CC BY
28
CONDITIONS OF A SINGLE-MODE RIB CHANNEL WAVEGUIDE BASED ON DIELECTRIC TIO2/SIO2
M.A. Butt1, E.S. Kozlova12, S.N. Khonina 12 1 Samara National Research University, Samara, Russia 2 Image Processing Systems Institute of RAS - Branch of the FSRC "Crystallography and Photonics " RAS, Samara, Russia
Abstract
In this paper, we propose conditions for the design of a single-mode rib channel waveguide based on dielectric materials such as titanium dioxide (TiO2) and silicon dioxide (SiO2) for the 0.633-^m visible light. We also design Y-splitter structures, which show high-degree optical confinement and low bend losses at various radii of curvatures. Small radii of curvatures are extremely desirable in integrated photonics as they permit decreasing the dimensions but can also potentially reduce power consumption in the active devices.
Keywords: single mode, rib channel waveguide, titanium dioxide, silicon dioxide, beam propagation method.
Citation: Butt MA, Kozlova ES, Khonina SN. Conditions of a single-mode rib channel waveguide based on dielectric TiO2/SiO2. Computer Optics 2017; 41(4): 494-498. DOI: 10.18287/24126179-2017-41-4-494-498.
Acknowledgements: The work was partially funded by the RF Ministry of Education and Science (# SP-4375.2016.5), a RF President's grant for support of leading scientific schools (# NSh-9498.2016.9) and RFBR (##17-47-630420, 17-47-630417, 16-47-630483, 15-07-01174).
Introduction
Optical communications through fiber have long been the technology of choice for high-speed long distance data links [1]. Progressively, as the capacity requirements have increased, the optical links have developed into shorter distance applications, such as fiber-to-the-home, local area network, and even into fiber optic interconnects between boards and cabinets. In the long run, optics would be used to interconnect the integrated circuits on a board or even to be used in intra-chip interconnects. That is, electrical interconnects, which have dominated since the infancy of electronics, are likely to be substituted with the optical interconnects in some cases [2]. Integrated optics devices are based on the processing of light confinement in optical structures called optical waveguides. It allows the confinement of light by total internal reflection, which takes place when the high index medium is surrounded by the low index medium [3-8]. The most significant passive elements in the integrated optics are the rib geometry waveguides [9-11]. They are the basic element practically in all integrated optical passive and active devices [9, 12].
In order to design a dielectric rib waveguides for optical communications, special care must be taken to confirm the single mode propagation of light for their farther coupling with the single mode fibres. One can subconsciously assume that the single mode condition for the rib waveguides have to look like the single mode condition for slab waveguides of the same dimensions, but it is not like this. The rib waveguide can be multimode in the vertical direction but if precise proportional sizes of the height and the width in thecen-tral region are chosen, it can support only one bound mode. In other words, all high order modes in the central rib region are filtered out by leaking away because their propagation constants are lower than that of the fundamental mode of the slab waveguide in the side region. Only the fundamental mode in the central rib region persists since only its propaga-
tion constant is higher than that of the fundamental mode of the slab waveguide in the side region. Therefore, a criterion should be worked out for the proportional sizes of transversal dimensions in order to ensure the single mode propagation [13]. In this paper, conditions for single mode rib channel waveguide based on titanium dioxide and silicon dioxide are proposed; afterwards, the Y-splitter structure is also designed which shows the high degree of confinement and low bend losses even at low radii of curvature.
These kind waveguides consist of three layers of dielectric materials. Layer 1 has a thickness of H with a refractive index of n1. The layer is then etched while covering the rib section of the waveguide with the help of some metal mask; this gives rise to a slab of height h. Layer 1 has a refractive index of n1. Layer 2 and layer 3 have a semi-finite thickness and index of n2 and n3, respectively. We shall assume that n\ > n2 and n\ > m. So that total internal reflection can occur at each interface. Layer 1 is referred to as the guiding layer, while layer 2 and 3 are a substrate and the cladding layer, respectively.
A guiding of this type can be formed simply by depositing a high index guiding layer onto a polished substrate. In our case, the cladding layer is air. Because of this geometry, it is normally described as an asymmetric rib waveguide and take n > n2 > m. For the modeling of such waveguides, we proposed TiO2 (2.5836 at 0.633 ^m) and SiO2 (1.4570 at 0.633 ^m) as high and low refractive index materials, respectively. The refractive index difference between two material is quite high An = 1.1266 which can be helpful in confining the light at the higher degrees of bends. The materials in which the guided light propagates must elude scattering and absorption losses in the wavelength range of interest [14].
