CC BY
26
CURRENCY RISK MANAGEMENT AT COMPANIES OF AGRO-INDUSTRIAL
COMPLEX
Yu.Yu. Platonova, Candidate of Economic Sciences, Associate Professor T.N. Bondarenko, Graduate Student Kuban State University (Russia, Krasnodar)
DOI: 10.24411/2411-0450-2020-10190
Abstract. This article examines the economic relations arising in the process of managing and minimizing currency risks. There was presented a comprehensive classification of currency risks and systematic methods of managing them. The commodity structure of Russian exports was analyzed and there was determined the current state of Russian exports of agricultural products. Moreover, based on the study and analysis of foreign and Russian experience in currency risk management, proposals were developedfor comprehensive optimization of hedging methods and currency risk management on the example of an export-oriented enterprise in the field of agriculture.
Keywords: risks, currency risks, assessment tools, risk hedging, management optimization.
The actuality of this article due to the problem of optimization of hedging methods of currency risks of company's that engaged in foreign economic activity. These companies are influenced by currency risk and the influence on them is no less than on large corporations.
Currency risk can have both positive and negative consequences, with the greatest impact on its appearance at the present time is the economic and political situation in the world. Therefore, a continuous assessment is essential to company's currency exposure, since the application of existing methods, techniques and tools is not able to completely rid the company's currency risk. It follows that, when any factors affect the currency risk, whether external or internal they are, it is advisable for economic entities to resort to the development of integrated management to reduce the currency risk by using a combination of methods and tools [1].
Currency risks have a significant impact on businesses at the micro and macro levels, as well as on the global scale.
So in figure 1, we show that from February 2019 to January 2020, the dollar and euro exchange rates declined moderately against the ruble. The most change in the value of the dollar occurred in August 2019 and October 2019, when exchange rate fluctuations exceeded 2,33 rubles, and the weakest one occurred in November. The most gain of euro rate was in October 2019, when it grew by 3,7%, and lost - in September 2019, when its value decreased by 3,45%.
In relation to the ruble rate and the Russian financial market as a whole, 2019 can be called a good year for the ruble. The reason of the strengthening of the national currency and the growth of stock quotes was the reduction of sanction risks and the inflow of foreign capital into ruble assets [2].
While in Russia, the main elements of hedging remain the use of derivatives, however, in China to control capital outflows of the yuan and to insure the national currency against the prospect of a strengthening of the strengthening of the US dollar.
55 -
.SS /•»' KV rf' if' if' t'
/ J? / ^ & /■ / / / S
--The US dollar ■ The Euro
Figure 1. Dynamics of the exchange rate of the dollar-ruble and the euro-ruble exchange rate
from February 2019 to January 2020 [3]
According to table 1, we monitored the 2019, the Chinese currency weakened against dynamics of the China's national currency, the dollar by 4,86%, which will have a posi-and noted that during February-December tive impact on exports.
Table 1. Dynamics of changes in yuan-dollar exchange rate for June 2019 - April 2020 [3]
Period Rate Change
February 2019 6,7012 -
March 2019 6,6936 -0,0076
April 2019 6,7114 0,0178
May 2019 6,7362 0,0248
June 2019 6,9053 0,1691
July 2019 6,8651 -0,0402
August 2019 6,8847 0,0196
September 2019 7,155 0,2703
October 2019 7,1318 -0,0232
November 2019 7,0396 -0,0922
December 2019 7,0269 -0,0127
Futhermore, we focused on the impact of currency risks on companies engaged in foreign economic activity in the agricultural sector, namely, the company Petrokhleb-Kuban LLC.
The main activity of this organization is wholesale trade of agricultural products. To date, Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C shows successful interaction with both russian and foreign major partners [4].
Our focus was on the main foreign partners, among which we identified and marked the leader in terms of the number of transactions with Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C. - the Swiss company Aston FFI (Suisse) S. A. The
total value of contracts exceeds 16 million dollars, and this is only for the last 6 months.
