CC BY
32
ЕКОНОМ1ЧНА СТАТИСТИКА. БУХГАЛТЕРСЬКИй ОБЛ1К ТА АУДИТ
UDC 658:005.33 JEL Classification: D89; M29; M49
ACCOUNTING AND ANALYTICAL SUPPORT FOR ECONOMIC SECURITY IN TODAY'S BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
® 2019 BURLAN S. A., KATKOVA N. V.
UDC 658:005.33
JEL Classification: D89; M29; M49
Burlan S. A., Katkova N. V. Accounting and Analytical Support for Economic Security in Today's Business Environment
The aim of the study is to determine the essence and role of accounting and analytical support for enterprise economic security in a modern globalized and infor-mationalized market. The article considers the main groups of approaches to the definition of the essence of economic security and justifies an integrated approach to determining its components. The authors analyze the existing points of view regarding the definition of the content of accounting and analytical support. As a result, the authors' vision of the categorization, composition and functions of accounting and analytical support for economic security of enterprises is formulated. Thus, accounting and analytical support for economic security of an enterprise under modern conditions is defined as an information system which covers operational, financial, statistical, and personnel accounting, information carriers, communication channels, methods of processing and can create preconditions for timely taking measures to combat the negative impact of threats to economic security of an enterprise. The functions of accounting and analytical support in the system of economic security of an enterprise include: providing management personnel with the necessary information on the state and main trends in the development of the enterprise and changes in market conditions; creating prerequisites for efficient functioning of the control system at the enterprise; ensuring the reliability of data on all business processes in the enterprise; forming an analytical basis to calculate the impact of internal and external threats, quantitative determination of economic security factors; planning and forecasting the development of the enterprise and level of its economic security; forming own analytical markers of the emergence, activation or strengthening of the impact of economic security threats to the enterprise; transmitting such signals to management personnel. It is noted that the organization of the accounting and analytical process includes three main stages: monitoring, comprehension, planning. It is substantiated that it is accounting data and indicators of financial statements that are the fundamental basis for making major decisions on combating threats to economic security. The main effective ways for organizing the formation of accounting and analytical support for economic security of an enterprise are identified. Keywords: economic security, analysis, accounting, control, accounting information, accounting and analytical support. DOI: https://doi.org/10.32983/2222-0712-2019-l-184-190 Fig.: 1. Tbl.: 1.
Burlan Svitlana A. - Candidate of Sciences (Economics), Associate Professor, Professor, Department of Accounting and Auditing, Black Sea State University named
after P. Mohyla (10 68 Desantnykiv Str., Mykolaiv, 54000, Ukraine)
E-mail: [email protected]
ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-1838-6891
Katkova Natalia V. - Candidate of Sciences (Economics), Associate Professor, Associate Professor, Department of Accounting and Economic Analysis, Admiral Ma-
karov National University of Shipbuilding (9 Heroiv Ukrainy Ave., Mykolaiv, 54025, Ukraine)
E-mail: [email protected]
ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6199-4841
Researcher ID: http://www.researcherid.com/rid/U-1777-2017
УДК 658:005.33 JEL Classification: D89; M29; M49 Бурлан С. А., Каткова Н. В. Облтво-аналтичне забезпечення eK0H0Mi4H0i безпеки в сучасних умовах ведення 6i3Hecy
Метою цього дослдження е визначення сутностi та рот обл'шово-аналтичного забезпечення економiчноi безпеки тдприемства в умовах сучасного глобалiзованого й 'тформатизованого ринку. Роз-глянуто основт групи пiдходiв до визначення сутностi економiчноi безпеки й об(рунтовано комплексний шдюд до встановлення ii скла-дових. Авторами проанал'вовано кнуюч точки зору щодо визначення змкту облково-аналтичного забезпечення. В результатi сформу-льовано власне бачення категоризацп, складу та функ^й обл'шово-аналтичного забезпечення економiчноi безпеки тдприемств. Так, обл'шово-аналтичне забезпечення економiчноi безпеки тдприемства в умовах сьогодення визначено як систему iнформацii, котра охоплюе
UDC 658:005.33 JEL Classification: D89; M29; M49 Бурлан С. А., Каткова Н. В. Учетно-аналитическое обеспечение экономической безопасности в современных условиях ведения бизнеса