Fig. 1 shows the cross-sectional view of the rib waveguide, where h is the height of the slab, H is the slab height plus rib height and W is the width of the rib. The structuration of the layer can be done with different techniques [15].
ni>Vl2>n3
Fig. 1. A cross-sectional view of rib-waveguide
Conditions for single mode straight channel rib waveguide
Nowadays, an increasing number of optical modulators, filters and other functions relevant to telecommunication networks have been proposed as integrated or embedded in dielectric rib/ridge waveguides [16, 17]. Many of them share the widespread feature of being based on the propagation of the light beam inside a waveguide which has been designed to sustain only its fundamental mode of propagation to allow lower insertion losses when coupled to optical fibres. For the modeling of a single mode straight channel rib waveguide, the parameters such as h (height of slab), H (height of rib) and W (width of the rib) are considered. All the bounded modes are determined at 0.633 |im by using beam propagation method (BPM). The thickness of H is kept in the range of 100-1000 nm limited to the deposition techniques. Table 1, shows the parameters of waveguide used in the simulations and the type of waveguide obtained by it.
The ratios between (h, H) and (W, H) are plotted in Fig. 2 which represents the dimensions that can be used to design single and multi-mode rib channel waveguides. It can be seen that the region defined by the grey squares are the dimensions of waveguides that can only support a fundamental single mode and the region which is covered by black dots is useful to design multi-mode waveguides. Therefore, this graph can offer an approximation for indicating the dimensions of single mode waveguide based on these materials.
W/H
5.0
4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
■ Single mode o Multimode
h/H
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2
Fig. 2. Single and multi-mode waveguides dimensions at 0.633 fim. Grey and black points represent single and multi-modal waveguide dimensions respectively
From Fig. 2, it is well noting that when the ratios of W/H> 2 and h/H< 0.3, the waveguide can support multi-modes. Single mode waveguide dimensions are obtained
when the ratios of h/H and W/H is greater than 0.3 and 1, respectively. However, when the ratio between h and H is higher than 1, then it is not possible to design a rib structure because the thickness of H should never be small than h. The simulated mode of a straight rib channel waveguide (Simulation number 5, Table 1) is shown in Fig. 3.
Table 1. Types of waveguides depending on its dimensions.
Where "h" is kept constant at 100 nm, however "H" and "W" are varied in each simulation
No. of h H W h/H W/H Waveguide
Simul. (nm) (nm) (nm) type
1 100 1000 5000 0.1 5 Multi
2 100 500 2250 0.2 4.5 Multi
3 100 300 1300 0.3 4 Single
4 100 250 875 0.4 3.5 Single
5 100 200 600 0.5 3 Single
6 100 170 400 0.6 2.5 Single
7 100 140 280 0.7 2 Single
8 100 125 180 0.8 1.5 Single
9 100 110 110 0.9 1 Single
10 100 100 50 1 0.5 Single
11 100 500 1000 0.2 2 Multi
12 100 200 400 0.5 2 Single
13 100 140 140 0.7 1 Single
14 100 125 375 0.8 3 Single
15 100 170 670 0.6 4 Single
16 100 1000 3000 0.1 3 Multi
17 100 1000 4000 0.1 4 Multi
18 100 150 625 0.4 2.5 Single
19 100 250 1375 0.4 5.5 Single
20 100 200 1100 0.5 5.5 Single
21 100 1000 1000 0.1 1 Single
22 100 300 300 0.3 1 Single
23 100 250 250 0.4 1 Single
24 100 200 900 0.5 4.5 Single
25 100 500 1500 0.2 3 Multi
26 100 300 1600 0.3 5 Single
27 100 125 560 0.8 4.5 Single
28 100 1000 2000 0.1 2 Multi
29 100 500 2750 0.2 5.5 Multi
30 100 300 100 0.3 3 Single
31 100 500 500 0.2 1 Single
32 100 300 670 0.3 2 Single
33 100 200 1000 0.45 4.5 Single
-4
Fig. 3.
0 2 4
mode of a straight rib channel waveguide
Single mode Y-splitter structure
After proposing the conditions of straight rib channel waveguide, the design for the balanced Y-splitter structure is proposed. Several Y-splitter structures with varying radii of curvatures are simulated. The waveguide dimensions (Simulations: 1-6) are kept constant. The size of Y-splitter is fixed to 8 mm but with inTable 2. Y-splitter structure of8000 ¡m
creasing radii of curvature in each simulation. The schematic of the Y-splitter design based on TiO2/SiO2 is shown in Fig. 4. The length of the input straight channel waveguide is kept as long as possible depending on the design. This helps in removing the fluctuations and clean the propagating mode.The detail about the parameters is shown in Table 2.
