CC BY
1
irina Podkolzina et al. RT&A, Special Issue № 6 (81), Part-3, ECONOMIC BENEFITS AND RISKS OF TRANSITION..._Volume 19, December 2024
ECONOMIC BENEFITS AND RISKS OF TRANSITION TO SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN KEY INDUSTRIAL SECTORS
Irina Podkolzina1, Vugar Aliyev2, Fatima Uzdenova3, Marianna Kelekhsaeva4,
Natalia Lazareva5
1North Caucasus Federal University, RUSSIA 2AMIR Technical Services Company, AZERBAIJAN 3North Caucasus State Academy (SKGA), RUSSIA 4Khetagurov North Ossetian State University, RUSSIA ^Technological Institute of Service Branch of the Don State Technical University, RUSSIA
Abstract
The transition to sustainable development in key industrial sectors presents both opportunities and challenges. On the one hand, adopting sustainable practices can lead to significant economic benefits, such as increased resource efficiency, cost savings in energy consumption, and access to new markets driven by growing demand for environmentally responsible products. Industries that prioritize sustainability also become more resilient to climate-related risks, including supply chain disruptions and regulatory changes aimed at reducing carbon emissions. Moreover, sustainable development fosters innovation, creating new business models and driving technological advancements. On the other hand, this transition carries inherent economic risks. High upfront investments in green technologies, infrastructure, and process transformations can be prohibitive for companies, especially in sectors with low profit margins. Additionally, the uncertainty surrounding evolving environmental regulations and market demands may cause disruptions to established business operations. Industries like energy, agriculture, and transportation face significant challenges in balancing short-term financial pressures with the long-term advantages of sustainability. This paper analyzes the economic benefits and risks associated with transitioning to sustainable development in these key sectors, focusing on how innovation, supportive policy frameworks, and financial incentives can help mitigate risks and promote long-term economic gains. It aims to provide insights into the strategies that industries and policymakers can adopt to ensure a smoother, more economically viable shift towards sustainability.
Keywords: sustainable development, industrial sectors, economic benefits, economic risks, climate resilience
I. Introduction
The global shift towards sustainable development has become a crucial priority for governments, businesses, and industries alike, as the impacts of climate change, resource depletion, and environmental degradation intensify. Key industrial sectors, including energy, agriculture, and transportation, are under growing pressure to adopt sustainable practices that minimize their environmental footprint while remaining economically viable. This transition is driven by a combination of regulatory mandates, market forces, and societal expectations for environmentally responsible production and consumption.
The benefits of moving towards sustainability are clear: enhanced resource efficiency, reduced operational costs, and new opportunities for innovation and growth. Companies that integrate sustainable practices can access emerging green markets, improve their brand reputation, and strengthen resilience against climate-related risks such as supply chain disruptions and stricter environmental regulations. Moreover, the increasing global focus on reducing carbon emissions has created incentives for industries to invest in renewable energy, waste reduction, and circular economy models.
Reducing the __
Magnitude of
change
Mitigation
" Crop cultivators
■ Changing of eco-system
" Wastage
■ Urbanization
■ Deforestation
■ GHG Emissions
Long term
Climate Changes
■ Temperature
■ Precipitation T"
Sectors
■ Agriculture 1 Biodiversity ■ Health ■Forestry ■ Tourism
■ Economy
■ Industrial
Minimizing t-
Harmful effects
Adaptation
■ Farmer education ■ Water management
■ Change of habit
" Germs
■ Weather changes
■ Population changes
interventions
Decision making
Short term
activities
Figure 1: Sectoral impacts of climate change with adaptation and mitigation measures
Researchers express significant concern regarding the methodologies for adaptation and mitigation within various sectoral and geographical contexts. Key sectors that require focused adaptation and mitigation policies include agriculture, industry, forestry, transport, and land use. It is essential to address adaptation and mitigation efforts at both national and international levels. In recent decades, the world has grappled with the pressing issue of climate change, making it imperative to adapt to its effects for sustainable economic and social development. To effectively address climate change (CC), there is a need to formulate comprehensive policies and strategies on an international scale. Figure 1 illustrates current studies related to the sectoral impacts of climate change, along with corresponding adaptation and mitigation measures implemented globally.
However, the path to sustainable development is not without risks. High initial investment costs, uncertainty surrounding future regulations, and the potential for market disruptions pose significant challenges, particularly for industries that rely heavily on traditional, carbon-intensive processes. For many businesses, the question of how to balance short-term economic pressures with the long-term advantages of sustainability remains a critical concern.
