CC BY
0ECONOMIC IMPACT OF 9/11 ON CULTURAL HERITAGE TOURISM OF TAXILA
VALLEY
*Muhammad Sohaib Khaliq, 2Dur E Shahwar https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.11098668
Abstract. Cultural heritage tourism has been a significant source of revenue for the region, attracting both domestic and international tourists which should be Sustainable tourism on the basis of the balance between multiple capabilities like environment, economy and social culture and political condition a country.
The research question is analyzing economic impacts ofpre and post 9/11 horrible attack on cultural heritage tourism in Taxila valley. However, the events of 9/11 had a significant impact on the tourism industry, particularly in countries with predominantly Muslim populations. The study examines the pre- and post-9/11 impact on cultural heritage tourism in the Taxila Valley. The Taxila Valley, located in the Punjab province of Pakistan, is a UNESCO World Heritage Site that is home to several ancient Buddhist archaeological sites and monuments dating back to the Gandhara period.
The study analyzes tourist arrivals, revenue generated, and the perception of tourists towards the security situation in the region. The findings indicate that the number of tourists visiting the Taxila Valley decreased significantly after 9/11, particularly from western countries. However, there was an increase in domestic tourism, which partially offset the decline in international arrivals. Additionally; the study found that the revenue generated from cultural heritage tourism also decreased after 9/11. The study also highlights the important capabilities e.g., infrastructure, accessibility, awareness their impact on tourist perception. The perception of these capabilities and issues, in the region was negatively affected after 9/11, but improved over time due to the implementation of security measures by the government.
Overall, the study suggests that while the events of 9/11 had a significant impact on cultural heritage tourism in the Taxila Valley, the region has shown resilience and has been able to recover partially due to the increase in domestic tourism. However, there is a need for continued investment in security measures to improve the perception of tourists and attract more international visitors to the region.
Keywords: 9/11, Economic impacts, cultural heritage tourism, ancient archaeological sites, Taxila valley.
Introduction
Tourism is often seen as a universal phenomenon with an almost unfathomably immense infrastructure (BONHAM, 2006).Tourism is an important economic sector in many countries. It often is described as perishable industry in that demand for travel is highly vulnerable to many tragedies, hazards and uneven situations such as wars, outbreaks of deadly infectious diseases e.g. COVID 19, political conditions or terrorism, economic fluctuations, currency instability, energy crises, and many more. When people travel, they do not want to be bare to individual hazards, so safety is a primary concern of most travelers (Coshall, 2005). Not unexpectedly, terrorism and other threats to individual safety—whether they are natural disasters or fatal infectious diseases are reducing people's partiality to travel. A number of major events have had significant negative impacts on international travel and tourism during the terrorist attacks of September
In the detailed exploration of the impact of the September 11, 2001 (9/11) terrorist attacks on the global tourism industry, it is important to consider various scholarly perspectives and empirical studies. The World Tourism Organization (WTO) has long recognized the significance of tourism as a crucial economic driver for countries, highlighting its ability to bolster economies and create a welcoming environment for tourists (Rezvi, 2013). In the context of Pakistan, a nation celebrated for its diverse landscapes and rich historical tapestry, the cultural heritage sites represent a key element in the attraction and development of tourism (Sofronov, 2018). The intricate relationship between tourism and economic growth is a topic of considerable study, particularly within the paradigms of sustainable and developing economies (Rezvi, 2013). The tourism industry is acknowledged for its profound influence on the global economy, where it has emerged as a dynamic sector with rapidly growing activities in each country, garnering the attention of stakeholders and policymakers alike (Khan, 2022; WTO). The literature affirms a robust linkage between cultural heritage tourism and economic development, identifying tourism as a multifaceted global system designed to cater to the travel desires of individuals and groups (Gyr, 2010).
