CC BY
5Impact Factor: SJIF 2020 - 5.497 *
2021 - 5.81 '
СОЦИОЛОГИЧЕСКИЕ НАУКИ SOCIALOGICAL SCIENCES
"CHALLENGING GREYWASH: A CALL FOR GENUINE ANTI-CORRUPTION EFFORTS AND CITIZENPARTICIPATION"
NIKOLAY TANCHEV CEO, Geya Foundation, Varna Bulgaria
Abstract: Greywash refers to a strategy employed within the public domain aiming to rectify a tainted reputation and alter societal attitudes through the implementation of infrastructural modifications. This approach is executed through a systematic and coercive exertion of influence. Various entities utilize media campaigns, social networks, and influential figures to manipulate perceptions and establish a fresh narrative linked to administrative accountability and modernization. Educational and awareness initiatives are incorporated, with emphasis placed on maximizing their visibility and tangibility. However, these practices are deemed inadequate, as an alternative approach is warranted, predicated on an authentic battle against corruption, infrastructural modernization fostered by transparency, and active citizen engagement.
Keywords: image, attitudes, change, society, institutions, corruption, transparency
Introduction:
Graywashing is a form of Brainwashing used to eradicate a corrupt image and alter public attitudes in order to win over voters from the incumbent party. Greywoosh is a process by which systematic and coercive influence is exerted on an individual through construction and renovation activities in an effort to alter the public's mentality, beliefs, and political affiliations.In politics and public administration, graywash can be used to clear up a corrupt image and alter societal attitudes toward corruption. Corruption-affected organizations and institutions can use greyhounding to alter public perception and create a new image that portrays them as accountable and immune to corrupt practices. Typically, this involves the utilization of media campaigns, social media, influencers, and other marketing strategies.
The term "graywashing" refers to a practice whereby a city government conceals or cleans up negative effects, activities related to their authority, through construction initiatives, advertising of new facilities, procurement, and most conveniently, plans for buildings with significant publicsignificance: schools, hospitals, roads, bridges, etc. In a city with a swiftly growing population and urbanization, the public attitudes that can be influenced by the practices observed in this research to alter citizens' perceptions are most applicable. In these locations, people are thrilled on a conscious and subconscious level to see more concrete-covered spaces, as well as repairs, renovations, and examples of scientific and technological advancement.
1.Purposes of Greywash
In this context, the purpose of greiwash is to alter public perception and persuade citizens that the organization or institution has altered its practices and redirected its efforts to meet public needs. "Manipulation of public opinion can be used to alter the attitudes, beliefs, and behaviorsof large groups of people. " (11) Organizations wishing to use Greywash must develop a strategyincorporating a variety of practices.
2.Greywash Methods:
The organization must establish a new image associated with transparency, accountability, and corruption resistance. This could involve active participation in the struggle against corruption, the implementation of ethical standards, the establishment of independent control mechanisms, and the
SOCIALOGICAL SCIENCES
reporting of its activities. "Reciprocity is a powerful principle of influence. When someone does us a favor or provides us with a gift, we feel a strong social obligation to return thefavour or repay the gift. This principle can be used strategically to create a sense of duty and influence others to fulfill our requests. Social proof is another key principle of influence. People often look to the actions and behaviors of others to guide their own choices and decisions. When we see others engaging in a certain behavior or adopting a certain belief, we are more likely to follow suit. This principle can be used to shape attitudes and behaviors through the use of recommendations, endorsements, and influence on social media. ..Authority plays a significant role in influencing others. People are more likely to comply with requests or directives from individuals who are perceived as trustworthy and knowledgeable. This principle can be reinforced through the use of expert endorsements, titles, and symbols of authority. Establishing oneself as an authority figure can increase the power of persuasion" (10).
2.1 Media Campaigns. This includes publishing articles, conducting interviews with key figures, and presenting success stories and examples that demonstrate the organization's dedication to combating corruption. "Mass media play a significant role in influencing public attitudes and perceptions." (1) "Information campaigns can be used to systematically manipulate public opinion by employing techniques to suspend information and create emotional responses." (13)
2.2 Utilizing social media, organizations can establish a strong online presence and communicate their anti-corruption efforts by utilizing prominent social networking sites.