This paper explores the economic benefits and risks of transitioning to sustainable development across key industrial sectors, focusing on how innovation, regulatory frameworks, and financial incentives can mitigate risks and promote long-term economic sustainability. By examining the complex dynamics at play, this research aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the economic implications of this transition and offer insights into strategies for navigating these challenges.
II. Methods
To explore the economic benefits and risks of transitioning to sustainable development in key industrial sectors, this study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining quantitative data
analysis with qualitative insights from case studies and expert interviews. The following methods were used to structure the research:
- Literature Review:
A comprehensive review of existing academic literature, industry reports, and policy papers was conducted to identify the current state of research on sustainable development in industrial sectors such as energy, agriculture, and transportation. This review helped define key concepts, challenges, and opportunities, providing a theoretical foundation for the study.
- Quantitative Analysis:
Data on investment trends, operational costs, and economic performance in industries transitioning to sustainable practices were collected from global databases, industry reports, and financial records. Key metrics analyzed included resource efficiency gains, cost reductions, and return on investment (ROI) in sustainable technologies, compared to traditional methods. Additionally, climate-related risks and financial impacts (e.g., insurance costs, supply chain disruptions) were quantified to assess the economic risks of inaction.
- Case Studies:
Detailed case studies of companies and sectors that have undergone successful transitions to sustainability were conducted to provide real-world examples of how economic benefits and risks manifest in practice. These case studies focused on leading firms in energy (e.g., renewable energy investments), agriculture (e.g., sustainable farming practices), and transportation (e.g., electric vehicle adoption), examining the strategies and outcomes of their sustainable initiatives.
- Expert Interviews:
Semi-structured interviews were conducted with industry experts, policymakers, and sustainability consultants to gather qualitative insights into the challenges and opportunities of transitioning to sustainable development. These interviews provided contextual understanding of the economic factors influencing decision-making, the role of policy, and the financial incentives that can mitigate risks in different sectors.
- Comparative Sector Analysis:
A comparative analysis across sectors (energy, agriculture, transportation) was performed to identify common patterns, sector-specific challenges, and the unique risks each sector faces. This method allowed for a holistic understanding of the economic impacts of sustainability transitions, while also identifying key differences in strategies required for various industries.
By combining these methods, this study aims to present a robust analysis of the economic implications of transitioning to sustainable development, highlighting both the benefits and the risks across key industrial sectors. The findings offer actionable insights for policymakers, businesses, and investors seeking to navigate the complex landscape of sustainability.
III. Results
The transition to a green economy involves redefining economic models and policies to promote environmental sustainability while ensuring economic growth and social well-being. This shift requires adopting practices that reduce carbon emissions, conserve resources, and encourage the use of renewable energy. The goal of this transition is to strike a balance between economic development and ecological preservation.
The benefits of moving to a green economy are substantial and wide-ranging (Fig.1). Environmentally, it helps mitigate climate change, protect ecosystems, and preserve biodiversity. By decreasing reliance on fossil fuels and embracing renewable energy, carbon emissions are reduced, and the overall ecological footprint is minimized, creating a healthier planet for future generations.
Economically, the green transition offers significant advantages. It promotes innovation, leading to the development of sustainable technologies and practices, which, in turn, generate new employment opportunities. Green sectors such as renewable energy, eco-friendly construction,
and waste management contribute to job creation, economic growth, and long-term prosperity.
Additionally, businesses benefit from enhanced resource efficiency and cost savings. Implementing energy-efficient technologies, adopting sustainable supply chain practices, and optimizing resource use can lower operational costs. By minimizing waste, improving energy use, and embracing circular economy principles, companies can significantly cut expenses while enhancing their competitive edge.
However, the transition to a green economy also carries risks that must be managed. Businesses may face high upfront costs related to adopting sustainable technologies, retraining employees, or retrofitting existing infrastructure. Careful planning, strategic decisions, and financial investment are required to overcome these initial hurdles. It's important to recognize that this transition is a long-term strategy, and sustainable policies and investments may take time to deliver profitable returns. For example, the construction of renewable energy infrastructure, such as wind farms and solar plants, demands significant upfront investment and planning. Yet, as these projects begin generating clean energy, they gradually become financially viable and deliver substantial returns over time.
Figure 2: Copper's Role in the Transition to a Green Economy
The Crucial Role of Copper in the Green Economy Transition
The significance of copper in the shift toward a green economy cannot be overstated. As global attention increasingly turns to renewable energy sources and sustainable technologies, the demand for copper is anticipated to surge dramatically. This versatile metal is essential in a variety of green technologies, including electric vehicles (EVs), solar panels, wind turbines, and energy storage systems. From a sustainability perspective, copper is an optimal material due to its high conductivity, durability, and recyclability. Additionally, its antimicrobial properties make it particularly valuable for applications in healthcare and sanitation, especially in light of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.