From the ancient civilizations to contemporary societies, tourism has evolved through various forms and practices. It has become a primary economic generator, serving as a powerful tool in the national economic arsenal. With this backdrop, the present study aims to scrutinize the specific effects of the 9/11 attacks on cultural heritage tourism in the Taxila Valley, a site of significant historical and archaeological importance in Pakistan (Gyr, 2010). Blunk's (2005) work on the societal ramifications of 9/11 underscores the profound shifts in not only security and politics but also cultural dynamics that inevitably influence tourism patterns. This assertion is corroborated by the World Tourism Organization's assessment of the terrorism event's extensive economic repercussions. The literature by Rezvi (2013) elaborates on the vital role of inbound and outbound tourism in bolstering a country's economy, affirming the centrality of tourism to economic strength and societal wellbeing. The scholarly discourse by Ahmed (2004) and coverage by Paknews (2005) highlight Pakistan's natural beauty and cultural depth, featuring mountains, deserts, and the remnants of ancient civilizations. Such attributes, particularly the cultural heritage sites, play a pivotal role in the promotion of tourism. Similarly, Sofronov's (2018) research emphasizes the significant contribution of cultural heritage to the development of tourism, suggesting that these sites are not just attractions but are integral to the broader tourism-driven economic development.
Given the extensive discourse on the relationship between tourism and economic development, it is evident that the 9/11 attacks had a significant impact, altering the course of tourism and thereby affecting the economies reliant on this sector. The decline in foreign visitors to Taxila post-9/11, as reflected in the visitor statistics, speaks volumes about the magnitude of the event's influence. The aforementioned studies present a cohesive narrative that portrays tourism as a delicate industry susceptible to global events, with cultural heritage sites like those in Taxila being particularly vulnerable to shifts in international travel behaviors and perceptions.
Research Questions:
How did the number of domestic and international tourists visiting the cultural heritage sites of Taxila valley change quantitatively before and after 9/11, terrorist attacks, and what were the economic consequences of these changes on the local tourism industry?
This study posed is concerned with the quantitative changes in domestic and international tourist flows to the cultural heritage sites of Taxila valley Pakistan, specifically in relation to the
temporal landmark of the 9/11 terrorist attacks. The inquiry seeks to delineate the pattern of visitation numbers, discerning any notable fluctuations that correlate with the occurrence of 9/11 and its aftermath. It is a question that aims to uncover not only the immediate impact of such a global event on local tourism but also to trace the potential long-term shifts that may have transpired in the wake of the attacks.
So, the aim of this study is dual-fold. First, it endeavors to measure the statistical variations in tourist attendance at Taxila's ancient sites, thereby providing an empirical account of how global events can reverberate through the tourism sector on a local scale. By analyzing data from before and after 9/11, the study intends to provide a clear comparative picture of the impact such an event can have on cultural tourism.
Second, the study aims to evaluate the economic repercussions these changes in tourist numbers have had on the local tourism industry of Taxila. This includes assessing factors such as revenue generated from tourism, employment opportunities within the sector, and the broader economic contribution of tourism to the region's economy. The intent is to contribute a nuanced understanding of how international crises affect local economies, particularly those heavily reliant on cultural tourism, and to potentially inform policy and strategic responses for future resilience.
Literature Review
The historical tapestry of tourism weaves back to the origins of leisure travel in ancient Rome, nearly 2,000 years ago. Ismagilova (2015) captures the essence of early Roman vacations, as citizens sought scenic landscapes, seashore retreats, and the novel experience of cruise trips. The flourishing of these activities under Roman patronage is further discussed by Spatt (1979), who illustrates the burgeoning industry's efforts to serve and facilitate a growing clientele of travelers. This period marked the inception of tourism as a social phenomenon, setting a precedent for subsequent European initiatives to ensure safe and sustainable tourism that would underpin economic, social, and environmental stability, as elaborated by AMérida AA (2016).