To assess the impact of currency risks on Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C., we analyzed its financial condition.
In table 2, we analyzed the solvency coefficients of the analyzed enterprise, which showed a slight decrease in solvency, which is not critical, since some coefficients are within the norm, and a slight deviation from the norm does not affect the overall financial result. However, the company should pay more attention to the repayment of short-term obligations in order to maintain the positive dynamics of the company's solvency.
Table 2. Analysis of solvency coefficients of Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C. for 2017-20
Indicators The beginning of2017 The beginning of 2018 The end of 2018 Change in 2017 Change in 2017-2018
1. Current assets, thousands of rubles 241 430 309 047 406 497 67 617 165 067
2. Noncurrent Assets, thousands of rubles 85 908 58 877 45 186 -27 031 -40 722
3. Short-term debt receivable, thousands of rubles 167 640 118 549 174 127 -49 091 6 487
4. Cash and short-term financial investments, thousands of rubles 1 673 5 132 3 521 3 459 1 848
5. Equity, thousands of rubles 19 748 25 594 28 335 5 846 8 587
6. Current liabilities, thousands of rubles 247 773 297 832 429 442 50 059 181 669
7. Cash ratio 0,00675 0,01723 0,00820 0,01048 0,00145
8. Liquidity ratio 0,68334 0,41527 0,41367 -0,26807 -0,26967
9. Current ratio 0,97440 1,03766 0,94657 0,06326 -0,02783
10. Working capital financed by equity to total assets ratio -0,27403 -0,10770 -0,04145 0,16634 0,23258
11. Net current assets, thousands of rubles -6 343 11 215 -22 945 17558 -16 602
We also analyzed the dynamics and structure of indicators of the report on the financial results as a percentage of sales revenue of Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C. We noted that during the two analyzed periods, the company's revenue decreased by 1 830 552 thousand rubles, which was a change of 42,97%. This sharp decline in revenue was influenced by the adoption in May 2017 of the "Charter on agricultural products turnover" with the active participation of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).
In order to assess the impact of currency risk of Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C., we analyzed the turnover balance sheet for 2019 and noted that there were 87 427, 87 dollars on the
company's currency account, which already shows the presence of currency risk. Speaking about the volume of currency in settlements with foreign partners, we have highlighted that the largest share of foreign currency is accounted for in 57.21, 57.22 and 62.21 subaccounts, where shares of 23,6%, 32,12% and 27,14% are concentrated on debits, respectively.
According to the analyzed information about Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C., we have been formulated the following proposals, presented in table 3, which will help to optimize the structure of currency risk management [5].
Table 3. Suggestions for the currency risk management system optimization of Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C.
Proposal Result
Application of the VaR method to assess the impact of foreign exchange risk Preservation of a certain percentage of the proceeds due to fluctuations of the ruble and ensuring further development of Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C.
Restriction of currency risks' concentration Setting of internal financial rules ensures the reduction of the risk of insolvency of enterprise Petrokhleb-Kuban LLC and reduces foreign exchange risk when performing transactions in foreign currency.
Hedging foreign exchange risk through derivatives (options and forwards) Benefits from increasing floating interest rates, while the maximum losses from applying a currency option are limited by the premium In application of the forward contract unfavorable change of exchange rate will ensure maximum expenses of enterprise Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C.
Application of the currency terms and conditions of a contract There is no financial cost involved. There is a possibility of the most comprehensive management of foreign exchange risk. There was flexibility with regard to payment terms.
Placement of foreign exchange accounting in a company Simplifying the procedure for including exchange rate differences in the financial report. Obtaining objective information on the effectiveness of foreign exchange transactions.
Table 4 shows the calculation of the value of VaR indicator, through which we got the amount of losses, which with a probability of 2.56 % does not exceed the established limit of 5 %. Moreover, we noted that it is necessary to control the VaR indicator at an ac-
ceptable level just like regular values of the dollar exchange rate update on the website of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation in real mode. This is the way to protect the company from 2.56 % of revenue losses only due to fluctuations of the ruble.