long with various radius of curvature
No. of simul. h (Mm) H (Mm) W (Mm) Length of input straightwaveguide, Lin(^m) Length of bend Waveguide, Lbend, (^m) Length of output straight waveguide, Lout (^m) Separation between two arms, Ls (^m) Radii of curvature, R (mm)
1 0.05 0.25 0.5 2000 1500 4500 2 560
2 0.05 0.25 0.5 2000 1500 4500 4 280
3 0.05 0.25 0.5 2000 1500 4500 6 188
4 0.05 0.25 0.5 2000 1500 4500 8 140
5 0.05 0.25 0.5 2000 1500 4500 10 110
6 0.05 0.25 0.5 2000 1500 4500 12 93
Fig. 4. Schematic of 8 mm long Y-splitter structure with varying distance between two arms ranges from 2-12 ¡xm
The propagation of light intensity in one arm of 6 different Y-splitters with a varying radius of curvature, R is plotted in Fig. 5(a). Since the Y-splitter structure is symmetric, therefore the power in each arm is equal. By keeping the optimum separations, coupling effect between two arms can be avoided. An optimum value of the radius of curvature should be selected in order to provide a smooth bending to the propagation light. S-bend waveguides with fixed radius of curvature R range between 93-560 mm are used to design the Y-splitters. S-bend waveguides are important as input/output waveguides for directional couplers and as waveguide path transformers in various circuits.
The fundamental mode of a straight channel rib waveguide was calculated and used as a launch field for Y-splitter. Let's consider, the launch field has an intensity of 1 a.u. The Y-splitter with a separation of 10 ^m between its arms contains the maximum energy of 0.491 a.u / arm. The lowest energy of 0.465 a.u / arm was obtained in the case of Y-splitter with 4 ^m of separation between its arms. This shows an energy difference of nearly 3 % if Y-splitters are designed with R between 93560 mm as shown in Fg. 5(b).
Intensity, a.u.
1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2
-Simulation 1
Simulation 2
-----Simulation 3
-------Simulation 4
----Simulation 5
-------Simulation 6
Z, mm
a) 0 1 Intensity, a.u. 0.50-
8
0.49
0.48
0.47
0.46
0.45
■ Simulation 1
Simulation 4
Simulation 2----Simulation 5
-----Simulation 3 -------Simulation 6
Z, mm
b) 4.0 4.2 4.4 4.6 4.8 5.0
Fig. 5. Variation of launch power a) 8 mm long Y-splitter structure with varying distance between two arms ranges from 2-12 xm b) Magnified image of the power in the propagation length from 4-5 mm
Out of six simulations shown in Fig. 5, we choose the best design of the Y-splitter and plotted its mode profile at the output as shown in Fig. 6(a). The separation between the two arms was at 20 ^m to avoid any possible evanescence field coupling between two arms. The optical field at the output of the matched S-bends and in the subsequent straight waveguide section is undistorted. As a consequence, the fields at the Y-branch output are balanced as demonstrated by the horizontal cross-section of the mode as shown in Fig. 6(b). Moreover, there is no leakage of the mode in the substrate as can be seen in Fig. 6(c), where mode has an FWHM of 0.1692 ^m which is nearly equal to the height of the rib.
c) -1.0 -0.5 0 0.5 1.0
Fig. 6. Simulated results of a Y-splitter at 0.633 /m with a) Mode profile at the output of Y-splitter b) Horizontal cross-section profile of the mode c) Vertical cross-section of the mode
Conclusion
We proposed the conditions of a single mode rib channel waveguide based on TiO2 and SiO2 dielectric materials at 0.633 ^m visible light by optimizing different parameters of the waveguide with the help of Beam Prop software. These dielectric materials have high refractive index contrast which makes them an outstanding platform for the realization of S-bend and Y-splitters with the small radii of curvature. Based on these results, many optical elements such as S-bend, Y-splitter can be realized which can be used for different optical applications. Moreover, the Y-splitter structures are designed which shows the high degree of optical confinement and low bend losses at various radii of curvatures. Small radii of curvatures are extremely desirable in integrated photonics as they permit decreasing the dimensions but can also potentially reduce the power consumption in the active devices.
References
[1] Senior JM. Optical fiber communications: Principles and practice. Pearson education Ltd.; 2009. ISBN: 978-0-13-032681-2.
[2] Tong XC. Advanced materials for integrated optical waveguides. Switzerland: Springer International Publishing; 2014. ISBN 978-3-319-01549-1.
[3] Butt MA, Pujol MC, Sole R, Rodenas A, Lifante G, Wilkinson JS, Aguilo M, Diaz F. Channel waveguides and mach-zehnder structures on RbTiOPO4 by Cs+ ion exchange. Opt Mat Express 2015; 5(5): 1183-1194. DOI: 10.1364/OME.5.001183.