The Growing Demand for Copper in Electric Vehicles
Electric vehicles are quickly becoming a cleaner alternative to traditional combustion engine vehicles. However, the transition to EVs necessitates a substantial increase in copper production. EVs require four times more copper than conventional vehicles, largely due to their electric motors, wiring, and charging infrastructure. With governments worldwide committing to phasing out the sale of new internal combustion engine vehicles in the coming decades, the demand for copper in the automotive sector is expected to rise significantly. Investing in copper now can yield long-term benefits as the EV market continues to expand.
Copper's Essential Role in Renewable Energy Generation
Copper is also vital in renewable energy generation, particularly in solar panels and wind turbines, which depend heavily on copper for electrical wiring and connections. The International Copper Association estimates that a single onshore wind turbine can contain up to four tons of copper, while large-scale solar farms can require hundreds of kilotons of copper for their infrastructure. As countries work to decrease their carbon footprints and increase their reliance on renewable energy sources, the demand for copper will inevitably grow. Investing in copper mining companies or copper exchange-traded funds (ETFs) can provide investors with valuable exposure to this expanding sector.
Copper's Importance in Energy Storage Solutions
Energy storage further highlights copper's significance. Batteries, essential for storing energy from renewable sources and ensuring a stable power supply, rely on copper for wiring and electrical connections. Lithium-ion batteries, commonly used in electric vehicles and renewable energy storage, contain a substantial amount of copper. Additionally, redox flow batteries, which offer scalable and efficient solutions for grid-scale energy storage, also incorporate copper in their design. As the demand for energy storage solutions rises, so will the need for copper. Investing in companies involved in battery manufacturing or copper mining can be a wise choice for long-term gains.
Investment Opportunities in Copper
When considering investment options in copper, several avenues are available. One approach is to invest directly in copper mining companies, providing exposure to the entire copper supply chain, from extraction to production. However, investing in individual mining firms carries risks related to geopolitical factors, labor disputes, and environmental concerns. An alternative is to invest in copper ETFs, which offer a diversified portfolio of copper mining companies, spreading risk across multiple entities and providing greater liquidity. Additionally, investing in renewable energy companies that significantly rely on copper can also be a practical strategy, as their success is closely linked to the demand for copper.
In summary, copper plays a pivotal role in the transition to a green economy. As the demand for renewable energy, electric vehicles, and energy storage solutions continues to grow, so too does the necessity for copper. Investing in this versatile metal presents a smart opportunity for long-term gains, as it is positioned to be a critical component of sustainable technologies. Whether through direct investments in copper mining companies, copper ETFs, or renewable energy firms, investors can strategically position themselves to benefit from the escalating demand for copper in the journey toward a greener future.
Additionally, companies must navigate regulatory risks as governments introduce policies to drive the green transition. Staying updated on evolving compliance requirements is critical, as non-compliance can result in fines, penalties, and reputational harm. By proactively aligning with environmental regulations and engaging in sustainability initiatives, businesses can reduce regulatory risks and show their commitment to responsible practices.
As we move toward a more sustainable future, the concept of a "green economy" has gained significant traction. A green economy is characterized by its low carbon emissions, resource efficiency, and social inclusivity. Its primary goals are to mitigate environmental risks, address ecological scarcities, and foster sustainable economic growth and social well-being. The advantages of a green economy are extensive and impactful, affecting our environment, economy, and society as a whole (Fig.3).
Job Creation
One of the most prominent benefits of a green economy is job creation. As we transition to more sustainable practices, the demand for labor in green industries—such as renewable energy, sustainable transportation, and eco-tourism—is set to rise significantly. The International Labour
Organization estimates that this transition could lead to the creation of up to 24 million new jobs globally by 2030.
Economic Growth
A green economy has the potential to stimulate substantial economic growth. Research indicates that investments in green sectors can yield higher returns than traditional investments, and these sectors are expanding more rapidly than the overall economy. For instance, the renewable energy industry has experienced a 43% increase in employment since 2010, while the broader economy has only grown by 3% during the same period.
Job creation
Environmental benefits
0)0) 0)0)
Economic growth
Social benefits
Figure 3: Benefits of a Green Economy - Green Economy: Driving Economic Growth through the Green Economy
Environmental Benefits
Transitioning to a green economy can significantly lessen our environmental impact. By prioritizing renewable energy sources and sustainable practices, we can reduce greenhouse gas emissions, enhance air and water quality, and protect biodiversity. For example, wind power generates zero emissions and requires minimal water, making it a much cleaner energy source compared to traditional fossil fuels.