This includes the dissemination of information, the development of user trust, and the promotion of discussion about the issue. "Media shapes the prism through which we understand andinterpret the world around us. They control the conversation, determining what is important, acceptable, and worthy of our attention. They help shape our shared reality. And when that reality is distorted or manipulated, it can have significant consequences for our society and democracy."
3.Moral and ethical conflicts in the practice of Greywash
It is essential to note, however, that the use of greyhound racing to cleanse a corrupt image and alter social attitudes is unethical and unacceptable. The preferable approach should be foundedon genuine anti-corruption, transparency, accountability, and citizen involvement in decision- making processes. The greyhound approach to altering civic attitudes raises significant moral and ethical concerns regarding the influence of individuals, freedom of choice, and manipulation of mass opinion. Personality and freedom of choice: Changing civic attitudes through Greywash can violate an individual's personality and freedom of choice. When mass media, advertisements,or other techniques are used to manipulate the beliefs and preferences of individuals, their rightto independent thought and choice may be violated.Occasionally, those who are dedicated to serving the public health interest are the ones who facilitate practices in which citizens are misled and manipulated by information.In the wrong hands, brain research can be oversimplified, misinterpreted, and even used for persuasion." The use of these techniques for manipulative purposes may be deemed unethical, particularly if personal autonomy and the right to make an informed decision are violated. Brainwashing is the ultimate form of psychological manipulation. It is the art of shaping and controlling people's thoughts, beliefs, and actions, often against their will, through a combinationof psychological tactics such as manipulation, deception, and intimidation. This can be detrimental to democratic processes and free speech. Effectiveness and Evidence: One of the ethical concerns associated with indoctrination relates to its efficacy and the evidence supportingits fidelity.Whether changing civic attitudes through greyhounding as a form of brainwashing is effective demonstrates the empirical evidence that supports the methods, while also serving as a reminder that the answers to these crucial questions are contingent on the principles of
SOCIALOGICAL SCIENCES
openness and accountability. These principles include reciprocity, commitment and consistency, social proof, authority, likability, and scarcity. Careful experimental research has revealed the specific triggers and cues that activate these principles and make them effective tools for persuasion. If such a method is used for malice or discrimination, it is an issue of morality and ethics that must be consistent with society's laws and values. Importantly, the moral and ethical implications of indoctrination to alter civic attitudes are subject to debate and differing perspectives. Those who use these methods bear the responsibility of applying them in accordance with moral and ethical principles, while respecting the rights and liberties of individuals and society as a whole.
4.Local instances. Decades of examples of cleaning up the image of local government through construction and renovation have been observed in the city of Varna, where significant renovations prior to every local election are intended to convince citizens to support the politicians in power. During these campaigns, numerous construction-related pledges are made, including oaths that more restorations will be made and that sufficient concrete and equipment will be used.
These local practices have had the potential to become a new concept of image clearance via restorations and construction for quite some time. The term greywashing was derived from the color of concrete. As a result, construction and renovation projects initiated by the local government can be observed frequently and everywhere prior to elections, both begun and incomplete, regardless of any norms, human resources, construction equipment, or utility conditions. Construction can be initiated and halted; in this case, the objective is to demonstrate to the public that "something is being done." Utilized are fundamental principles of local people psychology. "Psychological principles of influence can be utilized to manipulate public opinion by evoking emotionalresponses and employing social suggestion techniques" (15).