Целью настоящего исследования является определение сущности и роли учетно-аналитического обеспечения экономической безопасности предприятия в условиях современного глобализированного и ин-форматизированного рынка. Рассмотрены основные группы подходов к определению сущности экономической безопасности, и обоснован комплексный подход к установлению ее составляющих. Авторами проанализированы существующие точки зрения по определению содержания учетно-аналитического обеспечения. В результате сформулированы собственное видение категоризации, состава и функций учетно-аналитического обеспечения экономической безопасности предприятий. Так, учетно-аналитическое обеспечение экономической
дат оперативного, бухгалтерського, статистичного та кадрового облку, ii носи, канали комушкаци, методи обробки та здатна ство-рити передумови для своечасного вживання заходв протиди негативному впливу загроз економ/чнй безпец тдприемства. До основних функцй облково-аналтичного забезпечення в системi економЫноi безпеки тдприемства вiднесенi: забезпечення управлнського персоналу необхiдною шформа^ею про стан i основш тенденци розвитку тдприемства та змши ринковоi кон'юнктури; створення передумов ефективного функцюнування системи контролшгу на тдприемстт; забезпечення достов'рностi даних щодо вах господарських процеав на тдприемств'г, формування аналтичноi основи розрахунку впливу внутршнЫ i зовншнк загроз, кльксноi детермiнацi¡ фактор'в еко-номiчно'i безпеки; здшснювання планування та прогнозування розвитку тдприемства i р'вня його економiчно¡ безпеки; формування власних аналтичних маркерв виникнення, активiзацi¡ або посилення впливу загроз економiчнiй безпец тдприемства; передача таких сиг-нал'в управл'нському персоналу. Зазначено, що органiзацiя обл'шово-аналтичного процесу реал'вуеться у три основних етапи: спостере-ження, осмислення, планування. Об(рунтовано, що саме обл'шот дан та показники фтнсово)' звтностi е фундаментальною основою при-йняття основних ршень в частин протидПзагрозам економiчно¡ безпеки. Окреслено основн дiевi способи органiзацii створення обл'шово-аналтичного забезпечення економiчно¡ безпеки тдприемства. Ключовi слова: економiчна безпека, анал'в, обл'ш, контроль, обл'шова iнформацiя, облково-аналтичне забезпечення. Рис.: 1. Табл.: 1.
Бурлан Свтлана АнатолПвна - кандидат економiчних наук, доцент, професор, кафедра облку i аудиту, Чорноморський державний унверси-тет iм. П. Могили (вул. 68Десантниюв, 10, Миколав, 54000, Украна) E-mail: [email protected] ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-1838-6891
Каткова Наталя Володимирiвна - кандидат економiчних наук, доцент, доцент, кафедра облку i економiчного анал'ву, Нацональний утверситет кораблебудування iм. Адмiрала Макарова (просп. Герою Украни, 9, Миколав, 54025, Украна) E-mail: [email protected] ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6199-4841 Researcher ID: http://www.researcherid.com/rid/U-1777-2017
безопасности предприятия в условиях настоящего определено как система информации, которая охватывает данные оперативного, бухгалтерского, статистического и кадрового учета, ее носители, каналы коммуникации, обработки и способна создать предпосылки для своевременного принятия мер противодействия негативному влиянию угроз экономической безопасности предприятия. К основным функциям учетно-аналитического обеспечения в системе экономической безопасности предприятия отнесены: обеспечение управленческого персонала необходимой информацией о состоянии и основных тенденциях развития предприятия и изменения рыночной конъюнктуры; создание предпосылок эффективного функционирования системы контроллинга на предприятии; обеспечения достоверности данных о всех хозяйственных процессов на предприятии; формирование аналитической основы расчета влияния внутренних и внешних угроз, количественной детерминации факторов экономической безопасности; осуществление планирования и прогнозирования развития предприятия и уровня экономической безопасности; формирование собственных аналитических маркеров возникновения, активизации или усиления влияния угроз экономической безопасности предприятия; передача таких сигналов управленческому персоналу. Отмечено, что организация учетно-аналитического процесса реализуется в три основных этапа: наблюдение, осмысление, планирование. Обосновано, что именно учетные данные и показатели финансовой отчетности являются фундаментальной основой принятия основных решений в части противодействия угрозам экономической безопасности. Определены основные действенные способы организации создания учетно-аналитического обеспечения экономической безопасности предприятия. Ключевые слова:экономическая безопасность, анализ, учет, контроль, учетная информация, учетно-аналитическое обеспечение. Рис.: 1. Табл.: 1.