[4] Butt MA, Nguyen HD, Rodenas A, Romero C, Moreno P, Vazuez de Aldana JR, Aguilo M, Sole RM, Pujol MC, Diaz F. Low-repitition rate femtosecond laser writing of optical waveguides in KTP crystals: analysis of anisotropic refractive index changes. Opt Express 2015; 23(12): 1534315355. DOI: 10.1364/OE.23.015343.
[5] Butt MA, Sole R, Pujol MC, Rodenas A, Lifante G, Choudhary A, Murugan GS, Shepherd DP, Wilkinson JS, Aguilo M, Diaz F. Fabrication of Y-splitters and Mach-Zehnder structures on (Yb, Nb):RbTiOPO4/RbTiOPO4 Epitaxial layers by reactive ion etching. Journal of Lightwave Technology 2015; 33(9): 1863-1871.
[6] Kazanskiy NL, Serafmovich PG, Khonina SN. Optical nanoresonator in the ridge of photonic crystal waveguides crossing [In Russian]. Computer Optics 2011; 35(4): 426-431.
[7] Strilets TS, Kotlyar VV, Nalimov AG. Simulation of waveguide modes in multilayer structures [In Russian]. Computer Optics 2010; 34(4): 487-493.
[8] Moiseeva NM. The calculation of eigenvalues modes of the planar anistropic waveguides for various angles the optical axis. Computer Optics 2013; 37(1): 13-18.
[9] Adams MJ. An introduction to Optical waveguides. New York: John Wiley & Sons; 1981. ISBN: 978-0-471-27969-3.
[10] Robson PN, Kendall PC, eds. Rib waveguide theory by the spectral index method. Research Studies Press Ltd.; 1990. ISBN: 978-0-863-80110-5.
[11] Soref RA, Schmidtchen J, Petermann K. Large single mode rib waveguides in GeSi-Si and Si-on-SiO2. IEEE J Quantum Electron 1991; 27: 1971-1974. DOI: 10.1109/3.83406.
[12] Wang S. Principles of distributed feedback and distributed Bragg-reflector lasers, IEEE J Quantum Electron 1974, 10(4): 413-427. DOI: 10.1109/JQE.1974.1068152.
[13] Pogossian SP, Vescan L, Vonsovici A. The single mode condition for semiconductor Rib waveguides with large cross section. J Lightwave Technol 1998; 16(10), 1851-1853.
[14] Yeatman EM, Pita K, Ahmad MM. Strip-loaded high confinement waveguides for photonic applications. Journal of Sol-Gel Science and Technology 1998; 13(1-3): 517-521.
[15] Butt MA, Pujol MC, Sole R, Rodenas A, Lifante G, Aguilo M, Diaz F, Khonina SN, Skidanov RV, Verma P. Fabrication of optical waveguides in RbTiOPO4 single crystals by using different techniques. Proc SPIE 2016; 9807: 98070C. DOI: 10.1117/12.2231368.
[16] Boudrioua A. Photonic waveguides: Theory and applications. Hoboken, NJ: John Wliey & Sons, Inc.; 2009. ISBN:978-1-84821-027-1.
[17] Lifante G. Integrated Photonics fundamentals. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons Ltd.; 2003. ISBN: 0-470-84868-5.
Authors' information
Muhammad Ali Butt, (b. 1985) received a Bachelor's degree in Electrical (Telecommunication) Engineering from Comsats Institute of Information and Technology, Pakistan in year 2008. Then he left Pakistan for acquiring Master's degree from Germany. He attained Master's degree in Electrical Communication Engineering from University of Kassel (2010). He
accomplished his PhD degree with Cum Laude in Material Sciences from Universitat Rovira i Virgili, Spain in year 2015. In 2013, he made a research stay at Optoelectronic research Centre (ORC), University of Southampton, England. Currently he works as a Senior Scientist at Samara State Aerospace University, Russia. Research interests are optical waveguides, diffrac-tive optics, optical filters. E-mail: m.a.butt@ssau.ru .
Elena Sergeevna Kozlova, (b. 1989) received Master's degree in Applied Mathematics and Informatics in Samara State Aerospace University (2011). She received her PhD in 2014. She is researcher of Laser Measurements Laboratory at the Image Processing Systems Institute - Branch of the Federal Scientific Research Centre "Crystallography and Photonics" of Russian Academy of Sciences and assistant of Computer Science Department at Samara National Research University. Scientific interests: diffractive optics, FDTD method, near-field optics. E-mail: kozlova.elena.s@gmail.com .
The information about author Svetlana Nikolaevna Khonina you can find on page 488 of this issue.
Code of State Categories Scientific and Technical Information (in Russian - GRNTI)): 29.31.00, 29.33.39, 29.35.19.
Received May 20, 2017. The final version - July 22, 2017.