Further tracing the roots of travel for pleasure and education, evidence of similar practices was also prominent in Egypt under the pharaohs, where travel was pursued for leisure, experience, and relaxation, according to Curiel, J. d. (n.d.). Visitors of the time were drawn to monumental testaments of ancient Egyptian culture, such as the Pyramid of Sakkara, the Sphinx, and the Great Pyramids of Gizeh, as recorded in the UNWTO World Tourism Barometer (June 2008). These sites, constructed a millennium earlier, continue to draw crowds, affirming the enduring allure of cultural heritage. The mid-19th century innovation of organized group holidays, offering an all-inclusive price that significantly reduced travelers' costs, marked the genesis of commercialized mass tourism (Geschichte, 2007). Thomas Cook, hailed as the innovator of this model, transformed the tourism landscape, enabling more people to participate in travel. By 2017, the travel and tourism sector accounted for a remarkable 10.4% of global GDP, highlighting the sector's significant economic footprint and its ability to outperform all other major economic sectors, as reported by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO, 2018).
Historically, the tourism studies landscape has predominantly been inclined towards the 'natural' environment and cultural tourism. Urry (1996) scrutinizes this focus, suggesting that perceptions of nature are culturally conditioned. This critical viewpoint opens up a discourse on how the traditional separation of nature and culture is not as clear-cut as once thought. Traditional cultures often view nature and culture as a single entity, a perspective that has evolved over time in Western societies, as illustrated by Yi-Fu Tuan (1974) and further discussed by Aas (2005),
who notes the transition from a broad interpretation of nature to a more nuanced understanding that encompasses barren landscapes and rural countrysides.
Heritage tourism has become a vital industry, providing a lucrative avenue for both developed and developing economies, reinforcing Prentice's (1993) assertion of tourism's influential role. Peterson (1994) further advocates for the prominence of heritage sites, emphasizing their historical significance across built, natural, and cultural dimensions. This synergy between heritage and tourism is underlined by the World Tourism Organization's figures, which demonstrate a modest yet significant increase of 9% in international tours by cultural visitors from 2011 to 2019 (WTO, 2019). These numbers reflect the growing appeal of cultural heritage as an integral component of the global tourism market, asserting the sector's role as a driving force in the contemporary economy.
Terrorism (9/11) & Tourism
Terrorism, which has affected many countries since the 9/11 attack at the beginning of the new millennium, is a global challenge. Terrorism has affected both advanced economies and developing economies. Assessing the economic cost of terrorism is a very difficult exercise. The terrorist attacks have imposed a number of significant costs on individuals, societies and the State, and have thereby substantially changed the economic and social structure of the country. (ali, 2017).when we go through a historical review some of biggest authors worked on terrorism such as Keynes (1919), Pigou (1940) and Robbins (1942) they have already discussed the role of war, peace, and disputes in the economy. After the 9/11 incident, terrorism has received more attention amid economists (HESS, 2004) According to the "Prospect Theory" (Kahneman, 1992), tourists are rational consumers who, when confronted with two different options, tend to choose the option that will bring them more potential gains and lower risk (Cláudia Seabra, 2018). When tourists perceive the existence of any risk of terrorism, they become more careful as they plan their travel and tend to adopt risk-reducing strategies. Markets are increasingly global due to a combination of economic, socio-cultural, political, and technological factors (Jorge E, 2008). On 11 September 2001, 19 terrorists on a suicide mission took over control of 4 passenger airplanes and used it as bombs on several targets in the United States (Lee, 2005). Two of the airplanes were used in an attack on the "Twin Towers" of the World Trade Center in New York. This terrorist attack has exerted different impacts on the countries directly affected, on neighboring countries and regions, and on the global tourism market (CARL BONHAM, 2006). Terrorist attacks can have major negative effects on economic performance but measuring this impact with any degree of certainty is inherently challenging (Mario Arturo Ruiz Estrada, 2015). In the exploration of terrorism's profound impact on tourism, particularly focusing on Pakistan's cultural heritage sites, it is essential to delve deeper into the various dimensions that contribute to broader societal repercussions. Terrorism not only fosters poverty by destabilizing regions economically, but it also cultivates socio-cultural instability and environmental disruptions, leading to long-term detrimental effects on tourism.
This paper expands on the comparative analysis of pre and post-9/11 scenarios to assess how terrorism has reshaped the perception and viability of tourism in Pakistan. Specifically, the paper investigates changes in tourist inflow, the economic contributions of tourism, and shifts in local and international perceptions of safety and cultural value. The economic impact is particularly significant, with declines in tourism revenue affecting everything from local businesses to national infrastructure projects. Furthermore, increased security costs and reduced
foreign investment compound the financial strain, emphasizing the need for robust economic strategies to counteract these effects.