Social Benefits
A green economy also offers considerable social benefits. Investments in sustainable infrastructure and public transportation can improve access to essential services and help mitigate social inequalities. For example, a green economy could enhance access to healthcare and education for low-income communities and provide greater availability of green spaces and recreational areas.
The benefits of a green economy are extensive and impactful, influencing our environment, economy, and society as a whole. By investing in green industries and sustainable practices, we can create new jobs, foster economic growth, reduce our environmental footprint, and enhance social well-being. Embracing a green economy is not just an environmental imperative; it is a pathway to a more prosperous and equitable future for all.
IV. Discussion
Understanding what a company's transition to a green economy truly entails is crucial, as it represents not only a global necessity but also a strategic opportunity for businesses. This transition involves embedding sustainability into a company's core strategies, supply chains, and operations. By adopting green practices, businesses can improve their brand image, appeal to environmentally conscious consumers, and gain a competitive edge in the marketplace.
In addition, transitioning to a green economy enhances operational efficiency by optimizing resource use, reducing waste, and incorporating renewable energy. These initiatives lead to significant cost savings, increased profitability, and greater resilience to fluctuations in resource prices.
The European Union (EU) serves as a model of progress in the green economy transition, with its strong commitment to sustainable development. The EU has made substantial strides in
adopting renewable energy, implementing energy efficiency measures, and embracing circular economy principles. These efforts have not only minimized environmental impacts but also enhanced energy security by reducing reliance on fossil fuel imports. As a result, the transition has improved air quality, public health, and the overall well-being of the population.
Moreover, the EU has positioned itself as a global leader in sustainable innovation and technology. European companies have pioneered cutting-edge solutions in areas such as renewable energy, energy storage, sustainable mobility, and circular economy practices. The supportive ecosystem for green businesses within the EU has fostered collaboration, research, and development, driving economic growth and boosting competitiveness on a global scale.
For the full benefits of the green economy transition to be realized, cooperation between businesses and policymakers is essential. Governments can support this process through policies, incentives, and funding, helping to reduce risks for companies. Measures such as tax incentives, grants, and subsidies for green investments, along with regulatory frameworks that promote sustainable practices, are critical to facilitating this transition.
Figure 4: Transitioning to a green economy
A widely accepted viewpoint, supported by scientists, policymakers, and the general public, emphasizes the need for an integrated approach to addressing the climate crisis and advancing sustainable development. Achieving a transition to a green global economy while sustaining economic growth will require significant alterations in the frameworks of global production and consumption (fig.4). However, the precise mechanisms of resource reallocation—specifically, how and where these changes should take place —depend heavily on the underlying assumptions regarding the speed of the green transition.
Businesses, on the other hand, must develop a comprehensive strategy that includes sustainable practices, stakeholder engagement, and continuous innovation. This involves assessing current operations, setting ambitious sustainability targets, and investing in research
and development of green technologies. Collaboration with suppliers, customers, and industry peers is vital to driving collective action and building a sustainable value chain.
Furthermore, companies should integrate sustainable principles throughout their entire operation. This includes sourcing materials responsibly, adopting energy-efficient manufacturing processes, reducing waste and promoting recycling, and managing supply chains with sustainability in mind. By taking a holistic approach to sustainability, businesses can ensure their long-term viability and resilience in a rapidly evolving green economy.
In addition to the strategies mentioned earlier, sustainability reporting plays a crucial role in helping companies transition successfully to a green economy. It provides a structured framework for businesses to measure, monitor, and communicate their environmental, social, and governance (ESG) performance to stakeholders. This process is essential for ensuring transparency, accountability, and continuous improvement in sustainability practices.
By adopting robust sustainability reporting practices, companies can gain a clear understanding of their environmental impacts, resource usage, and social responsibilities. This enables them to identify areas where they can improve, set meaningful targets, and monitor their progress over time. Transparent reporting also allows stakeholders—including investors, customers, employees, and communities—to assess a company's commitment to sustainability and make more informed decisions based on this information.
Moreover, sustainability reporting promotes accountability by encouraging companies to disclose their ESG performance and showcase their efforts in reducing environmental footprints, promoting social equity, and upholding good governance practices. This can enhance a company's reputation, build trust with stakeholders, and attract both socially responsible investors and environmentally conscious customers.