Бурлан Светлана Анатолиевна - кандидат экономических наук, доцент, профессор, кафедра учета и аудита, Черноморский государственный университет им. П. Могилы (ул. 68 Десантников, 10, Николаев, 54000, Украина) E-mail: [email protected] ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-1838-6891 Каткова Наталья Владимировна - кандидат экономических наук, доцент, доцент, кафедра учета и экономического анализа, Национальный университет кораблестроения им. Адмирала Макарова (просп. Героев Украины, 9, Николаев, 54025, Украина) E-mail: [email protected] ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6199-4841 Researcher ID: http://www.researcherid.com/rid/U-1777-2017
Modern business conditions in Ukraine bring to the fore those aspects of management that are aimed at ensuring economic security. Under conditions of globalization of the economy and informatization of the business environment, the transformation of the main threats for economic entities and ways for combating them, and accordingly, the structure of the economic security system, is taking place. The uncertainty of the external business environment requires management personnel to be able to effectively manage situational and operational responses, which becomes possible only with the availability of necessary and sufficient information support.
The analysis and assessment of an enterprise's financial and property status, its counteragent environment, the state of the market as well as the forecasting of the tendencies are car-
ried out on the basis of the accounting data on the enterprise's activity, in particular financial, statistical, analytical, operational, and managerial as well as their consistent and competent processing. In this regard, the effectiveness of the organization of accounting and analytical work in an enterprise plays a fundamental role for ensuring its economic security, since it is one of its prerequisites.
The issues of the essence of economic security and the ways of its formation are highlighted in works of a number of scholars, namely, T. H. Vasyltsiv, N. M. Gapak, I. V. Sorokina. The essence of accounting and analytical support are investigated in research papers of T. M. Bezrodna, T. H. Kaminska, M. D. Korinko, H. B. Titarenko, R. P. Yuzva. It is worth noting the contribution of O. D. Hudzynskyi, H. H. Kireitsev, T. M. Pakhomova, and especially A. M. Shtanhret in terms of
determining the role of accounting and analytical support in the formation of economic security. At the same time, without neglecting the achievements of the mentioned scholars, it is worth noting that the modern paradigm of the information society provokes the transformation of interrelations in the studied systems.
The aim of the study is to determine the essence and role of accounting and analytical support for economic security of an enterprise under a modern globalized and informational-ized market.
The essence of economic security of an enterprise is defined by scientists in different ways. Based on the analysis of literary sources it becomes possible to single out typical approaches to the definition of the economic security essence [1-4]. The most common methods of grouping approaches to formulating the essence of economic security, which are to some extent repeated or are the basis of other classifications [3; 4], and are similar in their character to approaches of the Western scientific thought [13-18] presented in works of I. V. So-rokina [1] and N. M. Gapak [2]. The I. V. Sorokina distinguishes four main approaches:
■ resource and functional, the essence of which is reduced to the effective using of available assets and liabilities;
■ aimed at protecting against destructive effects of the external environment;
■ aimed at protecting economic and commercial interests;
■ aimed at ensuring the stability of the enterprise [1].
The second type of the grouping of approaches to defining the essence of economic security includes the following groups:
■ degree of protection against internal and external threats;
■ degree of protection against mercenary crimes;
■ degree of effective using of corporate resources;
■ ability to ensure reproduction [2].