History of Taxila Valley
The Taxila valley holds a special place in history because of its strategic location at the crossroads of civilizations, cultures, and trade routes. This has made it a significant area of interest for both regional and international powers throughout ancient times (khan, 2019). The Taxila Valley was an important part of the Silk Road, which connected China to the Punjab region and further to mainland India and the Arabian Sea (Mehmet SOMUNCU, 2016). This further elevated its importance and made it a hub for trade and cultural exchange. In addition to its role in trade, Taxila was renowned for its educational institutions and was home to prestigious universities like the famous Jaulian Monastic Complex.l (khan, 2019).
Taxila, an ancient city, is referred to by different spellings in various historical texts. In the puranic verses, it is spelled as Takhasila or Takshasila in the Prakrit epigraphs. However, in the Besnagar inscriptions by the Greek ambassador Helidorus, the city's name is spelled as Takkhasila (Dani, 1999) .
In Sanskrit, the term "Taksha" signifies "to cut" or "split," while "sila" translates to "stone," "rock," or "hill." Combining these two words, "Taksha sila" can be interpreted as "City of cut stones" or "City of split rocks." (Marshal, 1960). Taxila was the first kingdom that Alexander opposed after crossing the Hindu Kush Mountains in 327 BCE (khan, 2019). Taxila has changed hands many times over the centuries, with many empires competing for its control. Its history is twisted to an extent that only a simplified version is presented here (Marshal, 1960) . The realistic Chinese pilgrims credited the name Tathagata, Xuanzang's accounts (Lee D. H., 2008): 'this is the place where Tathagata officially dwelled when he was practicing the discipline of Bodhisattva; he was then the king of a great country and was called Chenta-lo-po-la-po (Chandraprabha); he cut off his head, earnestly seeking the acquirement of Bodhi' (Beal S, 1884). Xuanzang gives a glowing account of the fertility of the valley 'the land is renowned for its fertility and produces rich harvest. It is full of streams and fountains; Flowers and fruits are abundant and The climate is agreeably temperate.
Cultural Heritage sites in Taxila Valley
Taxila is a renowned tourist spot in Pakistan known for its rich archaeological significance. This ancient site showcases a blend of Persian, Greek, and Asian influences, reflecting its historical importance as a hub for various civilizations (Coshall, 2005). The extensive ruins of Taxila comprise diverse elements such as a Mesolithic Cave, multiple settlement sites, Buddhist monasteries, and medieval Muslim mosques and madrasas. Positioned strategically at the intersection of three major trading routes, Taxila served as a significant center for Buddhist learning from the 5th century BC to the 2nd century AD. Recognizing its cultural value, UNESCO declared Taxila a World Heritage site with multiple locations in 1980 based on its cultural significance.
Taxila, an ancient city in the Indian subcontinent, holds the distinction of being one of the oldest continuously inhabited cities in the region (The historic city of Taxila , 1986).The ruins of Taxila cover a vast area and include various structures such as city buildings and Buddhist stupas.
These remnants are divided into three main cities (Fussman, 1993), each belonging to a different time period. The oldest among them is Bhir Mound, dating back to the 6th century BCE AH(2010). The second city, known as Sitka, was constructed by Greco-Bactrian kings in the
second century B.C. The third and final city, Sirsukh, is associated with the Kushan kings (Coshall, 2005)..
Apart from the city ruins, the Taxila region is also home to several Buddhist monasteries and stupas. Among the notable ruins in this category are the stupa at Dharmarajika, the monastery at Jaulian, and the monastery at Mohra Muradu, along with several other stupas (Shakir 2021).
Source: Taxila Cultural Heritage sites map developed by author using GIS.