Table 4. Methodology of minimization of currency risks of Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C. based on the VaR method
Date Exchange rate, dollar/ruble Natural logarithm rate relation
01.02.2019 67,0795
01.03.2019 65,3577 -0,026003223
01.04.2019 65,8895 0,008103836
01.05.2019 65,4176 -0,007187761
01.06.2019 64,6314 -0,012090975
01.07.2019 65,3834 0,011568043
01.08.2019 63,0541 -0,036275316
01.09.2019 63,4172 0,00574203
01.10.2019 66,6235 0,04932225
01.11.2019 64,6407 -0,030213125
01.12.2019 63,7748 -0,013486115
01.01.2020 64,4097 0,009906115
Volatility — 0,000536177
VaR (with probability of 95%), rubles (k=1,65) 2,562878609
Further, we have shown the effectiveness in table 5. By applying this method, risk min-of using derivatives to hedge currency risks imization amounted to 760 919,876 rubles. on the example of an option, which is shown
Table 5. Effectiveness of currency risk insurance on the example of Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C. under various scenarios (purchase price - 529,760 dollars)_
The way of settlement of foreign currency transactions Indicator Current rate Exchange rate of the ruble against the dollar
Without hedging currency risk Exchange rate RUB/USD. 58,5318 55,6717
Expenses, rubles 0 0
Contract value, rubles 31 007 806,37 29 492 639,79
Profit/loss, rubles — -1 515 166,58
Using currency risk insurance (foreign exchange option) Exchange rate RUB/USD. — 58,9518
Expenses, rubles — 976 745,90
Contract value, rubles — 32 207 051,47
Profit/loss, rubles — 760 919,88
And the final stage of optimization of this system at the Petrokhleb-Kuban L.L.C. was the development of the document "Currency risk management policy for Petrokhleb-Kuban LLC ", which is presented in table 6. In this document, we have reflected such as-
pects of management as minimizing the impact of currency risks through the use of derivative financial instruments, including currency clauses in foreign trade contracts, as well as maintaining currency accounting at the company.
Table 6. Detailed structure of the "Currency risk management policy for Petrokhleb-Kuban
LLC.
№ Structure Key aspects The content
1 The general provisions - - introduction to the Policy; - - determining the procedure for making changes and additions to the Policy; - - indication of the level of importance of using this Policy; - - the width of application of the Policy by the company's structural divisions; - - compliance of this Policy with existing legal acts.
2 The terms and definitions Systematization of terms used in the Policy and disclosure of their definitions. - - risk owner; - - impact on risk; - - qualitative risk assessment; - - quantitative risk assessment; - - risk identification; - - risk assessment; - - consequences of risk; - - risk; - - risk-appetite; - - risk management.
3 The objectives of the company Determing the direction of setting risk management objectives for the company.
Key objectives in the area of risk management. - - implementation of the company's strategy; - - adaptation of the company in internal and external environments; - - efficiency of the company's foreign economic activity and its stability on the international market; - - constant reform of the company's development prospects.
Objectives of the integrated risk management framework - - contributing to the achievement of key goals; - - ensuring the effectiveness of an integrated functional foreign exchange risk management framework; - timely management decisions and continuous reporting on business planning; - rational allocation of resources for managing foreign exchange risks; - improvement of mechanisms for dealing with emerging consequences from already implemented currency risks.
4 Principles of risk management Determination the principles for the development of a mechanism for managing currency risks. - - the principle of strategy conformity; - - the principle of targeted liability; - - the principle of continuity and progression - - the principle of economic feasibility and efficiency; - - the principle of awareness.
5 Stages of currency risk management Identification of stages of currency risk management, as well as direct implementation of risk management mechanisms
I stage. Quantitative risk assessment and macroeconomic analysis. - - application of the VAR-method for quantitative estimation of currency risk; - - indication of the level of volatility of currency risks for carrying out macroeconomic analysis.