Approaches to advertising for public support in construction and renovation
In such instances, advertising strategies seek to influence the public through powerful suggestions, emotions, and sentiments. "The mass media have a significant influence on the formation of public opinion and can be used to manipulate people's beliefs and stereotypes."(14) Through publications with suggestive messages in local media and beautiful pictures of projects, visuals can be presented that may seem futuristically implausible and give the impression of responsibility and dedication to local development. The purpose of these suggestions is to create a false impression of better social responsiveness, to divert attention from communal issues, and to conceal the unfavorable visible results of local governance through the acceptable framework of making a makeover, a new order in the chaos, while in reality continuing the proverbial, routine, unsustainable methods of essentially absorbing public resources, even at the cost of making municipalities indebted, overdeveloped, and ghettoized. Advertising and marketing play a significant role in manipulating public opinion by using techniques to influence consumers and shape desirable behavior. Public funds as a chance for a successful image-improvement campaign Such a campaign is advantageous to the status quo because it is supported by public funds, allowing it to be expanded. In order for the public to be satisfied with the intended investments and their results, the public must first perceive that there is a significant problem that will be resolved by more municipally initiated construction and renovation projects. For a new city library, even if there is no real need, scandalous conversations with illiterates are promoted, etc. To make it appear as though the initiative is coming from civil society and not corporate interests,a foundation can be established to publicly raise funds through social networks for a particular idea project, and even receive funding from corporate participants related to the project's follow- up activities. It seems expedient to announce that the precise amount of money needed for the project has
SOCIALOGICAL SCIENCES
been raised at a temporary discount for this purpose. "Creating a feeling of scarcity or limited availability is one of the most effective persuasion techniques.
This principle is commonly used in sales and marketing to create a sense of urgency and encourage people to make fast decisions" (8). Once the conceptual design has been rendered visually appealing, this template is loudly presented to the local government and the public via the local media in order to establish it as a model for future procurement. The value of the acquisition is commensurate with public preferences, and large budgets are targeted. Once the procurement is announced, residents accept that a similar event will occur and form a favorable opinion of the local government and its leader. The manipulation of public opinion can be achieved by selectively presenting information, disregarding opposing viewpoints, and creating the illusion of consensus (16).
The function of public opinion in the utilization of image defamation campaigns
People's ability to anticipate the future, their preoccupation with the present, and their poor memory of the past provide a convenient opportunity to disregard previous similar activities and their outcomes, including election campaigns in which these practices have already been implemented. Typically, potent economic and political elites support campaigns to improve the public perception of local government. Conditions necessitating such a method of shaping civic attitudes include the financial dependence of rulers, certain gaps in legal regulations, self- censorship of local media, and permissible public attitudes. According to some valid public perceptions, people ought to prefer prolonged construction and renovation activities, even if they are detrimental to the environment and public health. "Public opinion can be manipulated through controlled dissemination of information, altering the context, and employing social norms" (17). Due to the fact that such activities are measured not only on material levels, but also on other levels, such as social, environmental, and moral-ethical levels, it is crucial to meticulously and analytically monitor the environment and urban management practices, as well as check for poor practices. Monitoring the relevant practices helps to identify instances of irresponsibility and abuse. This includes the detection of irregularities, the disclosure of unlawful practices, and whistleblowing. By detecting poor practices in a timely manner, their growth is halted, more sustainable solutions are discovered, and disasters, accidents, as well as negative effects on the economy, society, and institutions are prevented. This promotes accountability and openness in institutions and other organizations. In the future, companies are more likely to disclose their actions and take responsibility for their decisions and performance if they are subjected to monitoring and evaluation.
Because more trust must be established between citizens and public institutions, civil discourse is crucial. And when citizens see that corrupt practices are visible and that action can be taken against them (rather than elsewhere), they have a higher level of confidence in the institutionsand the system. The availability of information and data, as well as the maintenance of some sortof record on the subject, can be utilized to strengthen legislation, governance, and policies that safeguard the public interest.
Examining the concept of Greywoosh contributes to the comprehension of the causes and mechanisms of corruption, thereby strengthening democratic principles, institutions, and states. Increasingly, organizations and businesses are being criticized and exposed by the public and nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) for attempting to whitewash their negative image or activities by employing practices that alter public attitudes. The process of brainwashing to alter civic attitudes can affect society, its image, and the problem of corruption.It is a complex and ethically fraught issue based on the influence of mass media and other methods on the opinions, perceptions, and behaviors of individuals. Society is composed of individuals with diverse attitudes and perspectives.