Heritage sites of Taxila valley
Pakistan, enriched with the profound legacies of the Indus Valley and Gandhara civilizations, holds a significant position in the realm of cultural tourism. The country's rich cultural heritage, nurtured by its historical diversity, presents a valuable opportunity for tourists, particularly those drawn to exploring cultural nuances. Among the numerous historic sites, Taxila stands out with its history dating back to over 8000 BC. Known locally as "Takshilal," Taxila is recognized for its substantial potential in cultural heritage tourism, yet remains underutilized. Moreover, Taxila serves as a vibrant hub for cultural events and exhibitions, supported by its educational institutions like Taxila UET and HITEC universities, as well as its museums and markets known for specialized crafts such as grinding stones and sculptures (Government of Punjab, 2021)..
D Despite these assets, Taxila's share in the overall Pakistan tourism market has seen a decline over the years. Data from the Pakistan Tourism Development Corporation (PTDC, 2018) shows that while the early 1990s saw a more robust contribution to the regional economy, recent trends indicate a need for revitalization. Between 2005 and 2007, Taxila showed promising growth, suggesting that with strategic development, it can leverage its cultural heritage to boost regional development and increase its market share in Pakistan's tourism industry (Khan & Ahmed, 2019). This approach not only promises economic benefits but also ensures the preservation and promotion of Pakistan's rich cultural tapestry for future generations.
Methodology
This research delves into the dynamics shaping the tourism industry in Pakistan, with a specific focus on the historical and cultural heritage site of Taxila valley Pakistan. The study covers a significant timeframe from 1995 to 2010, a period punctuated by global and local upheavals such as the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, subsequent geopolitical tensions, and the worldwide
financial crisis. These events have had profound impacts on global travel patterns and perceptions of security, which are critical to understanding shifts in tourism dynamics.
The methodology of this study is rooted in a quantitative approach, utilizing time-series analysis and co-relation test of the data collected from the Statistical Bureau Department & the Taxila Museum in Pakistan. This data compilation includes the number of domestic and international visitors to Taxila, categorized under cultural tourism, aiming to explore the direct impact of socio-political events on tourism flows to cultural heritage sites.
Taxila, known for its rich archaeological sites like the Dharmarajika Stupa, Sirkap, Julian Monastery, and the central Taxila Museum, offers a unique vantage point to analyze shifts in cultural tourism. The study specifically aims to dissect the volume of both domestic and international tourists visiting these sites before and after the pivotal event of 9/11, providing a clear comparative analysis of the economic and socio-cultural consequences on the region's tourism industry. By examining this data, the research aspires to map out trends and trajectories in the tourism sector specific to heritage sites, providing insights into the growth and decline in tourist numbers over the specified years. This analysis not only aids in understanding the direct effects of global crises on localized tourism industries but also enhances the comprehension of the broader economic contributions of heritage tourism under fluctuating global conditions. Statistical data analysis Summary statistics
Variable Mean Std. Min. Median Max.
Pakistani 57273 23711.91 5044 64190 80295
Foreigners 7798 5530.729 1091 7087 20525
The statistical analysis of tourist visits to Taxila, segmented into Pakistani and foreign visitors, offers insightful observations into the patterns and dynamics of tourism at this cultural heritage site. For Pakistani tourists, the average number of visitors stands at 57,273, with a considerable standard deviation of 23,711.91, indicating substantial variability in the number of visitors. This variability may stem from seasonal trends, special cultural events, or fluctuating travel conditions within the country. The minimum observed value of 5,044 suggests lower visitation during off-peak times or in response to disruptive events, while the maximum of 80,295 points to peak periods likely coinciding with holidays or festivals that draw significant domestic interest. The median value, at 64,190, confirms that more than half of the observed periods had visitor counts above this number, emphasizing a generally high domestic turnout.
In contrast, the figures for foreign tourists are markedly lower, with an average visitation of 7,798 and a standard deviation of 5,530.729, reflecting a broad dispersion in the data likely influenced by international factors such as visa regulations, global economic conditions, or international awareness of Taxila as a travel destination. The minimum number of foreign visitors recorded is 1,091, indicating very low international turnout during certain periods, which could be due to external travel advisories or limited flight availability. The maximum number observed, 20,525, may occur during special promotional periods or when international travel conditions are favorable. The median of 7,087, being less than the mean, suggests that the data is skewed with many reporting periods attracting fewer than the average number of foreign visitors.
