994-7001.
14.Väduva CC, Vaszilcsin N, Kellenberger A. Aromatic amines as proton-carriers for catalytic enhancement of hydrogen evolution reaction on copper in acid solutions. Int J Hydrogen Energy. 2012, 37,12089-12096.
15. Jakab A, Vaszilcsin N, Manea F, Dan M. Effect of amines as proton vectors on catalytic
evolution reaction on copper. Studia UBB Chemia. 2015, 60, 63-76.
16. Trasatti S. Work function, electronegativity, and electrochemical behavior of metals.
JElectroanal Chem. 1972, 39, 163-176.
17. Cretu R, Kellenberger A, Vaszilcsin N. Cathodic hydrogen evolution reaction on gold catalyzed by proton carriers. Int J Hydrogen Energy. 2013, 38, 11685-11694.
18. Cretu R, Kellenberger A, Medeleanu M, Vaszilcsin N. Enhancement of HER on Pt by proton carriers. Int JElectrochem Sci. 2014, 9, 4465-4477.
19. Vaduva CC. Influence of some amines on
the kinetics of the cathodic copper deposition and hydrogen evolution reactio. PhD Thesis, University Politehnica Timisoara - Romania, 2013, p. 99.
20. Cretu R. Enhancement of the cathodic hydrogen evolution reaction by proton carriers catalysis. PhD Thesis, University Politehnica Timisoara - Romania, 2015, p. 43, 68.
21. Frisch MJ, Trucks GW, Schlegel HB, Scuseria GE, Robb MA et al. GAUSIAN 09, Revision B.01 GAUSIAN, Wallington, 2010.
22. Ciubotariu D, Medeleanu M, Iorga I, Derety E, Bologa C, Muresan S. Chem Bull Univ Timisoara. 1993, 38, 83-92.
ИНТЕНСИФИКАЦИЯ РЕАКЦИИ КАТОДНОГО ВЫДЕЛЕНИЯ ВОДОРОДА С ИСПОЛЬЗОВАНИЕМ ПЕРЕНОСЧИКОВ ПРОТОНА (КРАТКИЙ ОБЗОР)
Н.Василчын, А.Келленбергер, М.Медельяну
Тимишоарский политехнический университет, Факультет индустриальной химш и технической экологии, 300006 Пл. Викториеи, Тимишоара, Румыния mcolae.vaszilcsm@,upt. гр
Статья является кратким обзором работ по интенсификации реакции выделения водорода с использованием переносчиков протона. Представлены результаты, полученные при изучении каталитического эффекта аминов на упомянутую реакцию. Наилучшие результаты были получены на Pt в 0.5 МH2SO4 с использованием анилина как переносчика протона. В этом случае наблюдалось увеличение плотности тока обмена ¡а, с 2.9 Ат-2 до 67.6 Ат-2в H2SO4 в присутствии 10-2М анилина. В то же время значения адсорбционной энергии Гиббса показывают, что переносчики протона адсорбируются на поверхности металла с помощью слабых физических связей. Как правило, наблюдаются корреляции между каталитическим эффектом и молекулярными параметрами переносчиков протона.
Ключевые слова: выделение водорода, переносчики протона, анилин, каталитический эффект, электрокатализ
Поступила в редакцию 29.10.2016.