Conclusion:
SOCIALOGICAL SCIENCES
Brainwashing can have an effect on society as a whole by altering certain behavioral patterns and beliefs. This can be beneficial if directed toward modifying corrupt or negative attitudes. Brainoosh can also influence the perception of society. By fostering new perceptions and beliefs,altering civic attitudes can be used to construct or alter public image. If ethical and moral principles are not observed, this can have both positive and negative consequences. Brainwashing can also be linked to anti-corruption efforts. It can aid in reducing corruption and abuse if used to alter attitudes toward corruption and establish a free and accountable society. However, Brainwash's moral and ethical aspects must also be addressed. Individuals can employ a number of methods to evade brainwashing. First, critical reasoning is indispensable. Awareness of various biases, skepticism of information sources, and the pursuit ofmultiple perspectives can assist in resisting manipulation. It is essential to develop media literacyskills, including the capacity to analyze and evaluate media messages. Second, remaining informed through a variety of sources and fact-checking information can mitigate the impact of biased or false narratives. Maintaining an open mind while retaining a healthy amount of skepticism can prevent unquestioning acceptance of manipulative tactics. Effectively identifying and managing one's emotions is required to develop resistance to emotional manipulation. Being conscious of psychological stimuli and engaging in self-reflection can aid in the maintenance of autonomy. In addition, cultivating a strong sense of personal values and beliefs can serve as a defense against manipulative techniques that contradict these values. Lastly, engaging in open and respectful dialogue with others, valuing divergent viewpoints, and actively searching out diverse perspectives can strengthen critical thinking skills and protect against manipulation. By combining these strategies, individuals can protect themselves against indoctrination techniques. Important issues include the impact on the individual, freedom of choice, and the manipulation of mass opinion, which must be weighed against the principles of impartiality and respect for people's rights. Changing civic attitudes through brainwashing is a complex, morally and ethically fraught process. It can have an effect on society, its image, attitudes towards corruption,and other significant matters. Despite its potential for change and positive effects, it must be handled with care and responsibility, in accordance with fundamental moral and ethicalprinciples.
SOCIALOGICAL SCIENCES
BIBLIOGRAPHY:
1. Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media" by Edward S. Herman and Noam Chomsky (1988)
2. "Propaganda: The Formation of Men's Attitudes" by Jacques Ellul (1965)
3. "The Influencing Machine: Brooke Gladstone on the Media" by Brooke Gladstone and Josh Neufeld (2011)
4. "The Age of Propaganda: The Everyday Use and Abuse of Persuasion" by Anthony Pratkanisand Elliot Aronson (1992)
5. "Amusing Ourselves to Death: Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business" by Neil Postman (1985)
6. "The Manipulated Mind: Brainwashing, Conditioning, and Indoctrination" by Denise Winn(2000)
7. "Brainwashed: The Seductive Appeal of Mindless Neuroscience" by Sally Satel and Scott O. Lilienfeld (2013)
8. "The Power of Persuasion: How We're Bought and Sold" by Robert Levine (2003)
9. "Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion" by Robert Cialdini (1984)
10. "The Psychology of Influence: Theory, Research, and Practice" by Robert B. Cialdini and Noah J. Goldstein (2006)
11. Mental Contamination and Mental Correction: Unwanted Influences on Judgments and Evaluations. Wilson, T. D., & Brekke, N. (1994).
12. Exposure to ideologically diverse news and opinion on Facebook. Bakshy, E., Messing, S., & Adamic, L. A. (2015).
13. Beyond Misinformation: Understanding and Coping with the "Post-Truth" Era". Lewandowsky, S., Ecker, U. K., & Cook, J. (2017).
14. Scandal and Silence: Media Responses to Presidential Misconduct. Entman, R. M. (2012).
15. Influence: Science and Practice. Cialdini, R. B. (2001).
16. Republic: Divided Democracy in the Age of Social Media. Sunstein, C. R. (2017).
17. The influence of advertising on media reporting: An information-processing approach. Möller, J., & Sassenberg, K. (2013).
18. Contagious: How to Build Word of Mouth in the Digital Age. Berger, J. (2013).
19. Twitter and tear gas: The power and fragility of networked protest. Tufekci, Z. (2017).
20. Cyberwar: How Russian Hackers and Trolls Helped Elect a President. Jamieson, K. H., & Waldman, P. (2018).
ОФ "Международный научно-исследовательский центр "Endless Light in Science" PF "International Research Center "Endless Light in Science"