Overall, the statistical model reveals a robust domestic interest in Taxila contrasted with more fluctuating and generally lower foreign visitation numbers. These insights underline the
potential need for strategies aimed at boosting international tourism, possibly through improved marketing abroad and enhanced accessibility to the heritage sites.
visitors statistrics
90000
80295 79857
Years
-pakistani -foreigners
The line graph provided illustrates the visitation statistics of Taxila over a span of 16 years, from 1995 to 2010, differentiating between Pakistani and foreign visitors. Observing the trend for Pakistani visitors, there is a pronounced fluctuation in numbers throughout the years. The peak visitation for Pakistanis is noted in the year 2000, with close to 80,000 visitors, while the lowest is in 2008, with slightly above 30,000 visitors. There appears to be a cycle of rise and fall in domestic visitation numbers, with notable peaks roughly every four to five years (e.g., a rise leading up to 2000, a smaller peak around 2004, and then again in 2010). This could suggest a pattern influenced by domestic factors such as economic conditions, security situations, and possibly the popularity of the site which may be enhanced through national promotions or significant anniversaries.
For foreign visitors, the graph shows a different pattern, with the highest number of visitors recorded in 1995 at approximately 7,798 and a sharp decline thereafter. The lowest point is in 2008, with a count of 1,091 visitors, possibly indicative of the impact of global events such as the financial crisis or security concerns. After 2001, foreign visitation shows a dramatic drop, aligning with global travel trends post-9/11, which affected many countries' tourism industries due to increased security measures and travelers' concerns. Post-2001, there is no significant recovery to pre-2001 levels, suggesting a long-term impact on international tourism to Pakistan. The data for foreign visitors shows lesser variability in comparison to Pakistani visitors but remains significantly lower overall. Notably, after the year 2001, there is a persistent downward trend, with minor fluctuations that do not seem to return to the pre-2001 figures. This persistent decline may highlight challenges in attracting international tourists, potentially due to external perceptions of the region or competitive pressures from other historical sites globally.
In comparison, the number of Pakistani visitors, despite fluctuations, generally maintains higher numbers, indicating a sustained domestic interest in Taxila's cultural heritage. The years following 2001 do not seem to deter Pakistani visitors as much, with a relatively quick rebound in the following years. Overall, the graph narrates the story of a tourism sector that is resilient domestically but shows vulnerability to international influences. The disparity between domestic and international visitor trends over these 16 years underscores the importance of addressing the factors that may be discouraging foreign tourism and leveraging the sustained interest of domestic tourists to bolster the industry.
Correlations
Pakistani foreigners
Pakistani Pearson Correlation 1 .298
Sig. (2-tailed) .262
N 16 16
foreigners Pearson Correlation .298 1
Sig. (2-tailed) .262
N 16 16
The correlation test presented in the data analyzes the relationship between the number of Pakistani visitors and foreign visitors to Taxila over the period of 1995 to 2010. The Pearson Correlation Coefficient is a measure of the linear correlation between two variables, in this case, the two different visitor groups. The coefficient has a value between +1 and -1, where 1 is total positive linear correlation, 0 is no linear correlation, and -1 is total negative linear correlation.
Interpretation of Correlation Coefficient:
• Pearson Correlation (Pakistani and Foreigners): The coefficient value of .298 suggests a weak positive correlation between the number of Pakistani visitors and foreign visitors. This implies that there is a slight tendency that as the number of Pakistani visitors increases, the number of foreign visitors also increases, but the relationship is not strong.
Significance Level:
• Sig. (2-tailed) for Pakistani and Foreigners: The significance value, or p-value, is .262, which exceeds the conventional threshold of .05 for statistical significance. In academic research, a p-value less than .05 typically indicates that the observed correlation is statistically significant and not due to random chance. Therefore, a p-value of .262 suggests that the correlation between the number of Pakistani visitors and foreign visitors is not statistically significant. In other words, based on this data, we cannot confidently assert that the correlation observed is not due to random variation in the sample.