The large number of approaches to defining the essence of economic security in the literature is due to gradual changes in threats to enterprises. Thus, in 2012, the Concept of Economic Security of Ukraine defined economic security as "... the ability of the national economy to ensure its free, independent
development and to maintain the stability of civil society and its institutions as well as sufficient defense potential of the country in all sorts of adverse scenarios, and the ability of the Ukrainian state to protect national economic interests from external and internal threats" [3]. However, nowadays, under condition of the information hybrid warfare, antiterrorist operation, and partial occupation of the Ukrainian territory, it necessary to develop the latest instruments of economic security both for the country as a whole and for individual enterprises. A significant number of business entities felt the negative economic impact from changes in the market situation in the context of cooperation with residents of the country-aggressor and introduced economic sanctions.
Taking into account the above mentioned, economic security of an enterprise can be considered as its ability to take preventive measures for combating the negative effects of internal and external threats through effective operation and analysis of relevant information flows to make timely management decisions.
According to this approach, information about the state of an enterprise, its production processes and personnel, as well as the environment becomes the cornerstone for building its economic security system. Data of operational, financial, statistical, and personnel accounting become the basis of the analytical process in an enterprise. The assessment of the competitive and counteragent environment of the enterprise is carried out according to its public financial statements. The formed analytical arrays of data become an important tool for enterprise management in an information business environment. Accordingly, the protection of its own accounting and analytical information and its collection in the external environment is a modern element of economic security of an enterprise.
According to the team of authors under the guidance of T. H. Vasyltsiv, in the part of information security, an enterprise's personnel are the weakest link, which is closely connected with personnel security. Commercial secrets preservation in an enterprise is only part of the system of accounting and analytical support for economic security of the enterprise [4].
The definition of the essence of accounting and analytical support is also a controversy in the economic literature. The most common approaches are presented in Table 1.
Table 1
Basic approaches to the definition of the concept "accounting and analytical support"
Author Definition
1 2
T. Bezrodna [5] ensuring the implementation of the process of supplying accounting and analytical information in the management system
R. Yusva [6] a set of accounting and analytical processes, united in the accounting and analytical system and aimed at satisfying the information needs of users through the transformation of primary information into generalizing information in accordance with the set objectives and regulatory, methodological, organizational, program, mathematical, technical and ergonomic support
T. Kaminska [7] a system of collection, processing, generalization, presentation, and analysis of financial information, ensuring its quality for carrying out business activity and its management
O. Hudzynskyi [8] an integrated system of methods for accounting and analytical management support through the implementation of specific internally system and general system functions
End tbl. 1
1 2
L Napadovska [9] a totality of the final information about the state and results of an enterprise, concentrated in various forms of financial and managerial (internal economic) reporting
M. Korinko [10] a system which is based on accounting data, including operational data, and uses statistical, production, reference, and other types of information for economic analysis. The accounting and analytical system covers collection, processing, and evaluation of all types of information used to make management decisions at micro and macro levels
Z. Hutsaylyuk [11] the purpose of an accounting information system is the formation of individual information flows for managing production, financial and economic activities of economic entities or providing information for owners and other data consumers
A. Shtanhret [12] a system which is based on operational, statistical, financial, and management accounting data and uses statistical, production, reference, and other types of information for economic analysis through the application of analytical and economic and mathematical research methods, which enables forming an information base to make decisions adequate to the situation, in particular, within the framework of a comprehensive system of economic security of an enterprise
Source: developed by the authors
Summarizing these approaches, under current conditions, we can define accounting and analytical support for economic security of an enterprise as a system of information which covers operational, financial, statistical, and personnel accounting, information carriers, communication channels,
methods of processing and can create preconditions for timely taking measures to combat the negative impact of threats to economic security of an enterprise. Consequently, as part of this system, it is necessary to single out all the essential components and form effective ways of their interaction (Fig. 1).
Accounting and analytical support for economic security of an enterprise
Fig. 1. Composition of the accounting and analytical system of economic security of an enterprise
Source: developed by the authors
Thus, efficiently organized system of accounting and ■ continuous monitoring and evaluation of the finan-
analytical work in an enterprise can provide economic security cial and property status of the enterprise in order to
of an enterprise in the following areas: identify and prevent threats and insolvency;
■ availability of information basis for assessing the level of own economic security and counteragents, as well as of the enterprise's competitive position;
■ monitoring and information basis for making management decisions in terms of resource potential of the enterprise;
■ formation of the grounds for making strategic management decisions in the part of combating threats to economic security;
■ availability of information basis for monitoring and assessing the effectiveness of the taken and implemented propositions to ensure economic security.