II stage. Determining the appetite for currency risk. - - making a decision on managing foreign exchange risk at the highest structural level of the company; - - conformity with the principle of economic expediency and efficiency; - - to identify common, strategic, operational and tactical goals and objectives at the lowest level of internal organization; - - creation of a specialized department (group of employees) for managing currency risks; - distribution of functional duties of the department (group of employees).
III stage. Development of hedging strategies. - - determination of external and internal events and factors; - - implementation of risk control; - - carrying out a comprehensive analysis of risk management results; - - determination of methods of management and impact on currency risks; - - adjustment of currency risk management activities.
6 Restrictions on currency risk management Identifying restrictions that affect risk management decision-making. - - lack of impact of integrated risk management on other existing functional areas; - - compliance with the complex management of the given set of tasks and requirements by the senior management; - - adaptation of the company to geopolitical, political, economic environmental and legislative conditions.
Nowadays, you can notice an unstable sit- and management system of agro-industrial uation of currency exchange rate fluctuations, companies (technological, marketing, organiso agribusiness enterprises should develop zational risks and risk loss of profits), and al-effective programs and measures to manage so to keep in mind that the elimination of the-currency risks, as well as to minimize them in se risks can be realized through direct impact the future. At the same time, it is important to on risk factors.
remember that domestic enterprises benefit Thus, for the company Petrokhleb-Kuban
from the reduction of foreign currency in rela- L.L.C., we have developed a whole set of tion to the national currency when they are measures for managing currency risks, which making export transactions with foreign part- has been systematized in the currency risk ners. In order to assess the degree of exposure management policy, which covers the entire of company's currency risk, it is necessary to range of tools and methods for risk minimiza-consider features of the internal environment tion.
References
1. Dmitrieva M.A. Valyutnyj risk: ot opredeleniya k klassifikacii // Rossijskoe predprinimatelstvo. - 2015. - T. 16. №15. - S. 2423-2436.
2. Trends (Hedging currency risks) Marketing Core Investments & MACS. - [Electronic resource]. - URL: https://www.credit-suisse.com/pwp/am/downloads/marketing/trends_0203_en.pdf/ -March 2016/
3. Official website «WorldBankGroup». - [Electronic resource]. - URL: http://www.vsemirnyjbank.org/ (date 26.02.2020).
4. Non-commercial partnership of professionals and participants of foreign economic activity «PROVED». - [Electronic resource]. - URL: http://proved-np.org/services/novosti/novosti_ved/ (date: 27.02.2020).
5. Nikulina O.V., Krivosheina A.O. Razrabotka meropriyatij po minimizacii valyutnyh riskov predpriyatij APK v sfere zakupki importnyh materialov i oborudovaniya // Ekonomika i predprinimatelstvo. - 2014. - №24.
УПРАВЛЕНИЕ ВАЛЮТНЫМИ РИСКАМИ В КОМПАНИЯХ АГРОПРОМЫШЛЕННОГО КОМПЛЕКСА
Ю.Ю. Платонова, канд. экон. наук, доцент Т.Н. Бондаренко, магистрант Кубанский государственный университет (Россия, г. Краснодар)
Аннотация. В данной статье рассматриваются экономические отношения, возникающие в процессе управления и минимизации валютных рисков. Представлена комплексная классификация валютных рисков и систематических методов управления ими. Была проанализирована товарная структура российского экспорта и определено текущее состояние российского экспорта сельскохозяйственной продукции. Кроме того, на основе изучения и анализа зарубежного и российского опыта управления валютными рисками были разработаны предложения по комплексной оптимизации методов хеджирования и управления валютными рисками на примере экспортно-ориентированного предприятия в области сельского хозяйства.
Ключевые слова: риски, валютные риски, инструменты оценки, хеджирование рисков, оптимизация управления.