Sample Size:
• N (Sample Size): The sample size for both groups is 16, indicating that 16 years of data were included in the analysis. This is a relatively small sample size, which can limit the reliability of the correlation analysis.
Impact of 9/11 as Seen Through the Graph:
When looking at the line graph and considering the timeline of events, there is a noticeable decline in the number of foreign visitors after the year 2001, the year of the 9/11 terrorist attacks. This decline suggests that the 9/11 attacks and the subsequent geopolitical and security concerns may have had a chilling effect on international tourism to Pakistan, and particularly to Taxila. The drop in foreign visitors is not immediately mirrored by a similar decline in the number of Pakistani visitors, which indicates a divergence in the impact of these events on domestic versus international tourism. The resilience in domestic tourism could be due to a number of factors, including a stronger propensity for domestic travelers to visit cultural sites within their own country despite global events.
The statistical analysis does not find a significant correlation between the numbers of domestic and international tourists visiting Taxila from 1995 to 2010. While there is a weak positive relationship, the lack of statistical significance suggests that the two variables do not strongly affect each other within this time frame. Furthermore, the context of the 9/11 attacks offers an important historical point that appears to have had a significant and lasting impact on the pattern of foreign visitors to Taxila, which is not reflected in the domestic visitation data. This aspect could be explored further in a comprehensive study that includes qualitative data or additional variables that could affect tourism, such as marketing efforts, security measures, visa policies, and international perceptions of safety in Pakistan.
Conclusion
A study of the 9/11 economic effect on the cultural heritage tourism of Taxila Valley reveals that both short-term and long-term impacts are experienced in the region. Before the onslaughts, Taxila with a human face was one of the major archaeological and cultural sites that attracted a large number of international tourists, thus contributing very highly to the economies at local and regional levels. Post 9/11, however, one can notice a huge drop in those numbers— mainly from Western countries, given increased security and global travel apprehensions. Interesting to note is that this drop was softened, to some extent, by a rise in local tourism. What this shows is a shift in the local tourism market toward the realization of national visitors. Nonetheless, the total revenue from cultural heritage tourism still recorded a decline, meaning that the increase in domestic tourism was not just enough to offset the lost international tourists who spend much more. The article elaborates that "the tourism of Taxila Valley is resilient in global crises.". The appeal of the region among international tourists has started to reinstall, following all government initiatives, gradual recovery, and improved security situation.
But this recovery also underscores the importance of continued investment in the security, infrastructure, and marketing to improve both the perception and reality of Taxila as a safe and attractive destination for global tourists. In conclusion, though the impact on Taxila's international tourism flows was huge, due to 9/11, the region's cultural heritage tourism has shown some level of resiliency. While the shift to domestic tourism has, to some extent, saved the industry in the face of international tourism collapse, the full potential of the tourism industry in Taxila can only be materialized with added security measures and by increasing promotional efforts with diversity to lure a range of tourists from all walks of life.
In fact, the future tourism industry of Taxila will be strategic and responsive to being able to offer changing global conditions and take its right position among few world-class cultural heritage destinations. This conclusion reminds one of the complexities involved in the
management of cultural heritage tourism in areas affected by global geopolitical events and points to this need for adaptive strategies within the tourism industry in very strong signals. Limitations and Future Research
The study conducted on the economic impact of 9/11 attacks with reference to cultural he ritage tourism in Taxila Valley unfolds various limitations and scope for further research. The ma in shortcoming of this concept is that it focuses only on quantifiable economic indicators such as tourist arrivals and income, while completely ignoring other qualitative elements, for instance, to urist satisfaction and cultural exchange. Above all, this study has mainly looked at the impacts fr om an economic point of view without making too much of a plunge into the study of the socio-p olitical changes that might have affected post-9/11 tourism attitudes and behavior, probably touch ing the tourists in a wider multi-angular way.