As can be seen from Figure 1, the initial stage of the formation of a system of accounting and analytical support for economic security is collecting necessary information. This function relies on the accounting services of an enterprise, in particular, its accounting department, planning and analytical units, etc. At the same time, the system of financial accounting is retrospective and allows performing the necessary analysis, planning, and forecasting of the impact of threats to the enterprise's economic security at the level of management accounting. Based on financial accounting data, an array of management accounting information is formed for the adoption of operational, tactical, and strategic management decisions, in particular, in terms of economic security. That is, the accounting system transforms information about past events for future management purposes.
At the same time, accounting data have insignificant value for management purposes. They require specialized processing by means of management accounting, economic and mathematical analysis, modeling and forecasting. However, the idea of the financial and property status of an enterprise, its profitability, composition, status, and structure of assets and liabilities is formed solely upon accounting data. These data are the basis for assessing the current level of economic security of any enterprise, but taking into account the long-term impact of external threats.
The functions of accounting and analytical support in the system of economic security of an enterprise include:
■ providing management personnel with the necessary information on the state and main trends in the development of the enterprise and changes in market conditions;
■ creating prerequisites for efficient functioning of the control system at the enterprise;
■ ensuring the reliability of data on all business processes in the enterprise;
■ forming an analytical basis to calculate the impact of internal and external threats, quantitative determination of economic security factors;
■ planning and forecasting the development of the enterprise and level of its economic security;
■ forming own analytical markers of the emergence, activation or strengthening of the impact of economic security threats to the enterprise; transmitting such signals to management personnel.
The system of accounting and analytical support is a harmonized synergy of actions, information channels and methods of subsystems of accounting, analysis and audit, which de-
termines its objective necessity in terms of ensuring economic security of an enterprise.
Today, in Ukraine, active implementation of the norms of international standards of financial reporting and accounting takes place. In particular, even those enterprises which are not yet obliged to compile financial statements according to the international standards, for the most part, prepare a management report.
Financial reports become increasingly analytic and present accounting information from a different angle; the emphasis is on the value of intangible assets, reputational capital, goodwill, etc. More and more business entities in the text part of their reports, disclose information about the prospects of their own activities not only at the strategic level but also supporting them with the prediction calculations.
However, it should be noted that in the overwhelming majority, accounting services of domestic enterprises consider the requirements of the international standards formally, thus neglecting the value of analytical information in terms of achieving an appropriate level of economic security. Thus, a poor quality of financial reporting preparation, especially its text part, may provoke a decline in the competitiveness of an enterprise, discrediting its business reputation. Accordingly, the system for processing and generalizing accounting information, methods used for these purposes in an enterprise, the order of the accounting process are important elements of accounting and analytical support for economic security.
The movement of accounting information in an enterprise includes the following main stages:
■ emerging: realizing the economic transaction and its registration in primary documents (primary accounting);
■ processing: grouping accounting information on the accounts in specialized registries (current accounting);
■ generalizing: forming the results of a certain period in the form of aggregated indicators in the financial statements (final accounting).
The data of primary and current accounting are used for the adoption of operational management decisions, generalizing accounting - for making tactical ones. The basis of strategic decisions is the results of processing data over a longer period, revealing general trends and market dynamics. For these purposes, the accounting information should be sufficiently representative but within the limits of commercial information. These requirements for quality of accounting information are conditioned by the requirements for forming the system of economic security, and are confirmed by basic principles of accounting and financial reporting, which are defined by the norms of the Law of Ukraine "On Accounting and Financial Reporting in Ukraine" [13], in particular, the principles of the full coverage and prevalence of the essence over the form.
The principle of full coverage implies that the financial statements should contain all information about the actual and potential effects of business operations and events that can affect decisions taken on its basis [13]. Accordingly, the qualitative content of the accounting and analytical support for economic security of an enterprise should cover analytical data, which are not presented in financial statements now. This is
also confirmed by the essence of the principle of prevalence of the essence over the form, which envisages the priority of the economic process and its consequences over formal conditions.