Sustainability reporting also serves as a platform for sharing best practices, lessons learned, and innovative solutions within industries. This promotes collaboration among peers and encourages the exchange of knowledge, accelerating the collective transition to a green economy. By openly sharing successes and challenges, companies can inspire others, contribute to sector-wide improvements, and help drive broader sustainability goals.
In the context of the green economy transition, sustainability reporting becomes an essential tool for businesses to communicate their progress in aligning with sustainability objectives, reducing their environmental impacts, and embracing greener practices. It allows companies to demonstrate their contribution to the green economy and their commitment to long-term environmental stewardship. Furthermore, as investors, regulators, and consumers increasingly demand transparency and accountability in business practices, sustainability reporting enables companies to meet these expectations effectively.
Thus, sustainability reporting is a vital component of any company's journey towards a green economy. It provides a clear framework for measuring and communicating ESG performance, fostering accountability, transparency, and ongoing improvement. By integrating sustainability reporting into their operations, businesses can navigate the complexities of the green economy transition, gain stakeholder trust, and contribute meaningfully to a more sustainable future.
In conclusion, the transition to a green economy offers numerous benefits for businesses, society, and the environment. Shifting to sustainable practices not only helps mitigate environmental impacts but also drives economic growth, innovation, and job creation. While there are risks and challenges involved in this transition, proactive businesses can address these risks through careful planning, compliance with regulations, and engagement with stakeholders. At the same time, it is critical for policymakers to create supportive frameworks that encourage businesses to pursue sustainability and contribute to a more sustainable future.
References
[1] Taranova I.V., Kasaeva T.V., Shavrina J.O., Tekeeva H.E., Boeva K.Y. Methods of fraud management in the financial services market of the region// Business 4.0 as a Subject of the Digital Economy. Cham, 2022. С. 291-295.
[2] Podkolzina, I.M., Gladilin, A.V., Reshetov, K.Y., Taranova, I.V., Gladilin, V.A. Building a Financial Security System to Ensure Russia's Food Security // Lecture Notes in Networks and Systems, 2021, 205, страницы 539-548
[3] Gakaev , R. Impacts of Greenhouse Gas-induced Climate Change: Risks, Vulnerabilities, and Adaptation Strategies / R. Gakaev , L. Gatsaeva , M. Eskiev // E3S Web of Conferences. - 2024. - Vol. 537. - P. 03009. - DOI 10.1051/e3sconf/202453703009. - EDN OJVETT.
[4] Podkolzina, I.M., Belousov, A.I., Uzdenova, F.M., Romanko, L.V., Chernikova, O.A. Forms of Financial Fraud and Ways to Minimize Risks // Lecture Notes in Networks and Systems, 2021, 198, страницы 2197-2205
[5] Munchaev R.M., Amirov Sh.N. Once again about the Mesopotamian -Caucasian connections in the IV-III centuries thousand liters BC // Russian archeology. 2012. No4. pp. 37-46.
[6] Gakaev , R. Creating forest carbon landfills: forest carbon / R. Gakaev , MS Bahaev , I. Gumaev // Reliability: Theory & Applications. - 2023. - Vol. 18, No. S5(75). - P. 222-230. - DOI 10.24412/1932-2321-2023-575-222-230. - EDN LIMMLH.
[7] Fagan B. The Little Ice Age: How Climate Changed History. 1300-1850. Bombara Publishing House , 2021.
[8] Monin A.S., Shishkov Yu.A. History of climate. L .: Gidrometeoizdat , 1979. 408 p.
[9] Salamova A., Kantemirova M., Makazieva Z. Integrated approaches to poverty problems/ E3S Web of Conferences. 2nd International Conference on Environmental Sustainability Management and Green Technologies (ESMGT 2023). EDP Sciences, 2023. С. 05016.
[10] Khotinsky N.A., Savina S.S. Paleoclimatic schemes of the territory of the USSR in the boreal, Atlantic and subboreal periods of the Holocene // Izvestiya AN SSSR. Ser. Geography. 1985. No. 4
[11] Salamova A.S., Kantemirova M.A., Gishlakaev S. Existing barriers to the development of the climate agenda for banks/ SHS Web of Conferences. International Scientific and Practical Conference on Social Sciences and Humanities: Scientific Challenges of the Development of Modern Society (SHCMS 2023). Grozny, 2023.
[12] Taranova I.V., Tokova L.D., Shavrina J.O., Syrovatskaya V.I., Ivanova E.A. Banking management as the basis for effective management of a commercial bank// Modern Global Economic System: Evolutional Development vs. Revolutionary Leap. Institute of Scientific Communications Conference. Cham, 2021. С. 2137-2144