For considering such an approach in research for the specific topic, more broad-based qua litative data could be collected that, in a way, would present the overall picture of the impact on t he heritage tourism of the concerned country. It might focus on the social and psychological long -term impact of 9/11 for tourists from diverse cultural backgrounds. Moreover, the other outside c auses, such as the state of the world economy or geopolitical events taking place at the same time , might give a clue to their interplays with tourism trends. Further study into the effectiveness of t he security measures post-9/11 could allow evaluating how these have influenced perceptions by tourists on safety and hence their decisions to travel. Comparative studies with other regions, whi ch have similarly been affected by global incidents, would provide valuable benchmarks and less ons. Last but not least, continuous investment is to be made further for the up-gradation of infrast ructure and effective marketing strategies to help undoubtedly promote and enhance both domest ic and international tourism in Taxila Valley for the sustained growth and development of the reg ion's cultural heritage.
REFERENCES
1. Aas, C. L. (2005). . Stakeholder collaboration and heritage management. Annals of Tourism Research.
2. ali, A. (2017). ECONOMIC COST OF TERRORISM: A CASE STUDY OF PAKISTAN.
springer.
3. AMérida AA, G. (2016). Tourism-led growth revisited for Spain: Causality, business cycles and structural breaks. Journal of tourism research .
4. Beal S, S.-Y.-K. (1884). Buddhist Records of the Western World, translated from the Chinese of Hiuen Tsiang, AD 692. New Delhi: Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers, Pvt. Ltd.
5. Blunk. (2005). Evaluating the Long-Run Impacts of the 9/11 Terrorist Attacks on US Domestic Airline Travel. Applied Economics.
6. BONHAM, C. (2006). The Impact of 9/11 and Other Terrible Global Events on Tourism. Reseach gate.
7. CARL BONHAM, C. E. (2006). The Impact of 9/11 and Other Terrible Global Events on Tourism in the U.S. and Hawaii. Research Gate.
8. Cláudia Seabra, E. K. (2018). Peacefulness at home: impacts on international travel. International Journal of Tourism Cities.
9. Coshall, J. (2005). Interventions on UK Earnings and Expenditures. Annals of Torism Research.
10. Dani, A. H. (1986). The historic city of Taxila . Paris: UNESCO.
11. Dani, A. H. (1999). The Historic City of Taxila. Lahore: Sang-e-Meel Publications.
12. Fussman. (1993). Taxila: the central Asian Connection. In H. s. serinivasan, urban form and meaning in South Asia. Washington DC: National Gallery of Arts, Smithsonian.
13. HESS, S. B. (2004). THE MACROECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF TERRORISM. FISCAL POLICY, MACROECONOMICS AND GROWTH.
14. Ismagilova, G. (2015). Using historical heritage as a factor in tourism development. ELSEVIER.
15. Jorge E, A. &. (2008). The impact of terrorism on tourism demand. Annals of Tourism Research.
16. Kahneman, A. T. (1992). Advances in prospect theory: Cumulative representation of uncertainty. Springer.
17. khan, A. (2019). Fresh discoveries at the Buddhist Monastic Complex Badalpur, Taxila valley. In The Geography of Gandharan Art. summertown: Archaeopress Publishing Ltd.
18. Khan, N. U. (2022). Examining Factors That Influence the International Tourism in Pakistan and Its Nexus with Economic Growth: Evidence from ARDL Approach. Sustainability.
19. Lee, D. H. (2008). Xuanzang (Hsuan-tsang) (602—664). Intrnet Enyclopedia odphilosophy .
20. Lee, S. C. (2005). Estimating the Impact of the September 11 Terrorist Attacks on the US Air Transport Demand Using Intervention Analysis. Tourism Analysis.
21. Mario Arturo Ruiz Estrada, D. P. (2015). The economic impact of terrorism: A new model and its application to Pakistan. Journal of Policy Modeling.
22. Marshal, J. (1960). A Guide to Taxila. karachi: Department of Archaeology in Pakistan.
23. Mehmet SOMUNCU, A. A. (2016). Current Status of Management and Protection of Taxila World Heritage Site, Pakistan. journal of Asian Cevilization .
24. Sofronov, B. (2018). THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE TRAVEL AND TOURISM. Annals of Spiru Haret.