It is also worth noting the difference between the methods for assessing individual components of financial reporting in accordance with the domestic and international standards, in particular, those related to intangible assets, liabilities and expenses. Thus, in Ukraine, there are significant problems with the protection of intellectual property and assessment of the cost of trademarks. Typically, for these purposes, there used the methods to determine the present value of future cash flows, not taking into account the features of the situation in the market and the prospects for its development. Moreover, the using of purely mathematical methods under conditions of uncertainty and variability of the external environment inherent in the Ukrainian market can be unreliable and non-informative. There are also significant differences in the estimation of liabilities and expenses, since, according to the norms of the domestic accounting regulation, they are determined in accordance with the actual documented volumes, while the international standards imply determining transaction costs and results of actuarial expectations.
Thus, the organization of accounting and analytical support for the economic security of an enterprise should be aimed at creating all the necessary conditions for the adoption of effective management decisions in the area of combating various threats. Under modern conditions, the process of organizing collection, processing and generalization of accounting information is maximally automated. The process of automation involves the possibility for collecting and processing accounting information through specialized computer software, as well as forming analytical reports on different aspects depending on the needs of management personnel.
The organization of the accounting and analytical process includes three main stages: monitoring, comprehension, planning, which differ from those of the accounting process.
At the monitoring stage, the formation of an information array for managing economic security level is carried out by selecting the accounting data which are essential and necessary in this context. At the same time, the primary stage of accounting is the registration of business operations through the formation of primary documents, and then - at the stage of current accounting - grouping information with the help of synthetic and analytical accounts. The stage of comprehension actually presents a process of economic analysis of intermediate and aggregate indicators, which allows determining the level of influence of economic security factors and threats, establishing causal relationships in the analyzed system. The planning stage involves modeling future development of an enterprise under various conditions and searching the optimal solutions for ensuring the proper current and future level of the enterprise's economic security [14].
For the automated or partially automated organization of the processes of forming the accounting and analytical support for economic security in an enterprise, specialized software can be applied. Accounting software products can be applied to provide partial automation, while for management purposes a variety of database management systems or integrated information systems are used.
However, the system of accounting and analytical support is not restricted by data of financial and internal reporting but also includes non-financial information and information about the environment. In the analytical process, the enterprise's own databases, including open data from state registers, statistics and customs authorities of Ukraine, etc., are formed on public official resources. To form such databases, domestic enterprises can also use the specialized services, such as "Liga:Zakon Kontragent" or "YouControl" etc. Such services offer users information about counteragents in various sections: financial and property status, organizational legal form, owners and shareholders, lawsuits, capital and liabilities, etc.
Among the complex software solutions, which form accounting and analytical support for economic security of enterprises, it is necessary to single out several basic types of them. Transaction-Processing System, which is designed to automate the collection of operating information. Management Information System, which is used for the current grouping of operating information and its representation in various consolidated sections. Office Automation System, which is designed to create effective communicating in an enterprise. Executive Systems or Executive Information Systems, which are used to implement and monitor management decisions [15-18].
Conclusions. The system of accounting and analytical support for economic security is constantly transformed under the influence of the development of information technology and requirements for accounting information. The basis of such support is accounting and reporting data as well as public sources about the market situation, which is also based on public reports. In turn, ensuring the quality of accounting information, efficient organization of accounting and management processes is an integral part of both the analytical and management components of the system for forming a proper level of economic security of an enterprise. The information support for such processes should be not only complete and reliable but also economically feasible and relevant in its content, be highly useful. The formation of own databases and specialized forms of management reporting, descriptive elements of doing business will create preconditions for rapid response to the increased impact of internal or external threats to a business. Under such conditions, there is a need to strengthen the requirements for the qualification and responsibility of accounting personnel, their awareness of the essence and importance of mastering the latest methods for generalizing accounting information, accounting estimates, and analysis of aggregated information.
LITERATURE
1. Сорокша I. B. Теоретико-npaBOBÍ засади економ^чноТ безпеки. Державне буд'вництво та мкцеве самоврядування. 2016. № 31. С. 205-217.
2. Гапак Н. М. Економнчна безпека тдприемства: сутнкть, 3míct та основи оцшки. Науковий вкникУжНУ. Сер'я : Економка. 2013. № 3 (40). С. 62-65.
3. Про схвалення Концепцп забезпечення нацюнальноТ безпеки у фшансовш сферi : Розпорядження Кабшету MirnopiB УкраГни вщ 15.08.2012 № 596-р. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/ laws/show/569-2012-%D1%80
4. Васильев T. Г., Волошин В. I., Бойкевич О. P., Каркав-чук В. В. Фiнансово-економiчна безпека пiдпри£мств Укра'ши: стратегiя та мехашзми забезпечення : монографiя. Львiв : Л^а-Прес, 2012. 3S6 с.
5. Безродна T. M. Облiково-аналiтичне забезпечення yправлiння пiдпри£мством: визначення сутност поняття. URL: http://dspace.snu.edu.ua:S0S0/jspui/bitstream/1234Sб7S9/S23/S/ bezrodna.pdf
6. Юзва P. П. Облiково-аналiтичне забезпечення управ-лiння дiяльнiстю пiдпри£мств спиртовоТ промисловостi : авто-реф. дис. ... канд. екон. наук : 0S.00.09. Тернопть, 2011. 20 с.
7. Камшська T. Г., Шатковська Л. С., Шиш A. M. Облтово-анал™чне забезпечення фiнансового менеджменту на сть-ськогосподарських пiдпри£мствах : монографiя. КиТв : ЦП «Ком-принт». 2013. 33S с.
8. Гудзинський О. Д., Никончук В. M. Управлшня акти-вiзацi£ю дiяльностi аграрних пiдпри£мств (теоретико-мето-дологiчний аспект) : монографiя. КиТв : Аграр Mедiа Груп, 2012. 197 c.
9. Нападовська Л. В. Базовi принципи yправлiнського об-лiкy. Актуальн проблемиeKOHOMÍKU. 2013. № 1. С. 173-1S1.
10. Коршько M. Д. Управлшський контроль в сиоемн yправлiння пiдпри£мницькою дiяльнiстю // Стратепя розвитку Укра'Тни: Eкономiчний та гумаштарний вимiри : матерiали наук.-практ. конф. КиТв : 1нформ.-аналгт. агентство, 201S. C. 90-94.
11. Гуцайлюк З. Системи бухгалтерського облiкy: критич-ний аналiз думок економiстiв. Бухгалтерський обл'ш i аудит. 2012. № 4. С. 3-11.
12. Штангрет A. M. Облтово-анал™чне забезпечення процесу гарантування економiчноï безпеки пщпри£мства. На-уков'1 записки : наук.-техн. зб. 2013. № 2. С. SS-бЗ.
13. Про бухгалтерський облт та фшансову звiтнiсть в Украïнi : Закон УкраГни вiд 1б.07.1999 № 99б. URL: https://zakon. rada.gov.ua/laws/show/99б-14
14. Stachowiak Z. Teoria i praktyka mechanizmu bezpieczenstwa ekonomicznego panstwa: [podrçczniki szkolne]. Akademia Obrony Narodowej. 2012. 220 s.
15. Ramljak, Br. Rogosic A. Strategic Management Accounting Practices in Croatia. The Journal of International Management Studies. 201S. Vol. 7, Nо. 2. P. 93-100.
16. Global Management Accounting Principles. URL: http:// www.cgma.org/resources/reports/globalmanagementaccounting principles.html
17. Pitcher G. S. Management Accounting in Support of the Strategic Management Process. Chartered Institute of Management Accountants CIMA Executive Summary Report. 2014. Vol. 11, Issue 1.
18. Delkhosh M., Mousavi H. Strategic Financial Management Review on the Financial Success of an Organization. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences. 201б. Vol. 7. No. 2. P. 30-34.
REFERENCES
Bezrodna, T. M. "Oblikovo-analitychne zabezpechennia up-ravlinnia pidpryiemstvom: vyznachennia sutnosti poniattia" [Accounting and analytical support for enterprise management: the definition of the essence of the concept]. http://dspace.snu.edu. ua:8080/jspui/bitstream/123456789/523/8/bezrodna.pdf
Delkhosh, M., and Mousavi, H. "Strategic Financial Management Review on the Financial Success of an Organization". Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, vol. 7, no. 2 (2016): 30-34.
Global Management Accounting Principles. http://www. cgma.org/resources/reports/globalmanagementaccountingprin-ciples.html
Hapak, N. M. "Ekonomichna bezpeka pidpryiemstva: sutnist, zmist ta osnovy otsinky" [Economic security of an enterprise: the essence, content and basis of assessment]. Naukovyi visnyk UzhNU. Seriia :Ekonomika, no. 3 (40) (2013): 62-65.
Hudzynskyi, O. D., and Nykonchuk, V. M. Upravlinnia ak-tyvizatsiieiu diialnosti ahrarnykh pidpryiemstv (teoretyko-metodolo-hichnyi aspekt) [Management of activization of activity of agrarian enterprises (theoretical and methodological aspect)]. Kyiv: Ahrar Media Hrup, 2012.
Hutsailiuk, Z. "Systemy bukhhalterskoho obliku: krytychnyi analiz dumok ekonomistiv" [Accounting systems: critical analysis of economists]. Bukhhalterskyioblikiaudyt, no. 4 (2012): 3-11.
Kaminska, T. H., Shatkovska, L. S., and Shysh, A. M. Oblikovo-analitychne zabezpechennia finansovoho menedzhmentu na silsko-hospodarskykh pidpryiemstvakh [Accounting and analytical support of financial management at agricultural enterprises]. Kyiv: TsP «Komprynt», 2013.
Korinko, M. D. "Upravlinskyi kontrol v systemi upravlinnia pidpryiemnytskoiu diialnistiu" [Management control in the system of management of entrepreneurial activity]. Stratehiia rozvytku Ukrainy: Ekonomichnyi ta humanitarnyi vymiry. Kyiv: Inform.-analit. ahentstvo, 2015. 90-94.
[Legal Act of Ukraine] (1999). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/ laws/show/996-14
[Legal Act of Ukraine] (2012). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/ laws/show/569-2012-%D1%80
Napadovska, L. V. "Bazovi pryntsypy upravlinskoho obliku" [Basic principles of managerial accounting]. Aktualni problemy ekonomiky, no. 1 (2013): 173-181.
Pitcher, G. S. "Management Accounting in Support of the Strategic Management Process". Chartered Institute of Management Accountants CIMA Executive Summary Report, vol. 11, no. 1 (2014).
Ramljak, Br., and Rogosic, A. "Strategic Management Accounting Practices in Croatia". The Journal of International Management Studies, vol. 7, no. 2 (2015): 93-100.
Shtanhret, A. M. "Oblikovo-analitychne zabezpechennia protsesu harantuvannia ekonomichnoi bezpeky pidpryiemstva" [Accounting and analytical support of the process of guaranteeing the economic security of the enterprise]. Naukovi zapysky, no. 2 (2013): 58-63.
Sorokina, I. V. "Teoretyko-pravovi zasady ekonomichnoi bezpeky" [Theoretical and legal principles of economic security]. Der-zhavne budivnytstvo ta mistseve samovriaduvannia, no. 31 (2016): 205-217.
Stachowiak, Z. Teoria i praktyka mechanizmu bezpieczenstwa ekonomicznego panstwa. Akademia Obrony Narodowej, 2012.
Vasyltsiv, T. H. et al. Finansovo-ekonomichna bezpeka pidpryiemstv Ukrainy: stratehiia ta mekhanizmy zabezpechennia [Financial and economic security of Ukrainian enterprises: strategy and mechanisms of provision]. Lviv: Liha-Pres, 2012.
Yuzva, R. P. "Oblikovo-analitychne zabezpechennia upravlinnia diialnistiu pidpryiemstv spyrtovoi promyslovosti" [Accounting and analytical support for the management of the enterprises of the alcohol industry]: avtoref. dys.... kand. ekon. nauk : 08.00.09, 2011.
